-
Complex asymptotics of the Möbius energy gradient of symmetric helix pairs
Authors:
Max Lipton
Abstract:
The Möbius energy is a well-studied knot energy with nice regularity and self-repulsive properties. Stationary curves under the Möbius energy gradient are of significant theoretical interest as they they can indicate equilibrium states of a curve under its own forces. In this paper, we consider stationary symmetric helix pairs under the Möbius energy. Through methods of complex asymptotics, we cha…
▽ More
The Möbius energy is a well-studied knot energy with nice regularity and self-repulsive properties. Stationary curves under the Möbius energy gradient are of significant theoretical interest as they they can indicate equilibrium states of a curve under its own forces. In this paper, we consider stationary symmetric helix pairs under the Möbius energy. Through methods of complex asymptotics, we characterize the limiting behavior of the Möbius gradient as the coiling ratio tends to infinity: the gradient will diverge in opposing directions depending on whether the radius is less than or greater than $\frac{1}{2}$.
We conclude by discussing the implications to the more general Möbius-Plateau energy, where the energy of a curve, or pair of curves, includes the area of the minimal surface bounded by them. Symmetric helix pairs bound a helicoid between them, and applying our result shows that stationary helicoids grow to radius $\frac{1}{2}$ from below as the coiling tends to infinity.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Stationary curves under the Möbius-Plateau energy
Authors:
Max Lipton,
Gokul Nair
Abstract:
Plateau problems with elastic boundary energy have been of recent theoretical and applied interest. However, avoidance of self-intersection on the boundary during the gradient descent requires strong assumptions on the initial conditions. To make progress towards an alternative to these strong assumptions, we introduce the novel Möbius-Plateau energy, where we instead use the repulsive Möbius ener…
▽ More
Plateau problems with elastic boundary energy have been of recent theoretical and applied interest. However, avoidance of self-intersection on the boundary during the gradient descent requires strong assumptions on the initial conditions. To make progress towards an alternative to these strong assumptions, we introduce the novel Möbius-Plateau energy, where we instead use the repulsive Möbius energy first introduced by O'Hara, and later expounded upon by Freedman, He, and Wang. This new energy also has myriad scientific utility and presents interesting theoretical phenomena.
We first prove the existence of minimizing curves in the case of immersed discs bounded by knots, placing our work on solid footing. We then investigate the Möbius-Plateau energy of helicoidal strips, which are classified as screws or ribbons based on the orientations of the boundary helices. Through direct methods of the variational equation, we show that stable helicoidal screws are plentiful, whilst stable helicoidal ribbons impose strong constraints on their parameters: they must have high coiling, thin width in comparison to the coiling, and remain close to axis.
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2023; v1 submitted 26 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Exploring the electric field around a loop of static charge: Rectangles, stadiums, ellipses, and knots
Authors:
Max Lipton,
Steven H Strogatz,
Alex Townsend
Abstract:
We study the electric field around a continuous one-dimensional loop of static charge, under the assumption that the charge is distributed uniformly along the loop. For rectangular or stadium-shaped loops in the plane, we find that the electric field can undergo a symmetry-breaking pitchfork bifurcation as the loop is elongated; the field can have either one or three zeros, depending on the loop's…
▽ More
We study the electric field around a continuous one-dimensional loop of static charge, under the assumption that the charge is distributed uniformly along the loop. For rectangular or stadium-shaped loops in the plane, we find that the electric field can undergo a symmetry-breaking pitchfork bifurcation as the loop is elongated; the field can have either one or three zeros, depending on the loop's aspect ratio. For knotted charge distributions in three-dimensional space, we compute the electric field numerically and compare our results to previously published theoretical bounds on the number of equilibrium points around charged knots. Our computations reveal that the previous bounds are far from sharp. The numerics also suggest conjectures for the actual minimum number of equilibrium points for all charged knots with five or fewer crossings. In addition, we provide the first images of the equipotential surfaces around charged knots, and visualize their topological transitions as the level of the potential is varied.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2022; v1 submitted 21 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Topological approaches to knotted electric charge distributions
Authors:
Max Lipton
Abstract:
Consider a knot $K$ in $S^3$ with uniformly distributed electric charge. Whilst solutions to the Laplace equation in terms of Dirichlet integrals are readily available, it is still of theoretical and physical interest to understand the qualitative behavior of the potential, particularly with respect to critical points and equipotential surfaces. In this paper, we demonstrate how techniques from ge…
▽ More
Consider a knot $K$ in $S^3$ with uniformly distributed electric charge. Whilst solutions to the Laplace equation in terms of Dirichlet integrals are readily available, it is still of theoretical and physical interest to understand the qualitative behavior of the potential, particularly with respect to critical points and equipotential surfaces. In this paper, we demonstrate how techniques from geometric topology can yield novel insights from the perspective of electrostatics. Specifically, we show that when the knot is sufficiently close to a planar projection, we prove a lower bound on the size of the critical set based on the projection's crossings, improving a 2019 result of the author. We then classify the equipotential surfaces of a charged knot distribution by tracking how the topology of the knot complement restricts the Morse surgeries associated to the critical points of the potential. keywords: Physical knot theory, electrostatics, Morse theory, dynamical systems, geometric topology, Cerf theory
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2022; v1 submitted 8 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
A lower bound on critical points of the electric potential of a knot
Authors:
Max Lipton
Abstract:
Given a knot $K$ parametrized by $r: [0,2π] \to \mathbb{R}^3$, we can define the electric potential on its complement by $Φ(x) = \int_0^{2π} \frac{|r'(t)|}{|x - r(t)|}dt$. Physicists and knot theorists want to understand the critical points of the potential and their behavior.
The tunneling number $t(K)$ of a knot is the smallest number of arcs one needs to add to a knot so the complement is a h…
▽ More
Given a knot $K$ parametrized by $r: [0,2π] \to \mathbb{R}^3$, we can define the electric potential on its complement by $Φ(x) = \int_0^{2π} \frac{|r'(t)|}{|x - r(t)|}dt$. Physicists and knot theorists want to understand the critical points of the potential and their behavior.
The tunneling number $t(K)$ of a knot is the smallest number of arcs one needs to add to a knot so the complement is a handlebody. We show the number of critical points of the potential is at least $2t(K) + 2$. The result is proven using Morse theory and stable manifold theory.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2021; v1 submitted 5 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
The Kuramoto model on a sphere: Explaining its low-dimensional dynamics with group theory and hyperbolic geometry
Authors:
Max Lipton,
Renato Mirollo,
Steven H. Strogatz
Abstract:
We study a system of $N$ interacting particles moving on the unit sphere in $d$-dimensional space. The particles are self-propelled and coupled all to all, and their motion is heavily overdamped. For $d=2$, the system reduces to the classic Kuramoto model of coupled oscillators; for $d=3$, it has been proposed to describe the orientation dynamics of swarms of drones or other entities moving about…
▽ More
We study a system of $N$ interacting particles moving on the unit sphere in $d$-dimensional space. The particles are self-propelled and coupled all to all, and their motion is heavily overdamped. For $d=2$, the system reduces to the classic Kuramoto model of coupled oscillators; for $d=3$, it has been proposed to describe the orientation dynamics of swarms of drones or other entities moving about in three-dimensional space. Here we use group theory to explain the recent discovery that the model shows low-dimensional dynamics for all $N \ge 3$, and to clarify why it admits the analog of the Ott-Antonsen ansatz in the continuum limit $N \rightarrow \infty$. The underlying reason is that the system is intimately connected to the natural hyperbolic geometry on the unit ball $B^d$. In this geometry, the isometries form a Lie group consisting of higher-dimensional generalizations of the Möbius transformations used in complex analysis. Once these connections are realized, the reduced dynamics and the generalized Ott-Antonsen ansatz follow immediately. This framework also reveals the seamless connection between the finite and infinite-$N$ cases. Finally, we show that special forms of coupling yield gradient dynamics with respect to the hyperbolic metric, and use that fact to obtain global stability results about convergence to the synchronized state.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2021; v1 submitted 16 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Conformal Group Actions on Generalized Kuramoto Oscillators
Authors:
Max Lipton
Abstract:
This paper unifies the recent results on generalized Kuramoto Model reductions. Lohe took a coupled system of $N$ bodies on $S^d$ governed by the Kuramoto equations $\dot{x_i} = Ωx_i + X - \langle x_i, X \rangle x_i$ and used the method of Watanabe and Strogatz to reduce this system to $d + \frac{d(d-1)}{2}$ equations. Using a model of rigid rotations on a sphere as a guide, we show that the reduc…
▽ More
This paper unifies the recent results on generalized Kuramoto Model reductions. Lohe took a coupled system of $N$ bodies on $S^d$ governed by the Kuramoto equations $\dot{x_i} = Ωx_i + X - \langle x_i, X \rangle x_i$ and used the method of Watanabe and Strogatz to reduce this system to $d + \frac{d(d-1)}{2}$ equations. Using a model of rigid rotations on a sphere as a guide, we show that the reduction is described by a smooth path in the Lie group of conformal transformations on the sphere, which is diffeomorphic to $SO(d) \times D^d$. Seeing the reduction this way allows us to apply geometric and topological reasoning in order to understand qualitative behavior of the Kuramoto Model.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2021; v1 submitted 16 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Six variations on a theme: almost planar graphs
Authors:
Max Lipton,
Eoin Mackall,
Thomas W. Mattman,
Mike Pierce,
Samantha Robinson,
Jeremy Thomas,
Ilan Weinschelbaum
Abstract:
A graph is apex if it can be made planar by deleting a vertex, that is, $\exists v$ such that $G-v$ is planar. We define the related notions of edge apex, $\exists e$ such that $G-e$ is planar, and contraction apex, $\exists e$ such that $G/e$ is planar, as well as the analogues with a universal quantifier: $\forall v$, $G-v$ planar; $\forall e$, $G-e$ planar; and $\forall e$, $G/e$ planar. The Gr…
▽ More
A graph is apex if it can be made planar by deleting a vertex, that is, $\exists v$ such that $G-v$ is planar. We define the related notions of edge apex, $\exists e$ such that $G-e$ is planar, and contraction apex, $\exists e$ such that $G/e$ is planar, as well as the analogues with a universal quantifier: $\forall v$, $G-v$ planar; $\forall e$, $G-e$ planar; and $\forall e$, $G/e$ planar. The Graph Minor Theorem of Robertson and Seymour ensures that each of these six gives rise to a finite set of obstruction graphs. For the three definitions with universal quantifiers we determine this set. For the remaining properties, apex, edge apex, and contraction apex, we show there are at least 36, 55, and 82 obstruction graphs respectively. We give two similar approaches to almost nonplanar ($\exists e$, $G+e$ is nonplanar and $\forall e$, $G+e$ is nonplanar) and determine the corresponding minor minimal graphs.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
