-
Noise-induced servo errors in optical clocks utilizing Rabi interrogation
Authors:
T. Lindvall,
A. E. Wallin,
K. J. Hanhijärvi,
T. Fordell
Abstract:
We show that in optical clocks based on Rabi interrogation, both laser-frequency and magnetic-field flicker ($1/f$) noise with zero mean can lead to servo errors at the $10^{-18}$ level if the negative-detuning (red) and positive-detuning (blue) sides of the transition are always probed in the same order. This is due to the strong correlations of flicker noise in combination with an imbalance in t…
▽ More
We show that in optical clocks based on Rabi interrogation, both laser-frequency and magnetic-field flicker ($1/f$) noise with zero mean can lead to servo errors at the $10^{-18}$ level if the negative-detuning (red) and positive-detuning (blue) sides of the transition are always probed in the same order. This is due to the strong correlations of flicker noise in combination with an imbalance in the response of the servo discriminator to positive and negative differential frequency noise between the red- and blue-side probing. This imbalance is particularly large for a normalized discriminator. We derive an analytical expression for the servo error based on the correlation function of the laser-frequency or magnetic-field noise and compare it to numerical servo simulations to demonstrate how the error depends on the noise level, servo parameters, and probing sequence. We also show that the servo error can be avoided by normalizing the discriminator with a moving mean or by reversing the red/blue probing order for every second servo cycle.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Evaluation of a $^{88}$Sr$^+$ optical clock with a direct measurement of the blackbody radiation shift and determination of the clock frequency
Authors:
M. Steinel,
H. Shao,
M. Filzinger,
B. Lipphardt,
M. Brinkmann,
A. Didier,
T. E. Mehlstäubler,
T. Lindvall,
E. Peik,
N. Huntemann
Abstract:
We report on an evaluation of an optical clock that uses the $\phantom{}^2S_{1/2} \rightarrow \phantom{}^2D_{5/2}$ transition of a single $^{88}$Sr$^+$ ion as the reference. In contrast to previous work, we estimate the effective temperature of the blackbody radiation that shifts the reference transition directly during operation from the corresponding frequency shift and the well-characterized se…
▽ More
We report on an evaluation of an optical clock that uses the $\phantom{}^2S_{1/2} \rightarrow \phantom{}^2D_{5/2}$ transition of a single $^{88}$Sr$^+$ ion as the reference. In contrast to previous work, we estimate the effective temperature of the blackbody radiation that shifts the reference transition directly during operation from the corresponding frequency shift and the well-characterized sensitivity to thermal radiation. We measure the clock output frequency against an independent $^{171}$Yb$^+$ ion clock, based on the $\phantom{}^2S_{1/2} (F=0) \rightarrow \phantom{}^2F_{7/2} (F=3)$ electric octupole (E3) transition, and determine the frequency ratio with a total fractional uncertainty of $2.3\times 10^{-17}$. Relying on a previous measurement of the $^{171}$Yb$^+$ (E3) clock frequency, we find the absolute frequency of the $^{88}$Sr$^+$ clock transition to be $444779044095485.271(59)\,\text{Hz}$. Our result reduces the uncertainty by a factor of $3$ compared to the previously most accurate measurement and may help to resolve so far inconsistent determinations of this value. We also show that for three simultaneously interrogated $^{88}$Sr$^+$ ions, the increased number causes the expected improvement of the short-term frequency instability of the optical clock without degrading its systematic uncertainty.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
High-Accuracy Determination of Paul-Trap Stability Parameters for Electric-Quadrupole-Shift Prediction
Authors:
T. Lindvall,
K. J. Hanhijärvi,
T. Fordell,
A. E. Wallin
Abstract:
The motion of an ion in a radiofrequency (rf) Paul trap is described by the Mathieu equation and the associated stability parameters that are proportional to the rf and dc electric field gradients. Here, a higher-order, iterative method to accurately solve the stability parameters from measured secular frequencies is presented. It is then used to characterize an endcap trap by showing that the tra…
▽ More
The motion of an ion in a radiofrequency (rf) Paul trap is described by the Mathieu equation and the associated stability parameters that are proportional to the rf and dc electric field gradients. Here, a higher-order, iterative method to accurately solve the stability parameters from measured secular frequencies is presented. It is then used to characterize an endcap trap by showing that the trap's radial asymmetry is dominated by the dc field gradients and by measuring the relation between the applied voltages and the gradients. The results are shown to be in good agreement with an electrostatic finite-element-method simulation of the trap. Furthermore, a method to determine the direction of the radial trap axes using a 'tickler' voltage is presented and the temperature dependence of the rf voltage is discussed. As an application for optical ion clocks, the method is used to predict and minimize the electric quadrupole shift (EQS) using the applied dc voltages. Finally, a lower limit of 1070 for the cancellation factor of the Zeeman-averaging EQS cancellation method is determined in an interleaved low/high EQS clock measurement. This reduces the EQS uncertainty of our $^{88}$Sr$^+$ optical clock to ${\lesssim} 1\times 10^{-19}$ in fractional frequency units.
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Guidelines for develo** optical clocks with $10^{-18}$ fractional frequency uncertainty
Authors:
Moustafa Abdel-Hafiz,
Piotr Ablewski,
Ali Al-Masoudi,
Héctor Álvarez Martínez,
Petr Balling,
Geoffrey Barwood,
Erik Benkler,
Marcin Bober,
Mateusz Borkowski,
William Bowden,
Roman Ciuryło,
Hubert Cybulski,
Alexandre Didier,
Miroslav Doležal,
Sören Dörscher,
Stephan Falke,
Rachel M. Godun,
Ramiz Hamid,
Ian R. Hill,
Richard Hobson,
Nils Huntemann,
Yann Le Coq,
Rodolphe Le Targat,
Thomas Legero,
Thomas Lindvall
, et al. (20 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
There has been tremendous progress in the performance of optical frequency standards since the first proposals to carry out precision spectroscopy on trapped, single ions in the 1970s. The estimated fractional frequency uncertainty of today's leading optical standards is currently in the $10^{-18}$ range, approximately two orders of magnitude better than that of the best caesium primary frequency…
▽ More
There has been tremendous progress in the performance of optical frequency standards since the first proposals to carry out precision spectroscopy on trapped, single ions in the 1970s. The estimated fractional frequency uncertainty of today's leading optical standards is currently in the $10^{-18}$ range, approximately two orders of magnitude better than that of the best caesium primary frequency standards. This exceptional accuracy and stability is resulting in a growing number of research groups develo** optical clocks. While good review papers covering the topic already exist, more practical guidelines are needed as a complement. The purpose of this document is therefore to provide technical guidance for researchers starting in the field of optical clocks. The target audience includes national metrology institutes (NMIs) wanting to set up optical clocks (or subsystems thereof) and PhD students and postdocs entering the field. Another potential audience is academic groups with experience in atomic physics and atom or ion trap**, but with less experience of time and frequency metrology and optical clock requirements. These guidelines have arisen from the scope of the EMPIR project "Optical clocks with $1 \times 10^{-18}$ uncertainty" (OC18). Therefore, the examples are from European laboratories even though similar work is carried out all over the world. The goal of OC18 was to push the development of optical clocks by improving each of the necessary subsystems: ultrastable lasers, neutral-atom and single-ion traps, and interrogation techniques. This document shares the knowledge acquired by the OC18 project consortium and gives practical guidance on each of these aspects.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2019; v1 submitted 27 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Broadband lasers for photo-ionization and repum** of trapped ions
Authors:
T. Fordell,
T. Lindvall
Abstract:
A frequency-stable, broadband laser is presented for experiments on trapped ions. Since the design is based on widely available semiconductor optical amplifier technology, similar lasers can be realized for virtually any wavelength in the near-infrared, and the coherence properties and output power allow for efficient second harmonic generation. No closed-loop frequency stabilization for addressin…
▽ More
A frequency-stable, broadband laser is presented for experiments on trapped ions. Since the design is based on widely available semiconductor optical amplifier technology, similar lasers can be realized for virtually any wavelength in the near-infrared, and the coherence properties and output power allow for efficient second harmonic generation. No closed-loop frequency stabilization for addressing Doppler- or naturally-broadened, dipole-allowed transitions is needed, and the light source can be turned on and off during a measurement cycle with sub-microsecond response time. As a case study, a 921.7-nm laser with an output power of 20mW and a linewidth of 10GHz is realized, which is then frequency doubled to 460.9nm for excitation of strontium as the first step in photo-ionization. The excitation efficiency is compared to that achievable with a narrow-linewidth distributed Bragg reflector laser as well as to theory.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Measurement of differential polarizabilities at a mid-infrared wavelength in $^{171}\mathrm{Yb}^+$
Authors:
C F A Baynham,
E A Curtis,
R M Godun,
J M Jones,
P B R Nisbet-Jones,
P E G Baird,
K Bongs,
P Gill,
T Fordell,
T Hieta,
T Lindvall,
M T Spidell,
J H Lehman
Abstract:
An atom exposed to an electric field will experience Stark shifts of its internal energy levels, proportional to their polarizabilities. In optical frequency metrology, the Stark shift due to background black-body radiation (BBR) modifies the frequency of the optical clock transition, and often represents a large contribution to a clock's uncertainty budget. For clocks based on singly-ionized ytte…
▽ More
An atom exposed to an electric field will experience Stark shifts of its internal energy levels, proportional to their polarizabilities. In optical frequency metrology, the Stark shift due to background black-body radiation (BBR) modifies the frequency of the optical clock transition, and often represents a large contribution to a clock's uncertainty budget. For clocks based on singly-ionized ytterbium, the ion's complex structure makes this shift difficult to calculate theoretically. We present a measurement of the differential polarizabilities of two ultra-narrow optical clock transitions present in $^{171}\mathrm{Yb}^+$, performed by exposing the ion to an oscillating electric field at a wavelength in the region of room temperature BBR spectra. By measuring the frequency shift to the transitions caused by a laser at $λ=7.17 μm$, we obtain values for scalar and tensor differential polarizabilities with uncertainties at the percent level for both the electric quadrupole and octupole transitions at 436nm and 467nm respectively. These values agree with previously reported experimental measurements and, in the case of the electric quadrupole transition, allow a 5-fold improvement in the determination of the room-temperature BBR shift.
However, we note significant concerns over the validity of the uncertainty charactarization presented and draw the reader's attention to the Note on applicability section for a discussion.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2020; v1 submitted 30 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
The spin resonance clock transition of the endohedral fullerene $^{15}\mathrm{N@C}_{60}$
Authors:
R. T. Harding,
S. Zhou,
J. Zhou,
T. Lindvall,
W. K. Myers,
A. Ardavan,
G. A. D. Briggs,
K. Porfyrakis,
E. A. Laird
Abstract:
The endohedral fullerene $^{15}\mathrm{N@C}_{60}$ has narrow electron paramagnetic resonance lines which have been proposed as the basis for a condensed-matter portable atomic clock. We measure the low-frequency spectrum of this molecule, identifying and characterizing a clock transition at which the frequency becomes insensitive to magnetic field. We infer a linewidth at the clock field of 100 kH…
▽ More
The endohedral fullerene $^{15}\mathrm{N@C}_{60}$ has narrow electron paramagnetic resonance lines which have been proposed as the basis for a condensed-matter portable atomic clock. We measure the low-frequency spectrum of this molecule, identifying and characterizing a clock transition at which the frequency becomes insensitive to magnetic field. We infer a linewidth at the clock field of 100 kHz. Using experimental data, we are able to place a bound on the clock's projected frequency stability. We discuss ways to improve the frequency stability to be competitive with existing miniature clocks.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Analysis of thermal radiation in ion traps for optical frequency standards
Authors:
Miroslav Doležal,
Petr Balling,
Peter B R Nisbet-Jones,
Steven A King,
Jonathan M Jones,
Hugh A Klein,
Patrick Gill,
Thomas Lindvall,
Anders E Wallin,
Mikko Merimaa,
Christian Tamm,
Christian Sanner,
Nils Huntemann,
Nils Scharnhorst,
Ian D Leroux,
Piet O Schmidt,
Tobias Burgermeister,
Tanja E Mehlstäubler,
Ekkehard Peik
Abstract:
In many of the high-precision optical frequency standards with trapped atoms or ions that are under development to date, the AC Stark shift induced by thermal radiation leads to a major contribution to the systematic uncertainty. We present an analysis of the inhomogeneous thermal environment experienced by ions in various types of ion traps. Finite element models which allow the determination of…
▽ More
In many of the high-precision optical frequency standards with trapped atoms or ions that are under development to date, the AC Stark shift induced by thermal radiation leads to a major contribution to the systematic uncertainty. We present an analysis of the inhomogeneous thermal environment experienced by ions in various types of ion traps. Finite element models which allow the determination of the temperature of the trap structure and the temperature of the radiation were developed for 5 ion trap designs, including operational traps at PTB and NPL and further optimized designs. Models were refined based on comparison with infrared camera measurement until an agreement of better than 10% of the measured temperature rise at critical test points was reached. The effective temperature rises of the radiation seen by the ion range from 0.8 K to 2.1 K at standard working conditions. The corresponding fractional frequency shift uncertainties resulting from the uncertainty in temperature are in the 10-18 range for optical clocks based on the Sr+ and Yb+ E2 transitions, and even lower for Yb+ E3, In+ and Al+. Issues critical for heating of the trap structure and its predictability were identified and design recommendations developed.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2015; v1 submitted 19 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Broadband, unpolarized repum** and clearout light sources for Sr$^+$ single-ion clocks
Authors:
T. Fordell,
T. Lindvall,
P. Dubé,
A. A. Madej,
A. E. Wallin,
M. Merimaa
Abstract:
Future transportable optical clocks require compact and reliable light sources. Here, broadband, unpolarized repumper and state clearout sources for Sr+ single-ion optical clocks are reported. These turn-key devices require no frequency stabilization nor external modulators. They are fiber based, inexpensive, and compact. Key characteristics for clock operation are presented, including optical spe…
▽ More
Future transportable optical clocks require compact and reliable light sources. Here, broadband, unpolarized repumper and state clearout sources for Sr+ single-ion optical clocks are reported. These turn-key devices require no frequency stabilization nor external modulators. They are fiber based, inexpensive, and compact. Key characteristics for clock operation are presented, including optical spectra, induced light shifts and required extinction ratios. Tests with an operating single-ion standard show a clearout efficiency of 100%. Compared to a laser-based repumper, the achievable fluorescence rates for ion detection are a few tens of per cent lower. The resulting ion kinetic temperature is 1--1.5 mK, near the Doppler limit of the ion system. Similar repumper light sources could be made for Ca+ (866 nm) and Ba+ (650 nm) using semiconductor gain media.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Unpolarized, incoherent repum** light for prevention of dark states in a trapped and laser-cooled single ion
Authors:
T. Lindvall,
T. Fordell,
I. Tittonen,
M. Merimaa
Abstract:
Many ion species commonly used for laser-cooled ion trap** studies have a low-lying metastable 2D3/2 state that can become populated due to spontaneous emission from the 2P1/2 excited state. This requires a repumper laser to maintain the ion in the Doppler cooling cycle. Typically the 2D3/2 state, or some of its hyperfine components if the ion has nuclear spin, has a higher multiplicity than the…
▽ More
Many ion species commonly used for laser-cooled ion trap** studies have a low-lying metastable 2D3/2 state that can become populated due to spontaneous emission from the 2P1/2 excited state. This requires a repumper laser to maintain the ion in the Doppler cooling cycle. Typically the 2D3/2 state, or some of its hyperfine components if the ion has nuclear spin, has a higher multiplicity than the upper state of the repum** transition. This can lead to dark states, which have to be destabilized by an external magnetic field or by modulating the polarization of the repumper laser. We propose using unpolarized, incoherent amplified spontaneous emission (ASE) to drive the repum** transition. An ASE source offers several advantages compared to a laser. It prevents the buildup of dark states without external polarization modulation even in zero magnetic field, it can drive multiple hyperfine transitions simultaneously, and it requires no frequency stabilization. These features make it very compact and robust, which is essential for the development of practical, transportable optical ion clocks. We construct a theoretical model for the ASE radiation, including the possibility of the source being partially polarized. Using 88Sr+ as an example, the performance of the ASE source compared to a single-mode laser is analyzed by numerically solving the eight-level density matrix equations for the involved energy levels. Finally a reduced three-level system is derived, yielding a simple formula for the excited state population and scattering rate, which can be used to optimize the experimental parameters. The required ASE power spectral density can be obtained with current technology.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2013; v1 submitted 23 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Dark-state suppression and optimization of laser cooling and fluorescence in a trapped alkaline-earth-metal single ion
Authors:
T. Lindvall,
M. Merimaa,
I. Tittonen,
A. A. Madej
Abstract:
We study the formation and destabilization of dark states in a single trapped 88Sr+ ion caused by the cooling and repum** laser fields required for Doppler cooling and fluorescence detection of the ion. By numerically solving the time-dependent density matrix equations for the eight-level system consisting of the sublevels of the 5s 2S1/2, 5p 2P1/2, and 4d 2D3/2 states, we analyze the different…
▽ More
We study the formation and destabilization of dark states in a single trapped 88Sr+ ion caused by the cooling and repum** laser fields required for Doppler cooling and fluorescence detection of the ion. By numerically solving the time-dependent density matrix equations for the eight-level system consisting of the sublevels of the 5s 2S1/2, 5p 2P1/2, and 4d 2D3/2 states, we analyze the different types of dark states and how to prevent them in order to maximize the scattering rate, which is crucial for both the cooling and the detection of the ion. The influence of the laser linewidths and ion motion on the scattering rate and the dark resonances is studied. The calculations are then compared with experimental results obtained with an endcap ion trap system located at the National Research Council of Canada and found to be in good agreement. The results are applicable also to other alkaline earth ions and isotopes without hyperfine structure.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Translated Poisson approximation for Markov chains
Authors:
A. D. Barbour,
Torgny Lindvall
Abstract:
The paper is concerned with approximating the distribution of a sum W of n integer valued random variables Y_i, whose distributions depend on the state of an underlying Markov chain X. The approximation is in terms of a translated Poisson distribution, with mean and variance chosen to be close to those of W, and the error is measured with respect to the total variation norm. Error bounds compara…
▽ More
The paper is concerned with approximating the distribution of a sum W of n integer valued random variables Y_i, whose distributions depend on the state of an underlying Markov chain X. The approximation is in terms of a translated Poisson distribution, with mean and variance chosen to be close to those of W, and the error is measured with respect to the total variation norm. Error bounds comparable to those found for normal approximation with respect to the weaker Kolmogorov distance are established, provided that the distribution of the sum of the Y_i's between the successive visits of X to a reference state is aperiodic. Without this assumption, approximation in total variation cannot be expected to be good.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2008;
originally announced October 2008.
-
Trap** atoms on a transparent permanent-magnet atom chip
Authors:
A. Shevchenko,
M. Heilio,
T. Lindvall,
A. Jaakkola,
I. Tittonen,
M. Kaivola,
T. Pfau
Abstract:
We describe experiments on trap** of atoms in microscopic magneto-optical traps on an optically transparent permanent-magnet atom chip. The chip is made of magnetically hard ferrite-garnet material deposited on a dielectric substrate. The confining magnetic fields are produced by miniature magnetized patterns recorded in the film by magneto-optical techniques. We trap Rb atoms on these structu…
▽ More
We describe experiments on trap** of atoms in microscopic magneto-optical traps on an optically transparent permanent-magnet atom chip. The chip is made of magnetically hard ferrite-garnet material deposited on a dielectric substrate. The confining magnetic fields are produced by miniature magnetized patterns recorded in the film by magneto-optical techniques. We trap Rb atoms on these structures by applying three crossed pairs of counter-propagating laser beams in the conventional magneto-optical trap** (MOT) geometry. We demonstrate the flexibility of the concept in creation and in-situ modification of the trap** geometries through several experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2006; v1 submitted 24 January, 2006;
originally announced January 2006.
