Showing 1–38 of 38 results for author: Linde, N

Rare event probability estimation for groundwater inverse problems with a two-stage Sequential Monte Carlo approach

Authors: Lea Friedli, Niklas Linde

Abstract: Bayesian inversions followed by estimations of rare event probabilities are often needed to analyse groundwater hazards. Instead of focusing on the posterior distribution of model parameters, the main interest lies then in the distribution of a specific quantity of interest contingent upon these parameters. To address the associated methodological challenges, we introduce a two-stage Sequential Mo… ▽ More Bayesian inversions followed by estimations of rare event probabilities are often needed to analyse groundwater hazards. Instead of focusing on the posterior distribution of model parameters, the main interest lies then in the distribution of a specific quantity of interest contingent upon these parameters. To address the associated methodological challenges, we introduce a two-stage Sequential Monte Carlo approach. In the first stage, it generates particles that approximate the posterior distribution; in the second stage, it employs subset sampling techniques to assess the probability of the rare event of interest. By considering two hydrogeological problems of increasing complexity, we showcase the efficiency and accuracy of the resulting PostRisk-SMC method for rare event probability estimation related to groundwater hazards. We compare the performance of the PostRisk-SMC method with a traditional Monte Carlo approach that relies on Markov chain Monte Carlo samples. We showcase that our estimates align with those of the traditional method, but the coefficients of variation are notably lower for the same computational budget when targeting more rare events. Furthermore, we highlight that the PostRisk-SMC method allows estimating rare event probabilities approaching one in a billion using less than one hundred thousand forward simulations. Even if the presented examples are related to groundwater hazards, the methodology is well-suited for addressing a wide range of topics in the geosciences and beyond. △ Less

Submitted 24 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

An energy-based model approach to rare event probability estimation

Authors: Lea Friedli, David Ginsbourger, Arnaud Doucet, Niklas Linde

Abstract: The estimation of rare event probabilities plays a pivotal role in diverse fields. Our aim is to determine the probability of a hazard or system failure occurring when a quantity of interest exceeds a critical value. In our approach, the distribution of the quantity of interest is represented by an energy density, characterized by a free energy function. To efficiently estimate the free energy, a… ▽ More The estimation of rare event probabilities plays a pivotal role in diverse fields. Our aim is to determine the probability of a hazard or system failure occurring when a quantity of interest exceeds a critical value. In our approach, the distribution of the quantity of interest is represented by an energy density, characterized by a free energy function. To efficiently estimate the free energy, a bias potential is introduced. Using concepts from energy-based models (EBM), this bias potential is optimized such that the corresponding probability density function approximates a pre-defined distribution targeting the failure region of interest. Given the optimal bias potential, the free energy function and the rare event probability of interest can be determined. The approach is applicable not just in traditional rare event settings where the variable upon which the quantity of interest relies has a known distribution, but also in inversion settings where the variable follows a posterior distribution. By combining the EBM approach with a Stein discrepancy-based stop** criterion, we aim for a balanced accuracy-efficiency trade-off. Furthermore, we explore both parametric and non-parametric approaches for the bias potential, with the latter eliminating the need for choosing a particular parameterization, but depending strongly on the accuracy of the kernel density estimate used in the optimization process. Through three illustrative test cases encompassing both traditional and inversion settings, we show that the proposed EBM approach, when properly configured, (i) allows stable and efficient estimation of rare event probabilities and (ii) compares favorably against subset sampling approaches. △ Less

Submitted 6 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Bayesian tomography using polynomial chaos expansion and deep generative networks

Authors: Giovanni Angelo Meles, Macarena Amaya, Shiran Levy, Stefano Marelli, Niklas Linde

Abstract: Implementations of Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods need to confront two fundamental challenges: accurate representation of prior information and efficient evaluation of likelihoods. Principal component analysis (PCA) and related techniques can in some cases facilitate the definition and sampling of the prior distribution, as well as the training of accurate surrogate models, using for inst… ▽ More Implementations of Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods need to confront two fundamental challenges: accurate representation of prior information and efficient evaluation of likelihoods. Principal component analysis (PCA) and related techniques can in some cases facilitate the definition and sampling of the prior distribution, as well as the training of accurate surrogate models, using for instance, polynomial chaos expansion (PCE). However, complex geological priors with sharp contrasts necessitate more complex dimensionality-reduction techniques, such as, deep generative models (DGMs). By sampling a low-dimensional prior probability distribution defined in the low-dimensional latent space of such a model, it becomes possible to efficiently sample the physical domain at the price of a generator that is typically highly non-linear. Training a surrogate that is capable of capturing intricate non-linear relationships between latent parameters and outputs of forward modeling presents a notable challenge. Indeed, while PCE models provide high accuracy when the input-output relationship can be effectively approximated by relatively low-degree multivariate polynomials, this condition is typically not met when employing latent variables derived from DGMs. In this contribution, we present a strategy combining the excellent reconstruction performances of a variational autoencoder (VAE) with the accuracy of PCA-PCE surrogate modeling in the context of Bayesian ground penetrating radar (GPR) traveltime tomography. Within the MCMC process, the parametrization of the VAE is leveraged for prior exploration and sample proposals. Concurrently, surrogate modeling is conducted using PCE, which operates on either globally or locally defined principal components of the VAE samples under examination. △ Less

Submitted 19 October, 2023; v1 submitted 9 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 25 pages, 15 figures

Bayesian tomography with prior-knowledge-based parametrization and surrogate modeling

Authors: Giovanni Angelo Meles, Niklas Linde, Stefano Marelli

Abstract: We present a Bayesian tomography framework operating with prior-knowledge-based parametrization that is accelerated by surrogate models. Standard high-fidelity forward solvers solve wave equations with natural spatial parametrizations based on fine discretization. Similar parametrizations, typically involving tens of thousand of variables, are usually employed to parameterize the subsurface in tom… ▽ More We present a Bayesian tomography framework operating with prior-knowledge-based parametrization that is accelerated by surrogate models. Standard high-fidelity forward solvers solve wave equations with natural spatial parametrizations based on fine discretization. Similar parametrizations, typically involving tens of thousand of variables, are usually employed to parameterize the subsurface in tomography applications. When the data do not allow to resolve details at such finely parameterized scales, it is often beneficial to instead rely on a prior-knowledge-based parametrization defined on a lower dimension domain (or manifold). Due to the increased identifiability in the reduced domain, the concomitant inversion is better constrained and generally faster. We illustrate the potential of a prior-knowledge-based approach by considering ground penetrating radar (GPR) travel-time tomography in a crosshole configuration. An effective parametrization of the input (i.e., the permittivity distributions) and compression in the output (i.e., the travel-time gathers) spaces are achieved via data-driven principal component decomposition based on random realizations of the prior Gaussian-process model with a truncation determined by the performances of the standard solver on the full and reduced model domains. To accelerate the inversion process, we employ a high-fidelity polynomial chaos expansion (PCE) surrogate model. We show that a few hundreds design data sets is sufficient to provide reliable Markov chain Monte Carlo inversion. Appropriate uncertainty quantification is achieved by reintroducing the truncated higher-order principle components in the original model space after inversion on the manifold and by adapting a likelihood function that accounts for the fact that the truncated higher-order components are not completely located in the null-space. △ Less

Submitted 7 January, 2022; originally announced January 2022.

Comments: 27 pages, 14 images

Using deep generative neural networks to account for model errors in Markov chain Monte Carlo inversion

Authors: Shiran Levy, Jürg Hunziker, Eric Laloy, James Irving, Niklas Linde

Abstract: Most geophysical inverse problems are nonlinear and rely upon numerical forward solvers involving discretization and simplified representations of the underlying physics. As a result, forward modeling errors are inevitable. In practice, such model errors tend to be either completely ignored, which leads to biased and over-confident inversion results, or only partly taken into account using restric… ▽ More Most geophysical inverse problems are nonlinear and rely upon numerical forward solvers involving discretization and simplified representations of the underlying physics. As a result, forward modeling errors are inevitable. In practice, such model errors tend to be either completely ignored, which leads to biased and over-confident inversion results, or only partly taken into account using restrictive Gaussian assumptions. Here, we rely on deep generative neural networks to learn problem-specific low-dimensional probabilistic representations of the discrepancy between high-fidelity and low-fidelity forward solvers. These representations are then used to probabilistically invert for the model error jointly with the target geophysical property field, using the computationally-cheap, low-fidelity forward solver. To this end, we combine a Markov-chain-Monte-Carlo (MCMC) inversion algorithm with a trained convolutional neural network of the spatial generative adversarial network (SGAN) type, whereby at each MCMC step, the simulated low-fidelity forward response is corrected using a proposed model-error realization. Considering the crosshole ground-penetrating radar traveltime tomography inverse problem, we train SGAN networks on traveltime discrepancy images between: (1) curved-ray (high fidelity) and straight-ray (low fidelity) forward solvers; and (2) finite-difference-time-domain (high fidelity) and straight-ray (low fidelity) forward solvers. We demonstrate that the SGAN is able to learn the spatial statistics of the model error and that suitable representations of both the subsurface model and model error can be recovered by MCMC. In comparison with inversion results obtained when model errors are either ignored or approximated by a Gaussian distribution, we find that our method has lower posterior parameter bias and better explains the observed traveltime data.[...] △ Less

Submitted 1 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Comments: Original publication: Geophys. J. Int., 23 September 2021

Journal ref: Geophysical Journal International, Volume 228, Issue 2, February 2022

Lithological Tomography with the Correlated Pseudo-Marginal Method

Authors: Lea Friedli, Niklas Linde, David Ginsbourger, Arnaud Doucet

Abstract: We consider lithological tomography in which the posterior distribution of (hydro)geological parameters of interest is inferred from geophysical data by treating the intermediate geophysical properties as latent variables. In such a latent variable model, one needs to estimate the intractable likelihood of the (hydro)geological parameters given the geophysical data. The pseudo-marginal method is a… ▽ More We consider lithological tomography in which the posterior distribution of (hydro)geological parameters of interest is inferred from geophysical data by treating the intermediate geophysical properties as latent variables. In such a latent variable model, one needs to estimate the intractable likelihood of the (hydro)geological parameters given the geophysical data. The pseudo-marginal method is an adaptation of the Metropolis-Hastings algorithm in which an unbiased approximation of this likelihood is obtained by Monte Carlo averaging over samples from, in this setting, the noisy petrophysical relationship linking (hydro)geological and geophysical properties. To make the method practical in data-rich geophysical settings with low noise levels, we demonstrate that the Monte Carlo sampling must rely on importance sampling distributions that well approximate the posterior distribution of petrophysical scatter around the sampled (hydro)geological parameter field. To achieve a suitable acceptance rate, we rely both on (1) the correlated pseudo-marginal method, which correlates the samples used in the proposed and current states of the Markov chain, and (2) a model proposal scheme that preserves the prior distribution. As a synthetic test example, we infer porosity fields using crosshole ground-penetrating radar (GPR) first-arrival travel times. We use a (50x50)-dimensional pixel-based parameterization of the multi-Gaussian porosity field with known statistical parameters, resulting in a parameter space of high dimension. We demonstrate that the correlated pseudo-marginal method with our proposed importance sampling and prior-preserving proposal scheme outperforms current state-of-the-art methods in both linear and non-linear settings by greatly enhancing the posterior exploration. △ Less

Submitted 11 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Journal ref: Geophysical Journal International, Volume 228, Issue 2, February 2022

Uncertainty Quantification and Experimental Design for Large-Scale Linear Inverse Problems under Gaussian Process Priors

Authors: Cédric Travelletti, David Ginsbourger, Niklas Linde

Abstract: We consider the use of Gaussian process (GP) priors for solving inverse problems in a Bayesian framework. As is well known, the computational complexity of GPs scales cubically in the number of datapoints. We here show that in the context of inverse problems involving integral operators, one faces additional difficulties that hinder inversion on large grids. Furthermore, in that context, covarianc… ▽ More We consider the use of Gaussian process (GP) priors for solving inverse problems in a Bayesian framework. As is well known, the computational complexity of GPs scales cubically in the number of datapoints. We here show that in the context of inverse problems involving integral operators, one faces additional difficulties that hinder inversion on large grids. Furthermore, in that context, covariance matrices can become too large to be stored. By leveraging results about sequential disintegrations of Gaussian measures, we are able to introduce an implicit representation of posterior covariance matrices that reduces the memory footprint by only storing low rank intermediate matrices, while allowing individual elements to be accessed on-the-fly without needing to build full posterior covariance matrices. Moreover, it allows for fast sequential inclusion of new observations. These features are crucial when considering sequential experimental design tasks. We demonstrate our approach by computing sequential data collection plans for excursion set recovery for a gravimetric inverse problem, where the goal is to provide fine resolution estimates of high density regions inside the Stromboli volcano, Italy. Sequential data collection plans are computed by extending the weighted integrated variance reduction (wIVR) criterion to inverse problems. Our results show that this criterion is able to significantly reduce the uncertainty on the excursion volume, reaching close to minimal levels of residual uncertainty. Overall, our techniques allow the advantages of probabilistic models to be brought to bear on large-scale inverse problems arising in the natural sciences. △ Less

Submitted 31 August, 2022; v1 submitted 8 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

MSC Class: 86A22; 60G15; 62F15; 62L05

Adaptive sequential Monte Carlo for posterior inference and model selection among complex geological priors

Authors: M. Amaya, N. Linde, E. Laloy

Abstract: Bayesian model selection enables comparison and ranking of conceptual subsurface models described by spatial prior models, according to the support provided by available geophysical data. Deep generative neural networks can efficiently encode such complex spatial priors, thereby, allowing for a strong model dimensionality reduction that comes at the price of enhanced non-linearity. In this setting… ▽ More Bayesian model selection enables comparison and ranking of conceptual subsurface models described by spatial prior models, according to the support provided by available geophysical data. Deep generative neural networks can efficiently encode such complex spatial priors, thereby, allowing for a strong model dimensionality reduction that comes at the price of enhanced non-linearity. In this setting, we explore a recent adaptive sequential Monte Carlo (ASMC) approach that builds on Annealed Importance Sampling (AIS); a method that provides both the posterior probability density function (PDF) and the evidence (a central quantity for Bayesian model selection) through a particle approximation. Both techniques are well suited to parallel computation and rely on importance sampling over a sequence of intermediate distributions, linking the prior and the posterior PDF. Each subsequent distribution is approximated by updating the particle weights and states, compared with the previous approximation, using a small pre-defined number of Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) proposal steps. Compared with AIS, the ASMC method adaptively tunes the tempering between neighboring distributions and performs resampling of particles when the variance of the particle weights becomes too large. We evaluate ASMC using two different conceptual models and associated synthetic cross-hole ground penetrating radar (GPR) tomography data. For the most challenging test case, we find that the ASMC method is faster and more reliable in locating the posterior PDF than state-of-the-art adaptive MCMC. The evidence estimates are found to be robust with respect to the choice of ASMC algorithmic variables and much less sensitive to the model proposal type than MCMC.[...] △ Less

Submitted 5 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Comments: Geophysical Journal International (2021)

Fast ABC with joint generative modelling and subset simulation

Authors: Eliane Maalouf, David Ginsbourger, Niklas Linde

Abstract: We propose a novel approach for solving inverse-problems with high-dimensional inputs and an expensive forward map**. It leverages joint deep generative modelling to transfer the original problem spaces to a lower dimensional latent space. By jointly modelling input and output variables and endowing the latent with a prior distribution, the fitted probabilistic model indirectly gives access to t… ▽ More We propose a novel approach for solving inverse-problems with high-dimensional inputs and an expensive forward map**. It leverages joint deep generative modelling to transfer the original problem spaces to a lower dimensional latent space. By jointly modelling input and output variables and endowing the latent with a prior distribution, the fitted probabilistic model indirectly gives access to the approximate conditional distributions of interest. Since model error and observational noise with unknown distributions are common in practice, we resort to likelihood-free inference with Approximate Bayesian Computation (ABC). Our method calls on ABC by Subset Simulation to explore the regions of the latent space with dissimilarities between generated and observed outputs below prescribed thresholds. We diagnose the diversity of approximate posterior solutions by monitoring the probability content of these regions as a function of the threshold. We further analyze the curvature of the resulting diagnostic curve to propose an adequate ABC threshold. When applied to a cross-borehole tomography example from geophysics, our approach delivers promising performance without using prior knowledge of the forward nor of the noise distribution. △ Less

Submitted 16 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 13 pages, 6 figures

Advancing quantitative understanding of self-potential signatures in the critical zone through long-term monitoring

Authors: Kaiyan Hu, Damien Jougnot, Qinghua Huang, Majken C. Looms, Niklas Linde

Abstract: The self-potential (SP) method is a passive geophysical technique, which may offer insights about water and ionic fluxes in the vadose zone. The main obstacles presently prohibiting its routine use in quantitative vadose zone hydrology are the superposition of signals arising from various source mechanisms, difficult-to-predict electrode polarization effects that depend on electrode design and age… ▽ More The self-potential (SP) method is a passive geophysical technique, which may offer insights about water and ionic fluxes in the vadose zone. The main obstacles presently prohibiting its routine use in quantitative vadose zone hydrology are the superposition of signals arising from various source mechanisms, difficult-to-predict electrode polarization effects that depend on electrode design and age, as well as water saturation, pore water chemistry, clay content, and temperature in the immediate vicinity of the electrodes. We present a unique long-term SP monitoring experiment focusing on the first four years of data acquired at different depths in the vadose zone within the HOBE hydrological observatory in Denmark. Using state-of-the-art SP theory combined with flow and transport simulations, we attempt to replicate the observed data and suggest reasons for observed discrepancies. The predictions are overall satisfactory during the first six months of monitoring after which both the patterns and magnitudes of the observed data change drastically. Our main observations are (1) that predicted SP magnitudes are strongly sensitive to how the effective excess charge scales with water saturation implying that continued research is needed to build more accurate models of electrokinetic phenomena in unsaturated conditions, (2) that significant changes in electrode polarization occur in the shallowest electrodes at time scales of a year, suggesting that electrode effects cannot be ignored and that explicit electrode modeling should be considered in future monitoring studies, and (3) that multi-rate mass transfer and reactive transport modeling are needed to better predict salinity and pore water conductivity. We hope to stimulate other researchers to test new SP modeling approaches and interpretation strategies against these data by making the SP and complimentary data time-series available. △ Less

Submitted 18 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Comments: 17 pages, 12 figures, 2 tables

Journal ref: Journal of Hydrology 585 (2020) 124771

Approaching geoscientific inverse problems with vector-to-image domain transfer networks

Authors: Eric Laloy, Niklas Linde, Diederik Jacques

Abstract: We present vec2pix, a deep neural network designed to predict categorical or continuous 2D subsurface property fields from one-dimensional measurement data (e.g., time series), thereby offering a new approach to solve inverse problems. The performance of the method is investigated through two types of synthetic inverse problems: (a) a crosshole ground penetrating radar (GPR) tomography experiment… ▽ More We present vec2pix, a deep neural network designed to predict categorical or continuous 2D subsurface property fields from one-dimensional measurement data (e.g., time series), thereby offering a new approach to solve inverse problems. The performance of the method is investigated through two types of synthetic inverse problems: (a) a crosshole ground penetrating radar (GPR) tomography experiment with GPR travel times being used to infer a 2D velocity field, and (2) a multi-well pum** experiment within an unconfined aquifer with time series of transient hydraulic heads being used to retrieve a 2D hydraulic conductivity field. For each type of problem, both a multi-Gaussian and a binary channelized subsurface domain with long-range connectivity are considered. Using a training set of 20,000 examples (implying as many forward model evaluations), the method is found to recover a 2D model that is in much closer agreement with the true model than the closest training model in the forward-simulated data space. Further testing with smaller training sample sizes shows only a moderate reduction in performance when using 5000 training examples only. Even if the recovered models are visually close to the true ones, the data misfits associated with their forward responses are generally larger than the noise level used to contaminate the true data. Uncertainty of the inverse solution is partially assessed using deep ensembles, in which the network is trained repeatedly with random initialization. Overall, this study advances understanding of how to use deep learning to infer subsurface models from indirect measurement data. △ Less

Submitted 10 November, 2020; v1 submitted 20 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Reduction of conceptual model uncertainty using ground-penetrating radar profiles: Field-demonstration for a braided-river aquifer

Authors: Guillaume Pirot, Emanuel Huber, James Irving, Niklas Linde

Abstract: Hydrogeological flow and transport strongly depend on the connectivity of subsurface properties. Uncertainty concerning the underlying geological setting, due to a lack of field data and prior knowledge, calls for an evaluation of alternative geological conceptual models. To reduce the computational costs associated with inversions (parameter estimation for a given conceptual model), it is benefic… ▽ More Hydrogeological flow and transport strongly depend on the connectivity of subsurface properties. Uncertainty concerning the underlying geological setting, due to a lack of field data and prior knowledge, calls for an evaluation of alternative geological conceptual models. To reduce the computational costs associated with inversions (parameter estimation for a given conceptual model), it is beneficial to rank and discard unlikely conceptual models prior to inversion. Here, we demonstrate an approach based on a quantitative comparison of ground-penetrating radar (GPR) sections obtained from field data with corresponding simulation results arising from various geological scenarios. The comparison is based on three global distance measures related to wavelet decomposition, multiple-point histograms, and connectivity that capture geometrical characteristics of geophysical reflection images. Using field data from the Tagliamento braided river system, Italy, we demonstrate that seven out of nine considered geological scenarios can be discarded as they produce GPR sections that are incompatible with those observed in the field. The retained scenarios reproduce important features such as cross-stratified deposits and irregular property interfaces. The most convenient distance measure of those considered is the one based on wavelet-decomposition. Direct analysis of the distances is the most intuitive and fastest way to compare scenarios. △ Less

Submitted 28 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Gradient-based deterministic inversion of geophysical data with Generative Adversarial Networks: is it feasible?

Authors: Eric Laloy, Niklas Linde, Cyprien Ruffino, Romain Hérault, Gilles Gasso, Diedrik Jacques

Abstract: Global probabilistic inversion within the latent space learned by a Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) has been recently demonstrated. Compared to inversion on the original model space, using the latent space of a trained GAN can offer the following benefits: (1) the generated model proposals are geostatistically consistent with the prescribed prior training image (TI), and (2) the parameter spa… ▽ More Global probabilistic inversion within the latent space learned by a Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) has been recently demonstrated. Compared to inversion on the original model space, using the latent space of a trained GAN can offer the following benefits: (1) the generated model proposals are geostatistically consistent with the prescribed prior training image (TI), and (2) the parameter space is reduced by orders of magnitude compared to the original model space. Nevertheless, exploring the learned latent space by state-of-the-art Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods may still require a large computational effort. As an alternative, parameters in this latent space could possibly be optimized with much less computationally expensive gradient-based methods. We show that due to the typically highly nonlinear relationship between the latent space and the associated output space of a GAN, gradient-based deterministic inversion may fail even when considering a linear forward physical model. We tested two deterministic inversion approaches: a quasi-Newton gradient descent using the Adam algorithm and a Gauss-Newton (GN) method that makes use of the Jacobian matrix calculated by finite-differencing. For a channelized binary TI and a synthetic linear crosshole ground penetrating radar (GPR) tomography problem involving 576 measurements with low noise, we observe that when allowing for a total of 10,000 iterations only 13% of the gradient descent trials locate a solution that has the required data misfit. The tested GN inversion was unable to recover a solution with the appropriate data misfit. Our results suggest that deterministic inversion performance strongly depends on the inversion approach, starting model, true reference model, number of iterations and noise realization. In contrast, computationally-expensive probabilistic global optimization always finds an appropriate solution. △ Less

Submitted 23 May, 2019; v1 submitted 21 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Inversion using a new low-dimensional representation of complex binary geological media based on a deep neural network

Authors: Eric Laloy, Romain Hérault, John Lee, Diederik Jacques, Niklas Linde

Abstract: Efficient and high-fidelity prior sampling and inversion for complex geological media is still a largely unsolved challenge. Here, we use a deep neural network of the variational autoencoder type to construct a parametric low-dimensional base model parameterization of complex binary geological media. For inversion purposes, it has the attractive feature that random draws from an uncorrelated stand… ▽ More Efficient and high-fidelity prior sampling and inversion for complex geological media is still a largely unsolved challenge. Here, we use a deep neural network of the variational autoencoder type to construct a parametric low-dimensional base model parameterization of complex binary geological media. For inversion purposes, it has the attractive feature that random draws from an uncorrelated standard normal distribution yield model realizations with spatial characteristics that are in agreement with the training set. In comparison with the most commonly used parametric representations in probabilistic inversion, we find that our dimensionality reduction (DR) approach outperforms principle component analysis (PCA), optimization-PCA (OPCA) and discrete cosine transform (DCT) DR techniques for unconditional geostatistical simulation of a channelized prior model. For the considered examples, important compression ratios (200 - 500) are achieved. Given that the construction of our parameterization requires a training set of several tens of thousands of prior model realizations, our DR approach is more suited for probabilistic (or deterministic) inversion than for unconditional (or point-conditioned) geostatistical simulation. Probabilistic inversions of 2D steady-state and 3D transient hydraulic tomography data are used to demonstrate the DR-based inversion. For the 2D case study, the performance is superior compared to current state-of-the-art multiple-point statistics inversion by sequential geostatistical resampling (SGR). Inversion results for the 3D application are also encouraging. △ Less

Submitted 25 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Journal ref: Advances in Water Resources (2017)

Training-image based geostatistical inversion using a spatial generative adversarial neural network

Authors: Eric Laloy, Romain Hérault, Diederik Jacques, Niklas Linde

Abstract: Probabilistic inversion within a multiple-point statistics framework is often computationally prohibitive for high-dimensional problems. To partly address this, we introduce and evaluate a new training-image based inversion approach for complex geologic media. Our approach relies on a deep neural network of the generative adversarial network (GAN) type. After training using a training image (TI),… ▽ More Probabilistic inversion within a multiple-point statistics framework is often computationally prohibitive for high-dimensional problems. To partly address this, we introduce and evaluate a new training-image based inversion approach for complex geologic media. Our approach relies on a deep neural network of the generative adversarial network (GAN) type. After training using a training image (TI), our proposed spatial GAN (SGAN) can quickly generate 2D and 3D unconditional realizations. A key characteristic of our SGAN is that it defines a (very) low-dimensional parameterization, thereby allowing for efficient probabilistic inversion using state-of-the-art Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods. In addition, available direct conditioning data can be incorporated within the inversion. Several 2D and 3D categorical TIs are first used to analyze the performance of our SGAN for unconditional geostatistical simulation. Training our deep network can take several hours. After training, realizations containing a few millions of pixels/voxels can be produced in a matter of seconds. This makes it especially useful for simulating many thousands of realizations (e.g., for MCMC inversion) as the relative cost of the training per realization diminishes with the considered number of realizations. Synthetic inversion case studies involving 2D steady-state flow and 3D transient hydraulic tomography with and without direct conditioning data are used to illustrate the effectiveness of our proposed SGAN-based inversion. For the 2D case, the inversion rapidly explores the posterior model distribution. For the 3D case, the inversion recovers model realizations that fit the data close to the target level and visually resemble the true model well. △ Less

Submitted 8 January, 2019; v1 submitted 16 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Journal ref: Water Resources Research, 54, 381-406, 2018

Two-dimensional probabilistic inversion of plane-wave electromagnetic data: Methodology, model constraints and joint inversion with electrical resistivity data

Authors: M. Rosas-Carbajal, N. Linde, T. Kalscheuer, J. A. Vrugt

Abstract: Probabilistic inversion methods based on Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) simulation are well suited to quantify parameter and model uncertainty of nonlinear inverse problems. Yet, application of such methods to CPU-intensive forward models can be a daunting task, particularly if the parameter space is high dimensional. Here, we present a two-dimensional (2D) pixel-based MCMC inversion of plane-wav… ▽ More Probabilistic inversion methods based on Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) simulation are well suited to quantify parameter and model uncertainty of nonlinear inverse problems. Yet, application of such methods to CPU-intensive forward models can be a daunting task, particularly if the parameter space is high dimensional. Here, we present a two-dimensional (2D) pixel-based MCMC inversion of plane-wave electromagnetic (EM) data. Using synthetic data, we investigate how model parameter uncertainty depends on model structure constraints using different norms of the likelihood function and the model constraints, and study the added benefits of joint inversion of EM and electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) data. Our results demonstrate that model structure constraints are a necessity to stabilize the MCMC inversion results of a highly-discretized model. These constraints decrease model parameter uncertainty and facilitate model interpretation. A drawback is that these constraints may lead to posterior distributions that do not fully include the true underlying model, because some of its features exhibit a low sensitivity to the EM data, and hence are difficult to resolve. This problem can be partly mitigated if the plane-wave EM data is augmented with ERT observations. The hierarchical Bayesian inverse formulation introduced and used herein is able to successfully recover the probabilistic properties of the measurement data errors and a model regularization weight. Application of the proposed inversion methodology to field data from an aquifer demonstrates that the posterior mean model realization is very similar to that derived from a deterministic inversion with similar model constraints. △ Less

Submitted 10 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Journal ref: Geophysical Journal International, 196, 1508-1524 (2014)

Focused time-lapse inversion of radio and audio magnetotelluric data

Authors: M. Rosas Carbajal, N. Linde, T. Kalscheuer

Abstract: Geoelectrical techniques are widely used to monitor groundwater processes, while surprisingly few studies have considered audio (AMT) and radio (RMT) magnetotellurics for such purposes. In this numerical investigation, we analyze to what extent inversion results based on AMT and RMT monitoring data can be improved by (1) time-lapse difference inversion; (2) incorporation of statistical information… ▽ More Geoelectrical techniques are widely used to monitor groundwater processes, while surprisingly few studies have considered audio (AMT) and radio (RMT) magnetotellurics for such purposes. In this numerical investigation, we analyze to what extent inversion results based on AMT and RMT monitoring data can be improved by (1) time-lapse difference inversion; (2) incorporation of statistical information about the expected model update (i.e., the model regularization is based on a geostatistical model); (3) using alternative model norms to quantify temporal changes (i.e., approximations of l1 and Cauchy norms using iteratively reweighted least-squares), (4) constraining model updates to predefined ranges (i.e., using Lagrange Multipliers to only allow either increases or decreases of electrical resistivity with respect to background conditions). To do so, we consider a simple illustrative model and a more realistic test case related to seawater intrusion. The results are encouraging and show significant improvements when using time-lapse difference inversion with non l2 model norms. Artifacts that may arise when imposing compactness of regions with temporal changes can be suppressed through inequality constraints to yield models without oscillations outside the true region of temporal changes. Based on these results, we recommend approximate l1-norm solutions as they can resolve both sharp and smooth interfaces within the same model. △ Less

Submitted 10 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Journal ref: Journal of Applied Geophysics, 84, 29-38 (2012)

Conditioning of stochastic 3-D fracture networks to hydrological and geophysical data

Authors: C. Dorn, N. Linde, T. Le Borgne, O. Bour, J. -R. de Dreuzy

Abstract: The geometry and connectivity of fractures exert a strong influence on the flow and transport properties of fracture networks. We present a novel approach to stochastically generate three-dimensional discrete networks of connected fractures that are conditioned to hydrological and geophysical data. A hierarchical rejection sampling algorithm is used to draw realizations from the posterior probabil… ▽ More The geometry and connectivity of fractures exert a strong influence on the flow and transport properties of fracture networks. We present a novel approach to stochastically generate three-dimensional discrete networks of connected fractures that are conditioned to hydrological and geophysical data. A hierarchical rejection sampling algorithm is used to draw realizations from the posterior probability density function at different conditioning levels. The method is applied to a well-studied granitic formation using data acquired within two boreholes located 6 m apart. The prior models include 27 fractures with their geometry (position and orientation) bounded by information derived from single-hole ground-penetrating radar (GPR) data acquired during saline tracer tests and optical televiewer logs. Eleven cross-hole hydraulic connections between fractures in neighboring boreholes and the order in which the tracer arrives at different fractures are used for conditioning. Furthermore, the networks are conditioned to the observed relative hydraulic importance of the different hydraulic connections by numerically simulating the flow response. Among the conditioning data considered, constraints on the relative flow contributions were the most effective in determining the variability among the network realizations. Nevertheless, we find that the posterior model space is strongly determined by the imposed prior bounds. Strong prior bounds were derived from GPR measurements and helped to make the approach computationally feasible. We analyze a set of 230 posterior realizations that reproduce all data given their uncertainties assuming the same uniform transmissivity in all fractures. The posterior models provide valuable statistics on length scales and density of connected fractures, as well as their connectivity. △ Less

Submitted 7 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Journal ref: Advances in Water Resources, 62, 79-89 (2013)

Inferring transport characteristics in a fractured rock aquifer by combining single-hole GPR reflection monitoring and tracer test data

Authors: C. Dorn, N. Linde, T. Le Borgne, O. Bour, M. Kleptikova

Abstract: Investigations of solute transport in fractured rock aquifers often rely on tracer test data acquired at a limited number of observation points. Such data do not, by themselves, allow detailed assessments of the spreading of the injected tracer plume. To better understand the transport behavior in a granitic aquifer, we combine tracer test data with single-hole ground-penetrating radar (GPR) refle… ▽ More Investigations of solute transport in fractured rock aquifers often rely on tracer test data acquired at a limited number of observation points. Such data do not, by themselves, allow detailed assessments of the spreading of the injected tracer plume. To better understand the transport behavior in a granitic aquifer, we combine tracer test data with single-hole ground-penetrating radar (GPR) reflection monitoring data. Five successful tracer tests were performed under various experimental conditions between two boreholes 6 m apart. For each experiment, saline tracer was injected into a previously identified packed-off transmissive fracture while repeatedly acquiring single-hole GPR reflection profiles together with electrical conductivity logs in the pum** borehole. By analyzing depth-migrated GPR difference images together with tracer breakthrough curves and associated simplified flow and transport modeling, we estimate (1) the number, the connectivity, and the geometry of fractures that contribute to tracer transport, (2) the velocity and the mass of tracer that was carried along each flow path, and (3) the effective transport parameters of the identified flow paths. We find a qualitative agreement when comparing the time evolution of GPR reflectivity strengths at strategic locations in the formation with those arising from simulated transport. The discrepancies are on the same order as those between observed and simulated breakthrough curves at the outflow locations. The rather subtle and repeatable GPR signals provide useful and complementary information to tracer test data acquired at the outflow locations and may help us to characterize transport phenomena in fractured rock aquifers. △ Less

Submitted 7 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Journal ref: Water Resources Research, 48, W11521 (2012)

Distributed soil moisture from crosshole ground-penetrating radar travel times using stochastic inversion

Authors: N. Linde, J. A. Vrugt

Abstract: Geophysical methods offer several key advantages over conventional subsurface measurement approaches, yet their use for hydrologic interpretation is often problematic. Here, we introduce theory and concepts of a novel Bayesian approach for high-resolution soil moisture estimation using traveltime observations from crosshole Ground Penetrating Radar (GPR) experiments. The recently developed Multi-t… ▽ More Geophysical methods offer several key advantages over conventional subsurface measurement approaches, yet their use for hydrologic interpretation is often problematic. Here, we introduce theory and concepts of a novel Bayesian approach for high-resolution soil moisture estimation using traveltime observations from crosshole Ground Penetrating Radar (GPR) experiments. The recently developed Multi-try DiffeRential Evolution Adaptive Metropolis with sampling from past states, MT-DREAM(ZS) is being used to infer, as closely and consistently as possible, the posterior distribution of spatially distributed vadose zone soil moisture and/or porosity under saturated conditions. Two differing and opposing model parameterization schemes are being considered, one involving a classical uniform grid discretization and the other based on a discrete cosine transformation (DCT). We illustrate our approach using two different case studies involving geophysical data from a synthetic water tracer infiltration study and a real-world field study under saturated conditions. Our results demonstrate that the DCT parameterization yields the most accurate estimates of distributed soil moisture for a large range of spatial resolutions, and superior MCMC convergence rates. In addition, DCT is admirably suited to investigate and quantify the effects of model truncation errors on the MT-DREAM(ZS) inversion results. For the field example, lateral anisotropy needs to be enforced to derive reliable soil moisture variability. Our results also demonstrate that the posterior soil moisture uncertainty derived with the proposed Bayesian procedure is significantly larger than its counterpart estimated from classical smoothness-constrained deterministic inversions. △ Less

Submitted 6 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Comments: in Vadose Zone Journal, 12 (2013)

3D density structure and geological evolution of Stromboli volcano (Aeolian Islands, Italy) inferred from land-based and marine gravity data

Authors: N. Linde, L. Baron, T. Ricci, A. Finizola, A. Revil, F. Muccini, L. Cocchi, C. Carmisciano

Abstract: We present the first density model of Stromboli volcano (Aeolian Islands, Italy) obtained by simultaneously inverting land-based (543) and sea-surface (327) relative gravity data. Modern positioning technology, a 1 * 1 m digital elevation model, and a 15 * 15 m bathymetric model made it possible to obtain a detailed 3-D density model through an iteratively reweighted smoothness-constrained least-s… ▽ More We present the first density model of Stromboli volcano (Aeolian Islands, Italy) obtained by simultaneously inverting land-based (543) and sea-surface (327) relative gravity data. Modern positioning technology, a 1 * 1 m digital elevation model, and a 15 * 15 m bathymetric model made it possible to obtain a detailed 3-D density model through an iteratively reweighted smoothness-constrained least-squares inversion that explained the land-based gravity data to 0.09 mGal and the sea-surface data to 5 mGal. Our inverse formulation avoids introducing any assumptions about density magnitudes. At 125 m depth from the land surface, the inferred mean density of the island is 2380 kg m-3, with corresponding 2.5 and 97.5 percentiles of 2200 and 2530 kg m-3. This density range covers the rock densities of new and previously published samples of Paleostromboli I, Vancori, Neostromboli and San Bartolo lava flows. High-density anomalies in the central and southern part of the island can be related to two main degassing faults crossing the island (N41 and N64) that are interpreted as preferential regions of dyke intrusions. In addition, two low-density anomalies are found in the northeastern part and in the summit area of the island. These anomalies seem to be geographically related with past paroxysmal explosive phreato-magmatic events that have played important roles in the evolution of Stromboli Island by forming the Scari caldera and the Neostromboli crater, respectively. △ Less

Submitted 6 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Journal ref: Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research, 273, 58-69 (2014)

Joint inversion in hydrogeophysics and near-surface geophysics

Authors: N. Linde, J. Doetsch

Abstract: The near-surface environment is often too complex to enable inference of hydrological and environmental variables using one geophysical data type alone. Joint inversion and coupled inverse modeling involving numerical flow- and transport simulators have, in the last decade, played important roles in pushing applications towards increasingly challenging targets. Joint inversion of geophysical data… ▽ More The near-surface environment is often too complex to enable inference of hydrological and environmental variables using one geophysical data type alone. Joint inversion and coupled inverse modeling involving numerical flow- and transport simulators have, in the last decade, played important roles in pushing applications towards increasingly challenging targets. Joint inversion of geophysical data that is based on structural constraints is often favored over model coupling based on explicit petrophysical relationships. More specifically, cross-gradient joint inversion has been applied to a wide range of near-surface applications and geophysical data types. To infer hydrological subsurface properties, the most appropriate approach is often to use temporal changes in geophysical data that can be related to hydrological state variables. This allows using geophysical data as indirect hydrological observables, while the coupling with a flow- and transport simulator ensures physical consistency. Future research avenues include investigating the validity of different coupling strategies at various scales, the spatial statistics of near-surface petrophysical relationships, the influence of the model conceptualization, fully probabilistic joint inversions, and how to include complex prior information in the joint inversion. △ Less

Submitted 6 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Journal ref: Integrated imaging of the Earth, M. Moorkamp, P. Lelievre, N. Linde, and A. Khan (Editors), ch.7, 119-135 (2016)

Tomogram-based comparison of geostatistical models: Application to the MAcro-Dispersion Experiment (MADE) site

Authors: N. Linde, T. Lochbühler, M. Dogan, R. L. Van Dam

Abstract: We propose a new framework to compare alternative geostatistical descriptions of a given site. Multiple realizations of each of the considered geostatistical models and their corresponding tomograms (based on inversion of noise-contaminated simulated data) are used as a multivariate training image. The training image is scanned with a direct sampling algorithm to obtain conditional realizations of… ▽ More We propose a new framework to compare alternative geostatistical descriptions of a given site. Multiple realizations of each of the considered geostatistical models and their corresponding tomograms (based on inversion of noise-contaminated simulated data) are used as a multivariate training image. The training image is scanned with a direct sampling algorithm to obtain conditional realizations of hydraulic conductivity that are not only in agreement with the geostatistical model, but also honor the spatially varying resolution of the site-specific tomogram. Model comparison is based on the quality of the simulated geophysical data from the ensemble of conditional realizations. The tomogram in this study is obtained by inversion of cross-hole ground-penetrating radar (GPR) first-arrival travel time data acquired at the MAcro-Dispersion Experiment (MADE) site in Mississippi (USA). Various heterogeneity descriptions ranging from multi-Gaussian fields to fields with complex multiple-point statistics inferred from outcrops are considered. Under the assumption that the relationship between porosity and hydraulic conductivity inferred from local measurements is valid, we find that conditioned multi-Gaussian realizations and derivatives thereof can explain the crosshole geophysical data. A training image based on an aquifer analog from Germany was found to be in better agreement with the geophysical data than the one based on the local outcrop, which appears to under-represent high hydraulic conductivity zones. These findings are only based on the information content in a single resolution-limited tomogram and extending the analysis to tracer or higher resolution surface GPR data might lead to different conclusions (e.g., that discrete facies boundaries are necessary). △ Less

Submitted 6 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Journal ref: Journal of Hydrology, 531, 543-556 (2015)

Geological realism in hydrogeological and geophysical inverse modeling: a review

Authors: N. Linde, P. Renard, T. Mukerji, J. Caers

Abstract: Scientific curiosity, exploration of georesources and environmental concerns are pushing the geoscientific research community toward subsurface investigations of ever-increasing complexity. This review explores various approaches to formulate and solve inverse problems in ways that effectively integrate geological concepts with geophysical and hydrogeological data. Modern geostatistical simulation… ▽ More Scientific curiosity, exploration of georesources and environmental concerns are pushing the geoscientific research community toward subsurface investigations of ever-increasing complexity. This review explores various approaches to formulate and solve inverse problems in ways that effectively integrate geological concepts with geophysical and hydrogeological data. Modern geostatistical simulation algorithms can produce multiple subsurface realizations that are in agreement with conceptual geological models and statistical rock physics can be used to map these realizations into physical properties that are sensed by the geophysical or hydrogeological data. The inverse problem consists of finding one or an ensemble of such subsurface realizations that are in agreement with the data. The most general inversion frameworks are presently often computationally intractable when applied to large-scale problems and it is necessary to better understand the implications of simplifying (1) the conceptual geological model (e.g., using model compression); (2) the physical forward problem (e.g., using proxy models); and (3) the algorithm used to solve the inverse problem (e.g., Markov chain Monte Carlo or local optimization methods) to reach practical and robust solutions given today's computer resources and knowledge. We also highlight the need to not only use geophysical and hydrogeological data for parameter estimation purposes, but also to use them to falsify or corroborate alternative geological scenarios. △ Less

Submitted 6 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Journal ref: Advances in Water Resources, 86, 86-101 (2015)

Image synthesis with graph cuts: a fast model proposal mechanism in probabilistic inversion

Authors: T. Zahner, T. Lochbühler, G. Mariethoz, N. Linde

Abstract: Geophysical inversion should ideally produce geologically realistic subsurface models that explain the available data. Multiple-point statistics is a geostatistical approach to construct subsurface models that are consistent with site-specific data, but also display the same type of patterns as those found in a training image. The training image can be seen as a conceptual model of the subsurface… ▽ More Geophysical inversion should ideally produce geologically realistic subsurface models that explain the available data. Multiple-point statistics is a geostatistical approach to construct subsurface models that are consistent with site-specific data, but also display the same type of patterns as those found in a training image. The training image can be seen as a conceptual model of the subsurface and is used as a non-parametric model of spatial variability. Inversion based on multiple-point statistics is challenging due to high nonlinearity and time-consuming geostatistical resimulation steps that are needed to create new model proposals. We propose an entirely new model proposal mechanism for geophysical inversion that is inspired by texture synthesis in computer vision. Instead of resimulating pixels based on higher-order patterns in the training image, we identify a suitable patch of the training image that replace a corresponding patch in the current model without breaking the patterns found in the training image, that is, remaining consistent with the given prior. We consider three cross-hole ground-penetrating radar examples in which the new model proposal mechanism is employed within an extended Metropolis Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) inversion. The model proposal step is about 40 times faster than state-of-the-art multiple-point statistics resimulation techniques, the number of necessary MCMC steps is lower and the quality of the final model realizations is of similar quality. The model proposal mechanism is presently limited to 2-D fields, but the method is general and can be applied to a wide range of subsurface settings and geophysical data types. △ Less

Submitted 6 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Journal ref: Geophysical Journal International, 204, 1179-1190 (2016)

Summary statistics from training images as prior information in probabilistic inversion

Authors: T. Lochbühler, J. A. Vrugt, M. Sadegh, N. Linde

Abstract: A strategy is presented to incorporate prior information from conceptual geological models in probabilistic inversion of geophysical data. The conceptual geological models are represented by multiple-point statistics training images (TIs) featuring the expected lithological units and structural patterns. Information from an ensemble of TI realizations is used in two different ways. First, dominant… ▽ More A strategy is presented to incorporate prior information from conceptual geological models in probabilistic inversion of geophysical data. The conceptual geological models are represented by multiple-point statistics training images (TIs) featuring the expected lithological units and structural patterns. Information from an ensemble of TI realizations is used in two different ways. First, dominant modes are identified by analysis of the frequency content in the realizations, which drastically reduces the model parameter space in the frequency-amplitude domain. Second, the distributions of global, summary metrics (e.g. model roughness) are used to formulate a prior probability density function. The inverse problem is formulated in a Bayesian framework and the posterior pdf is sampled using Markov chain Monte Carlo simulation. The usefulness and applicability of this method is demonstrated on two case studies in which synthetic crosshole ground-penetrating radar traveltime data are inverted to recover 2-D porosity fields. The use of prior information from TIs significantly enhances the reliability of the posterior models by removing inversion artefacts and improving individual parameter estimates. The proposed methodology reduces the ambiguity inherent in the inversion of high-dimensional parameter spaces, accommodates a wide range of summary statistics and geophysical forward problems. △ Less

Submitted 5 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Journal ref: Geophysical Journal International, 201, 155-171 (2015)

Structure-coupled joint inversion of geophysical and hydrological data

Authors: T. Lochbühler, J. Doetsch, R. Brauchler, N. Linde

Abstract: In groundwater hydrology, geophysical imaging holds considerable promise for improving parameter estimation, due to the generally high resolution and spatial coverage of geophysical data. However, inversion of geophysical data alone cannot unveil the distribution of hydraulic conductivity. Jointly inverting geophysical and hydrological data allows us to benefit from the advantages of geophysical i… ▽ More In groundwater hydrology, geophysical imaging holds considerable promise for improving parameter estimation, due to the generally high resolution and spatial coverage of geophysical data. However, inversion of geophysical data alone cannot unveil the distribution of hydraulic conductivity. Jointly inverting geophysical and hydrological data allows us to benefit from the advantages of geophysical imaging and, at the same time, recover the hydrological parameters of interest. We have applied a coupling strategy between geophysical and hydrological models that is based on structural similarity constraints. Model combinations, for which the spatial gradients of the inferred parameter fields are not aligned in parallel, are penalized in the inversion. This structural coupling does not require introducing a potentially weak, unknown, and nonstationary petrophysical relation to link the models. The method was first tested on synthetic data sets and then applied to two combinations of geophysical/hydrological data sets from a saturated gravel aquifer in northern Switzerland. Crosshole ground-penetrating radar (GPR) traveltimes were jointly inverted with hydraulic tomography data, as well as with tracer mean arrival times, to retrieve the 2D distribution of GPR velocities and hydraulic conductivities. In the synthetic case, incorporating the GPR data through a joint inversion framework improved the resolution and localization properties of the estimated hydraulic conductivity field. For the field study, recovered hydraulic conductivities were in general agreement with flowmeter data. △ Less

Submitted 5 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Journal ref: Geophysics, 78, ID1-ID14 (2013)

Effective modeling of ground penetrating radar in fractured media using analytic solutions for propagation, thin-bed interaction and dipolar scattering

Authors: A. Shakas, N. Linde

Abstract: We propose a new approach to model ground penetrating radar signals that propagate through a homogeneous and isotropic medium, and are scattered at thin planar fractures of arbitrary dip, azimuth, thickness and material filling. We use analytical expressions for the Maxwell equations in a homogeneous space to describe the propagation of the signal in the rock matrix, and account for frequency-depe… ▽ More We propose a new approach to model ground penetrating radar signals that propagate through a homogeneous and isotropic medium, and are scattered at thin planar fractures of arbitrary dip, azimuth, thickness and material filling. We use analytical expressions for the Maxwell equations in a homogeneous space to describe the propagation of the signal in the rock matrix, and account for frequency-dependent dispersion and attenuation through the empirical Jonscher formulation. We discretize fractures into elements that are linearly polarized by the incoming electric field that arrives from the source to each element, locally, as a plane wave. To model the effective source wavelet we use a generalized Gamma distribution to define the antenna dipole moment. We combine microscopic and macroscopic Maxwell's equations to derive an analytic expression for the response of each element, which describes the full electric dipole radiation patterns along with effective reflection coefficients of thin layers. Our results compare favorably with finite-difference time-domain modeling in the case of constant electrical parameters of the rock-matrix and fracture filling. Compared with traditional finite-difference time-domain modeling, the proposed approach is faster and more flexible in terms of fracture orientations. A comparison with published laboratory results suggests that the modeling approach can reproduce the main characteristics of the reflected wavelet. △ Less

Submitted 5 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Journal ref: Journal of Applied Geophysics (2015), 116, 206-214

Hydrogeophysical characterization of transport processes in fractured rock by combining push-pull tracer tests and single-hole ground penetrating radar

Authors: A. Shakas, N. Linde, L. Baron, O. Bochet, T., O. Bour, Le Borgne

Abstract: The in situ characterization of transport processes in fractured media is particularly challenging due to the considerable spatial uncertainty on tracer pathways and dominant controlling processes, such as dispersion, channeling, trap**, matrix diffusion, ambient and density driven flows. We attempted to reduce this uncertainty by coupling push-pull tracer experiments with single-hole ground pen… ▽ More The in situ characterization of transport processes in fractured media is particularly challenging due to the considerable spatial uncertainty on tracer pathways and dominant controlling processes, such as dispersion, channeling, trap**, matrix diffusion, ambient and density driven flows. We attempted to reduce this uncertainty by coupling push-pull tracer experiments with single-hole ground penetrating radar (GPR) time-lapse imaging. The experiments involved different injection fractures, chaser volumes and resting times, and were performed at the fractured rock research site of Ploemeur in France (H+ network, hplus.ore.fr/en). For the GPR acquisitions, we used both fixed and moving antenna setups in a borehole that was isolated with a flexible liner. During the fixed-antenna experiment, time-varying GPR reflections allowed us to track the spatial and temporal dynamics of the tracer during the push-pull experiment. During the moving antenna experiments, we clearly imaged the dominant fractures in which tracer transport took place, fractures in which the tracer was trapped for longer time periods, and the spatial extent of the tracer distribution (up to 8 m) at different times. This demonstrated the existence of strongly channelized flow in the first few meters and radial flow at greater distances. By varying the resting time of a given experiment, we identified regions affected by density-driven and ambient flow. These experiments open up new perspectives for coupled hydrogeophysical inversion aimed at understanding transport phenomena in fractured rock formations. △ Less

Submitted 5 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Journal ref: Water Resources Research (2016), 52, 938-953

Single-hole GPR reflection imaging of solute transport in a granitic aquifer

Authors: C. Dorn, N- Linde, T. Le Borgne, O. Bour, L. Baron

Abstract: Identifying transport pathways in fractured rock is extremely challenging as flow is often organized in a few fractures that occupy a very small portion of the rock volume. We demonstrate that saline tracer experiments combined with single-hole ground penetrating radar (GPR) reflection imaging can be used to monitor saline tracer movement within mm-aperture fractures. A dipole tracer test was perf… ▽ More Identifying transport pathways in fractured rock is extremely challenging as flow is often organized in a few fractures that occupy a very small portion of the rock volume. We demonstrate that saline tracer experiments combined with single-hole ground penetrating radar (GPR) reflection imaging can be used to monitor saline tracer movement within mm-aperture fractures. A dipole tracer test was performed in a granitic aquifer by injecting a saline solution in a known fracture, while repeatedly acquiring single-hole GPR sections in the pum** borehole located 6 m away. The final depth-migrated difference sections make it possible to identify consistent temporal changes over a 30 m depth interval at locations corresponding to fractures previously imaged in GPR sections acquired under natural flow and tracer-free conditions. The experiment allows determining the dominant flow paths of the injected tracer and the velocity (0.4-0.7 m/min) of the tracer front. △ Less

Submitted 3 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Journal ref: Geophysical Research Letters, 38, L08401 (2011)

Fracture imaging within a granitic rock aquifer using multiple-offset single-hole and cross-hole GPR reflection data

Authors: C. Dorn, N. Linde, J. Doetsch, T. Le Borgne, O. Bour

Abstract: The sparsely spaced highly permeable fractures of the granitic rock aquifer at Stang-er-Brune (Brittany, France) form a well-connected fracture network of high permeability but unknown geometry. Previous work based on optical and acoustic logging together with single-hole and cross-hole flowmeter data acquired in 3 neighboring boreholes (70-100 m deep) have identified the most important permeable… ▽ More The sparsely spaced highly permeable fractures of the granitic rock aquifer at Stang-er-Brune (Brittany, France) form a well-connected fracture network of high permeability but unknown geometry. Previous work based on optical and acoustic logging together with single-hole and cross-hole flowmeter data acquired in 3 neighboring boreholes (70-100 m deep) have identified the most important permeable fractures crossing the boreholes and their hydraulic connections. To constrain possible flow paths by estimating the geometries of known and previously unknown fractures, we have acquired, processed and interpreted multifold, single- and cross-hole GPR data using 100 and 250 MHz antennas. The GPR data processing scheme consisting of time-zero corrections, scaling, bandpass filtering and F-X deconvolution, eigenvector filtering, muting, pre-stack Kirchhoff depth migration and stacking was used to differentiate fluid-filled fracture reflections from source-generated noise. The final stacked and pre-stack depth-migrated GPR sections provide high-resolution images of individual fractures (dip** 30-90°) in the surroundings (2-20 m for the 100 MHz antennas; 2-12 m for the 250 MHz antennas) of each borehole in a 2D plane projection that are of superior quality to those obtained from single-offset sections. Most fractures previously identified from hydraulic testing can be correlated to reflections in the single-hole data. Several previously unknown major near vertical fractures have also been identified away from the boreholes. △ Less

Submitted 3 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Journal ref: Journal of Applied Geophysics, 78, 123-132 (2012)

Streaming potential modeling in fractured rock: Insights into the identification of hydraulically active fractures

Authors: D. Roubinet, N. Linde, D. Jougnot, J. Irving

Abstract: Numerous field experiments suggest that the self-potential (SP) geophysical method may allow for the detection of hydraulically active fractures and provide information about fracture properties. However, a lack of suitable numerical tools for modeling streaming potentials in fractured media prevents quantitative interpretation and limits our understanding of how the SP method can be used in this… ▽ More Numerous field experiments suggest that the self-potential (SP) geophysical method may allow for the detection of hydraulically active fractures and provide information about fracture properties. However, a lack of suitable numerical tools for modeling streaming potentials in fractured media prevents quantitative interpretation and limits our understanding of how the SP method can be used in this regard. To address this issue, we present a highly efficient two-dimensional discrete-dual-porosity approach for solving the fluid flow and associated self-potential problems in fractured rock. Our approach is specifically designed for complex fracture networks that cannot be investigated using standard numerical methods. We then simulate SP signals associated with pum** conditions for a number of examples to show that (i) accounting for matrix fluid flow is essential for accurate SP modeling and (ii) the sensitivity of SP to hydraulically active fractures is intimately linked with fracture-matrix fluid interactions. This implies that fractures associated with strong SP amplitudes are likely to be hydraulically conductive, attracting fluid flow from the surrounding matrix. △ Less

Submitted 25 May, 2016; originally announced May 2016.

Comments: 8 pages, 2 figures

Journal ref: Geophysical Research Letters 43 (2016)

Feature-preserving interpolation and filtering of environmental time series

Authors: Gregoire Mariethoz, Niklas Linde, Damien Jougnot, Hassan Rezaee

Abstract: We propose a method for filling gaps and removing interferences in time series for applications involving continuous monitoring of environmental variables. The approach is non-parametric and based on an iterative pattern-matching between the affected and the valid parts of the time series. It considers several variables jointly in the pattern matching process and allows preserving linear or non-li… ▽ More We propose a method for filling gaps and removing interferences in time series for applications involving continuous monitoring of environmental variables. The approach is non-parametric and based on an iterative pattern-matching between the affected and the valid parts of the time series. It considers several variables jointly in the pattern matching process and allows preserving linear or non-linear dependences between variables. The uncertainty in the reconstructed time series is quantified through multiple realizations. The method is tested on self-potential data that are affected by strong interferences as well as data gaps, and the results show that our approach allows reproducing the spectral features of the original signal. Even in the presence of intense signal perturbations, it significantly improves the signal and corrects bias introduced by asymmetrical interferences. Potential applications are wide-ranging, including geophysics, meteorology and hydrology. △ Less

Submitted 10 August, 2015; originally announced August 2015.

Comments: 6 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Environmental Modelling & Software 72 (2015) 71e76

An analytical study of seismoelectric signals produced by 1D mesoscopic heterogeneities

Authors: Leonardo B. Monachesi, J. German Rubino, Marina Rosas-Carbajal, Damien Jougnot, Niklas Linde, Beatriz Quintal, Klaus Holliger

Abstract: The presence of mesoscopic heterogeneities in fluid-saturated porous rocks can produce measurable seismoelectric signals due to wave-induced fluid flow between regions of differing compressibility. The dependence of these signals on the petrophysical and structural characteristics of the probed rock mass remains largely unexplored. In this work, we derive an analytical solution to describe the sei… ▽ More The presence of mesoscopic heterogeneities in fluid-saturated porous rocks can produce measurable seismoelectric signals due to wave-induced fluid flow between regions of differing compressibility. The dependence of these signals on the petrophysical and structural characteristics of the probed rock mass remains largely unexplored. In this work, we derive an analytical solution to describe the seismoelectric response of a rock sample, containing a horizontal layer at its center, that is subjected to an oscillatory compressibility test. We then adapt this general solution to compute the seismoelectric signature of a particular case related to a sample that is permeated by a horizontal fracture located at its center. Analyses of the general and particular solutions are performed to study the impact of different petrophysical and structural parameters on the seismoelectric response. We find that the amplitude of the seismoelectric signal is directly proportional to the applied stress, to the Skempton coefficient contrast between the host rock and the layer, and to a weighted average of the effective excess charge of the two materials. Our results also demonstrate that the frequency at which the maximum electrical potential amplitude prevails does not depend on the applied stress or the Skempton coefficient contrast. In presence of strong permeability variations, this frequency is rather controlled by the permeability and thickness of the less permeable material. The results of this study thus indicate that seismoelectric measurements can potentially be used to estimate key mechanical and hydraulic rock properties of mesoscopic heterogeneities, such as compressibility, permeability, and fracture compliance. △ Less

Submitted 25 February, 2015; originally announced February 2015.

Comments: 14 pages, 8 figures

Journal ref: Geophys. J. Int. (2015) 201, 329-342;

Monitoring of saline tracer movement with vertically distributed self-potential measurements at the HOBE agricultural test site, Voulund, Denmark

Authors: Damien Jougnot, Niklas Linde, Eline B. Haarder, Majken C. Looms

Abstract: The self-potential (SP) method is sensitive to water fluxes in saturated and partially saturated porous media, such as those associated with rainwater infiltration and groundwater recharge. We present a field-based study at the Voulund agricultural test site, Denmark, that is, to the best of our knowledge, the first to focus on the vertical self-potential distribution prior to and during a saline… ▽ More The self-potential (SP) method is sensitive to water fluxes in saturated and partially saturated porous media, such as those associated with rainwater infiltration and groundwater recharge. We present a field-based study at the Voulund agricultural test site, Denmark, that is, to the best of our knowledge, the first to focus on the vertical self-potential distribution prior to and during a saline tracer test. A coupled hydrogeophysical modeling framework is used to simulate the SP response to precipitation and saline tracer infiltration. A layered hydrological model is first obtained by inverting dielectric and matric potential data. The resulting model that compares favorably with electrical resistance tomography models is subsequently used to predict the SP response. The electrokinetic contribution (caused by water fluxes in a charged porous soil) is modeled by an effective excess charge approach that considers both water saturation and pore water salinity. Our results suggest that the effective excess charge evolution prior to the tracer injection is better described by a recent flux-averaged model based on soil water retention functions than by a previously proposed volume-averaging model. This is the first time that raw vertically distributed SP measurements have been explained by a physically based model. The electrokinetic contribution cannot alone reproduce the SP data during the tracer test and an electro-diffusive contribution (caused by concentration gradients) is needed. The predicted amplitude of this contribution is too small to perfectly explain the data, but the shape is in accordance with the field data. This discrepancy is attributed to imperfect descriptions of electro-diffusive phenomena in partially saturated soils, unaccounted soil heterogeneity, and discrepancies between the measured and predicted electrical conductivities in the tracer infiltration area. △ Less

Submitted 9 January, 2015; originally announced January 2015.

Comments: 45 pages, 9 figures, 2 tables

Journal ref: Journal of Hydrology 521 (2015) 314-327

Seismoelectric effects due to mesoscopic heterogeneities

Authors: D. Jougnot, J. G. Rubino, M. Rosas Carbajal, N. Linde, K. Holliger

Abstract: While the seismic effects of wave-induced fluid flow due to mesoscopic heterogeneities have been studied for several decades, the role played by these types of heterogeneities on seismoelectric phenomena is largely unexplored. To address this issue, we have developed a novel methodological framework which allows for the coupling of wave-induced fluid flow, as inferred through numerical oscillatory… ▽ More While the seismic effects of wave-induced fluid flow due to mesoscopic heterogeneities have been studied for several decades, the role played by these types of heterogeneities on seismoelectric phenomena is largely unexplored. To address this issue, we have developed a novel methodological framework which allows for the coupling of wave-induced fluid flow, as inferred through numerical oscillatory compressibility tests, with the pertinent seismoelectric conversion mechanisms. Simulating the corresponding response of a water-saturated sandstone sample containing mesoscopic fractures, we demonstrate for the first time that these kinds of heterogeneities can produce measurable seismoelectric signals under typical laboratory conditions. Given that this phenomenon is sensitive to key hydraulic and mechanical properties, we expect that the results of this pilot study will stimulate further exploration on this topic in several domains of the Earth, environmental, and engineering sciences. △ Less

Submitted 10 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

Comments: 14 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: Geophys. Res. Lett. 40 (2013) 2033-2037

Self-potentials in partially saturated media: the importance of explicit modeling of electrode effects

Authors: D. Jougnot, N. Linde

Abstract: Self-potential (SP) data are of interest to vadose zone hydrology because of their direct sensitivity to water flow and ionic transport. There is unfortunately little consensus in the literature about how to best model SP data under partially saturated conditions and different approaches (often supported by one laboratory data set alone) have been proposed. We argue herein that this lack of agreem… ▽ More Self-potential (SP) data are of interest to vadose zone hydrology because of their direct sensitivity to water flow and ionic transport. There is unfortunately little consensus in the literature about how to best model SP data under partially saturated conditions and different approaches (often supported by one laboratory data set alone) have been proposed. We argue herein that this lack of agreement can largely be traced to electrode effects that have not been properly taken into account. A series of drainage and imbibition experiments are considered, in which we find that previously proposed approaches to remove electrode effects are unlikely to provide adequate corrections. Instead, we explicitly model the electrode effects together with classical SP contributions using a flow and transport model. The simulated data agree overall with the observed SP signals and allow decomposing the different signal contributions to analyze them separately. By reviewing other published experimental data, we suggest that most of them include electrode effects that have not been properly taken into account. Our results suggest that previously presented SP theory works well when considering the modeling uncertainties presently associated with electrode effects. Additional work is warranted to not only develop suitable electrodes for laboratory experiments, but also to assure that associated electrode effects that appear inevitable in longer-term experiments are predictable, such that they can be incorporated in the modeling framework. △ Less

Submitted 21 May, 2013; originally announced May 2013.

Journal ref: Vadose Zone J. 12(2)

Derivation of soil-specific streaming potential electrical parameters from hydrodynamic characteristics of partially saturated soils

Authors: Damien Jougnot, Niklas Linde, A. Revil, Claude Doussan

Abstract: Water movement in unsaturated soils gives rise to measurable electrical potential differences that are related to the flow direction and volumetric fluxes, as well as to the soil properties themselves. Laboratory and field data suggest that these so-called streaming potentials may be several orders of magnitudes larger than theoretical predictions that only consider the influence of the relative p… ▽ More Water movement in unsaturated soils gives rise to measurable electrical potential differences that are related to the flow direction and volumetric fluxes, as well as to the soil properties themselves. Laboratory and field data suggest that these so-called streaming potentials may be several orders of magnitudes larger than theoretical predictions that only consider the influence of the relative permeability and electrical conductivity on the self potential (SP) data. Recent work has partly improved predictions by considering how the volumetric excess charge in the pore space scales with the inverse of water saturation. We present a new theoretical approach that uses the flux-averaged excess charge, not the volumetric excess charge, to predict streaming potentials. We present relationships for how this effective excess charge varies with water saturation for typical soil properties using either the water retention or the relative permeability function. We find large differences between soil types and the predictions based on the relative permeability function display the best agreement with field data. The new relationships better explain laboratory data than previous work and allow us to predict the recorded magnitudes of the streaming potentials following a rainfall event in sandy loam, whereas previous models predict three orders of magnitude too small values. We suggest that the strong signals in unsaturated media can be used to gain information about fluxes (including very small ones related to film flow), but also to constrain the relative permeability function, the water retention curve, and the relative electrical conductivity function. △ Less

Submitted 27 September, 2012; originally announced September 2012.

Journal ref: Vadose Zone Journal 11, 1 (2012) 272-286