-
Thermodynamic route of Nb3Sn nucleation: Role of oxygen
Authors:
Zeming Sun,
Darrah K. Dare,
Zhaslan Baraissov,
David A. Muller,
Michael O. Thompson,
Matthias U. Liepe
Abstract:
Intermetallic Nb3Sn alloys have long been believed to form through Sn diffusion into Nb. However, our observations of significant oxygen content in Nb3Sn prompted an investigation of alternative formation mechanisms. Through experiments involving different oxide interfaces (clean HF-treated, native oxidized, and anodized), we demonstrate a thermodynamic route that fundamentally challenges the conv…
▽ More
Intermetallic Nb3Sn alloys have long been believed to form through Sn diffusion into Nb. However, our observations of significant oxygen content in Nb3Sn prompted an investigation of alternative formation mechanisms. Through experiments involving different oxide interfaces (clean HF-treated, native oxidized, and anodized), we demonstrate a thermodynamic route that fundamentally challenges the conventional Sn diffusion mechanism for Nb3Sn nucleation. Our results highlight the critical involvement of a SnOx intermediate phase. This new nucleation mechanism identifies the principles for growth optimization and new synthesis of high-quality Nb3Sn superconductors.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2023; v1 submitted 8 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Surface oxides, carbides, and impurities on RF superconducting Nb and Nb3Sn: A comprehensive analysis
Authors:
Zeming Sun,
Zhaslan Baraissov,
Catherine A. Dukes,
Darrah K. Dare,
Thomas Oseroff,
Michael O. Thompson,
David A. Muller,
Matthias U. Liepe
Abstract:
Surface structures on radio-frequency (RF) superconductors are crucially important in determining their interaction with the RF field. Here we investigate the surface compositions, structural profiles, and valence distributions of oxides, carbides, and impurities on niobium (Nb) and niobium-tin (Nb3Sn) in situ under different processing conditions. We establish the underlying mechanisms of vacuum…
▽ More
Surface structures on radio-frequency (RF) superconductors are crucially important in determining their interaction with the RF field. Here we investigate the surface compositions, structural profiles, and valence distributions of oxides, carbides, and impurities on niobium (Nb) and niobium-tin (Nb3Sn) in situ under different processing conditions. We establish the underlying mechanisms of vacuum baking and nitrogen processing in Nb and demonstrate that carbide formation induced during high-temperature baking, regardless of gas environment, determines subsequent oxide formation upon air exposure or low-temperature baking, leading to modifications of the electron population profile. Our findings support the combined contribution of surface oxides and second-phase formation to the outcome of ultra-high vacuum baking (oxygen processing) and nitrogen processing. Also, we observe that vapor-diffused Nb3Sn contains thick metastable oxides, while electrochemically synthesized Nb3Sn only has a thin oxide layer. Our findings reveal fundamental mechanisms of baking and processing Nb and Nb3Sn surface structures for high-performance superconducting RF and quantum applications
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2023; v1 submitted 3 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
ZrNb(CO) RF superconducting thin film with high critical temperature in the theoretical limit
Authors:
Zeming Sun,
Thomas Oseroff,
Zhaslan Baraissov,
Darrah K. Dare,
Katrina Howard,
Benjamin Francis,
A**kya C. Hire,
Nathan Sitaraman,
Tomas A. Arias,
Mark K. Transtrum,
Richard Hennig,
Michael O. Thompson,
David A. Muller,
Matthias U. Liepe
Abstract:
Superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) resonators are critical components for particle accelerator applications, such as free-electron lasers, and for emerging technologies in quantum computing. Develo** advanced materials and their deposition processes to produce RF superconductors that yield nanoohms surface resistances is a key metric for the wider adoption of SRF technology. Here we report Zr…
▽ More
Superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) resonators are critical components for particle accelerator applications, such as free-electron lasers, and for emerging technologies in quantum computing. Develo** advanced materials and their deposition processes to produce RF superconductors that yield nanoohms surface resistances is a key metric for the wider adoption of SRF technology. Here we report ZrNb(CO) RF superconducting films with high critical temperatures (Tc) achieved for the first time under ambient pressure. The attainment of a Tc near the theoretical limit for this material without applied pressure is promising for its use in practical applications. A range of Tc, likely arising from Zr do** variation, may allow a tunable superconducting coherence length that lowers the sensitivity to material defects when an ultra-low surface resistance is required. Our ZrNb(CO) films are synthesized using a low-temperature (100 - 200 C) electrochemical recipe combined with thermal annealing. The phase transformation as a function of annealing temperature and time is optimized by the evaporated Zr-Nb diffusion couples. Through phase control, we avoid hexagonal Zr phases that are equilibrium-stable but degrade Tc. X-ray and electron diffraction combined with photoelectron spectroscopy reveal a system containing cubic ZrNb mixed with rocksalt NbC and low-dielectric-loss ZrO2. We demonstrate proof-of-concept RF performance of ZrNb(CO) on an SRF sample test system. BCS resistance trends lower than reference Nb, while quench fields occur at approximately 35 mT. Our results demonstrate the potential of ZrNb(CO) thin films for particle accelerator and other SRF applications.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2023; v1 submitted 28 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Smooth, homogeneous, high-purity Nb3Sn superconducting RF resonant cavity by seed-free electrochemical synthesis
Authors:
Zeming Sun,
Zhaslan Baraissov,
Ryan D. Porter,
Liana Shpani,
Yu-Tsun Shao,
Thomas Oseroff,
Michael O. Thompson,
David A. Muller,
Matthias U. Liepe
Abstract:
Workbench-size particle accelerators, enabled by Nb3Sn-based superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) cavities, hold the potential of driving scientific discovery by offering a widely accessible and affordable source of high-energy electrons and X-rays. Thin-film Nb3Sn RF superconductors with high quality factors, high operation temperatures, and high-field potentials are critical for these devices.…
▽ More
Workbench-size particle accelerators, enabled by Nb3Sn-based superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) cavities, hold the potential of driving scientific discovery by offering a widely accessible and affordable source of high-energy electrons and X-rays. Thin-film Nb3Sn RF superconductors with high quality factors, high operation temperatures, and high-field potentials are critical for these devices. However, surface roughness, non-stoichiometry, and impurities in Nb3Sn deposited by conventional Sn-vapor diffusion prevent them from reaching their theoretical capabilities. Here we demonstrate a seed-free electrochemical synthesis that pushes the limit of chemical and physical properties in Nb3Sn. Utilization of electrochemical Sn pre-deposits reduces the roughness of converted Nb3Sn by five times compared to typical vapor-diffused Nb3Sn. Quantitative map**s using chemical and atomic probes confirm improved stoichiometry and minimized impurity concentrations in electrochemically synthesized Nb3Sn. We have successfully applied this Nb3Sn to the large-scale 1.3 GHz SRF cavity and demonstrated ultra-low BCS surface resistances at multiple operation temperatures, notably lower than vapor-diffused cavities. Our smooth, homogeneous, high-purity Nb3Sn provides the route toward high efficiency and high fields for SRF applications under helium-free cryogenic operations.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2023; v1 submitted 3 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Electrochemical Polishing of Chemical Vapor Deposited Niobium Thin Films
Authors:
Zeming Sun,
Mingqi Ge,
James T. Maniscalco,
Victor Arrieta,
Shawn R. McNeal,
Matthias U. Liepe
Abstract:
Combining chemical vapor deposition (CVD) with electrochemical polish (EP) operations is a promising route to producing performance-capable superconducting films for use in the fabrication of cost-effective components for superconducting radiofrequency (SRF) particle accelerators and superconducting quantum computers. The post-deposition EP process enables a critically necessary reduction in surfa…
▽ More
Combining chemical vapor deposition (CVD) with electrochemical polish (EP) operations is a promising route to producing performance-capable superconducting films for use in the fabrication of cost-effective components for superconducting radiofrequency (SRF) particle accelerators and superconducting quantum computers. The post-deposition EP process enables a critically necessary reduction in surface roughness of niobium thin films to promote optimal superconducting surface conditions. In this work, surface morphology, roughness, and crystal orientation of the CVD-grown and EP-polished niobium films were investigated. The grain growth and polishing mechanisms were analyzed. The CVD films were found to comprise steps, kinks, and pyramidal features, resulting in undesirable large peak-to-valley distances. The electrochemical polish was demonstrated to significantly diminish the height of pyramids and effectively minimize the overall surface roughness. In contrast to buffered chemical polishing (BCP), EP results showed a probable dependence on crystal orientation, suggesting this process was influenced by locally enhanced current density and thickness variations of oxide dielectrics. These understandings identify the EP principles tied to CVD-grown Nb films that allow further refinement of surface profiles for film-based SRF applications
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Thermal annealing of sputtered Nb3Sn and V3Si thin films for superconducting radio-frequency cavities
Authors:
Katrina Howard,
Zeming Sun,
Matthias U. Liepe
Abstract:
Nb3Sn and V3Si thin films are promising candidates as thin films for the next generation of superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) cavities. However, sputtered films often suffer from stoichiometry and strain issues during deposition and post annealing. In this study, we explore the structural and chemical effects of thermal annealing, both in-situ and post-sputtering, on DC-sputtered Nb3Sn and V3S…
▽ More
Nb3Sn and V3Si thin films are promising candidates as thin films for the next generation of superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) cavities. However, sputtered films often suffer from stoichiometry and strain issues during deposition and post annealing. In this study, we explore the structural and chemical effects of thermal annealing, both in-situ and post-sputtering, on DC-sputtered Nb3Sn and V3Si films of varying thickness on Nb or Cu substrates, extending from our initial studies [1]. Through annealing at 950 °C, we successfully enabled recrystallization of 100 nm thin Nb3Sn films on Nb substrate with stoichiometric and strain-free grains. For 2 um thick films, we observed the removal of strain and a slight increase in grain size with increasing temperature. Annealing enabled a phase transformation from unstable to stable structure on V3Si films, while we observed significant Sn loss in 2 um thick Nb3Sn films after high temperature anneals. We observed similar Sn and Si loss on films atop Cu substrates during annealing, likely due to Cu-Sn and Cu-Si phase generation and subsequent Sn and Si evaporation. These results encourage us to refine our process to obtain high-quality sputtered films for SRF use.
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Theory of Nb-Zr Alloy Superconductivity and First Experimental Demonstration for Superconducting Radio-Frequency Cavity Applications
Authors:
Nathan S. Sitaraman,
Zeming Sun,
Ben Francis,
A**kya C. Hire,
Thomas Oseroff,
Zhaslan Baraissov,
Tomás A. Arias,
Richard Hennig,
Matthias U. Liepe,
David A. Muller,
Mark K. Transtrum
Abstract:
Niobium-zirconium (Nb-Zr) alloy is an old superconductor that is a promising new candidate for superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) cavity applications. Using density-functional and Eliashberg theories, we show that addition of Zr to a Nb surface in small concentrations increases the critical temperature $T_c$ and improves other superconducting properties. Furthermore, we calculate $T_c$ for Nb-Z…
▽ More
Niobium-zirconium (Nb-Zr) alloy is an old superconductor that is a promising new candidate for superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) cavity applications. Using density-functional and Eliashberg theories, we show that addition of Zr to a Nb surface in small concentrations increases the critical temperature $T_c$ and improves other superconducting properties. Furthermore, we calculate $T_c$ for Nb-Zr alloys across a broad range of Zr concentrations, showing good agreement with the literature for disordered alloys as well as the potential for significantly higher $T_c$ in ordered alloys near 75%Nb/25%Zr composition. We provide experimental verification on Nb-Zr alloy samples and SRF sample test cavities prepared with either physical vapor or our novel electrochemical deposition recipes. These samples have the highest measured $T_c$ of any Nb-Zr superconductor to date and indicate a reduction in BCS resistance compared to the conventional Nb reference sample; they represent the first steps along a new pathway to greatly enhanced SRF performance. Finally, we use Ginzburg-Landau theory to show that the addition of Zr to a Nb surface increases the superheating field $B_{sh}$, a key figure of merit for SRF which determines the maximum accelerating gradient at which cavities can operate.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Higgs Factory Considerations
Authors:
J. A. Bagger,
B. C. Barish,
S. Belomestnykh,
P. C. Bhat,
J. E. Brau,
M. Demarteau,
D. Denisov,
S. C. Eno,
C. G. R. Geddes,
P. D. Grannis,
A. Hutton,
A. J. Lankford,
M. U. Liepe,
D. B. MacFarlane,
T. Markiewicz,
H. E. Montgomery,
J. R. Patterson,
M. Perelstein,
M. E. Peskin,
M. C. Ross,
J. Strube,
A. P. White,
G. W. Wilson
Abstract:
We discuss considerations that can be used to formulate recommendations for initiating a lepton collider project that would provide precision studies of the Higgs boson and related electroweak phenomena.
We discuss considerations that can be used to formulate recommendations for initiating a lepton collider project that would provide precision studies of the Higgs boson and related electroweak phenomena.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2022; v1 submitted 11 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
$\textit{Ab Initio}$ Study of Antisite Defects in Nb$_3$Sn: Phase Diagram and Impact on Superconductivity
Authors:
Nathan S. Sitaraman,
Jared Carlson,
Alden R. Pack,
Ryan D. Porter,
Matthias U. Liepe,
Mark K. Transtrum,
Tomás A. Arias
Abstract:
Antisite defects play a critical role in Nb$_3$Sn superconducting radio frequency (SRF) cavity physics. Such defects are the primary form of disorder in Nb$_3$Sn, and are responsible for stoichiometry variations, including experimentally observed tin-depleted regions within grains and tin-rich regions around grain boundaries. But why they cluster to form regions of different stoichiometries and ho…
▽ More
Antisite defects play a critical role in Nb$_3$Sn superconducting radio frequency (SRF) cavity physics. Such defects are the primary form of disorder in Nb$_3$Sn, and are responsible for stoichiometry variations, including experimentally observed tin-depleted regions within grains and tin-rich regions around grain boundaries. But why they cluster to form regions of different stoichiometries and how they affect the SRF properties of Nb$_3$Sn cavities are not fully understood. Using $\textit{ab initio}$ techniques, we calculate the A15 region of the Nb-Sn phase diagram, discuss a possible modification to the phase diagram near grain boundaries, and calculate $T_c$ as a function of stoichiometry, including experimentally inaccessible tin-rich stoichiometry. We find that the impact of antisite defects on the density of states near the Fermi-level of Nb$_3$Sn plays a key role in determining many of their properties. These results improve our understanding of the obstacles facing Nb$_3$Sn SRF systems, and how modified growth processes might overcome them.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Shielding superconductors with thin films
Authors:
Sam Posen,
Mark K. Transtrum,
Gianluigi Catelani,
Matthias U. Liepe,
James P. Sethna
Abstract:
Determining the optimal arrangement of superconducting layers to withstand large amplitude AC magnetic fields is important for certain applications such as superconducting radiofrequency cavities. In this paper, we evaluate the shielding potential of the superconducting film/insulating film/superconductor (SIS') structure, a configuration that could provide benefits in screening large AC magnetic…
▽ More
Determining the optimal arrangement of superconducting layers to withstand large amplitude AC magnetic fields is important for certain applications such as superconducting radiofrequency cavities. In this paper, we evaluate the shielding potential of the superconducting film/insulating film/superconductor (SIS') structure, a configuration that could provide benefits in screening large AC magnetic fields. After establishing that for high frequency magnetic fields, flux penetration must be avoided, the superheating field of the structure is calculated in the London limit both numerically and, for thin films, analytically. For intermediate film thicknesses and realistic material parameters we also solve numerically the Ginzburg-Landau equations. It is shown that a small enhancement of the superheating field is possible, on the order of a few percent, for the SIS' structure relative to a bulk superconductor of the film material, if the materials and thicknesses are chosen appropriately.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Response to comment on theoretical RF field limits of multilayer coating structures of superconducting resonator cavities
Authors:
Sam Posen,
Gianluigi Catelani,
Matthias U. Liepe,
James P. Sethna,
Mark K. Transtrum
Abstract:
A comment to the authors' SRF Conference pre-print [1] was submitted by A. Gurevich to the arXiv [2]. In this response, we show that the arguments used in the comment are not valid.
[1] arXiv:1309.3239 [2] arXiv:1309.5626
A comment to the authors' SRF Conference pre-print [1] was submitted by A. Gurevich to the arXiv [2]. In this response, we show that the arguments used in the comment are not valid.
[1] arXiv:1309.3239 [2] arXiv:1309.5626
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Theoretical Field Limits for Multi-Layer Superconductors
Authors:
Sam Posen,
Gianluigi Catelani,
Matthias U. Liepe,
James P. Sethna,
Mark K. Transtrum
Abstract:
The SIS structure---a thin superconducting film on a bulk superconductor separated by a thin insulating film---was propsed as a method to protect alternative SRF materials from flux penetration by enhancing the first critical field $B_{c1}$. In this work, we show that in fact $B_{c1}$ = 0 for a SIS structure. We calculate the superheating field $B_{sh}$, and we show that it can be enhanced slightl…
▽ More
The SIS structure---a thin superconducting film on a bulk superconductor separated by a thin insulating film---was propsed as a method to protect alternative SRF materials from flux penetration by enhancing the first critical field $B_{c1}$. In this work, we show that in fact $B_{c1}$ = 0 for a SIS structure. We calculate the superheating field $B_{sh}$, and we show that it can be enhanced slightly using the SIS structure, but only for a small range of film thicknesses and only if the film and the bulk are different materials. We also show that using a multilayer instead of a single thick layer is detrimental, as this decreases $B_{sh}$ of the film. We calculate the dissipation due to vortex penetration above the $B_{sh}$ of the film, and find that it is unmanageable for SRF applications. However, we find that if a gradient in the phase of the order parameter is introduced, SIS structures may be able to shield large DC and low frequency fields. We argue that the SIS structure is not beneficial for SRF cavities, but due to recent experiments showing low-surface-resistance performance above $B_{c1}$ in cavities made of superconductors with small coherence lengths, we argue that enhancement of $B_{c1}$ is not necessary, and that bulk films of alternative materials show great promise.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2013; v1 submitted 12 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Temperature dependence of the superheating field in niobium
Authors:
N. R. A. Valles,
M. U. Liepe
Abstract:
This study experimentally investigates the temperature dependence of superheating field, Hsh, of niobium. Accurately determining this field is important both to test theory and to understand gradient limits in superconducting cavities for particle accelerators. This paper discusses theories that have been proposed in modeling the field and discriminates between them. The experimental procedure f…
▽ More
This study experimentally investigates the temperature dependence of superheating field, Hsh, of niobium. Accurately determining this field is important both to test theory and to understand gradient limits in superconducting cavities for particle accelerators. This paper discusses theories that have been proposed in modeling the field and discriminates between them. The experimental procedure for measuring the temperature dependence of Hsh utilizes high power pulses to drive a niobium cavity resonator, ram** up surface magnetic fields extremely quickly. The moment any part of the cavity transitions between the superconducting and normal conducting state can be determined by measuring the quality factor of the cavity as a function of time. Oscillating superleak transducers are used to demonstrate that the transition to the normal conducting state is global in nature, showing that a fundamental limit is encountered. Finally, we see that 110-120 C heat treatment of the cavity--a method commonly used to increase the quality factor at high accelerating gradients--may have the deleterious effect of reducing the superheating field of the material, which is the fundamental limiting factor in pursuing the maximal achievable accelerating gradient in superconducting niobium cavities.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2010;
originally announced February 2010.
