-
Growing and Trap** Pebbles with Fragile Collisions of Particles in Protoplanetary Disks
Authors:
Paola Pinilla,
Christian T. Lenz,
Sebastian M. Stammler
Abstract:
[abridged] Recent laboratory experiments indicate that destructive collisions of icy dust particles occur with much lower velocities than previously thought. When these new velocities are considered from laboratory experiments in dust evolution models, a growth to pebble sizes in protoplanetary disks (PPDs) is difficult. This may contradict (sub-)mm observations and challenge the formation of plan…
▽ More
[abridged] Recent laboratory experiments indicate that destructive collisions of icy dust particles occur with much lower velocities than previously thought. When these new velocities are considered from laboratory experiments in dust evolution models, a growth to pebble sizes in protoplanetary disks (PPDs) is difficult. This may contradict (sub-)mm observations and challenge the formation of planetesimals and planets. We investigate the conditions that are required in dust evolution models for growing and trap** pebbles in PPDs when the fragmentation speed is 1ms$^{-1}$ in the entire disk. We distinguish the parameters controlling the effects of turbulent velocities, vertical stirring, radial diffusion, and gas viscous evolution, always assuming that particles cannot diffuse faster (radially or vertically) than the gas. To form pebbles and produce effective particle trap**, the parameter that controls the particle turbulent velocities must be small ($δ_t\lesssim10^{-4}$). In these cases, the vertical settling can limit the formation of pebbles, which also prevents particle trap**. Therefore the parameter that sets the vertical settling of the grains must be $δ_z<10^{-3}$. Our results suggest that different combinations of the particle and gas diffusion parameters can lead to a large diversity of millimeter fluxes and dust-disk radii. When pebble formation occurs and trap** is efficient, gaps and rings have higher contrast at mm-emission than in the NIR. In the case of inefficient trap**, structures are also formed at the two wavelengths, producing deeper and wider gaps in the NIR. Our results highlight the importance of obtaining observational constraints of gas and particle diffusion parameters and the properties of gaps at short and long wavelengths to better understand basic features of PPDs and the origin of the structures that are observed in these objects.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2020; v1 submitted 18 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Constraining the parameter space for the Solar Nebula
Authors:
Christian T. Lenz,
Hubert Klahr,
Tilman Birnstiel,
Katherine Kretke,
Sebastian Stammler
Abstract:
If we want to understand planetesimal formation, the only data set we have is our own Solar System. It is particularly interesting as it is so far the only planetary system we know of that developed life. Understanding the conditions under which the Solar Nebula evolved is crucial in order to understand the different processes in the disk and the subsequent dynamical interaction between (proto-)pl…
▽ More
If we want to understand planetesimal formation, the only data set we have is our own Solar System. It is particularly interesting as it is so far the only planetary system we know of that developed life. Understanding the conditions under which the Solar Nebula evolved is crucial in order to understand the different processes in the disk and the subsequent dynamical interaction between (proto-)planets, once the gas disk is gone. Protoplanetary disks provide a plethora of different parameters to explore. The question is whether this parameter space can be constrained, allowing simulations to reproduce the Solar System. Models and observations of planet formation provide constraints on the initial planetesimal mass in certain regions of the Solar Nebula. By making use of pebble flux-regulated planetesimal formation, we perform a parameter study with nine different disk parameters like the initial disk mass, initial disk size, initial dust-to-gas ratio, turbulence level, and more. We find that the distribution of mass in planetesimals in the disk depends on the planetesimal formation timescale and the pebbles' drift timescale. Multiple disk parameters can influence pebble properties and thus planetesimal formation. However, it is still possible to draw some conclusions on potential parameter ranges. Pebble flux-regulated planetesimal formation seems to be very robust, allowing simulations with a wide range of parameters to meet the initial planetesimal constraints for the Solar Nebula. I.e., it does not require a lot of fine tuning.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Linking planetesimal and dust content in protoplanetary disks via a local toy model
Authors:
Konstantin Gerbig,
Christian T. Lenz,
Hubert Klahr
Abstract:
If planetesimal formation is an efficient process, as suggested by several models involving gravitational collapse of pebble clouds, then, before long, a significant part of the primordial dust mass should be absorbed in many km sized objects. A good understanding of the total amount of solids in the disk around a young star is crucial for planet formation theory. But as the mass of particles abov…
▽ More
If planetesimal formation is an efficient process, as suggested by several models involving gravitational collapse of pebble clouds, then, before long, a significant part of the primordial dust mass should be absorbed in many km sized objects. A good understanding of the total amount of solids in the disk around a young star is crucial for planet formation theory. But as the mass of particles above the mm size cannot be assessed observationally, one must ask how much mass is hidden in bigger objects. We perform 0-d local simulations to study how the planetesimal to dust and pebble ratio is evolving in time and to develop an understanding of the potentially existing mass in planetesimals for a certain amount of dust and pebbles at a given disk age. We perform a parameter study based on a model considering dust growth, planetesimal formation and collisional fragmentation of planetesimals, while neglecting radial transport processes. While at early times, dust is the dominant solid particle species, there is a phase during which planetesimals make up a significant portion of the total mass starting at approximately $10^4 - 10^6$ yr. The time of this phase and the maximal total planetesimal mass strongly depend on the distance to the star $R$, the initial disk mass, and the efficiency of planetesimal formation $ε$. After approximately $10^6$ yr, our model predicts planetesimal collisions to dominate, which resupplies small particles. In our model, planetesimals form fast and everywhere in the disk. For a given $ε$, we were able to relate the dust content and mass of a given disk to its planetesimal content, providing us with some helpful basic intuition about mass distribution of solids and its dependence on underlying physical processes.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Planetesimal Population Synthesis: Pebble Flux Regulated Planetesimal Formation
Authors:
Christian T. Lenz,
Hubert Klahr,
Tilman Birnstiel
Abstract:
We propose an expression for a local planetesimal formation rate proportional to the instantaneous radial pebble flux. The result --- a radial planetesimal distribution --- can be used as initial condition to study the formation of planetary embryos. We follow the idea that one needs particle traps to locally enhance the dust-to-gas ratio sufficiently such that particle gas interactions can no lon…
▽ More
We propose an expression for a local planetesimal formation rate proportional to the instantaneous radial pebble flux. The result --- a radial planetesimal distribution --- can be used as initial condition to study the formation of planetary embryos. We follow the idea that one needs particle traps to locally enhance the dust-to-gas ratio sufficiently such that particle gas interactions can no longer prevent planetesimal formation on small scales. The location of these traps can emerge everywhere in the disk. Their occurrence and lifetime is subject of ongoing research, thus they are implemented via free parameters. This enables us to study the influence of the disk properties on the formation of planetesimals, predicting their time dependent formation rates and location of primary pebble accretion. We show that large $α$-values of $0.01$ (strong turbulence) prevent the formation of planetesimals in the inner part of the disk, arguing for lower values of around $0.001$ (moderate turbulence), at which planetesimals form quickly at all places where they are needed for proto-planets. Planetesimals form as soon as dust has grown to pebbles ($\sim\mathrm{mm}$ to $\mathrm{dm}$) and the pebble flux reaches a critical value, which is after a few thousand years at $2-3\,$AU and after a few hundred thousand years at $20-30\,$AU. Planetesimal formation lasts until the pebble supply has decreased below a critical value. The final spatial planetesimal distribution is steeper compared to the initial dust and gas distribution which helps to explain the discrepancy between the minimum mass solar nebula and viscous accretion disks.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2019; v1 submitted 19 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.