-
Applying Trust for Operational States of ICT-Enabled Power Grid Services
Authors:
Michael Brand,
Anand Narayan,
Sebastian Lehnhoff
Abstract:
Digitalization enables the automation required to operate modern cyber-physical energy systems (CPESs), leading to a shift from hierarchical to organic systems. However, digitalization increases the number of factors affecting the state of a CPES (e.g., software bugs and cyber threats). In addition to established factors like functional correctness, others like security become relevant but are yet…
▽ More
Digitalization enables the automation required to operate modern cyber-physical energy systems (CPESs), leading to a shift from hierarchical to organic systems. However, digitalization increases the number of factors affecting the state of a CPES (e.g., software bugs and cyber threats). In addition to established factors like functional correctness, others like security become relevant but are yet to be integrated into an operational viewpoint, i.e. a holistic perspective on the system state. Trust in organic computing is an approach to gain a holistic view of the state of systems. It consists of several facets (e.g., functional correctness, security, and reliability), which can be used to assess the state of CPES. Therefore, a trust assessment on all levels can contribute to a coherent state assessment. This paper focuses on the trust in ICT-enabled grid services in a CPES. These are essential for operating the CPES, and their performance relies on various data aspects like availability, timeliness, and correctness. This paper proposes to assess the trust in involved components and data to estimate data correctness, which is crucial for grid services. The assessment is presented considering two exemplary grid services, namely state estimation and coordinated voltage control. Furthermore, the interpretation of different trust facets is also discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Coupling OMNeT++ and mosaik for integrated Co-Simulation of ICT-reliant Smart Grids
Authors:
Frauke Oest,
Emilie Frost,
Malin Radtke,
Sebastian Lehnhoff
Abstract:
The increasing integration of renewable energy resources requires so-called smart grid services for monitoring, control and automation tasks. Simulation environments are vital for evaluating and develo** innovative solutions and algorithms. Especially in smart energy systems, we face a variety of heterogeneous simulators representing, e.g., power grids, analysis or control components and markets…
▽ More
The increasing integration of renewable energy resources requires so-called smart grid services for monitoring, control and automation tasks. Simulation environments are vital for evaluating and develo** innovative solutions and algorithms. Especially in smart energy systems, we face a variety of heterogeneous simulators representing, e.g., power grids, analysis or control components and markets. The co-simulation framework mosaik can be used to orchestrate the data exchange and time synchronization between individual simulators. So far, the underlying communication infrastructure has often been assumed to be optimal and therefore, the influence of e.g., communication delays has been neglected. This paper presents the first results of the project cosima, which aims at connecting the communication simulator OMNeT++ to the co-simulation framework mosaik to analyze the resilience and robustness of smart grid services, e.g., multi-agent-based services with respect to adaptivity, scalability, extensibility and usability. This facilitates simulations with realistic communication technologies (such as 5G) and the analysis of dynamic communication characteristics by simulating multiple messages. We show the functionality and benefits of cosima in experiments with 50 agents.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2024; v1 submitted 26 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Learning to Attack Powergrids with DERs
Authors:
Eric MSP Veith,
Nils Wenninghoff,
Stephan Balduin,
Thomas Wolgast,
Sebastian Lehnhoff
Abstract:
In the past years, power grids have become a valuable target for cyber-attacks. Especially the attacks on the Ukrainian power grid has sparked numerous research into possible attack vectors, their extent, and possible mitigations. However, many fail to consider realistic scenarios in which time series are incorporated into simulations to reflect the transient behaviour of independent generators an…
▽ More
In the past years, power grids have become a valuable target for cyber-attacks. Especially the attacks on the Ukrainian power grid has sparked numerous research into possible attack vectors, their extent, and possible mitigations. However, many fail to consider realistic scenarios in which time series are incorporated into simulations to reflect the transient behaviour of independent generators and consumers. Moreover, very few consider the limited sensory input of a potential attacker. In this paper, we describe a reactive power attack based on a well-understood scenario. We show that independent agents can learn to use the dynamics of the power grid against it and that the attack works even in the face of other generator and consumer nodes acting independently.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Sampling Strategies for Static Powergrid Models
Authors:
Stephan Balduin,
Eric MSP Veith,
Sebastian Lehnhoff
Abstract:
Machine learning and computational intelligence technologies gain more and more popularity as possible solution for issues related to the power grid. One of these issues, the power flow calculation, is an iterative method to compute the voltage magnitudes of the power grid's buses from power values. Machine learning and, especially, artificial neural networks were successfully used as surrogates f…
▽ More
Machine learning and computational intelligence technologies gain more and more popularity as possible solution for issues related to the power grid. One of these issues, the power flow calculation, is an iterative method to compute the voltage magnitudes of the power grid's buses from power values. Machine learning and, especially, artificial neural networks were successfully used as surrogates for the power flow calculation. Artificial neural networks highly rely on the quality and size of the training data, but this aspect of the process is apparently often neglected in the works we found. However, since the availability of high quality historical data for power grids is limited, we propose the Correlation Sampling algorithm. We show that this approach is able to cover a larger area of the sampling space compared to different random sampling algorithms from the literature and a copula-based approach, while at the same time inter-dependencies of the inputs are taken into account, which, from the other algorithms, only the copula-based approach does.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Comparison of Random Sampling and Heuristic Optimization-Based Methods for Determining the Flexibility Potential at Vertical System Interconnections
Authors:
Gerster Johannes,
Marcel Sarstedt,
Eric MSP Veith,
Sebastian Lehnhoff,
Lutz Hofmann
Abstract:
In order to prevent conflicting or counteracting use of flexibility options, the coordination between distribution system operator and transmission system operator has to be strengthened. For this purpose, methods for the standardized description and identification of the aggregated flexibility potential of distribution grids are developed. Approaches for identifying the feasible operation region…
▽ More
In order to prevent conflicting or counteracting use of flexibility options, the coordination between distribution system operator and transmission system operator has to be strengthened. For this purpose, methods for the standardized description and identification of the aggregated flexibility potential of distribution grids are developed. Approaches for identifying the feasible operation region (FOR) of distribution grids can be categorized into two main classes: Random sampling/stochastic approaches and optimization-based approaches. While the latter have the advantage of working in real-world scenarios where no full grid models exist, when relying on naive sampling strategies, they suffer from poor coverage of the edges of the FOR due to convoluted distributions. In this paper, we tackle the problem from two different angles. First, we present a random sampling approach which mitigates the convolution problem by drawing sample values from a multivariate Dirichlet distribution. Second, we come up with a hybrid approach which solves the underlying optimal power flow problems of the optimization-based approach by means of a stochastic evolutionary optimization algorithm codenamed REvol. By means of synthetic feeders, we compare the two proposed FOR identification methods with regard to how well the FOR is covered and number of power flow calculations required.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Pointing out the Convolution Problem of Stochastic Aggregation Methods for the Determination of Flexibility Potentials at Vertical System Interconnections
Authors:
Johannes Gerster,
Marcel Sarstedt,
Eric MSP Veith,
Sebastian Lehnhoff,
Lutz Hofmann
Abstract:
The increase of generation capacity in the area of responsibility of the distribution system operator (DSO) requires strengthening of coordination between transmission system operator (TSO) and DSO in order to prevent conflicting or counteracting use of flexibility options. For this purpose, methods for the standardized description and identification of the aggregated flexibility potential of dist…
▽ More
The increase of generation capacity in the area of responsibility of the distribution system operator (DSO) requires strengthening of coordination between transmission system operator (TSO) and DSO in order to prevent conflicting or counteracting use of flexibility options. For this purpose, methods for the standardized description and identification of the aggregated flexibility potential of distribution grids (DGs) are developed. Approaches for identifying the feasible operation region (FOR) of DGs can be categorized into two main classes: Data-driven/stochastic approaches and optimization based approaches. While the latter have the advantage of working in real-world scenarios where no full grid models exist, when relying on naive sampling strategies, they suffer from poor coverage of the edges of the FOR. To underpin the need for improved sampling strategies for data-driven approaches, in this paper we point out and analyse the shortcomings of naive sampling strategies with focus on the problem of leptocurtic distribution of resulting interconnection power flows (IPFs). We refer to this problem as convolution problem, as it can be traced back to the fact that the probability density function (PDF) of the sum of two or more independent random variables is the convolution of their respective PDFs. To demonstrate the convolution problem, we construct a series of synthetic 0.4 kV feeders, which are characterized by an increasing number of nodes and apply a sampling strategy to them that draws set-values for the controllable distributed energy resources (DERs) from independent uniform distributions. By calculating the power flow for each sample in each feeder, we end up with a collapsing IPF point cloud clearly indicating the convolution problem.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2021; v1 submitted 5 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Design of experiments aided holistic testing of cyber-physical energy systems
Authors:
Arjen van der Meer,
Cornelius Steinbrink,
Kai Heussen,
Daniel Morales Bondy,
Merkebu Zenebe Degefa,
Filip Pröstl Andren,
Thomas Strasser,
Sebastian Lehnhoff,
Peter Palensky
Abstract:
The complex and often safety-critical nature of cyber-physical energy systems makes validation a key challenge in facilitating the energy transition, especially when it comes to the testing on system level. Reliable and reproducible validation experiments can be guided by the concept of design of experiments, which is, however, so far not fully adopted by researchers. This paper suggests a structu…
▽ More
The complex and often safety-critical nature of cyber-physical energy systems makes validation a key challenge in facilitating the energy transition, especially when it comes to the testing on system level. Reliable and reproducible validation experiments can be guided by the concept of design of experiments, which is, however, so far not fully adopted by researchers. This paper suggests a structured guideline for design of experiments application within the holistic testing procedure suggested by the European ERIGrid project. In this paper, a general workflow as well as a practical example are provided with the aim to give domain experts a basic understanding of design of experiments compliant testing.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Smart Grid Co-Simulation with MOSAIK and HLA: A Comparison Study
Authors:
Cornelius Steinbrink,
Arjen A. van der Meer,
Milos Cvetkovic,
Davood Babazadeh,
Sebastian Rohjans,
Peter Palensky,
Sebastian Lehnhoff
Abstract:
Evaluating new technological developments for energy systems is becoming more and more complex. The overall application environment is a continuously growing and interconnected cyber-physical system so that analytical assessment is practically impossible to realize. Consequently, new solutions must be evaluated in simulation studies. Due to the interdisciplinarity of the simulation scenarios, vari…
▽ More
Evaluating new technological developments for energy systems is becoming more and more complex. The overall application environment is a continuously growing and interconnected cyber-physical system so that analytical assessment is practically impossible to realize. Consequently, new solutions must be evaluated in simulation studies. Due to the interdisciplinarity of the simulation scenarios, various heterogeneous tools must be connected. This approach is known as co-simulation. During the last years, different approaches have been developed or adapted for applications in energy systems. In this paper, two co-simulation approaches are compared that follow generic, versatile concepts. The tool mosaik, which has been explicitly developed for the purpose of co-simulation in complex energy systems, is compared to the High Level Architecture (HLA), which possesses a domain-independent scope but is often employed in the energy domain. The comparison is twofold, considering the tools' conceptual architectures as well as results from the simulation of representative test cases. It suggests that mosaik may be the better choice for entry-level, prototypical co-simulation while HLA is more suited for complex and extensive studies.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Future Perspectives of Co-Simulation in the Smart Grid Domain
Authors:
Cornelius Steinbrink,
Florian Schlögl,
Davood Babazadeh,
Sebastian Lehnhoff,
Sebastian Rohjans,
Anand Narajan
Abstract:
The recent attention towards research and development in cyber-physical energy systems has introduced the necessity of emerging multi-domain co-simulation tools. Different educational, research and industrial efforts have been set to tackle the co-simulation topic from several perspectives. The majority of previous works has addressed the standardization of models and interfaces for data exchange,…
▽ More
The recent attention towards research and development in cyber-physical energy systems has introduced the necessity of emerging multi-domain co-simulation tools. Different educational, research and industrial efforts have been set to tackle the co-simulation topic from several perspectives. The majority of previous works has addressed the standardization of models and interfaces for data exchange, automation of simulation, as well as improving performance and accuracy of co-simulation setups. Furthermore, the domains of interest so far have involved communication, control, markets and the environment in addition to physical energy systems. However, the current characteristics and state of co-simulation testbeds need to be re-evaluated for future research demands. These demands vary from new domains of interest, such as human and social behavior models, to new applications of co-simulation, such as holistic prognosis and system planning. This paper aims to formulate these research demands that can then be used as a road map and guideline for future development of co-simulation in cyber-physical energy systems.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Validating Intelligent Power and Energy Systems - A Discussion of Educational Needs
Authors:
Panos Kotsampopoulos,
Nikos Hatziargyriou,
Thomas I. Strasser,
Cyndi Moyo,
Sebastian Rohjans,
Cornelius Steinbrink,
Sebastian Lehnhoff,
Peter Palensky,
Arjen A. van der Meer,
Daniel Esteban Morales Bondy,
Kai Heussen,
Mihai Calin,
Ata Khavari,
Maria Sosnina,
J. Emilio Rodriguez,
Graeme M. Burt
Abstract:
Traditional power systems education and training is flanked by the demand for co** with the rising complexity of energy systems, like the integration of renewable and distributed generation, communication, control and information technology. A broad understanding of these topics by the current/future researchers and engineers is becoming more and more necessary. This paper identifies educational…
▽ More
Traditional power systems education and training is flanked by the demand for co** with the rising complexity of energy systems, like the integration of renewable and distributed generation, communication, control and information technology. A broad understanding of these topics by the current/future researchers and engineers is becoming more and more necessary. This paper identifies educational and training needs addressing the higher complexity of intelligent energy systems. Education needs and requirements are discussed, such as the development of systems-oriented skills and cross-disciplinary learning. Education and training possibilities and necessary tools are described focusing on classroom but also on laboratory-based learning methods. In this context, experiences of using notebooks, co-simulation approaches, hardware-in-the-loop methods and remote labs experiments are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Simulation-based Validation of Smart Grids - Status Quo and Future Research Trends
Authors:
Cornelius Steinbrink,
Sebastian Lehnhoff,
Sebastian Rohjans,
Thomas I. Strasser,
Edmund Widl,
Cyndi Moyo,
Georg Lauss,
Felix Lehfuss,
Mario Faschang,
Peter Palensky,
Arjen A. van der Meer,
Kai Heussen,
Oliver Gehrke,
Efren Guillo-Sansano,
Mazheruddin H. Syed,
Abdullah Emhemed,
Ron Brandl,
Van Hoa Nguyen,
Ata Khavari,
Quoc Tuan Tran,
Panos Kotsampopoulos,
Nikos Hatziargyriou,
Akroud Akroud,
Evangelos Rikos,
Merkebu Z. Degefa
Abstract:
Smart grid systems are characterized by high complexity due to interactions between a traditional passive network and active power electronic components, coupled using communication links. Additionally, automation and information technology plays an important role in order to operate and optimize such cyber-physical energy systems with a high(er) penetration of fluctuating renewable generation and…
▽ More
Smart grid systems are characterized by high complexity due to interactions between a traditional passive network and active power electronic components, coupled using communication links. Additionally, automation and information technology plays an important role in order to operate and optimize such cyber-physical energy systems with a high(er) penetration of fluctuating renewable generation and controllable loads. As a result of these developments the validation on the system level becomes much more important during the whole engineering and deployment process, today. In earlier development stages and for larger system configurations laboratory-based testing is not always an option. Due to recent developments, simulation-based approaches are now an appropriate tool to support the development, implementation, and roll-out of smart grid solutions. This paper discusses the current state of simulation-based approaches and outlines the necessary future research and development directions in the domain of power and energy systems.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
An Integrated Research Infrastructure for Validating Cyber-Physical Energy Systems
Authors:
Thomas I. Strasser,
Cyndi Moyo,
Roland Bründlinger,
Sebastian Lehnhoff,
Marita Blank,
Peter Palensky,
Arjen A. van der Meer,
Kai Heussen,
Oliver Gehrke,
J. Emilio Rodriguez,
Julia Merino,
Carlo Sandroni,
Maurizio Verga,
Mihai Calin,
Ata Khavari,
Maria Sosnina,
Erik de Jong,
Sebastian Rohjans,
Anna Kulmala,
Kari Mäki,
Ron Brandl,
Federico Coffele,
Graeme M. Burt,
Panos Kotsampopoulos,
Nikos Hatziargyriou
Abstract:
Renewables are key enablers in the plight to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and cope with anthropogenic global warming. The intermittent nature and limited storage capabilities of renewables culminate in new challenges that power system operators have to deal with in order to regulate power quality and ensure security of supply. At the same time, the increased availability of advanced automation…
▽ More
Renewables are key enablers in the plight to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and cope with anthropogenic global warming. The intermittent nature and limited storage capabilities of renewables culminate in new challenges that power system operators have to deal with in order to regulate power quality and ensure security of supply. At the same time, the increased availability of advanced automation and communication technologies provides new opportunities for the derivation of intelligent solutions to tackle the challenges. Previous work has shown various new methods of operating highly interconnected power grids, and their corresponding components, in a more effective way. As a consequence of these developments, the traditional power system is being transformed into a cyber-physical energy system, a smart grid. Previous and ongoing research have tended to mainly focus on how specific aspects of smart grids can be validated, but until there exists no integrated approach for the analysis and evaluation of complex cyber-physical systems configurations. This paper introduces integrated research infrastructure that provides methods and tools for validating smart grid systems in a holistic, cyber-physical manner. The corresponding concepts are currently being developed further in the European project ERIGrid.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Cyber-Physical Energy Systems Modeling, Test Specification, and Co-Simulation Based Testing
Authors:
Arjen A. van der Meer,
Peter Palensky,
Kai Heussen,
Daniel Esteban Morales Bondy,
Oliver Gehrke,
Cornelius Steinbrink,
Marita Blank,
Sebastian Lehnhoff,
Edmund Widl,
Cyndi Moyo,
Thomas I. Strasser,
Van Hoa Nguyen,
Nabil Akroud,
Mazheruddin H. Syed,
Abdullah Emhemed,
Sebastian Rohjans,
Ron Brandl,
Ata M. Khavari
Abstract:
The gradual deployment of intelligent and coordinated devices in the electrical power system needs careful investigation of the interactions between the various domains involved. Especially due to the coupling between ICT and power systems a holistic approach for testing and validating is required. Taking existing (quasi-) standardised smart grid system and test specification methods as a starting…
▽ More
The gradual deployment of intelligent and coordinated devices in the electrical power system needs careful investigation of the interactions between the various domains involved. Especially due to the coupling between ICT and power systems a holistic approach for testing and validating is required. Taking existing (quasi-) standardised smart grid system and test specification methods as a starting point, we are develo** a holistic testing and validation approach that allows a very flexible way of assessing the system level aspects by various types of experiments (including virtual, real, and mixed lab settings). This paper describes the formal holistic test case specification method and applies it to a particular co-simulation experimental setup. The various building blocks of such a simulation (i.e., FMI, mosaik, domain-specific simulation federates) are covered in more detail. The presented method addresses most modeling and specification challenges in cyber-physical energy systems and is extensible for future additions such as uncertainty quantification.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Using large-scale local and cross-location experiments for smart grid system validation
Authors:
Martin Buscher,
Sebastian Lehnhoff,
Sebastian Rohjans,
Filip Andrén,
Thomas Strasser
Abstract:
For robust testing of new technologies used in future, intelligent power and energy systems, realistic testing environments are needed. Due to the dimensions of a real-world environment a field-based installation is often not viable. More efficient instead of a local installation is to connect existing and highly sophisticated labs with different focus of specialization. Today's experimental setup…
▽ More
For robust testing of new technologies used in future, intelligent power and energy systems, realistic testing environments are needed. Due to the dimensions of a real-world environment a field-based installation is often not viable. More efficient instead of a local installation is to connect existing and highly sophisticated labs with different focus of specialization. Today's experimental setups for the Smart Grid domain are very time-consuming solutions or specific implementations for a single project. To overcome this challenge, an innovative concept for a novel approach for large-scale co-simulation across locations (different labs) is presented in this paper.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Towards a foundation for holistic power system validation and testing
Authors:
Marita Blank,
Sebastian Lehnhoff,
Kai Hessen,
Daniel Esteban Morales Bondy,
Cyndi Moyo,
Thomas Strasser
Abstract:
Renewable energy sources and further electrificationof energy consumption are key enablers for decreasing green-house gas emissions, but also introduce increased complexitywithin the electric power system. The increased availability ofautomation, information and communication technology, andintelligent solutions for system operation have transformed thepower system into a smart grid. In order to s…
▽ More
Renewable energy sources and further electrificationof energy consumption are key enablers for decreasing green-house gas emissions, but also introduce increased complexitywithin the electric power system. The increased availability ofautomation, information and communication technology, andintelligent solutions for system operation have transformed thepower system into a smart grid. In order to support thedevelopment process of smart grid solutions on the system level,testing has to be done in a holistic manner, covering the multi-domain aspect of such complex systems. This paper introducesthe concept of holistic power system testing and discuss first stepstowards a corresponding methodology that is being developed inthe European ERIGrid research infrastructure project.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2017; v1 submitted 29 April, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
OMNeT++ and mosaik: Enabling Simulation of Smart Grid Communications
Authors:
Jens Dede,
Koojana Kuladinithi,
Anna Förster,
Okko Nannen,
Sebastian Lehnhoff
Abstract:
This paper presents a preliminary system architecture of integrating OMNeT++ into the mosaik co-simulation framework. This will enable realistic simulation of communication network protocols and services for smart grid scenarios and on the other side, further development of communication protocols for smart grid applications. Thus, by integrating OMNeT++ and mosaik, both communities will be able t…
▽ More
This paper presents a preliminary system architecture of integrating OMNeT++ into the mosaik co-simulation framework. This will enable realistic simulation of communication network protocols and services for smart grid scenarios and on the other side, further development of communication protocols for smart grid applications. Thus, by integrating OMNeT++ and mosaik, both communities will be able to leverage each others's sophisticated simulation models and expertise. The main challenges identified are the external management of the OMNeT++ simulation kernel and performance issues when federating various simulators, including OMNeT++ into the mosaik framework. The purpose of this paper is to bring these challenges up and to gather relevant experience and expertise from the OMNeT++ community. We especially encourage collaboration among all OMNeT++ developers and users.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
