-
Towards Robust Benchmarking of Quantum Optimization Algorithms
Authors:
David Bucher,
Nico Kraus,
Jonas Blenninger,
Michael Lachner,
Jonas Stein,
Claudia Linnhoff-Popien
Abstract:
Benchmarking the performance of quantum optimization algorithms is crucial for identifying utility for industry-relevant use cases. Benchmarking processes vary between optimization applications and depend on user-specified goals. The heuristic nature of quantum algorithms poses challenges, especially when comparing to classical counterparts. A key problem in existing benchmarking frameworks is the…
▽ More
Benchmarking the performance of quantum optimization algorithms is crucial for identifying utility for industry-relevant use cases. Benchmarking processes vary between optimization applications and depend on user-specified goals. The heuristic nature of quantum algorithms poses challenges, especially when comparing to classical counterparts. A key problem in existing benchmarking frameworks is the lack of equal effort in optimizing for the best quantum and, respectively, classical approaches. This paper presents a comprehensive set of guidelines comprising universal steps towards fair benchmarks. We discuss (1) application-specific algorithm choice, ensuring every solver is provided with the most fitting mathematical formulation of a problem; (2) the selection of benchmark data, including hard instances and real-world samples; (3) the choice of a suitable holistic figure of merit, like time-to-solution or solution quality within time constraints; and (4) equitable hyperparameter training to eliminate bias towards a particular method. The proposed guidelines are tested across three benchmarking scenarios, utilizing the Max-Cut (MC) and Travelling Salesperson Problem (TSP). The benchmarks employ classical mathematical algorithms, such as Branch-and-Cut (BNC) solvers, classical heuristics, Quantum Annealing (QA), and the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA).
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Solving the Turbine Balancing Problem using Quantum Annealing
Authors:
Arnold Unterauer,
David Bucher,
Matthias Knoll,
Constantin Economides,
Michael Lachner,
Thomas Germain,
Moritz Kessel,
Smajo Hajdinovic,
Jonas Stein
Abstract:
Quantum computing has the potential for disruptive change in many sectors of industry, especially in materials science and optimization. In this paper, we describe how the Turbine Balancing Problem can be solved with quantum computing, which is the NP-hard optimization problem of analytically balancing rotor blades in a single plane as found in turbine assembly. Small yet relevant instances occur…
▽ More
Quantum computing has the potential for disruptive change in many sectors of industry, especially in materials science and optimization. In this paper, we describe how the Turbine Balancing Problem can be solved with quantum computing, which is the NP-hard optimization problem of analytically balancing rotor blades in a single plane as found in turbine assembly. Small yet relevant instances occur in industry, which makes the problem interesting for early quantum computing benchmarks. We model it as a Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization problem and compare the performance of a classical rule-based heuristic and D-Wave Systems' Quantum Annealer Advantage_system4.1. In this case study, we use real-world as well as synthetic datasets and observe that the quantum hardware significantly improves an actively used heuristic's solution for small-scale problem instances with bare disk imbalance in terms of solution quality. Motivated by this performance gain, we subsequently design a quantum-inspired classical heuristic based on simulated annealing that achieves extremely good results on all given problem instances, essentially solving the optimization problem sufficiently well for all considered datasets, according to industrial requirements.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Linear and non-linear machine learning attacks on physical unclonable functions
Authors:
Michael Lachner
Abstract:
In this thesis, several linear and non-linear machine learning attacks on optical physical unclonable functions (PUFs) are presented. To this end, a simulation of such a PUF is implemented to generate a variety of datasets that differ in several factors in order to find the best simulation setup and to study the behavior of the machine learning attacks under different circumstances. All datasets a…
▽ More
In this thesis, several linear and non-linear machine learning attacks on optical physical unclonable functions (PUFs) are presented. To this end, a simulation of such a PUF is implemented to generate a variety of datasets that differ in several factors in order to find the best simulation setup and to study the behavior of the machine learning attacks under different circumstances. All datasets are evaluated in terms of individual samples and their correlations with each other. In the following, both linear and deep learning approaches are used to attack these PUF simulations and comprehensively investigate the impact of different factors on the datasets in terms of their security level against attackers. In addition, the differences between the two attack methods in terms of their performance are highlighted using several independent metrics. Several improvements to these models and new attacks will be introduced and investigated sequentially, with the goal of progressively improving modeling performance. This will lead to the development of an attack capable of almost perfectly predicting the outputs of the simulated PUF. In addition, data from a real optical PUF is examined and both compared to that of the simulation and used to see how the machine learning models presented would perform in the real world. The results show that all models meet the defined criterion for a successful machine learning attack.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Clones of the Unclonable: Nanoduplicating Optical PUFs and Applications
Authors:
E. Marakis,
U. Rührmair,
M. Lachner,
R. Uppu,
B. Škorić,
P. W. H. Pinkse
Abstract:
Physical unclonable functions (PUFs), physical objects that are practically unclonable because of their andom and uncontrollable manufacturing variations, are becoming increasingly popular as security primitives and unique identifiers in a fully digitized world. One of the central PUF premises states that both friends and foes, both legitimate manufacturers and external attackers alike, cannot clo…
▽ More
Physical unclonable functions (PUFs), physical objects that are practically unclonable because of their andom and uncontrollable manufacturing variations, are becoming increasingly popular as security primitives and unique identifiers in a fully digitized world. One of the central PUF premises states that both friends and foes, both legitimate manufacturers and external attackers alike, cannot clone a PUF, producing two instances that are the same. Using the latest nanofabrication techniques, we show that this premise is not always met: We demonstrate the possibility of effective PUF duplication through sophisticated manufacturers by producing 63 copies of a non-trivial optical scattering structure which exhibit essentially the same scattering behavior. The remaining minuscule differences are close to or below noise levels, whence the duplicates have to be considered fully equivalent from a PUF perspective. The possibility for manufacturer-based optical PUF duplication has positive and negative consequences at the same time: While fully breaking the security of certain schemes, it enables new applications, too. For example, it facilitates unforgeable labels for valuable items; the first key-free group identification schemes over digital networks; or new types of encryption/decryption devices that do not contain secret keys.
△ Less
Submitted 23 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
