-
3D hydrodynamical and radiative transfer modeling of Eta Carinae's colliding winds
Authors:
Thomas I. Madura,
Nicola Clementel,
Theodore R. Gull,
Chael J. H. Kruip,
Jan-Pieter Paardekooper,
Vincent Icke
Abstract:
We present results of full 3D hydrodynamical and radiative transfer simulations of the colliding stellar winds in the massive binary system Eta Carinae. We accomplish this by applying the SimpleX algorithm for 3D radiative transfer on an unstructured Voronoi-Delaunay grid to recent 3D smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH) simulations of the binary colliding winds. We use SimpleX to obtain detailed…
▽ More
We present results of full 3D hydrodynamical and radiative transfer simulations of the colliding stellar winds in the massive binary system Eta Carinae. We accomplish this by applying the SimpleX algorithm for 3D radiative transfer on an unstructured Voronoi-Delaunay grid to recent 3D smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH) simulations of the binary colliding winds. We use SimpleX to obtain detailed ionization fractions of hydrogen and helium, in 3D, at the resolution of the original SPH simulations. We investigate several computational domain sizes and Luminous Blue Variable primary star mass-loss rates. We furthermore present new methods of visualizing and interacting with output from complex 3D numerical simulations, including 3D interactive graphics and 3D printing. While we initially focus on Eta Car, the methods employed can be applied to numerous other colliding wind (WR 140, WR 137, WR 19) and dusty 'pinwheel' (WR 104, WR 98a) binary systems. Coupled with 3D hydrodynamical simulations, SimpleX simulations have the potential to help determine the regions where various observed time-variable emission and absorption lines form in these unique objects.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
3D radiative transfer simulations of Eta Carinae's inner colliding winds - II: Ionization structure of helium at periastron
Authors:
Nicola Clementel,
Thomas I. Madura,
Chael J. H. Kruip,
Jan-Pieter Paardekooper
Abstract:
Spectral observations of the massive colliding wind binary Eta Carinae show phase-dependent variations, in intensity and velocity, of numerous helium emission and absorption lines throughout the entire 5.54-year orbit. Approaching periastron, the 3D structure of the wind-wind interaction region (WWIR) gets highly distorted due to the eccentric ($e \sim 0.9$) binary orbit. The secondary star (…
▽ More
Spectral observations of the massive colliding wind binary Eta Carinae show phase-dependent variations, in intensity and velocity, of numerous helium emission and absorption lines throughout the entire 5.54-year orbit. Approaching periastron, the 3D structure of the wind-wind interaction region (WWIR) gets highly distorted due to the eccentric ($e \sim 0.9$) binary orbit. The secondary star ($η_{\mathrm{B}}$) at these phases is located deep within the primary's dense wind photosphere. The combination of these effects is thought to be the cause of the particularly interesting features observed in the helium lines at periastron. We perform 3D radiative transfer simulations of $η$ Car's interacting winds at periastron. Using the SimpleX radiative transfer algorithm, we post-process output from 3D smoothed particle hydrodynamic simulations of the inner 150 au of the $η$ Car system for two different primary star mass-loss rates ($\dot{M}_{η_{\mathrm{A}}}$). Using previous results from simulations at apastron as a guide for the initial conditions, we compute 3D helium ionization maps. We find that, for higher $\dot{M}_{η_{\mathrm{A}}}$, $η_{\mathrm{B}}$ He$^{0+}$-ionizing photons are not able to penetrate into the pre-shock primary wind. He$^{+}$ due to $η_{\mathrm{B}}$ is only present in a thin layer along the leading arm of the WWIR and in a small region close to the stars. Lowering $\dot{M}_{η_{\mathrm{A}}}$ allows $η_{\mathrm{B}}$'s ionizing photons to reach the expanding unshocked secondary wind on the apastron side of the system, and create a low fraction of He$^{+}$ in the pre-shock primary wind. With apastron on our side of the system, our results are qualitatively consistent with the observed variations in strength and radial velocity of $η$ Car's helium emission and absorption lines, which helps better constrain the regions where these lines arise.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
3D Printing Meets Computational Astrophysics: Deciphering the Structure of Eta Carinae's Inner Colliding Winds
Authors:
Thomas I. Madura,
Nicola Clementel,
Theodore R. Gull,
Chael J. H. Kruip,
Jan-Pieter Paardekooper
Abstract:
We present the first 3D prints of output from a supercomputer simulation of a complex astrophysical system, the colliding stellar winds in the massive (>120 M_Sun), highly eccentric (e ~ 0.9) binary star system Eta Carinae. We demonstrate the methodology used to incorporate 3D interactive figures into a PDF journal publication and the benefits of using 3D visualization and 3D printing as tools to…
▽ More
We present the first 3D prints of output from a supercomputer simulation of a complex astrophysical system, the colliding stellar winds in the massive (>120 M_Sun), highly eccentric (e ~ 0.9) binary star system Eta Carinae. We demonstrate the methodology used to incorporate 3D interactive figures into a PDF journal publication and the benefits of using 3D visualization and 3D printing as tools to analyze data from multidimensional numerical simulations. Using a consumer-grade 3D printer (MakerBot Replicator 2X), we successfully printed 3D smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH) simulations of Eta Carinae's inner (r ~ 110 au) wind-wind collision interface at multiple orbital phases. The 3D prints and visualizations reveal important, previously unknown 'finger-like' structures at orbital phases shortly after periastron (phi ~ 1.045) that protrude radially outward from the spiral wind-wind collision region. We speculate that these fingers are related to instabilities (e.g. thin-shell, Rayleigh-Taylor) that arise at the interface between the radiatively-cooled layer of dense post-shock primary-star wind and the fast (3000 km/s), adiabatic post-shock companion-star wind. The success of our work and easy identification of previously unrecognized physical features highlight the important role 3D printing and interactive graphics can play in the visualization and understanding of complex 3D time-dependent numerical simulations of astrophysical phenomena.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
3D radiative transfer simulations of Eta Carinae's inner colliding winds - I. Ionization structure of helium at apastron
Authors:
Nicola Clementel,
Thomas I. Madura,
Chael Kruip,
Jan-Pieter Paardekooper,
Theodore R. Gull
Abstract:
The highly eccentric binary system Eta Carinae shows numerous time-variable emission and absorption features. These observational signatures are the result of interactions between the complex three-dimensional (3D) wind-wind collision regions and photoionization by the luminous stars. Specifically, helium presents several interesting spectral features that provide important clues on the geometry a…
▽ More
The highly eccentric binary system Eta Carinae shows numerous time-variable emission and absorption features. These observational signatures are the result of interactions between the complex three-dimensional (3D) wind-wind collision regions and photoionization by the luminous stars. Specifically, helium presents several interesting spectral features that provide important clues on the geometry and physical properties of the system and the individual stars. We use the SimpleX algorithm to post-process 3D smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulation output of the interacting winds in Eta Car in order to obtain the fractions of ionized helium assuming three different primary star mass-loss rates. The resultant ionization maps constrain the regions where helium is singly- and doubly-ionized. We find that reducing the primary's mass-loss rate increases the volume of He+. Lowering the primary mass-loss rate produces large variations in the volume of He+ in the pre-shock primary wind on the periastron side of the system. Our results show that binary orientations in which apastron is on our side of the system are more consistent with available observations. We suggest that small variations in the primary's mass-loss rate might explain the observed increase in HeI absorption in recent decades, although numerous questions regarding this scenario remain open. We also propose that the absence of broad HeI lines in the spectra of Eta Car between its 1890's eruption and 1944 might be explained by the companion star's He0+ ionizing photons not being able to penetrate the wind-wind interaction region, due to a higher primary mass-loss rate at that time (by a factor >2, compared to the present value).
△ Less
Submitted 23 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
3D Radiative Transfer in $η$ Carinae: Application of the SimpleX Algorithm to 3D SPH Simulations of Binary Colliding Winds
Authors:
N. Clementel,
T. I. Madura,
C. J. H. Kruip,
V. Icke,
T. R. Gull
Abstract:
Eta Carinae is an ideal astrophysical laboratory for studying massive binary interactions and evolution, and stellar wind-wind collisions. Recent three-dimensional (3D) simulations set the stage for understanding the highly complex 3D flows in $η$ Car. Observations of different broad high- and low-ionization forbidden emission lines provide an excellent tool to constrain the orientation of the sys…
▽ More
Eta Carinae is an ideal astrophysical laboratory for studying massive binary interactions and evolution, and stellar wind-wind collisions. Recent three-dimensional (3D) simulations set the stage for understanding the highly complex 3D flows in $η$ Car. Observations of different broad high- and low-ionization forbidden emission lines provide an excellent tool to constrain the orientation of the system, the primary's mass-loss rate, and the ionizing flux of the hot secondary. In this work we present the first steps towards generating synthetic observations to compare with available and future HST/STIS data. We present initial results from full 3D radiative transfer simulations of the interacting winds in $η$ Car. We use the SimpleX algorithm to post-process the output from 3D SPH simulations and obtain the ionization fractions of hydrogen and helium assuming three different mass-loss rates for the primary star. The resultant ionization maps of both species constrain the regions where the observed forbidden emission lines can form. Including collisional ionization is necessary to achieve a better description of the ionization states, especially in the areas shielded from the secondary's radiation. We find that reducing the primary's mass-loss rate increases the volume of ionized gas, creating larger areas where the forbidden emission lines can form. We conclude that post processing 3D SPH data with SimpleX is a viable tool to create ionization maps for $η$ Car.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
A companion as the cause of latitude-dependent effects in the wind of Eta Carinae
Authors:
Jose H. Groh,
Thomas I. Madura,
D. J. Hillier,
C. J. H. Kruip,
G. Weigelt
Abstract:
We analyze spatially resolved spectroscopic observations of the Eta Carinae binary system obtained with HST/STIS. Eta Car is enshrouded by the dusty Homunculus nebula, which scatters light emitted by the central binary and provides a unique opportunity to study a massive binary system from different vantage points. We investigate the latitudinal and azimuthal dependence of H$α$ line profiles cause…
▽ More
We analyze spatially resolved spectroscopic observations of the Eta Carinae binary system obtained with HST/STIS. Eta Car is enshrouded by the dusty Homunculus nebula, which scatters light emitted by the central binary and provides a unique opportunity to study a massive binary system from different vantage points. We investigate the latitudinal and azimuthal dependence of H$α$ line profiles caused by the presence of a wind-wind collision (WWC) cavity created by the companion star. Using two-dimensional radiative transfer models, we find that the wind cavity can qualitatively explain the observed line profiles around apastron. Regions of the Homunculus which scatter light that propagated through the WWC cavity show weaker or no H alpha absorption. Regions scattering light that propagated through a significant portion of the primary wind show stronger P Cygni absorption. Our models overestimate the H alpha absorption formed in the primary wind, which we attribute to photoionization by the companion, not presently included in the models. We can qualitatively explain the latitudinal changes that occur during periastron, shedding light on the nature of Eta Car's spectroscopic events. Our models support the idea that during the brief period of time around periastron when the primary wind flows unimpeded toward the observer, H alpha absorption occurs in directions toward the central object and Homunculus SE pole, but not toward equatorial regions close to the Weigelt blobs. We suggest that observed latitudinal and azimuthal variations are dominated by the companion star via the WWC cavity, rather than by rapid rotation of the primary star.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
The escape of ionising radiation from high-redshift dwarf galaxies
Authors:
Jan-Pieter Paardekooper,
Federico I. Pelupessy,
Gabriel Altay,
Chael Kruip
Abstract:
The UV escape fraction from high-redshift galaxies plays a key role in models of cosmic reionisation. Because it is currently not possible to deduce the escape fractions during the epoch of reionisation from observations, we have to rely on numerical simulations. Our aim is to better constrain the escape fraction from high-redshift dwarf galaxies, as these are the most likely sources responsible f…
▽ More
The UV escape fraction from high-redshift galaxies plays a key role in models of cosmic reionisation. Because it is currently not possible to deduce the escape fractions during the epoch of reionisation from observations, we have to rely on numerical simulations. Our aim is to better constrain the escape fraction from high-redshift dwarf galaxies, as these are the most likely sources responsible for reionising the Universe. We employ a N-body/SPH method that includes realistic prescriptions for the physical processes that are important for the evolution of dwarf galaxies. These models are post-processed with radiative transfer to determine the escape fraction of ionising radiation. We perform a parameter study to assess the influence of the spin parameter, gas fraction and formation redshift of the galaxy and study the importance of numerical parameters as resolution, source distribution and local gas clearing. We find that the UV escape fraction from high-redshift dwarf galaxies that have formed a rotationally supported disc lie between 1e-5 and 0.1. The mass and angular momentum of the galaxy are the most important parameters that determine the escape fraction. We compare our results to previous work and discuss the uncertainties of our models. The low escape fraction we find for high-redshift dwarf galaxies is balanced by their high stellar content, resulting in an efficiency parameter for stars that is only marginally lower than the values found by semi-analytic models of reionisation. We therefore conclude that dwarf galaxies play an important role in cosmic reionisation also after the initial starburst phase, when the gas has settled into a disc.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
Mathematical properties of the SimpleX algorithm
Authors:
C. J. H. Kruip,
J. -P. Paardekooper,
B. J. F. Clauwens,
V. Icke
Abstract:
Context. Analytical and numerical analysis of the SimpleX radiative transfer algorithm, which features transport on a Delaunay triangulation. Aims. Verify whether the SimpleX radiative transfer algorithm conforms to mathematical expectations, to develop error analysis and present improvements upon earlier versions of the code. Methods. Voronoi-Delaunay tessellation, classical Markov theory. Resu…
▽ More
Context. Analytical and numerical analysis of the SimpleX radiative transfer algorithm, which features transport on a Delaunay triangulation. Aims. Verify whether the SimpleX radiative transfer algorithm conforms to mathematical expectations, to develop error analysis and present improvements upon earlier versions of the code. Methods. Voronoi-Delaunay tessellation, classical Markov theory. Results. Quantitative description of the error properties of the SimpleX method. Numerical validation of the method and verification of the analytical results. Improvements in accuracy and speed of the method. Conclusions. It is possible to transport particles such as photons in a physically correct manner with the SimpleX algorithm. This requires the use of weighting schemes or the modification of the point process underlying the transport grid. We have explored and applied several possibilities.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2010;
originally announced February 2010.
-
SimpleX2: radiative transfer on an unstructured, dynamic grid
Authors:
J. -P. Paardekooper,
C. J. H. Kruip,
V. Icke
Abstract:
We present an improved version of the SimpleX method for radiative transfer on an unstructured Delaunay grid. The grid samples the medium through which photons are transported in an optimal way for fast radiative transfer calculations. In this paper we study the detailed working of SimpleX in test problems and show improvements over the previous version of the method. We have applied a direction c…
▽ More
We present an improved version of the SimpleX method for radiative transfer on an unstructured Delaunay grid. The grid samples the medium through which photons are transported in an optimal way for fast radiative transfer calculations. In this paper we study the detailed working of SimpleX in test problems and show improvements over the previous version of the method. We have applied a direction conserving transport scheme that correctly transports photons in the optically thin regime, a regime where the original SimpleX algorithm lost its accuracy. In addition, a scheme of dynamic grid updates is employed to ensure correct photon transport when the optical depth changes during a simulation. For the application to large data sets, the method is parallellised for distributed memory machines using MPI. To test the new method, we have performed standard tests for cosmological radiative transfer. We show excellent correspondence with both the analytical solution (when available) and to the results of other codes compared to the former version of SimpleX, without sacrificing the benefits of the high computational speed of the method.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2010; v1 submitted 21 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
-
Detecting Irregular Orbits in Gravitational N-body Simulations
Authors:
Jort Gemmeke,
Simon Portegies Zwart,
Chael Kruip
Abstract:
We present a qualitative diagnostic based on the continuous wavelet transform, for the detection of irregular behavior in time series of particle simulations. We apply the method to three qualitatively different gravitational 3-body encounters. The intrinsic irregular behavior of these encounters is well reproduced by the presented method, and we show that the method accurately identifies the ir…
▽ More
We present a qualitative diagnostic based on the continuous wavelet transform, for the detection of irregular behavior in time series of particle simulations. We apply the method to three qualitatively different gravitational 3-body encounters. The intrinsic irregular behavior of these encounters is well reproduced by the presented method, and we show that the method accurately identifies the irregular regime in these encounters. We also provide an instantaneous quantification for the degree of irregularity in these simulations. Furthermore we demonstrate how the method can be used to analyze larger systems by applying it to simulations with 100-particles. It turns out that the number of stars on irregular orbits is systematically larger for clusters in which all stars have the same mass compared to a multimass system. The proposed method provides a quick and sufficiently accurate diagnostic for identifying stars on irregular orbits in large scale N-body simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2006;
originally announced July 2006.
