-
Robust Model Predictive Control for nonlinear discrete-time systems using iterative time-varying constraint tightening
Authors:
Daniel D. Leister,
Justin P. Koeln
Abstract:
Robust Model Predictive Control (MPC) for nonlinear systems is a problem that poses significant challenges as highlighted by the diversity of approaches proposed in the last decades. Often compromises with respect to computational load, conservatism, generality, or implementation complexity have to be made, and finding an approach that provides the right balance is still a challenge to the researc…
▽ More
Robust Model Predictive Control (MPC) for nonlinear systems is a problem that poses significant challenges as highlighted by the diversity of approaches proposed in the last decades. Often compromises with respect to computational load, conservatism, generality, or implementation complexity have to be made, and finding an approach that provides the right balance is still a challenge to the research community. This work provides a contribution by proposing a novel shrinking-horizon robust MPC formulation for nonlinear discrete-time systems. By explicitly accounting for how disturbances and linearization errors are propagated through the nonlinear dynamics, a constraint tightening-based formulation is obtained, with guarantees of robust constraint satisfaction. The proposed controller relies on iteratively solving a Nonlinear Program (NLP) to simultaneously optimize system operation and the required constraint tightening. Numerical experiments show the effectiveness of the proposed controller with three different choices of NLP solvers as well as significantly improved computational speed, better scalability, and generally reduced conservatism when compared to an existing technique from the literature.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
zonoLAB: A MATLAB toolbox for set-based control systems analysis using hybrid zonotopes
Authors:
Justin Koeln,
Trevor J. Bird,
Jacob Siefert,
Justin Ruths,
Herschel Pangborn,
Neera Jain
Abstract:
This paper introduces zonoLAB, a MATLAB-based toolbox for set-based control system analysis using the hybrid zonotope set representation. Hybrid zonotopes have proven to be an expressive set representation that can exactly represent the reachable sets of mixed-logical dynamical systems and tightly approximate the reachable sets of nonlinear dynamic systems. Moreover, hybrid zonotopes can exactly r…
▽ More
This paper introduces zonoLAB, a MATLAB-based toolbox for set-based control system analysis using the hybrid zonotope set representation. Hybrid zonotopes have proven to be an expressive set representation that can exactly represent the reachable sets of mixed-logical dynamical systems and tightly approximate the reachable sets of nonlinear dynamic systems. Moreover, hybrid zonotopes can exactly represent the continuous piecewise linear control laws associated with model predictive control and the input-output map**s of neural networks with piecewise linear activation functions. The hybrid zonotope set representation is also highly exploitable, where efficient methods developed for mixed-integer linear programming can be directly used for set operation and analysis. The zonoLAB toolbox is designed to make these capabilities accessible to the dynamic systems and controls community, with functionality spanning fundamental operations with hybrid zonotope, constrained zonotope, and zonotope set representations, powerful set analysis tools, and general-purpose algorithms for reachability analysis of open- and closed-loop systems.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2024; v1 submitted 23 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Reachability Analysis Using Hybrid Zonotopes and Functional Decomposition
Authors:
Jacob A. Siefert,
Trevor J. Bird,
Andrew F. Thompson,
Jonah J. Glunt,
Justin P. Koeln,
Neera Jain,
Herschel C. Pangborn
Abstract:
This paper proposes methods for reachability analysis of nonlinear systems in both open loop and closed loop with advanced controllers. The methods combine hybrid zonotopes, a construct called a state-update set, functional decomposition, and special ordered set approximations to enable linear growth in reachable set memory complexity with time and linear scaling in computational complexity with t…
▽ More
This paper proposes methods for reachability analysis of nonlinear systems in both open loop and closed loop with advanced controllers. The methods combine hybrid zonotopes, a construct called a state-update set, functional decomposition, and special ordered set approximations to enable linear growth in reachable set memory complexity with time and linear scaling in computational complexity with the system dimension. Facilitating this combination are new identities for constructing nonconvex sets that contain nonlinear functions and for efficiently converting a collection of polytopes from vertex representation to hybrid zonotope representation. Benchmark numerical examples from the literature demonstrate the proposed methods and provide comparison to state-of-the-art techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2024; v1 submitted 13 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Hybrid Zonotopes Exactly Represent ReLU Neural Networks
Authors:
Joshua Ortiz,
Alyssa Vellucci,
Justin Koeln,
Justin Ruths
Abstract:
We show that hybrid zonotopes offer an equivalent representation of feed-forward fully connected neural networks with ReLU activation functions. Our approach demonstrates that the complexity of binary variables is equal to the total number of neurons in the network and hence grows linearly in the size of the network. We demonstrate the utility of the hybrid zonotope formulation through three case…
▽ More
We show that hybrid zonotopes offer an equivalent representation of feed-forward fully connected neural networks with ReLU activation functions. Our approach demonstrates that the complexity of binary variables is equal to the total number of neurons in the network and hence grows linearly in the size of the network. We demonstrate the utility of the hybrid zonotope formulation through three case studies including nonlinear function approximation, MPC closed-loop reachability and verification, and robustness of classification on the MNIST dataset.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Switched Moving Boundary Modeling of Phase Change Thermal Energy Storage Systems
Authors:
Trent J. Sakakini,
Justin P. Koeln
Abstract:
Thermal Energy Storage (TES) devices, which leverage the constant-temperature thermal capacity of the latent heat of a Phase Change Material (PCM), provide benefits to a variety of thermal management systems by decoupling the absorption and rejection of thermal energy. While performing a role similar to a battery in an electrical system, it is critical to know when to charge (freeze) and discharge…
▽ More
Thermal Energy Storage (TES) devices, which leverage the constant-temperature thermal capacity of the latent heat of a Phase Change Material (PCM), provide benefits to a variety of thermal management systems by decoupling the absorption and rejection of thermal energy. While performing a role similar to a battery in an electrical system, it is critical to know when to charge (freeze) and discharge (melt) the TES to maximize the capabilities and efficiency of the overall system. Therefore, control-oriented models of TES are needed to predict the behavior of the TES and make informed control decisions. While existing modeling approaches divide the TES in to multiple sections using a Fixed Grid (FG) approach, this paper proposes a switched Moving Boundary (MB) model that captures the key dynamics of the TES with significantly fewer dynamic states. Specifically, a graph-based modeling approach is used to model the heat flow through the TES and a MB approach is used to model the time-varying liquid and solid regions of the TES. Additionally, a Finite State Machine (FSM) is used to switch between four different modes of operation based on the State-of-Charge (SOC) of the TES. Numerical simulations comparing the proposed approach with a more traditional FG approach show that the MB model is capable of accurately modeling the behavior of the FG model while using far fewer states, leading to five times faster simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2023; v1 submitted 27 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Successor Sets of Discrete-time Nonlinear Systems Using Hybrid Zonotopes
Authors:
Jacob A. Siefert,
Trevor J. Bird,
Justin P. Koeln,
Neera Jain,
Herschel C. Pangborn
Abstract:
This paper presents identities for calculating over-approximated successor sets of discrete-time nonlinear systems using hybrid zonotopes. The proposed technique extends the state-update set construct, previously developed for linear hybrid systems, to nonlinear systems. Forward reachability of nonlinear systems can then be performed using only projection, intersection, and Cartesian product set o…
▽ More
This paper presents identities for calculating over-approximated successor sets of discrete-time nonlinear systems using hybrid zonotopes. The proposed technique extends the state-update set construct, previously developed for linear hybrid systems, to nonlinear systems. Forward reachability of nonlinear systems can then be performed using only projection, intersection, and Cartesian product set operations with the state-update set. It is shown that use of an over-approximation of the state-update set yields over-approximations of successor sets. A technique to over-approximate a nonlinear function using a special ordered set approximation, equivalently represented as a hybrid zonotope, is then presented. A numerical example of a nonlinear system controlled by a piecewise-affine control law demonstrates that the approach provides a computationally-efficient and tight over-approximation of the closed-loop reachable set.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2023; v1 submitted 18 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Hierarchical MPC for coupled subsystems using adjustable tubes
Authors:
Vignesh Raghuraman,
Justin P. Koeln
Abstract:
A hierarchical Model Predictive Control (MPC) formulation is presented for coupled discrete-time linear systems with state and input constraints. Compared to a centralized approach, a two-level hierarchical controller, with one controller in the upper-level and one controller per subsystem in the lower-level, can significantly reduce the computational cost associated with MPC. Hierarchical coordin…
▽ More
A hierarchical Model Predictive Control (MPC) formulation is presented for coupled discrete-time linear systems with state and input constraints. Compared to a centralized approach, a two-level hierarchical controller, with one controller in the upper-level and one controller per subsystem in the lower-level, can significantly reduce the computational cost associated with MPC. Hierarchical coordination is achieved using adjustable tubes, which are optimized by the upper-level controller and bound permissible lower-level controller deviations from the system trajectories determined by the upper-level controller. The size of these adjustable tubes determines the degree of uncertainty between subsystems and directly affects the required constraint tightening under a tube-based robust MPC framework. Sets are represented as zonotopes to enable the ability to optimize the size of these adjustable tubes and perform the necessary constraint tightening online as part of the MPC optimization problems. State and input constraint satisfaction is proven for the two-level hierarchical controller with an arbitrary number of controllers at the lower-level and a numerical example demonstrates the key features and performance of the approach.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Hybrid zonotopes: a new set representation for reachability analysis of mixed logical dynamical systems
Authors:
Trevor J. Bird,
Herschel C. Pangborn,
Neera Jain,
Justin P. Koeln
Abstract:
This article presents a new set representation named the hybrid zonotope that is equivalent to the union of $2^N$ constrained zonotopes -- convex polytopes -- through the addition of $N$ binary zonotope factors. The major contribution of this manuscript is a closed-form solution for exact forward reachable sets of discrete-time, linear hybrid systems modeled as mixed logical dynamical systems. The…
▽ More
This article presents a new set representation named the hybrid zonotope that is equivalent to the union of $2^N$ constrained zonotopes -- convex polytopes -- through the addition of $N$ binary zonotope factors. The major contribution of this manuscript is a closed-form solution for exact forward reachable sets of discrete-time, linear hybrid systems modeled as mixed logical dynamical systems. The proposed approach captures the worst-case exponential growth in the number of convex sets required to represent the nonconvex reachable set while exhibiting only linear growth in the complexity of the hybrid zonotope set representation. Redundancy removal techniques are provided that leverage binary trees to store the combinations of binary factors of the hybrid zonotope that map to nonempty convex subsets. Numerical examples show the hybrid zonotope's ability to compactly represent nonconvex reachable sets with an exponential number of features. Furthermore, the hybrid zonotope is shown to be closed under linear map**s, Minkowski sums, generalized intersections, and halfspace intersections.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2023; v1 submitted 28 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Graphene-Based Electromechanical Thermal Switches
Authors:
Michelle E. Chen,
Miguel Muñoz Rojo,
Feifei Lian,
Justin Koeln,
Aditya Sood,
Stephanie M. Bohaichuk,
Christopher M. Neumann,
Sarah G. Garrow,
Andrew G. Alleyne,
Kenneth E. Goodson,
Eric Pop
Abstract:
Thermal management is an important challenge in modern electronics, avionics, automotive, and energy storage systems. While passive thermal solutions (like heat sinks or heat spreaders) are often used, actively modulating heat flow (e.g. via thermal switches or diodes) would offer additional degrees of control over the management of thermal transients and system reliability. Here we report the fir…
▽ More
Thermal management is an important challenge in modern electronics, avionics, automotive, and energy storage systems. While passive thermal solutions (like heat sinks or heat spreaders) are often used, actively modulating heat flow (e.g. via thermal switches or diodes) would offer additional degrees of control over the management of thermal transients and system reliability. Here we report the first thermal switch based on a flexible, collapsible graphene membrane, with low operating voltage, < 2 V. We also employ active-mode scanning thermal microscopy (SThM) to measure the device behavior and switching in real time. A compact analytical thermal model is developed for the general case of a thermal switch based on a double-clamped suspended membrane, highlighting the thermal and electrical design challenges. System-level modeling demonstrates the thermal trade-offs between modulating temperature swing and average temperature as a function of switching ratio. These graphene-based thermal switches present new opportunities for active control of fast (even nanosecond) thermal transients in densely integrated systems.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Set operations and order reductions for constrained zonotopes
Authors:
Vignesh Raghuraman,
Justin P. Koeln
Abstract:
This paper presents methods for using zonotopes and constrained zonotopes to improve the practicality of a wide variety of set-based operations commonly used in control theory. The proposed methods extend the use of constrained zonotopes to represent sets resulting from operations including halfspace intersections, convex hulls, robust positively invariant sets, and Pontryagin differences. Order r…
▽ More
This paper presents methods for using zonotopes and constrained zonotopes to improve the practicality of a wide variety of set-based operations commonly used in control theory. The proposed methods extend the use of constrained zonotopes to represent sets resulting from operations including halfspace intersections, convex hulls, robust positively invariant sets, and Pontryagin differences. Order reduction techniques are also presented that provide lower-complexity inner-approximations of zonotopes and constrained zonotopes. Numerical examples are used to demonstrate the efficacy and computational advantages of using zonotope-based set representations for dynamic system analysis and control.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
