-
Contemporary Philosophical Perspectives on the Cosmological Constant
Authors:
Adam Koberinski,
Bridget Falck,
Chris Smeenk
Abstract:
The (re)introduction of $Λ$ into cosmology has spurred debates that touch on central questions in philosophy of science, as well as the foundations of general relativity and particle physics. We provide a systematic assessment of the often implicit philosophical assumptions guiding the methodology of precision cosmology in relation to dark energy. We start by briefly introducing a recent account o…
▽ More
The (re)introduction of $Λ$ into cosmology has spurred debates that touch on central questions in philosophy of science, as well as the foundations of general relativity and particle physics. We provide a systematic assessment of the often implicit philosophical assumptions guiding the methodology of precision cosmology in relation to dark energy. We start by briefly introducing a recent account of scientific progress in terms of risky and constrained lines of inquiry. This allows us to contrast aspects of $Λ$ that make it relevantly different from other theoretical entities in science, such as its remoteness from direct observation or manipulability. We lay out a classification for possible ways to explain apparent accelerated expansion but conclude that these conceptually clear distinctions may blur heavily in practice. Finally, we consider the important role played in cosmology by critical tests of background assumptions, approximation techniques, and core principles, arguing that the weak anthropic principle fits into this category. We argue that some core typicality assumptions -- like the Copernican principle and the cosmological principle -- are necessary though not provable, while others -- like the strong anthropic principle and appeals to naturalness or probability in the multiverse -- are not similarly justifiable.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2023; v1 submitted 8 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Regularizing (away) vacuum energy
Authors:
Adam Koberinski
Abstract:
In this paper I formulate Minimal Requirements for Candidate Predictions in quantum field theories, inspired by viewing the standard model as an effective field theory. I then survey standard effective field theory regularization procedures, to see if the vacuum expectation value of energy density ($\langleρ\rangle$) is a quantity that meets these requirements. The verdict is negative, leading to…
▽ More
In this paper I formulate Minimal Requirements for Candidate Predictions in quantum field theories, inspired by viewing the standard model as an effective field theory. I then survey standard effective field theory regularization procedures, to see if the vacuum expectation value of energy density ($\langleρ\rangle$) is a quantity that meets these requirements. The verdict is negative, leading to the conclusion that $\langleρ\rangle$ is not a physically significant quantity in the standard model. Rigorous extensions of flat space quantum field theory eliminate $\langleρ\rangle$ from their conceptual framework, indicating that it lacks physical significance in the framework of quantum field theory more broadly. This result has consequences for problems in cosmology and quantum gravity, as it suggests that the correct solution to the cosmological constant problem involves a revision of the vacuum concept within quantum field theory.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Quantum theory as a principle theory: insights from an information-theoretic reconstruction
Authors:
Adam Koberinski,
Markus P. Mueller
Abstract:
We give a condensed and accessible summary of a recent derivation of quantum theory from information-theoretic principles, and use it to study the consequences of this and other reconstructions for our conceptual understanding of the quantum world. Since these principles are to a large extent expressed in computational terminology, we argue that the hypothesis of "physics as computation", if suita…
▽ More
We give a condensed and accessible summary of a recent derivation of quantum theory from information-theoretic principles, and use it to study the consequences of this and other reconstructions for our conceptual understanding of the quantum world. Since these principles are to a large extent expressed in computational terminology, we argue that the hypothesis of "physics as computation", if suitably interpreted, attains surprising explanatory power. Similarly as Jeffrey Bub and others, we conclude that quantum theory should be understood as a "principle theory of information", and we regard this view as a partial interpretation of quantum theory. We outline three options for completion into a full-fledged interpretation of quantum theory, but argue that, despite their interpretational agnosticism, the principled reconstructions pose a challenge for existing psi-ontic interpretations. We also argue that continuous reversible time evolution can be understood as a characteristic property of quantum theory, offering a possible answer to Chris Fuchs' search for a "glimpse of quantum reality".
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
