-
Relative yield of thermal and nonthermal emission during weak flares observed by STIX during September 20-25, 2021
Authors:
Arun Kumar Awasthi,
Tomasz Mrozek,
Sylwester Kołomański,
Michalina Litwicka,
Marek Stęślicki,
Karol Kułaga
Abstract:
The disparate nature of thermal-nonthermal energy partition during flares, particularly during weak flares, is still an open issue. Following the Neupert effect, quantifying the relative yield of X-ray emission in different energy bands can enable inferring the underlying energy release mechanism. During September 20-25, 2021, the Solar Orbiter mission - being closer to the Sun ($\sim$0.6 AU) and…
▽ More
The disparate nature of thermal-nonthermal energy partition during flares, particularly during weak flares, is still an open issue. Following the Neupert effect, quantifying the relative yield of X-ray emission in different energy bands can enable inferring the underlying energy release mechanism. During September 20-25, 2021, the Solar Orbiter mission - being closer to the Sun ($\sim$0.6 AU) and having a moderate separation angle (<40$^{\circ}$) from the Sun-Earth line provided a unique opportunity to analyze multi-wavelength emission from $\sim$200 (mostly weak) flares, commonly observed by the Spectrometer Telescope for Imaging X-rays (STIX), STEREO-A, GOES, and SDO observatories. Associating the quotient (q$_{f}$) of hard X-ray fluence (12-20 keV) and soft X-ray flux (4-10 keV) with the peak SXR flux enabled us to identify strongly non-thermal flares. Multi-wavelength investigation of spectral and imaging mode observations of the 20 strongly non-thermal weak flares reveals an inverse relationship of q$_{f}$ with the emission measure (EM) (and density), and a positive relationship with the flare plasma temperature. This indicates that plasma in tenuous loops attains higher temperatures compared to that in the denser loops, in response to nonthermal energy deposition. This is in agreement with the plasma parameters of the coronal loops, as derived by applying the one-dimensional Palermo Harvard (PH) hydrodynamical code to the coronal loop plasma having different initial coronal loop base pressures when subjected to similar heating input. Our investigation, therefore, indicates that the plasma parameters of the flaring loop in the initial phase have a decisive role in thermal-nonthermal energy partitioning.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Plasma dynamics in the flaring loop observed by RHESSI
Authors:
T. Mrozek,
R. Falewicz,
S. Kolomanski,
M. Litwicka
Abstract:
The thick-target model predicts that in flare foot points, we should observe lowering of HXR sources' altitude with increasing energy. The foot point of HXR sources result from the direct interaction of non-thermal electron beams with plasma in the lower part of the solar atmosphere, where the density increases rapidly. Therefore, we can estimate the plasma density distribution along the non-therm…
▽ More
The thick-target model predicts that in flare foot points, we should observe lowering of HXR sources' altitude with increasing energy. The foot point of HXR sources result from the direct interaction of non-thermal electron beams with plasma in the lower part of the solar atmosphere, where the density increases rapidly. Therefore, we can estimate the plasma density distribution along the non-thermal electron beam directly from the observations of the altitude-energy relation obtained for the HXR foot point sources. The relation's shape is density-dependent and is also determined by the power-law distribution of non-thermal electrons. Additionally, during the impulsive phase these parameters may change dramatically. Thus, the interpretation of observed HXR foot point sources' altitudes is not straightforward and needs detailed numerical modelling of the electron precipitation process. The numerical model was calculated using the hydrodynamic 1D model with an application of the Fokker-Planck formalism for non-thermal beam precipitation. HXR data from RHESSI were used to trace chromospheric density changes during a non-thermal emission burst, in detail. We have found that the amount of mass that evaporated from the chromosphere is in good agreement with the ranges obtained from hydrodynamical modelling of a flaring loop, and from an analysis of observed emission measure in the loop top, and with specific scaling laws. Consistency between the obtained values shows that HXR images may provide an important constraint for models - a mass of plasma that evaporated due to a non-thermal electron beam depositing energy in the chromosphere. High-energy, non-thermal sources' (above 20 keV in this case) positions fit the column density changes obtained from the hydrodynamical model perfectly. Density changes seem to be less affected by the electrons' spectral index.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Fine structure and long duration of a flare coronal X-ray source with RHESSI and SDO/AIA data
Authors:
Sylwester Kolomanski,
Tomasz Mrozek,
Ewa Chmielewska
Abstract:
Coronal X-ray sources (CXSs) are phenomenon very often occurring in solar flares regardless of a flare size, duration or power. The nature of the sources was difficult to uncover for many years. It seems that at last, combining data from RHESSI and SDO/AIA, there is a unprecedented possibility to 'look inside' CXSs and to answer the questions about their formation, evolution and structure. We pres…
▽ More
Coronal X-ray sources (CXSs) are phenomenon very often occurring in solar flares regardless of a flare size, duration or power. The nature of the sources was difficult to uncover for many years. It seems that at last, combining data from RHESSI and SDO/AIA, there is a unprecedented possibility to 'look inside' CXSs and to answer the questions about their formation, evolution and structure. We present a study of a CXS of the SOL2011-10-22T11:10 long-duration flare observed simultaneously with RHESSI and SDO/AIA. We focus our attention on the following questions: What was responsible for the CXS presence and long duration? Was there any fine structure in the CXS? Available data enables us to study a relation between the CXS and structures observed in EUV during the decay phase of the flare. X-ray emission recorded by RHESSI during the decay phase of the flare came from about 10 MK hot CXS. The source was observable for 5 hours. This long presence of the source could be supported by magnetic reconnection ongoing during the decay phase. Supra-arcade downflows, which are considered to be a manifestation of magnetic reconnection, were observed at the same time as the CXS. The source was co-spatial with the part of the hot supra-arcade region that had the highest emission measure and simultaneously the temperature within the range of RHESSI thermal-response. However, while the supra-arcade region was a dynamic region consisting of small-scale structures, the CXS seemed to be smooth, structureless. We run simulations using real and synthetic RHESSI data, but we did not find any strong evidence that the CXS had any small-scale structure.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Coronal Mass Ejections Associated with Slow Long Duration Flares
Authors:
U. Bak-Steslicka,
S. Kolomanski,
T. Mrozek
Abstract:
It is well known that there is temporal relationship between coronal mass ejections (CMEs) and associated flares. The duration of the acceleration phase is related to the duration of the rise phase of a flare. We investigate CMEs associated with slow long duration events (LDEs), i.e. flares with the long rising phase. We determined the relationships between flares and CMEs and analyzed the CME kin…
▽ More
It is well known that there is temporal relationship between coronal mass ejections (CMEs) and associated flares. The duration of the acceleration phase is related to the duration of the rise phase of a flare. We investigate CMEs associated with slow long duration events (LDEs), i.e. flares with the long rising phase. We determined the relationships between flares and CMEs and analyzed the CME kinematics in detail. The parameters of the flares (GOES flux, duration of the rising phase) show strong correlations with the CME parameters (velocity, acceleration during main acceleration phase and duration of the CME acceleration phase). These correlations confirm the strong relation between slow LDEs and CMEs. We also analyzed the relation between the parameters of the CMEs, i.e. a velocity, an acceleration during the main acceleration phase, a duration of the acceleration phase, and a height of a CME at the end of the acceleration phase. The CMEs associated with the slow LDEs are characterized by high velocity during the propagation phase, with the median equal 1423 km/s. In half of the analyzed cases, the main acceleration was low (a<300 m/s^2), which suggests that the high velocity is caused by the prolongated acceleration phase (the median for the duration of the acceleration phase is equal 90 minutes). The CMEs were accelerated up to several solar radii (with the median 7 Rsun), which is much higher than in typical impulsive CMEs. Therefore, slow LDEs may potentially precede extremely strong geomagnetic storms. The analysis of slow LDEs and associated CMEs may give important information for develo** more accurate space weather forecasts, especially for extreme events.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2013;
originally announced February 2013.
-
EUV and HXR Signatures of Electron Acceleration During the Failed Eruption of a Filament
Authors:
A. Netzel,
T. Mrozek,
S. Kolomanski,
S. Gburek
Abstract:
We search for EUV brightenings in TRACE 171 Å images and HXR bursts observed during failed eruptions. We expect that if an eruption is confined due to interaction with overlying magnetic structures then we should observe effects connected with reconnection between magnetic structures and acceleration of particles. We utilized TRACE observations of three well observed failed eruptions. EUV images w…
▽ More
We search for EUV brightenings in TRACE 171 Å images and HXR bursts observed during failed eruptions. We expect that if an eruption is confined due to interaction with overlying magnetic structures then we should observe effects connected with reconnection between magnetic structures and acceleration of particles. We utilized TRACE observations of three well observed failed eruptions. EUV images were compared to HXR spatial distribution reconstructed from Yohkoh/HXT and RHESSI data. The EUV light curves of a selected area were compared to height profiles of eruption, HXR emission and HXR photon spectral index of power-law fit to HXR data. We have found that EUV brightenings are closely related to the eruption velocity decrease, to HXR bursts and to episodes of hardening of HXR spectra. The EUV brightened areas are observed far from the flaring structure, in footpoints of large systems of loops observed 30-60 minutes after the maximum of a flare. These are not `post-flare' loops that are also observed but at significantly lower heights. The high lying systems of loops are observed at heights equal to height, at which eruption was observed to stop. We observed HXR source spatially correlated with EUV brightening only once. For other EUV brightened areas we estimated the expected brightness of HXR sources. We find that EUV brightenings are produced due to interaction between the erupting structure with overlying loops. The interaction is strong enough to heat the system of high loops. These loops cool down and are visible in EUV range about 30-60 minutes later. The estimated brightness of HXR sources associated with EUV brightenings shows that they are too weak to be detected with present instruments. However, next generation instruments will have enough dynamic range and sensitivity to enable such observations.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2012; v1 submitted 1 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
RHESSI Investigation of X-ray Coronal Sources During Decay Phase of Solar Flares: II. Energy Balance
Authors:
Sylwester Kolomanski,
Zbigniew Koltun,
Tomasz Mrozek,
Urszula Bak-Steslicka
Abstract:
As it was shown by many authors, a slow decrease in X-rays observed during the decay phase of long duration flares (LDE) can be explained only by a magnetic reconnection and energy release ceaselessly ongoing in the coronal part of a flare. Using RHESSI data we try to answer two following questions. How effective are these processes at the LDEs decay phase and how can precisely the energy release…
▽ More
As it was shown by many authors, a slow decrease in X-rays observed during the decay phase of long duration flares (LDE) can be explained only by a magnetic reconnection and energy release ceaselessly ongoing in the coronal part of a flare. Using RHESSI data we try to answer two following questions. How effective are these processes at the LDEs decay phase and how can precisely the energy release rate be calculated based on these data? To answer the questions images of the selected LDEs during their decay phase were reconstructed. Physical parameters of flare coronal sources obtained from image spectral analysis allowed us to study the efficiency of the energy release process. We also examined terms included in the energy equation to find out what is the accuracy of determination of each term.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
RHESSI Observations of Long-Duration Flares With Long-Lasting X-ray Loop-Top Sources
Authors:
Sylwester Kolomanski,
Tomasz Mrozek,
Urszula Bak-Steslicka
Abstract:
Context: The Yohkoh/HXT observations of Long Duration Events (LDEs) showed that the HXR emission (14-23 keV) is present for tens of minutes after flare maximum. Hence, some heating process is expected to exist during that time. The better energy resolution of RHESSI compared to HXT allow us to analyse LDEs in more comprehensive way.
Aims: We selected three LDEs observed by RHESSI to answer the q…
▽ More
Context: The Yohkoh/HXT observations of Long Duration Events (LDEs) showed that the HXR emission (14-23 keV) is present for tens of minutes after flare maximum. Hence, some heating process is expected to exist during that time. The better energy resolution of RHESSI compared to HXT allow us to analyse LDEs in more comprehensive way.
Aims: We selected three LDEs observed by RHESSI to answer the questions how long HXR emission can be present, where it is emitted, what is its nature and how much energy should be released to sustain the emission.
Methods: We used RHESSI data to reconstruct images of the selected flares with an energy resolution as good as 1 keV. Next we estimated physical parameters of HXR sources through imaging spectroscopy. The physical parameters obtained were then used to calculate the energy balance of the observed sources.
Results: We found that HXR thermal emission can be present for many hours after LDE flare maximum. The emission comes from large and hot loop-top sources. The total energy that must be released to sustain the emission of the sources is as high as 10^31 erg.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
RHESSI Investigation of X-Ray Coronal Sources During Decay Phase of Solar Flares: I. Observations
Authors:
Tomasz Mrozek,
Zbigniew Koltun,
Sylwester Kolomanski,
Urszula Bak-Steslicka
Abstract:
We analyse the observational characteristics for a set of Long Duration Events (LDE) using Reuven Ramaty High Energy Solar Spectroscopic Imager (RHESSI). Excellent energy resolution (1 keV) of HXR images reconstructed with RHESSI allowed us to perform imaging spectroscopy of coronal loop top sources (LTS) observed for hours after maximum of the flare. We found that the sources are large structures…
▽ More
We analyse the observational characteristics for a set of Long Duration Events (LDE) using Reuven Ramaty High Energy Solar Spectroscopic Imager (RHESSI). Excellent energy resolution (1 keV) of HXR images reconstructed with RHESSI allowed us to perform imaging spectroscopy of coronal loop top sources (LTS) observed for hours after maximum of the flare. We found that the sources are large structures. The diameter of an LTS is changing with time and energy. High temperature component can be observed for few dozen hours after the maximum. For some time intervals clear non-thermal component was observed in spectra, but there was no significant footpoint emission at that time. All thermal and non-thermal emissions originate from the LTS. The obtained observational characteristics were used in calculating the energy balance within LTS, which are presented in Kolomanski, 2011 (this issue).
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
Coronal mass ejections associated with LDE flares of slow rise phase
Authors:
Urszula Bak-Steslicka,
Sylwester Kolomanski,
Tomasz Mrozek
Abstract:
It is well known, that there is temporal relationship between CMEs and associated flares. The duration of the acceleration phase is related to the duration of the rise phase of a flare. We investigated CMEs associated with long duration flares of slow rise phase (slow LDE). These CMEs are characterized by high velocity (v>1000 km/s) during the propagation phase and low average acceleration during…
▽ More
It is well known, that there is temporal relationship between CMEs and associated flares. The duration of the acceleration phase is related to the duration of the rise phase of a flare. We investigated CMEs associated with long duration flares of slow rise phase (slow LDE). These CMEs are characterized by high velocity (v>1000 km/s) during the propagation phase and low average acceleration during the main, prolongated, acceleration phase. The CMEs are accelerated until the height $> 5 R_\odot$, which is higher value than in typical impulsive CMEs. CMEs associated with slow LDEs have characteristics of both classes of CMEs, i.e. CMEs associated with flares and CMEs associated with eruptive prominences.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
Energy Release During Slow Long Duration Flares Observed by RHESSI
Authors:
Urszula Bak-Steslicka,
Tomasz Mrozek,
Sylwester Kolomanski
Abstract:
Slow Long Duration Events (SLDEs) are flares characterized by long duration of rising phase. In many such cases impulsive phase is weak with lack of typical short-lasting pulses. Instead of that smooth, long-lasting Hard X-ray (HXR) emission is observed. We analysed hard X-ray emission and morphology of six selected SLDEs. In our analysis we utilized data from RHESSI and GOES satellites. Physical…
▽ More
Slow Long Duration Events (SLDEs) are flares characterized by long duration of rising phase. In many such cases impulsive phase is weak with lack of typical short-lasting pulses. Instead of that smooth, long-lasting Hard X-ray (HXR) emission is observed. We analysed hard X-ray emission and morphology of six selected SLDEs. In our analysis we utilized data from RHESSI and GOES satellites. Physical parameters of HXR sources were obtained from imaging spectroscopy and were used for the energy balance analysis. Characteristic time of heating rate decrease, after reaching its maximum value, is very long, which explains long rising phase of these flares.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
Geometrical and Physical Properties of SXR Loop-Top Flare Kernels
Authors:
P. Preś,
S. Kołomański
Abstract:
We investigate how the geometrical and physical properties of soft X-ray flare kernels change with their altitude above the photosphere. We analyze limb flares well observed by {\em Yohkoh}/SXT showing clear geometry with well separated loop-top kernels. Our analysis concerns relations between kernel size, plasma pressure, energy release and the kernel altitude. We define scaling laws describing…
▽ More
We investigate how the geometrical and physical properties of soft X-ray flare kernels change with their altitude above the photosphere. We analyze limb flares well observed by {\em Yohkoh}/SXT showing clear geometry with well separated loop-top kernels. Our analysis concerns relations between kernel size, plasma pressure, energy release and the kernel altitude. We define scaling laws describing how the sizes and its physical properties of kernels vary with the altitude above the photosphere. We interpret the observed relations in terms of the general magnetic structure of active regions.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2007;
originally announced July 2007.
