-
Dense Particle Clouds in Laboratory Experiments in Context of Drafting and Streaming Instability
Authors:
Niclas Schneider,
Gerhard Wurm,
Jens Teiser,
Hubert Klahr,
Vincent Carpenter
Abstract:
The streaming instability, as an example of instabilities driven by particle feedback on a gas flow, has been proven to have a major role in controlling the formation of planetesimals. Here, we present experiments to approach this situation in the laboratory for particles in the Knudsen flow regime. In these experiments, we observe a particle cloud trapped for about 30 s in a rotating system under…
▽ More
The streaming instability, as an example of instabilities driven by particle feedback on a gas flow, has been proven to have a major role in controlling the formation of planetesimals. Here, we present experiments to approach this situation in the laboratory for particles in the Knudsen flow regime. In these experiments, we observe a particle cloud trapped for about 30 s in a rotating system under Earth's gravity. For average dust-to-gas ratios up to 0.08, particles behave like individual test particles. Their sedimentation speed is identical to that of a single free-falling particle, even in locally denser regions. However, for higher dust-to-gas ratios, the motion of particles becomes sensitive to clum**. Particles in locally denser regions now sediment faster. Their sedimentation speed then depends linearly on the overall dust-to-gas ratio. This clearly shows a transition from tracerlike behavior to collective behavior. Beyond these findings, these types of experiments can now be used as a gauge to test the particle feedback models in astrophysical hydrocodes which are currently used for numerical simulations of streaming instabilities.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Pebble trap** backreaction does not destroy vortices
Authors:
Wladimir Lyra,
Natalie Raettig,
Hubert Klahr
Abstract:
The formation of planets remains one of the most challenging problems of contemporary astrophysics. Starting with micron-sized dust grains, coagulation models predict growth up to centimeter (pebbles), but growth beyond this size is difficult because of fragmentation and drift. Ways to bypass this problem have focused on inhomogeneities in the flow, be that zonal flows, streaming instability, or v…
▽ More
The formation of planets remains one of the most challenging problems of contemporary astrophysics. Starting with micron-sized dust grains, coagulation models predict growth up to centimeter (pebbles), but growth beyond this size is difficult because of fragmentation and drift. Ways to bypass this problem have focused on inhomogeneities in the flow, be that zonal flows, streaming instability, or vortices. Because vortices are in equilibrium between the Coriolis and the pressure force, the pressureless grains will orbit along a vortex streamline experiencing a drag force. This is a very effective mechanism to concentrate pebbles as also seen in numerical simulations and possibly in ALMA observations. Yet, a high pebble load is dangerous for the vortex, and we showed that in two-dimensional simulations the backreaction eventually leads to vortex disruption. We investigate whether the same happens in three dimensions. We perform 3D simulations with pebbles in a local box finding that, although the pebbles disturb the vortex around the midplane, the column does not get destroyed. This result is important because, based on the previous 2D result suggesting complete disruption, the vortex interpretation of ALMA observations has been called into question. We show instead that the vortex behaves like a Taylor column, and the pebbles as obstacles to the flow. Pebble accumulation in the center of the vortices proceeds to roughly the same concentration as in the control run without backreaction.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Map** the Conditions for Hydrodynamic Instability on Steady State Accretion Models of Protoplanetary Disks
Authors:
Thomas Pfeil,
Hubert Klahr
Abstract:
Hydrodynamical instabilities in disks around young stars depend on the thermodynamic stratification of the disk and on the local rate of thermal relaxation. Here, we map the spatial extent of unstable regions for the Vertical Shear Instability (VSI), the Convective OverStability (COS), and the amplification of vortices via the Subcritical Baroclinic Instability (SBI). We use steady state accretion…
▽ More
Hydrodynamical instabilities in disks around young stars depend on the thermodynamic stratification of the disk and on the local rate of thermal relaxation. Here, we map the spatial extent of unstable regions for the Vertical Shear Instability (VSI), the Convective OverStability (COS), and the amplification of vortices via the Subcritical Baroclinic Instability (SBI). We use steady state accretion disk models, including stellar irradiation, accretion heating and radiative transfer. We determine the local radial and vertical stratification and thermal relaxation rate in the disk, in dependence of the stellar mass, disk mass and mass accretion rate. We find that passive regions of disks - i.e. the midplane temperature dominated by irradiation - are COS unstable about one pressure scale height above the midplane and VSI unstable at radii $> 10 \, \text{au}$. Vortex amplification via SBI should operate in most parts of active and passive disks. For active parts of disks (midplane temperature determined by accretion power) COS can become active down to the midplane. Same is true for the VSI because of the vertically adiabatic stratification of an internally heated disk. If hydro instabilities or other non-ideal MHD processes are able to create $α$-stresses ($> 10^{-5}$) and released accretion energy leads to internal heating of the disk, hydrodynamical instabilities are likely to operate in significant parts of the planet forming zones in disks around young stars, driving gas accretion and flow structure formation. Thus hydro-instabilities are viable candidates to explain the rings and vortices observed with ALMA and VLT.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2019; v1 submitted 30 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Vortex Formation and Survival in Protoplanetary Disks subject to Vertical Shear Instability
Authors:
Natascha Manger,
Hubert Klahr
Abstract:
Several protoplanetary disks observed by ALMA show dust concentrations consistent with particle trap** in giant vortices. The formation and survival of vortices is of major importance for planet formation, because vortices act as particle traps and are therefore preferred locations of planetesimal formation. Recent studies showed that the vertical shear instability (VSI) is capable of generating…
▽ More
Several protoplanetary disks observed by ALMA show dust concentrations consistent with particle trap** in giant vortices. The formation and survival of vortices is of major importance for planet formation, because vortices act as particle traps and are therefore preferred locations of planetesimal formation. Recent studies showed that the vertical shear instability (VSI) is capable of generating turbulence and small vortices in protoplanetary disks that have the proper radial and vertical stratification and thermally relax on sufficiently short time scales. But the effect of the azimuthal extend of the disk is often neglected as the disks azimuth is limited to $Δφ\leq π/2$. We aim to investigate the influence of the azimuthal extent of the disk on the long-term evolution of a protoplanetary disk and the possibility of large vortices forming. To this end, we perform 3-dimensional simulations for up to 1000 local orbits using different values of $Δφ= π/2 $ to $2π$ for VSI in disks with a prescribed radial density and temperature gradient cooling on short timescales. We find the VSI capable of forming large vortices which can exist at least several hundred orbits in simulations covering a disk with $Δφ\geq π$. This suggests the VSI to be capable to form vortices or at least to trigger vortex formation via a secondary instability, e.g. Rossby Wave Instability or Kelvin Helmholtz Instability.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
The GJ 504 system revisited. Combining interferometric, radial velocity, and high contrast imaging data
Authors:
M. Bonnefoy,
K. Perraut,
A. -M. Lagrange,
P. Delorme,
A. Vigan,
M. Line,
L. Rodet,
C. Ginski,
D. Mourard,
G. -D. Marleau,
M. Samland,
P. Tremblin,
R. Ligi,
F. Cantalloube,
P. Mollière,
B. Charnay,
M. Kuzuhara,
M. Janson,
C. Morley,
D. D. Homeier,
V. D Orazi,
H. Klahr,
C. Mordasini,
B. Lavie,
J. -L. Baudino
, et al. (57 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The G-type star GJ504A is known to host a 3 to 35 MJup companion whose temperature, mass, and projected separation all contribute to make it a test case for the planet formation theories and for atmospheric models of giant planets and light brown dwarfs. We collected data from the CHARA interferometer, SOPHIE spectrograph, and VLT/SPHERE high contrast imager to revisit the properties of the system…
▽ More
The G-type star GJ504A is known to host a 3 to 35 MJup companion whose temperature, mass, and projected separation all contribute to make it a test case for the planet formation theories and for atmospheric models of giant planets and light brown dwarfs. We collected data from the CHARA interferometer, SOPHIE spectrograph, and VLT/SPHERE high contrast imager to revisit the properties of the system. We measure a radius of 1.35+/- 0.04Rsun for GJ504A which yields isochronal ages of 21+/-2Myr or 4.0+/-1.8Gyr for the system and line-of-sight stellar rotation axis inclination of $162.4_{-4.3}^{+3.8}$ degrees or $18.6_{-3.8}^{+4.3}$ degrees. We re-detect the companion in the Y2, Y3, J3, H2, and K1 dual band SPHERE images. The complete 1-4 $μ$m SED shape of GJ504b is best reproduced by T8-T9.5 objects with intermediate ages ($\leq1.5$Gyr), and/or unusual dusty atmospheres and/or super-solar metallicities. All six atmospheric models used yield $\mathrm{T_{eff}=550 \pm 50}$K for GJ504b and point toward a low surface gravity (3.5-4.0 dex). The accuracy on the metallicity value is limited by model-to-model systematics. It is not degenerate with the C/O ratio. We derive $\mathrm{log\:L/L_{\odot}=-6.15\pm0.15}$ dex for the companion compatible with masses of $\mathrm{M=1.3^{+0.6}_{-0.3}M_{Jup}}$ and $\mathrm{M=23^{+10}_{-9} M_{Jup}}$ for the young and old age ranges, respectively. The semi-major axis (sma) is above 27.8 au and the eccentricity lower than 0.55. The posterior on GJ~504b's orbital inclination suggests a misalignment with GJ~504A rotation axis. We combine the radial velocity and multi-epoch imaging data to exclude additional objects (90\% prob.) more massive than 2.5 and 30 $\mathrm{M_{Jup}}$ with sma in the range 0.01-80 au for the young and old system ages, respectively. The companion is in the envelope of the population of planets synthetized with our core-accretion model.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2018; v1 submitted 2 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Instabilities and Flow Structures in Protoplanetary Disks: Setting the Stage for Planetesimal Formation
Authors:
Hubert Klahr,
Thomas Pfeil,
Andreas Schreiber
Abstract:
This chapter highlights the properties of turbulence and meso-scale flow structures in protoplanetary disks and their role in the planet formation process. Here we focus on the formation of planetesimals from a gravitational collapse of a pebble cloud. Large scale and long lived flow structures - vortices and zonal flows - are a consequence of weak magneto and hydrodynamic instabilities in the pre…
▽ More
This chapter highlights the properties of turbulence and meso-scale flow structures in protoplanetary disks and their role in the planet formation process. Here we focus on the formation of planetesimals from a gravitational collapse of a pebble cloud. Large scale and long lived flow structures - vortices and zonal flows - are a consequence of weak magneto and hydrodynamic instabilities in the pressure and entropy stratified quasi-Keplerian shear flow interacting with the fast rotation of the disk. The vortices and zonal flows on the other hand are particle traps tap** into the radial pebble flux of the disk, leading to locally sufficient accumulations to trigger gravitational collapse, directly converting pebbles to many kilometer sized planetesimals. This collapse is moderated by the streaming instability, which is a back-reaction from the particle accumulations onto the gas flow. Without trap** pebbles and increasing thus the local solid to gas ratio, this back-reaction would ultimately prevent the formation of planetsimals via turbulent diffusion. The formation of long lived flow structures is therefore a necessary condition for an efficient and fast formation of planetesimals.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2018; v1 submitted 11 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Azimuthal and Vertical Streaming Instability at High Dust-to-gas Ratios and on the Scales of Planetesimal Formation
Authors:
Andreas Schreiber,
Hubert Klahr
Abstract:
The collapse of dust particle clouds directly to km-sized planetesimals is a promising way to explain the formation of planetesimals, asteroids and comets. In the past, this collapse has been studied in stratified shearing box simulations with super-solar dust-to-gas ratio ε, allowing for streaming instability (SI) and gravitational collapse. This paper studies the non-stratified SI under dust-to-…
▽ More
The collapse of dust particle clouds directly to km-sized planetesimals is a promising way to explain the formation of planetesimals, asteroids and comets. In the past, this collapse has been studied in stratified shearing box simulations with super-solar dust-to-gas ratio ε, allowing for streaming instability (SI) and gravitational collapse. This paper studies the non-stratified SI under dust-to-gas ratios from ε=0.1 up to ε=1000 without self-gravity. The study covers domain sizes of L=0.1 H, 0.01 H and 0.001 H, in terms of gas disk scale height H, using the PencilCode. They are performed in radial-azimuthal (2-d) and radial-vertical (2.5-d) extent. The used particles of St=0.01 and 0.1 mark the upper end of the expected dust growth. SI-activity is found up to very high dust-to-gas ratios, providing fluctuations in the local dust-to-gas ratios and turbulent particle diffusion δ. We find an SI-like instability that operates in r-\varphi even when vertical modes are suppressed. This new azimuthal streaming instability (aSI) shows similar properties and appearance as the SI. Both, SI and aSI, show diffusivity at ε=100 only to be two orders of magnitude lower than at ε=1, suggesting a δ~ ε^{-1} relation that is shallow around ε= 1. The (a)SI ability to concentrate particles is found to be uncorrelated with its strength in particle turbulence. Finally, we performed a resolution study to test our findings of the aSI. This paper stresses out the importance of properly resolving the (a)SI at high dust-to-gas ratios and planetesimal collapse simulations, leading else wise to potentially incomplete results.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
VLT/SPHERE astrometric confirmation and orbital analysis of the brown dwarf companion HR 2562 B
Authors:
A. -L. Maire,
L. Rodet,
C. Lazzoni,
A. Boccaletti,
W. Brandner,
R. Galicher,
F. Cantalloube,
D. Mesa,
H. Klahr,
H. Beust,
G. Chauvin,
S. Desidera,
M. Janson,
M. Keppler,
J. Olofsson,
J. -C. Augereau,
S. Daemgen,
T. Henning,
P. Thébault,
M. Bonnefoy,
M. Feldt,
R. Gratton,
A. -M. Lagrange,
M. Langlois,
M. R. Meyer
, et al. (24 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Context. A low-mass brown dwarf has been recently imaged around HR 2562 (HD 50571), a star hosting a debris disk resolved in the far infrared. Interestingly, the companion location is compatible with an orbit coplanar with the disk and interior to the debris belt. This feature makes the system a valuable laboratory to analyze the formation of substellar companions in a circumstellar disk and poten…
▽ More
Context. A low-mass brown dwarf has been recently imaged around HR 2562 (HD 50571), a star hosting a debris disk resolved in the far infrared. Interestingly, the companion location is compatible with an orbit coplanar with the disk and interior to the debris belt. This feature makes the system a valuable laboratory to analyze the formation of substellar companions in a circumstellar disk and potential disk-companion dynamical interactions. Aims. We aim to further characterize the orbital motion of HR 2562 B and its interactions with the host star debris disk. Methods. We performed a monitoring of the system over ~10 months in 2016 and 2017 with the VLT/SPHERE exoplanet imager. Results. We confirm that the companion is comoving with the star and detect for the first time an orbital motion at high significance, with a current orbital motion projected in the plane of the sky of 25 mas (~0.85 au) per year. No orbital curvature is seen in the measurements. An orbital fit of the SPHERE and literature astrometry of the companion without priors on the orbital plane clearly indicates that its orbit is (quasi-)coplanar with the disk. To further constrain the other orbital parameters, we used empirical laws for a companion chaotic zone validated by N-body simulations to test the orbital solutions that are compatible with the estimated disk cavity size. Non-zero eccentricities (>0.15) are allowed for orbital periods shorter than 100 yr, while only moderate eccentricities up to ~0.3 for orbital periods longer than 200 yr are compatible with the disk observations. A comparison of synthetic Herschel images to the real data does not allow us to constrain the upper eccentricity of the companion.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2018; v1 submitted 12 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Discovery of a brown dwarf companion to the star HIP 64892
Authors:
A. Cheetham,
M. Bonnefoy,
S. Desidera,
M. Langlois,
A. Vigan,
T. Schmidt,
J. Olofsson,
G. Chauvin,
H. Klahr,
R. Gratton,
V. D'Orazi,
T. Henning,
M. Janson,
B. Biller,
S. Peretti,
J. Hagelberg,
D. Ségransan,
S. Udry,
D. Mesa,
E. Sissa,
Q. Kral,
J. Schlieder,
A. -L. Maire,
C. Mordasini,
F. Menard
, et al. (67 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We report the discovery of a bright, brown dwarf companion to the star HIP 64892, imaged with VLT/SPHERE during the SHINE exoplanet survey. The host is a B9.5V member of the Lower-Centaurus-Crux subgroup of the Scorpius Centaurus OB association. The measured angular separation of the companion ($1.2705\pm0.0023$") corresponds to a projected distance of $159\pm12$ AU. We observed the target with th…
▽ More
We report the discovery of a bright, brown dwarf companion to the star HIP 64892, imaged with VLT/SPHERE during the SHINE exoplanet survey. The host is a B9.5V member of the Lower-Centaurus-Crux subgroup of the Scorpius Centaurus OB association. The measured angular separation of the companion ($1.2705\pm0.0023$") corresponds to a projected distance of $159\pm12$ AU. We observed the target with the dual-band imaging and long-slit spectroscopy modes of the IRDIS imager to obtain its SED and astrometry. In addition, we reprocessed archival NACO L-band data, from which we also recover the companion. Its SED is consistent with a young (<30 Myr), low surface gravity object with a spectral type of M9$_γ\pm1$. From comparison with the BT-Settl atmospheric models we estimate an effective temperature of $T_{\textrm{eff}}=2600 \pm 100$ K, and comparison of the companion photometry to the COND evolutionary models yields a mass of $\sim29-37$ M$_{\text{J}}$ at the estimated age of $16^{+15}_{-7}$ Myr for the system. HIP 64892 is a rare example of an extreme-mass ratio system ($q\sim0.01$) and will be useful for testing models relating to the formation and evolution of such low-mass objects.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
First scattered light detection of a nearly edge-on transition disk around the T Tauri star RY Lup
Authors:
M. Langlois,
A. Pohl,
A. -M. Lagrange,
A. - L. Maire,
D. Mesa,
A. Boccaletti,
R. Gratton,
L. Denneulin,
H. Klahr,
A. Vigan,
M. Benisty,
C. Dominik,
M. Bonnefoy,
F. Menard,
H. Avenhaus,
A. Cheetham,
R. Van Boekel,
J. de Boer,
G. Chauvin,
S. Desidera,
M. Feldt,
R. Galicher,
C. Ginski,
J. Girard,
T. Henning
, et al. (19 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Transition disks are considered sites of ongoing planet formation, and their dust and gas distributions could be signposts of embedded planets. The transition disk around the T Tauri star RY Lup has an inner dust cavity and displays a strong silicate emission feature. Using high-resolution imaging we study the disk geometry, including non-axisymmetric features, and its surface dust grain, to gain…
▽ More
Transition disks are considered sites of ongoing planet formation, and their dust and gas distributions could be signposts of embedded planets. The transition disk around the T Tauri star RY Lup has an inner dust cavity and displays a strong silicate emission feature. Using high-resolution imaging we study the disk geometry, including non-axisymmetric features, and its surface dust grain, to gain a better understanding of the disk evolutionary process. Moreover, we search for companion candidates, possibly connected to the disk. We obtained high-contrast and high angular resolution data in the near-infrared with the VLT/SPHERE extreme adaptive optics instrument whose goal is to study the planet formation by detecting and characterizing these planets and their formation environments through direct imaging. We performed polarimetric imaging of the RY~Lup disk with IRDIS (at 1.6 microns), and obtained intensity images with the IRDIS dual-band imaging camera simultaneously with the IFS spectro-imager (0.9-1.3 microns). We resolved for the first time the scattered light from the nearly edge-on circumstellar disk around RY~Lup, at projected separations in the 100 \,au range. The shape of the disk and its sharp features are clearly detectable at wavelengths ranging from 0.9 to 1.6 microns. We show that the observed morphology can be interpreted as spiral arms in the disk. This interpretation is supported by in-depth numerical simulations. We also demonstrate that these features can be produced by one planet interacting with the disk. We also detect several point sources which are classified as probable background objects.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
The fragmentation criteria in local vertically stratified self-gravitating disk simulations
Authors:
Hans Baehr,
Hubert Klahr,
Kaitlin M. Kratter
Abstract:
Massive circumstellar disks are prone to gravitational instabilities, which trigger the formation of spiral arms that can fragment into bound clumps under the right conditions. Two dimensional simulations of self-gravitating disks are useful starting points for studying fragmentation, allowing for high-resolution simulations of thin disks. However, convergence issues can arise in 2D from various s…
▽ More
Massive circumstellar disks are prone to gravitational instabilities, which trigger the formation of spiral arms that can fragment into bound clumps under the right conditions. Two dimensional simulations of self-gravitating disks are useful starting points for studying fragmentation, allowing for high-resolution simulations of thin disks. However, convergence issues can arise in 2D from various sources. One of these sources is the 2D approximation of self-gravity, which exaggerates the effect of self-gravity on small scales when the potential is not smoothed to account for the assumed vertical extent of the disk. This effect is enhanced by increased resolution, resulting in fragmentation at longer cooling timescales $β$. If true, it suggests that the 3D simulations of disk fragmentation may not have the same convergence problem and could be used to examine the nature of fragmentation without smoothing self-gravity on scales similar to the disk scale height. To that end, we have carried out local 3D self-gravitating disk simulations with simple $β$ cooling with fixed background irradiation to determine if 3D is necessary to properly describe disk fragmentation. Above a resolution of $\sim 40$ grid cells per scale height, we find that our simulations converge with respect to the cooling timescale. This result converges in agreement with analytic expectations which place a fragmentation boundary at $β_\mathrm{crit} = 3$.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Efficiency of thermal relaxation by radiative processes in protoplanetary discs: constraints on hydrodynamic turbulence
Authors:
M. G. Malygin,
H. Klahr,
D. Semenov,
Th. Henning,
C. P. Dullemond
Abstract:
Hydrodynamic, non-magnetic instabilities can provide turbulent stress in the regions of protoplanetary discs, where the MRI can not develop. The induced motions influence the grain growth, from which formation of planetesimals begins. Thermal relaxation of the gas constrains origins of the identified hydrodynamic sources of turbulence in discs.
We estimate the radiative relaxation timescale of t…
▽ More
Hydrodynamic, non-magnetic instabilities can provide turbulent stress in the regions of protoplanetary discs, where the MRI can not develop. The induced motions influence the grain growth, from which formation of planetesimals begins. Thermal relaxation of the gas constrains origins of the identified hydrodynamic sources of turbulence in discs.
We estimate the radiative relaxation timescale of temperature perturbations and study the dependence of this timescale on the perturbation wavelength, the location within the disc, the disc mass, and the dust-to-gas mass ratio. We then apply thermal relaxation criteria to localise modes of the convective overstability, the vertical shear instability, and the zombie vortex instability.
Our calculations employed the latest tabulated dust and gas mean opacities and we account for the collisional coupling to the emitting species.
The relaxation criterion defines the bulk of a typical T Tauri disc as unstable to the development of linear hydrodynamic instabilities. The midplane is unstable to the convective overstability from at most $2\mbox{ au}$ and up to $40\mbox{ au}$, as well as beyond $140\mbox{ au}$. The vertical shear instability can develop between $15\mbox{ au}$ and $180\mbox{ au}$. The successive generation of (zombie) vortices from a seeded noise can work within the inner $0{.}8\mbox{ au}$.
Dynamic disc modelling with the evolution of dust and gas opacities is required to clearly localise the hydrodynamic turbulence, and especially its non-linear phase.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
The Planetary Accretion Shock: I. Framework for Radiation-hydrodynamical Simulations and First Results
Authors:
Gabriel-Dominique Marleau,
Hubert Klahr,
Rolf Kuiper,
Christoph Mordasini
Abstract:
The key aspect determining the post-formation luminosity of gas giants has long been considered to be the energetics of the accretion shock at the planetary surface. We use 1D radiation-hydrodynamical simulations to study the radiative loss efficiency and to obtain post-shock temperatures and pressures and thus entropies. The efficiency is defined as the fraction of the total incoming energy flux…
▽ More
The key aspect determining the post-formation luminosity of gas giants has long been considered to be the energetics of the accretion shock at the planetary surface. We use 1D radiation-hydrodynamical simulations to study the radiative loss efficiency and to obtain post-shock temperatures and pressures and thus entropies. The efficiency is defined as the fraction of the total incoming energy flux which escapes the system (roughly the Hill sphere), taking into account the energy recycling which occurs ahead of the shock in a radiative precursor. We focus here on a constant equation of state to isolate the shock physics but use constant and tabulated opacities. While robust quantitative results will require a self-consistent treatment including hydrogen dissocation and ionization, the results show the correct qualitative behavior and can be understood semi-analytically. The shock is found to be isothermal and supercritical for a range of conditions relevant to core accretion (CA), with Mach numbers greater than ca. 3. Across the shock, the entropy decreases significantly, by a few entropy units (k_B/baryon). While nearly 100 percent of the incoming kinetic energy is converted to radiation locally, the efficiencies are found to be as low as roughly 40 percent, implying that a meaningful fraction of the total accretion energy is brought into the planet. For realistic parameter combinations in the CA scenario, a non-zero fraction of the luminosity always escapes the system. This luminosity could explain, at least in part, recent observations in the LkCa 15 and HD 100546 systems.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Gaps, rings, and non-axisymmetric structures in protoplanetary disks - Emission from large grains
Authors:
J. P. Ruge,
M. Flock,
S. Wolf,
N. Dzyurkevich,
S. Fromang,
Th. Henning,
H. Klahr,
H. Meheut
Abstract:
Dust grains with sizes around (sub)mm are expected to couple only weakly to the gas motion in regions beyond 10 au of circumstellar disks. In this work, we investigate the influence of the spatial distribution of such grains on the (sub)mm appearance of magnetized protoplanetary disks. We perform non-ideal global 3D magneto-hydrodynamic stratified disk simulations including particles of different…
▽ More
Dust grains with sizes around (sub)mm are expected to couple only weakly to the gas motion in regions beyond 10 au of circumstellar disks. In this work, we investigate the influence of the spatial distribution of such grains on the (sub)mm appearance of magnetized protoplanetary disks. We perform non-ideal global 3D magneto-hydrodynamic stratified disk simulations including particles of different sizes (50 micron to 1 cm), using a Lagrangian particle solver. We calculate the spatial dust temperature distribution, including the dynamically coupled submicron-sized dust grains, and derive ideal continuum re-emission maps of the disk through radiative transfer simulations. Finally, we investigate the feasibility to observe specific structures in the thermal re-emission maps with the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA). The pressure bump close to the outer edge of the dead-zone leads to particle trap** in ring structures. More specifically, vortices in the disk concentrate the dust and create an inhomogeneous distribution of the solid material in the azimuthal direction. The large-scale disk perturbations are preserved in the (sub)mm re-emission maps. The observable structures are very similar to those expected to result from planet-disk interaction. The larger dust particles increase the brightness contrast between gap and ring structures. We find that rings, gaps and the dust accumulation in the vortex could be traced with ALMA down to a scale of a few astronomical units in circumstellar disks located in nearby star-forming regions. Finally, we present a brief comparison of these structures with those recently found with ALMA in the young circumstellar disks of HL Tau and Oph IRS 48.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
The VLA view of the HL Tau Disk - Disk Mass, Grain Evolution, and Early Planet Formation
Authors:
Carlos Carrasco-Gonzalez,
Thomas Henning,
Claire J. Chandler,
Hendrik Linz,
Laura Perez,
Luis F. Rodriguez,
Roberto Galvan-Madrid,
Guillem Anglada,
Til Birnstiel,
Roy van Boekel,
Mario Flock,
Hubert Klahr,
Enrique Macias,
Karl Menten,
Mayra Osorio,
Leonardo Testi,
Jose M. Torrelles,
Zhaohuan Zhu
Abstract:
The first long-baseline ALMA campaign resolved the disk around the young star HL Tau into a number of axisymmetric bright and dark rings. Despite the very young age of HL Tau these structures have been interpreted as signatures for the presence of (proto)planets. The ALMA images triggered numerous theoretical studies based on disk-planet interactions, magnetically driven disk structures, and grain…
▽ More
The first long-baseline ALMA campaign resolved the disk around the young star HL Tau into a number of axisymmetric bright and dark rings. Despite the very young age of HL Tau these structures have been interpreted as signatures for the presence of (proto)planets. The ALMA images triggered numerous theoretical studies based on disk-planet interactions, magnetically driven disk structures, and grain evolution. Of special interest are the inner parts of disks, where terrestrial planets are expected to form. However, the emission from these regions in HL Tau turned out to be optically thick at all ALMA wavelengths, preventing the derivation of surface density profiles and grain size distributions. Here, we present the most sensitive images of HL Tau obtained to date with the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array at 7.0 mm wavelength with a spatial resolution comparable to the ALMA images. At this long wavelength the dust emission from HL Tau is optically thin, allowing a comprehensive study of the inner disk. We obtain a total disk dust mass of 0.001 - 0.003 Msun, depending on the assumed opacity and disk temperature. Our optically thin data also indicate fast grain growth, fragmentation, and formation of dense clumps in the inner densest parts of the disk. Our results suggest that the HL Tau disk may be actually in a very early stage of planetary formation, with planets not already formed in the gaps but in the process of future formation in the bright rings.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2016; v1 submitted 11 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
The Role of the Cooling Prescription for Disk Fragmentation: Numerical Convergence & Critical Cooling Parameter in Self-Gravitating Disks
Authors:
Hans Baehr,
Hubert Klahr
Abstract:
Protoplanetary disks fragment due to gravitational instability when there is enough mass for self-gravitation, described by the Toomre parameter, and when heat can be lost at a rate comparable to the local dynamical timescale, described by t_c=beta Omega^-1. Simulations of self-gravitating disks show that the cooling parameter has a rough critical value at beta_crit=3. When below beta_crit, gas ov…
▽ More
Protoplanetary disks fragment due to gravitational instability when there is enough mass for self-gravitation, described by the Toomre parameter, and when heat can be lost at a rate comparable to the local dynamical timescale, described by t_c=beta Omega^-1. Simulations of self-gravitating disks show that the cooling parameter has a rough critical value at beta_crit=3. When below beta_crit, gas overdensities will contract under their own gravity and fragment into bound objects while otherwise maintaining a steady state of gravitoturbulence. However, previous studies of the critical cooling parameter have found dependence on simulation resolution, indicating that the simulation of self-gravitating protoplanetary disks is not so straightforward. In particular, the simplicity of the cooling timescale t_c prevents fragments from being disrupted by pressure support as temperatures rise. We alter the cooling law so that the cooling timescale is dependent on local surface density fluctuations, a means of incorporating optical depth effects into the local cooling of an object. For lower resolution simulations, this results in a lower critical cooling parameter and a disk more stable to gravitational stresses suggesting the formation of large gas giants planets in large, cool disks is generally suppressed by more realistic cooling. At our highest resolution however, the model becomes unstable to fragmentation for cooling timescales up to beta = 10.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Vortex Formation and Evolution in Planet Harboring Disks under Thermal Relaxation
Authors:
A. Lobo Gomes,
H. Klahr,
A. L. Uribe,
P. Pinilla,
C. Surville
Abstract:
We study the evolution of planet-induced vortices in radially stratified disks, with initial conditions allowing for radial buoyancy. For this purpose we run global two dimensional hydrodynamical simulations, using the PLUTO code. Planet-induced vortices are a product of the Rossby wave instability (RWI) triggered in the edges of a planetary gap. In this work we assess the influence of radial buoy…
▽ More
We study the evolution of planet-induced vortices in radially stratified disks, with initial conditions allowing for radial buoyancy. For this purpose we run global two dimensional hydrodynamical simulations, using the PLUTO code. Planet-induced vortices are a product of the Rossby wave instability (RWI) triggered in the edges of a planetary gap. In this work we assess the influence of radial buoyancy for the development of the vortices. We found that radial buoyancy leads to smoother planetary gaps, which generates weaker vortices. This effect is less pronounced for locally isothermal and quasi-isothermal (very small cooling rate) disks. We observed the formation of two generations of vortices. The first generation of vortices is formed in the outer wall of the planetary gap. The merged primary vortex induces accretion, depleting the mass on its orbit. This process creates a surface density enhancement beyond the primary vortex position. The second generation of vortices arise in this surface density enhancement, indicating that the bump in this region is sufficient to trigger the RWI. The merged secondary vortex is a promising explanation for the location of the vortex in the Oph IRS48 system. Finally, we observed a nonmonotonic behavior for the vortex lifetimes as a function of the thermal relaxation timescale, agreeing with previous studies. The birth times of the secondary vortices also display a nonmonotonic behavior, which is correlated with the growth time of the primary vortex and its induced accretion.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2015; v1 submitted 4 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Tracing planet-induced structures in circumstellar disks using molecular lines
Authors:
F. Ober,
S. Wolf,
A. L. Uribe,
H. H. Klahr
Abstract:
Circumstellar disks are considered to be the birthplace of planets. Specific structures like spiral arms, gaps, and cavities are characteristic indicators of planet-disk interaction. Investigating these structures can provide insights into the growth of protoplanets and the physical properties of the disk. We investigate the feasibility of using molecular lines to trace planet-induced structures i…
▽ More
Circumstellar disks are considered to be the birthplace of planets. Specific structures like spiral arms, gaps, and cavities are characteristic indicators of planet-disk interaction. Investigating these structures can provide insights into the growth of protoplanets and the physical properties of the disk. We investigate the feasibility of using molecular lines to trace planet-induced structures in circumstellar disks. Based on 3D hydrodynamic simulations of planet-disk interactions, we perform self-consistent temperature calculations and produce N-LTE molecular line velocity-channel maps and spectra of these disks using our new N-LTE line radiative transfer code Mol3D. Subsequently, we simulate ALMA observations using the CASA simulator. We consider two nearly face-on inclinations, 5 disk masses, 7 disk radii, and 2 different typical pre-main-sequence host stars (T Tauri, Herbig Ae). We calculate up to 141 individual velocity-channel maps for five molecules/isotopoloques in a total of 32 rotational transitions to investigate the frequency dependence of the structures indicated above. We find that the majority of protoplanetary disks in our parameter space could be detected in the molecular lines considered. However, unlike the continuum case, gap detection is not straightforward in lines. For example, gaps are not seen in symmetric rings but are masked by the pattern caused by the global (Keplerian) velocity field. We identify specific regions in the velocity-channel maps that are characteristic of planet-induced structures. Simulations of high angular resolution molecular line observations demonstrate the potential of ALMA to provide complementary information about the planet-disk interaction as compared to continuum observations. In particular, the detection of planet-induced gaps is possible under certain conditions.(abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Particle Trap** and Streaming Instability in Vortices
Authors:
Natalie Raettig,
Hubert Klahr,
Wladimir Lyra
Abstract:
We analyse the concentration of solid particles in vortices created and sustained by radial buoyancy in protoplanetary disks, i.e. baroclinic vortex growth. Besides the gas drag acting on particles we also allow for back-reaction from dust onto the gas. This becomes important when the local dust-to-gas ratio approaches unity. In our 2D, local, shearing sheet simulations we see high concentrations…
▽ More
We analyse the concentration of solid particles in vortices created and sustained by radial buoyancy in protoplanetary disks, i.e. baroclinic vortex growth. Besides the gas drag acting on particles we also allow for back-reaction from dust onto the gas. This becomes important when the local dust-to-gas ratio approaches unity. In our 2D, local, shearing sheet simulations we see high concentrations of grains inside the vortices for a broad range of Stokes numbers, ${\rm St}$. An initial dust-to-gas ratio of 1:100 can easily be reversed to 100:1 for ${\rm St}=1$. The increased dust-to-gas ratio triggers the streaming instability, thus counter-intuitively limiting the maximal achievable overdensities. We find that particle trap** inside vortices opens the possibility for gravity-assisted planetesimal formation even for small particles ($\rm{St}=0.01$) and low initial dust-to-gas ratios (1:$10^4$)
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
Gaps, Rings, and Non-Axisymmetric Structures in Protoplanetary Disks - From Simulations to ALMA Observations
Authors:
M. Flock,
J. P. Ruge,
N. Dzyurkevich,
Th. Henning,
H. Klahr,
S. Wolf
Abstract:
Recent observations by the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) of disks around young stars revealed distinct asymmetries in the dust continuum emission. In this work we want to study axisymmetric and non-axisymmetric structures, evocated by the magneto-rotational instability in the outer regions of protoplanetary disks. We combine the results of state-of-the-art numerical simulatio…
▽ More
Recent observations by the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) of disks around young stars revealed distinct asymmetries in the dust continuum emission. In this work we want to study axisymmetric and non-axisymmetric structures, evocated by the magneto-rotational instability in the outer regions of protoplanetary disks. We combine the results of state-of-the-art numerical simulations with post-processing radiative transfer (RT) to generate synthetic maps and predictions for ALMA. We performed non-ideal global 3D MHD stratified simulations of the dead-zone outer edge using the FARGO MHD code PLUTO. The stellar and disk parameters are taken from a parameterized disk model applied for fitting high-angular resolution multi-wavelength observations of circumstellar disks. The 2D temperature and density profiles are calculated consistently from a given surface density profile and Monte-Carlo radiative transfer. The 2D Ohmic resistivity profile is calculated using a dust chemistry model. The magnetic field is a vertical net flux field. The resulting dust reemission provides the basis for the simulation of observations with ALMA. The fiducial model develops a large gap followed by a jump in surface density located at the dead-zone outer edge. The jump in density and pressure is strong enough to stop the radial drift of particles. In addition, we observe the generation of vortices by the Rossby wave instability (RWI) at the jumps location close to 60 AU. The vortices are steadily generated and destroyed at a cycle of 40 local orbits. The RT results and simulated ALMA observations predict the feasibility to observe such large scale structures appearing in magnetized disks without having a planet.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2014; v1 submitted 11 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
Planet-induced disk structures: A comparison between (sub)mm and infrared radiation
Authors:
Jan Philipp Ruge,
Sebastian Wolf,
Ana L. Uribe,
Hubert H. Klahr
Abstract:
Young giant planets, which are embedded in a circumstellar disk, will significantly perturb the disk density distribution. This effect can potentially be used as an indirect tracer for planets. We investigate the feasibility of observing planet-induced gaps in circumstellar disks in scattered light. We perform 3D hydrodynamical disk simulations combined with subsequent radiative transfer calculati…
▽ More
Young giant planets, which are embedded in a circumstellar disk, will significantly perturb the disk density distribution. This effect can potentially be used as an indirect tracer for planets. We investigate the feasibility of observing planet-induced gaps in circumstellar disks in scattered light. We perform 3D hydrodynamical disk simulations combined with subsequent radiative transfer calculations in scattered light for different star, disk, and planet configurations. The results are compared to those of a corresponding study for the (sub)mm thermal re-emission. The feasibility of detecting planet-induced gaps in scattered light is mainly influenced by the optical depth of the disk and therefore by the disk size and mass. Planet-induced gaps are in general only detectable if the photosphere of the disks is sufficiently disturbed. Within the limitations given by the parameter space here considered, we find that gap detection is possible in the case of disks with masses below $\sim 10^{-4\dots-3} \, \rm M_\odot$. Compared to the disk mass that marks the lower Atacama Large (Sub)Millimeter Array (ALMA) detection limit for the thermal radiation re-emitted by the disk, it is possible to detect the same gap both in re-emission and scattered light only in a narrow range of disk masses around $\sim 10^{-4} \, \rm M_\odot$, corresponding to $16\%$ of cases considered in our study.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
SPOTS: The Search for Planets Orbiting Two Stars. I. Survey description and first observations
Authors:
Christian Thalmann,
Silvano Desidera,
Mariangela Bonavita,
Markus Janson,
Tomonori Usuda,
Thomas Henning,
Rainer Köhler,
Joseph C. Carson,
Anthony Boccaletti,
Carolina Bergfors,
Wolfgang Brandner,
Markus Feldt,
Miwa Goto,
Hubert Klahr,
Francesco Marzari,
Christoph Mordasini
Abstract:
Direct imaging surveys for exoplanets commonly exclude binary stars from their target lists, leaving a large part of the overall planet demography unexplored. To address this gap in our understanding of planet formation and evolution, we have launched the first direct imaging survey dedicated to circumbinary planets: SPOTS, the Search for Planets Orbiting Two Stars. In this paper, we discuss the t…
▽ More
Direct imaging surveys for exoplanets commonly exclude binary stars from their target lists, leaving a large part of the overall planet demography unexplored. To address this gap in our understanding of planet formation and evolution, we have launched the first direct imaging survey dedicated to circumbinary planets: SPOTS, the Search for Planets Orbiting Two Stars. In this paper, we discuss the theoretical context, scientific merit, and technical feasibility of such observations, describe the target sample and observational strategy of our survey, and report on the first results from our pilot survey of 26 targets with the VLT NaCo facility. While we have not found any confirmed substellar companions to date, a number of promising candidate companions remain to be tested for common proper motion in upcoming follow-up observations. We also report on the astrometry of the three resolved binaries in our target sample. This pilot survey constitutes a successful proof of concept for our survey strategy and paves the way for a second stage of exploratory observations with VLT SPHERE.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
Mean gas opacity for circumstellar environments and equilibrium temperature degeneracy
Authors:
M. G. Malygin,
R. Kuiper,
H. Klahr,
C. P. Dullemond,
Th. Henning
Abstract:
In a molecular cloud dust opacity typically dominates over gas opacity, yet in the vicinities of forming stars dust is depleted, and gas is the sole provider of opacity. In the optically thin circumstellar environments the radiation temperature cannot be assumed to be equal to the gas temperature, hence the two-temperature Planck means are necessary to calculate the radiative equilibrium.
By usi…
▽ More
In a molecular cloud dust opacity typically dominates over gas opacity, yet in the vicinities of forming stars dust is depleted, and gas is the sole provider of opacity. In the optically thin circumstellar environments the radiation temperature cannot be assumed to be equal to the gas temperature, hence the two-temperature Planck means are necessary to calculate the radiative equilibrium.
By using the two-temperature mean opacity one does obtain the proper equilibrium gas temperature in a circumstellar environment, which is in a chemical equilibrium. A careful consideration of a radiative transfer problem reveals that the equilibrium temperature solution can be degenerate in an optically thin gaseous environment.
We compute mean gas opacities based on the publicly available code DFSYNTHE by Kurucz and Castelli. We performed the calculations assuming local thermodynamic equilibrium and an ideal gas equation of state. The values were derived by direct integration of the high-resolution opacity spectrum.
We produced two sets of gas opacity tables: Rosseland means and two-temperature Planck means (the tables available via http://cdsweb.u-strasbg.fr/ as well as via http://www.mpia-hd.mpg.de/homes/malygin). For three metallicities [Me/H] = 0.0,+/-0.3 we covered the parameter range 3.48 <= log T_rad[K] <= 4.48 in radiation temperature, 2.8 <= log T_gas[K]} <= 6.0 in gas temperature, and -10 <= log P[dyn cm^-2] <= 6 in gas pressure. We show that in the optically thin circumstellar environment for a given stellar radiation field and local gas density there are several equilibrium gas temperatures possible.
We conclude that, in general, equilibrium gas temperature cannot be determined without treating the temperature evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
Convective Overstability in radially stratified accretion disks under thermal relaxation
Authors:
Hubert Klahr,
Alexander Hubbard
Abstract:
This letter expands the stability criterion for radially stratified, vertically {unstratified} accretion disks incorporating thermal relaxation. We find a linear amplification of epicyclic oscillations in these disks that depends on the effective cooling time, i.e. an overstability. The growth rates of the overstability vanish for both extreme cases, e.g. infinite cooling time and instantaneous co…
▽ More
This letter expands the stability criterion for radially stratified, vertically {unstratified} accretion disks incorporating thermal relaxation. We find a linear amplification of epicyclic oscillations in these disks that depends on the effective cooling time, i.e. an overstability. The growth rates of the overstability vanish for both extreme cases, e.g. infinite cooling time and instantaneous cooling, i.e. the adiabatic and fully isothermal cases. However, for thermal relaxation times $τ$ on the order of the orbital frequency, $τΩ\sim 1$, modes grow at a rate proportional to the square of the Brunt-Väisälä frequency. The overstability is based on epicyclic motions, with the thermal relaxation causing gas to heat while radially displaced inwards, and cool while radially displaced outwards. This causes the gas to have a lower density when moving outwards compared to when it moves inwards, so it feels the outwards directed pressure force more strongly on that leg of the journey. We suggest the term ``Convective Overstability" for the phenomenon that has already been numerically studied in the non-linear regime in the context of amplifying vortices in disks, under the name ``Subcritical Baroclinic Instability". The point of the present paper is to make clear that vortex formation in three-dimensional disks is neither subcritical, i.e. does not need a finite perturbation, nor is it baroclinic in the sense of geophysical fluid dynamics, which requires on vertical shear. We find that Convective Overstability is a linear instability that will operate under a wide range of physical conditions for circumstellar disks.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2014; v1 submitted 26 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Grain opacity and the bulk composition of extrasolar planets. I. Results from scaling the ISM opacity
Authors:
C. Mordasini,
H. Klahr,
Y. Alibert,
N. Miller,
T. Henning
Abstract:
The opacity due to grains in the envelope of a protoplanet regulates the accretion rate of gas during formation, thus the final bulk composition of planets with primordial H/He is a function of it. Observationally, for exoplanets with known mass and radius it is possible to estimate the bulk composition via internal structure models. We first determine the reduction factor of the ISM grain opacity…
▽ More
The opacity due to grains in the envelope of a protoplanet regulates the accretion rate of gas during formation, thus the final bulk composition of planets with primordial H/He is a function of it. Observationally, for exoplanets with known mass and radius it is possible to estimate the bulk composition via internal structure models. We first determine the reduction factor of the ISM grain opacity f_opa that leads to gas accretion rates consistent with grain evolution models. We then compare the bulk composition of synthetic low-mass and giant planets at different f_opa with observations. For f_opa=1 (full ISM opacity) the synthetic low-mass planets have too small radii, i.e., too low envelope masses compared to observations. At f_opa=0.003, the value calibrated with the grain evolution models, synthetic and actual planets occupy similar mass-radius loci. The mean enrichment of giant planets relative to the host star as a function of planet mass M can be approximated as Z_p/Z_star = beta*(M/M_Jup)^alpha. We find alpha=-0.7 independent of f_opa in synthetic populations in agreement with the observational result (-0.71+-0.10). The absolute enrichment level decreases from beta=8.5 at f_opa=1 to 3.5 at f_opa=0. At f_opa=0.003 one finds beta=7.2 which is similar to the observational result (6.3+-1.0). We thus find observational hints that the opacity in protoplanetary atmospheres is much smaller than in the ISM even if the specific value of the grain opacity cannot be constrained here. The result for the enrichment of giant planets helps to distinguish core accretion and gravitational instability. In the simplest picture of core accretion where first a critical core forms and afterwards only gas is added, alpha=-1. If a core accretes all planetesimals inside the feeding zone, alpha=-2/3. The observational result lies between these values, pointing to core accretion as the formation mechanism.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Impacts of planet migration models on planetary populations. Effects of saturation, cooling and stellar irradiation
Authors:
K. -M. Dittkrist,
C. Mordasini,
H. Klahr,
Y. Alibert,
T. Henning
Abstract:
Context: Several recent studies have found that planet migration in adiabatic discs differs significantly from migration in isothermal discs. Depending on the thermodynamic conditions, i.e., the effectiveness of radiative cooling, and the radial surface density profile, planets migrate inward or outward. Clearly, this will influence the semimajor axis - mass distribution of planets as predicted by…
▽ More
Context: Several recent studies have found that planet migration in adiabatic discs differs significantly from migration in isothermal discs. Depending on the thermodynamic conditions, i.e., the effectiveness of radiative cooling, and the radial surface density profile, planets migrate inward or outward. Clearly, this will influence the semimajor axis - mass distribution of planets as predicted by population synthesis simulations. Aims: Our goal is to study the global effects of radiative cooling, viscous torque desaturation and gap opening as well as stellar irradiation on the tidal migration of a synthetic planet population. Methods: We combine results from several analytical studies and 3D hydrodynamic simulations in a new semi-analytical migration model for the application in our planet population synthesis calculations. Results: We find a good agreement of our model with torques obtained in a 3D radiative hydrodynamic simulations. We find three convergence zones in a typical disc, towards which planets migrate from the in- and outside, affecting strongly the migration behavior of low-mass planets. Interestingly, this leads to slow type II like migration behavior for low-mass planets captured in those zones even without an ad hoc migration rate reduction factor or a yet to be defined halting mechanism. This means that the new prescription of migration including non-isothermal effects makes the preciously widely used artificial migration rate reduction factor obsolete. Conclusions: Outward migration in parts of a disc makes some planets survive long enough to become massive. The convergence zones lead to a potentially observable accumulations of low-mass planets at certain semimajor axes. Our results indicate that further studies of the mass where the corotation torque saturates will be needed since its value has a major impact on the properties of planet populations.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
Transport and Accretion in Planet-Forming Disks
Authors:
N. J. Turner,
S. Fromang,
C. Gammie,
H. Klahr,
G. Lesur,
M. Wardle,
X. -N. Bai
Abstract:
Planets appear to form in environments shaped by the gas flowing through protostellar disks to the central young stars. The flows in turn are governed by orbital angular momentum transfer. In this chapter we summarize current understanding of the transfer processes best able to account for the flows, including magneto-rotational turbulence, magnetically-launched winds, self-gravitational instabili…
▽ More
Planets appear to form in environments shaped by the gas flowing through protostellar disks to the central young stars. The flows in turn are governed by orbital angular momentum transfer. In this chapter we summarize current understanding of the transfer processes best able to account for the flows, including magneto-rotational turbulence, magnetically-launched winds, self-gravitational instability and vortices driven by hydrodynamical instabilities. For each in turn we outline the major achievements of the past few years and the outstanding questions. We underscore the requirements for operation, especially ionization for the magnetic processes and heating and cooling for the others. We describe the distribution and strength of the resulting flows and compare with the long-used phenomenological $α$-picture, highlighting issues where the fuller physical picture yields substantially different answers. We also discuss the links between magnetized turbulence and magnetically-launched outflows, and between magnetized turbulence and hydrodynamical vortices. We end with a summary of the status of efforts to detect specific signatures of the flows.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
Characterization of the gaseous companion κ Andromedae b: New Keck and LBTI high-contrast observations
Authors:
M. Bonnefoy,
T. Currie,
G. -D. Marleau,
J. E. Schlieder,
J. Wisniewski,
J. Carson,
K. R. Covey,
T. Henning,
B. Biller,
P. Hinz,
H. Klahr,
A. N. Marsh Boyer,
N. Zimmerman,
M. Janson,
M. McElwain,
C. Mordasini,
A. Skemer,
V. Bailey,
D. Defrère,
C. Thalmann,
M. Skrutskie,
F. Allard,
D. Homeier,
M. Tamura,
M. Feldt
, et al. (42 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We previously reported the direct detection of a low mass companion at a projected separation of 55+-2 AU around the B9 type star κ Andromedae. The properties of the system (mass ratio, separation) make it a benchmark for the understanding of the formation and evolution of gas giant planets and brown dwarfs on wide-orbits. We present new angular differential imaging (ADI) images of the Kappa Andro…
▽ More
We previously reported the direct detection of a low mass companion at a projected separation of 55+-2 AU around the B9 type star κ Andromedae. The properties of the system (mass ratio, separation) make it a benchmark for the understanding of the formation and evolution of gas giant planets and brown dwarfs on wide-orbits. We present new angular differential imaging (ADI) images of the Kappa Andromedae system at 2.146 (Ks), 3.776 (L'), 4.052 (NB 4.05) and 4.78 μm (M') obtained with Keck/NIRC2 and LBTI/LMIRCam, as well as more accurate near-infrared photometry of the star with the MIMIR instrument. We derive a more accurate J = 15.86 +- 0.21, H = 14.95 +- 0.13, Ks = 14.32 +- 0.09 mag for κ And b. We redetect the companion in all our high contrast observations. We confirm previous contrasts obtained at Ks and L' band. We derive NB 4.05 = 13.0 +- 0.2 and M' = 13.3 +- 0.3 mag and estimate Log10(L/Lsun) = -3.76 +- 0.06. We build the 1-5 microns spectral energy distribution of the companion and compare it to seven PHOENIX-based atmospheric models in order to derive Teff = 1900+100-200 K. Models do not set constrains on the surface gravity. ``Hot-start" evolutionary models predict masses of 14+25-2 MJup based on the luminosity and temperature estimates, and considering a conservative age range for the system (30+120-10 Myr). ``warm-start" evolutionary tracks constrain the mass to M >= 11 MJup. Therefore, the mass of κ Andromedae b mostly falls in the brown-dwarf regime, due to remaining uncertainties in age and mass-luminosity models. According to the formation models, disk instability in a primordial disk could account for the position and a wide range of plausible masses of κ And b.
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
Discovery of a probable 4-5 Jupiter-mass exoplanet to HD 95086 by direct-imaging
Authors:
J. Rameau,
G. Chauvin,
A. -M. Lagrange,
A. Boccaletti,
S. P. Quanz,
M. Bonnefoy,
J. H. Girard,
P. Delorme,
S. Desidera,
H. Klahr,
C. Mordasini,
C. Dumas,
M. Bonavita,
T. Meshkat,
V. Bailey,
M. Kenworthy
Abstract:
Direct imaging has just started the inventory of the population of gas giant planets on wide-orbits around young stars in the solar neighborhood. Following this approach, we carried out a deep imaging survey in the near-infrared using VLT/NaCo to search for substellar companions. We report here the discovery in L' (3.8 microns) images of a probable companion orbiting at 56 AU the young (10-17 Myr)…
▽ More
Direct imaging has just started the inventory of the population of gas giant planets on wide-orbits around young stars in the solar neighborhood. Following this approach, we carried out a deep imaging survey in the near-infrared using VLT/NaCo to search for substellar companions. We report here the discovery in L' (3.8 microns) images of a probable companion orbiting at 56 AU the young (10-17 Myr), dusty, and early-type (A8) star HD 95086. This discovery is based on observations with more than a year-time-lapse. Our first epoch clearly revealed the source at 10 sigma while our second epoch lacked good observing conditions hence yielding a 3 sigma detection. Various tests were thus made to rule out possible artifacts. This recovery is consistent with the signal at the first epoch but requires cleaner confirmation. Nevertheless, our astrometric precision suggests the companion to be comoving with the star, with a 3 sigma confidence level. The planetary nature of the source is reinforced by a non-detection in Ks-band (2.18 microns) images according to its possible extremely red Ks - L' color. Conversely, background contamination is rejected with good confidence level. The luminosity yields a predicted mass of about 4-5MJup (at 10-17 Myr) using "hot-start" evolutionary models, making HD 95086 b the exoplanet with the lowest mass ever imaged around a star.
△ Less
Submitted 30 August, 2013; v1 submitted 31 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Accretion of gas onto gap-opening planets and circumplanetary flow structure in magnetized turbulent disks
Authors:
Ana Uribe,
Hubert Klahr,
Thomas Henning
Abstract:
We have performed three-dimensional magneto-hydrodynamical simulations of stellar accretion disks, using the PLUTO code, and studied the accretion of gas onto a Jupiter-mass planet and the structure of the circumplanetary gas flow after opening a gap in the disk. We compare our results with simulations of laminar, yet viscous disks with different levels of an $α$-type viscosity. In all cases, we f…
▽ More
We have performed three-dimensional magneto-hydrodynamical simulations of stellar accretion disks, using the PLUTO code, and studied the accretion of gas onto a Jupiter-mass planet and the structure of the circumplanetary gas flow after opening a gap in the disk. We compare our results with simulations of laminar, yet viscous disks with different levels of an $α$-type viscosity. In all cases, we find that the accretion flow across the surface of the Hill sphere of the planet is not spherically or azimuthally symmetric, and is predominantly restricted to the mid-plane region of the disk. Even in the turbulent case, we find no significant vertical flow of mass into the Hill sphere. The outer parts of the circumplanetary disk are shown to rotate significantly below Keplerian speed, independent of viscosity, while the circumplanetary disk density (therefore the angular momentum) increases with viscosity. For a simulation of a magnetized turbulent disk, where the global averaged alpha stress is $α_{MHD}=10^{-3}$, we find the accretion rate onto the planet to be $\dot{M}\approx 2\times10^{-6}M_{J}yr^{-1}$ for a gap surface density of $12 g cm^{-2}$. This is about a third of the accretion rate obtained in a laminar viscous simulation with equivalent $α$ parameter.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
A survey of young, nearby, and dusty stars to understand the formation of wide-orbit giant planets
Authors:
J. Rameau,
G. Chauvin,
A. -M. Lagrange,
H. Klahr,
M. Bonnefoy,
C. Mordasini,
M. Bonavita,
S. Desidera,
C. Dumas,
J. H. Girard
Abstract:
Direct imaging has confirmed the existence of substellar companions on wide orbits. To understand the formation and evolution mechanisms of these companions, the full population properties must be characterized. We aim at detecting giant planet and/or brown dwarf companions around young, nearby, and dusty stars. Our goal is also to provide statistics on the population of giant planets at wide-orbi…
▽ More
Direct imaging has confirmed the existence of substellar companions on wide orbits. To understand the formation and evolution mechanisms of these companions, the full population properties must be characterized. We aim at detecting giant planet and/or brown dwarf companions around young, nearby, and dusty stars. Our goal is also to provide statistics on the population of giant planets at wide-orbits and discuss planet formation models. We report a deep survey of 59 stars, members of young stellar associations. The observations were conducted with VLT/NaCo at L'-band (3.8 micron). We used angular differential imaging to reach optimal detection performance. A statistical analysis of about 60 % of the young and southern A-F stars closer than 65 pc allows us to derive the fraction of giant planets on wide orbits. We use gravitational instability models and planet population synthesis models following the core-accretion scenario to discuss the occurrence of these companions. We resolve and characterize new visual binaries and do not detect any new substellar companion. The survey's median detection performance reaches contrasts of 10 mag at 0.5as and 11.5 mag at 1as. We find the occurrence of planets to be between 10.8-24.8 % at 68 % confidence level assuming a uniform distribution of planets in the interval 1-13 Mj and 1-1000 AU. Considering the predictions of formation models, we set important constraints on the occurrence of massive planets and brown dwarf companions that would have formed by GI. We show that this mechanism favors the formation of rather massive clump (Mclump > 30 Mj) at wide (a > 40 AU) orbits which might evolve dynamically and/or fragment. For the population of close-in giant planets that would have formed by CA, our survey marginally explore physical separations (<20 AU) and cannot constrain this population.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2013; v1 submitted 21 February, 2013;
originally announced February 2013.
-
A Parameter Study for Baroclinic Vortex Amplification
Authors:
N. Raettig,
W. Lyra,
H. Klahr
Abstract:
Recent studies have shown that baroclinic vortex amplification is strongly dependent on certain factors, namely, the global entropy gradient, the efficiency of thermal diffusion and/or relaxation as well as numerical resolution. We conduct a comprehensive study of a broad range and combination of various entropy gradients, thermal diffusion and thermal relaxation time-scales via local shearing she…
▽ More
Recent studies have shown that baroclinic vortex amplification is strongly dependent on certain factors, namely, the global entropy gradient, the efficiency of thermal diffusion and/or relaxation as well as numerical resolution. We conduct a comprehensive study of a broad range and combination of various entropy gradients, thermal diffusion and thermal relaxation time-scales via local shearing sheet simulations covering the parameter space relevant for protoplanetary disks. We measure the Reynolds stresses as a function of our control parameters and see that there is angular momentum transport even for entropy gradients as low as $β=-{d\ln s}/{d\ln r}={1}/{2}$, which corresponds to values observed in protoplanetary accretion disks. The amplification-rate of the perturbations, $Γ$, appears to be proportional to $β^2$ and thus proportional to the square of the \BV ($Γ\propto β^2 \propto N^2$). The saturation level of Reynolds stresses on the other hand seems to be proportional to $β^{1/2}$. This highlights the importance of baroclinic effects even for the low entropy gradients expected in protoplanetary disks.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2013; v1 submitted 18 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Tracing large-scale structures in circumstellar disks with ALMA
Authors:
Jan Philipp Ruge,
Sebastian Wolf,
Ana L. Uribe,
Hubert H. Klahr
Abstract:
Planets are supposed to form in circumstellar disks. The gravitational potential of a planet perturbs the disk and leads to characteristic structures, i.e. spiral waves and gaps, in the disk's density profile. We perform a large-scale parameter study of the observability of these planet-induced structures in circumstellar disks with ALMA. On the basis of HD and MHD simulations, we calculated the d…
▽ More
Planets are supposed to form in circumstellar disks. The gravitational potential of a planet perturbs the disk and leads to characteristic structures, i.e. spiral waves and gaps, in the disk's density profile. We perform a large-scale parameter study of the observability of these planet-induced structures in circumstellar disks with ALMA. On the basis of HD and MHD simulations, we calculated the disk temperature structure and (sub)mm images of these systems. These were used to derive simulated ALMA images. Because appropriate objects are frequent in Taurus, we focused on a distance of 140pc and a declination of 20°. The explored range of star-disk-planet configurations consists of 6 HD simulations (including magnetic fields and different planet masses), 9 disk sizes, 15 total disk masses, 6 different central stars, and two different grain size distributions. On almost all scales and in particular down to a scale of a few AU, ALMA is able to trace disk structures induced by planet-disk interaction or by the influence of magnetic fields on the wavelength range between 0.4 and 2.0mm. In most cases, the optimum angular resolution is limited by the sensitivity. However, within the range of typical masses of protoplanetary disks (0.1-0.001Msun) the disk mass has a minor impact on the observability. It is possible to resolve disks down to 2.67e-6Msun and trace gaps induced by a planet with M_p/M_s = 0.001 in disks with 2.67e-4Msun with a signal-to-noise ratio greater than three. The central star has a major impact on the observability of gaps, as well as the considered maximum grainsize of the dust in the disk. In general, it is more likely to trace planet-induced gaps in our MHD models, because gaps are wider in the presence of magnetic fields. We also find that zonal flows resulting from MRI create gap-like structures in the disk's re-emission radiation, which are observable with ALMA.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2012; v1 submitted 8 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
A solution to the radiation pressure problem in the formation of massive stars
Authors:
Rolf Kuiper,
Hubert Klahr,
Henrik Beuther,
Thomas Henning
Abstract:
We review our recent studies demonstrating that the radiation pressure problem in the formation of massive stars can be circumvented via an anisotropy of the thermal radiation field. Such an anisotropy naturally establishes with the formation of a circumstellar disk. The required angular momentum transport within the disk can be provided by develo** gravitational torques. Radiative Rayleigh-Tayl…
▽ More
We review our recent studies demonstrating that the radiation pressure problem in the formation of massive stars can be circumvented via an anisotropy of the thermal radiation field. Such an anisotropy naturally establishes with the formation of a circumstellar disk. The required angular momentum transport within the disk can be provided by develo** gravitational torques. Radiative Rayleigh-Taylor instabilities in the cavity regions - as previously suggested in the literature - are not required and are shown to be not occurring in the context of massive star formation.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Gravoturbulent Planetesimal Formation: The Positive Effect of long-lived Zonal Flows
Authors:
Karsten Dittrich,
Hubert Klahr,
Anders Johansen
Abstract:
Recent numerical simulations have shown long-lived axisymmetric sub- and super-Keplerian flows in protoplanetary disks. These zonal flows are found in local as well as global simulations of disks unstable to the magnetorotational instability. This paper covers our study of the strength and lifetime of zonal flows and the resulting long-lived gas over- and underdensities as functions of the azimuth…
▽ More
Recent numerical simulations have shown long-lived axisymmetric sub- and super-Keplerian flows in protoplanetary disks. These zonal flows are found in local as well as global simulations of disks unstable to the magnetorotational instability. This paper covers our study of the strength and lifetime of zonal flows and the resulting long-lived gas over- and underdensities as functions of the azimuthal and radial size of the local shearing box. We further investigate dust particle concentrations without feedback on the gas and without self-gravity. Strength and lifetime of zonal flows increase with the radial extent of the simulation box, but decrease with the azimuthal box size. Our simulations support earlier results that zonal flows have a natural radial length scale of 5-7 gas pressure scale heights. This is the first study that combines three-dimensional MHD simulations of zonal flows and dust particles feeling the gas pressure. The pressure bumps trap particles with $\textrm{St} = 1$ very efficiently. We show that $\textrm{St} = 0.1$ particles (of some centimeters in size if at $5\textrm{AU}$ in an MMSN) reach a hundred-fold higher density than initially. This opens the path for particles of $\textrm{St} = 0.1$ and dust-to-gas ratio of 0.01 or for particles of $\textrm{St} \geq 0.5$ and dust-to-gas ratio $10^{-4}$ to still reach densities that potentially trigger the streaming instability and thus gravoturbulent formation of planetesimals.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2013; v1 submitted 9 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Turbulence in weakly-ionized proto-planetary disks
Authors:
M. Flock,
Th. Henning,
H. Klahr
Abstract:
We investigate the characteristic properties of self-sustained MRI turbulence in low-ionized proto-planetary disks. We study the transition regime between active and dead-zone, performing 3D global non-ideal MHD simulations of stratified disk covering range of magnetic Reynolds number between 2700 < Rm < 6600. We found converged and saturated MRI turbulence for Rm > 5000 with a strength of alpha ~…
▽ More
We investigate the characteristic properties of self-sustained MRI turbulence in low-ionized proto-planetary disks. We study the transition regime between active and dead-zone, performing 3D global non-ideal MHD simulations of stratified disk covering range of magnetic Reynolds number between 2700 < Rm < 6600. We found converged and saturated MRI turbulence for Rm > 5000 with a strength of alpha ~ 0.01. Below Rm < 5000 the MRI starts to decay at the midplane, having Elsasser numbers below one. We find a transition regime between 3300 < Rm < 5000 where the MRI turbulence is still sustained but damped. At around Rm < 3000 the MRI turbulence decays but could reestablished due to the accumulation of toroidal magnetic field or the radial transport of magnetic field from the active region. Below Rm < 3000 the MRI cannot be sustained and is decaying. Here hydro-dynamical motions, like density waves dominate. We observe anti-cyclonic vortices in the transition between dead-zone and active zone.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Characterization of exoplanets from their formation I: Models of combined planet formation and evolution
Authors:
C. Mordasini,
Y. Alibert,
H. Klahr,
T. Henning
Abstract:
A first characterization of many exoplanets has recently been achieved by the observational determination of their radius. For some planets, a measurement of the luminosity has also been possible, with many more directly imaged planets expected in the future. The statistical characterization of exoplanets through their mass-radius and mass-luminosity diagram is thus becoming possible. This is for…
▽ More
A first characterization of many exoplanets has recently been achieved by the observational determination of their radius. For some planets, a measurement of the luminosity has also been possible, with many more directly imaged planets expected in the future. The statistical characterization of exoplanets through their mass-radius and mass-luminosity diagram is thus becoming possible. This is for planet formation and evolution theory of similar importance as the mass-distance diagram. Our aim in this and a companion paper is to extend our formation model into a coupled formation and evolution model. We want to calculate in a self-consistent way all basic characteristics (M,a,R,L) of a planet and use the model for population synthesis calculations. Here we show how we solve the structure equations describing the gaseous envelope not only during the early formation phase, but also during gas runaway accretion, and during the evolutionary phase at constant mass on Gyr timescales. We then study the in situ formation and evolution of Jupiter, the mass-radius relationship of giants, the influence of the core mass on the radius and the luminosity both in the "hot start" and the "cold start" scenario. We put special emphasis on the comparison with other models. We find that our results agree very well with those of more complex models, despite a number of simplifications. The upgraded model yields the most important characteristics of a planet from its beginning as a seed embryo to a Gyr old planet. This is the case for all planets in a synthetic planetary population. Therefore, we can now use self-consistently the statistical constraints coming from all major observational techniques. This is important in a time where different techniques yield constraints on very diverse sub-populations of planets, and where its is challenging to put all these constraints together in one coherent picture.
△ Less
Submitted 29 July, 2012; v1 submitted 26 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
Characterization of exoplanets from their formation II: The planetary mass-radius relationship
Authors:
C. Mordasini,
Y. Alibert,
C. Georgy,
K. -M. Dittkrist,
H. Klahr,
T. Henning
Abstract:
The research of exoplanets has entered an era in which we characterize extrasolar planets. This has become possible with measurements of radii and luminosities. Meanwhile, radial velocity surveys discover also very low-mass planets. Uniting all this observational data into one coherent picture to better understand planet formation is an important, but difficult undertaking. Our approach is to deve…
▽ More
The research of exoplanets has entered an era in which we characterize extrasolar planets. This has become possible with measurements of radii and luminosities. Meanwhile, radial velocity surveys discover also very low-mass planets. Uniting all this observational data into one coherent picture to better understand planet formation is an important, but difficult undertaking. Our approach is to develop a model which can make testable predictions for all these observational methods. We continue to describe how we have extended our formation model into a self-consistently coupled formation and evolution model. We show how we calculate the internal structure of the solid core and radiogenic heating. We also improve the protoplanetary disk model. Finally, we conduct population synthesis calculations. We present how the planetary mass-radius relationship of planets with primordial H/He envelopes forms and evolves in time. The basic shape of the M-R relation can be understood from the core accretion model. Low-mass planets cannot bind massive envelopes, while super-critical cores necessarily trigger runway gas accretion, leading to "forbidden" zones in the M-R plane. For a given mass, there is a considerable diversity of radii. We compare the synthetic M-R relation with the observed one, finding good agreement for a>0.1 AU. The synthetic radius distribution is characterized by a strong increase towards small R, and a second, lower local maximum at ~1 Jovian radius. The increase towards small radii reflects the increase of the mass function towards low M. The second local maximum is due to the fact that radii are nearly independent of mass for giant planets. A comparison of the synthetic radius distribution with Kepler data shows agreement for R>2 Earth radii, but divergence for smaller radii. We predict that in the next few years, Kepler should find the second, local maximum at ~1 Jovian radius.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2012; v1 submitted 14 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
A simple model for the evolution of the dust population in protoplanetary disks
Authors:
T. Birnstiel,
H. Klahr,
B. Ercolano
Abstract:
Context: The global size and spatial distribution of dust is an important ingredient in the structure and evolution of protoplanetary disks and in the formation of larger bodies, such as planetesimals. Aims: We aim to derive simple equations that explain the global evolution of the dust surface density profile and the upper limit of the grain size distribution and which can readily be used for fur…
▽ More
Context: The global size and spatial distribution of dust is an important ingredient in the structure and evolution of protoplanetary disks and in the formation of larger bodies, such as planetesimals. Aims: We aim to derive simple equations that explain the global evolution of the dust surface density profile and the upper limit of the grain size distribution and which can readily be used for further modeling or for interpreting of observational data. Methods: We have developed a simple model that follows the upper end of the dust size distribution and the evolution of the dust surface density profile. This model is calibrated with state-of-the-art simulations of dust evolution, which treat dust growth, fragmentation, and transport in viscously evolving gas disks. Results: We find very good agreement between the full dust-evolution code and the toy model presented in this paper. We derive analytical profiles that describe the dust-to-gas ratios and the dust surface density profiles well in protoplanetary disks, as well as the radial flux by solid material "rain out", which is crucial for triggering any gravity assisted formation of planetesimals. We show that fragmentation is the dominating effect in the inner regions of the disk leading to a dust surface density exponent of -1.5, while the outer regions at later times can become drift-dominated, yielding a dust surface density exponent of -0.75. Our results show that radial drift is not efficient in fragmenting dust grains. This supports the theory that small dust grains are resupplied by fragmentation due to the turbulent state of the disk.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2012;
originally announced January 2012.
-
Extrasolar planet population synthesis IV. Correlations with disk metallicity, mass and lifetime
Authors:
C. Mordasini,
Y. Alibert,
W. Benz,
H. Klahr,
T. Henning
Abstract:
Context. This is the fourth paper in a series showing the results of planet population synthesis calculations.
Aims. Our goal in this paper is to systematically study the effects of important disk properties, namely disk metallicity, mass and lifetime on fundamental planetary properties.
Methods. For a large number of protoplanetary disks we calculate a population of planets with our core accr…
▽ More
Context. This is the fourth paper in a series showing the results of planet population synthesis calculations.
Aims. Our goal in this paper is to systematically study the effects of important disk properties, namely disk metallicity, mass and lifetime on fundamental planetary properties.
Methods. For a large number of protoplanetary disks we calculate a population of planets with our core accretion formation model including planet migration and disk evolution.
Results. We find a large number of correlations: Regarding the planetary initial mass function, metallicity, disk mass and disk lifetime have different roles: For high [Fe/H], giant planets are more frequent. For high disk masses, giant planets are more massive. For long disk lifetimes, giant planets are both more frequent and massive. At low metallicities, very massive giant planets cannot form, but otherwise giant planet mass and metallicity are uncorrelated. In contrast, planet masses and disk gas masses are correlated. The sweet spot for giant planet formation is at 5 AU. In- and outside this distance, higher planetesimals surface densities are necessary. Low metallicities can be compensated by high disk masses, and vice versa, but not ad infinitum. At low metallicities, giant planets only form outside the ice line, while at high metallicities, giant planet formation occurs throughout the disk. The extent of migration increases with disk mass and lifetime and usually decreases with metallicity. No clear correlation of metallicity and the semimajor axis of giant planets exists because in low [Fe/H] disks, planets start further out, but migrate more, whereas for high [Fe/H] they start further in, but migrate less. Close-in low mass planets have a lower mean metallicity than Hot Jupiters.
Conclusions. The properties of protoplanetary disks are decisive for the properties of planets, and leave many imprints.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2012;
originally announced January 2012.
-
On the stability of radiation-pressure-dominated cavities
Authors:
Rolf Kuiper,
Hubert Klahr,
Henrik Beuther,
Thomas Henning
Abstract:
Context: When massive stars exert a radiation pressure onto their environment that is higher than their gravitational attraction, they launch a radiation-pressure-driven outflow. It has been claimed that a radiative Rayleigh-Taylor instability should lead to the collapse of the outflow cavity and foster the growth of massive stars.
Aims: We investigate the stability of idealized radiation-pressu…
▽ More
Context: When massive stars exert a radiation pressure onto their environment that is higher than their gravitational attraction, they launch a radiation-pressure-driven outflow. It has been claimed that a radiative Rayleigh-Taylor instability should lead to the collapse of the outflow cavity and foster the growth of massive stars.
Aims: We investigate the stability of idealized radiation-pressure-dominated cavities, focusing on its dependence on the radiation transport approach for the stellar radiation feedback.
Methods: We compare two different methods for stellar radiation feedback: gray flux-limited diffusion (FLD) and ray-tracing (RT). We also derive simple analytical models to support our findings.
Results: Only the FLD cases lead to prominent instability in the cavity shell. The RT cases do not show such instability. The gray FLD method underestimates the opacity at the location of the cavity shell and leads to extended epochs of marginal Eddington equilibrium in the cavity shell, making them prone to the radiative Rayleigh-Taylor instability. In the RT cases, the radiation pressure exceeds gravity by 1-2 orders of magnitude. The radiative Rayleigh-Taylor instability is then consequently suppressed.
Conclusions: Treating the stellar irradiation in the gray FLD approximation underestimates the radiative forces acting on the cavity shell. This can lead artificially to situations that are affected by the radiative Rayleigh-Taylor instability. The proper treatment of direct stellar irradiation by massive stars is crucial for the stability of radiation-pressure-dominated cavities.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
How do Most Planets Form? -- Constraints on Disk Instability from Direct Imaging
Authors:
Markus Janson,
Mariangela Bonavita,
Hubert Klahr,
David Lafreniere
Abstract:
Core accretion and disk instability have traditionally been regarded as the two competing possible paths of planet formation. In recent years, evidence have accumulated in favor of core accretion as the dominant mode, at least for close-in planets. However, it might be hypothesized that a significant population of wide planets formed by disk instabilities could exist at large separations, forming…
▽ More
Core accretion and disk instability have traditionally been regarded as the two competing possible paths of planet formation. In recent years, evidence have accumulated in favor of core accretion as the dominant mode, at least for close-in planets. However, it might be hypothesized that a significant population of wide planets formed by disk instabilities could exist at large separations, forming an invisible majority. In previous work, we addressed this issue through a direct imaging survey of B2--A0-type stars, and concluded that <30% of such stars form and retain planets and brown dwarfs through disk instability, leaving core accretion as the likely dominant mechanism. In this paper, we extend this analysis to FGKM-type stars by applying a similar analysis to the Gemini Deep Planet Survey (GDPS) sample. The results strengthen the conclusion that substellar companions formed and retained around their parent stars by disk instabilities are rare. Specifically, we find that the frequency of such companions is <8% for FGKM-type stars under our most conservative assumptions, for an outer disk radius of 300 AU, at 99% confidence. Furthermore, we find that the frequency is always <10% at 99% confidence independently of outer disk radius, for any radius from 5 to 500 AU. We also simulate migration at a wide range of rates, and find that the conclusions hold even if the companions move substantially after formation. Hence, core accretion remains the likely dominant formation mechanism for the total planet population, for every type of star from M-type through B-type.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
Large Scale Azimuthal Structures Of Turbulence In Accretion Disks - Dynamo triggered variability of accretion
Authors:
M. Flock,
N. Dzyurkevich,
H. Klahr,
N. Turner,
Th. Henning
Abstract:
We investigate the significance of large scale azimuthal, magnetic and velocity modes for the MRI turbulence in accretion disks. We perform 3D global ideal MHD simulations of global stratified proto-planetary disk models. Our domains span azimuthal angles of π/4, π/2, πand 2π. We observe up to 100% stronger magnetic fields and stronger turbulence for the restricted azimuthal domain models π/2 and…
▽ More
We investigate the significance of large scale azimuthal, magnetic and velocity modes for the MRI turbulence in accretion disks. We perform 3D global ideal MHD simulations of global stratified proto-planetary disk models. Our domains span azimuthal angles of π/4, π/2, πand 2π. We observe up to 100% stronger magnetic fields and stronger turbulence for the restricted azimuthal domain models π/2 and π/4 compared to the full 2πmodel. We show that for those models, the Maxwell Stress is larger due to strong axisymmetric magnetic fields, generated by the αΩdynamo. Large radial extended axisymmetric toroidal fields trigger temporal magnification of accretion stress. All models display a positive dynamo-αin the northern hemisphere (upper disk). The parity is distinct in each model and changes on timescales of 40 local orbits. In model 2π, the toroidal field is mostly antisymmetric in respect to the midplane. The eddies of the MRI turbulence are highly anisotropic. The major wavelengths of the turbulent velocity and magnetic fields are between one and two disk scale heights. At the midplane, we find magnetic tilt angles around 8-9 degree increasing up to 12-13 degree in the corona. We conclude that an azimuthal extent of πis sufficient to reproduce most turbulent properties in 3D global stratified simulations of magnetised accretion disks.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2011;
originally announced October 2011.
-
High-contrast Imaging Search for Planets and Brown Dwarfs around the Most Massive Stars in the Solar Neighborhood
Authors:
Markus Janson,
Mariangela Bonavita,
Hubert Klahr,
David Lafreniere,
Ray Jayawardhana,
Hans Zinnecker
Abstract:
There has been a long-standing discussion in the literature as to whether core accretion or disk instability is the dominant mode of planet formation. Over the last decade, several lines of evidence have been presented showing that core accretion is most likely the dominant mechanism for the close-in population of planets probed by radial velocity and transits. However, this does not by itself pro…
▽ More
There has been a long-standing discussion in the literature as to whether core accretion or disk instability is the dominant mode of planet formation. Over the last decade, several lines of evidence have been presented showing that core accretion is most likely the dominant mechanism for the close-in population of planets probed by radial velocity and transits. However, this does not by itself prove that core accretion is the dominant mode for the total planet population, since disk instability might conceivably produce and retain large numbers of planets in the far-out regions of the disk. If this is a relevant scenario, then the outer massive disks of B-stars should be among the best places for massive planets and brown dwarfs to form and reside. In this study, we present high-contrast imaging of 18 nearby massive stars, of which 15 are in the B2--A0 spectral type range and provide excellent sensitivity to wide companions. By comparing our sensitivities to model predictions of disk instability based on physical criteria for fragmentation and cooling, and using Monte-Carlo simulations for orbital distributions, we find that ~85 % of such companions should have been detected in our images on average. Given this high degree of completeness, stringent statistical limits can be set from the null-detection result, even with the limited sample size. We find that <32 % of massive stars form and retain disk instability planets, brown dwarfs and very low-mass stars of <100 Mjup within 300 AU, at 99 % confidence. These results, combined with previous findings in the literature, lead to the conclusion that core accretion is likely the dominant mode of planet formation.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2011;
originally announced May 2011.
-
3D MHD Simulations of Planet Migration in Turbulent Stratified Disks
Authors:
Ana Uribe,
Hubert Klahr,
Mario Flock,
Thomas Henning
Abstract:
We performed 3D MHD simulations of planet migration in stratified disks using the Godunov code PLUTO, where the disk is turbulent due to the magnetorotational instability. We study the migration for planets with different planet-star mass ratios $q=M_{p}/M_{s}$. In agreement with previous studies, for the low-mass planet cases ($q=5\times10^{-6}$ and $10^{-5}$), migration is dominated by random fl…
▽ More
We performed 3D MHD simulations of planet migration in stratified disks using the Godunov code PLUTO, where the disk is turbulent due to the magnetorotational instability. We study the migration for planets with different planet-star mass ratios $q=M_{p}/M_{s}$. In agreement with previous studies, for the low-mass planet cases ($q=5\times10^{-6}$ and $10^{-5}$), migration is dominated by random fluctuations in the torque. For a Jupiter-mass planet $(q=M_{p}/M_{s}=10^{-3}$ for $M_{s}=1M_{\odot})$, we find a reduction of the magnetic stress inside the orbit of the planet and around the gap region. After an initial stage where the torque on the planet is positive, it reverses and we recover migration rates similar to those found in disks where the turbulent viscosity is modelled by an $α$ viscosity. For the intermediate-mass planets ($q=5\times10^{-5}, 10^{-4}$ and $2\times10^{-4}$) we find a new and so far unexpected behavior. In some cases they experience sustained and systematic outwards migration for the entire duration of the simulation. For this case, the horseshoe region is resolved and torques coming from the corotation region can remain unsaturated due to the stresses in the disk. These stresses are generated directly by the magnetic field. The magnitude of the horseshoe drag can overcome the negative Lindblad contribution when the local surface density profile is flat or increasing outwards, which we see in certain locations in our simulations due to the presence of a zonal flow. The intermediate-mass planet is migrating radially outwards in locations where there is a positive gradient of a pressure bump (zonal flow).
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2011;
originally announced May 2011.
-
Turbulence and Steady Flows in 3D Global Stratified MHD Simulations of Accretion Disks
Authors:
M. Flock,
N. Dzyurkevich,
H. Klahr,
N. J. Turner,
Th. Henning
Abstract:
We present full 2 Pi global 3-D stratified MHD simulations of accretion disks. We interpret our results in the context of proto-planetary disks. We investigate the turbulence driven by the magneto-rotational instability (MRI) using the PLUTO Godunov code in spherical coordinates with the accurate and robust HLLD Riemann solver. We follow the turbulence for more than 1500 orbits at the innermost ra…
▽ More
We present full 2 Pi global 3-D stratified MHD simulations of accretion disks. We interpret our results in the context of proto-planetary disks. We investigate the turbulence driven by the magneto-rotational instability (MRI) using the PLUTO Godunov code in spherical coordinates with the accurate and robust HLLD Riemann solver. We follow the turbulence for more than 1500 orbits at the innermost radius of the domain to measure the overall strength of turbulent motions and the detailed accretion flow pattern. We find that regions within two scale heights of the midplane have a turbulent Mach number of about 0.1 and a magnetic pressure two to three orders of magnitude less than the gas pressure, while outside three scale heights the magnetic pressure equals or exceeds the gas pressure and the turbulence is transonic, leading to large density fluctuations. The strongest large-scale density disturbances are spiral density waves, and the strongest of these waves has m=5. No clear meridional circulation appears in the calculations because fluctuating radial pressure gradients lead to changes in the orbital frequency, comparable in importance to the stress gradients that drive the meridional flows in viscous models. The net mass flow rate is well-reproduced by a viscous model using the mean stress distribution taken from the MHD calculation. The strength of the mean turbulent magnetic field is inversely proportional to the radius, so the fields are approximately force-free on the largest scales. Consequently the accretion stress falls off as the inverse square of the radius.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
Theory of planet formation and comparison with observation: Formation of the planetary mass-radius relationship
Authors:
C. Mordasini,
Y. Alibert,
W. Benz,
H. Klahr
Abstract:
The planetary mass-radius diagram is an observational result of central importance to understand planet formation. We present an updated version of our planet formation model based on the core accretion paradigm which allows to calculate planetary radii and luminosities during the entire formation and evolution of the planets. We first study with it the formation of Jupiter, and compare with previ…
▽ More
The planetary mass-radius diagram is an observational result of central importance to understand planet formation. We present an updated version of our planet formation model based on the core accretion paradigm which allows to calculate planetary radii and luminosities during the entire formation and evolution of the planets. We first study with it the formation of Jupiter, and compare with previous works. Then we conduct planetary population synthesis calculations to obtain a synthetic mass-radius diagram which we compare with the observed one. Except for bloated Hot Jupiters which can be explained only with additional mechanisms related to their proximity to the star, we find a good agreement of the general shape of the observed and the synthetic mass-radius diagram. This shape can be understood with basic concepts of the core accretion model.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
-
Three-dimensional simulation of massive star formation in the disk accretion scenario
Authors:
Rolf Kuiper,
Hubert Klahr,
Henrik Beuther,
Thomas Henning
Abstract:
The most massive stars can form via standard disk accretion - despite of the radiation pressure generated - due to the fact that the massive accretion disk yields a strong anisotropy in the radiation field, releasing most of the radiation pressure perpendicular to the disk accretion flow. Here, we analyze the self-gravity of the forming circumstellar disk as the potential major driver of the angul…
▽ More
The most massive stars can form via standard disk accretion - despite of the radiation pressure generated - due to the fact that the massive accretion disk yields a strong anisotropy in the radiation field, releasing most of the radiation pressure perpendicular to the disk accretion flow. Here, we analyze the self-gravity of the forming circumstellar disk as the potential major driver of the angular momentum transport in such massive disks responsible for the high accretion rates needed for the formation of massive stars. For this purpose, we perform self-gravity radiation hydrodynamics simulations of the collapse of massive pre-stellar cores. The formation and evolution of the resulting circumstellar disk is investigated in 1.) axially symmetric simulations using an alpha-shear-viscosity prescription and 2.) a three-dimensional simulation, in which the angular momentum transport is provided self-consistently by develo** gravitational torques in the self-gravitating accretion disk. The simulation series of different strength of the alpha-viscosity shows that the accretion history of the forming star is mostly independent of the alpha-viscosity-parameter. The accretion history of the three-dimensional run driven by self-gravity is more time-dependent than the viscous disk evolution in axial symmetry. The mean accretion rate, i.e. the stellar mass growth, is nearly identical to the alpha-viscosity models. We conclude that the development of gravitational torques in self-gravitating disks around forming massive stars provides a self-consistent mechanism to efficiently transport the angular momentum to outer disk radii. Also the formation of the most massive stars can therefore be understood in the standard accretion disk scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2011; v1 submitted 20 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
-
Radiation pressure feedback in the formation of massive stars
Authors:
Rolf Kuiper,
Hubert Klahr,
Henrik Beuther,
Thomas Henning
Abstract:
We investigate the radiation pressure feedback in the formation of massive stars in 1, 2, and 3D radiation hydrodynamics simulations of the collapse of massive pre-stellar cores. In contrast to previous research, we consider frequency dependent stellar radiation feedback, resolve the dust sublimation front in the vicinity of the forming star down to 1.27 AU, compute the evolution for several 10^5…
▽ More
We investigate the radiation pressure feedback in the formation of massive stars in 1, 2, and 3D radiation hydrodynamics simulations of the collapse of massive pre-stellar cores. In contrast to previous research, we consider frequency dependent stellar radiation feedback, resolve the dust sublimation front in the vicinity of the forming star down to 1.27 AU, compute the evolution for several 10^5 yrs covering the whole accretion phase of the forming star, and perform a comprehensive survey of the parameter space. The most fundamental result is that the formation of a massive accretion disk in slowly rotating cores preserves a high anisotropy in the radiation field. The thermal radiation escapes through the optically thin atmosphere, effectively diminishing the radiation pressure feedback onto the accretion flow. Gravitational torques in the self-gravitating disk drive a sufficiently high accretion rate to overcome the residual radiation pressure. Simultaneously, the radiation pressure launches an outflow in the bipolar direction, which grows in angle with time and releases a substantial fraction of the initial core mass from the star-disk system. Summarized, for an initial core mass of 60, 120, 240, and 480 Msol these mechanisms allow the star to grow up to 28.2, 56.5, 92.6, and at least 137.2 Msol respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
-
Application of recent results on the orbital migration of low mass planets: convergence zones
Authors:
C. Mordasini,
K. -M. Dittkrist,
Y. Alibert,
H. Klahr,
W. Benz,
T. Henning
Abstract:
Previous models of the combined growth and migration of protoplanets needed large ad hoc reduction factors for the type I migration rate as found in the isothermal approximation. In order to eliminate these factors, a simple semi-analytical model is presented that incorporates recent results on the migration of low mass planets in non-isothermal disks. It allows for outward migration. The model is…
▽ More
Previous models of the combined growth and migration of protoplanets needed large ad hoc reduction factors for the type I migration rate as found in the isothermal approximation. In order to eliminate these factors, a simple semi-analytical model is presented that incorporates recent results on the migration of low mass planets in non-isothermal disks. It allows for outward migration. The model is used to conduct planetary populations synthesis calculations. Two points with zero torque are found in the disks. Planets migrate both in- and outward towards these convergence zones. They could be important for accelerating planetary growth by concentrating matter in one point. We also find that the updated type I migration models allow the formation of both close-in low mass planets, but also of giant planets at large semimajor axes. The problem of too rapid migration is significantly mitigated.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2011;
originally announced January 2011.