-
3D non-LTE modeling of the stellar center-to-limb variation for transmission spectroscopy studies
Authors:
G. Canocchi,
K. Lind,
C. Lagae,
A. G. M. Pietrow,
A. M. Amarsi,
D. Kiselman,
O. Andriienko,
H. J. Hoeijmakers
Abstract:
Context. Transmission spectroscopy is one of the most powerful techniques to characterize transiting exoplanets since it allows to measure the abundance of the atomic and molecular species in the planetary atmosphere. However, the stellar lines can bias the determination of such abundances if their center-to-limb variations (CLVs) are not properly accounted for.
Aims. This paper aims to show tha…
▽ More
Context. Transmission spectroscopy is one of the most powerful techniques to characterize transiting exoplanets since it allows to measure the abundance of the atomic and molecular species in the planetary atmosphere. However, the stellar lines can bias the determination of such abundances if their center-to-limb variations (CLVs) are not properly accounted for.
Aims. This paper aims to show that three-dimensional (3D) radiation hydrodynamic models and non-local thermodynamic equilibrium (non-LTE) line formation are required for an accurate modeling of the stellar CLV of the Na I D$_1$ and K I resonance lines on transmission spectra.
Methods. We model the CLV of the Na I D$_1$ and K I resonance lines in the Sun with 3D non-LTE radiative transfer. The synthetic spectra are compared to solar observations with high spatial and spectral resolution, including new data collected with the CRISP instrument at the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope between $μ=0.1$ and $μ=1.0$.
Results. Our 3D non-LTE modeling of the Na I D$_1$ resonance line at 5896 Å and the K I 7699 Å resonance line in the Sun is in good agreement with the observed CLV in the solar spectrum. The simulated CLV curve for a Jupiter-Sun system inferred with a 3D non-LTE analysis shows significant differences from that obtained from a 1D atmosphere. The latter tends to overestimate the amplitude of the transmission curve by a factor that is of the same order of magnitude as a planetary absorption depth (up to 0.2 %).
Conclusions. In order to correctly characterize exoplanetary atmospheres, 3D non-LTE synthetic spectra should be used to estimate the stellar CLV effect in transmission spectra of solar-like planet hosts. The work will be extended to other lines and FGK-type stars, allowing synthetic high-resolution spectra to mitigate the stellar contamination of low-resolution planetary spectra, e.g. those from JWST.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Center-to-limb variation of spectral lines and continua observed with SST/CRISP and SST/CHROMIS
Authors:
A. G. M. Pietrow,
D. Kiselman,
O. Andriienko,
D. J. M. Petit dit de la Roche,
C. J. Díaz Baso,
F. Calvo
Abstract:
Observations of center-to-limb variations (CLV) of spectral lines and continua provide a good test for the accuracy of models of solar and stellar atmospheric structure and spectral-line formation. They are also widely used to constrain elemental abundances and are becoming increasingly important in atmospheric studies of exoplanets. However, only a few such data sets exist for chromospheric lines…
▽ More
Observations of center-to-limb variations (CLV) of spectral lines and continua provide a good test for the accuracy of models of solar and stellar atmospheric structure and spectral-line formation. They are also widely used to constrain elemental abundances and are becoming increasingly important in atmospheric studies of exoplanets. However, only a few such data sets exist for chromospheric lines. We aim to create a set of standard profiles by means of mosaics made with the CRISP and CHROMIS instruments of the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope (SST), as well as to explore the robustness of said profiles obtained using this method. For each spectral line we use a mosaic that ranges from the center to the limb. Each of these mosaics are averaged down to 50 individual spectral profiles, spaced by 0.02 in the $μ$ scale. These profiles are corrected for p-mode oscillations, and their line parameters (equivalent width, line shift, full-width at half-maximum, and line depth) are then compared against literature values where possible. We present a set of 50 average profiles that are spaced equidistantly along the cosine of the heliocentric angle ($μ$) by steps of 0.02 for five continuum points between 4001 and 7772 Å, as well as ten of the most commonly observed spectral lines at the SST (Ca II H & K, H$β$, Mg I 5173 Å, C I 5380 Å, Fe I 6173 Å, Fe I 6301 Å, H$α$, O I 7772 Å, and Ca II 8542 Å). Center-to-limb variation of line profiles and continua are shared in the CDS as machine-readable tables; providing a quantitative constraint on theoretical models that aim to model stellar atmospheres.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2023; v1 submitted 7 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Physical properties of a fan-shaped jet backlit by an X9.3 flare
Authors:
A. G. M. Pietrow,
M. Druett,
J. de la Cruz Rodriguez,
F. Calvo,
D. Kiselman
Abstract:
Fan-shaped jets can be observed above light bridges and are driven by reconnection of the vertical umbral field with the more horizontal field above the light bridges. Because these jets are not fully opaque in chromospheric lines, one cannot study their spectra without the highly complex considerations of radiative transfer in spectral lines from the atmosphere behind the fan. We get around this…
▽ More
Fan-shaped jets can be observed above light bridges and are driven by reconnection of the vertical umbral field with the more horizontal field above the light bridges. Because these jets are not fully opaque in chromospheric lines, one cannot study their spectra without the highly complex considerations of radiative transfer in spectral lines from the atmosphere behind the fan. We get around this by taking advantage of a unique set of observations of the H$α$ line along with the Ca II 8542 and Ca II K lines obtained with the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope where a fan-shaped jet was backlit by an X9.3 flare. The H$α$ flare ribbon emission profiles from behind the fan are highly broadened and flattened, allowing us to investigate the fan as if it were backlit by continuous emission. Using this model we derived the opacity and velocity of the material in the jet and what we believe to be the first observationally derived estimate of the mass and density of material in a fan-shaped jet. Using inversions of Ca II 8542 emission via STiC, we were also able to estimate the temperature in the jet. Finally, we use the masses and POS and LOS velocities as functions of time to investigate the downward supply of energy and momentum to the photosphere in the collapse of this jet, and evaluate it as a potential driver for a sunquake beneath. We found that the physical properties of the fan material are reasonably chromospheric in nature, with a temperature of 7050 $\pm$ 250 K and a mean density of 2 $\pm$ 0.3 $\times$ 10$^{-11}$ g cm$^{-3}$. The total mass observed in $\mathrm{Hα}$ was found to be 3.9 $\pm$ 0.7 $\times$ 10$^{13}$g and the kinetic energy delivered to the base of the fan in its collapse was nearly two orders of magnitude below typical sunquake energies. We therefore rule out this jet as the sunquake driver, but cannot completely rule out larger fan jets as potential drivers.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2021; v1 submitted 20 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Inference of the chromospheric magnetic field configuration of solar plage using the Ca II 8542 Å line
Authors:
A. G. M. Pietrow,
D. Kiselman,
J. de la Cruz Rodríguez,
C. J. Díaz Baso,
A. Pastor Yabar,
R. Yadav
Abstract:
It has so far proven impossible to reproduce all aspects of the solar plage chromosphere in quasi-realistic numerical models. The magnetic field configuration in the lower atmosphere is one of the few free parameters in such simulations. The literature only offers proxy-based estimates of the field strength, as it is difficult to obtain observational constraints in this region. Sufficiently sensit…
▽ More
It has so far proven impossible to reproduce all aspects of the solar plage chromosphere in quasi-realistic numerical models. The magnetic field configuration in the lower atmosphere is one of the few free parameters in such simulations. The literature only offers proxy-based estimates of the field strength, as it is difficult to obtain observational constraints in this region. Sufficiently sensitive spectro-polarimetric measurements require a high signal-to-noise ratio, spectral resolution, and cadence, which are at the limit of current capabilities. We use critically sampled spectro-polarimetric observations of the \cair line obtained with the CRISP instrument of the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope to study the strength and inclination of the chromospheric magnetic field of a plage region. This will provide direct physics-based estimates of these values, which could aid modelers to put constraints on plage models. We increased the signal-to-noise ratio of the data by applying several methods including deep learning and PCA. We estimated the noise level to be $1\cdot10^{-3} I_c$. We then used STiC, a non-local thermodynamic equilibrium (NLTE) inversion code to infer the atmospheric structure and magnetic field pixel by pixel. We are able to infer the magnetic field strength and inclination for a plage region and for fibrils in the surrounding canopy. In the plage we report an absolute field strength of $|B| =440 \pm 90$ G, with an inclination of $10^\circ \pm 16^\circ$ with respect to the local vertical. This value for $|B|$ is roughly double of what was reported previously, while the inclination matches previous studies done in the photosphere. In the fibrillar region we found $|B| = 300 \pm 50$ G, with an inclination of $50^\circ \pm 13^\circ$.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2020; v1 submitted 25 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Solar off-limb emission of the OI 7772 Å line
Authors:
Hiva Pazira,
D. Kiselman,
J. Leenaarts
Abstract:
The aim of this paper is to understand the formation of the OI line at 7772 Å in the solar chromosphere. We used SST/CRISP observations to observe OI 7772 Å in several places around the solar limb. We compared the observations with synthetic spectra calculated with the RH code in the one-dimension spherical geometry mode. New accurate hydrogen collisional rates were included for the RH calculation…
▽ More
The aim of this paper is to understand the formation of the OI line at 7772 Å in the solar chromosphere. We used SST/CRISP observations to observe OI 7772 Å in several places around the solar limb. We compared the observations with synthetic spectra calculated with the RH code in the one-dimension spherical geometry mode. New accurate hydrogen collisional rates were included for the RH calculations. The observations reveal a dark gap in the lower chromosphere, which is caused by variations in the line opacity as shown by our models. The lower level of the 7772 Å transition is populated by a downward cascade from the continuum. We study the effect of Lyman-$β$ pum** and hydrogen collisions between the triplet and quintet system in OI. Both have a small but non-negligible influence on the line intensity.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Non-LTE line formation of Fe in late-type stars IV: Modelling of the solar centre-to-limb variation in 3D
Authors:
K. Lind,
A. M. Amarsi,
M. Asplund,
P. S. Barklem,
M. Bautista,
M. Bergemann,
R. Collet,
D. Kiselman,
J. Leenaarts,
T. M. D. Pereira
Abstract:
Our ability to model the shapes and strengths of iron lines in the solar spectrum is a critical test of the accuracy of the solar iron abundance, which sets the absolute zero-point of all stellar metallicities. We use an extensive 463-level Fe atom with new photoionisation cross-sections for FeI as well as quantum mechanical calculations of collisional excitation and charge transfer with neutral h…
▽ More
Our ability to model the shapes and strengths of iron lines in the solar spectrum is a critical test of the accuracy of the solar iron abundance, which sets the absolute zero-point of all stellar metallicities. We use an extensive 463-level Fe atom with new photoionisation cross-sections for FeI as well as quantum mechanical calculations of collisional excitation and charge transfer with neutral hydrogen; the latter effectively remove a free parameter that has hampered all previous line formation studies of Fe in non-local thermodynamic equilibrium (NLTE). For the first time, we use realistic 3D NLTE calculations of Fe for a quantitative comparison to solar observations. We confront our theoretical line profiles with observations taken at different viewing angles across the solar disk with the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope. We find that 3D modelling well reproduces the observed centre-to-limb behaviour of spectral lines overall, but highlight aspects that may require further work, especially cross-sections for inelastic collisions with electrons. Our inferred solar iron abundance is log(eps(Fe))=7.48+-0.04.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Stable Umbral Chromospheric Structures
Authors:
V. M. J. Henriques,
E. Scullion,
M. Mathioudakis,
D. Kiselman,
P. T. Gallagher,
F. P. Keenan
Abstract:
Aims. To understand the morphology of the chromosphere in sunspot umbra. We investigate if the horizontal structures observed in the spectral core of the Ca II H line are ephemeral visuals caused by the shock dynamics of more stable structures, and examine their relationship with observables in the H-alpha line. Methods. Filtergrams in the core of the Ca II H and H-alpha lines as observed with the…
▽ More
Aims. To understand the morphology of the chromosphere in sunspot umbra. We investigate if the horizontal structures observed in the spectral core of the Ca II H line are ephemeral visuals caused by the shock dynamics of more stable structures, and examine their relationship with observables in the H-alpha line. Methods. Filtergrams in the core of the Ca II H and H-alpha lines as observed with the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope are employed. We utilise a technique that creates composite images and tracks the flash propagation horizontally. Results. We find 0"15 wide horizontal structures, in all of the three target sunspots, for every flash where the seeing was moderate to good. Discrete dark structures are identified that are stable for at least two umbral flashes, as well as systems of structures that live for up to 24 minutes. We find cases of extremely extended structures with similar stability, with one such structure showing an extent of 5". Some of these structures have a correspondence in H-alpha but we were unable to find a one to one correspondence for every occurrence. If the dark streaks are formed at the same heights as umbral flashes then there are systems of structures with strong departures from the vertical for all three analysed sunspots. Conclusions. Long-lived Ca II H filamentary horizontal structures are a common and likely ever-present feature in the umbra of sunspots. If the magnetic field in the chromosphere of the umbra is indeed aligned with the structures, then the present theoretical understanding of the typical umbra needs to be revisited.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Is the solar spectrum latitude dependent? An investigation with SST/TRIPPEL
Authors:
Dan Kiselman,
Tiago Pereira,
Bengt Gustafsson,
Martin Asplund,
Jorge Meléndez,
Kai Langhans
Abstract:
Context: In studies of the solar spectrum relative to spectra of solar twin stars, it has been found that the chemical composition of the Sun seems to depart systematically from those of the twins. One possible explanation is that the effect is due to the special aspect angle of the Sun when observed from Earth, as compared with the aspect angles of the twins. Thus, a latitude dependence of the so…
▽ More
Context: In studies of the solar spectrum relative to spectra of solar twin stars, it has been found that the chemical composition of the Sun seems to depart systematically from those of the twins. One possible explanation is that the effect is due to the special aspect angle of the Sun when observed from Earth, as compared with the aspect angles of the twins. Thus, a latitude dependence of the solar spectrum, even with the heliocentric angle constant, could lead to effects of the type observed.
Aim: We explore a possible variation in the strength of certain spectral lines, used in the comparisons between the composition of the Sun and the twins, at loci on the solar disk with different latitudes but at constant heliocentric angle.
Methods: We use the TRIPPEL spectrograph at the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope on La Palma to record spectra in five spectral regions in order to compare different locations on the solar disk at a heliocentric angle of 45 deg. Equivalent widths and other parameters are measured for fifteen different lines representing nine atomic species.
Results: The relative variations in equivalent widths at the equator and at solar latitude 45 deg are found to be less than 1.5 % for all spectral lines studied. Translated to elemental abundances as they would be measured from a terrestrial and a hypothetical pole-on observer, the difference is estimated to be within 0.005 dex in all cases.
Conclusion: It is very unlikely that latitude effects could cause the reported abundance difference between the Sun and the solar twins. The accuracy obtainable in measurements of small differences in spectral line strengths between different solar disk positions is very high.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2011; v1 submitted 23 August, 2011;
originally announced August 2011.
-
A tilted interference filter in a converging beam
Authors:
Mats G. Löfdahl,
Vasco M. J. Henriques,
Dan Kiselman
Abstract:
Context. Narrow-band interference filters can be tuned toward shorter wavelengths by tilting them from the perpendicular to the optical axis. This can be used as a cheap alternative to real tunable filters, such as Fabry-Pérot interferometers and Lyot filters. At the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope, such a setup is used to scan through the blue wing of the Ca II H line. Because the filter is mounted i…
▽ More
Context. Narrow-band interference filters can be tuned toward shorter wavelengths by tilting them from the perpendicular to the optical axis. This can be used as a cheap alternative to real tunable filters, such as Fabry-Pérot interferometers and Lyot filters. At the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope, such a setup is used to scan through the blue wing of the Ca II H line. Because the filter is mounted in a converging beam, the incident angle varies over the pupil, which causes a variation of the transmission over the pupil, different for each wavelength within the passband. This causes broadening of the filter transmission profile and degradation of the image quality. Aims. We want to characterize the properties of our filter, at normal incidence as well as at different tilt angles. Knowing the broadened profile is important for the interpretation of the solar images. Compensating the images for the degrading effects will improve the resolution and remove one source of image contrast degradation. In particular, we need to solve the latter problem for images that are also compensated for blurring caused by atmospheric turbulence. Methods. We simulate the process of image formation through a tilted interference filter in order to understand the effects. We test the hypothesis that they are separable from the effects of wavefront aberrations for the purpose of image deconvolution. We measure the filter transmission profile and the degrading PSF from calibration data. Results. We find that the filter transmission profile differs significantly from the specifications.We demonstrate how to compensate for the image-degrading effects. Because the filter tilt effects indeed appear to be separable from wavefront aberrations in a useful way, this can be done in a final deconvolution, after standard image restoration with MFBD/Phase Diversity based methods. We illustrate the technique with real data.
△ Less
Submitted 30 August, 2011; v1 submitted 4 August, 2011;
originally announced August 2011.
-
Solar velocity references from 3D HD photospheric models
Authors:
Jaime de la Cruz Rodríguez,
Dan Kiselman,
Mats Carlsson
Abstract:
The measurement of Doppler velocities in spectroscopic solar observations requires a reference for the local frame of rest. The rotational and radial velocities of the Earth and the rotation of the Sun introduce velocity offsets in the observations. Normally, good references for velocities are missing (e.g. telluric lines), especially in filter-based spectropolarimetric observations. We determine…
▽ More
The measurement of Doppler velocities in spectroscopic solar observations requires a reference for the local frame of rest. The rotational and radial velocities of the Earth and the rotation of the Sun introduce velocity offsets in the observations. Normally, good references for velocities are missing (e.g. telluric lines), especially in filter-based spectropolarimetric observations. We determine an absolute reference for line-of-sight velocities measured from solar observations for any heliocentric angle, calibrating the convective line shift of spatially-averaged profiles on quiet sun from a 3D hydrodynamical simulation. This method works whenever there is quiet sun in the field-of-view, and it has the advantage of being relatively insensitive to uncertainties in the atomic data. We carry out radiative transfer computations in LTE for selected C I and Fe I lines, whereas the Ca II infrared lines are synthesized in non-LTE. The degree of asymmetry and the line shifts, however, show a clear dependence on the heliocentric angle and the properties of the lines. The profiles at μ= 1 are compared with observed profiles to prove their reliability, and they are tested against errors induced by the LTE calculations, inaccuracies in the atomic data and the 3D simulation. Theoretical quiet-sun profiles of lines commonly used by solar observers are provided to the community. Those can be used as absolute references for line-of-sight velocities. The limb effect is produced by the projection of the 3D atmosphere along the line of sight. We estimate the precision of the disk-center line shifts to be approximately 50 m s^-1, but the off-center profiles remain to be tested against observations.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2011;
originally announced January 2011.
-
Testing 3D solar models against observations
Authors:
Tiago M. D. Pereira,
Martin Asplund,
Dan Kiselman
Abstract:
We present results from a series of observational tests to 3D and 1D solar models. In particular, emphasis is given to the line formation of atomic oxygen lines, used to derive the much debated solar oxygen photospheric abundance. Using high-quality observations obtained with the Swedish Solar Telescope (SST) we study the centre-to-limb variation of the O I lines, testing the models and line for…
▽ More
We present results from a series of observational tests to 3D and 1D solar models. In particular, emphasis is given to the line formation of atomic oxygen lines, used to derive the much debated solar oxygen photospheric abundance. Using high-quality observations obtained with the Swedish Solar Telescope (SST) we study the centre-to-limb variation of the O I lines, testing the models and line formation (LTE and non-LTE). For the O I 777 nm triplet, the centre-to-limb variation sets strong constraints in the non-LTE line formation, and is used to derive an empirical correction factor (S_H) to the classical Drawin recipe for neutral hydrogen collisions. Taking advantage of the spatially-resolved character of the SST data, an additional framework for testing the 3D model and line formation is also studied. From the tests we confirm that the employed 3D model is realistic and its predictions agree very well with the observations.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
-
Oxygen lines in solar granulation. II. Centre-to-limb variation, NLTE line formation, blends and the solar oxygen abundance
Authors:
Tiago M. D. Pereira,
Martin Asplund,
Dan Kiselman
Abstract:
Context: There is a lively debate about the solar oxygen abundance and the role of 3D models in its recent downward revision. The models have been tested using high resolution solar atlases. Further testing can be done using centre-to-limb variations. Aims: Using high quality observations of oxygen lines across the solar surface we seek to test if the 3D and 1D models reproduce their observed ce…
▽ More
Context: There is a lively debate about the solar oxygen abundance and the role of 3D models in its recent downward revision. The models have been tested using high resolution solar atlases. Further testing can be done using centre-to-limb variations. Aims: Using high quality observations of oxygen lines across the solar surface we seek to test if the 3D and 1D models reproduce their observed centre-to-limb variation (CLV). In particular we seek to assess whether the 3D model is appropriate to derive the solar oxygen abundance. Methods: We use our recent observations of OI 777 nm, OI 615.81 nm, [OI] 630.03 nm and nine lines of other elements for five viewing angles 0.2<mu<1 of the quiet solar disk. We compare them with the predicted line profiles from the 3D and 1D models computed using the most up-to-date line formation codes, line data and allowing for departures of LTE. The CLV of the OI 777 nm lines is also used to obtain an empirical correction for the poorly known efficiency of the inelastic collisions with H. Results: The 3D model generally reproduces the CLV observations of the lines very well, particularly the oxygen lines. From the OI 777 nm lines we find that the classical Drawin recipe slightly overestimates H collisions. The limb observations of the OI 615.82 nm line allow us to identify a previously unknown contribution of molecules for this line, prevalent at the solar limb. A detailed treatment of the [OI] 630.03 nm line shows that the 3D modeling provides an excellent agreement with the observations. The derived oxygen abundances with the 3D model are 8.68 (OI 777 nm), 8.66 ([OI] 630.03 nm) and 8.62 (OI 615.82 nm). Conclusions: These additional tests have reinforced the trustworthiness of the 3D model and line formation for abundance analyses.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
-
Oxygen lines in solar granulation. I. Testing 3D models against new observations with high spatial and spectral resolution
Authors:
Tiago M. D. Pereira,
Dan Kiselman,
Martin Asplund
Abstract:
Aims: we seek to provide additional tests of the line formation of theoretical 3D solar photosphere models. In particular, we set out to test the spatially-resolved line formation at several viewing angles, from the solar disk-centre to the limb and focusing on atomic oxygen lines. The purpose of these tests is to provide additional information on whether the 3D model is suitable to derive the s…
▽ More
Aims: we seek to provide additional tests of the line formation of theoretical 3D solar photosphere models. In particular, we set out to test the spatially-resolved line formation at several viewing angles, from the solar disk-centre to the limb and focusing on atomic oxygen lines. The purpose of these tests is to provide additional information on whether the 3D model is suitable to derive the solar oxygen abundance. We also aim to empirically constrain the NLTE recipes for neutral hydrogen collisions, using the spatially-resolved observations of the OI 777 nm lines. Methods: using the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope we obtained high-spatial-resolution observations of five atomic oxygen lines (along with lines for other species) for five positions on the solar disk. These observations have a high spatial and spectral resolution, and a continuum intensity contrast up to 9% at 615 nm. The theoretical line profiles were computed using the 3D model, with a full 3D NLTE treatment for oxygen and LTE for the other lines. Results: at disk-centre we find an excellent agreement between predicted and observed line shifts, strengths, FWHM and asymmetries. At other viewing angles the agreement is also good, but the smaller continuum intensity contrast makes a quantitative comparison harder. We use the disk-centre observations we constrain S_H, the scaling factor for the efficiency of collisions with neutral hydrogen. We find that S_H=1 provides the best match to the observations. Conclusions: overall there is a very good agreement between predicted and observed line properties over the solar granulation. This further reinforces the view that the 3D model is realistic and a reliable tool to derive the solar oxygen abundance.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
-
Neutral oxygen spectral line formation revisited with new collisional data: large departures from LTE at low metallicity
Authors:
D. Fabbian,
M. Asplund,
P. S. Barklem,
M. Carlsson,
D. Kiselman
Abstract:
We present a detailed study of the non-Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium (non-LTE) formation of the high-excitation neutral oxygen 777 nm triplet in MARCS model atmospheres representative of late-type stars with spectral types F to K. We carried out the calculations using the statistical equilibrium code MULTI, including estimates of the impact on elemental abundance analysis. The atomic model emp…
▽ More
We present a detailed study of the non-Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium (non-LTE) formation of the high-excitation neutral oxygen 777 nm triplet in MARCS model atmospheres representative of late-type stars with spectral types F to K. We carried out the calculations using the statistical equilibrium code MULTI, including estimates of the impact on elemental abundance analysis. The atomic model employed includes, in particular, recent quantum-mechanical electron collision data. We confirm that the O I triplet lines form under non-LTE conditions in late-type stars, suffering negative abundance corrections with respect to LTE. At low metallicity, large line opacity stems from triplet-quintet intersystem electron collisions, a form of coupling previously not considered or seriously underestimated. The non-LTE effects become generally severe for models (both giants and dwarfs) with higher T_eff. Interestingly, in metal-poor turn-off stars, the negative non-LTE abundance corrections tend to rapidly become more severe towards lower metallicity. When neglecting H collisions, they amount to as much as ~ 0.9 dex and ~ 1.2 dex, respectively at [Fe/H]=-3 and [Fe/H]=-3.5. Even when such collisions are included, the LTE abundance remains a serious overestimate, correspondingly by ~ 0.5 dex and ~ 0.9 dex at such low metallicities. Although the poorly known inelastic hydrogen collisions thus remain an important uncertainty, the large metallicity-dependent non-LTE effects seem to point to a resulting "low" (compared to LTE) [O/Fe] in metal-poor halo stars.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2009;
originally announced February 2009.
-
CRISP Spectropolarimetric Imaging of Penumbral Fine Structure
Authors:
G. B. Scharmer,
G. Narayan,
T. Hillberg,
J. de la Cruz Rodriguez,
M. G. Lofdahl,
D. Kiselman,
P. Sutterlin,
M. van Noort,
A. Lagg
Abstract:
We discuss penumbral fine structure in a small part of a pore, observed with the CRISP imaging spectropolarimeter at the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope (SST), close to its diffraction limit of 0.16 arcsec. Milne-Eddington inversions applied to these Stokes data reveal large variations of field strength and inclination angle over dark-cored penumbral intrusions and a dark-cored light bridge. The mid…
▽ More
We discuss penumbral fine structure in a small part of a pore, observed with the CRISP imaging spectropolarimeter at the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope (SST), close to its diffraction limit of 0.16 arcsec. Milne-Eddington inversions applied to these Stokes data reveal large variations of field strength and inclination angle over dark-cored penumbral intrusions and a dark-cored light bridge. The mid-outer part of this penumbra structure shows 0.3 arcsec wide spines, separated by 1.6 arcsec (1200 km) and associated with 30 deg inclination variations. Between these spines, there are no small-scale magnetic structures that easily can be be identified with individual flux tubes. A structure with nearly 10 deg more vertical and weaker magnetic field is seen midways between two spines. This structure is co-spatial with the brightest penumbral filament, possibly indicating the location of a convective upflow from below.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2008; v1 submitted 10 June, 2008;
originally announced June 2008.
-
The non-LTE line formation of neutral carbon in late-type stars
Authors:
D. Fabbian,
M. Asplund,
M. Carlsson,
D. Kiselman
Abstract:
We investigate the non-Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium (non-LTE) line formation of neutral carbon in late-type stars in order to remove some of the potential systematic errors in stellar abundance analyses employing C I features. The statistical equilibrium code MULTI was used on a grid of plane-parallel 1D MARCS atmospheric models. Within the parameter space explored, the high-excitation C I li…
▽ More
We investigate the non-Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium (non-LTE) line formation of neutral carbon in late-type stars in order to remove some of the potential systematic errors in stellar abundance analyses employing C I features. The statistical equilibrium code MULTI was used on a grid of plane-parallel 1D MARCS atmospheric models. Within the parameter space explored, the high-excitation C I lines are stronger in non-LTE due to the combined effect of line source function drop and increased lower level population; the relative importance of the two effects depends on the particular combination of Teff, log g, [Fe/H] and [C/Fe] and on the analysed C I line. As a consequence, the non-LTE abundance corrections are negative and can be substantially so, for example ~-0.4 dex in halo turn-off stars at [Fe/H]~-3. The magnitude of the non-LTE corrections is rather insensitive to whether inelastic H collisions are included or not. Our results have implications on studies of nucleosynthetic processes and on Galactic chemical evolution models. When applying our calculated corrections to recent observational data, the upturn in [C/O] at low metallicity might still be present (thus apparently still necessitating contributions from massive Pop. III stars for the carbon production), but at a lower level and possibly with a rather shallow trend of ~-0.2 dex/dex below [O/H]~-1
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2006;
originally announced August 2006.
-
Non-LTE neutral carbon spectral line formation in late-type stars
Authors:
Damian Fabbian,
Martin Asplund,
Mats Carlsson,
Dan Kiselman
Abstract:
We present non-Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium (non-LTE) calculations for neutral carbon spectral line formation, carried out for a grid of model atmospheres covering the range of late-type stars. The results of our detailed calculations suggest that the carbon non-LTE corrections in these stars are higher than usually adopted, remaining substantial even at low metallicity. For the most metal-po…
▽ More
We present non-Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium (non-LTE) calculations for neutral carbon spectral line formation, carried out for a grid of model atmospheres covering the range of late-type stars. The results of our detailed calculations suggest that the carbon non-LTE corrections in these stars are higher than usually adopted, remaining substantial even at low metallicity. For the most metal-poor stars in the sample of Akerman et al. (2004), the non-LTE abundance corrections are of the order of -0.35...-0.45 dex (when neglecting H collisions). Applying our results to those observations, the apparent [C/O] upturn seen in their LTE analysis is no longer present, thus revealing no need to invoke contributions from Pop. III stars to the carbon nucleosynthesis.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2005; v1 submitted 2 August, 2005;
originally announced August 2005.
-
Line formation in solar granulation: IV. [O I], OI and OH lines and the photospheric O abundance
Authors:
M. Asplund,
N. Grevesse,
A. J. Sauval,
C. Allende Prieto,
D. Kiselman
Abstract:
The solar photospheric oxygen abundance has been determined from [OI], OI, OH vibration-rotation and OH pure rotation lines by means of a realistic time-dependent, 3D, hydrodynamical model of the solar atmosphere. In the case of the OI lines, 3D non-LTE calculations have been performed, revealing significant departures from LTE as a result of photon losses in the lines. We derive a solar oxygen…
▽ More
The solar photospheric oxygen abundance has been determined from [OI], OI, OH vibration-rotation and OH pure rotation lines by means of a realistic time-dependent, 3D, hydrodynamical model of the solar atmosphere. In the case of the OI lines, 3D non-LTE calculations have been performed, revealing significant departures from LTE as a result of photon losses in the lines. We derive a solar oxygen abundance of log O = 8.66 +/- 0.05. All oxygen diagnostics yield highly consistent abundances, in sharp contrast with the results of classical 1D model atmospheres. This low value is in good agreement with measurements of the local interstellar medium and nearby B stars. This low abundance is also supported by the excellent correspondence between lines of very different line formation sensitivities, and between the observed and predicted line shapes and center-to-limb variations. Together with the corresponding down-ward revisions of the solar carbon, nitrogen and neon abundances, the resulting significant decrease in solar metal mass fraction to Z = 0.0126 can, however, potentially spoil the impressive agreement between predicted and observed sound speed in the solar interior determined from helioseismology.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2003;
originally announced December 2003.
-
The formation of G-band bright points. I: Standard LTE modelling
Authors:
D. Kiselman,
R. J. Rutten,
B. Plez
Abstract:
Assuming LTE, we synthesise solar G band spectra from the semiempirical flux-tube model of Briand Solanki (1995). The results agree with observed G-band bright-point contrasts within the uncertainty set by the amount of scattered light. We find that it is the weakening of spectral lines within the flux tube that makes the bright-point contrast in the G band exceed the continuum contrast. We also…
▽ More
Assuming LTE, we synthesise solar G band spectra from the semiempirical flux-tube model of Briand Solanki (1995). The results agree with observed G-band bright-point contrasts within the uncertainty set by the amount of scattered light. We find that it is the weakening of spectral lines within the flux tube that makes the bright-point contrast in the G band exceed the continuum contrast. We also synthesise flux-tube spectra assuming LTE for the full wavelength range from UV to IR, and identify other promising passbands for flux-tube observations.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2000;
originally announced October 2000.
-
NLTE effects on oxygen lines
Authors:
Dan Kiselman
Abstract:
The NLTE effects affecting oxygen-abundance determinations of solar-type stars are discussed. LTE is perfectly safe for the forbidden lines. The permitted triplet at 777 nm is expected to show NLTE effects on the order of a few tenths of a dex (always in the sense that LTE overestimates the abundance), but the magnitude of the effects is dependent on the still very uncertain cross sections of co…
▽ More
The NLTE effects affecting oxygen-abundance determinations of solar-type stars are discussed. LTE is perfectly safe for the forbidden lines. The permitted triplet at 777 nm is expected to show NLTE effects on the order of a few tenths of a dex (always in the sense that LTE overestimates the abundance), but the magnitude of the effects is dependent on the still very uncertain cross sections of collisional excitation by collisions with neutral hydrogen atoms. Little is known about the NLTE effects on molecular line formation.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2000;
originally announced October 2000.
-
Effects of NLTE and granulation on LiBeB abundance determinations
Authors:
Dan Kiselman
Abstract:
NLTE effects - the errors caused by assuming local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE) - on LiBeB abundance determinations for cool stars are discussed. These NLTE effects are significant in many cases for B I and Li I lines. The Be II 313 nm lines are not formed under LTE circumstances, but the NLTE effects on equivalent widths seem to be rather small. Reasons for doing LTE abundance analysis are d…
▽ More
NLTE effects - the errors caused by assuming local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE) - on LiBeB abundance determinations for cool stars are discussed. These NLTE effects are significant in many cases for B I and Li I lines. The Be II 313 nm lines are not formed under LTE circumstances, but the NLTE effects on equivalent widths seem to be rather small. Reasons for doing LTE abundance analysis are discussed and confronted with the reasons for doing NLTE abundance analysis. The impact of three-dimensional photospheric inhomogeneity on line formation is discussed - there are not many definite results on this yet, but there may be soon.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 1999;
originally announced February 1999.
-
The 671 nm Li I line in solar granulation
Authors:
Dan Kiselman
Abstract:
The astrophysically very interesting Li I 671 nm line has been observed with high spatial resolution in solar granulation with the intention to diagnose departures from local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE) in the line formation. The spectral feature is very weak, so this is also a test on the limits of such observations. The observations of the Li I line and other weak lines nearby are compared…
▽ More
The astrophysically very interesting Li I 671 nm line has been observed with high spatial resolution in solar granulation with the intention to diagnose departures from local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE) in the line formation. The spectral feature is very weak, so this is also a test on the limits of such observations. The observations of the Li I line and other weak lines nearby are compared with the results of synthetic line calculations in three-dimensional granulation simulations. The dependence of line-centre velocities on photospheric continuum brightness is well described by the simulations. The observed equivalent width of the Li I line show an approximately flat dependence on continuum brightness, contrary to the theoretical LTE results. Detailed modelling of the line radiative transfer, with an approximate inclusion of three-dimensional effects, gives a better agreement with observations. The match is not perfect and various interesting reasons for this are considered. However, the possibility of systematic errors caused by the sensitivity of the Li I equivalent width to continuum placement calls for cautiousness in the conclusions.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 1998;
originally announced February 1998.
-
Boron in Very Metal-Poor Stars
Authors:
R. J. Garcia Lopez,
D. L. Lambert,
B. Edvardsson,
B. Gustafsson,
D. Kiselman,
R. Rebolo
Abstract:
We have observed the B I 2497 A line to derive the boron abundances of two very metal-poor stars selected to help in tracing the origin and evolution of this element in the early Galaxy: BD +23 3130 and HD 84937. The observations were conducted using the Goddard High Resolution Spectrograph on board the Hubble Space Telescope. A very detailed abundance analysis via spectral synthesis has been ca…
▽ More
We have observed the B I 2497 A line to derive the boron abundances of two very metal-poor stars selected to help in tracing the origin and evolution of this element in the early Galaxy: BD +23 3130 and HD 84937. The observations were conducted using the Goddard High Resolution Spectrograph on board the Hubble Space Telescope. A very detailed abundance analysis via spectral synthesis has been carried out for these two stars, as well as for two other metal-poor objects with published spectra, using both Kurucz and OSMARCS model photospheres, and taking into account consistently the NLTE effects on the line formation. We have also re-assessed all published boron abundances of old disk and halo unevolved stars. Our analysis shows that the combination of high effective temperature (Teff > 6000 K, for which boron is mainly ionized) and low metallicity ([Fe/H]<-1) makes it difficult to obtain accurate estimates of boron abundances from the B I 2497 A line. This is the case of HD 84937 and three other published objects (including two stars with [Fe/H] ~ -3), for which only upper limits can be established. BD +23 3130, with [Fe/H] ~ -2.9 and logN(B)_NLTE=0.05+/-0.30, appears then as the most metal-poor star for which a firm measurement of the boron abundance presently exists. The evolution of the boron abundance with metallicity that emerges from the seven remaining stars with Teff < 6000 K and [Fe/H]<-1, for which beryllium abundances were derived using the same stellar parameters, shows a linear increase with a slope ~ 1. Furthermore, the B/Be ratio found is constant at a value ~ 20 for stars in the range -3<[Fe/H]<-1. These results point to spallation reactions of ambient protons and alpha particles with energetic particles enriched in CNO as the origin of boron and beryllium in halo stars.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 1998;
originally announced January 1998.
-
Formation of Li I lines in photospheric granulation
Authors:
Dan Kiselman
Abstract:
The possibility of significant systematic errors due to the use of 1D homogeneous atmospheres in lithium-abundance determinations of cool stars motivates a study of non-local-thermodynamic-equilibrium (NLTE) effects on Li I line formation in a 3D solar-granulation simulation snapshot. The NLTE effect on the equivalent width of the 671 nm resonance line is small in 1D models or in integrated ligh…
▽ More
The possibility of significant systematic errors due to the use of 1D homogeneous atmospheres in lithium-abundance determinations of cool stars motivates a study of non-local-thermodynamic-equilibrium (NLTE) effects on Li I line formation in a 3D solar-granulation simulation snapshot. The NLTE effect on the equivalent width of the 671 nm resonance line is small in 1D models or in integrated light from the granulation model. The line-strength variations over the granulation pattern are however markedly different in NLTE compared to LTE -- observations of this may provide diagnostics to NLTE effects. The effects of horizontal photon exchange found in the granulation model are moderate and due entirely to bound-bound processes, ultraviolet overionization is unimportant.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 1997; v1 submitted 21 August, 1997;
originally announced August 1997.
-
The NLTE formation of neutral-boron lines in cool stars
Authors:
Dan Kiselman,
Mats Carlsson
Abstract:
We study the formation of B I lines in a grid of cool stellar model atmospheres without the assumption of local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE). The non-LTE modelling includes the effect of other lines blending with the B I resonance lines. Except for the cases where the B I lines are very strong, the departures from LTE relevant for the resonance lines can be described as an overionisation effe…
▽ More
We study the formation of B I lines in a grid of cool stellar model atmospheres without the assumption of local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE). The non-LTE modelling includes the effect of other lines blending with the B I resonance lines. Except for the cases where the B I lines are very strong, the departures from LTE relevant for the resonance lines can be described as an overionisation effect and an optical-pum** effect. This causes the lines to be weaker than in LTE so that an abundance analysis assuming LTE will underestimate stellar boron abundances. We present non-LTE abundance corrections useful to improve on abundances derived from the B I 250 nm and 209 nm lines under the LTE assumption. Application of the results on literature data indicates that the B/Fe ratio in metal-poor stars is constant.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 1996;
originally announced January 1996.
-
3D non-LTE line formation in the solar photosphere and the solar oxygen abundance
Authors:
Dan Kiselman,
Åke Nordlund
Abstract:
We study the formation of O I and OH spectral lines in three-dimensional hydrodynamic models of the solar photosphere. The line source function of the O I 777 nm triplet is allowed to depart from local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE), within the two-level-atom approximation. Comparison with results from 1D models show that the 3D models alleviate, but do not remove, the discrepancy between the o…
▽ More
We study the formation of O I and OH spectral lines in three-dimensional hydrodynamic models of the solar photosphere. The line source function of the O I 777 nm triplet is allowed to depart from local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE), within the two-level-atom approximation. Comparison with results from 1D models show that the 3D models alleviate, but do not remove, the discrepancy between the oxygen abundances reported from non-LTE work on the 777 nm triplet and from the [O I] 630 nm and OH lines. Results for the latter two could imply that the solar oxygen abundance is below 8.8 (lg(H) = 12). If this is confirmed, the discrepancy between theory and observation for the 777 nm triplet lines might fall within the range of errors in equivalent width measurements and f-values. The line source function of the 777 nm triplet in the 1.5D approximation is shown to differ insignificantly from the full 3D non-LTE result.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 1995;
originally announced May 1995.
-
A non-LTE study of Li I lines in AGB stars
Authors:
Dan Kiselman,
Bertrand Plez
Abstract:
We study the formation of Li lines in a case study of an S-type AGB star in the SMC. AGB stars may be important providers of $^7$Li to the interstellar medium. Abundance analysis of these stars is difficult due to the heavy molecular blanketing, uncertainties in the model atmospheres and possible departures from LTE in the Li atomic level populations. We address here the latter problem and somew…
▽ More
We study the formation of Li lines in a case study of an S-type AGB star in the SMC. AGB stars may be important providers of $^7$Li to the interstellar medium. Abundance analysis of these stars is difficult due to the heavy molecular blanketing, uncertainties in the model atmospheres and possible departures from LTE in the Li atomic level populations. We address here the latter problem and somewhat also that of background molecular line formation. We do not find non-LTE effects big enough to alone rule out the possibility that the reported super-Li-rich stars exist. There are, however, several other complications connected to the formation of the Li lines in these stars.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 1994;
originally announced November 1994.
-
Non-Lte Effects on be and B Abundance Determinations in Cool Stars
Authors:
Dan Kiselman,
Mats Carlsson
Abstract:
We discuss the nature of non-LTE effects affecting abundance analysis of cool stars. The departures from LTE of importance for the B I lines in solar-type stars are described and some new results are presented. Boron abundances derived under the LTE assumption have significant systematic errors, especially for metal-poor stars. For beryllium, current results suggest that departures from LTE will…
▽ More
We discuss the nature of non-LTE effects affecting abundance analysis of cool stars. The departures from LTE of importance for the B I lines in solar-type stars are described and some new results are presented. Boron abundances derived under the LTE assumption have significant systematic errors, especially for metal-poor stars. For beryllium, current results suggest that departures from LTE will not affect abundance analysis significantly.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 1994;
originally announced September 1994.
-
Boron in the Extreme Pop II Star HD 140283 and the Production of Light Elements in the Early Galaxy
Authors:
B. Edvardsson,
B. Gustafsson,
S. G. Johansson,
D. Kiselman,
D. L. Lambert,
P. E. Nissen,
G. Gilmore
Abstract:
Using observations of the 2496.7 A B I line with the HST GHRS at a nominal resolution of 90,000, we have found the abundance of boron of HD 140283 to be log epsilon_B (= 12 + log (N_B/N_H)) = 0.34 \pm 0.20. This result is found when a significant non-LTE effect in the formation of the B I line is taken into account. The resulting N_B/N_Be ratio is about 17 (in the range 9 -- 34), which is in ver…
▽ More
Using observations of the 2496.7 A B I line with the HST GHRS at a nominal resolution of 90,000, we have found the abundance of boron of HD 140283 to be log epsilon_B (= 12 + log (N_B/N_H)) = 0.34 \pm 0.20. This result is found when a significant non-LTE effect in the formation of the B I line is taken into account. The resulting N_B/N_Be ratio is about 17 (in the range 9 -- 34), which is in very good agreement with what is expected from spallation by cosmic rays. We conclude that this origin of Be and B in the Early Galaxy is the most probable of recently suggested formation mechanisms. (Submitted to A&A. Postscript figures available via annymous ftp to "chiron.astro.uu.se" in directory pub/Preprints/P87)
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 1994;
originally announced March 1994.
-
A NLTE study of neutral boron in solar-type stars
Authors:
Dan Kiselman
Abstract:
The formation of the resonance lines of neutral boron in solar-type stellar atmospheres is investigated taking into account effects of departures from local thermodynamic equilibrium (NLTE effects). The latter are due to a combination of overionisation and optical pum** in resonance lines, both caused by the hot, non-local, ultraviolet radiation fields in the line-forming regions. They lead to…
▽ More
The formation of the resonance lines of neutral boron in solar-type stellar atmospheres is investigated taking into account effects of departures from local thermodynamic equilibrium (NLTE effects). The latter are due to a combination of overionisation and optical pum** in resonance lines, both caused by the hot, non-local, ultraviolet radiation fields in the line-forming regions. They lead to an underestimation of the boron abundance when analysis methods assuming local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE) are used. The abundance correction, for the 249.7~nm resonance line, amounts to $+$0.6 dex for the metal-poor star HD140283 and $+$0.4 dex for Procyon. No significant NLTE effects are predicted for the Sun. Applying the abundance correction on the results for HD140283 of Duncan et al. (1992) leads to a B/Be ratio well above the minimum value required by spallation production of beryllium. The reliability of the results in view of atomic and atmospheric uncertainties is discussed. With the possible exception of photospheric inhomogeneity, it seems unlikely that these could remove the effect for HD140283.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 1994;
originally announced January 1994.
