-
Playing with FIRE: A Galactic Feedback-Halting Experiment Challenges Star Formation Rate Theories
Authors:
Shivan Khullar,
Christopher D. Matzner,
Norman Murray,
Michael Y. Grudić,
Dávid Guszejnov,
Andrew Wetzel,
Philip F. Hopkins
Abstract:
Stellar feedback influences the star formation rate (SFR) and the interstellar medium of galaxies in ways that are difficult to quantify numerically, because feedback is an essential ingredient of realistic simulations. To overcome this, we conduct a feedback-halting experiment starting with a Milky Way-mass galaxy in the FIRE-2 simulation framework. Terminating feedback, and comparing to a simula…
▽ More
Stellar feedback influences the star formation rate (SFR) and the interstellar medium of galaxies in ways that are difficult to quantify numerically, because feedback is an essential ingredient of realistic simulations. To overcome this, we conduct a feedback-halting experiment starting with a Milky Way-mass galaxy in the FIRE-2 simulation framework. Terminating feedback, and comparing to a simulation in which feedback is maintained, we monitor how the runs diverge. We find that without feedback, interstellar turbulent velocities decay. There is a marked increase of dense material, while the SFR increases by over an order of magnitude. Importantly, this SFR boost is a factor of $\sim$15-20 larger than is accounted for by the increased free fall rate caused by higher densities. This implies that feedback moderates the star formation efficiency per free-fall time more directly than simply through the density distribution. To probe changes at the scale of giant molecular clouds (GMCs), we identify GMCs using density and virial parameter thresholds, tracking clouds as the galaxy evolves. Halting feedback stimulates rapid changes, including a proliferation of new bound clouds, a decrease of turbulent support in loosely-bound clouds, an overall increase in cloud densities, and a surge of internal star formation. Computing the cloud-integrated SFR using several theories of turbulence regulation, we show that these theories underpredict the surge in SFR by at least a factor of three. We conclude that galactic star formation is essentially feedback-regulated on scales that include GMCs, and that stellar feedback affects GMCs in multiple ways.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
The density structure of supersonic self-gravitating turbulence
Authors:
Shivan Khullar,
Christoph Federrath,
Mark R. Krumholz,
Christopher D. Matzner
Abstract:
We conduct numerical experiments to determine the density probability distribution function (PDF) produced in supersonic, isothermal, self-gravitating turbulence of the sort that is ubiquitous in star-forming molecular clouds. Our experiments cover a wide range of turbulent Mach number and virial parameter, allowing us for the first time to determine how the PDF responds as these parameters vary,…
▽ More
We conduct numerical experiments to determine the density probability distribution function (PDF) produced in supersonic, isothermal, self-gravitating turbulence of the sort that is ubiquitous in star-forming molecular clouds. Our experiments cover a wide range of turbulent Mach number and virial parameter, allowing us for the first time to determine how the PDF responds as these parameters vary, and we introduce a new diagnostic, the dimensionless star formation efficiency versus density ($ε_{\rm ff}(s)$) curve, which provides a sensitive diagnostic of the PDF shape and dynamics. We show that the PDF follows a universal functional form consisting of a log-normal at low density with two distinct power law tails at higher density; the first of these represents the onset of self-gravitation, and the second reflects the onset of rotational support. Once the star formation efficiency reaches a few percent, the PDF becomes statistically steady, with no evidence for secular time-evolution at star formation efficiencies from about five to 20 percent. We show that both the Mach number and the virial parameter influence the characteristic densities at which the log-normal gives way to the first power-law, and the first to the second, and we extend (for the former) and develop (for the latter) simple theoretical models for the relationship between these density thresholds and the global properties of the turbulent medium.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2021; v1 submitted 1 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
The Single-Cloud Star Formation Relation
Authors:
Riwaj Pokhrel,
Robert A. Gutermuth,
Mark R. Krumholz,
Christoph Federrath,
Mark Heyer,
Shivan Khullar,
S. Thomas Megeath,
Philip C. Myers,
Stella S. R. Offner,
Judith L. Pipher,
William J. Fischer,
Thomas Henning,
Joseph L. Hora
Abstract:
One of the most important and well-established empirical results in astronomy is the Kennicutt-Schmidt (KS) relation between the density of interstellar gas and the rate at which that gas forms stars. A tight correlation between these quantities has long been measured at galactic scales. More recently, using surveys of YSOs, a KS relationship has been found within molecular clouds relating the sur…
▽ More
One of the most important and well-established empirical results in astronomy is the Kennicutt-Schmidt (KS) relation between the density of interstellar gas and the rate at which that gas forms stars. A tight correlation between these quantities has long been measured at galactic scales. More recently, using surveys of YSOs, a KS relationship has been found within molecular clouds relating the surface density of star formation to the surface density of gas; however, the scaling of these laws varies significantly from cloud to cloud. In this Letter, we use a recently developed, high-accuracy catalog of young stellar objects from $\textit{Spitzer}$ combined with high-dynamic-range gas column density maps of twelve nearby ($<$1.5 kpc) molecular clouds from $\textit{Herschel}$ to re-examine the KS relation within individual molecular clouds. We find a tight, linear correlation between clouds' star formation rate per unit area and their gas surface density normalized by the gas free-fall time. The measured intracloud KS relation, which relates star formation rate to the volume density, extends over more than two orders of magnitude within each cloud and is nearly identical in each of the twelve clouds, implying a constant star formation efficiency per free-fall time $ε_{\rm ff}\approx 0.026$. The finding of a universal correlation within individual molecular clouds, including clouds that contain no massive stars or massive stellar feedback, favors models in which star formation is regulated by local processes such as turbulence or stellar feedback such as protostellar outflows, and disfavors models in which star formation is regulated only by galaxy properties or supernova feedback on galactic scales.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Probing the high-z IGM with the hyperfine transition of $^3$He$^+$
Authors:
Shivan Khullar,
Qingbo Ma,
Philipp Busch,
Benedetta Ciardi,
Marius B. Eide,
Koki Kakiichi
Abstract:
The hyperfine transition of $^3$He$^+$ at 3.5cm has been thought as a probe of the high-z IGM since it offers a unique insight into the evolution of the helium component of the gas, as well as potentially give an independent constraint on the 21cm signal from neutral hydrogen. In this paper, we use radiative transfer simulations of reionization driven by sources such as stars, X-ray binaries, accr…
▽ More
The hyperfine transition of $^3$He$^+$ at 3.5cm has been thought as a probe of the high-z IGM since it offers a unique insight into the evolution of the helium component of the gas, as well as potentially give an independent constraint on the 21cm signal from neutral hydrogen. In this paper, we use radiative transfer simulations of reionization driven by sources such as stars, X-ray binaries, accreting black holes and shock heated interstellar medium, and simulations of a high-z quasar to characterize the signal and analyze its prospects of detection. We find that the peak of the signal lies in the range 1-50 $μ$K for both environments, but while around the quasar it is always in emission, in the case of cosmic reionization a brief period of absorption is expected. As the evolution of HeII is determined by stars, we find that it is not possible to distinguish reionization histories driven by more energetic sources. On the other hand, while a bright QSO produces a signal in 21cm that is very similar to the one from a large collection of galaxies, its signature in 3.5cm is very peculiar and could be a powerful probe to identify the presence of the QSO. We analyze the prospects of the signal's detectability using SKA1-mid as our reference telescope. We find that the noise power spectrum dominates over the power spectrum of the signal, although a modest S/N ratio can be obtained when the wavenumber bin width and the survey volume are sufficiently large.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Determining Star Formation Thresholds from Observations
Authors:
Shivan Khullar,
Mark R. Krumholz,
Christoph Federrath,
Andrew J. Cunningham
Abstract:
Most gas in giant molecular clouds is relatively low-density and forms star inefficiently, converting only a small fraction of its mass to stars per dynamical time. However, star formation models generally predict the existence of a threshold density above which the process is efficient and most mass collapses to stars on a dynamical timescale. A number of authors have proposed observational techn…
▽ More
Most gas in giant molecular clouds is relatively low-density and forms star inefficiently, converting only a small fraction of its mass to stars per dynamical time. However, star formation models generally predict the existence of a threshold density above which the process is efficient and most mass collapses to stars on a dynamical timescale. A number of authors have proposed observational techniques to search for a threshold density above which star formation is efficient, but it is unclear which of these techniques, if any, are reliable. In this paper we use detailed simulations of turbulent, magnetised star-forming clouds, including stellar radiation and outflow feedback, to investigate whether it is possible to recover star formation thresholds using current observational techniques. Using mock observations of the simulations at realistic resolutions, we show that plots of projected star formation efficiency per free-fall time $ε_{\rm ff}$ can detect the presence of a threshold, but that the resolutions typical of current dust emission or absorption surveys are insufficient to determine its value. In contrast, proposed alternative diagnostics based on a change in the slope of the gas surface density versus star formation rate surface density (Kennicutt-Schmidt relation) or on the correlation between young stellar object counts and gas mass as a function of density are ineffective at detecting thresholds even when they are present. The signatures in these diagnostics sometimes taken as indicative of a threshold in observations, which we generally reproduce in our mock observations, do not prove to correspond to real physical features in the 3D gas distribution.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2019; v1 submitted 3 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
