-
Klein-Gordon equation for electrically charged particles with new energy-momentum operator
Authors:
A. L. Kholmetskii,
T. Yarman,
O. Missevitch
Abstract:
We address the Klein-Gordon equation for a spinless charged particle in the presence of an electromagnetic (EM) field, and focus on its known shortcoming, related to the existence of solutions with a negative probability density. We disclose a principal way to overcome this shortcoming, using our recent results obtained in the analysis of quantum phase effects for charges and dipoles, which prove…
▽ More
We address the Klein-Gordon equation for a spinless charged particle in the presence of an electromagnetic (EM) field, and focus on its known shortcoming, related to the existence of solutions with a negative probability density. We disclose a principal way to overcome this shortcoming, using our recent results obtained in the analysis of quantum phase effects for charges and dipoles, which prove the need to abandon the customary definition of the momentum operator for a charged particle in an EM field through its canonical momentum, and to adopt the more general definition of this operator through the sum of mechanical and electromagnetic momenta for the charged particle in an EM field. We show that the ap-plication of the new energy-momentum operator to the Klein-Gordon equation actually eliminates solutions with negative probability density. Some implications of the obtained results are discussed
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Force law in material media and quantum phases
Authors:
Alexander L Kholmetskii,
Oleg V. Missevitch,
Tolga Yarman
Abstract:
We show that the known expressions for the force on a point-like dipole are incompatible with the relativistic transformation of force, and in this respect we apply the Lagrangian approach to the derivation of the correct equation for force on a small electric/magnetic dipole. The obtained expression for the generalized momentum of a moving dipole predicts two novel quantum effects with non-topolo…
▽ More
We show that the known expressions for the force on a point-like dipole are incompatible with the relativistic transformation of force, and in this respect we apply the Lagrangian approach to the derivation of the correct equation for force on a small electric/magnetic dipole. The obtained expression for the generalized momentum of a moving dipole predicts two novel quantum effects with non-topological and non-dynamic phases, when an electric dipole is moving in an electric field, and when a magnetic dipole is moving in a magnetic field, correspondingly. The implications of the obtained results are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Novel Moessbauer experiment in a rotating system and the extra-energy shift between emission and absorption lines
Authors:
T. Yarman,
A. L. Kholmetskii,
M. Arik,
B. Akkus,
Y. Oktem,
L. A. Susam,
O. V. Missevitch
Abstract:
We present the results of a novel Mossbauer experiment in a rotating system, implemented recently in Istanbul University, which yields the coefficient k=0.69+/-0.02 within the frame of the expression for the relative energy shift between emission and absorption lines dE/E=ku2/c2. This result turned out to be in a quantitative agreement with an experiment achieved earlier on the subject matter (A.L…
▽ More
We present the results of a novel Mossbauer experiment in a rotating system, implemented recently in Istanbul University, which yields the coefficient k=0.69+/-0.02 within the frame of the expression for the relative energy shift between emission and absorption lines dE/E=ku2/c2. This result turned out to be in a quantitative agreement with an experiment achieved earlier on the subject matter (A.L. Kholmetskii et al. 2009 Phys. Scr. 79 065007), and once again strongly pointed to the inequality k>0.5, revealed originally in (A.L. Kholmetskii et al. 2008 Phys. Scr. 77, 035302 (2008)) via the re-analysis of Kundig experiment (W. Kundig. Phys. Rev. 129, 2371 (1963)). A possible explanation of the deviation of the coefficient k from the relativistic prediction k=0.5 is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Pure bound field corrections to the atomic energy levels and the proton size puzzle
Authors:
Alexander L Kholmetskii,
Oleg V Missevitch,
Tolga Yarman
Abstract:
Reinforcement of the puzzle about the proton charge radius r, stimulated by the recent experiments with muonic hydrogen induced news discussions on the subject, and now some physicists are ready to adopt the exotic properties of muon, lying beyond the Standard Model, in order to explain the difference between the results of muonic hydrogen experiments (r=0.84087(39) fm) and CODATA-2010 value r=0.8…
▽ More
Reinforcement of the puzzle about the proton charge radius r, stimulated by the recent experiments with muonic hydrogen induced news discussions on the subject, and now some physicists are ready to adopt the exotic properties of muon, lying beyond the Standard Model, in order to explain the difference between the results of muonic hydrogen experiments (r=0.84087(39) fm) and CODATA-2010 value r=0.8775(51) fm based on electron-proton scattering and H spectroscopy. In the present contribution we suggest a way to achieve a progress in the entire problem via paying attention on a logical inconsistency of fundamental equations of atomic physics, constructed by analogy with corresponding classical equations without, however, taking into account a purely bound nature of electromagnetic field generated by electrically bound particles in the stationary energy states. We suggest eliminating this inconsistency via introducing some appropriate correcting factors into these equations, which involve the requirement of total momentum conservation in the system of bound particles in the absence of electromagnetic radiation. We further show that this approach allows not only eliminating long-standing discrepancies between theory and experiment in physics of simple atoms, but also yields the same estimation for the proton size in the classic 2S-2P Lamb shift in hydrogen, 1S Lamb shift in hydrogen, and 2S-2P Lamb shift in muonic hydrogen, with the mean value r=0.841 fm. Finally, we suggest the crucial experiment for verification of the validity of pure bound field corrections: the measurement of lifetime of bound moun in meso-atoms with large Z, where the standard calculations and our predictions essentially deviate from each other, and some of the available experimental results (Yovanovitch, Phys. Rev. 117 (1960) 1580) strongly support our approach.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Generalized electromagnetic energy-momentum tensor and scalar curvature of space at the location of charged particle
Authors:
A. L. Kholmetskii,
O. V. Missevitch,
T. Yarman
Abstract:
We consider the Einstein equation, where the common electromagnetic energy momentum tensor is replaced by its generalized equivalent as suggested in our earlier paper (A.L. Kholmetskii et al. Phys. Scr. 83, 055406 (2011)). Now we show that with this new electromagnetic energy-momentum tensor, the scalar curvature at the location of charges is significantly altered in comparison with the common res…
▽ More
We consider the Einstein equation, where the common electromagnetic energy momentum tensor is replaced by its generalized equivalent as suggested in our earlier paper (A.L. Kholmetskii et al. Phys. Scr. 83, 055406 (2011)). Now we show that with this new electromagnetic energy-momentum tensor, the scalar curvature at the location of charges is significantly altered in comparison with the common result, and it even may change its sign. Some implications of the obtained results are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
Going from Classical to Quantum Description of Bound Charged Particles Part 2: Implications for the light hydrogenic atoms
Authors:
T. Yarman,
A. L. Kholmetskii,
O. V. Missevitch
Abstract:
This paper continues the analysis of bound quantum systems started in (T. Yarman, A.L. Kholmetskii and O.V. Missevitch. Going from classical to quantum description of bound charged particles. Part 1: basic concepts and assertions), based on a novel approach, involving the requirement of energy-momentum conservation for the bound electromagnetic (EM) field, when the EM radiation is forbidden. It ha…
▽ More
This paper continues the analysis of bound quantum systems started in (T. Yarman, A.L. Kholmetskii and O.V. Missevitch. Going from classical to quantum description of bound charged particles. Part 1: basic concepts and assertions), based on a novel approach, involving the requirement of energy-momentum conservation for the bound electromagnetic (EM) field, when the EM radiation is forbidden. It has been shown that the modified expression for the energy levels of hydrogenic atoms within such a pure bound field theory (PBFT) provides the same gross and fine structure of energy levels, like in the standard theory. At the scale of hyperfine interactions our approach, in general, evokes important corrections to the energy levels. Part of such corrections, like the spin-spin splitting in hydrogen, is less than the present theoretical uncertainty in the evaluation of hyperfine contributions into the atomic levels. But the most interesting result is the appearance of a number of significant corrections, which improve the convergence between theory and experiment. In particular, the corrected 1S-2S interval and 1S spin-spin splitting in positronium reduce the existing up to date discrepancy between theoretical and experimental data. The re-estimated classic 2S-2P Lamb shift in the hydrogen atom lead to the proton charge radius rp=0.841(6) fm, which perfectly agrees with the latest estimation of proton size via the measurement of 2S-2P Lamb shift in muonic hydrogen, i.e. rp=0.84184(67) fm.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2011; v1 submitted 25 November, 2009;
originally announced November 2009.
-
Going from Classical to Quantum Description of Bound Charged Particles Part 1: Basic Concepts and Assertions
Authors:
T. Yarman,
A. L. Kholmetskii,
O. V. Missevitch
Abstract:
In this paper we analyze again a transition from the classical to quantum description of bound charged particles, which involves a substantial modification of the structure of their electromagnetic (EM) fields related to the well-known fact that bound micro-particles do not radiate in sta-tionary energy states. We show that a simple exclusion of the radiative component of EM field produced by boun…
▽ More
In this paper we analyze again a transition from the classical to quantum description of bound charged particles, which involves a substantial modification of the structure of their electromagnetic (EM) fields related to the well-known fact that bound micro-particles do not radiate in sta-tionary energy states. We show that a simple exclusion of the radiative component of EM field produced by bound particles leads to a violation of the energy-momentum conservation law, if the non-radiative EM field is left unmodified. In order to restore the energy-momentum conservation, we make a closer look at the interaction of two hypothetical classical charges with the prohibited radiation component of their EM field and bring the appropriate modifications in the structure of their bound EM field and, accordingly, in the Hamilton function of this system. In comparison with the common Hamilton function for the one-body problem, the electric interaction energy is multiplied by the Lorentz factor of orbiting charged particle, and its rest mass m is replaced by an effective rest mass parameter, which includes the interaction EM energy. We introduce, as a novel postulate, these replacements into the Dirac equation for the bound electron and show that the solution of the modified Dirac Coulomb equation gives the same gross and fine structure of energy levels, as the one furnished by the conventional approach, for hydrogen-like atoms. The correction to spin-spin splitting of 1S state of hydrogen and heavier atoms is much smaller than nuclear structure contribution and can be ignored. However, as discussed in the part 2 of this paper, our approach does induce corrections to the energy levels at the scale of hyperfine interactions, which at once remove a number of long-standing discrepancies between theory and experiment in the atomic physics.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2011; v1 submitted 25 November, 2009;
originally announced November 2009.
-
Quantum Mechanical Disclosure of the Classical Adiabatic Constancy of PVg for an Ideal Gas, and for a Photon Gas
Authors:
Metin Arik,
Tolga Yarman,
Alexander L. Kholmetskii
Abstract:
Previously, we established a connection between the macroscopic classical laws of gases and the quantum mechanical description of molecules of an ideal gas (T. Yarman et al. arXiv:0805.4494). In such a gas, the motion of each molecule can be considered independently on all other molecules, and thus the macroscopic parameters of the ideal gas, like pressure P and temperature T, can be introduced…
▽ More
Previously, we established a connection between the macroscopic classical laws of gases and the quantum mechanical description of molecules of an ideal gas (T. Yarman et al. arXiv:0805.4494). In such a gas, the motion of each molecule can be considered independently on all other molecules, and thus the macroscopic parameters of the ideal gas, like pressure P and temperature T, can be introduced as a result of simple averaging over all individual motions of the molecules. It was shown that for an ideal gas enclosed in a macroscopic cubic box of volume V, the constant, arising along with the classical law of adiabatic expansion, i.e. PV5/3=constant, can be explicitly derived based on quantum mechanics, so that the constant comes to be proportional to h^2/m; here h is the Planck Constant, and m is the relativistic mass of the molecule the gas is made of. In this article we show that the same holds for a photon gas, although the related setup is quite different than the previous ideal gas setup. At any rate, we come out with PV5/3 hc=constant, where c is the speed of light. No matter what the dimensions of the constants in question are different from each other, they are still rooted to universal constants, more specifically to h2 and to hc, respectively; their ratio, i.e. V1/3 h/mc, interestingly pointing to the de Broglie relationship's cast.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2009;
originally announced June 2009.
-
The Ideal Gas Behavior is in Fact Nothing, But a Macroscopic Quantum Mechanical Manifestation
Authors:
Tolga Yarman,
Alexander L. Kholmetskii,
Jean-Louis Tane
Abstract:
This article mainly consists in the quantum mechanical study of an adiabatically compressed particle, in an infinitely high well, which we conjecture, can be considered as the basis of an ideal gas. Thus we prove that, all the compression energy is, as may be expected, transformed into extra kinetic energy of the particle. This result frames a quantum mechanical definition of an ideal gas. It fu…
▽ More
This article mainly consists in the quantum mechanical study of an adiabatically compressed particle, in an infinitely high well, which we conjecture, can be considered as the basis of an ideal gas. Thus we prove that, all the compression energy is, as may be expected, transformed into extra kinetic energy of the particle. This result frames a quantum mechanical definition of an ideal gas. It further helps the elucidation of a paradox.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2009;
originally announced February 2009.
-
Mossbauer Experiment in a Rotating System on the Time Dilation Effect
Authors:
Alexander L. Kholmetskii,
Tolga Yarman,
Oleg V. Missevitch,
Boris I. Rogozev
Abstract:
We present results of Moessbauer experiment in a rotating system, which is induced by our recent disclosure (Phys. Scr., 77 (2008) 035302) and which consisted in the fact that a correct processing of Kundig experiment data on the subject gives an appreciable deviation of a relative energy shift dE/E between emission and absorption resonant lines from the standard prediction based on the relativi…
▽ More
We present results of Moessbauer experiment in a rotating system, which is induced by our recent disclosure (Phys. Scr., 77 (2008) 035302) and which consisted in the fact that a correct processing of Kundig experiment data on the subject gives an appreciable deviation of a relative energy shift dE/E between emission and absorption resonant lines from the standard prediction based on the relativistic dilation of time (that is dE/E=-v2/2c2 to the accuracy c-2, where v is the tangential velocity of absorber of resonant radiation, and c is the light velocity in vacuum). Namely, the Kundig result following the correction we brought to it, is dE/E=-(0.596+/-0.006)v2/c2. In our own experiment we carried out measurements for two absorbers with substantially different isomer shift, which allowed us to make a correction of Moessbauer data to a level of vibrations in the rotor system at various rotational frequencies. As a result we got the estimation dE/E=-(0.68+/-0.03)v2/c2. A deviation from the relativistic formula is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 24 December, 2008;
originally announced December 2008.
-
Experimental Evidence on Non-Applicability of the Standard Retardation Condition to Bound Magnetic Fields and on New Generalized Biot-Savart Law
Authors:
A. L. Kholmetskii,
O. V. Missevitch,
R. Smirnov-Rueda,
R. I. Tzontchev,
A. E. Chubykalo,
I. Moreno
Abstract:
In this work we made an analysis of the current status of velocity dependent (bound) field components in the framework of the standard electromagnetic theory. Preliminary discussions of the structure of the magnetic field due to an idealized oscillating magnetic dipole provided us with the quantitative insights on the relative contribution of velocity dependent (bound) and acceleration dependent…
▽ More
In this work we made an analysis of the current status of velocity dependent (bound) field components in the framework of the standard electromagnetic theory. Preliminary discussions of the structure of the magnetic field due to an idealized oscillating magnetic dipole provided us with the quantitative insights on the relative contribution of velocity dependent (bound) and acceleration dependent (radiation) terms into the resultant magnetic field. According to this analysis we defined the methodological scheme based on a generalized (time-dependent) Biot-Savart law capable to test the applicability of the standard retardation condition on bound field components. In the second part of this work we made the theoretical analysis of the finite size multi-section antennas, confirming the validity of the methodological scheme conceived for an idealized magnetic dipole. The use of multi-section antennas is fully justified by a substantial rise of the ratio of bound-to-radiation field strength. Finally, we effected numerical calculations taking into account particular experimental settings and compared them with experimentally obtained data that unambiguously indicate on the non-applicability of the standard retardation condition to bound magnetic fields. In addition, experimental observations show a striking coincidence with the predictions of a new generalized Biot-Savart law which implies the spreading velocity of bound fields highly exceeding the velocity of light.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2006;
originally announced January 2006.
-
The Faraday induction law in relativity theory
Authors:
Alexander L Kholmetskii,
Oleg V. Missevitch
Abstract:
We analyze the transformation properties of Faraday law in an empty space and its relationship with Maxwell equations. In our analysis we express the Faraday law via the four-potential of electromagnetic field and the field of four-velocity, defined on a circuit under its deforming motion. The obtained equations show one more facet of the physical meaning of electromagnetic potentials, where the…
▽ More
We analyze the transformation properties of Faraday law in an empty space and its relationship with Maxwell equations. In our analysis we express the Faraday law via the four-potential of electromagnetic field and the field of four-velocity, defined on a circuit under its deforming motion. The obtained equations show one more facet of the physical meaning of electromagnetic potentials, where the motional and transformer parts of the flux rule are incorporated into a common phenomenon, reflecting the dependence of four-potential on spatial and time coordinates, correspondingly. It has been explicitly shown that for filamentary closed deforming circuit the flux rule is Lorentz-invariant. At the same time, analyzing a transformation of e.m.f., we revealed a controversy: due to causal requirements, the e.m.f. should be the value of fixed sign, whereas the Lorentz invariance of flux rule admits the cases, where the e.m.f. might change its sign for different inertial observers. Possible resolutions of this controversy are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2005;
originally announced April 2005.
-
On "gauge renormalization" in classical electrodynamics
Authors:
Alexander L. Kholmetskii
Abstract:
In this paper we pay attention to the inconsistency in the derivation of the symmetric electromagnetic energy-momentum tensor for a system of charged particles from its canonical form, when the homogeneous Maxwell equations are applied to the symmetrizing gauge transformation, while the non-homogeneous Maxwell equations are used to obtain the motional equation. Applying the appropriate non-homog…
▽ More
In this paper we pay attention to the inconsistency in the derivation of the symmetric electromagnetic energy-momentum tensor for a system of charged particles from its canonical form, when the homogeneous Maxwell equations are applied to the symmetrizing gauge transformation, while the non-homogeneous Maxwell equations are used to obtain the motional equation. Applying the appropriate non-homogeneous Maxwell equation to both operations, we have revealed an additional symmetric term in the tensor, named as "compensating term". Analyzing the structure of this "compensating term", we suggested a method of "gauge renormalization, which allows transforming the divergent terms of classical electrodynamics (infinite self-force, self-energy and self-momentum) to converging integrals. The motional equation obtained for a non-radiating charged particle does not contain its self-force, and the mass parameter includes the sum of mechanical and electromagnetic masses. The motional equation for a radiating particle also contains the sum of mechanical and electromagnetic masses, and does not yield any "runaway solutions". It has been shown that the energy flux in a free electromagnetic field is guided by the Poynting vector, whereas the energy flux in a bound EM field is described by the generalized Umov vector, defined in the paper. The problem of "Poincare stresses" is also examined. It has been shown that the presence of the "compensating term" in the electromagnetic energy-momentum tensor allows a solution of the "4/3 problem", where the total observable mass of the electron is completely determined by the Poincare stresses and hence the conventional relativistic relationship between the energy and momentum is recovered.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2005;
originally announced March 2005.
-
On momentum and energy of a non-radiating electromagnetic field
Authors:
Alexander L. Kholmetskii
Abstract:
This paper inspects more closely the problem of the momentum and energy of a bound (non-radiating) electromagnetic (EM) field. It has been shown that for an isolated system of non-relativistic mechanically free charged particles a transformation of mechanical to EM momentum and vice versa occurs in accordance with the requirement PG=const, where PG is the canonical momentum. If such a system con…
▽ More
This paper inspects more closely the problem of the momentum and energy of a bound (non-radiating) electromagnetic (EM) field. It has been shown that for an isolated system of non-relativistic mechanically free charged particles a transformation of mechanical to EM momentum and vice versa occurs in accordance with the requirement PG=const, where PG is the canonical momentum. If such a system contains bound charges, fixed on insulators then, according to the assumption of a number of authors, a so-called "hidden" momentum can contribute into the total momentum of the system. The problem of "hidden momentum" (pro and contra) is also examined in the paper, as well as the law of conservation of total energy for different static configurations of the system "magnetic dipole plus charged particle". Analyzing two expressions for electromagnetic momentum of a bound EM field, qA and the Poynting expression, we emphasize that they coincide with each other for quasi-static configurations, but give a discrepancy for rapid dynamical processes. We conclude that neither the first, nor the second expressions provide a continuous implementation of the momentum conservation law. Finally, we consider the energy flux in a bound EM field, using the Umov vector. It has been shown that Umov vector can be directly derived from Maxwell equations. A new form of the momentum-energy tensor, which explicitly unites the mechanical and EM masses, has been proposed.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2005; v1 submitted 28 January, 2005;
originally announced January 2005.
-
Empty space-time, general relativity principle and covariant ether theories
Authors:
Alexander L. Kholmetskii
Abstract:
We look for the properties of empty space-time proceeding from the general relativity principle. An infinite number of the so-called covariant ether theories (CETs) has been found, which, like the special relativity theory (SRT), satisfy all known experimental facts in the physics of empty space-time. In this connection a new approach to the problem of experimental testing of SRT is discussed. I…
▽ More
We look for the properties of empty space-time proceeding from the general relativity principle. An infinite number of the so-called covariant ether theories (CETs) has been found, which, like the special relativity theory (SRT), satisfy all known experimental facts in the physics of empty space-time. In this connection a new approach to the problem of experimental testing of SRT is discussed. In particular, we show that covariant ether theories predict a dependence of Thomas-Wigner angle on an absolute velocity of a reference frame of observation. Hence, a measurement of this dependence is capable to distinguish SRT and CETs. It has been shown that the Lorentz ether theory is one of CETs, corresponding to the admissible Galilean transformations in physical space-time. Hence, we conclude that SRT and Lorentz ether theory can be distinguished experimentally, at least in principle. A crucial experiments, based on the Moessbauer effect, has been proposed.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2005;
originally announced January 2005.
-
Remarks on the correspondence of the relativity and causality principles
Authors:
Alexander L. Kholmetskii
Abstract:
A particular problem about special kind of two light pulses propagation has been considered in cases of inertial motion, constant homogeneous gravitation field and progressive non-inertial motion with constant acceleration. A contradiction between the causality principle and relativity theory has been revealed.
A particular problem about special kind of two light pulses propagation has been considered in cases of inertial motion, constant homogeneous gravitation field and progressive non-inertial motion with constant acceleration. A contradiction between the causality principle and relativity theory has been revealed.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2002;
originally announced January 2002.
