-
Crystal Nucleation in an AlNiZr Metallic Liquid: Within and Beyond Classical Nucleation Theory
Authors:
Fangzheng Chen,
Kian Cole Dahlberg,
Zohar Nussinov,
K. F. Kelton
Abstract:
The Classical Nucleation Theory (CNT) has played a key role in crystal nucleation studies since the 19th century and has significantly advanced the understanding of nucleation. However, certain key assumptions of CNT, such as a compact and spherical nucleating cluster and the concept of individual diffusive jumps are questionable. The results of molecular dynamics (MD) studies of crystal nucleatio…
▽ More
The Classical Nucleation Theory (CNT) has played a key role in crystal nucleation studies since the 19th century and has significantly advanced the understanding of nucleation. However, certain key assumptions of CNT, such as a compact and spherical nucleating cluster and the concept of individual diffusive jumps are questionable. The results of molecular dynamics (MD) studies of crystal nucleation in a Al20Ni60Zr20 metallic liquid demonstrate that the nucleating cluster is neither spherical nor compact. The seeding method was employed to determine the critical cluster size and nucleation parameters from CNT, which were then compared to those derived from the Mean First Passage Time (MFPT) method. While the CNT-based nucleation rate aligns well with experimental data from similar metallic liquids, the MFPT rate differs significantly. Further, contrary to the assumption of individual jumps for atoms to join the nucleating cluster, a cooperative mechanism of attachment or detachment is observed. This is accompanied by synchronized changes in the local potential energy. Similar cooperative motion also appeared in a non-classical nucleation process, particularly during the coalescence of nuclei.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Crystal Nucleation and Growth in Liquids: Cooperative Atom Attachment and Detachment
Authors:
Fangzheng Chen,
Zohar Nussinov,
K. F. Kelton
Abstract:
Classical theories of crystal nucleation and growth from the liquid assume activated processes that are interface limited, with the atoms individually joining the growing interface by jumps that occur at a rate that is determined by the diffusion coefficient in the liquid phase. These assumptions are in contradiction with the results of molecular dynamics studies that are presented here for superc…
▽ More
Classical theories of crystal nucleation and growth from the liquid assume activated processes that are interface limited, with the atoms individually joining the growing interface by jumps that occur at a rate that is determined by the diffusion coefficient in the liquid phase. These assumptions are in contradiction with the results of molecular dynamics studies that are presented here for supercooled Ni and Al20Ni60Zr20. Instead of diffusion-based attachment across the interface, atoms join the interface by making small changes so as to match the orientational order parameter of the nucleating crystal. Further, instead of joining individually multiple atoms join cooperatively, with the number of cooperative atoms increasing with decreasing temperature.
△ Less
Submitted 28 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Training language models to follow instructions with human feedback
Authors:
Long Ouyang,
Jeff Wu,
Xu Jiang,
Diogo Almeida,
Carroll L. Wainwright,
Pamela Mishkin,
Chong Zhang,
Sandhini Agarwal,
Katarina Slama,
Alex Ray,
John Schulman,
Jacob Hilton,
Fraser Kelton,
Luke Miller,
Maddie Simens,
Amanda Askell,
Peter Welinder,
Paul Christiano,
Jan Leike,
Ryan Lowe
Abstract:
Making language models bigger does not inherently make them better at following a user's intent. For example, large language models can generate outputs that are untruthful, toxic, or simply not helpful to the user. In other words, these models are not aligned with their users. In this paper, we show an avenue for aligning language models with user intent on a wide range of tasks by fine-tuning wi…
▽ More
Making language models bigger does not inherently make them better at following a user's intent. For example, large language models can generate outputs that are untruthful, toxic, or simply not helpful to the user. In other words, these models are not aligned with their users. In this paper, we show an avenue for aligning language models with user intent on a wide range of tasks by fine-tuning with human feedback. Starting with a set of labeler-written prompts and prompts submitted through the OpenAI API, we collect a dataset of labeler demonstrations of the desired model behavior, which we use to fine-tune GPT-3 using supervised learning. We then collect a dataset of rankings of model outputs, which we use to further fine-tune this supervised model using reinforcement learning from human feedback. We call the resulting models InstructGPT. In human evaluations on our prompt distribution, outputs from the 1.3B parameter InstructGPT model are preferred to outputs from the 175B GPT-3, despite having 100x fewer parameters. Moreover, InstructGPT models show improvements in truthfulness and reductions in toxic output generation while having minimal performance regressions on public NLP datasets. Even though InstructGPT still makes simple mistakes, our results show that fine-tuning with human feedback is a promising direction for aligning language models with human intent.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Deviations from Arrhenius dynamics in high temperature liquids, a possible collapse, and a viscosity bound
Authors:
**g Xue,
Flavio S. Nogueira,
K. F. Kelton,
Zohar Nussinov
Abstract:
Liquids realize a highly complex state of matter in which strong competing kinetic and interaction effects come to life. As such, liquids are more challenging to understand than either gases or solids generally. In weakly interacting gases, the kinetic effects dominate. By contrast, low temperature solids typically feature far smaller fluctuations about their ground state. Notwithstanding their co…
▽ More
Liquids realize a highly complex state of matter in which strong competing kinetic and interaction effects come to life. As such, liquids are more challenging to understand than either gases or solids generally. In weakly interacting gases, the kinetic effects dominate. By contrast, low temperature solids typically feature far smaller fluctuations about their ground state. Notwithstanding their complexity, with the exception of quantum fluids and supercooled liquids, various aspects of common liquid dynamics such as their dynamic viscosity are often assumed to be given by rather simple, Arrhenius-type, activated forms with nearly constant (i.e., temperature independent) energy barriers. In this work, we analyze experimentally measured viscosities of numerous liquids far above their equilibrium melting temperature to see how well this assumption fares. We find, for the investigated liquids, marked deviations from simple activated dynamics. Even far above their equilibrium melting temperatures, as the temperature drops, the viscosity of these liquids increases more strongly than predicted by activated dynamics dominated by a single uniform energy barrier. For metallic fluids, the scale of the prefactors of the best Arrhenius fits for the viscosity is typically consistent with that given by the product $nh$ with $n$ the number density and $h$ Planck's constant. In various fluids that we examined, $nh$ constitutes a lower bound scale on the viscosity. We find that a scaling of the temperature axis (complementing that of the viscosity) leads to a partial collapse of the temperature dependent viscosities of different fluids; such a scaling allows for a functional dependence of the viscosity on temperature that includes yet is far more general than activated Arrhenius form alone. We speculate on relations between non-Arrhenius dynamics and thermodynamic observables.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2022; v1 submitted 27 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Demonstration of the effect of stirring on nucleation from experiments on the International Space Station using the ISS-EML facility
Authors:
A. K. Gangopadhyay,
M. E. Sellers,
G. P. Bracker,
D. Holland-Moritz,
D. C. Van Hoesen,
S. Koch,
P. K. Galenko,
A. K. Pauls,
R. W. Hyers,
K. F. Kelton
Abstract:
The effect of fluid flow on crystal nucleation in supercooled liquids is not well understood. The variable density and temperature gradients in the liquid make it difficult to study this under terrestrial gravity conditions. Nucleation experiments were therefore made in a microgravity environment using the Electromagnetic Levitation facility on the International Space Station on a bulk glass-formi…
▽ More
The effect of fluid flow on crystal nucleation in supercooled liquids is not well understood. The variable density and temperature gradients in the liquid make it difficult to study this under terrestrial gravity conditions. Nucleation experiments were therefore made in a microgravity environment using the Electromagnetic Levitation facility on the International Space Station on a bulk glass-forming Zr57Cu15.4Ni12.6Al10Nb5 (Vit106), as well as Cu50Zr50 and the quasicrystal-forming Ti39.5Zr39.5Ni21 liquids. The maximum supercooling temperatures for each alloy were measured as a function of controlled stirring by applying various combinations of radio frequency positioner and heater voltages to the water-cooled copper coils. The flow patterns were simulated from the known parameters for the coil and the levitated samples. The maximum nucleation temperatures increased systematically with increased fluid flow in the liquids for Vit106, but stayed nearly unchanged for the other two. These results are consistent with the predictions from the coupled-flux model for nucleation.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Nucleation Pathways in Barium Silicate Glasses
Authors:
Matthew E. McKenzie,
Binghui Deng,
D. C. Van Hoesen,
Xinsheng Xia,
David E. Baker,
Aram Rezikyan,
Randall E. Youngman,
K. F. Kelton
Abstract:
Nucleation is generally viewed as a structural fluctuation that passes a critical size to eventually become a stable emerging new phase. However, this concept leaves out many details, such as changes in cluster composition and competing pathways to the new phase. In this work, both experimental and computer modeling studies are used to understand the cluster composition and pathways. Monte Carlo a…
▽ More
Nucleation is generally viewed as a structural fluctuation that passes a critical size to eventually become a stable emerging new phase. However, this concept leaves out many details, such as changes in cluster composition and competing pathways to the new phase. In this work, both experimental and computer modeling studies are used to understand the cluster composition and pathways. Monte Carlo and molecular dynamics approaches are used to analyze the thermodynamic and kinetic contributions to the nucleation landscape in barium silicate glasses. Experimental techniques examine the resulting polycrystals that form. Both the modeling and experimental data indicate that a silica rich core plays a dominant role in the nucleation process.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
The Low-Temperature Nucleation Rate Anomaly in Silicate Glasses is an Artifact
Authors:
Xinsheng Xia,
D. C. Van Hoesen,
Matthew E. McKenzie,
Randall E. Youngman,
K. F. Kelton
Abstract:
Over the past 40 years measurements of the nucleation rates in a large number of silicate glasses have indicated a breakdown in the widely used Classical Nucleation Theory (CNT) for temperatures below that of the peak nucleation rate. The data show that instead of steadily decreasing with decreasing temperature, the work of critical cluster formation enters a plateau, and even starts to increase.…
▽ More
Over the past 40 years measurements of the nucleation rates in a large number of silicate glasses have indicated a breakdown in the widely used Classical Nucleation Theory (CNT) for temperatures below that of the peak nucleation rate. The data show that instead of steadily decreasing with decreasing temperature, the work of critical cluster formation enters a plateau, and even starts to increase. While many explanations have been offered to explain this anomaly, none have provided a satisfactory answer. We present the first experimental results that demonstrate that the anomaly is not real, but is instead an artifact arising from an insufficient annealing time at the low temperatures. The time-dependent nucleation rate was measured in a 5BaO.8SiO2 glass at a temperature 50 K below the peak nucleation rate temperature for a time many times longer than any previous measurement time for a silicate glass. The new data give results that are consistent with the predictions of the CNT. Since the artifact has been widely observed in many silicate glasses, these results indicate that much of the existing nucleation rate data at low temperatures are incorrect.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Time-dependent nucleation rate measurements in BaO.2SiO2 and 5BaO.8SiO2 glasses
Authors:
Xinsheng Xia,
D. C. Van Hoesen,
Matthew E. McKenzie,
Randall E. Youngman,
Ozgur Gulbiten,
K. F. Kelton
Abstract:
The two-step heat treatment method is used to measure the steady state crystal nucleation rate and induction time as a function of temperature in BaO.2SiO2 and 5BaO.8SiO2 glasses. For both glasses, the temperature for maximum nucleation rate and the temperature range for significant nucleation agree well with previous estimates from differential thermal analysis studies. The data are analyzed with…
▽ More
The two-step heat treatment method is used to measure the steady state crystal nucleation rate and induction time as a function of temperature in BaO.2SiO2 and 5BaO.8SiO2 glasses. For both glasses, the temperature for maximum nucleation rate and the temperature range for significant nucleation agree well with previous estimates from differential thermal analysis studies. The data are analyzed with a new iterative method to obtain the interfacial free energy and critical work of cluster formation as a function of temperature. For temperatures below the temperature at which steady-state nucleation rate is a maximum, the critical work of cluster formation is shown to strongly deviate from expectations of the classical theory of nucleation.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Maximum Supercooling Studies in Ti39.5Zr39.5Ni21 and Zr80Pt20 - Connecting Liquid Structure and the Nucleation Barrier
Authors:
M. E. Sellers,
D. C. Van Hoesen,
A. K. Gangopadhyay,
K. F. Kelton
Abstract:
Almost three quarters of a century ago, Charles Frank proposed that the deep supercooling observed in metallic liquids is due to icosahedral short-range order (ISRO), which is incompatible with the long-range order of crystal phases. Some evidence in support of this hypothesis has been published previously. However, those studies were based on a small population of maximum supercooling measurement…
▽ More
Almost three quarters of a century ago, Charles Frank proposed that the deep supercooling observed in metallic liquids is due to icosahedral short-range order (ISRO), which is incompatible with the long-range order of crystal phases. Some evidence in support of this hypothesis has been published previously. However, those studies were based on a small population of maximum supercooling measurements before the onset of crystallization. Here, the results of a systematic statistical study of several hundred maximum supercooling measurements on Ti39.5Zr39.5Ni21 and Zr80Pt20 liquids are presented. Previous X-Ray and neutron scattering studies have shown that the structures of these liquid alloys contain significant amounts of ISRO. The results presented here show a small work of critical cluster formation (W* = 31 - 40 kBT) from the analysis of the supercooling data for the Ti39.5Zr39.5Ni21 liquid, which crystallizes to a metastable icosahedral quasicrystal. A much larger value (W* = 60 - 99 kBT) was obtained for the Zr80Pt20 liquid, which does not crystallize to an icosahedral quasicrystal. Taken together, these results significantly strengthen the validity of Frank's hypothesis.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Prediction of glass formability from liquid properties
Authors:
R. Dai,
R. Ashcraft,
A. K. Gangopadhyay,
K. F. Kelton
Abstract:
Glass formation is one of the most interesting phenomena in the condensed matter field. Considerable effort has gone into understanding and predicting the glass formability. However, the previous prediction requires the glass first made before the prediction can be performed. Here, we propose a new prediction formula using liquid properties only. Moreover, we demonstrated that the similarity betwe…
▽ More
Glass formation is one of the most interesting phenomena in the condensed matter field. Considerable effort has gone into understanding and predicting the glass formability. However, the previous prediction requires the glass first made before the prediction can be performed. Here, we propose a new prediction formula using liquid properties only. Moreover, we demonstrated that the similarity between liquid and crystalline structure plays an important role in determine the glass formability. Previously, only the kinetics of nucleation and growth processes have been considered.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Estimates of bond length and thermal expansion coefficients from x-ray scattering experimental data using reverse Monte Carlo simulations
Authors:
R. Ashcraft,
K. F. Kelton
Abstract:
The previously discussed anomalous behavior (i.e. negative) of the thermal expansion coefficient obtained from the pair correlation function is examined in the context of the nearest-neighbor distance (bond length) distribution. The bond length distribution is obtained from a Voronoi tessellation analysis of the atomic structures obtained from both reverse Monte Carlo simulations of x-ray scatteri…
▽ More
The previously discussed anomalous behavior (i.e. negative) of the thermal expansion coefficient obtained from the pair correlation function is examined in the context of the nearest-neighbor distance (bond length) distribution. The bond length distribution is obtained from a Voronoi tessellation analysis of the atomic structures obtained from both reverse Monte Carlo simulations of x-ray scattering data and molecular dynamics simulations. When a robust measure of central tendency (mean or median) is used a positive thermal expansion is obtained from the temperature-dependent bond length that has the same magnitude as that obtained from direct measurements of the volume as a function of temperature. The same is true when larger neighbor distances, as obtained in higher order peaks in the pair distribution function are tracked. This calls into question the recent claim that fragility of metallic liquids is embedded in these higher order peaks. It also shows that the previously reported anomalous contraction of the bond length arise from tracking the mode, which does not account for the skewness of the distribution.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Assessing the Reliability of Minimally Constrained Reverse Monte Carlo Simulations for Model Metallic Liquids
Authors:
R. Ashcraft,
K. F. Kelton
Abstract:
Molecular dynamics simulations using semi-empirical potentials are examined for three liquids to check the reliability of reverse Monte Carlo (RMC) simulations to reproduce atomic configurations when only total pair correlation functions (TPCF) are used as constraints. The local structures are determined from a Voronoi tessellation of the ensemble and compared with the structures obtained by RMC i…
▽ More
Molecular dynamics simulations using semi-empirical potentials are examined for three liquids to check the reliability of reverse Monte Carlo (RMC) simulations to reproduce atomic configurations when only total pair correlation functions (TPCF) are used as constraints. The local structures are determined from a Voronoi tessellation of the ensemble and compared with the structures obtained by RMC in terms of asphericity, volume, coordination number, Voronoi index, and nearest-neighbor distance. It is found that in general the distributions generated from RMC do not match the MD configurations, using the $L^1$ (taxicab) distance as a metric, although in some cases a measure of central tendency for the distribution did match. Since only TPCFs are typically used to constrain the RMC simulations of experimental data, this study establishes the limits on what can be learned by this analysis. It indicates that caution should be used when interpreting RMC-generated structures using few constraints since many structural quantities are not reproduced well.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Experimental measurements of the temperature-dependent Van Hove function in a $\text{Zr}_{80} \text{Pt}_{20}$ liquid
Authors:
R. Ashcraft,
Z. Wang,
D. L. Abernathy,
D. G. Quirinale,
T. Egami,
K. F. Kelton
Abstract:
Even though the viscosity is one of the most fundamental properties of liquids, the connection with the atomic structure of the liquid has proven elusive. By combining inelastic neutron scattering with the electrostatic levitation technique the time-dependent pair-distribution function (i.e. the Van Hove function) has been determined for liquid Zr80Pt20. We show that the decay-time of the first pe…
▽ More
Even though the viscosity is one of the most fundamental properties of liquids, the connection with the atomic structure of the liquid has proven elusive. By combining inelastic neutron scattering with the electrostatic levitation technique the time-dependent pair-distribution function (i.e. the Van Hove function) has been determined for liquid Zr80Pt20. We show that the decay-time of the first peak of the Van Hove function is directly related to the Maxwell relaxation time of the liquid, which is proportional to the shear viscosity. This result demonstrates that the local dynamics for increasing or decreasing the coordination number of local clusters by one determines the viscosity at high temperature, supporting earlier predictions from molecular dynamics simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2019; v1 submitted 4 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Correlation of the fragility of metallic liquids with the high temperature structure, volume, and cohesive energy
Authors:
A. K. Gangopadhyay,
C. E. Pueblo,
R. Dai,
M. L. Johnson,
R. Ashcraft,
D. Van Hoesen,
M. Sellers,
K. F. Kelton
Abstract:
The thermal expansion coefficients, structure factors, and viscosities of twenty-five equilibrium and supercooled metallic liquids have been measured using an electrostatic levitation (ESL) facility. The structure factor was measured at the Advanced Photon Source, Argonne, using the ESL. A clear connection between liquid fragility and structural and volumetric changes at high temperatures is estab…
▽ More
The thermal expansion coefficients, structure factors, and viscosities of twenty-five equilibrium and supercooled metallic liquids have been measured using an electrostatic levitation (ESL) facility. The structure factor was measured at the Advanced Photon Source, Argonne, using the ESL. A clear connection between liquid fragility and structural and volumetric changes at high temperatures is established; the observed changes are larger for the more fragile liquids. It is also demonstrated that the fragility of metallic liquids is determined to a large extent by the cohesive energy and is, therefore, predictable. These results are expected to provide useful guidance in the future design of metallic glasses.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Does the repulsive interatomic potential determine fragility in metallic liquids?
Authors:
Christopher E. Pueblo,
Minhua Sun,
Kenneth F. Kelton
Abstract:
The dynamical behavior of liquids is frequently characterized by the fragility, which can be defined from the temperature dependence of the shear viscosity, η. For a strong liquid, the activation energy for η changes little with cooling towards the glass transition temperature, Tg. The change is much greater in fragile liquids, with the activation energy becoming very large near Tg. While fragilit…
▽ More
The dynamical behavior of liquids is frequently characterized by the fragility, which can be defined from the temperature dependence of the shear viscosity, η. For a strong liquid, the activation energy for η changes little with cooling towards the glass transition temperature, Tg. The change is much greater in fragile liquids, with the activation energy becoming very large near Tg. While fragility is widely recognized as an important concept, for example believed to play an important role in glass formation, the microscopic origin of fragility is poorly understood. Here, we present new experimental evidence showing that fragility reflects the strength of the repulsive part of the interatomic potential, which can be determined from the steepness of the pair distribution function near the hard-sphere cutoff. Based on an analysis of scattering data from ten different metallic alloy liquids, we show that stronger liquids have steeper repulsive potentials.
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
A phase space approach to supercooled liquids and a universal collapse of their viscosity
Authors:
Nicholas B. Weingartner,
Chris Pueblo,
Flavio S. Nogueira,
K. F. Kelton,
Zohar Nussinov
Abstract:
A broad fundamental understanding of the mechanisms underlying the phenomenology of supercooled liquids has remained elusive, despite decades of intense exploration. When supercooled beneath its characteristic melting temperature, a liquid sees a sharp rise in its viscosity over a narrow temperature range, eventually becoming frozen on laboratory timescales. Explaining this immense increase in vis…
▽ More
A broad fundamental understanding of the mechanisms underlying the phenomenology of supercooled liquids has remained elusive, despite decades of intense exploration. When supercooled beneath its characteristic melting temperature, a liquid sees a sharp rise in its viscosity over a narrow temperature range, eventually becoming frozen on laboratory timescales. Explaining this immense increase in viscosity is one of the principle goals of condensed matter physicists. To that end, numerous theoretical frameworks have been proposed which explain and reproduce the temperature dependence of the viscosity of supercooled liquids. Each of these frameworks appears only applicable to specific classes of glassformers and each possess a number of variable parameters. Here we describe a classical framework for explaining the dynamical behavior of supercooled liquids based on statistical mechanical considerations, and possessing only a single variable parameter. This parameter varies weakly from liquid to liquid. Furthermore, as predicted by this new classical theory and its earlier quantum counterpart, we find with the aid of a small dimensionless constant that varies in size from $\sim 0.05-0.12$, a universal (16 decade) collapse of the viscosity data as a function of temperature. The collapse appears in all known types of glass forming supercooled liquids (silicates, metallic alloys, organic systems, chalcogenide, sugars, and water).
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Universal collapse of the viscosity of supercooled fluids
Authors:
N. B. Weingartner,
C. Pueblo,
F. S. Nogueira,
K. F. Kelton,
Z. Nussinov
Abstract:
All liquids in nature can be supercooled to form a glass. Surprisingly, although this phenomenon has been employed for millennia, it still remains ill-understood. Perhaps the most puzzling feature of supercooled liquids is the dramatic increase in their viscosity as the temperature ($T$) is lowered. This precipitous rise has long posed a fundamental theoretical challenge. Numerous approaches curre…
▽ More
All liquids in nature can be supercooled to form a glass. Surprisingly, although this phenomenon has been employed for millennia, it still remains ill-understood. Perhaps the most puzzling feature of supercooled liquids is the dramatic increase in their viscosity as the temperature ($T$) is lowered. This precipitous rise has long posed a fundamental theoretical challenge. Numerous approaches currently attempt to explain this phenomenon. When present, data collapse points to an underlying simplicity in various branches of science. In this Letter, we report on a 16 decade data collapse of the viscosity of 45 different liquids of all known types. Specifically, the viscosity of supercooled liquids scaled by their value at their respective equilibrium melting temperature ($η(T)/η(T_{melt}))$ is, for all temperatures $T<T_{melt}$, a universal function of $(T_{melt} - T)/(B T)$ where $B$ is a constant that does not change significantly from one liquid to another. This exceptionally plain behavior hints at a link between glassy dynamics and the conventional equilibrium melting transition in all known supercooled fluids.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Correlation between Fragility and the Arrhenius Crossover Phenomenon in Metallic, Molecular, and Network Liquids
Authors:
Abhishek Jaiswal,
Takeshi Egami,
K. F. Kelton,
Kenneth S. Schweizer,
Yang Zhang
Abstract:
We report the observation of a distinct correlation between the kinetic fragility index $m$ and the reduced Arrhenius crossover temperature $θ_A = T_A/T_g$ in various glass-forming liquids, identifying three distinguishable groups. In particular, for 11 glass-forming metallic liquids, we universally observe a crossover in the mean diffusion coefficient from high-temperature Arrhenius to low-temper…
▽ More
We report the observation of a distinct correlation between the kinetic fragility index $m$ and the reduced Arrhenius crossover temperature $θ_A = T_A/T_g$ in various glass-forming liquids, identifying three distinguishable groups. In particular, for 11 glass-forming metallic liquids, we universally observe a crossover in the mean diffusion coefficient from high-temperature Arrhenius to low-temperature super-Arrhenius behavior at approximately $θ_A \approx 2$ which is in the stable liquid phases. In contrast, for fragile molecular liquids, this crossover occurs at much lower $θ_A \approx 1.4$ and usually in their supercooled states. The $θ_A$ values for strong network liquids spans a wide range higher than 2. Intriguingly, the high-temperature activation barrier $E_\infty$ is universally found to be $\sim 11\ k_B T_g$ and uncorrelated with the fragility or the reduced crossover temperature $θ_A$ for metallic and molecular liquids. These observations provide a way to estimate the low-temperature glassy characteristics ($T_g$ and $m$) from the high-temperature liquid quantities ($E_\infty$ and $θ_A$).
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2016; v1 submitted 29 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Critical assessment of the equilibrium melting-based, energy distribution theory of supercooled liquids and application to jammed systems
Authors:
Nicholas B. Weingartner,
Chris Pueblo,
K. F. Kelton,
Zohar Nussinov
Abstract:
Despite decades of intense study, the mechanisms underlying the extraordinary dynamics of supercooled liquids as they approach the glass transition remain, at best, mis-characterized, and at worst, misunderstood. A long standing endeavor is to understand the remarkable increase of the viscosity with supercooling. Recently, a new theory of supercooled liquids has been proposed that starts from firs…
▽ More
Despite decades of intense study, the mechanisms underlying the extraordinary dynamics of supercooled liquids as they approach the glass transition remain, at best, mis-characterized, and at worst, misunderstood. A long standing endeavor is to understand the remarkable increase of the viscosity with supercooling. Recently, a new theory of supercooled liquids has been proposed that starts from first principles, using elementary statistical mechanics arguments, to derive a form for the viscosity that contains only a single fitting parameter in its simplest form. In this we demonstrate that this exact same form may be derived from a different starting point, and then critically examine its performance. In the process we find that functional form proposed fits the viscosity data of a diverse group of 45 liquids exceptionally well over a wide temperature range, and uncover a number of interesting correlations of the single parameter with various thermodynamic quantities, ultimately allowing for the prediction of low temperature viscosity from high temperature data. Additionally, we find that similar physical reasoning can be used to derive a similar, single parameter form for the viscosity of hard-sphere/jammed liquids. We demonstrate that this form accurately reproduces the viscosity of hard-spheres, suggesting an underlying universality in metastable dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2017; v1 submitted 14 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Liquid-to-liquid phase transition underlying the structural crossover in a supercooled metallic liquid
Authors:
S. Lan,
M. Blodgett,
K. F. Kelton,
X. -L. Wang
Abstract:
The existence of a 'crossover region' in glass-forming liquids has long been considered as a general phenomenon that is as important as the glass transition. One potential origin for the crossover behavior is a liquid-to-liquid phase transition (LLPT). Although a LLPT is thought to exist in all forms of liquids, structural evidence for this, particularly in supercooled liquids, is scarce, elusive,…
▽ More
The existence of a 'crossover region' in glass-forming liquids has long been considered as a general phenomenon that is as important as the glass transition. One potential origin for the crossover behavior is a liquid-to-liquid phase transition (LLPT). Although a LLPT is thought to exist in all forms of liquids, structural evidence for this, particularly in supercooled liquids, is scarce, elusive, and in many cases controversial. A key challenge to the search for a LLPT in a supercooled liquid is the interference of crystallization during cooling. Crystallization induces major structural changes, which can overwhelm and therefore mask the more subtle changes associated with a LLPT. Here, we report the results of an in-situ containerless synchrotron study of a metallic-glass-forming liquid (Zr57Nb5Al10Cu15.4Ni12.6) that show distinct changes in the liquid structure at ~1000 K, a temperature well below the melting temperature of the liquid and 150 K above the crystallization temperature. The structural transition is characterized by growing short- and extended-range order below the transition temperature, and is accompanied by a concurrent change in density. These data provide strong evidence for a LLPT in the supercooled metallic liquid, particularly in the light of a recent computer simulation study. That a LLPT is found in a metallic liquid supports the increasingly widely held view that a LLPT may be a common feature of a variety of liquids.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
A Dramatically Growing Shear Rigidity Length Scale in a Supercooled Glass Former ($NiZr_2$)
Authors:
Nicholas B. Weingartner,
Ryan Soklaski,
K. F. Kelton,
Zohar Nussinov
Abstract:
Finding a suitably growing length scale that increases in tandem with the immense viscous slowdown of supercooled liquids is an open problem associated with the glass transition. Here, we define and demonstrate the existence of one such length scale which may be experimentally verifiable. This is the length scale over which external shear perturbations appreciably penetrate into a liquid as the gl…
▽ More
Finding a suitably growing length scale that increases in tandem with the immense viscous slowdown of supercooled liquids is an open problem associated with the glass transition. Here, we define and demonstrate the existence of one such length scale which may be experimentally verifiable. This is the length scale over which external shear perturbations appreciably penetrate into a liquid as the glass transition is approached. We provide simulation based evidence of its existence, and its growth by at least an order of magnitude, by using molecular dynamics simulations of NiZr2, a good fragile glass former. On the probed timescale, upon approaching the glass transition temperature from above, this length scale, ξ is also shown to be consistent with Ising-like scaling. Furthermore, we demonstrate the possible scaling of ξ about the temperature at which super-Arrhenius growth of viscosity, and a marked growth of the penetration depth sets in. Our simulation results suggest that upon supercooling, marked initial increase of the shear penetration depth in fluids may occur in tandem with the breakdown of the Stokes-Einstein relation.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2016; v1 submitted 11 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
A locally preferred structure characterises all dynamical regimes of a supercooled liquid
Authors:
Ryan Soklaski,
Vy Tran,
Zohar Nussinov,
K. F. Kelton,
Li Yang
Abstract:
Recent experimental results suggest that metallic liquids universally exhibit a high-temperature dynamical crossover, which is correlated with the glass transition temperature ($T_{g}$). We demonstrate, using molecular dynamics results for Cu64Zr36, that this temperature, $T_{A} \approx 2 \times T_{g}$, is linked with cooperative atomic rearrangements that produce domains of connected icosahedra.…
▽ More
Recent experimental results suggest that metallic liquids universally exhibit a high-temperature dynamical crossover, which is correlated with the glass transition temperature ($T_{g}$). We demonstrate, using molecular dynamics results for Cu64Zr36, that this temperature, $T_{A} \approx 2 \times T_{g}$, is linked with cooperative atomic rearrangements that produce domains of connected icosahedra. Supercooling to a new characteristic temperature, $T_{D}$, is shown to produce higher order cooperative rearrangements amongst connected icosahedra, leading to large-scale domain fluctuations and the onset of glassy dynamics. These extensive domains then abruptly stabilize above $T_{g}$ and eventually percolate before the glass is formed. All characteristic temperatures ($T_{A}$, $T_{D}$ and $T_{g}$) are thus connected by successive manifestations of the structural cooperativity that begins at $T_{A}$.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2016; v1 submitted 5 February, 2015;
originally announced February 2015.
-
Thermalization and possible quantum relaxation times in "classical" fluids: theory and experiment
Authors:
Z. Nussinov,
F. Nogueira,
M. Blodgett,
K. F. Kelton
Abstract:
Quantum effects in material systems are often pronounced at low energies and become insignificant at high temperatures. We find that, perhaps counterintuitively, certain quantum effects may follow the opposite route and become sharp when extrapolated to high temperature within a "classical" liquid phase. In the current work, we suggest basic quantum bounds on relaxation (and thermalization) times,…
▽ More
Quantum effects in material systems are often pronounced at low energies and become insignificant at high temperatures. We find that, perhaps counterintuitively, certain quantum effects may follow the opposite route and become sharp when extrapolated to high temperature within a "classical" liquid phase. In the current work, we suggest basic quantum bounds on relaxation (and thermalization) times, examine kinetic theory by taking into account such possible fundamental quantum time scales, find new general equalities connecting semi-classical dynamics and thermodynamics to Planck's constant, and compute current correlation functions. Our analysis suggests that, on average, the extrapolated high temperature dynamical viscosity of general liquids may tend to a value set by the product of the particle number density ${\sf n}$ and Planck's constant $h$. We compare this theoretical result with experimental measurements of an ensemble of 23 metallic fluids where this seems to indeed be the case. The extrapolated high temperature viscosity of each of these liquids $η$ divided (for each respective fluid by its value of ${\sf n} h$) veers towards a Gaussian with an ensemble average value that is close to unity up to an error of size $0.6 \%$. Inspired by the Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis, we suggest a relation between the lowest equilibration temperature to the melting or liquidus temperature and discuss a possible corollary concerning the absence of finite temperature "ideal glass" transitions. We suggest a general quantum mechanical derivation for the viscosity of glasses at general temperatures. We invoke similar ideas to discuss other transport properties and demonstrate how simple behaviors including resistivity saturation and linear $T$ resistivity may appear very naturally. Our approach suggests that minimal time lags may be present in fluid dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2015; v1 submitted 5 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
Unexpected Universality in the Viscosity of Metallic Liquids
Authors:
M. Blodgett,
T. Egami,
Z. Nussinov,
K. F. Kelton
Abstract:
The range of the magnitude of the liquid viscosity as a function of the temperature (T) is one of the most impressive of any physical property, changing by approximately 17 orders of magnitude from its extrapolated value at infinite temperature to that at the glass transition. We present experimental measurements of containerlessly processed metallic liquids that reveal that the ratio of the visco…
▽ More
The range of the magnitude of the liquid viscosity as a function of the temperature (T) is one of the most impressive of any physical property, changing by approximately 17 orders of magnitude from its extrapolated value at infinite temperature to that at the glass transition. We present experimental measurements of containerlessly processed metallic liquids that reveal that the ratio of the viscosity to its extrapolated infinite temperature value follows a universal function of Tcoop/T. The temperature Tcoop corresponds to the onset of cooperative motion and is strongly correlated with the glass transition temperature. On average the extrapolated infinite temperature viscosity is found to be nh, where h is Planck's constant and n is the particle number density. A surprising universality in the viscosity of metallic liquids and its relation to the glass transition is demonstrated.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Connectivity of the Icosahedral Network and a Dramatically Growing Static Length Scale in Cu-Zr Binary Metallic Glasses
Authors:
Ryan Soklaski,
Zohar Nussinov,
Zachary Markow,
K. F. Kelton,
Li Yang
Abstract:
We report on and characterize, via molecular dynamics (MD) studies, the evolution of the structure of Cu50Zr50 and Cu64Zr36 metallic glasses (MGs) as temperature is varied. Interestingly, a percolating icosahedral network appears in the Cu64Zr36 system as it is supercooled. This leads us to introduce a static length scale, which grows dramatically as this three dimensional system approaches the gl…
▽ More
We report on and characterize, via molecular dynamics (MD) studies, the evolution of the structure of Cu50Zr50 and Cu64Zr36 metallic glasses (MGs) as temperature is varied. Interestingly, a percolating icosahedral network appears in the Cu64Zr36 system as it is supercooled. This leads us to introduce a static length scale, which grows dramatically as this three dimensional system approaches the glass transition. Amidst interpenetrating connections, non-interpenetrating connections between icosahedra are shown to become prevalent upon supercooling and to greatly enhance the connectivity of the MG's icosahedral network. Additionally, we characterize the chemical compositions of the icosahedral networks and their components. These findings demonstrate the importance of non-interpenetrating connections for facilitating extensive structural networks in Cu-Zr MGs, which in turn drive dynamical slowing in these materials.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2013;
originally announced February 2013.
-
Detecting hidden spatial and spatio-temporal structures in glasses and complex physical systems by multiresolution network clustering
Authors:
P. Ronhovde,
S. Chakrabarty,
D. Hu,
M. Sahu,
K. F. Kelton,
N. A. Mauro,
K . K. Sahu,
Z. Nussinov
Abstract:
We elaborate on a general method that we recently introduced for characterizing the "natural" structures in complex physical systems via a multiscale network based approach for the data mining of such structures. The approach is based on "community detection" wherein interacting particles are partitioned into "an ideal gas" of optimally decoupled groups of particles. Specifically, we construct a s…
▽ More
We elaborate on a general method that we recently introduced for characterizing the "natural" structures in complex physical systems via a multiscale network based approach for the data mining of such structures. The approach is based on "community detection" wherein interacting particles are partitioned into "an ideal gas" of optimally decoupled groups of particles. Specifically, we construct a set of network representations ("replicas") of the physical system based on interatomic potentials and apply a multiscale clustering ("multiresolution community detection") analysis using information-based correlations among the replicas. Replicas may be (i) different representations of an identical static system or (ii) embody dynamics by when considering replicas to be time separated snapshots of the system (with a tunable time separation) or (iii) encode general correlations when different replicas correspond to different representations of the entire history of the system as it evolves in space-time. We apply our method to computer simulations of a binary Kob-Andersen Lennard-Jones system, a ternary model system, and to atomic coordinates in a ZrPt system as gleaned by reverse Monte Carlo analysis of experimentally determined structure factors. We identify the dominant structures (disjoint or overlap**) and general length scales by analyzing extrema of the information theory measures. We speculate on possible links between (i) physical transitions or crossovers and (ii) changes in structures found by this method as well as phase transitions associated with the computational complexity of the community detection problem. We briefly also consider continuum approaches and discuss the shear penetration depth in elastic media; this length scale increases as the system becomes increasingly rigid.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2011; v1 submitted 8 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
-
Detection of hidden structures on all scales in amorphous materials and complex physical systems: basic notions and applications to networks, lattice systems, and glasses
Authors:
P. Ronhovde,
S. Chakrabarty,
M. Sahu,
K. K. Sahu,
K. F. Kelton,
N. Mauro,
Z. Nussinov
Abstract:
Recent decades have seen the discovery of numerous complex materials. At the root of the complexity underlying many of these materials lies a large number of possible contending atomic- and larger-scale configurations and the intricate correlations between their constituents. For a detailed understanding, there is a need for tools that enable the detection of pertinent structures on all spatial an…
▽ More
Recent decades have seen the discovery of numerous complex materials. At the root of the complexity underlying many of these materials lies a large number of possible contending atomic- and larger-scale configurations and the intricate correlations between their constituents. For a detailed understanding, there is a need for tools that enable the detection of pertinent structures on all spatial and temporal scales. Towards this end, we suggest a new method by invoking ideas from network analysis and information theory. Our method efficiently identifies basic unit cells and topological defects in systems with low disorder and may analyze general amorphous structures to identify candidate natural structures where a clear definition of order is lacking. This general unbiased detection of physical structure does not require a guess as to which of the system properties should be deemed as important and may constitute a natural point of departure for further analysis. The method applies to both static and dynamic systems.
△ Less
Submitted 29 December, 2010;
originally announced January 2011.
-
Icosahedral Ti-Zr-Ni: A groundstate quasicrystal?
Authors:
R. G. Hennig,
A. E. Carlsson,
K. F. Kelton,
C. L. Henley
Abstract:
The first complete ab initio zero-temperature ternary phase diagram is constructed from the calculated energies of the elemental, binary and ternary Ti-Zr-Ni phases; for this, the icosahedral i-TiZrNi quasicrystal phase is approximated by periodic structures of up to 123 atoms/unit cell, based on a decorated-tiling model. The approximant structures containing the 45-atom Bergman cluster were nea…
▽ More
The first complete ab initio zero-temperature ternary phase diagram is constructed from the calculated energies of the elemental, binary and ternary Ti-Zr-Ni phases; for this, the icosahedral i-TiZrNi quasicrystal phase is approximated by periodic structures of up to 123 atoms/unit cell, based on a decorated-tiling model. The approximant structures containing the 45-atom Bergman cluster were nearly degenerate, and stable against the competing binary phases. It is speculated that i-TiZrNi may be a ground state quasicrystal, as it is experimentally the low-temperature phase for its composition.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2002;
originally announced May 2002.
-
Structure of the icosahedral Ti-Zr-Ni quasicrystal
Authors:
R. G. Hennig,
K. F. Kelton,
A. E. Carlsson,
C. L. Henley
Abstract:
The atomic structure of the icosahedral Ti-Zr-Ni quasicrystal is determined by invoking similarities to periodic crystalline phases, diffraction data and the results from ab initio calculations. The structure is modeled by decorations of the canonical cell tiling geometry. The initial decoration model is based on the structure of the Frank-Kasper phase W-TiZrNi, the 1/1 approximant structure of…
▽ More
The atomic structure of the icosahedral Ti-Zr-Ni quasicrystal is determined by invoking similarities to periodic crystalline phases, diffraction data and the results from ab initio calculations. The structure is modeled by decorations of the canonical cell tiling geometry. The initial decoration model is based on the structure of the Frank-Kasper phase W-TiZrNi, the 1/1 approximant structure of the quasicrystal. The decoration model is optimized using a new method of structural analysis combining a least-squares refinement of diffraction data with results from ab initio calculations. The resulting structural model of icosahedral Ti-Zr-Ni is interpreted as a simple decoration rule and structural details are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2002;
originally announced February 2002.
