Showing 1–50 of 61 results for author: Karak, B B

Variabilities in the polar field and solar cycle due to irregular properties of Bipolar Magnetic Regions

Authors: Pawan Kumar, Bidya Binay Karak, Anu Sreedevi

Abstract: Decay and dispersal of the tilted Bipolar Magnetic Regions (BMRs) on the solar surface are observed to produce large-scale poloidal field, which acts as the seed for the toroidal field and, thus, the next sunspot cycle. However, various properties of BMR, namely, the tilt, time delay between successive emergences, location, and flux, all have irregular variations. Previous studies show that these… ▽ More Decay and dispersal of the tilted Bipolar Magnetic Regions (BMRs) on the solar surface are observed to produce large-scale poloidal field, which acts as the seed for the toroidal field and, thus, the next sunspot cycle. However, various properties of BMR, namely, the tilt, time delay between successive emergences, location, and flux, all have irregular variations. Previous studies show that these variations can lead to changes in the polar field. In this study, we first demonstrate that our 3D kinematic dynamo model, STABLE, reproduces the robust feature of the surface flux transport (SFT) model, namely the variation of the generated dipole moment with the latitude of the BMR position. Using STABLE in both SFT and dynamo modes, we perform simulations by varying the individual properties of BMR and kee** their distributions the same in all the cycles as inspired by the observations. We find that randomness due to the distribution in either the time delay or the BMR latitude produces negligible variation in the polar field and the solar cycle. However, randomness due to BMR flux distribution produces substantial effects, while the scatter in the tilt around Joy law produces the largest variation. Our comparative analyses suggest that the scatter of BMR tilt around Joy law is the major cause of variation in the solar cycle. Furthermore, our simulations also show that the magnetic field-dependent time delay of BMR emergence produces more realistic features of the magnetic cycle, consistent with observation. △ Less

Submitted 16 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Comments: 11 Pages, 10 figures, Under review in MNRAS Journal

Analysis of BMR tilt from AutoTAB catalog: Hinting towards the thin flux tube model?

Authors: Anu Sreedevi, Bibhuti Kumar Jha, Bidya Binay Karak, Dipankar Banerjee

Abstract: One of the intriguing mechanisms of the Sun is the formation of the bipolar magnetic regions (BMRs) in the solar convection zone which are observed as regions of concentrated magnetic fields of opposite polarity on photosphere. These BMRs are tilted with respect to the equatorial line, which statistically increases with latitude. The thin flux tube model, employing the rise of magnetically buoyant… ▽ More One of the intriguing mechanisms of the Sun is the formation of the bipolar magnetic regions (BMRs) in the solar convection zone which are observed as regions of concentrated magnetic fields of opposite polarity on photosphere. These BMRs are tilted with respect to the equatorial line, which statistically increases with latitude. The thin flux tube model, employing the rise of magnetically buoyant flux loops and their twist by Coriolis force, is a popular paradigm for explaining the formation of tilted BMRs. In this study, we assess the validity of the thin flux tube model by analyzing the tracked BMR data obtained through the Automatic Tracking Algorithm for BMRs (AutoTAB). Our observations reveal that the tracked BMRs exhibit the expected collective behaviors. We find that the polarity separation of BMRs increases over their normalized lifetime, supporting the assumption of a rising flux tube from the CZ. Moreover, we observe an increasing trend of the tilt with the flux of the BMR, suggesting that rising flux tubes associated with lower flux regions are primarily influenced by drag force and Coriolis force, while in higher flux regions, magnetic buoyancy dominates. Furthermore, we observe Joy's law dependence for emerging BMRs from their first detection, indicating that at least a portion of the tilt observed in BMRs can be attributed to the Coriolis force. Notably, lower flux regions exhibit a higher amount of fluctuations associated with their tilt measurement compared to stronger flux regions, suggesting that lower flux regions are more susceptible to turbulent convection. △ Less

Submitted 14 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 16 pages, 10 figures. Under consideration in ApJ. Comments are welcome

Characterizing the solar cycle variability using nonlinear time series analysis at different amounts of dynamo supercriticality: Solar dynamo is not highly supercritical

Authors: Aparup Ghosh, Pawan Kumar, Amrita Prasad, Bidya Binay Karak

Abstract: The solar dynamo is essentially a cyclic process in which the toroidal component of the magnetic field is converted into the poloidal one and vice versa. This cyclic loop is disturbed by some nonlinear and stochastic processes mainly operating in the toroidal to poloidal part. Hence, the memory of the polar field decreases in every cycle. On the other hand, the dynamo efficiency and, thus, the sup… ▽ More The solar dynamo is essentially a cyclic process in which the toroidal component of the magnetic field is converted into the poloidal one and vice versa. This cyclic loop is disturbed by some nonlinear and stochastic processes mainly operating in the toroidal to poloidal part. Hence, the memory of the polar field decreases in every cycle. On the other hand, the dynamo efficiency and, thus, the supercriticality of the dynamo decreases with the Sun's age. Previous studies have shown that the memory of the polar magnetic field decreases with the increase of supercriticality of the dynamo. In this study, we employ popular techniques of time series analysis, namely, compute Higuchi's fractal dimension, Hurst exponent, and Multi-Fractal Detrended Fluctuation Analysis, to the amplitude of the solar magnetic cycle obtained from dynamo models operating at near-critical and supercritical regimes. We show that the magnetic field in the near-critical regime is governed by strong memory, less stochasticity, intermittency, and breakdown of self-similarity. On the contrary, the magnetic field in the supercritical region has less memory, strong stochasticity, and shows a good amount of self-similarity. Finally, applying the same time series analysis techniques in the reconstructed sunspot data of 85 cycles and comparing their results with that from models, we conclude that the solar dynamo is possibly operating near the critical regime and not too much supercritical regime. Thus Sun may not be too far from the critical dynamo transition. △ Less

Submitted 10 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: Accepted for publication in the Astronomical Journal

AutoTAB: An Algorithm to Track Bipolar Magnetic Regions and Initial results from the Tracked BMRs

Authors: Anu Sreedevi, Bibhuti Kumar Jha, Bidya Binay Karak, Dipankar Banerjee

Abstract: AutoTAB is a state-of-the-art, fully automatic algorithm that tracks the Bipolar Magnetic Regions (BMRs) in magnetogram observations. AutoTAB employs identified BMR regions from Line-of-Sight magnetograms from MDI and HMI (1996--2022) to track the BMRs through their evolution on the nearside of the Sun. AutoTAB enables us to create a comprehensive and unique catalog of tracked information of 9232… ▽ More AutoTAB is a state-of-the-art, fully automatic algorithm that tracks the Bipolar Magnetic Regions (BMRs) in magnetogram observations. AutoTAB employs identified BMR regions from Line-of-Sight magnetograms from MDI and HMI (1996--2022) to track the BMRs through their evolution on the nearside of the Sun. AutoTAB enables us to create a comprehensive and unique catalog of tracked information of 9232 BMRs in the mentioned time period. This dataset is used to study the collective statistical properties of BMRs and particularly to identify the correct theory for the BMR formation. Here, we discuss the algorithm's functionality and the initial findings obtained from the AutoTAB BMRs catalog. △ Less

Submitted 15 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Comments: 7 pages, 4 figure: IAUS 365 Proceedings Series

Recent Developments in the Babcock-Leighton Solar Dynamo Theory

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak

Abstract: Babcock-Leighton process, in which the poloidal field is generated through the decay and dispersal of tilted bipolar magnetic regions (BMRs), is observed to be the major process behind the generating poloidal field in the Sun. Based on this process, the Babcock-Leighton dynamo models have been a promising tool for explaining various aspects of solar and stellar magnetic cycles. In recent years, in… ▽ More Babcock-Leighton process, in which the poloidal field is generated through the decay and dispersal of tilted bipolar magnetic regions (BMRs), is observed to be the major process behind the generating poloidal field in the Sun. Based on this process, the Babcock-Leighton dynamo models have been a promising tool for explaining various aspects of solar and stellar magnetic cycles. In recent years, in the toroidal to poloidal part of this dynamo loop, various nonlinear mechanisms, namely the flux loss through the magnetic buoyancy in the formation of BMRs, latitude quenching, tilt quenching, and inflows around BMRs, have been identified. While these nonlinearities tend to produce a stable magnetic cycle, the irregular properties of BMR, mainly the scatter around Joy's law tilt, make a considerable variation in the solar cycle, including grand minima and maxima. After reviewing recent developments in these topics, I end the presentation by discussing the recent progress in making the early prediction of the solar cycle. △ Less

Submitted 12 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Comments: IAU proceedings based on the invited talk given at IAU Symposium 365 in Yerevan, Armenia

Exploring the Quenching of Bipolar Magnetic Region Tilts using AutoTAB

Authors: Bibhuti Kumar Jha, Anu B. Sreedevi, Bidya Binay Karak, Dipankar Banerjee

Abstract: The tilt of the bipolar magnetic region (BMR) is crucial in the Babcock-Leighton process for the generation of the poloidal magnetic field in the Sun. We extend the work of Jha et al. (2020) and analyze the recently reported tracked BMR catalogue based on AutoTAB Sreedevi et al. (2023) from Michelson Doppler Imager (1996-2011) and Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (2010-2018). Using the tracked inf… ▽ More The tilt of the bipolar magnetic region (BMR) is crucial in the Babcock-Leighton process for the generation of the poloidal magnetic field in the Sun. We extend the work of Jha et al. (2020) and analyze the recently reported tracked BMR catalogue based on AutoTAB Sreedevi et al. (2023) from Michelson Doppler Imager (1996-2011) and Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (2010-2018). Using the tracked information of BMRs based on AutoTAB, we confirm that the distribution of bmax reported by Jha et al. (2020) is not because of the BMRs are picked multiple times at the different phases of their evolution instead it is also present if we consider each BMRs only once. Moreover, we find that the slope of Joy's law initially increases slowly with the increase of bmax. However, when bmax>2.5 kG, gamma_0 decreases. The decrease of observed $gamma_0$ with bmax provides a hint to a nonlinear tilt quenching in the Babcock-Leighton process. △ Less

Submitted 8 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Comments: 4 Pages, 2 Figures; IAUS 365 Proceedings Series;

Exploring the reliability of polar field rise rate as a precursor for an early prediction of solar cycle

Authors: Akash Biswas, Bidya Binay Karak, Pawan Kumar

Abstract: The prediction of the strength of an upcoming solar cycle has been a long-standing challenge in the field of solar physics. The inherent stochastic nature of the underlying solar dynamo makes the strength of the solar cycle vary in a wide range. Till now, the polar precursor methods and the dynamo simulations, that use the strength of the polar field at the cycle minimum to predict the strength of… ▽ More The prediction of the strength of an upcoming solar cycle has been a long-standing challenge in the field of solar physics. The inherent stochastic nature of the underlying solar dynamo makes the strength of the solar cycle vary in a wide range. Till now, the polar precursor methods and the dynamo simulations, that use the strength of the polar field at the cycle minimum to predict the strength of the following cycle has gained reasonable consensus by providing convergence in the predictions for solar cycles 24 and 25. Recently, it has been shown that just by using the observed correlation of the polar field rise rate with the peak of the polar field at the cycle minimum and the amplitude of the following cycle, a reliable prediction can be made much earlier than the cycle minimum. In this work, we perform surface flux transport (SFT) simulations to explore the robustness of this correlation against the stochastic fluctuations of BMR tilt properties including anti-Joy and anti-Hale type anomalous BMRs, and against the variation of meridional flow speed. We find that the observed correlation is a robust feature of the solar cycles and thus it can be utilized for a reliable prediction of solar cycle much earlier than the cycle minimum, the usual landmark of the solar cycle prediction. △ Less

Submitted 29 September, 2023; v1 submitted 2 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS

Probing the variations in the timing of the Sun's polar magnetic field reversals through observations and surface flux transport simulations

Authors: Elena M. Golubeva, Akash Biswas, Anna I. Khlystova, Pawan Kumar, Bidya Binay Karak

Abstract: The polar field reversal is a crucial process in the cyclic evolution of the large-scale magnetic field of the Sun.Various important characteristics of a solar cycle, such as its duration and strength, and also the cycle predictability, are determined by the polar field reversal time. While the regular measurements of solar magnetic field have been accumulated for more than half a century, there i… ▽ More The polar field reversal is a crucial process in the cyclic evolution of the large-scale magnetic field of the Sun.Various important characteristics of a solar cycle, such as its duration and strength, and also the cycle predictability, are determined by the polar field reversal time. While the regular measurements of solar magnetic field have been accumulated for more than half a century, there is no consensus in the heliophysics community concerning the interpretation of the Sun's polar field measurements and especially the determination of polar field reversal time. There exists a severe problem of non-reproducibility in the reported results even from studies of the same observational dataset, and this causes an obstacle to make more accurate forecasts of solar cycle. Here, we analyze the solar magnetograms from four instruments for the last four cycles, to provide a more correct interpretation of the polar field observations and to find more accurate time of the reversals. We show the absence of triple (multipolar) reversals in Cycles 21 - 24, significant variations in the time interval between reversals in the hemispheres and in the time interval between a reversal and a cycle beginning. In order to understand the origin of the reversal time variation, we perform Surface Flux Transport (SFT) simulations and find out that the presence of the 'anomalous' bipolar magnetic regions (BMRs) in different phases of a cycle can cause cycle-to-cycle variations of the reversal time within the similar range found in observations. △ Less

Submitted 25 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS

Models for the long-term variations of solar activity

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak

Abstract: One obvious feature of the solar cycle is its variation from one cycle to another. In this article, we review the dynamo models for the long-term variations of the solar cycle. By long-term variations, we mean the cycle modulations beyond the 11-year periodicity and these include, the Gnevyshev-Ohl/Even-Odd rule, grand minima, grand maxima, Gleissberg cycle, and Suess cycles. After a brief review… ▽ More One obvious feature of the solar cycle is its variation from one cycle to another. In this article, we review the dynamo models for the long-term variations of the solar cycle. By long-term variations, we mean the cycle modulations beyond the 11-year periodicity and these include, the Gnevyshev-Ohl/Even-Odd rule, grand minima, grand maxima, Gleissberg cycle, and Suess cycles. After a brief review of the observed data, we present the dynamo models for the solar cycle. By carefully analyzing the dynamo models and the observed data, we identify the following broad causes for the modulation: (i) magnetic feedback on the flow, (ii) stochastic forcing, and (iii) time delays in various processes of the dynamo. To demonstrate each of these causes, we present the results from some illustrative models for the cycle modulations and discuss their strengths and weakness. We also discuss a few critical issues and their current trends. The article ends with a discussion of our current state of ignorance about comparing detailed features of the magnetic cycle and the large-scale velocity from the dynamo models with robust observations. △ Less

Submitted 26 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: Invited review article for Living Reviews in Solar Physics, in press (53 pages including 25 figures)

AutoTAB: Automatic Tracking Algorithm for Bipolar Magnetic Regions

Authors: Anu Sreedevi, Bibhuti Kumar Jha, Bidya Binay Karak, Dipankar Banerjee

Abstract: Bipolar Magnetic Regions (BMRs) provide crucial information about solar magnetism. They exhibit varying morphology and magnetic properties throughout their lifetime, and studying these properties can provide valuable insights into the workings of the solar dynamo. The majority of previous studies have counted every detected BMR as a new one and have not been able to study the full life history of… ▽ More Bipolar Magnetic Regions (BMRs) provide crucial information about solar magnetism. They exhibit varying morphology and magnetic properties throughout their lifetime, and studying these properties can provide valuable insights into the workings of the solar dynamo. The majority of previous studies have counted every detected BMR as a new one and have not been able to study the full life history of each BMRs. To address this issue, we have developed an Automatic Tracking Algorithm (AutoTAB) for BMRs, that tracks the BMRs for their entire lifetime or throughout their disk passage. AutoTAB uses the binary maps of detected BMRs to automatically track the regions. This is done by differentially rotating the binary maps of the detected regions and checking for overlaps between them. In this first article of this project, we provide a detailed description of the working of the algorithm and evaluate its strengths and weaknesses by comparing it with existing algorithms. AutoTAB excels in tracking even for the small BMRs (with flux $\sim 10^{20}$ Mx) and it has successfully tracked 9152 BMRs over the last two solar cycles (1996--2020), providing a comprehensive dataset that depicts the evolution of various properties for each BMR. The tracked BMRs exhibit the well-known latitudinal-time distribution and 11 year cyclic variation except for small BMRs which appear at all phases of the solar cycle and show weak latitudinal dependency. Finally, we discuss the possibility of adapting our algorithm to other datasets and expanding the technique to track other solar features in the future. △ Less

Submitted 15 June, 2023; v1 submitted 13 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Comments: 14 pages including 9 figures; Re-submitted in ApJS; Comments are welcome

Journal ref: The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series, Volume 268, Issue 2, id.58, 10 pp. (2023)

Dynamo modelling for cycle variability and occurrence of grand minima in Sun-like stars: Rotation rate dependence

Authors: Vindya Vashishth, Bidya Binay Karak, Leonid Kitchatinov

Abstract: Like the solar cycle, stellar activity cycles are also irregular. Observations reveal that rapidly rotating (young) Sun-like stars exhibit a high level of activity with no Maunder-like grand minima and rarely display smooth regular activity cycles. On the other hand, slowly rotating old stars like the Sun have low activity levels and smooth cycles with occasional grand minima. We, for the first ti… ▽ More Like the solar cycle, stellar activity cycles are also irregular. Observations reveal that rapidly rotating (young) Sun-like stars exhibit a high level of activity with no Maunder-like grand minima and rarely display smooth regular activity cycles. On the other hand, slowly rotating old stars like the Sun have low activity levels and smooth cycles with occasional grand minima. We, for the first time, try to model these observational trends using flux transport dynamo models. Following previous works, we build kinematic dynamo models of one solar mass star with different rotation rates. Differential rotation and meridional circulation are specified with a mean-field hydrodynamic model. We include stochastic fluctuations in the Babcock-Leighton source of the poloidal field to capture the inherent fluctuations in the stellar convection. Based on extensive simulations, we find that rapidly rotating stars produce highly irregular cycles with strong magnetic fields and rarely produce Maunder-like grand minima, whereas the slowly-rotating stars (with a rotation period of 10 days and longer) produce smooth cycles of weaker strength, long-term modulation in the amplitude, and occasional extended grand minima. The average duration and the frequency of grand minima increase with decreasing rotation rate. These results can be understood as the tendency of less supercritical dynamo in slower rotating stars to be more prone to produce extended grand minima △ Less

Submitted 12 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Comments: Accepted in MNRAS

Toroidal flux loss due to flux emergence explains why solar cycles rise differently but decay in a similar way

Authors: Akash Biswas, Bidya Binay Karak, Robert Cameron

Abstract: A striking feature of the solar cycle is that at the beginning, sunspots appear around mid-latitudes, and over time the latitudes of emergences migrate towards the equator.The maximum level of activity (e.g., sunspot number) varies from cycle to cycle.For strong cycles, the activity begins early and at higher latitudes with wider sunspot distributions than for weak cycles. The activity and the wid… ▽ More A striking feature of the solar cycle is that at the beginning, sunspots appear around mid-latitudes, and over time the latitudes of emergences migrate towards the equator.The maximum level of activity (e.g., sunspot number) varies from cycle to cycle.For strong cycles, the activity begins early and at higher latitudes with wider sunspot distributions than for weak cycles. The activity and the width of sunspot belts increase rapidly and begin to decline when the belts are still at high latitudes. Surprisingly, it has been reported that in the late stages of the cycle the level of activity (sunspot number) as well as the widths and centers of the butterfly wings all have the same statistical properties independent of how strong the cycle was during its rise and maximum phases.We have modeled these features using a Babcock--Leighton type dynamo model and show that the flux loss through magnetic buoyancy is an essential nonlinearity in the solar dynamo.Our study shows that the nonlinearity is effective if the flux emergence becomes efficient at the mean-field strength of the order of $10^4$~G in the lower part of the convection zone. △ Less

Submitted 13 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: Accepted in Phys.Rev.Lett. (PRL)

Physical link of the polar field build-up with the Waldmeier effect broadens the scope of early solar cycle prediction: Cycle 25 is likely to be slightly stronger than Cycle 24

Authors: Pawan Kumar, Akash Biswas, Bidya Binay Karak

Abstract: Prediction of the solar cycle is challenging but essential because it drives space weather. Several predictions with varying amplitudes of the ongoing Cycle~25 have been made. We show that an aspect of the Waldmeier effect (WE2), i.e., a strong positive correlation between the rise rate and the amplitude of the cycle, has a physical link with the build-up of the previous cycle's polar field after… ▽ More Prediction of the solar cycle is challenging but essential because it drives space weather. Several predictions with varying amplitudes of the ongoing Cycle~25 have been made. We show that an aspect of the Waldmeier effect (WE2), i.e., a strong positive correlation between the rise rate and the amplitude of the cycle, has a physical link with the build-up of the previous cycle's polar field after its reversal. We find that the rise rate of the polar field is highly correlated with the rise rate and the amplitude of the next solar cycle. Thus, the prediction of the amplitude of the solar cycle can be made just a few years after the reversal of the previous cycle's polar field, thereby extending the scope of the solar cycle prediction to much earlier than the usual time. Our prediction of Cycle 25 based on the rise rate of the previous polar field is $137\pm 23$, which is quite close to the prediction $138\pm 26$ based on the WE2 computed from the available 2 years sunspot data of the ongoing cycle. △ Less

Submitted 22 May, 2022; v1 submitted 22 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: Accepted in MNRAS: Letters

Journal ref: MNRAS: Letters, 2022

Evolution of the Sun's activity and the poleward transport of remnant magnetic flux in Cycles 21--24

Authors: Alexander V. Mordvinov, Bidya Binay Karak, Dipankar Banerjee, Elena M. Golubeva, Anna I. Khlystova, Anastasiya V. Zhukova, Pawan Kumar

Abstract: Detailed study of the solar magnetic field is crucial to understand its generation, transport and reversals. The timing of the reversals may have implications on space weather and thus identification of the temporal behavior of the critical surges that lead to the polar field reversals is important. We analyze the evolution of solar activity and magnetic flux transport in Cycles 21--24. We identif… ▽ More Detailed study of the solar magnetic field is crucial to understand its generation, transport and reversals. The timing of the reversals may have implications on space weather and thus identification of the temporal behavior of the critical surges that lead to the polar field reversals is important. We analyze the evolution of solar activity and magnetic flux transport in Cycles 21--24. We identify critical surges of remnant flux that reach the Sun's poles and lead to the polar field reversals. We reexamine the polar field buildup and reversals in their causal relation to the Sun's low-latitude activity. We further identify the major remnant flux surges and their sources in the time-latitude aspect. We find that special characteristics of individual 11-year cycles are generally determined by the spatiotemporal organization of emergent magnetic flux and its unusual properties. We find a complicated restructuring of high-latitude magnetic fields in Cycle~21. The global rearrangements of solar magnetic fields were caused by surges of trailing and leading polarities that occurred near the activity maximum. The decay of non-Joy and anti-Hale active regions resulted in the remnant flux surges that disturbed the usual order in magnetic flux transport. We finally show that the leading-polarity surges during cycle minima sometimes link the following cycle and a collective effect of these surges may lead to secular changes in solar activity. The magnetic field from a Babcock--Leighton dynamo model generally agrees with these observations. △ Less

Submitted 30 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS; 5 pages including 5 figures

Is the Hemispheric Asymmetry of Monthly Sunspot Area an Irregular Process with Long-Term Memory?

Authors: Ratul Das, Aparup Ghosh, Bidya Binay Karak

Abstract: The hemispheric asymmetry of the sunspot cycle is a real feature of the Sun. However, its origin is still not well understood. Here we perform nonlinear time series analysis of the sunspot area (and number) asymmetry to explore its dynamics. By measuring the correlation dimension of the sunspot area asymmetry, we conclude that there is no strange attractor in the data. Further computing Higuchi's… ▽ More The hemispheric asymmetry of the sunspot cycle is a real feature of the Sun. However, its origin is still not well understood. Here we perform nonlinear time series analysis of the sunspot area (and number) asymmetry to explore its dynamics. By measuring the correlation dimension of the sunspot area asymmetry, we conclude that there is no strange attractor in the data. Further computing Higuchi's dimension, we conclude that the hemispheric asymmetry is largely governed by stochastic noise. However, the behaviour of Hurst exponent reveals that the time series is not completely determined by a memory-less stochastic noise, rather there is a long-term persistence, which can go beyond two solar cycles. Therefore, our study suggests that the hemispheric asymmetry of the sunspot cycle is predominantly originated due to some irregular process in the solar dynamo. The long-term persistence in the solar cycle asymmetry suggests that the solar magnetic field has some memory in the convection zone. △ Less

Submitted 11 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: Under review in MNRAS

Subcritical dynamo and hysteresis in a Babcock-Leighton type kinematic dynamo model

Authors: Vindya Vashishth, Bidya Binay Karak, Leonid Kitchatinov

Abstract: In Sun and sun-like stars, it is believed that the cycles of the large-scale magnetic field are produced due to the existence of differential rotation and helicity in the plasma flows in their convection zones (CZs). Hence, it is expected that for each star, there is a critical dynamo number for the operation of a large-scale dynamo. As a star slows down, it is expected that the large-scale dynamo… ▽ More In Sun and sun-like stars, it is believed that the cycles of the large-scale magnetic field are produced due to the existence of differential rotation and helicity in the plasma flows in their convection zones (CZs). Hence, it is expected that for each star, there is a critical dynamo number for the operation of a large-scale dynamo. As a star slows down, it is expected that the large-scale dynamo ceases to operate above a critical rotation period. In our study, we explore the possibility of the operation of the dynamo in the subcritical region using the Babcock--Leighton type kinematic dynamo model. In some parameter regimes, we find that the dynamo shows hysteresis behavior, i.e., two dynamo solutions are possible depending on the initial parameters -- decaying solution if started with weak field and strong oscillatory solution (subcritical dynamo) when started with a strong field. However, under large fluctuations in the dynamo parameter, the subcritical dynamo mode is unstable in some parameter regimes. Therefore, our study supports the possible existence of subcritical dynamo in some stars which was previously shown in a mean-field dynamo model with distributed $α$ and MHD turbulent dynamo simulations. △ Less

Submitted 4 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: 11 pages, including 7 figures

Supercriticality of the dynamo limits the memory of the polar field to one cycle

Authors: Pawan Kumar, Bidya Binay Karak, Vindya Vashishth

Abstract: The polar magnetic field precursor is considered to be the most robust and physics-based method for the prediction of the next solar cycle strength. However, to make a reliable prediction of a cycle, is the polar field at the solar minimum of the previous cycle enough or we need the polar field of many previous cycles? To answer this question, we performed several simulations using Babcock-Leighto… ▽ More The polar magnetic field precursor is considered to be the most robust and physics-based method for the prediction of the next solar cycle strength. However, to make a reliable prediction of a cycle, is the polar field at the solar minimum of the previous cycle enough or we need the polar field of many previous cycles? To answer this question, we performed several simulations using Babcock-Leighton type flux transport dynamo models with the stochastically forced source for the poloidal field ($α$ term). We show that when the dynamo is operating near the critical dynamo transition or only weakly supercritical, the polar field of the cycle n determines the amplitude of the next several cycles (at least three). However, when the dynamo is substantially supercritical, this correlation of the polar field is reduced to one cycle. This change in the memory of the polar field from multi- to one-cycle with the increase of the super-criticality of the dynamo is independent of the importance of various turbulent transport processes in the model. We further show that when the dynamo operates near the critical, it produces frequent extended episodes of weaker activity, resembling the solar grand minima. The occurrence of grand minima is accompanied by the multi-cycle correlation of polar field. The frequency of grand minima decreases with the increase of supercriticality of the dynamo. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2022; v1 submitted 22 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: 12 pages, 7 figures and accepted in ApJ

The polar precursor method for solar cycle prediction: comparison of predictors and their temporal range

Authors: Pawan Kumar, Melinda Nagy, Alexandre Lemerle, Bidya Binay Karak, Kristof Petrovay

Abstract: The polar precursor method is widely considered to be the most robust physically motivated method to predict the amplitude of an upcoming solar cycle.It uses indicators of the magnetic field concentrated near the poles around sunspot minimum. Here, we present an extensive performance analysis of various such predictors, based on both observational data (WSO magnetograms, MWO polar faculae counts a… ▽ More The polar precursor method is widely considered to be the most robust physically motivated method to predict the amplitude of an upcoming solar cycle.It uses indicators of the magnetic field concentrated near the poles around sunspot minimum. Here, we present an extensive performance analysis of various such predictors, based on both observational data (WSO magnetograms, MWO polar faculae counts and Pulkovo $A(t)$ index) and outputs (polar cap magnetic flux and global dipole moment) of various existing flux transport dynamo models.We calculate Pearson correlation coefficients ($r$) of the predictors with the next cycle amplitude as a function of time measured from several solar cycle landmarks: setting $r= 0.8$ as a lower limit for acceptable predictions, we find that observations and models alike indicate that the earliest time when the polar predictor can be safely used is 4 years after polar field reversal. This is typically 2--3 years before solar minimum and about 7~years before the predicted maximum, considerably extending the {usual} temporal scope of the polar precursor method. Re-evaluating the predictors another 3 years later, at the time of solar minimum, further increases the correlation level to $r\ga 0.9$. As an illustration of the result, we determine the predicted amplitude of Cycle 25 based on the value of the WSO polar field at the now official minimum date of December 2019 as $126\pm 3$. A forecast based on the value in early 2017, 4~years after polar reversal would have only differed from this final prediction by $3.1\pm 14.7$\%. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2022; v1 submitted 13 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: Accepted in ApJ; 13 pages,7 figures

Journal ref: The Astrophysical Journal, 909:87 (12pp), 2021 March 1

Chaotic transients and hysteresis in an $α^{2}$ dynamo model

Authors: Dalton N. Oliveira, Erico L. Rempel, Roman Chertovskih, Bidya B. Karak

Abstract: The presence of chaotic transients in a nonlinear dynamo is investigated through numerical simulations of the 3D magnetohydrodynamic equations. By using the kinetic helicity of the flow as a control parameter, a hysteretic blowout bifurcation is conjectured to be responsible for the transition to dynamo, leading to a sudden increase in the magnetic energy of the attractor. This high-energy hydroma… ▽ More The presence of chaotic transients in a nonlinear dynamo is investigated through numerical simulations of the 3D magnetohydrodynamic equations. By using the kinetic helicity of the flow as a control parameter, a hysteretic blowout bifurcation is conjectured to be responsible for the transition to dynamo, leading to a sudden increase in the magnetic energy of the attractor. This high-energy hydromagnetic attractor is suddenly destroyed in a boundary crisis when the helicity is decreased. Both the blowout bifurcation and the boundary crisis generate long chaotic transients that are due, respectively, to a chaotic saddle and a relative chaotic attractor. △ Less

Submitted 26 October, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Journal ref: J. Phys. Complex. 2 025012 (2021)

Long-Term Evolution of the Sun's magnetic field during Cycles 15--19 based on their proxies from Kodaikanal Solar Observatory

Authors: Alexander V. Mordvinov, Bidya Binay Karak, Dipankar Banerjee, Subhamoy Chatterjee, Elena M. Golubeva, Anna I. Khlystova

Abstract: The regular observation of the solar magnetic field is available only for about last five cycles. Thus, to understand the origin of the variation of the solar magnetic field, it is essential to reconstruct the magnetic field for the past cycles, utilizing other datasets. Long-term uniform observations for the past 100 years as recorded at the Kodaikanal Solar Observatory (KoSO) provide such opport… ▽ More The regular observation of the solar magnetic field is available only for about last five cycles. Thus, to understand the origin of the variation of the solar magnetic field, it is essential to reconstruct the magnetic field for the past cycles, utilizing other datasets. Long-term uniform observations for the past 100 years as recorded at the Kodaikanal Solar Observatory (KoSO) provide such opportunity. We develop a method for the reconstruction of the solar magnetic field using the synoptic observations of the Sun's emission in the Ca II K and H$α$ lines from KoSO for the first time. The reconstruction method is based on the facts that the Ca II K intensity correlates well with the unsigned magnetic flux, while the sign of the flux is derived from the corresponding H$α$ map which provides the information of the dominant polarities. Based on this reconstructed magnetic map, we study the evolution of the magnetic field in Cycles 15--19. We also study bipolar magnetic regions (BMRs) and their remnant flux surges in their causal relation. Time-latitude analysis of the reconstructed magnetic flux provides an overall view of magnetic field evolution: emergent magnetic flux, its further transformations with the formation of unipolar magnetic regions (UMRs) and remnant flux surges. We identify the reversals of the polar field and critical surges of following and leading polarities. We found that the poleward transport of opposite polarities led to multiple changes of the dominant magnetic polarities in poles. Furthermore, the remnant flux surges that occur between adjacent 11-year cycles reveal physical connections between them. △ Less

Submitted 23 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: 6 pages including figures; accepted for publication in ApJL

Journal ref: The Astrophysical Journal Letters, 902:L15 (6pp), 2020

Dynamo saturation through the latitudinal variation of bipolar magnetic regions in the Sun

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak

Abstract: Observations of the solar magnetic cycle showed that the amplitude of the cycle did not grow all the time in the past. Thus, there must be a mechanism to halt the growth of the magnetic field in the Sun. We demonstrate a recently proposed mechanism for this under the Babcock--Leighton dynamo framework, which is believed to be the most promising paradigm for the generation of the solar magnetic fie… ▽ More Observations of the solar magnetic cycle showed that the amplitude of the cycle did not grow all the time in the past. Thus, there must be a mechanism to halt the growth of the magnetic field in the Sun. We demonstrate a recently proposed mechanism for this under the Babcock--Leighton dynamo framework, which is believed to be the most promising paradigm for the generation of the solar magnetic field at present. This mechanism is based on the observational fact that the stronger solar cycles produce bipolar magnetic regions (BMRs) at higher latitudes and thus have higher mean latitudes than the weaker ones. We capture this effect in our three-dimensional Babcock--Leighton solar dynamo model and show that when the toroidal magnetic field tries to grow, it produces BMRs at higher latitudes. The BMRs at higher latitudes generate a less poloidal field, which consequently limits the overall growth of the magnetic field in our model. Thus, our study suggests that the latitudinal variation of BMRs is a potential mechanism for limiting the magnetic field growth in the Sun. △ Less

Submitted 1 February, 2021; v1 submitted 15 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: Published in ApJL; 6 pages, including 4 figures

Journal ref: The Astrophysical Journal Letters, 901:L35 (6pp), 2020

Global maps of the magnetic field in the solar corona

Authors: Zihao Yang, Christian Bethge, Hui Tian, Steven Tomczyk, Richard Morton, Giulio Del Zanna, Scott W. McIntosh, Bidya Binay Karak, Sarah Gibson, Tanmoy Samanta, Jiansen He, Yajie Chen, Linghua Wang

Abstract: Understanding many physical processes in the solar atmosphere requires determination of the magnetic field in each atmospheric layer. However, direct measurements of the magnetic field in the Sun's corona are difficult to obtain. Using observations with the Coronal Multi-channel Polarimeter, we have determined the spatial distribution of the plasma density in the corona, and the phase speed of the… ▽ More Understanding many physical processes in the solar atmosphere requires determination of the magnetic field in each atmospheric layer. However, direct measurements of the magnetic field in the Sun's corona are difficult to obtain. Using observations with the Coronal Multi-channel Polarimeter, we have determined the spatial distribution of the plasma density in the corona, and the phase speed of the prevailing transverse magnetohydrodynamic waves within the plasma. We combine these measurements to map the plane-of-sky component of the global coronal magnetic field. The derived field strengths in the corona from 1.05 to 1.35 solar radii are mostly 1-4 Gauss. These results demonstrate the capability of imaging spectroscopy in coronal magnetic field diagnostics. △ Less

Submitted 7 August, 2020; originally announced August 2020.

Comments: Published in Science, File includes the main text and supplementary materials. This is the author's version of the work. It is posted here by permission of the AAAS for personal use, not for redistribution. The definitive version was published in Science , (2020-08-07), doi: 10.1126/science.abb4462 (https://science.sciencemag.org/content/369/6504/694)

Journal ref: Science, 369, 694 (2020)

Magnetic field dependence of bipolar magnetic region tilts on the Sun: Indication of tilt quenching

Authors: Bibhuti Kumar Jha, Bidya Binay Karak, Sudip Mandal, Dipankar Banerjee

Abstract: The tilt of bipolar magnetic region (BMR) is crucial in the Babcock--Leighton process for the generation of the poloidal magnetic field in Sun. Based on the thin flux tube model of the BMR formation, the tilt is believed to be caused by the Coriolis force acting on the rising flux tube of the strong toroidal magnetic field from the base of the convection zone (BCZ). We analyze the magnetic field d… ▽ More The tilt of bipolar magnetic region (BMR) is crucial in the Babcock--Leighton process for the generation of the poloidal magnetic field in Sun. Based on the thin flux tube model of the BMR formation, the tilt is believed to be caused by the Coriolis force acting on the rising flux tube of the strong toroidal magnetic field from the base of the convection zone (BCZ). We analyze the magnetic field dependence of BMR tilts using the magnetograms of Michelson Doppler Imager (MDI) (1996-2011) and Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (HMI) (2010-2018). We observe that the distribution of the maximum magnetic field ($B_{\rm max}$) of BMRs is bimodal. Its first peak at the low field corresponds to BMRs which do not have sunspots as counterparts in the white light images, whereas the second peak corresponds to sunspots as recorded in both types of images. We find that the slope of Joy's law ($γ_0$) initially increases slowly with the increase of $B_{\rm max}$. However, when $B_{\rm max} \gtrsim 2$ kG, $γ_0$ decreases. Scatter of BMR tilt around Joy's law systematically decreases with the increase of $B_{\rm max}$. The decrease of observed $γ_0$ with $B_{\rm max}$ provides a hint to a nonlinear tilt quenching in the Babcock--Leighton process. We finally discuss how our results may be used to make a connection with the thin flux tube model. △ Less

Submitted 31 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Comments: 7 pages and 4 figures; Accepted for Publication in ApJL

Journal ref: 2020 ApJL 889 L19

Stellar Dynamos with Solar and Anti-solar Differential Rotations: Implications to Magnetic Cycles of Slowly Rotating Stars

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak, Aparna Tomar, Vindya Vashishth

Abstract: Simulations of magnetohydrodynamics convection in slowly rotating stars predict anti-solar differential rotation (DR) in which the equator rotates slower than poles. This anti-solar DR in the usual $αΩ$ dynamo model does not produce polarity reversal. Thus, the features of large-scale magnetic fields in slowly rotating stars are expected to be different than stars having solar-like DR. In this stu… ▽ More Simulations of magnetohydrodynamics convection in slowly rotating stars predict anti-solar differential rotation (DR) in which the equator rotates slower than poles. This anti-solar DR in the usual $αΩ$ dynamo model does not produce polarity reversal. Thus, the features of large-scale magnetic fields in slowly rotating stars are expected to be different than stars having solar-like DR. In this study, we perform mean-field kinematic dynamo modelling of different stars at different rotation periods. We consider anti-solar DR for the stars having rotation period larger than 30~days and solar-like DR otherwise. We show that with particular $α$ profiles, the dynamo model produces magnetic cycles with polarity reversals even with the anti-solar DR provided, the DR is quenched when the toroidal field grows considerably high and there is a sufficiently strong $α$ for the generation of toroidal field. Due to the anti-solar DR, the model produces an abrupt increase of magnetic field exactly when the DR profile is changed from solar-like to anti-solar. This enhancement of magnetic field is in good agreement with the stellar observational data as well as some global convection simulations. In the solar-like DR branch, with the decreasing rotation period, we find the magnetic field strength increases while the cycle period shortens. Both of these trends are in general agreement with observations. Our study provides additional support for the possible existence of anti-solar DR in slowly rotating stars and the presence of unusually enhanced magnetic fields and possibly cycles which are prone to production of superflare. △ Less

Submitted 25 November, 2019; v1 submitted 25 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS

Journal ref: MNRAS 491, 3155-3164, 2020

Waldmeier Effect in Stellar Cycles

Authors: Suyog Garg, Bidya Binay Karak, Ricky Egeland, Willie Soon, Sallie Baliunas

Abstract: One of the most robust features of the solar magnetic cycle is that the stronger cycles rise faster than the weaker ones. This is popularly known as the Waldmeier Effect, which is known for more than 80 years. This fundamental feature of the solar cycle has not only practical implications, e,g., in predicting the solar cycle, but also implications in understanding the solar dynamo. Here we ask the… ▽ More One of the most robust features of the solar magnetic cycle is that the stronger cycles rise faster than the weaker ones. This is popularly known as the Waldmeier Effect, which is known for more than 80 years. This fundamental feature of the solar cycle has not only practical implications, e,g., in predicting the solar cycle, but also implications in understanding the solar dynamo. Here we ask the question whether the Waldmeier Effect exists in other Sun-like stars. To answer this question, we analyze the Ca \II{} H \& K S-index from Mount Wilson Observatory for 21 Sun-like G--K stars. We specifically check two aspects of Waldmeier Effect, namely, WE1: the anti-correlation between the rise times and the peaks and WE2: the positive correlation between rise rates and amplitudes. We show that except HD~16160, HD~81809, HD~155886 and HD~161239, all stars considered in the analysis show WE2. While WE1 is found to be present only in some of the stars studied. Further, the WE1 correlation is weaker than the WE2. Both WE1 and WE2 exist in the solar S-index as well. Similar to the solar cycles, the magnetic cycles of many stars are asymmetric about their maxima. The existence of the Waldmeier Effect and asymmetric cycles in Sun-like stars suggests that the dynamo mechanism which operates in the Sun is also operating in other stars. △ Less

Submitted 26 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: Submitted in ApJ

Journal ref: The Astrophysical Journal, 886:132 (12pp), 2019

Exploring cycle period and parity of stellar magnetic activity with dynamo modeling

Authors: Gopal Hazra, Jie Jiang, Bidya Binay Karak, Leonid Kitchatinov

Abstract: Observations of chromospheric and coronal emissions from various solar-type stars show that the stellar magnetic activity varies with the rotation rates of the stars. The faster the star rotates, its magnetic activity gets stronger but activity cycle period does not show a straightforward variation with the rotation rate. For slowly rotating stars, the cycle period decreases with the increase of r… ▽ More Observations of chromospheric and coronal emissions from various solar-type stars show that the stellar magnetic activity varies with the rotation rates of the stars. The faster the star rotates, its magnetic activity gets stronger but activity cycle period does not show a straightforward variation with the rotation rate. For slowly rotating stars, the cycle period decreases with the increase of rotation rate, while for the fast rotators dependency of cycle period on rotation is presently quite complicated. We aim to provide an explanation of these observational trends of stellar magnetic activity using a dynamo model. We construct a theoretical dynamo model for stars of mass 1 $M_\odot$ based on the kinematic flux transport dynamo model including radial pum** near the surface of the stars. The inclusion of this near surface downward radial pum** is found to be necessary to match the observed surface magnetic field in case of the Sun. The main ingredients of our dynamo model, meridional circulation and differential rotation for stars are obtained from a mean-field hydrodynamic model. Our model shows a decrease of cycle period with increasing rotation rate in the slowly rotating regime and a slight increase of cycle period with rotation rate for the rapid rotators. The strength of the magnetic field is found to be increasing as the rotation rate of the star increases. We also find that the parity of the stellar magnetic field changes with rotation. According to our model, the parity flips to quadrupolar from dipolar if the rotation period of the star is less than 17 days. △ Less

Submitted 3 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: 16 pages, 10 figures, Accepted for publication in ApJ

Double-peaks of the solar cycle: An explanation from a dynamo model

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak, Sudip Mandal, Dipankar Banerjee

Abstract: One peculiar feature of the solar cycle which is yet to be understood properly is the frequent occurrence of double peaks (also known as the Gnevyshev peaks). Not only the double peaks but also multiple peaks and spikes are often observed in any phase of the cycle. We propose that these peaks and spikes are generated due to fluctuations in the Babcock-Leighton process (the poloidal field generatio… ▽ More One peculiar feature of the solar cycle which is yet to be understood properly is the frequent occurrence of double peaks (also known as the Gnevyshev peaks). Not only the double peaks but also multiple peaks and spikes are often observed in any phase of the cycle. We propose that these peaks and spikes are generated due to fluctuations in the Babcock-Leighton process (the poloidal field generation from tilted bipolar magnetic regions). When the polar field develops, large negative fluctuations in the Babcock-Leighton process can reduce the net polar field abruptly. As these fluctuations in the polar field are propagated to the new toroidal field, these can promote double peaks in the next solar cycle. When fluctuations in the polar field occur outside the solar maximum, we observe their effects as spikes or dips in the following sunspot cycle. Using an axisymmetric Babcock-Leighton dynamo model we first demonstrate this idea. Later, we perform a long simulation by including random scatter in the poloidal field generation process and successfully reproduce the double-peaked solar cycles. These results are robust under reasonable changes in the model parameters as long as the diffusivity is not too larger than $10^{12}$ cm$^2$s$^{-1}$. Finally, we analyze the observed polar field data to show a close connection between the short-term fluctuations in the polar field and the double peaks/spikes in the next cycle. Thereby, this supports our theoretical idea that the fluctuations in the Babcock-Leighton process can be responsible for the double peaks/spikes in the observed solar cycle. △ Less

Submitted 12 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Comments: 12 pages including 5 figures. Accepted in ApJ

Journal ref: The Astrophysical Journal, Volume 866, Number 1 (2018)

The Extended Solar Cycle: Muddying the Waters of Solar/Stellar Dynamo Modeling Or Providing Crucial Observational Constraints?

Authors: A. K. Srivastava, S. W. McIntosh, N. Arge, D. Banerjee, E. Cliver, M. Dikpati, B. N. Dwivedi, M. Guhathakurta, B. B. Karak, R. J. Leamon, P. Martens, S. K. Matthew, A. Munoz-Jaramillo, D. Nandi, A. Norton, L. Upton, S. Chatterjee, R. Mazumder, Yamini K. Rao, R. Yadav

Abstract: In 1844 Schwabe discovered that the number of sunspots increased and decreased over a period of about 11 years, that variation became known as the sunspot cycle. Almost eighty years later, Hale described the nature of the Sun's magnetic field, identifying that it takes about 22 years for the Sun's magnetic polarity to cycle. It was also identified that the latitudinal distribution of sunspots rese… ▽ More In 1844 Schwabe discovered that the number of sunspots increased and decreased over a period of about 11 years, that variation became known as the sunspot cycle. Almost eighty years later, Hale described the nature of the Sun's magnetic field, identifying that it takes about 22 years for the Sun's magnetic polarity to cycle. It was also identified that the latitudinal distribution of sunspots resembles the wings of a butterfly showing migration of sunspots in each hemisphere that abruptly start at mid-latitudes towards the Sun's equator over the next 11 years. These sunspot patterns were shown to be asymmetric across the equator. In intervening years, it was deduced that the Sun (and sun-like stars) possess magnetic activity cycles that are assumed to be the physical manifestation of a dynamo process that results from complex circulatory transport processes in the star's interior. Understanding the Sun's magnetism, its origin and its variation, has become a fundamental scientific objective \-- the distribution of magnetism, and its interaction with convective processes, drives various plasma processes in the outer atmosphere. In the past few decades, a range of diagnostic techniques have been employed to systematically study finer scale magnetized objects, and associated phenomena. The patterns discerned became known as the ``Extended Solar Cycle'' (ESC). The patterns of the ESC appeared to extend the wings of the activity butterfly back in time, nearly a decade before the formation of the sunspot pattern, and to much higher solar latitudes. In this short review, we describe their observational patterns of the ESC and discuss possible connections to the solar dynamo as we depart on a multi-national collaboration to investigate the origins of solar magnetism through a blend of archived and contemporary data analysis with the goal of improving solar dynamo understanding and modeling. △ Less

Submitted 19 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Comments: 11 Pages; 03 Figures

Long-term variability of the solar cycle in the Babcock-Leighton dynamo framework

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak, Mark Miesch

Abstract: We explore the cause of the solar cycle variabilities using a novel 3D Babcock--Leighton dynamo model. In this model, based on the toroidal flux at the base of the convection zone, bipolar magnetic regions (BMRs) are produced with statistical properties obtained from observed distributions. We find that a little quenching in BMR tilt is sufficient to stabilize the dynamo growth. The randomness and… ▽ More We explore the cause of the solar cycle variabilities using a novel 3D Babcock--Leighton dynamo model. In this model, based on the toroidal flux at the base of the convection zone, bipolar magnetic regions (BMRs) are produced with statistical properties obtained from observed distributions. We find that a little quenching in BMR tilt is sufficient to stabilize the dynamo growth. The randomness and nonlinearity in the BMR emergences make the poloidal field unequal and cause some variability in the solar cycle. However, when observed scatter of BMR tilts around Joy's law with a standard deviation of $15^\circ$, is considered, our model produces a variation in the solar cycle, including north-south asymmetry comparable to the observations. The morphology of magnetic fields closely resembles observations, in particular the surface radial field possesses a more mixed polarity field. Observed scatter also produces grand minima. In 11,650 years of simulation, 17 grand minima are detected and $11\%$ of its time the model remained in these grand minima. When we double the tilt scatter, the model produces correct statistics of grand minima. Importantly, the dynamo continues even during grand minima with only a few BMRs, without requiring any additional alpha effect. The reason for this is the downward magnetic pum** which suppresses the diffusion of the magnetic flux across the surface. The magnetic pum** also helps to achieve 11-year magnetic cycle using the observed BMR flux distribution, even at the high diffusivity. △ Less

Submitted 13 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.

Comments: 4 pages including 4 figures

Consequences of high effective Prandtl number on solar differential rotation and convective velocity

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak, Mark Miesch, Yuto Bekki

Abstract: Observations suggest that the large-scale convective velocities obtained by solar convection simulations might be over-estimated (convective conundrum). One plausible solution to this could be the small-scale dynamo which cannot be fully resolved by global simulations. The small-scale Lorentz force suppresses the convective motions and also the turbulent mixing of entropy between upflows and downf… ▽ More Observations suggest that the large-scale convective velocities obtained by solar convection simulations might be over-estimated (convective conundrum). One plausible solution to this could be the small-scale dynamo which cannot be fully resolved by global simulations. The small-scale Lorentz force suppresses the convective motions and also the turbulent mixing of entropy between upflows and downflows, leading to a large effective Prandtl number ($\Pr$). We explore this idea in three-dimensional global rotating convection simulations at different thermal conductivity ($κ$), i.e., at different $\Pr$. In agreement with previous non-rotating simulations, the convective velocity is reduced with the increase of $\Pr$ as long as the thermal conductive flux is negligible. A subadiabatic layer is formed near the base of the convection zone due to continuous deposition of low entropy plumes in low-$κ$ simulations. The most interesting result of our low-$κ$ simulations is that the convective motions are accompanied by a change in the convection structure that is increasingly influenced by small-scale plumes. These plumes tend to transport angular momentum radially inward and thus establish an anti-solar differential rotation, in striking contrast to the solar rotation profile. If such low diffusive plumes, driven by the radiative-surface cooling, are present in the Sun, then our results cast doubt on the idea that a high effective $\Pr$ may be a viable solution to the solar convective conundrum. Our study also emphasizes that any resolution of the conundrum that relies on the downward plumes must take into account angular momentum transport as well as heat transport. △ Less

Submitted 29 April, 2018; v1 submitted 2 January, 2018; originally announced January 2018.

Comments: The published version may be freely available at https://doi.org/10.1063/1.5022034

Journal ref: Physics Of Fluids 30, 046602 (2018)

Recovery from Maunder-like Grand Minima in a Babcock--Leighton Solar Dynamo Model

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak, Mark Miesch

Abstract: The Sun occasionally goes through Maunder-like extended grand minima when its magnetic activity drops considerably from the normal activity level for several decades. Many possible theories have been proposed to explain the origin of these minima. However, how the Sun managed to recover from such inactive phases every time is even more enigmatic. The Babcock--Leighton type dynamos, which are succe… ▽ More The Sun occasionally goes through Maunder-like extended grand minima when its magnetic activity drops considerably from the normal activity level for several decades. Many possible theories have been proposed to explain the origin of these minima. However, how the Sun managed to recover from such inactive phases every time is even more enigmatic. The Babcock--Leighton type dynamos, which are successful in explaining many features of the solar cycle remarkably well, are not expected to operate during grand minima due to the lack of a sufficient number of sunspots. In this Letter, we explore the question of how the Sun could recover from grand minima through the Babcock--Leighton dynamo. In our three-dimensional dynamo model, grand minima are produced spontaneously as a result of random variations in the tilt angle of emerging active regions. We find that the Babcock-Leighton process can still operate during grand minima with only a minimal number of sunspots and that the model can emerge from such phases without the need for an additional generation mechanism for the poloidal field. The essential ingredient in our model is a downward magnetic pum** which inhibits the diffusion of the magnetic flux across the solar surface. △ Less

Submitted 20 June, 2018; v1 submitted 29 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Comments: Published in ApJ; 6 pages including 4 figures

Journal ref: The Astrophysical Journal Letters, 860, L26, 2018

Latitude Distribution of Sunspots: Analysis Using Sunspot Data and A Dynamo Model

Authors: Sudip Mandal, Bidya Binay Karak, Dipankar Banerjee

Abstract: In this paper, we explore the evolution of sunspot latitude distribution and explore its relations with the cycle strength. With the progress of the solar cycle, the distributions in two hemispheres from mid-latitudes propagate toward the equator and then (before the usual solar minimum) these two distributions touch each other. By visualizing the evolution of the distributions in two hemispheres,… ▽ More In this paper, we explore the evolution of sunspot latitude distribution and explore its relations with the cycle strength. With the progress of the solar cycle, the distributions in two hemispheres from mid-latitudes propagate toward the equator and then (before the usual solar minimum) these two distributions touch each other. By visualizing the evolution of the distributions in two hemispheres, we separate the solar cycles by excluding this hemispheric overlap. From these isolated solar cycles in two hemispheres, we generate latitude distributions for each cycle, starting from cycle 8 to cycle 23. We find that the parameters of these distributions, namely, the central latitude ($C$), width ($δ$) and height ($H$) evolve with the cycle number and they show some hemispheric asymmetries. Although the asymmetries in these parameters persist for a few successive cycles, they get corrected within a few cycles and the new asymmetries appear again. In agreement with the previous study, we find that distribution parameters are correlated with the strengths of the cycles, although these correlations are significantly different in two hemispheres. The general trend that stronger cycles begin sunspot eruptions at relatively higher latitudes and have wider bands of sunspot emergence latitudes are confirmed when combining the data from two hemispheres. We explore these features using a flux transport dynamo model with stochastic fluctuations. We find that these features are correctly reproduced in this model. The solar cycle evolution of the distribution center is also in good agreement with observations. Possible explanations of the observed features based on this dynamo model are presented. △ Less

Submitted 1 November, 2017; originally announced November 2017.

Comments: Accepted for publication in ApJ

Solar Cycle Variability Induced by Tilt Angle Scatter in a Babcock--Leighton Solar Dynamo Model

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak, Mark Miesch

Abstract: We present results from a three-dimensional Babcock--Leighton dynamo model that is sustained by the explicit emergence and dispersal of bipolar magnetic regions (BMRs). On average, each BMR has a systematic tilt given by Joy's law. Randomness and nonlinearity in the BMR emergence of our model produce variable magnetic cycles. However, when we allow for a random scatter in the tilt angle to mimic t… ▽ More We present results from a three-dimensional Babcock--Leighton dynamo model that is sustained by the explicit emergence and dispersal of bipolar magnetic regions (BMRs). On average, each BMR has a systematic tilt given by Joy's law. Randomness and nonlinearity in the BMR emergence of our model produce variable magnetic cycles. However, when we allow for a random scatter in the tilt angle to mimic the observed departures from Joy's law, we find more variability in the magnetic cycles. We find that the observed standard deviation in Joy's law of $σ_δ= 15^\circ$ produces a variability comparable to observed solar cycle variability of $\sim $ 32%, as quantified by the sunspot number maxima between 1755--2008. We also find that tilt angle scatter can promote grand minima and grand maxima. The time spent in grand minima for $σ_δ= 15^\circ$ is somewhat less than that inferred for the Sun from cosmogenic isotopes (about 9% compared to 17%). However, when we double the tilt scatter to $σ_δ= 30^\circ$, the simulation statistics are comparable to the Sun ($\sim $18% of the time in grand minima and $\sim 10$% in grand maxima). Though the Babcock--Leighton mechanism is the only source of poloidal field, we find that our simulations always maintain magnetic cycles even at large fluctuations in the tilt angle. We also demonstrate that tilt quenching is a viable and efficient mechanism for dynamo saturation; a suppression of the tilt by only 1-2$^\circ$ is sufficient to limit the dynamo growth. Thus, any potential observational signatures of tilt quenching in the Sun may be subtle. △ Less

Submitted 13 August, 2017; v1 submitted 27 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Comments: Accepted for publication in ApJ

Journal ref: The Astrophysical Journal, 847, 69 (2017)

Babcock-Leighton solar dynamo: the role of downward pum** and the equatorward propagation of activity

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak, Robert Cameron

Abstract: The key elements of the Babcock-Leighton dynamos are the generation of poloidal field through decay and dispersal of tilted bipolar active regions and the generation of toroidal field through the observed differential rotation. These models are traditionally known as flux transport dynamo models as the equatorward propagations of the butterfly wings in these models are produced due to an equatorwa… ▽ More The key elements of the Babcock-Leighton dynamos are the generation of poloidal field through decay and dispersal of tilted bipolar active regions and the generation of toroidal field through the observed differential rotation. These models are traditionally known as flux transport dynamo models as the equatorward propagations of the butterfly wings in these models are produced due to an equatorward flow at the bottom of the convection zone. Here we investigate the role of downward magnetic pum** near the surface using a kinematic Babcock-Leighton model. We find that the pum** causes the poloidal field to become predominately radial in the near-surface shear layer, which allows the negative radial shear to effectively act on the radial field to produce a toroidal field. We observe a clear equatorward migration of the toroidal field at low latitudes as a consequence of the dynamo wave even when there is no meridional flow in the deep convection zone. Both the dynamo wave and the flux transport type solutions are thus able to reproduce some of the observed features of the solar cycle, including the 11-year periodicity. The main difference between the two types of solutions is the strength of the Babcock-Leighton source required to produce the dynamo action. A second consequence of the magnetic pum** is that it suppresses the diffusion of fields through the surface, which helps to allow an 11-year cycle at (moderately) larger values of magnetic diffusivity than have previously been used. △ Less

Submitted 23 September, 2016; v1 submitted 20 May, 2016; originally announced May 2016.

Comments: Accepted for publication in ApJ; minor revision and a new figure added in this version!

Journal ref: The Astrophysical Journal, Volume 832, Number 1, 2016

Multiple dynamo modes as a mechanism for long-term solar activity variations

Authors: Maarit J. Käpylä, Petri J. Käpylä, Nigul Olspert, Axel Brandenburg, Jörn Warnecke, Bidya B. Karak, Jaan Pelt

Abstract: Solar magnetic activity shows both smooth secular changes, such as the Grand Modern Maximum, and quite abrupt drops that are denoted as Grand Minima. Direct numerical simulations (DNS) of convection driven dynamos offer one way of examining the mechanisms behind these events. In this work, we analyze a solution of a solar-like DNS that has been evolved for roughly 80 magnetic cycles of 4.9 years,… ▽ More Solar magnetic activity shows both smooth secular changes, such as the Grand Modern Maximum, and quite abrupt drops that are denoted as Grand Minima. Direct numerical simulations (DNS) of convection driven dynamos offer one way of examining the mechanisms behind these events. In this work, we analyze a solution of a solar-like DNS that has been evolved for roughly 80 magnetic cycles of 4.9 years, during which epochs of irregular behavior are detected. The emphasis of our analysis is to find physical causes for such behavior. The DNS employed is a semi-global (wedge) magnetoconvection model. For data analysis we use Ensemble Empirical Mode Decomposition (EEMD) and phase dispersion ($D^2$) methods. A special property of the DNS is the existence of multiple dynamo modes at different depths and latitudes. The dominant mode is solar-like. This mode is accompanied by a higher frequency mode near the surface and a low-frequency mode in the bottom of the convection zone. The overall behavior of the dynamo solution is very complex exhibiting variable cycle lengths, epochs of disturbed and even ceased surface activity, and strong short-term hemispherical asymmetries. Surprisingly, the most prominent suppressed surface activity epoch is actually a global magnetic energy maximum. We interpret the overall irregular behavior to be due to the interplay of the different dynamo modes showing different equatorial symmetries, especially the smoother part of the irregular variations being related to the variations of the mode strengths, evolving with different and variable cycle lengths. The abrupt low activity epoch in the dominant dynamo mode near the surface is related to a strong maximum of the bottom toroidal field strength, which causes abrupt disturbances especially in the differential rotation profile via the suppression of the Reynolds stresses. △ Less

Submitted 22 January, 2016; v1 submitted 20 July, 2015; originally announced July 2015.

Comments: 24 pages, 16 figures, Astronomy and Astrophysics, accepted for publication

Report number: NORDITA-2015-90

Journal ref: A&A 589, A56 (2016)

Is the small-scale magnetic field correlated with the dynamo cycle?

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak, Axel Brandenburg

Abstract: The small-scale magnetic field is ubiquitous at the solar surface---even at high latitudes. From observations we know that this field is uncorrelated (or perhaps even weakly anticorrelated) with the global sunspot cycle. Our aim is to explore the origin, and particularly the cycle dependence of such a phenomenon using three-dimensional dynamo simulations. We adopt a simple model of a turbulent dyn… ▽ More The small-scale magnetic field is ubiquitous at the solar surface---even at high latitudes. From observations we know that this field is uncorrelated (or perhaps even weakly anticorrelated) with the global sunspot cycle. Our aim is to explore the origin, and particularly the cycle dependence of such a phenomenon using three-dimensional dynamo simulations. We adopt a simple model of a turbulent dynamo in a shearing box driven by helically forced turbulence. Depending on the dynamo parameters, large-scale (global) and small-scale (local) dynamos can be excited independently in this model. Based on simulations in different parameter regimes, we find that, when only the large-scale dynamo is operating in the system, the small-scale magnetic field generated through shredding and tangling of the large-scale magnetic field is positively correlated with the global magnetic cycle. However, when both dynamos are operating, the small-scale field is produced from both the small-scale dynamo and the tangling of the large-scale field. In this situation, when the large-scale field is weaker than the equipartition value of the turbulence, the small-scale field is almost uncorrelated with the large-scale magnetic cycle. On the other hand, when the large-scale field is stronger than the equipartition value, we observe an anticorrelation between the small-scale field and the large-scale magnetic cycle. This anticorrelation can be interpreted as a suppression of the small-scale dynamo. Based on our studies we conclude that the observed small-scale magnetic field in the Sun is generated by the combined mechanisms of small-scale dynamo and tangling of the large-scale field. △ Less

Submitted 16 October, 2015; v1 submitted 25 May, 2015; originally announced May 2015.

Comments: Accepted for publication in ApJ; minor revision and a new figure added in this version

Report number: NORDITA-2015-60

Journal ref: The Astrophysical Journal, Volume 816, Issue 1, article id. 28, 9 pp. (2016)

Hysteresis between distinct modes of turbulent dynamos

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak, Leonid L. Kitchatinov, Axel Brandenburg

Abstract: Nonlinear mean-field models of the solar dynamo show long-term variability, which may be relevant to different states of activity inferred from long-term radiocarbon data. This paper is aimed to probe the dynamo hysteresis predicted by the recent mean-field models of Kitchatinov \& Olemskoy (2010) with direct numerical simulations. We perform three-dimensional simulations of large-scale dynamos in… ▽ More Nonlinear mean-field models of the solar dynamo show long-term variability, which may be relevant to different states of activity inferred from long-term radiocarbon data. This paper is aimed to probe the dynamo hysteresis predicted by the recent mean-field models of Kitchatinov \& Olemskoy (2010) with direct numerical simulations. We perform three-dimensional simulations of large-scale dynamos in a shearing box with helically forced turbulence. As initial condition, we either take a weak random magnetic field or we start from a snapshot of an earlier simulation. Two quasi-stable states are found to coexist in a certain range of parameters close to the onset of the large-scale dynamo. The simulations converge to one of these states depending on the initial conditions. When either the fractional helicity or the magnetic Prandtl number is increased between successive runs above the critical value for onset of the dynamo, the field strength jumps to a finite value. However, when the fractional helicity or the magnetic Prandtl number is then decreased again, the field strength stays at a similar value (strong field branch) even below the original onset. We also observe intermittent decaying phases away from the strong field branch close to the point where large-scale dynamo action is just possible. The dynamo hysteresis seen previously in mean-field models is thus reproduced by 3D simulations. Its possible relation to distinct modes of solar activity such as grand minima is discussed. △ Less

Submitted 23 April, 2015; v1 submitted 3 November, 2014; originally announced November 2014.

Comments: Published in ApJ

Report number: NORDITA-2014-126

Journal ref: ApJ, 803, 95 (2015)

Correlation between Decay Rate and Amplitude of Solar Cycles as Revealed from Observations and Dynamo Theory

Authors: Gopal Hazra, Bidya Binay Karak, Dipankar Banerjee, Arnab Rai Choudhuri

Abstract: Using different proxies of solar activity, we have studied the following features of solar cycle. (i) A linear correlation between the amplitude of cycle and its decay rate, (ii) a linear correlation between the amplitude of cycle $n$ and the decay rate of cycle $(n - 1)$ and (iii) an anti-correlation between the amplitude of cycle $n$ and the period of cycle $(n - 1)$. Features (ii) and (iii) are… ▽ More Using different proxies of solar activity, we have studied the following features of solar cycle. (i) A linear correlation between the amplitude of cycle and its decay rate, (ii) a linear correlation between the amplitude of cycle $n$ and the decay rate of cycle $(n - 1)$ and (iii) an anti-correlation between the amplitude of cycle $n$ and the period of cycle $(n - 1)$. Features (ii) and (iii) are very useful because they provide precursors for future cycles. We have reproduced these features using a flux transport dynamo model with stochastic fluctuations in the Babcock-Leighton $α$ effect and in the meridional circulation. Only when we introduce fluctuations in meridional circulation, we are able to reproduce different observed features of solar cycle. We discuss the possible reasons for these correlations. △ Less

Submitted 7 May, 2015; v1 submitted 31 October, 2014; originally announced October 2014.

Comments: 22 pages, 10 figures and 2 tables, accepted in Solar Physics

Report number: NORDITA-2014-122

Polar Network Index as a magnetic proxy for the solar cycle studies

Authors: Muthu Priyal, Dipankar Banerjee, Bidya Binay Karak, Andres Munoz-Jaramillo, B. Ravindra, Arnab Rai Choudhuri, Jagdev Singh

Abstract: The Sun has a polar magnetic field which oscillates with the 11 year sunspot cycle. This polar magnetic field is an important component of the dynamo process which is operating in the solar convection zone and produces the sunspot cycle. We have systematic direct measurements of the Sun's polar magnetic field only from about mid 1970s. There are, however, indirect proxies which give us information… ▽ More The Sun has a polar magnetic field which oscillates with the 11 year sunspot cycle. This polar magnetic field is an important component of the dynamo process which is operating in the solar convection zone and produces the sunspot cycle. We have systematic direct measurements of the Sun's polar magnetic field only from about mid 1970s. There are, however, indirect proxies which give us information about this field at earlier times. The Ca K spectroheliograms taken in Kodaikanal Solar Observatory during 1904 - 2007 have now been digitized with the 4k x 4k CCD and have higher resolution (0.86 arcsec) than the other available historical datasets. From these Ca-K spectroheliograms, we have developed a completely new proxy (Polar Network Index, PNI) for the Sun's polar magnetic field. We calculate the PNI from the digitized images using an automated algorithm and calibrate our measured PNI against the polar field as measured by the Wilcox Solar Observatory for the period of 1976 - 1990. This calibration allows us to estimate polar fields for the earlier period up to 1904. The dynamo calculations done with this proxy as input data reproduce the Sun's magnetic behavior for the past century reasonably well. △ Less

Submitted 18 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Comments: 19 pages, 5 figures Accepted for publication in APJL

Report number: NORDITA-2014-88

Magnetically controlled stellar differential rotation near the transition from solar to anti-solar profiles

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak, Petri J. Kapyla, Maarit J. Kapyla, Axel Brandenburg, N. Olspert, J. Pelt

Abstract: Late-type stars rotate differentially owing to anisotropic turbulence in their outer convection zones. The rotation is called solar-like (SL) when the equator rotates fastest and anti-solar (AS) otherwise. Hydrodynamic simulations show a transition from SL to AS rotation as the influence of rotation on convection is reduced, but the opposite transition occurs at a different point in the parameter… ▽ More Late-type stars rotate differentially owing to anisotropic turbulence in their outer convection zones. The rotation is called solar-like (SL) when the equator rotates fastest and anti-solar (AS) otherwise. Hydrodynamic simulations show a transition from SL to AS rotation as the influence of rotation on convection is reduced, but the opposite transition occurs at a different point in the parameter space. The system is bistable, i.e., SL and AS rotation profiles can both be stable. We study the effect of a dynamo-generated magnetic field on the large-scale flows, particularly on the possibility of bistable behavior of differential rotation. We solve the hydromagnetic equations numerically in a rotating spherical shell for a set of different radiative conductivities controlling the relative importance of convection. In agreement with earlier findings, our models display SL rotation profiles when the rotational influence on convection is strong and a transition to AS when the rotational influence decreases. We find that dynamo-generated magnetic fields help to produce SL differential rotation compared to the hydrodynamic simulations. We do not observe any bistable states of differential rotation. In the AS cases we get coherent single-cell meridional circulation, whereas in SL cases we get multi-cellular patterns. In both cases, we obtain poleward circulation near the surface with a magnitude close to that observed in the Sun. Moreover, both differential rotation and meridional circulation have significant magnetic cycle-related variations that are similar in strength to those of the Sun. Purely hydrodynamic simulations of differential rotation and meridional circulation are shown to be of limited relevance as magnetic fields, self-consistently generated by dynamo action, significantly affect the flows. △ Less

Submitted 21 January, 2015; v1 submitted 3 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Comments: Accepted for publication in A&A

Report number: NORDITA-2014-84

Journal ref: A&A 576, A26 (2015)

Quenching and anisotropy of hydromagnetic turbulent transport

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak, Matthias Rheinhardt, Axel Brandenburg, Petri J. Kapyla, Maarit J. Kapyla

Abstract: Hydromagnetic turbulence affects the evolution of large-scale magnetic fields through mean-field effects like turbulent diffusion and the $α$ effect. For stronger fields, these effects are usually suppressed or quenched, and additional anisotropies are introduced. Using different variants of the test-field method, we determine the quenching of the turbulent transport coefficients for the forced Ro… ▽ More Hydromagnetic turbulence affects the evolution of large-scale magnetic fields through mean-field effects like turbulent diffusion and the $α$ effect. For stronger fields, these effects are usually suppressed or quenched, and additional anisotropies are introduced. Using different variants of the test-field method, we determine the quenching of the turbulent transport coefficients for the forced Roberts flow, isotropically forced non-helical turbulence, and rotating thermal convection. We see significant quenching only when the mean magnetic field is larger than the equipartition value of the turbulence. Expressing the magnetic field in terms of the equipartition value of the {\it quenched} flows, we obtain for the quenching exponents of the turbulent magnetic diffusivity about 1.3, 1.1, and 1.3 for Roberts flow, forced turbulence, and convection, respectively. However, when the magnetic field is expressed in terms of the equipartition value of the unquenched flows these quenching exponents become about 4, 1.5, and 2.3, respectively. For the $α$ effect, the exponent is about 1.3 for the Roberts flow and 2 for convection in the first case, but 4 and 3, respectively, in the second. In convection, the quenching of turbulent pum** follows the same power law as turbulent diffusion, while for the coefficient describing the $\bf Ω\times \bf J$ effect nearly the same quenching exponent is obtained as for $α$. For forced turbulence, turbulent diffusion proportional to the second derivative along the mean magnetic field is quenched much less, especially for larger values of the magnetic Reynolds number. However, we find that in corresponding axisymmetric mean-field dynamos with dominant toroidal field the quenched diffusion coefficients are the same for the poloidal and toroidal field constituents. △ Less

Submitted 20 August, 2014; v1 submitted 17 June, 2014; originally announced June 2014.

Comments: Accepted for publication in ApJ

Report number: NORDITA-2014-72

Journal ref: ApJ, 795, 16 (2014)

A dynamo model of magnetic activity in solar-like stars with different rotational velocities

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak, Leonid L. Kitchatinov, Arnab Rai Choudhuri

Abstract: We attempt to provide a quantitative theoretical explanation for the observations that Ca II H/K emission and X-ray emission from solar-like stars increase with decreasing Rossby number (i.e., with faster rotation). Assuming that these emissions are caused by magnetic cycles similar to the sunspot cycle, we construct flux transport dynamo models of $1M_{\odot}$ stars rotating with different rotati… ▽ More We attempt to provide a quantitative theoretical explanation for the observations that Ca II H/K emission and X-ray emission from solar-like stars increase with decreasing Rossby number (i.e., with faster rotation). Assuming that these emissions are caused by magnetic cycles similar to the sunspot cycle, we construct flux transport dynamo models of $1M_{\odot}$ stars rotating with different rotation periods. We first compute the differential rotation and the meridional circulation inside these stars from a mean-field hydrodynamics model. Then these are substituted in our dynamo code to produce periodic solutions. We find that the dimensionless amplitude $f_m$ of the toroidal flux through the star increases with decreasing rotation period. The observational data can be matched if we assume the emissions to go as the power 3-4 of $f_m$. Assuming that the Babcock-Leighton mechanism saturates with increasing rotation, we can provide an explanation for the observed saturation of emission at low Rossby numbers. The main failure of our model is that it predicts an increase of magnetic cycle period with increasing rotation rate, which is the opposite of what is found observationally. Much of our calculations are based on the assumption that the magnetic buoyancy makes the magnetic flux tubes to rise radially from the bottom of the convection zone. On taking account of the fact that the Coriolis force diverts the magnetic flux tubes to rise parallel to the rotation axis in rapidly rotating stars, the results do not change qualitatively. △ Less

Submitted 11 July, 2014; v1 submitted 8 February, 2014; originally announced February 2014.

Comments: Accepted for publication in ApJ

Report number: NORDITA 2014-15

Journal ref: ApJ, 791, 59 (2014)

Forecasting the solar activity cycle: new insights

Authors: Dibyendu Nandy, Bidya Binay Karak

Abstract: Having advanced knowledge of solar activity is important because the Sun's magnetic output governs space weather and impacts technologies reliant on space. However, the irregular nature of the solar cycle makes solar activity predictions a challenging task. This is best achieved through appropriately constrained solar dynamo simulations and as such the first step towards predictions is to understa… ▽ More Having advanced knowledge of solar activity is important because the Sun's magnetic output governs space weather and impacts technologies reliant on space. However, the irregular nature of the solar cycle makes solar activity predictions a challenging task. This is best achieved through appropriately constrained solar dynamo simulations and as such the first step towards predictions is to understand the underlying physics of the solar dynamo mechanism. In Babcock-Leighton type dynamo models, the poloidal field is generated near the solar surface whereas the toroidal field is generated in the solar interior. Therefore a finite time is necessary for the coupling of the spatially segregated source layers of the dynamo. This time delay introduces a memory in the dynamo mechanism which allows forecasting of future solar activity. Here we discuss how this forecasting ability of the solar cycle is affected by downward turbulent pum** of magnetic flux. With significant turbulent pum** the memory of the dynamo is severely degraded and thus long term prediction of the solar cycle is not possible; only a short term prediction of the next cycle peak may be possible based on observational data assimilation at the previous cycle minimum. △ Less

Submitted 29 December, 2013; originally announced December 2013.

Comments: Proc. of IAU Symposium 294

Journal ref: Solar and Astrophysical Dynamos and Magnetic Activity, Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union, IAU Symposium, Volume 294, pp. 439-444 (2013)

Is a deep one-cell meridional circulation essential for the flux transport Solar Dynamo?

Authors: Gopal Hazra, Bidya Binay Karak, Arnab Rai Choudhuri

Abstract: The solar activity cycle is successfully modeled by the flux transport dynamo, in which the meridional circulation of the Sun plays an important role. Most of the kinematic dynamo simulations assume a one-cell structure of the meridional circulation within the convection zone, with the equatorward return flow at its bottom. In view of the recent claims that the return flow occurs at a much shallow… ▽ More The solar activity cycle is successfully modeled by the flux transport dynamo, in which the meridional circulation of the Sun plays an important role. Most of the kinematic dynamo simulations assume a one-cell structure of the meridional circulation within the convection zone, with the equatorward return flow at its bottom. In view of the recent claims that the return flow occurs at a much shallower depth, we explore whether a meridional circulation with such a shallow return flow can still retain the attractive features of the flux transport dynamo (such as a proper butterfly diagram, the proper phase relation between the toroidal and poloidal fields). We consider additional cells of the meridional circulation below the shallow return flow---both the case of multiple cells radially stacked above one another and the case of more complicated cell patterns. As long as there is an equatorward flow in low latitudes at the bottom of the convection zone, we find that the solar behavior is approximately reproduced. However, if there is either no flow or a poleward flow at the bottom of the convection zone, then we cannot reproduce solar behavior. On making the turbulent diffusivity low, we still find periodic behavior, although the period of the cycle becomes unrealistically large. Also, with a low diffusivity, we do not get the observed correlation between the polar field at the sunspot minimum and the strength of the next cycle, which is reproduced when diffusivity is high. On introducing radially downward pum**, we get a more reasonable period and more solar-like behavior even with low diffusivity. △ Less

Submitted 4 February, 2014; v1 submitted 11 September, 2013; originally announced September 2013.

Comments: 12 pages, 13 figures

Journal ref: ApJ, 782, 93 (2014)

Studies of grand minima in sunspot cycles from a flux transport solar dynamo model

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak, Arnab Rai Choudhuri

Abstract: We propose that grand minima in solar activity are caused by simultaneous fluctuations in the meridional circulation and the Babcock-Leighton mechanism for the poloidal field generation in the flux transport dynamo model. We present the following results: (a) fluctuations in the meridional circulation are more effective in producing grand minima; (b) both sudden and gradual initiations of grand mi… ▽ More We propose that grand minima in solar activity are caused by simultaneous fluctuations in the meridional circulation and the Babcock-Leighton mechanism for the poloidal field generation in the flux transport dynamo model. We present the following results: (a) fluctuations in the meridional circulation are more effective in producing grand minima; (b) both sudden and gradual initiations of grand minima are possible; (c) distributions of durations and waiting times between grand minima seem to be exponential; (d) the coherence time of the meridional circulation has an effect on the number and the average duration of grand minima, a coherence time of about 30 years being consistent with observational data. We also study the occurrence of grand maxima and find that the distributions of durations and waiting times between grand maxima are also exponential, like the grand minima. Finally we address the question whether the Babcock-Leighton mechanism can be operative during grand minima when there are no sunspots. We show that an alpha-effect restricted to the upper portions of the convection zone can pull the dynamo out of the grand minima and can match various observational requirements if the amplitude of this alpha-effect is suitably fine-tuned. △ Less

Submitted 28 June, 2013; v1 submitted 23 June, 2013; originally announced June 2013.

Comments: To appear in Research in Astronomy and Astrophysics

Journal ref: Research in Astronomy and Astrophysics 13 (2013) 1339-1357

Dynamo in Protostar

Authors: Mahendra K. Verma, Bidya Binay Karak, Rohit Kumar

Abstract: In this paper, we estimate the magnetic Reynolds number of a typical protostar before and after deuterium burning, and claim for the existence of dynamo process in both the phases, because the magnetic Reynolds number of the protostar far exceeds the critical magnetic Reynolds number for dynamo action. Using the equipartition of kinetic and magnetic energies, we estimate the steady-state magnetic… ▽ More In this paper, we estimate the magnetic Reynolds number of a typical protostar before and after deuterium burning, and claim for the existence of dynamo process in both the phases, because the magnetic Reynolds number of the protostar far exceeds the critical magnetic Reynolds number for dynamo action. Using the equipartition of kinetic and magnetic energies, we estimate the steady-state magnetic field of the protostar to be of the order of kilo-gauss, which is in good agreement with observations. △ Less

Submitted 25 April, 2013; originally announced April 2013.

Comments: 5 pages

Modelling grand minima of solar activity using a flux transport dynamo model

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak, Arnab Rai Choudhuri

Abstract: The occurrence of grand minima like the Maunder minimum is an intriguing aspect of the sunspot cycle. We use the flux transport dynamo model to explain the grand minima, showing that they arise when either the poloidal field or the meridional circulation falls to a sufficiently low value due to fluctuations. Assuming these fluctuations to be Gaussian and determining the various parameters from the… ▽ More The occurrence of grand minima like the Maunder minimum is an intriguing aspect of the sunspot cycle. We use the flux transport dynamo model to explain the grand minima, showing that they arise when either the poloidal field or the meridional circulation falls to a sufficiently low value due to fluctuations. Assuming these fluctuations to be Gaussian and determining the various parameters from the data of the last 28 cycles, we carry on a dynamo simulation with both these fluctuations. The results are remarkably close to the observational data. △ Less

Submitted 22 July, 2013; v1 submitted 1 November, 2012; originally announced November 2012.

Comments: IAU Symposium 294: Solar and Astrophysical Dynamos and Magnetic Activity. Editors: A.G. Kosovichev, E.M. de Gouveia Dal Pino, & Y.Yan

Journal ref: Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union Volume 8 Symposium S294, 2013, pp 433-438

Flux Transport Dynamo coupled with a Fast Tachocline Scenario

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak, Kristof Petrovay

Abstract: The tachocline is important in the solar dynamo for the generation and the storage of the magnetic fields. A most plausible explanation for the confinement of the tachocline is given by the fast tachocline model in which the tachocline is confined by the anisotropic momentum transfer by the Maxwell stress of the dynamo generated magnetic fields. We employ a flux transport dynamo model coupled with… ▽ More The tachocline is important in the solar dynamo for the generation and the storage of the magnetic fields. A most plausible explanation for the confinement of the tachocline is given by the fast tachocline model in which the tachocline is confined by the anisotropic momentum transfer by the Maxwell stress of the dynamo generated magnetic fields. We employ a flux transport dynamo model coupled with the simple feedback formula of this fast tachocline model which basically relates the thickness of the tachocline to the Maxwell stress. We find that this nonlinear coupling not only produces a stable solar-like dynamo solution but also a significant latitudinal variation in the tachocline thickness which is in agreement with the observations. △ Less

Submitted 30 September, 2013; v1 submitted 1 November, 2012; originally announced November 2012.

Comments: Proceedings of IAU 294: Solar and Astrophysical Dynamos and Magnetic Activity

Journal ref: Solar and Astrophysical Dynamos and Magnetic Activity, Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union, IAU Symposium, Volume 294, pp. 427-428 (2013)

On the compatibility of a flux transport dynamo with a fast tachocline scenario

Authors: Bidya Binay Karak, Kristof Petrovay

Abstract: The compatibility of the fast tachocline scenario with a flux transport dynamo model is explored. We employ a flux transport dynamo model coupled with simple feedback formulae relating the thickness of the tachocline to the amplitude of the magnetic field or to the Maxwell stress. The dynamo model is found to be robust against the nonlinearity introduced by this simplified fast tachocline mechanis… ▽ More The compatibility of the fast tachocline scenario with a flux transport dynamo model is explored. We employ a flux transport dynamo model coupled with simple feedback formulae relating the thickness of the tachocline to the amplitude of the magnetic field or to the Maxwell stress. The dynamo model is found to be robust against the nonlinearity introduced by this simplified fast tachocline mechanism. Solar-like butterfly diagrams are found to persist and, even without any parameter fitting, the overall thickness of the tachocline is well within the range admitted by helioseismic constraints. In the most realistic case of a time and latitude dependent tachocline thickness linked to the value of the Maxwell stress, both the thickness and its latitude dependence are in excellent agreement with seismic results. In the nonparametric models, cycle related temporal variations in tachocline thickness are somewhat larger than admitted by helioseismic constraints; we find, however, that introducing a further parameter into our feedback formula readily allows further fine tuning of the thickness variations. △ Less

Submitted 3 September, 2012; originally announced September 2012.

Comments: Accepted in Solar Physics

Journal ref: Solar Physics, 282, 321-334 (2013)

The origin of grand minima in the sunspot cycle

Authors: Arnab Rai Choudhuri, Bidya Binay Karak

Abstract: One of the most striking aspects of the 11-year sunspot cycle is that there have been times in the past when some cycles went missing, a most well-known example of this being the Maunder minimum during 1645-1715. Analyses of cosmogenic isotopes (C14 and Be10) indicated that there were about 27 grand minima in the last 11,000 yr, implying that about 2.7% of the solar cycles had conditions appropria… ▽ More One of the most striking aspects of the 11-year sunspot cycle is that there have been times in the past when some cycles went missing, a most well-known example of this being the Maunder minimum during 1645-1715. Analyses of cosmogenic isotopes (C14 and Be10) indicated that there were about 27 grand minima in the last 11,000 yr, implying that about 2.7% of the solar cycles had conditions appropriate for forcing the Sun into grand minima. We address the question how grand minima are produced and specifically calculate the frequency of occurrence of grand minima from a theoretical dynamo model. We assume that fluctuations in the poloidal field generation mechanism and the meridional circulation produce irregularities of sunspot cycles. Taking these fluctuations to be Gaussian and estimating the values of important parameters from the data of last 28 solar cycles, we show from our flux transport dynamo model that about 1-4% of the sunspot cycles may have conditions suitable for inducing grand minima. △ Less

Submitted 25 September, 2012; v1 submitted 20 August, 2012; originally announced August 2012.

Comments: Accepted for publication in Physical Review Letters

Journal ref: Physical Review Letters, 109, 171103 (2012)