-
Comments On "Multipath Matching Pursuit" by Kwon, Wang and Shim
Authors:
Nazim Burak Karahanoglu,
Hakan Erdogan
Abstract:
Straightforward combination of tree search with matching pursuits, which was suggested in 2001 by Cotter and Rao, and then later developed by some other authors, has been revisited recently as multipath matching pursuit (MMP). In this comment, we would like to point out some major issues regarding this publication. First, the idea behind MMP is not novel, and the related literature has not been pr…
▽ More
Straightforward combination of tree search with matching pursuits, which was suggested in 2001 by Cotter and Rao, and then later developed by some other authors, has been revisited recently as multipath matching pursuit (MMP). In this comment, we would like to point out some major issues regarding this publication. First, the idea behind MMP is not novel, and the related literature has not been properly referenced. MMP has not been compared to closely related algorithms such as A* orthogonal matching pursuit (A*OMP). The theoretical analyses do ignore the pruning strategies applied by the authors in practice. All these issues have the potential to mislead the reader and lead to misinterpretation of the results. With this short paper, we intend to clarify the relation of MMP to existing literature in the area and compare its performance with A*OMP.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Improving A*OMP: Theoretical and Empirical Analyses With a Novel Dynamic Cost Model
Authors:
Nazim Burak Karahanoglu,
Hakan Erdogan
Abstract:
Best-first search has been recently utilized for compressed sensing (CS) by the A* orthogonal matching pursuit (A*OMP) algorithm. In this work, we concentrate on theoretical and empirical analyses of A*OMP. We present a restricted isometry property (RIP) based general condition for exact recovery of sparse signals via A*OMP. In addition, we develop online guarantees which promise improved recovery…
▽ More
Best-first search has been recently utilized for compressed sensing (CS) by the A* orthogonal matching pursuit (A*OMP) algorithm. In this work, we concentrate on theoretical and empirical analyses of A*OMP. We present a restricted isometry property (RIP) based general condition for exact recovery of sparse signals via A*OMP. In addition, we develop online guarantees which promise improved recovery performance with the residue-based termination instead of the sparsity-based one. We demonstrate the recovery capabilities of A*OMP with extensive recovery simulations using the adaptive-multiplicative (AMul) cost model, which effectively compensates for the path length differences in the search tree. The presented results, involving phase transitions for different nonzero element distributions as well as recovery rates and average error, reveal not only the superior recovery accuracy of A*OMP, but also the improvements with the residue-based termination and the AMul cost model. Comparison of the run times indicate the speed up by the AMul cost model. We also demonstrate a hybrid of OMP and A?OMP to accelerate the search further. Finally, we run A*OMP on a sparse image to illustrate its recovery performance for more realistic coefcient distributions.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2015; v1 submitted 6 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Online Recovery Guarantees and Analytical Results for OMP
Authors:
Nazim Burak Karahanoglu,
Hakan Erdogan
Abstract:
Orthogonal Matching Pursuit (OMP) is a simple, yet empirically competitive algorithm for sparse recovery. Recent developments have shown that OMP guarantees exact recovery of K-sparse signals with K or more than K iterations if the observation matrix satisfies the restricted isometry property (RIP) with some conditions. We develop RIP-based online guarantees for recovery of a K-sparse signal with…
▽ More
Orthogonal Matching Pursuit (OMP) is a simple, yet empirically competitive algorithm for sparse recovery. Recent developments have shown that OMP guarantees exact recovery of K-sparse signals with K or more than K iterations if the observation matrix satisfies the restricted isometry property (RIP) with some conditions. We develop RIP-based online guarantees for recovery of a K-sparse signal with more than K OMP iterations. Though these guarantees cannot be generalized to all sparse signals a priori, we show that they can still hold online when the state-of-the-art K-step recovery guarantees fail. In addition, we present bounds on the number of correct and false indices in the support estimate for the derived condition to be less restrictive than the K-step guarantees. Under these bounds, this condition guarantees exact recovery of a K-sparse signal within 3K/2 iterations, which is much less than the number of steps required for the state-of-the-art exact recovery guarantees with more than K steps. Moreover, we present phase transitions of OMP in comparison to basis pursuit and subspace pursuit, which are obtained after extensive recovery simulations involving different sparse signal types. Finally, we empirically analyse the number of false indices in the support estimate, which indicates that these do not violate the developed upper bound in practice.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2013; v1 submitted 22 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Compressed Sensing Signal Recovery via Forward-Backward Pursuit
Authors:
Nazim Burak Karahanoglu,
Hakan Erdogan
Abstract:
Recovery of sparse signals from compressed measurements constitutes an l0 norm minimization problem, which is unpractical to solve. A number of sparse recovery approaches have appeared in the literature, including l1 minimization techniques, greedy pursuit algorithms, Bayesian methods and nonconvex optimization techniques among others. This manuscript introduces a novel two stage greedy approach,…
▽ More
Recovery of sparse signals from compressed measurements constitutes an l0 norm minimization problem, which is unpractical to solve. A number of sparse recovery approaches have appeared in the literature, including l1 minimization techniques, greedy pursuit algorithms, Bayesian methods and nonconvex optimization techniques among others. This manuscript introduces a novel two stage greedy approach, called the Forward-Backward Pursuit (FBP). FBP is an iterative approach where each iteration consists of consecutive forward and backward stages. The forward step first expands the support estimate by the forward step size, while the following backward step shrinks it by the backward step size. The forward step size is larger than the backward step size, hence the initially empty support estimate is expanded at the end of each iteration. Forward and backward steps are iterated until the residual power of the observation vector falls below a threshold. This structure of FBP does not necessitate the sparsity level to be known a priori in contrast to the Subspace Pursuit or Compressive Sampling Matching Pursuit algorithms. FBP recovery performance is demonstrated via simulations including recovery of random sparse signals with different nonzero coefficient distributions in noisy and noise-free scenarios in addition to the recovery of a sparse image.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2013; v1 submitted 20 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
A* Orthogonal Matching Pursuit: Best-First Search for Compressed Sensing Signal Recovery
Authors:
Nazim Burak Karahanoglu,
Hakan Erdogan
Abstract:
Compressed sensing is a develo** field aiming at reconstruction of sparse signals acquired in reduced dimensions, which make the recovery process under-determined. The required solution is the one with minimum $\ell_0$ norm due to sparsity, however it is not practical to solve the $\ell_0$ minimization problem. Commonly used techniques include $\ell_1$ minimization, such as Basis Pursuit (BP) an…
▽ More
Compressed sensing is a develo** field aiming at reconstruction of sparse signals acquired in reduced dimensions, which make the recovery process under-determined. The required solution is the one with minimum $\ell_0$ norm due to sparsity, however it is not practical to solve the $\ell_0$ minimization problem. Commonly used techniques include $\ell_1$ minimization, such as Basis Pursuit (BP) and greedy pursuit algorithms such as Orthogonal Matching Pursuit (OMP) and Subspace Pursuit (SP). This manuscript proposes a novel semi-greedy recovery approach, namely A* Orthogonal Matching Pursuit (A*OMP). A*OMP performs A* search to look for the sparsest solution on a tree whose paths grow similar to the Orthogonal Matching Pursuit (OMP) algorithm. Paths on the tree are evaluated according to a cost function, which should compensate for different path lengths. For this purpose, three different auxiliary structures are defined, including novel dynamic ones. A*OMP also incorporates pruning techniques which enable practical applications of the algorithm. Moreover, the adjustable search parameters provide means for a complexity-accuracy trade-off. We demonstrate the reconstruction ability of the proposed scheme on both synthetically generated data and images using Gaussian and Bernoulli observation matrices, where A*OMP yields less reconstruction error and higher exact recovery frequency than BP, OMP and SP. Results also indicate that novel dynamic cost functions provide improved results as compared to a conventional choice.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2012; v1 submitted 2 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.