Showing 1–50 of 62 results for author: Kar, G

Quantum Nonlocality: Multi-copy Resource Inter-convertibility & Their Asymptotic Inequivalence

Authors: Subhendu B. Ghosh, Snehasish Roy Chowdhury, Guruprasad Kar, Arup Roy, Tamal Guha, Manik Banik

Abstract: Quantum nonlocality, pioneered in Bell's seminal work and subsequently verified through a series of experiments, has drawn substantial attention due to its practical applications in various protocols. Evaluating and comparing the extent of nonlocality within distinct quantum correlations holds significant practical relevance. Within the resource theoretic framework this can be achieved by assessin… ▽ More Quantum nonlocality, pioneered in Bell's seminal work and subsequently verified through a series of experiments, has drawn substantial attention due to its practical applications in various protocols. Evaluating and comparing the extent of nonlocality within distinct quantum correlations holds significant practical relevance. Within the resource theoretic framework this can be achieved by assessing the inter-conversion rate among different nonlocal correlations under free local operations and shared randomness. In this study we, however, present instances of quantum nonlocal correlations that are incomparable in the strongest sense. Specifically, when starting with an arbitrary many copies of one nonlocal correlation, it becomes impossible to obtain even a single copy of the other correlation, and this incomparability holds in both directions. Remarkably, these incomparable quantum correlations can be obtained even in the simplest Bell scenario, which involves two parties, each having two dichotomic measurements setups. Notably, there exist an uncountable number of such incomparable correlations. Our result challenges the notion of a 'unique gold coin', often referred to as the 'maximally resourceful state', within the framework of the resource theory of quantum nonlocality, which has nontrivial implications in the study of nonlocality distillation. △ Less

Submitted 15 May, 2024; v1 submitted 25 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: New results have been added. Accepted in Physical Review Letters

Field-Free Spin-Orbit Torque driven Switching of Perpendicular Magnetic Tunnel Junction through Bending Current

Authors: Vaishnavi Kateel, Viola Krizakova, Siddharth Rao, Kaiming Cai, Mohit Gupta, Maxwel Gama Monteiro, Farrukh Yasin, Bart Sorée, Johan De Boeck, Sebastien Couet, Pietro Gambardella, Gouri Sankar Kar, Kevin Garello

Abstract: Current-induced spin-orbit torques (SOTs) enable fast and efficient manipulation of the magnetic state of magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs), making it attractive for memory, in-memory computing, and logic applications. However, the requirement of the external magnetic field to achieve deterministic switching in perpendicular magnetized SOT-MTJs limits its implementation for practical applications.… ▽ More Current-induced spin-orbit torques (SOTs) enable fast and efficient manipulation of the magnetic state of magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs), making it attractive for memory, in-memory computing, and logic applications. However, the requirement of the external magnetic field to achieve deterministic switching in perpendicular magnetized SOT-MTJs limits its implementation for practical applications. Here, we introduce a field-free switching (FFS) solution for the SOT-MTJ device by sha** the SOT channel to create a "bend" in the SOT current. The resulting bend in the charge current creates a spatially non-uniform spin current, which translates into inhomogeneous SOT on an adjacent magnetic free layer enabling deterministic switching. We demonstrate FFS experimentally on scaled SOT-MTJs at nanosecond time scales. This proposed scheme is scalable, material-agnostic, and readily compatible with wafer-scale manufacturing, thus creating a pathway for develo** purely current-driven SOT systems. △ Less

Submitted 6 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Monolithic TCAD Simulation of Phase-Change Memory (PCM/PRAM) + Ovonic Threshold Switch (OTS) Selector Device

Authors: M. Thesberg, Z. Stanojevic, O. Baumgartner, C. Kernstock, D. Leonelli, M. Barci, X. Wang, X. Zhou, H. Jiao, G. L. Donadio, D. Garbin, T. Witters, S. Kundu, H. Hody, R. Delhougne, G. Kar, M. Karner

Abstract: Owing to the increasing interest in the commercialization of phase-change memory (PCM) devices, a number of TCAD models have been developed for their simulation. These models formulate the melting, amorphization and crystallization of phase-change materials as well as their extreme conductivity dependence on both electric field and temperature into a set of self-consistently-solved thermoelectric… ▽ More Owing to the increasing interest in the commercialization of phase-change memory (PCM) devices, a number of TCAD models have been developed for their simulation. These models formulate the melting, amorphization and crystallization of phase-change materials as well as their extreme conductivity dependence on both electric field and temperature into a set of self-consistently-solved thermoelectric and phase-field partial-differential equations. However, demonstrations of the ability of such models to match actual experimental results are rare. In addition, such PCM devices also require a so-called selector device - such as an Ovonic Threshold Switching (OTS) device - in series for proper memory operation. However, monolithic simulation of both the PCM and OTS selector device in a single simulation is largely absent from the literature, despite its potential value for material- and design-space explorations. It is the goal of this work to first characterize a PCM device in isolation against experimental data, then to demonstrate the qualitative behavior of a simulated OTS device in isolation and finally to perform a single monolithic simulation of the PCM + OTS device within the confines of a commercially available TCAD solver: GTS Framework. △ Less

Submitted 11 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Journal ref: Solid-State Electronics, Volume 199, January 2023, 108504

Perspectives and Challenges of Scaled Boolean Spintronic Circuits Based on Magnetic Tunnel Junction Transducers

Authors: F. Meng, S. -Y. Lee, O. Zografos, M. Gupta, V. D. Nguyen, G. De Micheli, S. Cotofana, I. Asselberghs, C. Adelmann, G. Sankar Kar, S. Couet, F. Ciubotaru

Abstract: This paper addresses the question: Can spintronic circuits based on Magnetic Tunnel Junction (MTJ) transducers outperform their state-of-the-art CMOS counterparts? To this end, we use the EPFL combinational benchmark sets, synthesize them in 7 nm CMOS and in MTJ-based spintronic technologies, and compare the two implementation methods in terms of Energy-Delay-Product (EDP). To fully utilize the te… ▽ More This paper addresses the question: Can spintronic circuits based on Magnetic Tunnel Junction (MTJ) transducers outperform their state-of-the-art CMOS counterparts? To this end, we use the EPFL combinational benchmark sets, synthesize them in 7 nm CMOS and in MTJ-based spintronic technologies, and compare the two implementation methods in terms of Energy-Delay-Product (EDP). To fully utilize the technologies potential, CMOS and spintronic implementations are built upon standard Boolean and Majority Gates, respectively. For the spintronic circuits, we assumed that domain conversion (electric/magnetic to magnetic/electric) is performed by means of MTJs and the computation is accomplished by domain wall based majority gates, and considered two EDP estimation scenarios: (i) Uniform Benchmarking, which ignores the circuit's internal structure and only includes domain transducers power and delay contributions into the calculations, and (ii) Majority-Inverter-Graph Benchmarking, which also embeds the circuit structure, the associated critical path delay and energy consumption by DW propagation. Our results indicate that for the uniform case, the spintronic route is better suited for the implementation of complex circuits with few inputs and outputs. On the other hand, when the circuit structure is also considered via majority and inverter synthesis, our analysis clearly indicates that in order to match and eventually outperform CMOS performance, MTJ efficiency has to be improved by 3-4 orders of magnitude. While it is clear that for the time being the MTJ-based-spintronic way cannot compete with CMOS, further transducer developments may tip the balance, which, when combined with information non-volatility, may make spintronic implementation for certain applications that require a large number of calculations and have a rather limited amount of interaction with the environment. △ Less

Submitted 29 June, 2023; v1 submitted 5 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: This work was supported by imec Industrial Affiliation Program on Exploratory Logic Devices. It has also received funding from the European Union Horizon Europe research and innovation programme within the project SPIDER under grant agreement No 101070417

Tailoring the switching efficiency of magnetic tunnel junctions by the fieldlike spin-orbit torque

Authors: Viola Krizakova, Marco Hoffmann, Vaishnavi Kateel, Siddharth Rao, Sebastien Couet, Gouri Sankar Kar, Kevin Garello, Pietro Gambardella

Abstract: Current-induced spin-orbit torques provide a versatile tool for switching magnetic devices. In perpendicular magnets, the dam**like component of the torque is the main driver of magnetization reversal. The degree to which the fieldlike torque assists the switching is a matter of debate. Here we study the switching of magnetic tunnel junctions with a CoFeB free layer and either W or Ta underlayer… ▽ More Current-induced spin-orbit torques provide a versatile tool for switching magnetic devices. In perpendicular magnets, the dam**like component of the torque is the main driver of magnetization reversal. The degree to which the fieldlike torque assists the switching is a matter of debate. Here we study the switching of magnetic tunnel junctions with a CoFeB free layer and either W or Ta underlayers, which have a ratio of fieldlike to dam**like torque of 0.3 and 1, respectively. We show that the fieldlike torque can either assist or hinder the switching of CoFeB when the static in-plane magnetic field required to define the polarity of spin-orbit torque switching has a component transverse to the current. In particular, the non-collinear alignment of the field and current can be exploited to increase the switching efficiency and reliability compared to the standard collinear alignment. By probing individual switching events in real-time, we also show that the combination of transverse magnetic field and fieldlike torque can accelerate or decelerate the reversal onset. We validate our observations using micromagnetic simulations and extrapolate the results to materials with different torque ratios. Finally, we propose device geometries that leverage the fieldlike torque for density increase in memory applications and synaptic weight generation. △ Less

Submitted 28 October, 2022; v1 submitted 29 June, 2022; originally announced June 2022.

From no causal loop to absoluteness of cause: discarding the quantum NOT logic

Authors: Anandamay Das Bhowmik, Preeti Parashar, Guruprasad Kar, Manik Banik

Abstract: The principle of `absoluteness of cause' (AC) assumes the cause-effect relation to be observer independent and is a distinct assertion than prohibiting occurrence of any causal loop. Here, we study implication of this novel principle to derive a fundamental no-go result in quantum world. AC principle restrains the `time order' of two spacelike separated events/processes to be a potential cause of… ▽ More The principle of `absoluteness of cause' (AC) assumes the cause-effect relation to be observer independent and is a distinct assertion than prohibiting occurrence of any causal loop. Here, we study implication of this novel principle to derive a fundamental no-go result in quantum world. AC principle restrains the `time order' of two spacelike separated events/processes to be a potential cause of another event in their common future, and in turn negates existence of a quantum device that transforms an arbitrary pure state to its orthogonal one. The present {\it no-go} result is quite general as its domain of applicability stretches out from the standard linear quantum theory to any of its generalizations allowing deterministic or stochastic nonlinear evolution. We also analyze different possibilities of violating the AC principle in generalized probability theory framework. A strong form of violation enables instantaneous signaling, whereas a weak form of violation forbids the theory to be locally tomographic. On the other hand, impossibility of an intermediate violation suffices to discard the universal quantum NOT logic. △ Less

Submitted 27 September, 2021; v1 submitted 21 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Comments: More clarity added in presentation; comments are welcome

Interplay of voltage control of magnetic anisotropy, spin transfer torque, and heat in the spin-orbit torque switching in three-terminal magnetic tunnel junctions

Authors: Viola Krizakova, Eva Grimaldi, Kevin Garello, Giacomo Sala, Sebastien Couet, Gouri Sankar Kar, Pietro Gambardella

Abstract: We use three-terminal magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs) designed for field-free switching by spin-orbit torques (SOTs) to systematically study the impact of dual voltage pulses on the switching performances. We show that the concurrent action of an SOT pulse and an MTJ bias pulse allows for reducing the critical switching energy below the level typical of spin transfer torque while preserving the a… ▽ More We use three-terminal magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs) designed for field-free switching by spin-orbit torques (SOTs) to systematically study the impact of dual voltage pulses on the switching performances. We show that the concurrent action of an SOT pulse and an MTJ bias pulse allows for reducing the critical switching energy below the level typical of spin transfer torque while preserving the ability to switch the MTJ on the sub-ns time scale. By performing dc and real-time electrical measurements, we discriminate and quantify three effects arising from the MTJ bias: the voltage-controlled change of the perpendicular magnetic anisotropy, current-induced heating, and the spin transfer torque. The experimental results are supported by micromagnetic modeling. We observe that, depending on the pulse duration and the MTJ diameter, different effects take a lead in assisting the SOTs in the magnetization reversal process. Finally, we present a compact model that allows for evaluating the impact of each effect due to the MTJ bias on the critical switching parameters. Our results provide input to optimize the switching of three-terminal devices as a function of time, size, and material parameters. △ Less

Submitted 2 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Journal ref: Physical Review Applied 15, 054055 (2021)

Spin-torque induced wall motion in perpendicularly magnetized discs: ballistic versus oscillatory behavior

Authors: Paul Bouquin, Joo-Von Kim, Olivier Bultynck, Siddharth Rao, Sebastien Couet, Gouri Sankar Kar, Thibaut Devolder

Abstract: We use time-resolved measurement and modeling to study the spin-torque induced motion of a domain wall in perpendicular anisotropy magnets. In disc of diameters between 70 and 100 nm, the wall drifts across the disc with pronounced back-and-forth oscillations that arise because the wall moves in the Walker regime. Several switching paths occur stochastically and lead to distinct switching duration… ▽ More We use time-resolved measurement and modeling to study the spin-torque induced motion of a domain wall in perpendicular anisotropy magnets. In disc of diameters between 70 and 100 nm, the wall drifts across the disc with pronounced back-and-forth oscillations that arise because the wall moves in the Walker regime. Several switching paths occur stochastically and lead to distinct switching durations. The wall can cross the disc center either in a ballistic manner or with variably marked oscillations before and after the crossing. The crossing of the center can even occur multiple times if a vertical Bloch line nucleates within the wall. The wall motion is analyzed using a collective coordinate model parametrized by the wall position $q$ and the tilt $φ$ of its in-plane magnetization projection. The dynamics results from the stretch field, which describes the affinity of the wall to reduce its length and the wall stiffness field describing the wall tendency to reduce dipolar energy by rotating its tilt. The wall oscillations result from the continuous exchange of energy between to the two degrees of freedom $q$ and $φ$. The stochasticity of the wall dynamics can be understood from the concept of the retention pond: a region in the $q-φ$ space in which walls are transiently bound to the disc center. Walls having trajectories close to the pond must circumvent it and therefore have longer propagation times. The retention pond disappears for a disc diameter of typically 40 nm: the wall then moves in a ballistic manner irrespective of the dynamics of its tilt. The propagation time is then robust against fluctuations hence reproducible. △ Less

Submitted 22 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: submitted to Phys. Rev. B

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 103, 224431 (2021)

Voltage-Gate Assisted Spin-Orbit Torque Magnetic Random Access Memory for High-Density and Low-Power Embedded Application

Authors: Y. C. Wu, K. Garello, W. Kim, M. Gupta, M. Perumkunnil, V. Kateel, S. Couet, R. Carpenter, S. Rao, S. Van Beek, K. K. Vudya Sethu, F. Yasin, D. Crotti, G. S. Kar

Abstract: Voltage-gate assisted spin-orbit torque (VGSOT) writing scheme combines the advantages from voltage control of magnetic anisotropy (VCMA) and spin-orbit torque (SOT) effects, enabling multiple benefits for magnetic random access memory (MRAM) applications. In this work, we give a complete description of VGSOT writing properties on perpendicular magnetic tunnel junction (pMTJ) devices, and we propo… ▽ More Voltage-gate assisted spin-orbit torque (VGSOT) writing scheme combines the advantages from voltage control of magnetic anisotropy (VCMA) and spin-orbit torque (SOT) effects, enabling multiple benefits for magnetic random access memory (MRAM) applications. In this work, we give a complete description of VGSOT writing properties on perpendicular magnetic tunnel junction (pMTJ) devices, and we propose a detailed methodology for its electrical characterization. The impact of gate assistance on the SOT switching characteristics are investigated using electrical pulses down to 400ps. The VCMA coefficient (ξ) extracted from current switching scheme is found to be the same as that from the magnetic field switch method, which is in the order of 15fJ/Vm for the 80nm to 150nm devices. Moreover, as expected from the pure electronic VCMA effect, ξ is revealed to be independent of the writing speed and gate length. We observe that SOT switching current characteristics are modified linearly with gate voltage (V_g), similar as for the magnetic properties. We interpret this linear behavior as the direct modification of perpendicular magnetic anisotropy (PMA) and nucleation energy induced by VCMA. At V_g = 1V, the SOT write current is decreased by 25%, corresponding to a 45% reduction in total energy down to 30fJ/bit at 400ps speed for the 80nm devices used in this study. Further, the device-scaling criteria are proposed, and we reveal that VGSOT scheme is of great interest as it can mitigate the complex material requirements of achieving high SOT and VCMA parameters for scaled MTJs. Finally, how that VGSOT-MRAM can enable high-density arrays close to two terminal geometries, with high-speed performance and low-power operation, showing great potential for embedded memories as well as in-memory computing applications at advanced technology nodes. △ Less

Submitted 19 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Applied 15, 064015 (2021)

Impact of Magnetic Coupling and Density on STT-MRAM Performance

Authors: Lizhou Wu, Siddharth Rao, Mottaqiallah Taouil, Erik Jan Marinissen, Gouri Sankar Kar, Said Hamdioui

Abstract: As a unique mechanism for MRAMs, magnetic coupling needs to be accounted for when designing memory arrays. This paper models both intra- and inter-cell magnetic coupling analytically for STT-MRAMs and investigates their impact on the write performance and retention of MTJ devices, which are the data-storing elements of STT-MRAMs. We present magnetic measurement data of MTJ devices with diameters r… ▽ More As a unique mechanism for MRAMs, magnetic coupling needs to be accounted for when designing memory arrays. This paper models both intra- and inter-cell magnetic coupling analytically for STT-MRAMs and investigates their impact on the write performance and retention of MTJ devices, which are the data-storing elements of STT-MRAMs. We present magnetic measurement data of MTJ devices with diameters ranging from 35nm to 175nm, which we use to calibrate our intra-cell magnetic coupling model. Subsequently, we extrapolate this model to study inter-cell magnetic coupling in memory arrays. We propose the inter-cell magnetic coupling factor Psi to indicate coupling strength. Our simulation results show that Psi=2% maximizes the array density under the constraint that the magnetic coupling has negligible impact on the device's performance. Higher array densities show significant variations in average switching time, especially at low switching voltages, caused by inter-cell magnetic coupling, and dependent on the data pattern in the cell's neighborhood. We also observe a marginal degradation of the data retention time under the influence of inter-cell magnetic coupling. △ Less

Submitted 23 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

ACM Class: B.m

Multi-copy adaptive local discrimination: Strongest possible two-qubit nonlocal bases

Authors: Manik Banik, Tamal Guha, Mir Alimuddin, Guruprasad Kar, Saronath Halder, Some Sankar Bhattacharya

Abstract: Ensembles of composite quantum states can exhibit nonlocal behaviour in the sense that their optimal discrimination may require global operations. Such an ensemble containing N pairwise orthogonal pure states, however, can always be perfectly distinguished under adaptive local scheme if (N-1) copies of the state are available. In this letter, we provide examples of orthonormal bases in two-qubit H… ▽ More Ensembles of composite quantum states can exhibit nonlocal behaviour in the sense that their optimal discrimination may require global operations. Such an ensemble containing N pairwise orthogonal pure states, however, can always be perfectly distinguished under adaptive local scheme if (N-1) copies of the state are available. In this letter, we provide examples of orthonormal bases in two-qubit Hilbert space whose adaptive discrimination require 3 copies of the state. For this composite system we analyze multi-copy adaptive local distinguishability of orthogonal ensembles in full generality which in turn assigns varying nonlocal strength to different such ensembles. We also come up with ensembles whose discrimination under adaptive separable scheme require less number of copies than adaptive local schemes. Our construction finds important application in multipartite secret sharing tasks and indicates towards an intriguing super-additivity phenomenon for locally accessible information. △ Less

Submitted 5 May, 2021; v1 submitted 18 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: Accepted in Physical Review Letters

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 210505 (2021)

Single-shot dynamics of spin-orbit torque and spin transfer torque switching in three-terminal magnetic tunnel junctions

Authors: Eva Grimaldi, Viola Krizakova, Giacomo Sala, Farrukh Yasin, Sébastien Couet, Gouri Sankar Kar, Kevin Garello, Pietro Gambardella

Abstract: Current-induced spin-transfer torques (STT) and spin-orbit torques (SOT) enable the electrical switching of magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs) in nonvolatile magnetic random access memories. In order to develop faster memory devices, an improvement of the timescales underlying the current driven magnetization dynamics is required. Here we report all-electrical time-resolved measurements of magnetiza… ▽ More Current-induced spin-transfer torques (STT) and spin-orbit torques (SOT) enable the electrical switching of magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs) in nonvolatile magnetic random access memories. In order to develop faster memory devices, an improvement of the timescales underlying the current driven magnetization dynamics is required. Here we report all-electrical time-resolved measurements of magnetization reversal driven by SOT in a three-terminal MTJ device. Single-shot measurements of the MTJ resistance during current injection reveal that SOT switching involves a stochastic two-step process consisting of a domain nucleation time and propagation time, which have different genesis, timescales, and statistical distributions compared to STT switching. We further show that the combination of SOT, STT, and voltage control of magnetic anisotropy (VCMA) leads to reproducible sub-ns switching with a spread of the cumulative switching time smaller than 0.2 ns. Our measurements unravel the combined impact of SOT, STT, and VCMA in determining the switching speed and efficiency of MTJ devices. △ Less

Submitted 17 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Journal ref: Nature Nanotechnology 15, 111-117 (2020)

Stochastic processes in magnetization reversal involving domain wall motion in magnetic memory elements

Authors: Paul Bouquin, Joo-Von Kim, Olivier Bultynck, Siddharth Rao, Sebastien Couet, Gouri Sankar Kar, Thibaut Devolder

Abstract: We show experimentally through time-resolved conductance measurements that magnetization reversal through domain wall motion in sub-100 nm diameter magnetic tunnel junctions is dominated by two distinct stochastic effects. The first involves the incubation time related to domain wall nucleation, while the second results from stochastic motion in the Walker regime. Micromagnetics simulations reveal… ▽ More We show experimentally through time-resolved conductance measurements that magnetization reversal through domain wall motion in sub-100 nm diameter magnetic tunnel junctions is dominated by two distinct stochastic effects. The first involves the incubation time related to domain wall nucleation, while the second results from stochastic motion in the Walker regime. Micromagnetics simulations reveal several contributions to temporal pinning of the wall near the disk center, including Bloch point nucleation and wall precession. We show that a reproducible ballistic motion is recovered when Bloch and Néel wall profiles become degenerate in energy in optimally sized disks, which enables quasi-deterministic motion. △ Less

Submitted 16 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Applied 15, 024037 (2021)

Field-free switching of magnetic tunnel junctions driven by spin-orbit torques at sub-ns timescales

Authors: Viola Krizakova, Kevin Garello, Eva Grimaldi, Gouri Sankar Kar, Pietro Gambardella

Abstract: We report time-resolved measurements of magnetization switching by spin-orbit torques in the absence of an external magnetic field in perpendicularly magnetized magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJ). Field-free switching is enabled by the dipolar field of an in-plane magnetized layer integrated above the MTJ stack, the orientation of which determines the switching polarity. Real-time single-shot measure… ▽ More We report time-resolved measurements of magnetization switching by spin-orbit torques in the absence of an external magnetic field in perpendicularly magnetized magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJ). Field-free switching is enabled by the dipolar field of an in-plane magnetized layer integrated above the MTJ stack, the orientation of which determines the switching polarity. Real-time single-shot measurements provide direct evidence of magnetization reversal and switching distributions. Close to the critical switching voltage we observe stochastic reversal events due to a finite incubation delay preceding the magnetization reversal. Upon increasing the pulse amplitude to twice the critical voltage the reversal becomes quasi-deterministic, leading to reliable bipolar switching at sub-ns timescales in zero external field. We further investigate the switching probability as a function of dc bias of the MTJ and external magnetic field, providing insight on the parameters that determine the critical switching voltage. △ Less

Submitted 11 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Journal ref: Appl. Phys. Lett. 116, 232406 (2020)

Back-hop** in Spin-Transfer-Torque switching of perpendicularly magnetized tunnel junctions

Authors: T. Devolder, O. Bultynck, P. Bouquin, V. D. Nguyen, S. Rao, D. Wan, B. Sorée, I. P. Radu, G. S. Kar, S. Couet

Abstract: We analyse the phenomenon of back-hop** in spin-torque induced switching of the magnetization in perpendicularly magnetized tunnel junctions. The analysis is based on single-shot time-resolved conductance measurements of the pulse-induced back-hop**. Studying several material variants reveals that the back-hop** is a feature of the nominally fixed system of the tunnel junction. The back-hopp… ▽ More We analyse the phenomenon of back-hop** in spin-torque induced switching of the magnetization in perpendicularly magnetized tunnel junctions. The analysis is based on single-shot time-resolved conductance measurements of the pulse-induced back-hop**. Studying several material variants reveals that the back-hop** is a feature of the nominally fixed system of the tunnel junction. The back-hop** is found to proceed by two sequential switching events that lead to a final state P' of conductance close to --but distinct from-- that of the conventional parallel state. The P' state does not exist at remanence. It generally relaxes to the conventional antiparallel state if the current is removed. The P' state involves a switching of the sole spin-polarizing part of the fixed layers. The analysis of literature indicates that back-hop** occurs only when the spin-polarizing layer is too weakly coupled to the rest of the fixed system, which justifies a posteriori the mitigation strategies of back-hop** that were implemented empirically in spin-transfer-torque magnetic random access memories. △ Less

Submitted 9 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: submitted to Phys Rev. B

Effect of Tantalum spacer thickness and deposition conditions on the properties of MgO/CoFeB/Ta/CoFeB/MgO free layers

Authors: T. Devolder, S. Couet, J. Swerts, S. Mertens, S. Rao, G. S. Kar

Abstract: To get stable perpendicularly magnetized tunnel junctions at small device dimensions, composite free layers that comprise two MgO/FeCoB interfaces as sources of interface anisotropy are generally used. Proper cristallisation and annealing robustness is typically ensured by the insertion of a spacer layer of the early transition metal series within the FeCoB layer. We study the influence of the spa… ▽ More To get stable perpendicularly magnetized tunnel junctions at small device dimensions, composite free layers that comprise two MgO/FeCoB interfaces as sources of interface anisotropy are generally used. Proper cristallisation and annealing robustness is typically ensured by the insertion of a spacer layer of the early transition metal series within the FeCoB layer. We study the influence of the spacer thickness and growth condition on the switching metrics of tunnel junctions thermally annealed at 400$^\circ$C for the case of 1-4 Å Ta spacers. Thick Ta spacer results in a large anisotropies indicative of a better defined top FeCoB/MgO interface, but this is achieved at the systematic expense of a stronger dam**. For the best anisotropy-dam** compromise, junctions of diameter 22 nm can still be stable and spin-torque switched. Coercivity and inhomogeneous linewidth broadening, likely arising from roughness at the FeCoB/Ta interface, can be reduced if a sacrificial Mg layer is inserted before the Ta spacer deposition. △ Less

Submitted 6 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: To appear in IEEE magnetics letters

Manufacturable 300mm platform solution for Field-Free Switching SOT-MRAM

Authors: K. Garello, F. Yasin, H. Hody, S. Couet, L. Souriau, S. H. Sharifi, J. Swerts, R. Carpenter, S. Rao, W. Kim, J. Wu, K. K. V. Sethu, M. Pak, N. Jossart, D. Crotti, A. Furnémont, G. S. Kar

Abstract: We propose a field-free switching SOT-MRAM concept that is integration friendly and allows for separate optimization of the field component and SOT/MTJ stack properties. We demonstrate it on a 300 mm wafer, using CMOS-compatible processes, and we show that device performances are similar to our standard SOT-MTJ cells: reliable sub-ns switching with low writing power across the 300mm wafer. Our con… ▽ More We propose a field-free switching SOT-MRAM concept that is integration friendly and allows for separate optimization of the field component and SOT/MTJ stack properties. We demonstrate it on a 300 mm wafer, using CMOS-compatible processes, and we show that device performances are similar to our standard SOT-MTJ cells: reliable sub-ns switching with low writing power across the 300mm wafer. Our concept/design opens a new area for MRAM (SOT, STT and VCMA) technology development. △ Less

Submitted 30 August, 2019; v1 submitted 18 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: Presented at VLSI 2019 Circuit and Technology Symposium, JFS4p5

Journal ref: 2019 Symposium on VLSI Technology

Offset fields in perpendicularly magnetized tunnel junctions

Authors: T. Devolder, R. Carpenter, S. Rao, W. Kim, S. Couet, J. Swerts, G. S. Kar

Abstract: We study the offset fields affecting the free layer of perpendicularly magnetized tunnel junctions. In extended films, the free layer offset field results from interlayer exchange coupling with the reference layer through the MgO tunnel oxide. The free layer offset field is thus accompanied with a shift of the free layer and reference layer ferromagnetic resonance frequencies. The shifts depend on… ▽ More We study the offset fields affecting the free layer of perpendicularly magnetized tunnel junctions. In extended films, the free layer offset field results from interlayer exchange coupling with the reference layer through the MgO tunnel oxide. The free layer offset field is thus accompanied with a shift of the free layer and reference layer ferromagnetic resonance frequencies. The shifts depend on the mutual orientation of the two magnetizations. The offset field decreases with the resistance area product of the tunnel oxide. Patterning the tunnel junction into an STT-MRAM disk-shaped cell changes substantially the offset field, as the reduction of the lateral dimension comes with the generation of stray fields by the reference and the hard layer. The experimental offset field compares best with the spatial average of the sum of these stray fields, thereby providing guidelines for the offset field engineering. △ Less

Submitted 23 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Comments: Special issue of J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys (2019) on STT-MRAM

Indefinite causal order enables perfect quantum communication with zero capacity channels

Authors: Giulio Chiribella, Manik Banik, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Tamal Guha, Mir Alimuddin, Arup Roy, Sutapa Saha, Sristy Agrawal, Guruprasad Kar

Abstract: Quantum mechanics is compatible with scenarios where the relative order between two events can be indefinite. Here we show that two independent instances of a noisy process can behave as a perfect quantum communication channel when used in a coherent superposition of two alternative orders. This phenomenon occurs even if the original process has zero capacity to transmit quantum information. In co… ▽ More Quantum mechanics is compatible with scenarios where the relative order between two events can be indefinite. Here we show that two independent instances of a noisy process can behave as a perfect quantum communication channel when used in a coherent superposition of two alternative orders. This phenomenon occurs even if the original process has zero capacity to transmit quantum information. In contrast, perfect quantum communication does not occur when the message is sent directly from the sender to the receiver through a superposition of alternative paths, with an independent noise process acting on each path. The possibility of perfect quantum communication through independent noisy channels highlights a fundamental difference between the superposition of orders in time and the superposition of paths in space. △ Less

Submitted 5 September, 2022; v1 submitted 24 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 10+12 pages, Significantly expanded version with new results and a new figure. Accepted in New Journal of Physics

Journal ref: New Journal of Physics 23, 033039 (2021)

SOT-MRAM 300mm integration for low power and ultrafast embedded memories

Authors: K. Garello, F. Yasin, S. Couet, L. Souriau, J. Swerts, S. Rao, S. Van Beek, W. Kim, E. Liu, S. Kundu, D. Tsvetanova, N. Jossart, K. Croes, E. Grimaldi, M. Baumgartner, D. Crotti, A. Furnémont, P. Gambardella, G. S. Kar

Abstract: We demonstrate for the first time full-scale integration of top-pinned perpendicular MTJ on 300 mm wafer using CMOS-compatible processes for spin-orbit torque (SOT)-MRAM architectures. We show that 62 nm devices with a W-based SOT underlayer have very large endurance (> 5x10^10), sub-ns switching time of 210 ps, and operate with power as low as 300 pJ. We demonstrate for the first time full-scale integration of top-pinned perpendicular MTJ on 300 mm wafer using CMOS-compatible processes for spin-orbit torque (SOT)-MRAM architectures. We show that 62 nm devices with a W-based SOT underlayer have very large endurance (> 5x10^10), sub-ns switching time of 210 ps, and operate with power as low as 300 pJ. △ Less

Submitted 22 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: presented at VLSI2018 session C8-2

Journal ref: 2018 IEEE Symposium on VLSI Circuits

Size dependence of spin-torque switching in perpendicular magnetic tunnel junctions

Authors: Paul Bouquin, Siddharth Rao, Gouri Sankar Kar, Thibaut Devolder

Abstract: We simulate the spin torque-induced reversal of the magnetization in thin disks with perpendicular anisotropy at zero temperature. Disks typically smaller than 20 nm in diameter exhibit coherent reversal. A domain wall is involved in larger disks. We derive the critical diameter of this transition. Using a proper definition of the critical voltage, a macrospin model can account perfectly for the r… ▽ More We simulate the spin torque-induced reversal of the magnetization in thin disks with perpendicular anisotropy at zero temperature. Disks typically smaller than 20 nm in diameter exhibit coherent reversal. A domain wall is involved in larger disks. We derive the critical diameter of this transition. Using a proper definition of the critical voltage, a macrospin model can account perfectly for the reversal dynamics when the reversal is coherent. The same critical voltage appears to match with the micromagnetics switching voltage regardless of the switching path. △ Less

Submitted 15 November, 2018; v1 submitted 10 September, 2018; originally announced September 2018.

Journal ref: Appl. Phys. Lett. 113, 222408 (2018)

Gilbert dam** of high anisotropy Co/Pt multilayers

Authors: Thibaut Devolder, S. Couet, J. Swerts, G. S. Kar

Abstract: Using broadband ferromagnetic resonance, we measure the dam** parameter of [Co(5 Å)/Pt(3 Å)]${\times 6}$ multilayers whose growth was optimized to maximize the perpendicular anisotropy. Structural characterizations indicate abrupt interfaces essentially free of intermixing despite the miscible character of Co and Pt. Gilbert dam** parameters as low as 0.021 can be obtained despite a magneto-cr… ▽ More Using broadband ferromagnetic resonance, we measure the dam** parameter of [Co(5 Å)/Pt(3 Å)]${\times 6}$ multilayers whose growth was optimized to maximize the perpendicular anisotropy. Structural characterizations indicate abrupt interfaces essentially free of intermixing despite the miscible character of Co and Pt. Gilbert dam** parameters as low as 0.021 can be obtained despite a magneto-crystalline anisotropy as large as $10^6~\textrm{J/m}^3$. The inhomogeneous broadening accounts for part of the ferromagnetic resonance linewidth, indicating some structural disorder leading to a equivalent 20 mT of inhomogenity of the effective field. The unexpectedly relatively low dam** factor indicates that the presence of the Pt heavy metal within the multilayer may not be detrimental to the dam** provided that intermixing is avoided at the Co/Pt interfaces. △ Less

Submitted 13 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Journal ref: J. Phys. D:Appl. Phys. 51 135002 (2018)

Quantum nonlocality does not demand all-out randomness in measurement choice

Authors: Manik Banik, Samir Kunkri, Avijit Misra, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Arup Roy, Amit Mukherjee, Sibasish Ghosh, Guruprasad Kar

Abstract: Nonlocality is the most characteristic feature of quantum mechanics. John Bell, in his seminal 1964 work, proved that local-realism imposes a bound on the correlations among the measurement statistics of distant observers. Surpassing this bound rules out local-realistic description of microscopic phenomena, establishing the presence of nonlocal correlation. To manifest nonlocality, it requires, in… ▽ More Nonlocality is the most characteristic feature of quantum mechanics. John Bell, in his seminal 1964 work, proved that local-realism imposes a bound on the correlations among the measurement statistics of distant observers. Surpassing this bound rules out local-realistic description of microscopic phenomena, establishing the presence of nonlocal correlation. To manifest nonlocality, it requires, in the simplest scenario, two measurements performed randomly by each of two distant observers. In this work, we propose a novel framework where three measurements, two on Alice's side and one on Bob's side, suffice to reveal quantum nonlocality and hence does not require all-out randomness in measurement choice. Our method relies on a very naive operational task in quantum information theory, namely, the minimal error state discrimination. As a practical implication this method constitutes an economical entanglement detection scheme, which uses a less number of entangled states compared to all such existing schemes. Moreover, the method applies to class of generalized probability theories containing quantum theory as a special example. △ Less

Submitted 17 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: 6+2 pages; Two figures; Comments welcome

Annealing stability of magnetic tunnel junctions based on dual MgO free layers and [Co/Ni] based thin synthetic antiferromagnet fixed system

Authors: T. Devolder, S. Couet, J. Swerts, E. Liu, T. Lin, S. Mertens, G. Kar, A. Furnemont

Abstract: We study the annealing stability of bottom-pinned perpendicularly magnetized magnetic tunnel junctions based on dual MgO free layers and thin fixed systems comprising a hard [Co/Ni] multilayer antiferromagnetically coupled to thin a Co reference layer and a FeCoB polarizing layer. Using conventional magnetometry and advanced broadband ferromagnetic resonance, we identify the properties of each sub… ▽ More We study the annealing stability of bottom-pinned perpendicularly magnetized magnetic tunnel junctions based on dual MgO free layers and thin fixed systems comprising a hard [Co/Ni] multilayer antiferromagnetically coupled to thin a Co reference layer and a FeCoB polarizing layer. Using conventional magnetometry and advanced broadband ferromagnetic resonance, we identify the properties of each sub-unit of the magnetic tunnel junction and demonstrate that this material option can ensure a satisfactory resilience to the 400$^\circ$C thermal annealing needed in solid-state magnetic memory applications. The dual MgO free layer possesses an anneal-robust 0.4 T effective anisotropy and suffers only a minor increase of its Gilbert dam** from 0.007 to 0.010 for the toughest annealing conditions. Within the fixed system, the ferro-coupler and texture-breaking TaFeCoB layer keeps an interlayer exchange above 0.8 mJ/m$^2$, while the Ru antiferrocoupler layer within the synthetic antiferromagnet maintains a coupling above -0.5 mJ/m$^2$. These two strong couplings maintain the overall functionality of the tunnel junction upon the toughest annealing despite the gradual degradation of the thin Co layer anisotropy that may reduce the operation margin in spin torque memory applications. Based on these findings, we propose further optimization routes for the next generation magnetic tunnel junctions. △ Less

Submitted 21 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.

Journal ref: Journal of Applied Physics 121, 113904 (2017)

Material developments and domain wall based nanosecond-scale switching process in perpendicularly magnetized STT-MRAM cells

Authors: Thibaut Devolder, Joo-Von Kim, J. Swerts, S. Couet, S. Rao, W. Kim, S. Mertens, G. Kar, V. Nikitin

Abstract: We investigate the Gilbert dam** and the magnetization switching of perpendicularly magnetized FeCoB-based free layers embedded in tunnel junctions adequate for spin-torque operated memories. We study the influence of the boron content in MgO / FeCoB /Ta systems alloys on their Gilbert dam** after crystallization annealing. Increasing the boron content from 20 to 30\% increases the crystalliza… ▽ More We investigate the Gilbert dam** and the magnetization switching of perpendicularly magnetized FeCoB-based free layers embedded in tunnel junctions adequate for spin-torque operated memories. We study the influence of the boron content in MgO / FeCoB /Ta systems alloys on their Gilbert dam** after crystallization annealing. Increasing the boron content from 20 to 30\% increases the crystallization temperature, thereby postponing the onset of elemental diffusion within the free layer. This reduction of the interdiffusion of the Ta atoms helps maintaining the Gilbert dam** at a low level of 0.009 without any penalty on the anisotropy and the magneto-transport properties up to the 400$^\circ$C annealing required in CMOS back-end of line processing. In addition, we show that dual MgO free layers of composition MgO/FeCoB/Ta/FeCoB/MgO have a substantially lower dam** than their MgO/FeCoB/Ta counterparts, reaching dam** parameters as low as 0.0039 for a 3 Å thick Tantalum spacer. This confirms that the dominant channel of dam** is the presence of Ta impurities within the FeCoB alloy. On optimized tunnel junctions, we then study the duration of the switching events induced by spin-transfer-torque. We focus on the sub-threshold thermally activated switching in optimal applied field conditions. From the electrical signatures of the switching, we infer that once the nucleation has occurred, the reversal proceeds by a domain wall swee** though the device at a few 10 m/s. The smaller the device, the faster its switching. We present an analytical model to account for our findings. The domain wall velocity is predicted to scale linearly with the current for devices much larger than the wall width. The wall velocity depends on the Bloch domain wall width, such that the devices with the lowest exchange stiffness will be the ones that host the domain walls with the slowest mobilities. △ Less

Submitted 4 September, 2017; v1 submitted 9 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.

Comments: Submitted to the proceedings of TMRC 2017

Seed Layer Impact on Structural and Magnetic Properties of [Co/Ni] Multilayers with Perpendicular Magnetic Anisotropy

Authors: Enlong Liu, J. Swerts, T. Devolder, S. Couet, S. Mertens, T. Lin, V. Spampinato, A. Franquet, T. Conard, S. Van Elshocht, A. Furnemont, J. De Boeck, G. Kar

Abstract: [Co/Ni] multilayers with perpendicular magnetic anisotropy (PMA) have been researched and applied in various spintronic applications. Typically the seed layer material is studied to provide the desired face-centered cubic (\textit{fcc}) texture to the [Co/Ni] to obtain PMA. The integration of [Co/Ni] in back-end-of-line (BEOL) processes also requires the PMA to survive post-annealing. In this pape… ▽ More [Co/Ni] multilayers with perpendicular magnetic anisotropy (PMA) have been researched and applied in various spintronic applications. Typically the seed layer material is studied to provide the desired face-centered cubic (\textit{fcc}) texture to the [Co/Ni] to obtain PMA. The integration of [Co/Ni] in back-end-of-line (BEOL) processes also requires the PMA to survive post-annealing. In this paper, the impact of NiCr, Pt, Ru, and Ta seed layers on the structural and magnetic properties of [Co(0.3 nm)/Ni(0.6 nm)] multilayers is investigated before and after annealing. The multilayers were deposited \textit{in-situ} on different seeds via physical vapor deposition at room temperature. The as-deposited [Co/Ni] films show the required \textit{fcc}(111) texture on all seeds, but PMA is only observed on Pt and Ru. In-plane magnetic anisotropy (IMA) is obtained on NiCr and Ta seeds, which is attributed to strain-induced PMA loss. PMA is maintained on all seeds after post-annealing up to 400$^{\circ}$C. The largest effective perpendicular anisotropy energy ($K_U^{\mathrm{eff}}\approx 2\times10^5$J/m$^3$) after annealing is achieved on NiCr seed. The evolution of PMA upon annealing cannot be explained by further crystallization during annealing or strain-induced PMA, nor can the observed magnetization loss and the increased dam** after annealing. Here we identify the diffusion of the non-magnetic materials from the seed into [Co/Ni] as the major driver of the changes in the magnetic properties. By selecting the seed and post-annealing temperature, the [Co/Ni] can be tuned in a broad range for both PMA and dam**. △ Less

Submitted 26 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Comments: 9 pages, 11 figures

Journal ref: Journal of Applied Physics 121, 043905 (2017)

Ferromagnetic resonance study of composite Co/Ni - FeCoB free layers with perpendicular anisotropy

Authors: T. Devolder, E. Liu, J. Swerts, S. Couet, T. Lin, S. Mertens, A. Furnemont, G. Kar, J. De Boeck

Abstract: We study the properties of composite free layers with perpendicular anisotropy. The free layers are made of a soft FeCoB layer ferromagnetically coupled by a variable spacer (Ta, W, Mo) to a very anisotropic [Co/Ni] multilayer embodied in a magnetic tunnel junction meant for spin torque memory applications. For this we use broadband ferromagnetic resonance to follow the field dependence of the aco… ▽ More We study the properties of composite free layers with perpendicular anisotropy. The free layers are made of a soft FeCoB layer ferromagnetically coupled by a variable spacer (Ta, W, Mo) to a very anisotropic [Co/Ni] multilayer embodied in a magnetic tunnel junction meant for spin torque memory applications. For this we use broadband ferromagnetic resonance to follow the field dependence of the acoustical and optical excitation of the composite free layer in both in-plane and out-of-plane applied fields. The modeling provides the interlayer exchange coupling, the anisotropies and the dam** factors. The popular Ta spacer are outperformed by W and even more by Mo, which combines the strongest interlayer exchange coupling without sacrificing anisotropies, dam** factors and transport properties. △ Less

Submitted 26 September, 2016; originally announced September 2016.

Comments: To appear the Applied Physics Letters, 2016

Time-resolved spin-torque switching in MgO-based perpendicularly magnetized tunnel junctions

Authors: T. Devolder, Joo-Von Kim, F. Garcia-Sanchez, J. Swerts, W. Kim, S. Couet, G. Kar, A. Furnemont

Abstract: We study ns scale spin-torque-induced switching in perpendicularly magnetized tunnel junctions (pMTJ). Although the switching voltages match with the macrospin instability threshold, the electrical signatures of the reversal indicate the presence of domain walls in junctions of various sizes. In the antiparallel (AP) to parallel (P) switching, a nucleation phase is followed by an irreversible flow… ▽ More We study ns scale spin-torque-induced switching in perpendicularly magnetized tunnel junctions (pMTJ). Although the switching voltages match with the macrospin instability threshold, the electrical signatures of the reversal indicate the presence of domain walls in junctions of various sizes. In the antiparallel (AP) to parallel (P) switching, a nucleation phase is followed by an irreversible flow of a wall through the sample at an average velocity of 40 m/s with back and forth oscillation movements indicating a Walker propagation regime. A model with a single-wall locally responding to the spin-torque reproduces the essential dynamical signatures of the reversal. The P to AP transition has a complex dynamics with dynamical back-hop** whose probability increases with voltage. We attribute this back-hop** to the instability of the nominally fixed layers. △ Less

Submitted 2 February, 2016; originally announced February 2016.

Journal ref: Physical Review B 93, 024420 (2016)

Reciprocal ontological models show indeterminism of the order of quantum theory

Authors: Somshubhro Bandyopadhyay, Manik Banik, Some Sankar Bhattacharya, Sibasish Ghosh, Guruprasad Kar, Amit Mukherjee, Arup Roy

Abstract: The question whether indeterminism in quantum measurement outcomes is fundamental or is there a possibility of constructing a finer theory underlying quantum mechanics that allows no such indeterminism, has been debated for a long time. We show that within the class of ontological models due to Harrigan and Spekkens, those satisfying preparation-measurement reciprocity must allow indeterminism of… ▽ More The question whether indeterminism in quantum measurement outcomes is fundamental or is there a possibility of constructing a finer theory underlying quantum mechanics that allows no such indeterminism, has been debated for a long time. We show that within the class of ontological models due to Harrigan and Spekkens, those satisfying preparation-measurement reciprocity must allow indeterminism of the order of quantum theory. Our result implies that one can design quantum random number generator, for which it is impossible, even in principle, to construct a reciprocal deterministic model. △ Less

Submitted 10 August, 2015; originally announced August 2015.

Comments: Two column, 7 pages, 1 figure

GHZ correlation provides secure Anonymous Veto Protocol

Authors: Ramij Rahaman, Guruprasad Kar

Abstract: Anonymous Veto (AV) and Dining cryptographers (DC) are two basic primitives for the cryptographic problems where the main aim is to hide the identity of the senders of the messages. These can be achieved by classical methods where the security is based either on computational hardness or on shared private keys. In this regard, we present a secure quantum protocol for both DC and AV by exploiting t… ▽ More Anonymous Veto (AV) and Dining cryptographers (DC) are two basic primitives for the cryptographic problems where the main aim is to hide the identity of the senders of the messages. These can be achieved by classical methods where the security is based either on computational hardness or on shared private keys. In this regard, we present a secure quantum protocol for both DC and AV by exploiting the GHZ correlations. We first solve a generalized version of the DC problem with the help of multiparty GHZ state. This allow us to provide a secure quantum protocol for the AV. Securities for both the protocols rely on some novel and fundamental features of GHZ correlations related to quantum nonlocality. △ Less

Submitted 20 October, 2015; v1 submitted 2 July, 2015; originally announced July 2015.

Comments: 5 pages, In this version we provide detail security proof of our quantum protocols

Necessary Condition for Local Distinguishability of Maximally Entangled States: Beyond Orthogonality Preservation

Authors: Tanmay Singal, Ramij Rahman, Sibasish Ghosh, Guruprasad Kar

Abstract: The (im)possibility of local distinguishability of orthogonal multipartite quantum states still remains an intriguing question. Beyond $\mathbb{C}^{3}\otimes\mathbb{C}^{3}$, the problem remains unsolved even for maximally entangled states (MES). So far, the only known condition for the local distinguishability of states is the well-known orthogonality preservation (OP). Using an upper bound on the… ▽ More The (im)possibility of local distinguishability of orthogonal multipartite quantum states still remains an intriguing question. Beyond $\mathbb{C}^{3}\otimes\mathbb{C}^{3}$, the problem remains unsolved even for maximally entangled states (MES). So far, the only known condition for the local distinguishability of states is the well-known orthogonality preservation (OP). Using an upper bound on the locally accessible information for bipartite states, we derive a very simple necessary condition for any set of pairwise orthogonal MES in $\mathbb{C}^{d}\otimes \mathbb{C}^{d}$ to be perfectly locally distinguishable. This condition is seen to be stronger than the OP condition. This is particularly so for any set of $d$ number of pairwise orthogonal MES in $\mathbb{C}^{d}\otimes \mathbb{C}^{d}$. When testing this condition for the local distinguishability of all sets of four generalized Bell states in $\mathbb{C}^{4}\otimes \mathbb{C}^{4}$, we find that it is not only necessary but also sufficient to determine their local distinguishability. This demonstrates that the aforementioned upper-bound may play a significant role in the general scenario of local distinguishability of bipartite states. △ Less

Submitted 9 April, 2017; v1 submitted 11 June, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Comments: 11 pages. The content is essentially the same as the previous version, with the language having been simplified a bit. Also, the appendix has been shortened

Several foundational and information theoretic implications of Bell's theorem

Authors: Guruprasad Kar, Manik Banik

Abstract: In 1935, Albert Einstein and two colleagues, Boris Podolsky and Nathan Rosen (EPR) developed a thought experiment to demonstrate what they felt was a lack of completeness in quantum mechanics. EPR also postulated the existence of more fundamental theory where physical reality of any system would be completely describe by the variables/states of that fundamental theory. This variable is commonly ca… ▽ More In 1935, Albert Einstein and two colleagues, Boris Podolsky and Nathan Rosen (EPR) developed a thought experiment to demonstrate what they felt was a lack of completeness in quantum mechanics. EPR also postulated the existence of more fundamental theory where physical reality of any system would be completely describe by the variables/states of that fundamental theory. This variable is commonly called hidden variable and the theory is called hidden variable theory (HVT). In 1964, John Bell proposed an empirically verifiable criterion to test for the existence of these HVTs. He derived an inequality, which must be satisfied by any theory that fulfill the conditions of locality and reality} He also showed that quantum mechanics, as it violates this inequality, is incompatible with any local-realistic theory. Later it has been shown that Bell's inequality can be derived from different set of assumptions and it also find applications in useful information theoretic protocols. In this review we will discuss various foundational as well as information theoretic implications of Bell's inequality. We will also discuss about some restricted nonlocal feature of quantum nonlocality and elaborate the role of Uncertainty principle and Complementarity principle in explaining this feature. △ Less

Submitted 3 August, 2014; originally announced August 2014.

Comments: 27 pages; This article is a modified version of the tutorial lecture delivered by G. Kar at IPQI, February 17-28, 2014, Institute of Physics, Bhubaneswar, India

Journal ref: Int. J. Quantum Inform. 14, 1640027 (2016)

Degree of Complementarity Determines the Nonlocality in Quantum Mechanics

Authors: Manik Banik, M. D. Rajjak Gazi, Sibasish Ghosh, Guruprasad Kar

Abstract: Complementarity principle is one of the central concepts in quantum mechanics which restricts joint measurement for certain observables. Of course, later development shows that joint measurement could be possible for such observables with the introduction of a certain degree of unsharpness or fuzziness in the measurement. In this paper, we show that the optimal degree of unsharpness, which guarant… ▽ More Complementarity principle is one of the central concepts in quantum mechanics which restricts joint measurement for certain observables. Of course, later development shows that joint measurement could be possible for such observables with the introduction of a certain degree of unsharpness or fuzziness in the measurement. In this paper, we show that the optimal degree of unsharpness, which guarantees the joint measurement of all possible pairs of dichotomic observables, determines the degree of nonlocality in quantum mechanics as well as in more general no-signaling theories. △ Less

Submitted 27 May, 2013; v1 submitted 26 June, 2012; originally announced June 2012.

Comments: Close to published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 87, 052125 (2013) [5 pages]

LOCC distinguishability of unilaterally transformable quantum states

Authors: Somshubhro Bandyopadhyay, Sibasish Ghosh, Guruprasad Kar

Abstract: We consider the question of perfect local distinguishability of mutually orthogonal bipartite quantum states, with the property that every state can be specified by a unitary operator acting on the local Hilbert space of Bob. We show that if the states can be exactly discriminated by one-way LOCC where Alice goes first, then the unitary operators can also be perfectly distinguished by an orthogona… ▽ More We consider the question of perfect local distinguishability of mutually orthogonal bipartite quantum states, with the property that every state can be specified by a unitary operator acting on the local Hilbert space of Bob. We show that if the states can be exactly discriminated by one-way LOCC where Alice goes first, then the unitary operators can also be perfectly distinguished by an orthogonal measurement on Bob's Hilbert space. We give examples of sets of N<=d maximally entangled states in $d \otimes d $ for d=4,5,6 that are not perfectly distinguishable by one-way LOCC. Interestingly for d=5,6 our examples consist of four and five states respectively. We conjecture that these states cannot be perfectly discriminated by two-way LOCC. △ Less

Submitted 4 November, 2011; v1 submitted 4 February, 2011; originally announced February 2011.

Comments: Revised version, new proofs added; to appear in New Journal of Physics

Journal ref: New J. Phys. 13 (2011) 123013

A complementary relation between classical bits and randomness in local part in simulating singlet state

Authors: Guruprasad Kar, MD. Rajjak Gazi, Manik Banik, Subhadipa Das, Ashutosh Rai, Samir Kunkri

Abstract: Recently Leggett's proposal of non-local model generates new interest in simulating the statistics of singlet state. Singlet state statistics can be simulated by 1 bit of classical communication without using any further nonlocal correlation. But, interestingly, singlet state statistics can also be simulated with no classical cost if a non-local box is used. In the first case, the output is comple… ▽ More Recently Leggett's proposal of non-local model generates new interest in simulating the statistics of singlet state. Singlet state statistics can be simulated by 1 bit of classical communication without using any further nonlocal correlation. But, interestingly, singlet state statistics can also be simulated with no classical cost if a non-local box is used. In the first case, the output is completely unbiased whereas in second case outputs are completely random. We suggest a new (possibly) signaling correlation resource which successfully simulates singlet statistics and this result suggests a new complementary relation between required classical bits and randomness in local output when the classical communication is limited by 1 cbit. This result reproduces the above two models of simulation as extreme cases. This also explains why Leggett's non-local model and the model presented by Branciard et.al. should fail to reproduce the statistics of a singlet. △ Less

Submitted 7 February, 2011; v1 submitted 30 September, 2010; originally announced September 2010.

Comments: v3: Typos corrected, few changed notations, some extensions to earlier write-up

Journal ref: J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 44 (2011) 152002

Complete proof of Gisin's theorem for three qubits

Authors: Sujit K. Choudhary, Sibasish Ghosh, Guruprasad Kar, Ramij Rahaman

Abstract: Gisin's theorem assures that for any pure bipartite entangled state, there is violation of Bell-CHSH inequality revealing its contradiction with local realistic model. Whether, similar result holds for three-qubit pure entangled states, remained unresolved. We show analytically that all three-qubit pure entangled states violate a Bell-type inequality, derived on the basis of local realism, by ex… ▽ More Gisin's theorem assures that for any pure bipartite entangled state, there is violation of Bell-CHSH inequality revealing its contradiction with local realistic model. Whether, similar result holds for three-qubit pure entangled states, remained unresolved. We show analytically that all three-qubit pure entangled states violate a Bell-type inequality, derived on the basis of local realism, by exploiting the Hardy's non-locality argument. △ Less

Submitted 15 January, 2009; v1 submitted 13 January, 2009; originally announced January 2009.

Comments: Revised version with minor corrections in typos, written in double column format, 4 pages, Latex

Hardy's non-locality and generalized non-local theory

Authors: Sujit K. Choudhary, Sibasish Ghosh, Guruprasad Kar, Samir Kunkri, Ramij Rahaman, Anirban Roy

Abstract: Hardy's non-locality theorem for multiple two-level systems is explored in the context of generalized nonlocal theory. We find nonlocal but non-signaling probabilities, providing Hardy's nonlocal argument, which are higher than those in Quantum Mechanics. Maximum probability of success of Hardy's argument is obtained for three two-level systems in quantum as well as in a more generalized theory. I… ▽ More Hardy's non-locality theorem for multiple two-level systems is explored in the context of generalized nonlocal theory. We find nonlocal but non-signaling probabilities, providing Hardy's nonlocal argument, which are higher than those in Quantum Mechanics. Maximum probability of success of Hardy's argument is obtained for three two-level systems in quantum as well as in a more generalized theory. Interestingly, the maximum in the nonlocal generalized theory for both the cases turns out to be same. △ Less

Submitted 31 October, 2011; v1 submitted 28 July, 2008; originally announced July 2008.

Comments: 15 pages

Journal ref: Quantum Information and Computation, Vol. 10, No. 9 & 10 (2010) 0859-0871

Local cloning of genuine entangled states of three qubit

Authors: Sujit K. Choudhary, Guruprasad Kar, Samir Kunkri, Ramij Rahaman, Anirban Roy

Abstract: We discuss (im)possibility of the exact cloning of orthogonal but genuinely entangled three qubit states aided with entangled ancila under local operation and classical communication. Whereas any two orthogonal GHZ states taken from the canonical GHZ basis, can be cloned with the help of a known GHZ state, surprisingly we find that no two W states can be cloned by using any known three qubit (po… ▽ More We discuss (im)possibility of the exact cloning of orthogonal but genuinely entangled three qubit states aided with entangled ancila under local operation and classical communication. Whereas any two orthogonal GHZ states taken from the canonical GHZ basis, can be cloned with the help of a known GHZ state, surprisingly we find that no two W states can be cloned by using any known three qubit (possibly entangled) state as blank copy. △ Less

Submitted 18 July, 2007; originally announced July 2007.

Comments: 4 pages

Journal ref: Physical Review A 76, 062312 (2007)

Causality, Joint measurement and Tsirelson's bound

Authors: Sujit K. Choudhary, Guruprasad Kar, Samir Kunkri, Ramij Rahaman

Abstract: Tsirelson showed that $2\sqrt{2}$ is the maximum value that CHSH expression can take for quantum-correlations [B. S.Tsirelson, Lett. Math. Phys, 4 (1980) 93]. This bound simply follows from the algebra of observables. Recently by exploiting the physical structure of quantum mechanics like unitarity and linearity, Buhrman and Massar [H. Buhrman and S.Massar, Phys. Rev. A, 72 (2005) 052103] have e… ▽ More Tsirelson showed that $2\sqrt{2}$ is the maximum value that CHSH expression can take for quantum-correlations [B. S.Tsirelson, Lett. Math. Phys, 4 (1980) 93]. This bound simply follows from the algebra of observables. Recently by exploiting the physical structure of quantum mechanics like unitarity and linearity, Buhrman and Massar [H. Buhrman and S.Massar, Phys. Rev. A, 72 (2005) 052103] have established that violation of Tsirelson's bound in quantum mechanics will imply signalling. We prove the same with the help of realistic joint measurement in quantum mechanics and a Bell's inequality which has been derived under the assumption of existence of joint measurement and no signalling condition. △ Less

Submitted 31 March, 2008; v1 submitted 11 August, 2006; originally announced August 2006.

Comments: 8 pages

Journal ref: Physics Letters A 371 (2007) 395-398

Winning strategies for pseudo-telepathy games using single non-local box

Authors: Samir Kunkri, Guruprasad Kar, Sibasish Ghosh, Anirban Roy

Abstract: Using a single NL-box, a winning strategy is given for the impossible colouring pseudo-telepathy game for the set of vectors having Kochen-Specker property in four dimension. A sufficient condition to have a winning strategy for the impossible colouring pseudo-telepathy game for general $d$-dimension, with single use of NL-box, is then described. It is also shown that the magic square pseudo-tel… ▽ More Using a single NL-box, a winning strategy is given for the impossible colouring pseudo-telepathy game for the set of vectors having Kochen-Specker property in four dimension. A sufficient condition to have a winning strategy for the impossible colouring pseudo-telepathy game for general $d$-dimension, with single use of NL-box, is then described. It is also shown that the magic square pseudo-telepathy game of any size can be won by using just two ebits of entanglement -- for quantum strategy, and by a single NL-box -- for non-local strategy. △ Less

Submitted 20 February, 2006; v1 submitted 6 February, 2006; originally announced February 2006.

Comments: New game included, title and abstract change, 9 pages, Revtex4

No-Flip** as a consequence of No-Signalling and Non-increase of Entanglement under LOCC

Authors: Indrani Chattopadhyay, Sujit K. Choudhary, Guruprasad Kar, Samir Kunkri, Debasis Sarkar

Abstract: Non existence of Universal NOT gate for arbitrary quantum mechanical states is a fundamental constraint on the allowed operations performed on physical systems. The largest set of states that can be flipped by using a single NOT gate is the set of states lying on a great circle of the Bloch-sphere. In this paper, we show the impossibility of universal exact-flip** operation, first by using the… ▽ More Non existence of Universal NOT gate for arbitrary quantum mechanical states is a fundamental constraint on the allowed operations performed on physical systems. The largest set of states that can be flipped by using a single NOT gate is the set of states lying on a great circle of the Bloch-sphere. In this paper, we show the impossibility of universal exact-flip** operation, first by using the fact that no faster than light communication is possible and then by using the principle of "non-increase of entanglement under LOCC". Interestingly, exact flip** of the states of any great circle does not violate these two principles, as expected. △ Less

Submitted 14 April, 2006; v1 submitted 18 June, 2005; originally announced June 2005.

Comments: 8 pages, published version

Journal ref: Phys. Lett. A, 351, 384-387 (2006)

Two theorems of Jhon Bell and Communication Complexity

Authors: Guruprasad Kar

Abstract: John Bell taught us that quantum mechanics can not be reproduced by non-contextual and local Hidden variable theory. The impossibility of replacing quantum mechanics by non-contextual Hidden Variable Theory can be turned to a impossible coloring pseudo-telepathy game to be played by two distant players. The game can not be won without communication in the classical world. But if the players shar… ▽ More John Bell taught us that quantum mechanics can not be reproduced by non-contextual and local Hidden variable theory. The impossibility of replacing quantum mechanics by non-contextual Hidden Variable Theory can be turned to a impossible coloring pseudo-telepathy game to be played by two distant players. The game can not be won without communication in the classical world. But if the players share entangled state (quantum correlation) the game can be won deterministically using no communication. This again shows that though quantum correlation can not be used for communication, two parties can not simulate quantum correlation without classical communication. The motivation of the article is to present the earlier works on Hidden Variable Theory and recently developed pseudo-telepathy problem in a simpler way, which may be helpful for the beginners in this area. △ Less

Submitted 26 April, 2005; originally announced April 2005.

Comments: 11 pages, Invited lecture at the workshop on Quantum Information,computation and Communication (QICC-2005), IIT Kharagpur,India,February 2005

Locally Accessible Information and Distillation of Entanglement

Authors: Sibasish Ghosh, Pramod Joag, Guruprasad Kar, Samir Kunkri, Anirban Roy

Abstract: A new type of complementary relation is found between locally accessible information and final average entanglement for given ensemble. It is also shown that in some well known distillation protocol, this complementary relation is optimally satisfied. We discuss the interesting trade-off between locally accessible information and distillable entanglement for some states. A new type of complementary relation is found between locally accessible information and final average entanglement for given ensemble. It is also shown that in some well known distillation protocol, this complementary relation is optimally satisfied. We discuss the interesting trade-off between locally accessible information and distillable entanglement for some states. △ Less

Submitted 18 March, 2004; originally announced March 2004.

Comments: 5 pages revtex4

Probabilistic cloning and signalling

Authors: Sibasish Ghosh, Guruprasad Kar, Samir Kunkri, Anirban Roy

Abstract: We give a proof of impossibility of probabilistic exact $1\to 2$ cloning of any three different states of a qubit. The simplicity of the proof is due to the use of a surprising result of remote state preparation [M.-Yong Ye, Y.-Sheng Zhang and G.-Can Guo, quant-ph/0307027 (2003)]. The result is extented to higher dimentional cases for special ensemble of states. We give a proof of impossibility of probabilistic exact $1\to 2$ cloning of any three different states of a qubit. The simplicity of the proof is due to the use of a surprising result of remote state preparation [M.-Yong Ye, Y.-Sheng Zhang and G.-Can Guo, quant-ph/0307027 (2003)]. The result is extented to higher dimentional cases for special ensemble of states. △ Less

Submitted 23 December, 2003; v1 submitted 4 December, 2003; originally announced December 2003.

Comments: Replaced with revised version, 3 pages, latex

Local cloning of Bell states and distillable entanglement

Authors: Sibasish Ghosh, Guruprasad Kar, Anirban Roy

Abstract: The necessary and sufficient amount of entanglement required for cloning of orthogonal Bell states by local operation and classical communication is derived, and using this result, we provide here some additional examples of reversible, as well as irreversible states. The necessary and sufficient amount of entanglement required for cloning of orthogonal Bell states by local operation and classical communication is derived, and using this result, we provide here some additional examples of reversible, as well as irreversible states. △ Less

Submitted 21 May, 2004; v1 submitted 11 November, 2003; originally announced November 2003.

Comments: 5 pages, two columns, Latex. Few typos have been corrected. An explanation of the teleportation map (eqn. (3) in the manuscript) has been provided

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 69, 052312 (2004)

Distinguishability of maximally entangled states

Authors: Sibasish Ghosh, Guruprasad Kar, Anirban Roy, Debasis Sarkar

Abstract: In $2 \otimes 2$, more than 2 orthogonal Bell states with single copy can never be discriminated with certainty if only local operations and classical communication (LOCC) are allowed. More than $d$ orthogonal maximally entangled states in $d \otimed d$, which are in cannonical form, used by Bennett et. al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 70 (1993) 1895] can never be discriminated with certainty when a single… ▽ More In $2 \otimes 2$, more than 2 orthogonal Bell states with single copy can never be discriminated with certainty if only local operations and classical communication (LOCC) are allowed. More than $d$ orthogonal maximally entangled states in $d \otimed d$, which are in cannonical form, used by Bennett et. al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 70 (1993) 1895] can never be discriminated with certainty when a single copy of the states is provided. Interestingly we show that all orthogonal maximally entangled states, which are in cannonical form, can be discriminated with certainty if and only if two copies of each of the states are provided. The highly nontrivial problem of local discrimination of $d$ or less no. of pairwise orthogonal maximally entangled states in $d \otimes d$ (in single copy case), which are in cannonical form, is also discussed. △ Less

Submitted 17 November, 2003; v1 submitted 17 May, 2002; originally announced May 2002.

Comments: There were some mistakes in the previous versions, which have been corrected

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 70, 022304 (2004)

On local indistinguishability of orthogonal pure states by using a bound on distillable entanglement

Authors: Sibasish Ghosh, Guruprasad Kar, Anirban Roy, Debasis Sarkar, Aditi Sen De, Ujjwal Sen

Abstract: We show that the four states a|00>+b|11>, b^*|00>-a^*|11>, c|01>+d|10> and d^*|01>-c^*|10> cannot be discriminated with certainty if only local operations and classical communication (LOCC) are allowed and if only a single copy is provided, except in the case when they are simply |00>, |11>, |01> and |10> (in which case they are trivially distinguishable with LOCC). We go on to show that there e… ▽ More We show that the four states a|00>+b|11>, b^*|00>-a^*|11>, c|01>+d|10> and d^*|01>-c^*|10> cannot be discriminated with certainty if only local operations and classical communication (LOCC) are allowed and if only a single copy is provided, except in the case when they are simply |00>, |11>, |01> and |10> (in which case they are trivially distinguishable with LOCC). We go on to show that there exists a continuous range of values of a, b, c and d such that even three states among the above four are not locally distinguishable, if only a single copy is provided. The proof follows from the fact that logarithmic negativity is an upper bound of distillable entanglement. △ Less

Submitted 25 November, 2001; originally announced November 2001.

Comments: 6 pages latex, no figures

Entanglement teleportation via Bell Mixture

Authors: Sibasish Ghosh, Guruprasad Kar, Anirban Roy, Debasis Sarkar, Ujjwal Sen

Abstract: We investigate the teleportation of the bipartite entangled states through two equally noisy quantum channels, namely mixture of Bell states. There is a particular mixed state channel for which all pure entanglement in a known Schmidt basis remain entangled after teleportation and it happens till the channel state remains entangled. Werner state channel lacks both these features. The relation of… ▽ More We investigate the teleportation of the bipartite entangled states through two equally noisy quantum channels, namely mixture of Bell states. There is a particular mixed state channel for which all pure entanglement in a known Schmidt basis remain entangled after teleportation and it happens till the channel state remains entangled. Werner state channel lacks both these features. The relation of these noisy channels with violation of Bell's inequality and 2-E inequality is studied. △ Less

Submitted 10 July, 2001; originally announced July 2001.

Comments: 7 pages, latex

Distinguishability of the Bell states

Authors: Sibasish Ghosh, Guruprasad Kar, Anirban Roy, Aditi Sen De, Ujjwal Sen

Abstract: More than two multipartite orthogonal states cannot always be discriminated (with certainty) if only local operations and classical communication (LOCC) are allowed. Using an existing inequality among the measures of entanglement, we show that any three Bell states cannot be discriminated by LOCC. Exploiting the inequality, we calculate the distillable entanglement of a certain class of (4\otime… ▽ More More than two multipartite orthogonal states cannot always be discriminated (with certainty) if only local operations and classical communication (LOCC) are allowed. Using an existing inequality among the measures of entanglement, we show that any three Bell states cannot be discriminated by LOCC. Exploiting the inequality, we calculate the distillable entanglement of a certain class of (4\otimes 4) mixed states. △ Less

Submitted 3 July, 2001; v1 submitted 26 June, 2001; originally announced June 2001.

Comments: 3 Pages Latex, references added, minor changes

Mixedness in Bell-violation vs. Entanglement of Formation

Authors: Sibasish Ghosh, Guruprasad Kar, Aditi Sen De, Ujjwal Sen

Abstract: Recently Munro, Nemoto and White (The Bell Inequality: A measure of Entanglement?, quant-ph/0102119) tried to indicate that the reason behind a state rho having higher amount of entanglement (as quantified by the entanglement of formation) than a state eta, but producing the same amount of Bell-violation, is due to the fact that the amount of mixedness (as quantified by the linearised entropy) i… ▽ More Recently Munro, Nemoto and White (The Bell Inequality: A measure of Entanglement?, quant-ph/0102119) tried to indicate that the reason behind a state rho having higher amount of entanglement (as quantified by the entanglement of formation) than a state eta, but producing the same amount of Bell-violation, is due to the fact that the amount of mixedness (as quantified by the linearised entropy) in rho is higher than that in eta. We counter their argument with examples. We extend these considerations to the von Neumann entropy. Our results suggest that the reason as to why equal amount of Bell-violation requires different amounts of entanglement cannot, at least, be explained by mixedness alone. △ Less

Submitted 13 May, 2001; v1 submitted 2 April, 2001; originally announced April 2001.

Comments: 4 pages latex, no figures