-
Unveiling the outer core composition with neutrino oscillation tomography
Authors:
L. Maderer,
E. Kaminski,
J. A. B. Coelho,
S. Bourret,
V. Van Elewyck
Abstract:
In the last 70 years, geophysics has established that the Earth's outer core is an FeNi alloy containing a few percent of light elements, whose nature and amount remain controversial today. Besides the classical combinations of silicon and oxygen, hydrogen has been advocated as the only light element that could account alone for both the density and velocity profiles of the outer core. Here we sho…
▽ More
In the last 70 years, geophysics has established that the Earth's outer core is an FeNi alloy containing a few percent of light elements, whose nature and amount remain controversial today. Besides the classical combinations of silicon and oxygen, hydrogen has been advocated as the only light element that could account alone for both the density and velocity profiles of the outer core. Here we show how this question can be addressed from an independant viewpoint, by exploiting the tomographic information provided by atmospheric neutrinos, weakly-interacting particles produced in the atmosphere and constantly traversing the Earth. We evaluate the potential of the upcoming generation of atmospheric neutrino detectors for such a measurement, showing that they could efficiently detect the presence of 1 wt% of hydrogen in an FeNi core in 50 years of concomitant data taking. We then identify the main requirements for a next-generation detector to perform this measurement in a few years timescale, with the further capability to efficiently discriminate between FeNiH and FeNiSi(x)O(y) models in less than 15 years.
△ Less
Submitted 31 July, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Birth and decline of magma oceans. Part 2: wobbling thermal history of early accreted planetesimals
Authors:
Cyril Sturtz,
Angela Limare,
Stephen Tait,
Édouard Kaminski
Abstract:
A theoretical model that describes the evolution of a suspension in which crystals can sediment to form a dense cumulate or may produce a light flotation crust has been derived in a companion paper. We use this model to study the thermal history of early accreted planetary bodies accreted during the very early stages of the formation of the solar system. We study the conditions required to form an…
▽ More
A theoretical model that describes the evolution of a suspension in which crystals can sediment to form a dense cumulate or may produce a light flotation crust has been derived in a companion paper. We use this model to study the thermal history of early accreted planetary bodies accreted during the very early stages of the formation of the solar system. We study the conditions required to form and preserve flotation crusts and basal cumulates, and the implications for the thermal evolution of planetesimals. We calculate the temperature evolution in an early accreted planetesimals internally heated by the decay of $\rm{^{26}Al}$ and $\rm{^{60}Fe}$. For planetesimal with radius $R>30\, \rm{km}$, partial melting reaches 40%, planetesimals undergo a rheological transition and form a magma ocean, i.e.: a suspension from which crystals can segregate and form a floating crust and/or a dense cumulate. Because of the formation of an insulation floating crust, this magma ocean episode is characterized by a relatively long time life, a slow cooling rate, and a weak surface heat flux. The model further predicts a cyclic evolution where episodes of crustal thickening alternate with episodes of melting-induced crustal thinning. These cycles produce in turn an oscillating thermal history and prevent runaway thermal heating of the planetesimals. At the end of the magma ocean episode, when the fraction of crystals becomes larger than 60\%, a transition occurs to solid-state convection in the planetesimal's mantle. This stage is characterized by high viscous shear stress that tends to erode previously formed crystal deposits. However, the time scale of this erosion process is larger that the lifetime of the planetesimal. Hence solid-state evolution can be described by a well mixed mantle embedded by a metastable crust and a preserved cumulate at its base.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Birth and decline of magma oceans. Part 1: erosion and deposition of crystal layers in evolving magmatic reservoirs
Authors:
Cyril Sturtz,
Angela Limare,
Steve Tait,
Édouard Kaminski
Abstract:
This paper is the first of a two companion papers presenting a theoretical and experimental study of the evolution of crystallizing magma oceans in planetesimals. We aim to understand the behavior of crystals formed in a convective magma and the implications of crystal segregation for the reservoir thermal and structural evolution. In particular, the goal is to constrain the possibility to form an…
▽ More
This paper is the first of a two companion papers presenting a theoretical and experimental study of the evolution of crystallizing magma oceans in planetesimals. We aim to understand the behavior of crystals formed in a convective magma and the implications of crystal segregation for the reservoir thermal and structural evolution. In particular, the goal is to constrain the possibility to form and preserve cumulates and/or flotation crusts by sedimentation/flotation of crystals. We first use lab-scale analog experiments to study the stability and the erosion of a floating lid composed of plastics beads over a convective viscous fluid volumetrically heated by microwave absorption. We propose an erosion law that depends only on two dimensionless numbers which govern these phenomena: (i) the Rayleigh-Roberts number, characterizing the strength of convection and (ii) the Shields number, that encompasses the physics of the flow-particle interaction. We further consider the formation of a cumulate at the base of the convective layer due to sedimentation of beads that are denser than the fluid. We find that particles deposition occurs at a velocity that scales with the Stokes velocity, a result consistent with previous experimental studies. The theoretical framework built on these experimental results is applied in a second paper on the evolution of magma oceans in planetesimals and the fate of particles in this convective environment.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
The fate of particles in a volumetrically heated convective fluid at high Prandtl number
Authors:
Cyril Sturtz,
Edouard Kaminski,
Angela Limare,
Stephen Tait
Abstract:
The dynamics of suspensions plays a crucial role on the evolution of geophysical systems such as lava lakes, magma chambers and magma oceans. During their cooling and solidification, these magmatic bodies involve convective viscous fluids and dispersed solid crystals that can form either a cumulate or a floating lid by sedimentation. We study such systems based on internal heating convection exper…
▽ More
The dynamics of suspensions plays a crucial role on the evolution of geophysical systems such as lava lakes, magma chambers and magma oceans. During their cooling and solidification, these magmatic bodies involve convective viscous fluids and dispersed solid crystals that can form either a cumulate or a floating lid by sedimentation. We study such systems based on internal heating convection experiments in high Prandtl fluids bearing plastic beads. We aim to determine the conditions required to produce a floating lid or a sedimented deposit. We show that although the sign of particles buoyancy is the key parameter, it is not sufficient to predict the particles fate. To complement the model we introduce the Shields formalism and couple it with scaling laws describing convection. We propose a generalised Shields number that enables a self-consistent description of the fate of particles in the system, especially the possibility to segregate from the convective bulk. We provide a quantification of the partition of the mass of particles in the different potential reservoirs (bulk suspension, floating lid, settled cumulate) through reconciling the suspension stability framework with the Shields formalism. We illustrate the geophysical implications of the model by revisiting the problem of the stability of flotation crusts on solidifying rocky bodies.
△ Less
Submitted 31 August, 2021; v1 submitted 17 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Kinetic simulations of ladder climbing by electron plasma waves
Authors:
Kentaro Hara,
Ido Barth,
Erez Kaminski,
I. Y. Dodin,
N. J. Fisch
Abstract:
The energy of plasma waves can be moved up and down the spectrum using chirped modulations of plasma parameters, which can be driven by external fields. Depending on whether the wave spectrum is discrete (bounded plasma) or continuous (boundless plasma), this phenomenon is called ladder climbing (LC) or autoresonant acceleration of plasmons. It was first proposed by Barth \textit{et al.} [PRL \tex…
▽ More
The energy of plasma waves can be moved up and down the spectrum using chirped modulations of plasma parameters, which can be driven by external fields. Depending on whether the wave spectrum is discrete (bounded plasma) or continuous (boundless plasma), this phenomenon is called ladder climbing (LC) or autoresonant acceleration of plasmons. It was first proposed by Barth \textit{et al.} [PRL \textbf{115}, 075001 (2015)] based on a linear fluid model. In this paper, LC of electron plasma waves is investigated using fully nonlinear Vlasov-Poisson simulations of collisionless bounded plasma. It is shown that, in agreement with the basic theory, plasmons survive substantial transformations of the spectrum and are destroyed only when their wave numbers become large enough to trigger Landau dam**. Since nonlinear effects decrease the dam** rate, LC is even more efficient when practiced on structures like quasiperiodic Bernstein-Greene-Kruskal (BGK) waves rather than on Langmuir waves \textit{per~se}.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
On the role of ambient environments in the collapse of Bonnor-Ebert spheres
Authors:
Erica Kaminski,
Adam Frank,
Jonathan Carroll,
Phil Myers
Abstract:
We consider the interaction between a marginally stable Bonnor-Ebert (BE) sphere and the surrounding ambient medium. In particular, we explore how the infall from an evolving ambient medium can trigger collapse of the sphere using 3-D adaptive mesh refinement simulations. We find the resulting collapse dynamics to vary considerably with ambient density. In the highest ambient density cases, infall…
▽ More
We consider the interaction between a marginally stable Bonnor-Ebert (BE) sphere and the surrounding ambient medium. In particular, we explore how the infall from an evolving ambient medium can trigger collapse of the sphere using 3-D adaptive mesh refinement simulations. We find the resulting collapse dynamics to vary considerably with ambient density. In the highest ambient density cases, infalling material drives a strong compression wave into the cloud. It is the propagation of this wave through the cloud interior that triggers the subsequent collapse. For lower ambient densities, we find the main trigger of collapse to be a quasistatic adjustment of the BE sphere to gravitational settling of the ambient gas. In all cases, we find that the classic "outside-in" collapse mode for super-critical BE spheres is recovered before a protostar (i.e. sink particle) forms. Our work supports scenarios in which BE dynamics naturally begins with either a compression-wave or infall dominated phase, and only later assumes the usual outside-in collapse behavior.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2014; v1 submitted 20 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
