Showing 1–40 of 40 results for author: Julien, K

The solar dynamo begins near the surface

Authors: Geoffrey M Vasil, Daniel Lecoanet, Kyle Augustson, Keaton J Burns, Jeffrey S Oishi, Benjamin P Brown, Nicholas Brummell, Keith Julien

Abstract: The Sun's magnetic dynamo cycle features a distinct pattern: a propagating region of sunspot emergence appears around 30 degrees latitude and vanishes near the equator every 11 years. Moreover, longitudinal flows called "torsional oscillations" closely shadow sunspot migration, undoubtedly sharing a common cause. Contrary to theories suggesting deep origins for these phenomena, helioseismology pin… ▽ More The Sun's magnetic dynamo cycle features a distinct pattern: a propagating region of sunspot emergence appears around 30 degrees latitude and vanishes near the equator every 11 years. Moreover, longitudinal flows called "torsional oscillations" closely shadow sunspot migration, undoubtedly sharing a common cause. Contrary to theories suggesting deep origins for these phenomena, helioseismology pinpoints low-latitude torsional oscillations to the Sun's outer 5-10%, the "Near-Surface Shear Layer". Within this zone, inwardly increasing differential rotation coupled with a poloidal magnetic field strongly implicates the Magneto-Rotational Instability prominent in accretion-disk theory and observed in laboratory experiments. Together, these two facts prompt the general question: Is it possible that the solar dynamo is a near-surface instability? Here, we report strong affirmative evidence in stark contrast to traditional paradigms focusing on the deeper tachocline. Simple analytic estimates show that the near-surface magneto-rotational instability better explains the spatiotemporal scales of the torsional oscillations and inferred subsurface magnetic field amplitudes. State-of-the-art numerical simulations corroborate these estimates and, strikingly, reproduce hemispherical magnetic current helicity laws. The dynamo resulting from a well-understood near-surface phenomenon improves prospects for accurate predictions of full magnetic cycles and space weather, impacting Earth's electromagnetic infrastructure. △ Less

Submitted 13 April, 2024; v1 submitted 11 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Comments: In press, Nature

Parameterized Ekman boundary layers on the tilted $f$-plane

Authors: Sara Tro, Ian Grooms, Keith Julien

Abstract: Rotating convection is considered on the tilted $f$-plane where gravity and rotation are not aligned. For sufficiently large rotation rates, $Ω$, the Taylor-Proudman effect results in the gyroscopic alignment of anisotropic columnar structures with the rotation axis giving rise to rapidly varying radial length scales that vanishes as $Ω^{-1/3}$ for $Ω\rightarrow\infty$. Compounding this phenomenon… ▽ More Rotating convection is considered on the tilted $f$-plane where gravity and rotation are not aligned. For sufficiently large rotation rates, $Ω$, the Taylor-Proudman effect results in the gyroscopic alignment of anisotropic columnar structures with the rotation axis giving rise to rapidly varying radial length scales that vanishes as $Ω^{-1/3}$ for $Ω\rightarrow\infty$. Compounding this phenomenon is the existence of viscous (Ekman) layers adjacent to the impenetrable bounding surfaces that diminish in scale as $Ω^{-1/2}$. In this investigation, these constraints are relaxed upon utilizing a non-orthogonal coordinate representation of the fluid equations where the upright coordinate aligns with rotation axis. This exposes the problem to asymptotic perturbation methods that permit: (i) relaxation of the constraints of gyroscopic alignment; (ii) the filtering of Ekman layers through the uncovering of parameterized velocity pum** boundary conditions; and (iii) the development of reduced quasi-geostrophic systems valid in the limit $Ω\rightarrow\infty$. Linear stability investigations reveal excellent quantitative agreement between results from parameterized or unapproximated mechanical boundary conditions. For no-slip boundaries, it is demonstrated that the associated Ekman pum** dramatically alters convective onset through an enhanced destabilization of large spatial scales. The range of unstable modes at a fixed thermal forcing is thus significantly extended with a direct dependence on $Ω$. This holds true even for geophysical and astrophysical regimes characterized by extreme values of the non-dimensional Ekman number $E$. The nonlinear regime is explored via the global heat and momentum transport of single-mode solutions to the quasi-geostrophic systems which indicate $\mathcal{O}(1)$ changes irrespective of the smallness of $E$. △ Less

Submitted 26 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Fixed-flux Rayleigh-Bénard convection in doubly periodic domains: generation of large-scale shear

Authors: Chang Liu, Manjul Sharma, Keith Julien, Edgar Knobloch

Abstract: This work studies two-dimensional fixed-flux Rayleigh-Bénard convection with periodic boundary conditions in both horizontal and vertical directions and analyzes its dynamics using numerical continuation, secondary instability analysis and direct numerical simulation. The fixed-flux constraint leads to time-independent elevator modes with a well-defined amplitude. Secondary instability of these mo… ▽ More This work studies two-dimensional fixed-flux Rayleigh-Bénard convection with periodic boundary conditions in both horizontal and vertical directions and analyzes its dynamics using numerical continuation, secondary instability analysis and direct numerical simulation. The fixed-flux constraint leads to time-independent elevator modes with a well-defined amplitude. Secondary instability of these modes leads to tilted elevator modes accompanied by horizontal shear flow. For $Pr$=1, where $Pr$ is the Prandtl number, a subsequent subcritical Hopf bifurcation leads to hysteresis behavior between this state and a time-dependent direction-reversing state, followed by a global bifurcation leading to modulated traveling waves without flow reversal. Single-mode equations reproduce this moderate Rayleigh number behavior well. At high Rayleigh numbers, chaotic behavior dominated by modulated traveling waves appears. These transitions are characteristic of high wavenumber elevator modes since the vertical wavenumber of the secondary instability is linearly proportional to the horizontal wavenumber of the elevator mode. At a low $Pr$, relaxation oscillations between the conduction state and the elevator mode appear, followed by quasiperiodic and chaotic behavior as the Rayleigh number increases. In the high $Pr$ regime, the large-scale shear weakens, and the flow shows bursting behavior that can lead to significantly increased heat transport or even intermittent stable stratification. △ Less

Submitted 10 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: 31 pages, 29 figures

Low-Frequency Internal Gravity Waves are Pseudo-incompressible

Authors: Bradley W. Hindman, Keith Julien

Abstract: Starting from the fully compressible fluid equations in a plane-parallel atmosphere, we demonstrate that linear internal gravity waves are naturally pseudo-incompressible in the limit that the wave frequency $ω$ is much less than that of surface gravity waves, i.e., $ω\ll \sqrt{g k_h}$ where $g$ is the gravitational acceleration and $k_h$ is the horizontal wavenumber. We accomplish this by perform… ▽ More Starting from the fully compressible fluid equations in a plane-parallel atmosphere, we demonstrate that linear internal gravity waves are naturally pseudo-incompressible in the limit that the wave frequency $ω$ is much less than that of surface gravity waves, i.e., $ω\ll \sqrt{g k_h}$ where $g$ is the gravitational acceleration and $k_h$ is the horizontal wavenumber. We accomplish this by performing a formal expansion of the wave functions and the local dispersion relation in terms of a dimensionless frequency $\varepsilon = ω/ \sqrt{g k_h}$. Further, we show that in this same low-frequency limit, several forms of the anelastic approximation, including the Lantz-Braginsky-Roberts (LBR) formulation, poorly reproduce the correct behavior of internal gravity waves. The pseudo-incompressible approximation is achieved by assuming that Eulerian fluctuations of the pressure are small in the continuity equation. Whereas, in the anelastic approximation Eulerian density fluctuations are ignored. In an adiabatic stratification, such as occurs in a convection zone, the two approximations become identical. But, in a stable stratification, the differences between the two approximations are stark and only the pseudo-incompressible approximation remains valid. △ Less

Submitted 18 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Comments: 18 pages, 2 figures, submitted to the Astrophysical Journal

Journal ref: ApJ, 960, 64 (2024)

From a vortex gas to a vortex crystal in instability-driven two-dimensional turbulence

Authors: A. van Kan, B. Favier, K. Julien, E. Knobloch

Abstract: We study structure formation in two-dimensional turbulence driven by an external force, interpolating between linear instability forcing and random stirring, subject to nonlinear dam**. Using extensive direct numerical simulations, we uncover a rich parameter space featuring four distinct branches of stationary solutions: large-scale vortices, hybrid states with embedded shielded vortices (SVs)… ▽ More We study structure formation in two-dimensional turbulence driven by an external force, interpolating between linear instability forcing and random stirring, subject to nonlinear dam**. Using extensive direct numerical simulations, we uncover a rich parameter space featuring four distinct branches of stationary solutions: large-scale vortices, hybrid states with embedded shielded vortices (SVs) of either sign, and two states composed of many similar SVs. Of the latter, the first is a dense vortex gas where all SVs have the same sign and diffuse across the domain. The second is a hexagonal vortex crystal forming from this gas when the instability is sufficiently weak. These solutions coexist stably over a wide parameter range. The late-time evolution of the system from small-amplitude initial conditions is nearly self-similar, involving three phases: initial inverse cascade, random nucleation of SVs from turbulence and, once a critical number of vortices is reached, a phase of explosive nucleation of SVs, leading to a statistically stationary state. The vortex gas is continued in the forcing parameter, revealing a sharp transition towards the crystal state as the forcing strength decreases. This transition is analysed in terms of the diffusion of individual vortices and tools from statistical physics. The crystal can also decay via an inverse cascade resulting from the breakdown of shielding or insufficient nonlinear dam** acting on SVs. Our study highlights the importance of the forcing details in two-dimensional turbulence and reveals the presence of nontrivial SV states in this system, specifically the emergence and melting of a vortex crystal. △ Less

Submitted 6 January, 2024; v1 submitted 17 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

The Puzzling Structure of Solar Convection: Window into the Dynamo

Authors: Nicholas A. Featherstone, Kyle C. Augustson, Jonathan M. Aurnou, Catherine Blume, Benjamin P. Brown, Nicholas Brummell, Keaton J. Burns, Michael A. Calkins, Maria Camisassa, Mausumi Dikpati, Yuhong Fan, J. R. Fuentes, Gustavo Guerrero, Bradley W. Hindman, Keith Julien, Irina N. Kitiashvili, Lydia Korre, Daniel Lecoanet, Bhishek Manek, Loren Matilsky, Mark Miesch, Nicholas J. Nelson, Jeffrey S. Oishi, Whitney T. Powers, Matthias Rempel , et al. (3 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: The operation of the solar dynamo, with all of its remarkable spatio-temporal ordering, remains an outstanding problem of modern solar physics. A number of mechanisms that might plausibly contribute to its operation have been proposed, but the relative role played by each remains unclear. This uncertainty stems from continuing questions concerning the speed and structure of deep-seated convective… ▽ More The operation of the solar dynamo, with all of its remarkable spatio-temporal ordering, remains an outstanding problem of modern solar physics. A number of mechanisms that might plausibly contribute to its operation have been proposed, but the relative role played by each remains unclear. This uncertainty stems from continuing questions concerning the speed and structure of deep-seated convective flows. Those flows are in-turn thought to sustain both the Sun's turbulent EMF and the large-scale flows of differential rotation and meridional circulation suspected of influencing the dynamo's organization and timing. Continued progress in this area is complicated by (i) inconsistencies between helioseismic measurements of convective and meridional flow made with different techniques and instruments, and (ii) a lack of high-latitude data for convection, differential rotation, and meridional flow. We suggest that the path forward to resolving these difficulties is twofold. First, the acquisition of long-term helioseismic and emissivity measurements obtained from a polar vantage point is vital to complete our picture of the Sun's outer convection zone. Second, sustained and expanded investment in theory-oriented and combined theory/observational research initiatives will be crucial to fully exploit these new observations and to resolve inconsistencies between existing measurements. △ Less

Submitted 15 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: White paper submitted to the Decadal Survey for Solar and Space Physics 2024-2033. 7 pages; 4 figures

Gyroscopic polynomials

Authors: Abram C. Ellison, Keith Julien

Abstract: Gyroscopic alignment of a fluid occurs when flow structures align with the rotation axis. This often gives rise to highly spatially anisotropic columnar structures that in combination with complex domain boundaries pose challenges for efficient numerical discretizations and computations. We define gyroscopic polynomials to be three-dimensional polynomials expressed in a coordinate system that conf… ▽ More Gyroscopic alignment of a fluid occurs when flow structures align with the rotation axis. This often gives rise to highly spatially anisotropic columnar structures that in combination with complex domain boundaries pose challenges for efficient numerical discretizations and computations. We define gyroscopic polynomials to be three-dimensional polynomials expressed in a coordinate system that conforms to rotational alignment. We remap the original domain with radius-dependent boundaries onto a right cylindrical or annular domain to create the computational domain in this coordinate system. We find the volume element expressed in gyroscopic coordinates leads naturally to a hierarchy of orthonormal bases. We build the bases out of Jacobi polynomials in the vertical and generalized Jacobi polynomials in the radial. Because these coordinates explicitly conform to flow structures found in rapidly rotating systems the bases represent fields with a relatively small number of modes. We develop the operator structure for one-dimensional semi-classical orthogonal polynomials as a building block for differential operators in the full three-dimensional cylindrical and annular domains. The differential operators of generalized Jacobi polynomials generate a sparse linear system for discretization of differential operators acting on the gyroscopic bases. This enables efficient simulation of systems with strong gyroscopic alignment. △ Less

Submitted 22 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

MSC Class: 65M70; 65M35

Small scale quasi-geostrophic convective turbulence at large Rayleigh number

Authors: Tobias G. Oliver, Adrienne S. Jacobi, Keith Julien, Michael A. Calkins

Abstract: A numerical investigation of an asymptotically reduced model for quasi-geostrophic Rayleigh-Bénard convection is conducted in which the depth-averaged flows are numerically suppressed by modifying the governing equations. The Reynolds number and Nusselt number show evidence of approaching the diffusion-free scalings of $Re \sim Ra E/Pr$ and $Nu \sim Pr^{-1/2} Ra^{3/2} E^2$, respectively, where… ▽ More A numerical investigation of an asymptotically reduced model for quasi-geostrophic Rayleigh-Bénard convection is conducted in which the depth-averaged flows are numerically suppressed by modifying the governing equations. The Reynolds number and Nusselt number show evidence of approaching the diffusion-free scalings of $Re \sim Ra E/Pr$ and $Nu \sim Pr^{-1/2} Ra^{3/2} E^2$, respectively, where $E$ is the Ekman number and $Pr$ is the Prandtl number. For large $Ra$, the presence of depth-invariant flows, such as large-scale vortices, yield heat and momentum transport scalings that exceed those of the diffusion-free scaling laws. The Taylor microscale does not vary significantly with increasing $Ra$, whereas the integral length scale grows weakly. The computed length scales remain $O(1)$ with respect to the linearly unstable critical wavenumber; we therefore conclude that these scales remain viscously controlled. We do not find a point-wise Coriolis-Inertia-Archimedean (CIA) force balance in the turbulent regime; interior dynamics are instead dominated by horizontal advection (inertia), vortex stretching (Coriolis) and the vertical pressure gradient. A secondary, sub-dominant balance between the buoyancy force and the viscous force occurs in the interior and the ratio of the rms of these two forces is found to approach unity with increasing $Ra$. This secondary balance is attributed to the turbulent fluid interior acting as the dominant control on the heat transport. These findings indicate that a pointwise CIA balance does not occur in the high Rayleigh number regime of quasi-geostrophic convection in the plane layer geometry. Instead, simulations are characterized by what may be termed a \textsl{non-local} CIA balance in which the buoyancy force is dominant within the thermal boundary layers and is spatially separated from the interior Coriolis and inertial forces. △ Less

Submitted 21 August, 2023; v1 submitted 6 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: 32 pages, 11 figures

Corner cases of the tau method: symmetrically imposing boundary conditions on hypercubes

Authors: Keaton J. Burns, Daniel Fortunato, Keith Julien, Geoffrey M. Vasil

Abstract: Polynomial spectral methods produce fast, accurate, and flexible solvers for broad ranges of PDEs with one bounded dimension, where the incorporation of general boundary conditions is well understood. However, automating extensions to domains with multiple bounded dimensions is challenging because of difficulties in imposing boundary conditions at shared edges and corners. Past work has included v… ▽ More Polynomial spectral methods produce fast, accurate, and flexible solvers for broad ranges of PDEs with one bounded dimension, where the incorporation of general boundary conditions is well understood. However, automating extensions to domains with multiple bounded dimensions is challenging because of difficulties in imposing boundary conditions at shared edges and corners. Past work has included various workarounds, such as the anisotropic inclusion of partial boundary data at shared edges or approaches that only work for specific boundary conditions. Here we present a general system for imposing boundary conditions for elliptic equations on hypercubes. We take an approach based on the generalized tau method, which allows for a wide range of boundary conditions for many different spectral schemes. The generalized tau method has the distinct advantage that the specified polynomial residual determines the exact algebraic solution; afterwards, any stable numerical scheme will find the same result. We can, therefore, provide one-to-one comparisons to traditional collocation and Galerkin methods within the tau framework. As an essential requirement, we add specific tau corrections to the boundary conditions, in addition to the bulk PDE, which produce a unique set of compatible boundary data at shared subsurfaces. Our approach works with general boundary conditions that commute on intersecting subsurfaces, including Dirichlet, Neumann, Robin, and any combination of these on all boundaries. The boundary tau corrections can be made hyperoctahedrally symmetric and easily incorporated into existing solvers. We present the method explicitly for the Poisson equation in two and three dimensions and describe its extension to arbitrary elliptic equations (e.g. biharmonic) in any dimension. △ Less

Submitted 23 June, 2024; v1 submitted 30 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 22 pages, 9 figures

Staircase solutions and stability in vertically confined salt-finger convection

Authors: Chang Liu, Keith Julien, Edgar Knobloch

Abstract: Bifurcation analysis of confined salt-finger convection using single-mode equations obtained from a severely truncated Fourier expansion in the horizontal is performed. Strongly nonlinear staircase-like solutions having, respectively, one (S1), two (S2) and three (S3) regions of mixed salinity in the vertical direction are computed using numerical continuation, and their stability properties are d… ▽ More Bifurcation analysis of confined salt-finger convection using single-mode equations obtained from a severely truncated Fourier expansion in the horizontal is performed. Strongly nonlinear staircase-like solutions having, respectively, one (S1), two (S2) and three (S3) regions of mixed salinity in the vertical direction are computed using numerical continuation, and their stability properties are determined. Near onset, the one-layer S1 solution is stable and corresponds to maximum salinity transport among the three solutions. The S2 and S3 solutions are unstable but exert an influence on the statistics observed in direct numerical simulations (DNS) in larger two-dimensional (2D) domains. Secondary bifurcations of S1 lead either to tilted-finger (TF1) or to traveling wave (TW1) solutions, both accompanied by the spontaneous generation of large-scale shear, a process favored for lower density ratios and Prandtl numbers (Pr). These states at low Pr are associated, respectively, with two-layer and three-layer staircase-like salinity profiles in the mean. States breaking reflection symmetry in the midplane are also computed. In 2D and for low Pr the DNS results favor direction-reversing tilted fingers (RTF) resembling the pulsating wave state observed in other systems. Two-layer and three-layer mean salinity profiles corresponding to RTF and TW1 are observed in 2D DNS averaged over time. The single-mode solutions close to the high wavenumber onset are in an excellent agreement with 2D DNS in small horizontal domains and compare well with 3D DNS. △ Less

Submitted 11 October, 2022; v1 submitted 16 July, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

Comments: 37 pages, 24 figures

Spontaneous suppression of inverse energy cascade in instability-driven 2D turbulence

Authors: Adrian van Kan, Benjamin Favier, Keith Julien, Edgar Knobloch

Abstract: Instabilities of fluid flows often generate turbulence. Using extensive direct numerical simulations, we study two-dimensional turbulence driven by a wavenumber-localised instability superposed on stochastic forcing, in contrast to previous studies of state-independent forcing. As the contribution of the instability forcing, measured by a parameter $γ$, increases, the system undergoes two transiti… ▽ More Instabilities of fluid flows often generate turbulence. Using extensive direct numerical simulations, we study two-dimensional turbulence driven by a wavenumber-localised instability superposed on stochastic forcing, in contrast to previous studies of state-independent forcing. As the contribution of the instability forcing, measured by a parameter $γ$, increases, the system undergoes two transitions. For $γ$ below a first threshold, a regular large-scale vortex condensate forms. Above this threshold, shielded vortices (SVs) emerge within the condensate. At a second, larger value of $γ$, the condensate breaks down, and a gas of weakly interacting vortices with broken symmetry spontaneously emerges, characterised by preponderance of vortices of one sign only and suppressed inverse energy cascade. The latter transition is shown to depend on the dam** mechanism. The number density of SVs in the broken symmetry state slowly increases via a random nucleation process. Bistability is observed between the condensate and mixed SV-condensate states. Our findings provide new evidence for a strong dependence of two-dimensional turbulence phenomenology on the forcing. △ Less

Submitted 8 November, 2022; v1 submitted 24 June, 2022; originally announced June 2022.

A gyroscopic polynomial basis in the sphere

Authors: Abram C. Ellison, Keith Julien, Geoffrey M. Vasil

Abstract: Standard spectral codes for full sphere dynamics utilize a combination of spherical harmonics and a suitableradial basis to represent fluid variables. These basis functions have a rotational invariance not present ingeophysical flows. Gyroscopic alignment - alignment of dynamics along the axis of rotation - is ahallmark of geophysical fluids in the rapidly rotating regime. The Taylor-Proudman theo… ▽ More Standard spectral codes for full sphere dynamics utilize a combination of spherical harmonics and a suitableradial basis to represent fluid variables. These basis functions have a rotational invariance not present ingeophysical flows. Gyroscopic alignment - alignment of dynamics along the axis of rotation - is ahallmark of geophysical fluids in the rapidly rotating regime. The Taylor-Proudman theorem, resultingfrom a dominant balance of the Coriolis force and the pressure gradient force, yields nearly invariant flows along this axial direction.In this paper we tailor a coordinate system to the cylindrical structures found in rotating spherical flows.This "spherindrical" coordinate system yields a natural hierarchy of basis functions, composed of Jacobi polynomialsin the radial and vertical direction, regular throughout the ball.We expand fluid variables using this basis and utilize sparse Jacobi polynomial algebra to implement all operatorsrelevant for partial differential equations in the spherical setting. We demonstrate the representation power ofthe basis in three eigenvalue problems for rotating fluids. △ Less

Submitted 5 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

MSC Class: 65M70 (Primary); 65N35 (Secondary)

Journal ref: J.Comp.Phys. 460 (2022) 111170

Experimental observation of the geostrophic turbulence regime of rapidly rotating convection

Authors: Vincent Bouillaut, Benjamin Miquel, Keith Julien, Sébastien Aumaître, Basile Gallet

Abstract: The competition between turbulent convection and global rotation in planetary and stellar interiors governs the transport of heat and tracers, as well as magnetic-field generation. These objects operate in dynamical regimes ranging from weakly rotating convection to the `geostrophic turbulence' regime of rapidly rotating convection. However, the latter regime has remained elusive in the laboratory… ▽ More The competition between turbulent convection and global rotation in planetary and stellar interiors governs the transport of heat and tracers, as well as magnetic-field generation. These objects operate in dynamical regimes ranging from weakly rotating convection to the `geostrophic turbulence' regime of rapidly rotating convection. However, the latter regime has remained elusive in the laboratory, despite a worldwide effort to design ever-taller rotating convection cells over the last decade. Building on a recent experimental approach where convection is driven radiatively, we report heat transport measurements in quantitative agreement with this scaling regime, the experimental scaling-law being validated against direct numerical simulations (DNS) of the idealized setup. The scaling exponent from both experiments and DNS agrees well with the geostrophic turbulence prediction. The prefactor of the scaling-law is greater than the one diagnosed in previous idealized numerical studies, pointing to an unexpected sensitivity of the heat transport efficiency to the precise distribution of heat sources and sinks, which greatly varies from planets to stars. △ Less

Submitted 25 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Journal ref: PNAS 2021 118 (44) e2105015118

Exploiting self-organized criticality in strongly stratified turbulence

Authors: Gregory P. Chini, Guillaume Michel, Keith Julien, Cesar B. Rocha, Colm-cille P. Caulfield

Abstract: A multiscale reduced description of turbulent free shear flows in the presence of strong stabilizing density stratification is derived via asymptotic analysis of the Boussinesq equations in the simultaneous limits of small Froude and large Reynolds numbers. The analysis explicitly recognizes the occurrence of dynamics on disparate spatiotemporal scales, yielding simplified partial differential equ… ▽ More A multiscale reduced description of turbulent free shear flows in the presence of strong stabilizing density stratification is derived via asymptotic analysis of the Boussinesq equations in the simultaneous limits of small Froude and large Reynolds numbers. The analysis explicitly recognizes the occurrence of dynamics on disparate spatiotemporal scales, yielding simplified partial differential equations governing the coupled evolution of slow large-scale hydrostatic flows and fast small-scale isotropic instabilities and internal waves. The dynamics captured by the coupled reduced equations is illustrated in the context of two-dimensional strongly stratified Kolmogorov flow. A noteworthy feature of the reduced model is that the fluctuations are constrained to satisfy quasilinear (QL) dynamics about the comparably slowly-varying large-scale fields. Crucially, this QL reduction is not invoked as an ad hoc closure approximation, but rather is derived in a physically relevant and mathematically consistent distinguished limit. Further analysis of the resulting slow-fast QL system shows how the amplitude of the fast stratified-shear instabilities is slaved to the slowly-evolving mean fields to ensure the marginal stability of the latter. Physically, this marginal stability condition appears to be compatible with recent evidence of self-organized criticality in both observations and simulations of stratified turbulence. lgorithmically, the slaving of the fluctuation fields enables numerical simulations to be time-evolved strictly on the slow time scale of the hydrostatic flow. The reduced equations thus provide a solid mathematical foundation for future studies of three-dimensional strongly stratified turbulence in extreme parameter regimes of geophysical relevance and suggest avenues for new sub-grid-scale parameterizations. △ Less

Submitted 16 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Journal ref: J. Fluid Mech. 933 (2022) A22

The rotational influence on solar convection

Authors: Geoffrey M. Vasil, Keith Julien, Nicholas A. Featherstone

Abstract: This paper considers the dominant dynamical, thermal and rotational balances within the solar convection zone. The reasoning is such that: Coriolis forces balance pressure gradients. Background vortex stretching, baroclinic torques and nonlinear advection balance jointly. Turbulent fluxes convey what part of the solar luminosity that radiative diffusion cannot. These four relations determine estim… ▽ More This paper considers the dominant dynamical, thermal and rotational balances within the solar convection zone. The reasoning is such that: Coriolis forces balance pressure gradients. Background vortex stretching, baroclinic torques and nonlinear advection balance jointly. Turbulent fluxes convey what part of the solar luminosity that radiative diffusion cannot. These four relations determine estimates for the dominant length scales and dynamical amplitudes strictly in terms of known physical quantities. We predict that the dynamical Rossby number for convection is less than unity below the near-surface shear layer, indicating strong rotational constraint. We also predict a characteristic convection length scale of roughly 30 Mm throughout much of the convection zone. These inferences help explain recent observations that reveal weak flow amplitudes at 100-200 Mm scales. △ Less

Submitted 29 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

Comments: 11 pages + references. 4 figures

Connections between Non-Rotating, Slowly Rotating, and Rapidly Rotating Turbulent Convection Transport Scalings

Authors: Jonathan M. Aurnou, Susanne Horn, Keith Julien

Abstract: Buoyancy-driven convection is likely the dominant driver of turbulent motions in the universe, and thus, is widely studied by physicists, engineers, geophysicists and astrophysicists. Maybe unsurprisingly, these different communities discuss the gross convective behaviors in different ways, often without significant cross-talk existing between them. Here, we seek to draw connections between these… ▽ More Buoyancy-driven convection is likely the dominant driver of turbulent motions in the universe, and thus, is widely studied by physicists, engineers, geophysicists and astrophysicists. Maybe unsurprisingly, these different communities discuss the gross convective behaviors in different ways, often without significant cross-talk existing between them. Here, we seek to draw connections between these communities. We do so by carrying out a set of basic scale estimations for how heat and fluid momentum transport should behave in non-rotating, slowly rotating and rapidly rotating buoyancy-driven convective environments. We find that slowly and rapidly rotating scalings can be inter-related via one parameter, the so-called convective Rossby number $\RoC$, a dissipation-free parameter measuring the importance of buoyancy driving relative to rotation. Further, we map between non-flux-based and the flux-based, buoyancy-driven scalings used by different groups. In doing so, these scalings show that there are clean connections between the different communities' approaches and that a number of the seemingly different scalings are actually synonymous with one another. △ Less

Submitted 7 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: 15 pages, 3 figures, 2 Tables

On the inverse cascade and flow speed scaling behavior in rapidly rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection

Authors: S. Maffei, M. J. Krouss, K. Julien, M. A. Calkins

Abstract: Rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection is investigated numerically with the use of an asymptotic model that captures the rapidly rotating, small Ekman number limit, $Ek \rightarrow 0$. The Prandtl number ($Pr$) and the asymptotically scaled Rayleigh number ($\widetilde{Ra} = Ra Ek^{4/3}$, where $Ra$ is the typical Rayleigh number) are varied systematically. For sufficiently vigorous convection, an in… ▽ More Rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection is investigated numerically with the use of an asymptotic model that captures the rapidly rotating, small Ekman number limit, $Ek \rightarrow 0$. The Prandtl number ($Pr$) and the asymptotically scaled Rayleigh number ($\widetilde{Ra} = Ra Ek^{4/3}$, where $Ra$ is the typical Rayleigh number) are varied systematically. For sufficiently vigorous convection, an inverse kinetic energy cascade leads to the formation of a depth-invariant large-scale vortex (LSV). With respect to the kinetic energy, we find a transition from convection dominated states to LSV dominated states at an asymptotically reduced (small-scale) Reynolds number of $\widetilde{Re} \approx 6$ for all investigated values of $Pr$. The ratio of the depth-averaged kinetic energy to the kinetic energy of the convection reaches a maximum at $\widetilde{Re} \approx 24$, then decreases as $\widetilde{Ra}$ is increased. This decrease in the relative kinetic energy of the LSV is associated with a decrease in the convective correlations with increasing Rayleigh number. The scaling behavior of the convective flow speeds is studied; although a linear scaling of the form $\widetilde{Re} \sim \widetilde{Ra}/Pr$ is observed over a limited range in Rayleigh number and Prandtl number, a clear departure from this scaling is observed at the highest accessible values of $\widetilde{Ra}$. Calculation of the forces present in the governing equations shows that the ratio of the viscous force to the buoyancy force is an increasing function of $\widetilde{Ra}$, that approaches unity over the investigated range of parameters. △ Less

Submitted 3 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Heat transfer and flow regimes in quasi-static magnetoconvection with a vertical magnetic field

Authors: Ming Yan, Michael A. Calkins, Stefano Maffei, Keith Julien, Steven M. Tobias, Philippe Marti

Abstract: Numerical simulations of quasi-static magnetoconvection with a vertical magnetic field are carried out up to a Chandrasekhar number of $Q=10^8$ over a broad range of Rayleigh numbers $Ra$. Three magnetoconvection regimes are identified: two of the regimes are magnetically-constrained in the sense that a leading-order balance exists between the Lorentz and buoyancy forces, whereas the third regime… ▽ More Numerical simulations of quasi-static magnetoconvection with a vertical magnetic field are carried out up to a Chandrasekhar number of $Q=10^8$ over a broad range of Rayleigh numbers $Ra$. Three magnetoconvection regimes are identified: two of the regimes are magnetically-constrained in the sense that a leading-order balance exists between the Lorentz and buoyancy forces, whereas the third regime is characterized by unbalanced dynamics that is similar to non-magnetic convection. Each regime is distinguished by flow morphology, momentum and heat equation balances, and heat transport behavior. One of the magnetically-constrained regimes appears to represent an `ultimate' magnetoconvection regime in the dual limit of asymptotically-large buoyancy forcing and magnetic field strength; this regime is characterized by an interconnected network of anisotropic, spatially-localized fluid columns aligned with the direction of the imposed magnetic field that remain quasi-laminar despite having large flow speeds. As for non-magnetic convection, heat transport is controlled primarily by the thermal boundary layer. Empirically, the scaling of the heat transport and flow speeds with $Ra$ appear to be independent of the thermal Prandtl number within the magnetically-constrained, high-$Q$ regimes. △ Less

Submitted 29 August, 2019; v1 submitted 31 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Comments: 24 pages, 11 figures

Energy-conserving Galerkin approximations for quasigeostrophic dynamics

Authors: Matthew Watwood, Ian Grooms, Keith Julien, K. Shafer Smith

Abstract: A method is presented for constructing energy-conserving Galerkin approximations in the vertical coordinate of the full quasigeostrophic model with active surface buoyancy. The derivation generalizes the approach of Rocha \emph{et al.} (2016) to allow for general bases. Details are then presented for a specific set of bases: Legendre polynomials for potential vorticity and a recombined Legendre ba… ▽ More A method is presented for constructing energy-conserving Galerkin approximations in the vertical coordinate of the full quasigeostrophic model with active surface buoyancy. The derivation generalizes the approach of Rocha \emph{et al.} (2016) to allow for general bases. Details are then presented for a specific set of bases: Legendre polynomials for potential vorticity and a recombined Legendre basis from Shen (1994) for the streamfunction. The method is tested in the context of linear baroclinic instability calculations, where it is compared to the standard second-order finite-difference method and to a Chebyshev collocation method. The Galerkin scheme is quite accurate even for a small number of degrees of freedom $N$, and growth rates converge much more quickly with increasing $N$ for the Galerkin scheme than for the finite-difference scheme. The Galerkin scheme is at least as accurate as finite differences and can in some cases achieve the same accuracy as the finite difference scheme with ten times fewer degrees of freedom. The energy-conserving Galerkin scheme is of comparable accuracy to the Chebyshev collocation scheme in most linear stability calculations, but not in the Eady problem where the Chebyshev scheme is significantly more accurate. Finally the three methods are compared in the context of a simplified version of the nonlinear equations: the two-surface model with zero potential vorticity. The Chebyshev scheme is the most accurate, followed by the Galerkin scheme and then the finite difference scheme. All three methods conserve energy with similar accuracy, despite not having any a priori guarantee of energy conservation for the Chebyshev scheme. Further nonlinear tests with non-zero potential vorticity to assess the merits of the methods will be performed in a future work. △ Less

Submitted 24 January, 2019; v1 submitted 24 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 22 pages, 7 figures

Magnetic quenching of the inverse cascade in rapidly rotating convective turbulence

Authors: Stefano Maffei, Michael A. Calkins, Keith Julien, Philippe D. Marti

Abstract: We present results from an asymptotic magnetohydrodynamic model that is suited for studying the rapidly rotating, low viscosity regime typical of the electrically conducting fluid interiors of planets and stars. We show that the presence of sufficiently strong magnetic fields prevents the formation of large-scale vortices and saturates the inverse cascade at a finite length-scale. This saturation… ▽ More We present results from an asymptotic magnetohydrodynamic model that is suited for studying the rapidly rotating, low viscosity regime typical of the electrically conducting fluid interiors of planets and stars. We show that the presence of sufficiently strong magnetic fields prevents the formation of large-scale vortices and saturates the inverse cascade at a finite length-scale. This saturation corresponds to an equilibrated state in which the energetics of the depth-averaged flows are characterized by a balance of convective power input and ohmic dissipation. A quantitative criteria delineating the transition between finite-size flows and domain-filling (large-scale) vortices in electrically conducting fluids is found. By making use of the inferred and observed properties of planetary interiors, our results suggest that convection-driven large-scale vortices do not form in the electrically conducting regions of many bodies. △ Less

Submitted 12 March, 2019; v1 submitted 9 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Comments: Supplementary material included as ancillary file

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Fluids 4, 041801 (2019)

Dissipative shock waves generated by a quantum-mechanical piston

Authors: Maren E. Mossman, Mark A. Hoefer, Keith Julien, Panos G. Kevrekidis, Peter Engels

Abstract: The piston shock problem is a prototypical example of strongly nonlinear fluid flow that enables the experimental exploration of fluid dynamics in extreme regimes. Here we investigate this problem for a nominally dissipationless, superfluid Bose-Einstein condensate and observe rich dynamics including the formation of a plateau region, a non-expanding shock front, and rarefaction waves. Many aspect… ▽ More The piston shock problem is a prototypical example of strongly nonlinear fluid flow that enables the experimental exploration of fluid dynamics in extreme regimes. Here we investigate this problem for a nominally dissipationless, superfluid Bose-Einstein condensate and observe rich dynamics including the formation of a plateau region, a non-expanding shock front, and rarefaction waves. Many aspects of the observed dynamics follow predictions of classical dissipative---rather than superfluid dispersive---shock theory. The emergence of dissipative-like dynamics is attributed to the decay of large amplitude excitations at the shock front into turbulent vortex excitations which allow us to invoke an eddy viscosity hypothesis. Our experimental observations are accompanied by numerical simulations of the mean field, Gross-Pitaevskii equation that exhibit quantitative agreement with no fitting parameters. This work provides an avenue for the investigation of quantum shock waves and turbulence in channel geometries, which are currently the focus of intense research efforts. △ Less

Submitted 2 November, 2018; v1 submitted 18 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Comments: Main manuscript: 8 pages, 7 figures. Supplemental Material: 6 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Nature Communications, 9(1): 4665 (2018)

Impact of domain anisotropy on the inverse cascade in geostrophic turbulent convection

Authors: Keith Julien, Edgar Knobloch, Meredith Plumley

Abstract: The effect of domain anisotropy on the inverse cascade occurring within the geostrophic turbulence regime of rapidly rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection (RRBC) is investigated. In periodic domains with square cross-section in the horizontal a domain-filling dipole state is present. For rectangular periodic domains a Kolmogorov-like flow consisting of a periodic array of alternating unidirectional… ▽ More The effect of domain anisotropy on the inverse cascade occurring within the geostrophic turbulence regime of rapidly rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection (RRBC) is investigated. In periodic domains with square cross-section in the horizontal a domain-filling dipole state is present. For rectangular periodic domains a Kolmogorov-like flow consisting of a periodic array of alternating unidirectional jets with embedded vortices is observed, together with an underlying weak meandering transverse jet. Similar transitions occurring in weakly dissipative two-dimensional flows driven by externally imposed small amplitude noise as well as in classical hydrostatic geostrophic turbulence are a consequence of inviscid conservation of energy and potential enstrophy and can be understood using statistical mechanics considerations. RRBC represents an important three-dimensional system with only one inviscid invariant that nonetheless exhibits large-scale structures driven by intrinsically generated fluctuations. △ Less

Submitted 5 November, 2017; originally announced November 2017.

Comments: 13 pages, 7 figures

The sensitivity of rapidly rotating Rayleigh--Bénard convection to Ekman pum**

Authors: Meredith Plumley, Keith Julien, Philippe Marti, Stephan Stellmach

Abstract: The dependence of the heat transfer, as measured by the nondimensional Nusselt number $Nu$, on Ekman pum** for rapidly rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection in an infinite plane layer is examined for fluids with Prandtl number $Pr = 1$. A joint effort utilizing simulations from the Composite Non-hydrostatic Quasi-Geostrophic model (CNH-QGM) and direct numerical simulations (DNS) of the incompressi… ▽ More The dependence of the heat transfer, as measured by the nondimensional Nusselt number $Nu$, on Ekman pum** for rapidly rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection in an infinite plane layer is examined for fluids with Prandtl number $Pr = 1$. A joint effort utilizing simulations from the Composite Non-hydrostatic Quasi-Geostrophic model (CNH-QGM) and direct numerical simulations (DNS) of the incompressible fluid equations has mapped a wide range of the Rayleigh number $Ra$ - Ekman number $E$ parameter space within the geostrophic regime of rotating convection. Corroboration of the $Nu$-$Ra$ relation at $E = 10^{-7}$ from both methods along with higher $E$ covered by DNS and lower $E$ by the asymptotic model allows for this range of the heat transfer results. For stress-free boundaries, the relation $Nu-1 \propto (Ra E^{4/3} )^α $ has the dissipation-free scaling of $α= 3/2$ for all $E \leq 10^{-7}$. This is directly related to a geostrophic turbulent interior that throttles the heat transport supplied to the thermal boundary layers. For no-slip boundaries, the existence of ageostrophic viscous boundary layers and their associated Ekman pum** yields a more complex 2D surface in $Nu(E,Ra)$ parameter space. For $E<10^{-7}$ results suggest that the surface can be expressed as $Nu-1 \propto (1+ P(E)) (Ra E^{4/3} )^{3/2}$ indicating the dissipation-free scaling law is enhanced by Ekman pum** by the multiplicative prefactor $(1+ P(E))$ where $P(E) \approx 5.97 E^{1/8}$. It follows for $E<10^{-7}$ that the geostrophic turbulent interior remains the flux bottleneck in rapidly rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection. For $E\sim10^{-7}$, where DNS and asymptotic simulations agree quantitatively, it is found that the effects of Ekman pum** are sufficiently strong to influence the heat transport with diminished exponent $α\approx 1.2$ and $Nu-1 \propto (Ra E^{4/3} )^{1.2}$. △ Less

Submitted 15 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Comments: 9 pages, 14 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Fluids 2, 094801 (2017)

Hybrid Chebyshev function bases for sparse spectral methods in parity-mixed PDEs on an infinite domain

Authors: Benjamin Miquel, Keith Julien

Abstract: We present a numerical spectral method to solve systems of differential equations on an infinite interval $y\in (-\infty, \infty)$ in presence of linear differential operators of the form $Q(y) \left(\partial/\partial_y\right)^b$ (where $Q(y)$ is a rational fraction and $b$ a positive integer). Even when these operators are not parity-preserving, we demonstrate how a mixed expansion in interleaved… ▽ More We present a numerical spectral method to solve systems of differential equations on an infinite interval $y\in (-\infty, \infty)$ in presence of linear differential operators of the form $Q(y) \left(\partial/\partial_y\right)^b$ (where $Q(y)$ is a rational fraction and $b$ a positive integer). Even when these operators are not parity-preserving, we demonstrate how a mixed expansion in interleaved Chebyshev rational functions $TB_n(y)$ and $SB_n(y)$ preserves the sparsity of their discretization. This paves the way for fast $O(N\ln N)$ and spectrally accurate mixed implicit-explicit time-marching of sets of linear and nonlinear equations in unbounded geometries. △ Less

Submitted 7 August, 2017; v1 submitted 21 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.

Comments: 26 pages, 11 figures, submitted for publication

A Heuristic Framework for Next-Generation Models of Geostrophic Convective Turbulence

Authors: Jonathan S Cheng, Jonathan M Aurnou, Keith Julien, Rudie P J Kunnen

Abstract: Many geophysical and astrophysical phenomena are driven by turbulent fluid dynamics, containing behaviors separated by tens of orders of magnitude in scale. While direct simulations have made large strides toward understanding geophysical systems, such models still inhabit modest ranges of the governing parameters that are difficult to extrapolate to planetary settings. The canonical problem of ro… ▽ More Many geophysical and astrophysical phenomena are driven by turbulent fluid dynamics, containing behaviors separated by tens of orders of magnitude in scale. While direct simulations have made large strides toward understanding geophysical systems, such models still inhabit modest ranges of the governing parameters that are difficult to extrapolate to planetary settings. The canonical problem of rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection provides an alternate approach - isolating the fundamental physics in a reduced setting. Theoretical studies and asymptotically-reduced simulations in rotating convection have unveiled a variety of flow behaviors likely relevant to natural systems, but still inaccessible to direct simulation. In lieu of this, several new large-scale rotating convection devices have been designed to characterize such behaviors. It is essential to predict how this potential influx of new data will mesh with existing results. Surprisingly, a coherent framework of predictions for extreme rotating convection has not yet been elucidated. In this study, we combine asymptotic predictions, laboratory and numerical results, and experimental constraints to build a heuristic framework for cross-comparison between a broad range of rotating convection studies. We categorize the diverse field of existing predictions in the context of asymptotic flow regimes. We then consider the physical constraints that determine the points of intersection between flow behavior predictions and experimental accessibility. Applying this framework to several upcoming devices demonstrates that laboratory studies may soon be able to characterize geophysically-relevant flow regimes. These new data may transform our understanding of geophysical and astrophysical turbulence, and the conceptual framework developed herein should provide the theoretical infrastructure needed for meaningful discussion of these results. △ Less

Submitted 19 June, 2018; v1 submitted 8 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.

Comments: 36 pages, 8 figures. CHANGES: in revision at Geophysical and Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics

A reduced model for salt-finger convection in the small diffusivity ratio limit

Authors: **-Han Xie, Benjamin Miquel, Keith Julien, Edgar Knobloch

Abstract: A simple model of nonlinear salt-finger convection in two dimensions is derived and studied. The model is valid in the limit of small solute to heat diffusivity ratio and large density ratio, which is relevant to both oceanographic and astrophysical applications. Two limits distinguished by the magnitude of the Schmidt number are found. For order one Schmidt numbers, appropriate for astrophysical… ▽ More A simple model of nonlinear salt-finger convection in two dimensions is derived and studied. The model is valid in the limit of small solute to heat diffusivity ratio and large density ratio, which is relevant to both oceanographic and astrophysical applications. Two limits distinguished by the magnitude of the Schmidt number are found. For order one Schmidt numbers, appropriate for astrophysical applications, a modified Rayleigh-Bénard system with large-scale dam** due to a stabilizing temperature is obtained. For large Schmidt numbers, appropriate for the oceanic setting, the model combines a prognostic equation for the solute field and a diagnostic equation for inertia-free momentum dynamics. Two distinct saturation regimes are identified for the second model: The weakly driven regime is characterized by a large-scale flow associated with a balance between advection and linear instability, while the strongly driven regime produces multiscale structures, resulting in a balance between the energy input through linear instability and the energy transfer between scales. For both regimes, we analytically predict and numerically confirm the dependence of the kinetic energy and salinity fluxes on the ratio between solute and heat Rayleigh numbers. The spectra and probability density functions are also computed. △ Less

Submitted 27 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: 25 pages, 16 figures

MSC Class: 76Fxx; 76Rxx

Inertia-less convectively-driven dynamo models in the limit of low Rossby number and large Prandtl number

Authors: Michael A. Calkins, Keith Julien, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: Compositional convection is thought to be an important energy source for magnetic field generation within planetary interiors. The Prandtl number, $Pr$, characterizing compositional convection is significantly larger than unity, suggesting that the inertial force may not be important on the small scales of convection as long as the buoyancy force is not too strong. We develop asymptotic dynamo mod… ▽ More Compositional convection is thought to be an important energy source for magnetic field generation within planetary interiors. The Prandtl number, $Pr$, characterizing compositional convection is significantly larger than unity, suggesting that the inertial force may not be important on the small scales of convection as long as the buoyancy force is not too strong. We develop asymptotic dynamo models for the case of small Rossby number and large Prandtl number in which inertia is absent on the convective scale. The relevant diffusivity parameter for this limit is the compositional Roberts number, $q = D/η$, which is the ratio of compositional and magnetic diffusivities. Dynamo models are developed for both order one $q$ and the more geophysically relevant low $q$ limit. For both cases the ratio of magnetic to kinetic energy densities, $M$, is asymptotically large and reflects the fact that Alfvén waves have been filtered from the dynamics. Along with previous investigations of asymptotic dynamo models for $Pr=O(1)$, our results show that the ratio $M$ is not a useful indicator of dominant force balances in the momentum equation since many different asymptotic limits of $M$ can be obtained without changing the leading order geostrophic balance. Furthermore, the present models show that inertia is not a requirement for driving low $q$, large-scale dynamos. △ Less

Submitted 23 February, 2017; v1 submitted 13 September, 2016; originally announced September 2016.

Comments: 22 pages, fixed typos, added references to discussion

The effects of Ekman pum** on quasi-geostrophic Rayleigh-Benard convection

Authors: Meredith Plumley, Keith Julien, Philippe Marti, Stephan Stellmach

Abstract: Numerical simulations of 3D, rapidly rotating Rayleigh-Benard convection are performed using an asymptotic quasi-geostrophic model that incorporates the effects of no-slip boundaries through (i) parameterized Ekman pum** boundary conditions, and (ii) a thermal wind boundary layer that regularizes the enhanced thermal fluctuations induced by pum**. The fidelity of the model, obtained by an asym… ▽ More Numerical simulations of 3D, rapidly rotating Rayleigh-Benard convection are performed using an asymptotic quasi-geostrophic model that incorporates the effects of no-slip boundaries through (i) parameterized Ekman pum** boundary conditions, and (ii) a thermal wind boundary layer that regularizes the enhanced thermal fluctuations induced by pum**. The fidelity of the model, obtained by an asymptotic reduction of the Navier-Stokes equations that implicitly enforces a pointwise geostrophic balance, is explored for the first time by comparisons of simulations against the findings of direct numerical simulations and laboratory experiments. Results from these methods have established Ekman pum** as the mechanism responsible for significantly enhancing the vertical heat transport. This asymptotic model demonstrates excellent agreement over a range of thermal forcing for Pr ~1 when compared with results from experiments and DNS at maximal values of their attainable rotation rates, as measured by the Ekman number (E ~ 10^{-7}); good qualitative agreement is achieved for Pr > 1. Similar to studies with stress-free boundaries, four spatially distinct flow morphologies exists. Despite the presence of frictional drag at the upper and/or lower boundaries, a strong non-local inverse cascade of barotropic (i.e., depth-independent) kinetic energy persists in the final regime of geostrophic turbulence and is dominant at large scales. For mixed no-slip/stress-free and no-slip/no-slip boundaries, Ekman friction is found to attenuate the efficiency of the upscale energy transport and, unlike the case of stress-free boundaries, rapidly saturates the barotropic kinetic energy. For no-slip/no-slip boundaries, Ekman friction is strong enough to prevent the development of a coherent dipole vortex condensate. Instead vortex pairs are found to be intermittent, varying in both time and strength. △ Less

Submitted 8 August, 2016; originally announced August 2016.

Comments: 20 pages, 10 figures

Convection-driven kinematic dynamos at low Rossby and magnetic Prandtl numbers

Authors: Michael A. Calkins, Louie Long, David Nieves, Keith Julien, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: Most large-scale planetary magnetic fields are thought to be driven by low Rossby number convection of a low magnetic Prandtl number fluid. Here kinematic dynamo action is investigated with an asymptotic, rapidly rotating dynamo model for the plane layer geometry that is intrinsically low magnetic Prandtl number. The thermal Prandtl number and Rayleigh number are varied to illustrate fundamental c… ▽ More Most large-scale planetary magnetic fields are thought to be driven by low Rossby number convection of a low magnetic Prandtl number fluid. Here kinematic dynamo action is investigated with an asymptotic, rapidly rotating dynamo model for the plane layer geometry that is intrinsically low magnetic Prandtl number. The thermal Prandtl number and Rayleigh number are varied to illustrate fundamental changes in flow regime, ranging from laminar cellular convection to geostrophic turbulence in which an inverse energy cascade is present. A decrease in the efficiency of the convection to generate a dynamo, as determined by an increase in the critical magnetic Reynolds number, is observed as the buoyancy forcing is increased. This decreased efficiency may result from both the loss of correlations associated with the increasingly disordered states of flow that are generated, and boundary layer behavior that enhances magnetic diffusion locally. We find that the spatial characteristics of $α$, and thus the large-scale magnetic field, is dependent only weakly on changes in flow behavior. However, our results are limited to the linear, kinematic dynamo regime, and future simulations including the Lorentz force are therefore necessary to assess the robustness of this result. In contrast to the large-scale magnetic field, the behavior of the small-scale magnetic field is directly dependent on, and therefore shows significant variations with, the small-scale convective flow field. △ Less

Submitted 28 July, 2016; originally announced July 2016.

Comments: 28 pages, 12 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Fluids 1, 083701 (2016)

A nonlinear model for rotationally constrained convection with Ekman pum**

Authors: Keith Julien, Jonathan M. Aurnou, Michael A. Calkins, Edgar Knobloch, Philippe Marti, Stephan Stellmach, Geoffrey M. Vasil

Abstract: It is a well established result of linear theory that the influence of differing mechanical boundary conditions, i.e., stress-free or no-slip, on the primary instability in rotating convection becomes asymptotically small in the limit of rapid rotation. This is accounted for by the diminishing impact of the viscous stresses exerted within Ekman boundary layers and the associated vertical momentum… ▽ More It is a well established result of linear theory that the influence of differing mechanical boundary conditions, i.e., stress-free or no-slip, on the primary instability in rotating convection becomes asymptotically small in the limit of rapid rotation. This is accounted for by the diminishing impact of the viscous stresses exerted within Ekman boundary layers and the associated vertical momentum transport by Ekman pum**. By contrast, in the nonlinear regime recent experiments and supporting simulations are now providing evidence that the efficiency of heat transport remains strongly influenced by Ekman pum** in the rapidly rotating limit. In this paper, a reduced model is developed for the case of low Rossby number convection in a plane layer geometry with no-slip upper and lower boundaries held at fixed temperatures. A complete description of the dynamics requires the existence of three distinct regions within the fluid layer: a geostrophically balanced interior where fluid motions are predominately aligned with the axis of rotation, Ekman boundary layers immediately adjacent to the bounding plates, and thermal wind layers driven by Ekman pum** in between. The reduced model uses a classical Ekman pum** parameterization to alleviate the need for spatially resolving the Ekman boundary layers. Results are presented for both linear stability theory and a special class of nonlinear solutions described by a single horizontal spatial wavenumber. It is shown that Ekman pum** allows for significant enhancement in the heat transport relative to that observed in simulations with stress-free boundaries. Without the intermediate thermal wind layer the nonlinear feedback from Ekman pum** would be able to generate a heat transport that diverges to infinity. This layer arrests this blowup resulting in finite heat transport at a significantly enhanced value. △ Less

Submitted 29 January, 2016; originally announced January 2016.

Comments: 38 pages, 14 figures

Convection-driven kinematic dynamos at low Rossby and magnetic Prandtl numbers: single mode solutions

Authors: Michael A. Calkins, Keith Julien, Steven M. Tobias, Jonathan M. Aurnou, Philippe Marti

Abstract: The onset of dynamo action is investigated within the context of a newly developed low Rossby, low magnetic Prandtl number, convection-driven dynamo model. This multiscale model represents an asymptotically exact form of an $α^2$ mean field dynamo model in which the small-scale convection is represented explicitly by finite amplitude, single mode solutions. Both steady and oscillatory convection a… ▽ More The onset of dynamo action is investigated within the context of a newly developed low Rossby, low magnetic Prandtl number, convection-driven dynamo model. This multiscale model represents an asymptotically exact form of an $α^2$ mean field dynamo model in which the small-scale convection is represented explicitly by finite amplitude, single mode solutions. Both steady and oscillatory convection are considered for a variety of horizontal planforms. The kinetic helicity is observed to be a monotonically increasing function of the Rayleigh number. As a result, very small magnetic Prandtl number dynamos can be found for sufficiently large Rayleigh numbers. All dynamos are found to be oscillatory with an oscillation frequency that increases as the strength of the convection is increased and the magnetic Prandtl number is reduced. Kinematic dynamo action is strongly controlled by the profile of the helicity; single mode solutions which exhibit boundary layer behavior in the helicity show a decrease in the efficiency of dynamo action due to the enhancement of magnetic diffusion in the boundary layer regions. For a given value of the Rayleigh number, lower magnetic Prandtl number dynamos are excited for the case of oscillatory convection in comparison to steady convection. With regards to planetary dynamos, these results suggest that the low magnetic Prandtl number dynamos typical of liquid metals are more easily driven by thermal convection than by compositional convection. △ Less

Submitted 31 January, 2016; v1 submitted 19 November, 2015; originally announced November 2015.

Comments: 13 pages, 12 figures, submitted to Physical Review E

The asymptotic equivalence of fixed heat flux and fixed temperature thermal boundary conditions for rapidly rotating convection

Authors: Michael A. Calkins, Kevin Hale, Keith Julien, David Nieves, Derek Driggs, Philippe Marti

Abstract: The influence of fixed temperature and fixed heat flux thermal boundary conditions on rapidly rotating convection in the plane layer geometry is investigated for the case of stress-free mechanical boundary conditions. It is shown that whereas the leading order system satisfies fixed temperature boundary conditions implicitly, a double boundary layer structure is necessary to satisfy the fixed heat… ▽ More The influence of fixed temperature and fixed heat flux thermal boundary conditions on rapidly rotating convection in the plane layer geometry is investigated for the case of stress-free mechanical boundary conditions. It is shown that whereas the leading order system satisfies fixed temperature boundary conditions implicitly, a double boundary layer structure is necessary to satisfy the fixed heat flux thermal boundary conditions. The boundary layers consist of a classical Ekman layer adjacent to the solid boundaries that adjust viscous stresses to zero, and a layer in thermal wind balance just outside the Ekman layers adjusts the temperature such that the fixed heat flux thermal boundary conditions are satisfied. The influence of these boundary layers on the interior geostrophically balanced convection is shown to be asymptotically weak, however. Upon defining a simple rescaling of the thermal variables, the leading order reduced system of governing equations are therefore equivalent for both boundary conditions. These results imply that any horizontal thermal variation along the boundaries that varies on the scale of the convection has no leading order influence on the interior convection. △ Less

Submitted 25 July, 2015; originally announced July 2015.

A Multiscale Dynamo Model Driven by Quasi-geostrophic Convection

Authors: Michael A. Calkins, Keith Julien, Steven M. Tobias, Jonathan M. Aurnou

Abstract: A convection-driven multiscale dynamo model is developed in the limit of low Rossby number for the plane layer geometry in which the gravity and rotation vectors are aligned. The small-scale fluctuating dynamics are described by a magnetically-modified quasi-geostrophic equation set, and the large-scale mean dynamics are governed by a diagnostic thermal wind balance. The model utilizes three times… ▽ More A convection-driven multiscale dynamo model is developed in the limit of low Rossby number for the plane layer geometry in which the gravity and rotation vectors are aligned. The small-scale fluctuating dynamics are described by a magnetically-modified quasi-geostrophic equation set, and the large-scale mean dynamics are governed by a diagnostic thermal wind balance. The model utilizes three timescales that respectively characterize the convective timescale, the large-scale magnetic evolution timescale, and the large-scale thermal evolution timescale. Distinct equations are derived for the cases of order one and low magnetic Prandtl number. It is shown that the low magnetic Prandtl number model is characterized by a magnetic to kinetic energy ratio that is asymptotically large, with ohmic dissipation dominating viscous dissipation on the large-scales. For the order one magnetic Prandtl number model the magnetic and kinetic energies are equipartitioned and both ohmic and viscous dissipation are weak on the large-scales; large-scale ohmic dissipation occurs in thin magnetic boundary layers adjacent to the solid boundaries. For both magnetic Prandtl number cases the Elsasser number is small since the Lorentz force does not enter the leading order force balance. The new models can be considered fully nonlinear, generalized versions of the dynamo model originally developed by Childress and Soward [Phys. Rev. Lett., \textbf{29}, p.837, 1972]. These models may be useful for understanding the dynamics of convection-driven dynamos in regimes that are only just becoming accessible to direct numerical simulations. △ Less

Submitted 3 July, 2015; v1 submitted 12 February, 2015; originally announced February 2015.

Comments: 23 pages, 1 figure

Approaching the Asymptotic Regime of Rapidly Rotating Convection: Boundary Layers vs Interior Dynamics

Authors: S. Stellmach, M. Lischper, K. Julien, G. Vasil, J. S. Cheng, A. Ribeiro, E. M. King, J. M. Aurnou

Abstract: Rapidly rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection is studied by combining results from direct numerical simulations (DNS), laboratory experiments and asymptotic modeling. The asymptotic theory is shown to provide a good description of the bulk dynamics at low, but finite Rossby number. However, large deviations from the asymptotically predicted heat transfer scaling are found, with laboratory experiment… ▽ More Rapidly rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection is studied by combining results from direct numerical simulations (DNS), laboratory experiments and asymptotic modeling. The asymptotic theory is shown to provide a good description of the bulk dynamics at low, but finite Rossby number. However, large deviations from the asymptotically predicted heat transfer scaling are found, with laboratory experiments and DNS consistently yielding much larger Nusselt numbers than expected. These deviations are traced down to dynamically active Ekman boundary layers, which are shown to play an integral part in controlling heat transfer even for Ekman numbers as small as $10^{-7}$. By adding an analytical parameterization of the Ekman transport to simulations using stress-free boundary conditions, we demonstrate that the heat transfer jumps from values broadly compatible with the asymptotic theory to states of strongly increased heat transfer, in good quantitative agreement with no-slip DNS and compatible with the experimental data. Finally, similarly to non-rotating convection, we find no single scaling behavior, but instead that multiple well-defined dynamical regimes exist in rapidly-rotating convection systems. △ Less

Submitted 25 September, 2014; originally announced September 2014.

Comments: Submitted to Physical Review Letters on 17 July 2014

The Breakdown of the Anelastic Approximation in Rotating Compressible Convection: Implications for Astrophysical Systems

Authors: Michael A. Calkins, Keith Julien, Philippe Marti

Abstract: The linear theory for rotating compressible convection in a plane layer geometry is presented for the astrophysically-relevant case of low Prandtl number gases. When the rotation rate of the system is large, the flow remains geostrophically balanced for all stratification levels investigated and the classical (i.e., incompressible) asymptotic scaling laws for the critical parameters are recovered.… ▽ More The linear theory for rotating compressible convection in a plane layer geometry is presented for the astrophysically-relevant case of low Prandtl number gases. When the rotation rate of the system is large, the flow remains geostrophically balanced for all stratification levels investigated and the classical (i.e., incompressible) asymptotic scaling laws for the critical parameters are recovered. For sufficiently small Prandtl numbers, increasing stratification tends to further destabilise the fluid layer, decrease the critical wavenumber and increase the oscillation frequency of the convective instability. In combination, these effects increase the relative magnitude of the time derivative of the density perturbation contained in the conservation of mass equation to non-negligible levels; the resulting convective instabilities occur in the form of compressional quasi-geostrophic oscillations. We find that the anelastic equations, which neglect this term, cannot capture these instabilities and possess spuriously-growing eigenmodes in the rapidly rotating, low Prandtl number regime. It is shown that the Mach number for rapidly rotating compressible convection is intrinsically small for all background states, regardless of the departure from adiabaticity. △ Less

Submitted 5 December, 2014; v1 submitted 5 September, 2014; originally announced September 2014.

Comments: 16 pages, 6 figures, 1 table. Changes made: added new Figure 1, added discussion of Mach number, added references, added Table of linear stability data

Journal ref: Proc.R.Soc.A 471 (2015) 20140689

Reduced description of exact coherent states in parallel shear flows

Authors: Cedric Beaume, Gregory P. Chini, Keith Julien, Edgar Knobloch

Abstract: Exact coherent states of a linearly stable, plane parallel shear flow confined between stationary stress-free walls and driven by a sinusoidal body force (a flow first introduced by F. Waleffe, Phys. Fluids 9, 883 (1997)) are computed using equations obtained from a large Reynolds-number asymptotic reduction of the Navier-Stokes equations. The reduced equations employ a decomposition into streamwi… ▽ More Exact coherent states of a linearly stable, plane parallel shear flow confined between stationary stress-free walls and driven by a sinusoidal body force (a flow first introduced by F. Waleffe, Phys. Fluids 9, 883 (1997)) are computed using equations obtained from a large Reynolds-number asymptotic reduction of the Navier-Stokes equations. The reduced equations employ a decomposition into streamwise-averaged (mean) and streamwise-varying (fluctuation) components and are characterized by an effective order one Reynolds number in the mean equations along with a formally higher-order diffusive regularization of the fluctuation equations. A robust numerical algorithm for computing exact coherent states is introduced. Numerical continuation of the lower branch states to lower Reynolds numbers reveals the presence of a saddle-node; the saddle-node allows access to upper branch states that, like the lower branch states, appear to be self-consistently described by the reduced equations. Both lower and upper branch states are characterized in detail. △ Less

Submitted 10 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Exact coherent structures in a reduced model of parallel shear flow

Authors: Cedric Beaume, Edgar Knobloch, Greg P. Chini, Keith Julien

Abstract: A reduced description of shear flows consistent with the Reynolds number scaling of lower-branch exact coherent states in plane Couette flow [J. Wang et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 204501 (2007)] is constructed. Exact time-independent nonlinear solutions of the reduced equations corresponding to both lower and upper branch states are found for Waleffe flow [F. Waleffe, Phys. Fluids 9, 883--900 (1997… ▽ More A reduced description of shear flows consistent with the Reynolds number scaling of lower-branch exact coherent states in plane Couette flow [J. Wang et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 204501 (2007)] is constructed. Exact time-independent nonlinear solutions of the reduced equations corresponding to both lower and upper branch states are found for Waleffe flow [F. Waleffe, Phys. Fluids 9, 883--900 (1997)]. The lower branch solution is characterized by fluctuations that vary slowly along the critical layer while the upper branch solutions display a bimodal structure and are more strongly focused on the critical layer. The reduced model provides a rational framework for investigations of subcritical spatiotemporal patterns in parallel shear flows. △ Less

Submitted 16 February, 2014; originally announced February 2014.

Chaotic Advection and the Emergence of Tori in the Küppers-Lortz State

Authors: Paul Mullowney, Keith Julien, James D. Meiss

Abstract: Motivated by the roll-switching behavior observed in rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection, we define a Küppers-Lortz (K-L) state as a volume-preserving flow with periodic roll switching. For an individual roll state, the Lagrangian particle trajectories are periodic. In a system with roll-switching, the particles can exhibit three-dimensional, chaotic motion. We study a simple phenomenological ma… ▽ More Motivated by the roll-switching behavior observed in rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection, we define a Küppers-Lortz (K-L) state as a volume-preserving flow with periodic roll switching. For an individual roll state, the Lagrangian particle trajectories are periodic. In a system with roll-switching, the particles can exhibit three-dimensional, chaotic motion. We study a simple phenomenological map that models the Lagrangian dynamics in a K-L state. When the roll axes differ by $120^{\circ}$ in the plane of rotation, we show that the phase space is dominated by invariant tori if the ratio of switching time to roll turnover time is small. When this parameter approaches zero these tori limit onto the classical hexagonal convection patterns, and, as it gets large, the dynamics becomes fully chaotic and well-mixed. For intermediate values, there are interlinked toroidal and poloidal structures separated by chaotic regions. We also compute the exit time distributions and show that the unbounded chaotic orbits are normally diffusive. Although the map presumes instantaneous switching between roll states, we show that the qualitative features of the flow persist when the model has smooth, overlap** time-dependence for the roll amplitudes (the Busse-Heikes model). △ Less

Submitted 26 April, 2008; originally announced April 2008.

Comments: laTeX, 23 pages, 7 figures

Journal ref: Chaos 18: 033104 (2008)

Baroclinic Vorticity Production in Protoplanetary Disks; Part I: Vortex Formation

Authors: Mark R. Petersen, Keith Julien, Glen R. Stewart

Abstract: The formation of vortices in protoplanetary disks is explored via pseudo-spectral numerical simulations of an anelastic-gas model. This model is a coupled set of equations for vorticity and temperature in two dimensions which includes baroclinic vorticity production and radiative cooling. Vortex formation is unambiguously shown to be caused by baroclinicity because (1) these simulations have zer… ▽ More The formation of vortices in protoplanetary disks is explored via pseudo-spectral numerical simulations of an anelastic-gas model. This model is a coupled set of equations for vorticity and temperature in two dimensions which includes baroclinic vorticity production and radiative cooling. Vortex formation is unambiguously shown to be caused by baroclinicity because (1) these simulations have zero initial perturbation vorticity and a nonzero initial temperature distribution; and (2) turning off the baroclinic term halts vortex formation, as shown by an immediate drop in kinetic energy and vorticity. Vortex strength increases with: larger background temperature gradients; warmer background temperatures; larger initial temperature perturbations; higher Reynolds number; and higher resolution. In the simulations presented here vortices form when the background temperatures are $\sim 200K$ and vary radially as $r^{-0.25}$, the initial vorticity perturbations are zero, the initial temperature perturbations are 5% of the background, and the Reynolds number is $10^9$. A sensitivity study consisting of 74 simulations showed that as resolution and Reynolds number increase, vortices can form with smaller initial temperature perturbations, lower background temperatures, and smaller background temperature gradients. For the parameter ranges of these simulations, the disk is shown to be convectively stable by the Solberg-Høiland criteria. △ Less

Submitted 16 November, 2006; originally announced November 2006.

Comments: Originally submitted to The Astrophysical Journal April 3, 2006; resubmitted November 3, 2006; accepted Dec 5, 2006

Baroclinic Vorticity Production in Protoplanetary Disks; Part II: Vortex Growth and Longevity

Authors: Mark R. Petersen, Glen R. Stewart, Keith Julien

Abstract: The factors affecting vortex growth in convectively stable protoplanetary disks are explored using numerical simulations of a two-dimensional anelastic-gas model which includes baroclinic vorticity production and radiative cooling. The baroclinic feedback, where anomalous temperature gradients produce vorticity through the baroclinic term and vortices then reinforce these temperature gradients,… ▽ More The factors affecting vortex growth in convectively stable protoplanetary disks are explored using numerical simulations of a two-dimensional anelastic-gas model which includes baroclinic vorticity production and radiative cooling. The baroclinic feedback, where anomalous temperature gradients produce vorticity through the baroclinic term and vortices then reinforce these temperature gradients, is found to be an important process in the rate of growth of vortices in the disk. Factors which strengthen the baroclinic feedback include fast radiative cooling, high thermal diffusion, and large radial temperature gradients in the background temperature. When the baroclinic feedback is sufficiently strong, anticyclonic vortices form from initial random perturbations and maintain their strength for the duration of the simulation, for over 600 orbital periods. Based on both simulations and a simple vortex model, we find that the local angular momentum transport due to a single vortex may be inward or outward, depending its orientation. The global angular momentum transport is highly variable in time, and is sometimes negative and sometimes positive. This result is for an anelastic gas model, and does not include shocks that could affect angular momentum transport in a compressible-gas disk. △ Less

Submitted 5 December, 2006; v1 submitted 16 November, 2006; originally announced November 2006.

Comments: Originally submitted to The Astrophysical Journal April 3, 2006; resubmitted November 3, 2006; accepted by The Astrophysical Journal Dec 5, 2006