-
Steadiness of coronal heating
Authors:
Philip G. Judge
Abstract:
The EUI instrument on the Solar Orbiter spacecraft has obtained the most stable, high-resolution images of the solar corona from its orbit with a perihelion near 0.4 AU. A sequence of 360 images obtained at 17.1 nm, between 25-Oct-2022 19:00 and 19:30 UT is scrutinized. One image pixel corresponds to 148 km at the solar surface. The widely-held belief that the outer atmosphere of the Sun is in a c…
▽ More
The EUI instrument on the Solar Orbiter spacecraft has obtained the most stable, high-resolution images of the solar corona from its orbit with a perihelion near 0.4 AU. A sequence of 360 images obtained at 17.1 nm, between 25-Oct-2022 19:00 and 19:30 UT is scrutinized. One image pixel corresponds to 148 km at the solar surface. The widely-held belief that the outer atmosphere of the Sun is in a continuous state of magnetic turmoil is pitted against the EUI data. The observed plasma variations appear to fall into two classes. By far the dominant behavior is a very low amplitude variation in brightness (1%) in the coronal loops, with larger variations in some footpoint regions.
No hints of observable changes in magnetic topology are associated with such small variations. The larger amplitude, more rapid, rarer and less-well organized changes are associated with flux emergence. It is suggested therefore that while magnetic reconnection drives the latter, most of the active corona is heated with no evidence of a role for large-scale (observable) reconnection. Since most coronal emission line widths are subsonic, the bulk of coronal heating, if driven by reconnection, can only be of tangentially discontinuous magnetic fields, with angles below about $0.5c_S/c_A \sim 0.3β$, with $β$ the plasma beta parameter ($\sim 0.01)$, and $c_S$ and $c_A$ sound and Alfvén speeds. If heated by multiple small flare-like events, then these must be $\lesssim 10^{21}$ erg, i.e. pico-flares. But processes other than reconnection have yet to be ruled out, such as viscous dissipation, which may contribute to the steady heating of coronal loops over active regions.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Derivation of Instrument Requirements for Polarimetry using Mg, Fe, and Mn lines between 250 and 290 nm
Authors:
A. G. de Wijn,
P. G. Judge,
R. Ezzeddine,
A. Sainz Dalda
Abstract:
Judge et al. (2021) recently argued that a region of the solar spectrum in the near-UV between about 250 and 290 nm is optimal for studying magnetism in the solar chromosphere due to an abundance of Mg II, Fe II, and Fe I lines that sample various heights in the solar atmosphere. In this paper we derive requirements for spectropolarimetric instruments to observe these lines. We derive a relationsh…
▽ More
Judge et al. (2021) recently argued that a region of the solar spectrum in the near-UV between about 250 and 290 nm is optimal for studying magnetism in the solar chromosphere due to an abundance of Mg II, Fe II, and Fe I lines that sample various heights in the solar atmosphere. In this paper we derive requirements for spectropolarimetric instruments to observe these lines. We derive a relationship between the desired sensitivity to magnetic field and the signal-to-noise of the measurement from the weak-field approximation of the Zeeman effect. We find that many lines will exhibit observable polarization signals for both longitudinal and transverse magnetic field with reasonable amplitudes.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
First Observation of Chromospheric Waves in a Sunspot by DKIST/ViSP: The Anatomy of an Umbral Flash
Authors:
Ryan J. French,
Thomas J. Bogdan,
Roberto Casini,
Alfred G. de Wijn,
Philip G. Judge
Abstract:
The Visible Spectro-Polarimeter (ViSP) of the NSF Daniel K. Inouye Solar Telescope (DKIST) collected its Science Verification data on May 7-8, 2021. The instrument observed multiple layers of a sunspot atmosphere simultaneously, in passbands of Ca-II 397 nm (H-line), Fe-I 630 nm, and Ca-II 854 nm, scanning the region with a spatial sampling of 0.041" and average temporal cadence of 7.76 seconds, f…
▽ More
The Visible Spectro-Polarimeter (ViSP) of the NSF Daniel K. Inouye Solar Telescope (DKIST) collected its Science Verification data on May 7-8, 2021. The instrument observed multiple layers of a sunspot atmosphere simultaneously, in passbands of Ca-II 397 nm (H-line), Fe-I 630 nm, and Ca-II 854 nm, scanning the region with a spatial sampling of 0.041" and average temporal cadence of 7.76 seconds, for a 38.8 minute duration. The slit moves southward across the plane-of-the-sky at 3.83 km/s. The spectropolarimetric scans exhibit prominent oscillatory 'ridge' structures which lie nearly perpendicular to the direction of slit motion (north to south). These ridges are visible in maps of line intensity, central wavelength, line width, and both linear and circular polarizations. Contemporaneous Atmospheric Imaging Assembly observations indicate these ridges are purely temporal in character and likely attributed to the familiar chromospheric 3-minute umbral oscillations. We observe in detail a steady umbral flash near the center of the sunspot umbra. Although bad seeing limited the spatial resolution, the unique high signal-to-noise enable us to estimate the shock Mach numbers (= 2), propagation speeds (= 9 km/s), and their impact on longitudinal magnetic field (delta B = 50 G), gas pressure, and temperature (delta T/T = 0.1) of the subshocks over 30 seconds. We also find evidence for rarefaction waves situated between neighboring wave-train shocks. The Ca-II 854 nm line width is steady throughout the umbral flash except for a sharp 1.5 km/s dip immediately before, and comparable spike immediately after, the passage of the shock front. This zig-zag in line width is centered on the subshock and extends over 0.4".
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
The enduring mystery of the solar corona
Authors:
Philip G. Judge
Abstract:
Physicists have long known that the Sun's magnetic fields make its corona much hotter than the surface of the star itself. But how -- and why -- those fields transport and deposit their energy is still a mystery, as Philip G Judge explains
Physicists have long known that the Sun's magnetic fields make its corona much hotter than the surface of the star itself. But how -- and why -- those fields transport and deposit their energy is still a mystery, as Philip G Judge explains
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Thermal and Non-Thermal Properties of Active Region Recurrent Coronal Jets
Authors:
Alin R. Paraschiv,
Alina C. Donea,
Philip G. Judge
Abstract:
We present observations of recurrent active region coronal jets and derive their thermal and non-thermal properties, by studying the physical properties of the plasma simultaneously at the base footpoint, and along the outflow of jets. The sample of analyzed solar jets were observed by SDO-AIA in Extreme Ultraviolet and by RHESSI in the X-Ray domain. The main thermal plasma physical parameters: te…
▽ More
We present observations of recurrent active region coronal jets and derive their thermal and non-thermal properties, by studying the physical properties of the plasma simultaneously at the base footpoint, and along the outflow of jets. The sample of analyzed solar jets were observed by SDO-AIA in Extreme Ultraviolet and by RHESSI in the X-Ray domain. The main thermal plasma physical parameters: temperature, density, energy flux contributions, etc. are calculated using multiple inversion techniques to obtain the differential emission measure from extreme-ultraviolet filtergrams. The underlying models are assessed, and their limitations and applicability are scrutinized. Complementarily, we perform source reconstruction and spectral analysis of higher energy X-Ray observations to further assess the thermal structure and identify non-thermal plasma emission properties. We discuss a peculiar penumbral magnetic reconnection site, which we previously identified as a ``Coronal Geyser''. Evidence supporting cool and hot thermal emission, and non-thermal emission, is presented for a subset of geyser jets. These active region jets are found to be energetically stronger than their polar counterparts, but we find their potential influence on heliospheric energetics and dynamics to be limited. We scrutinize whether the geyser does fit the non-thermal erupting microflare picture, finding that our observations at peak flaring times can only be explained by a combination of thermal and non-thermal emission models. This analysis of geysers provides new information and observational constraints applicable to theoretical modeling of solar jets.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
The mercurial Sun at the heart of our solar system
Authors:
Philip Gordon Judge
Abstract:
As the powerhouse of our solar system, the Sun's electromagnetic planetary influences appear contradictory. On the one hand, the Sun for aeons emitted radiation which was "just right" for life to evolve in our terrestrial Goldilocks zone, even for such complex organisms as ourselves. On the other, in the dawn of Earth's existence the Sun was far dimmer than today, and yet evidence for early liquid…
▽ More
As the powerhouse of our solar system, the Sun's electromagnetic planetary influences appear contradictory. On the one hand, the Sun for aeons emitted radiation which was "just right" for life to evolve in our terrestrial Goldilocks zone, even for such complex organisms as ourselves. On the other, in the dawn of Earth's existence the Sun was far dimmer than today, and yet evidence for early liquid water is written into geology. Now in middle age, the Sun should be a benign object of little interest to society or even astronomers. However, for physical reasons yet to be fully understood, it contains a magnetic machine with a slightly arrhythmic 11 year magnetic heartbeat. Although these variations require merely
0.1% of the solar luminosity, this power floods the solar system with rapidly changing fluxes of photons and particles at energies far above the 0.5eV thermal energy characteristic of the photosphere. Ejected solar plasma carries magnetic fields into space with consequences for planets, the Earth being vulnerable to geomagnetic storms.
This chapter discusses some physical reasons why the Sun suffers from such ailments, and examine consequences through time across the solar system. A Leitmotiv of the discussion is that any rotating and convecting star must inevitably generate magnetic "activity" for which the Sun represents the example par excellence.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Efficient and Automated Inversions of Magnetically-Sensitive Forbidden Coronal Lines: CLEDB -- The Coronal Line Emission DataBase Magnetic Field Inversion Algorithm
Authors:
Alin Razvan Paraschiv,
Philip Gordon Judge
Abstract:
We present CLEDB, a "single point inversion" algorithm for inferring magnetic parameters using I,Q,U, and V Stokes parameters of forbidden magnetic dipole lines formed in the solar corona. We select lines of interest and construct databases of Stokes parameters for combinations of plasma thermal and magnetic configurations. The size and complexity of such databases are drastically reduced by takin…
▽ More
We present CLEDB, a "single point inversion" algorithm for inferring magnetic parameters using I,Q,U, and V Stokes parameters of forbidden magnetic dipole lines formed in the solar corona. We select lines of interest and construct databases of Stokes parameters for combinations of plasma thermal and magnetic configurations. The size and complexity of such databases are drastically reduced by taking advantage of symmetries. Using wavelength-integrated line profiles, each of which might be decomposed beforehand into several line-of-sight components, we search for nearest matches to observed Stokes parameters computed for the elongation corresponding to the observed region. The method is intended to be applied to two or more lines observed simultaneously. The solutions initially yield magnetic orientation, thermal properties, and the spatial position of the emitting plasma in three dimensions. Multiple possible solutions for each observation are returned, including irreducible degeneracies, where usually sets of two solutions are compatible with the two input I,Q,U, and V measurements. In solving for the scattering geometry, this method avoids an additional degeneracy pointed out by Dima & Schad (2020). The magnetic field strength is separately derived from the simple ratio of observed to database Stokes V data, after the thermal properties and scattering geometry solutions have been determined.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Magnetic connections across the chromosphere-corona transition region
Authors:
Philip G. Judge
Abstract:
The plasma contributing to emission from the Sun between the cool chromosphere ($\le 10^4$K) and hot corona ($\ge 10^6$K) has been subjected to many different interpretations. Here we look at the magnetic structure of this transition region (TR) plasma, based upon the implications of CLASP2 data of an active region recently published by Ishikawa et al., and earlier IRIS and SDO data of quiet regio…
▽ More
The plasma contributing to emission from the Sun between the cool chromosphere ($\le 10^4$K) and hot corona ($\ge 10^6$K) has been subjected to many different interpretations. Here we look at the magnetic structure of this transition region (TR) plasma, based upon the implications of CLASP2 data of an active region recently published by Ishikawa et al., and earlier IRIS and SDO data of quiet regions. Ishikawa et al. found that large areas of sunspot plages are magnetically unipolar as measured in the cores of \ion{Mg}{2} resonance lines, formed in the lower transition region under low plasma-$β$ conditions. Here we show that IRIS images in the line cores have fibrils which well aligned with the overlying coronal loop segments seen in the 171 Å channel of SDO. When the TR emission in active regions arise from plasma magnetically and thermally connected to the corona, then the line cores can provide the first credible magnetic boundary conditions for force-free calculations extended to the corona. We also re-examine IRIS images of dynamic TR cool loops previously reported as a major contributor to transition region emission from the quiet Sun. Dynamic cool loops contribute only a small fraction of the total TR emission from the quiet Sun.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Critical Science Plan for the Daniel K. Inouye Solar Telescope (DKIST)
Authors:
Mark P. Rast,
Nazaret Bello González,
Luis Bellot Rubio,
Wenda Cao,
Gianna Cauzzi,
Edward DeLuca,
Bart De Pontieu,
Lyndsay Fletcher,
Sarah E. Gibson,
Philip G. Judge,
Yukio Katsukawa,
Maria D. Kazachenko,
Elena Khomenko,
Enrico Landi,
Valentin Martínez Pillet,
Gordon J. D. Petrie,
Jiong Qiu,
Laurel A. Rachmeler,
Matthias Rempel,
Wolfgang Schmidt,
Eamon Scullion,
Xudong Sun,
Brian T. Welsch,
Vincenzo Andretta,
Patrick Antolin
, et al. (62 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Daniel K. Inouye Solar Telescope (DKIST) will revolutionize our ability to measure, understand and model the basic physical processes that control the structure and dynamics of the Sun and its atmosphere. The first-light DKIST images, released publicly on 29 January 2020, only hint at the extraordinary capabilities which will accompany full commissioning of the five facility instruments. With…
▽ More
The Daniel K. Inouye Solar Telescope (DKIST) will revolutionize our ability to measure, understand and model the basic physical processes that control the structure and dynamics of the Sun and its atmosphere. The first-light DKIST images, released publicly on 29 January 2020, only hint at the extraordinary capabilities which will accompany full commissioning of the five facility instruments. With this Critical Science Plan (CSP) we attempt to anticipate some of what those capabilities will enable, providing a snapshot of some of the scientific pursuits that the Daniel K. Inouye Solar Telescope hopes to engage as start-of-operations nears. The work builds on the combined contributions of the DKIST Science Working Group (SWG) and CSP Community members, who generously shared their experiences, plans, knowledge and dreams. Discussion is primarily focused on those issues to which DKIST will uniquely contribute.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2020; v1 submitted 18 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Inevitable consequences of ion-neutral dam** of intermediate MHD waves in Sun-like stars
Authors:
Philip G. Judge
Abstract:
In the context of the solar atmosphere, we re-examine the role of of neutral and ionized species in dissipating the ordered energy of intermediate-mode MHD waves into heat. We solve conservation equations for the hydrodynamics and for hydrogen and helium ionization stages, along closed tubes of magnetic field. First, we examine the evolution of coronal plasma under conditions where coronal heating…
▽ More
In the context of the solar atmosphere, we re-examine the role of of neutral and ionized species in dissipating the ordered energy of intermediate-mode MHD waves into heat. We solve conservation equations for the hydrodynamics and for hydrogen and helium ionization stages, along closed tubes of magnetic field. First, we examine the evolution of coronal plasma under conditions where coronal heating has abruptly ceased. We find that cool ($< 10^5$K) structures are formed lasting for several hours. MHD waves of modest amplitude can heat the plasma through ion-neutral collisions with sufficient energy rates to support the plasma against gravity. Then we examine a calculation starting from a cooler atmosphere. The calculation shows that warm ($> 10^4 $) K long ($>$ several Mm) tubes of plasma arise by the same mechanism. We speculate on the relevance of these solutions to observed properties of the Sun and similar stars whose atmospheres are permeated with emerging magnetic fields and stirred by convection. Perhaps this elementary process might help explain the presence of ``cool loops'' in the solar transition region and the production of broad components of transition region lines. The production of ionized hydrogen from such a simple and perhaps inevitable mechanism may be an important step towards finding the more complex mechanisms needed to generate coronae with temperatures in excess of 10$^6$K, independent of a star's metallicity.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Dynamics of Late-Stage Reconnection in the 2017 September 10 Solar Flare
Authors:
Ryan J. French,
Sarah A. Matthews,
Lidia van Driel-Gesztelyi,
David M. Long,
Philip G. Judge
Abstract:
In this multi-instrument paper, we search for evidence of sustained magnetic reconnection far beyond the impulsive phase of the X8.2-class solar flare on 2017 September 10. Using Hinode/EIS, CoMP, SDO/AIA, K-Cor, Hinode/XRT, RHESSI, and IRIS, we study the late-stage evolution of the flare dynamics and topology, comparing signatures of reconnection with those expected from the standard solar flare…
▽ More
In this multi-instrument paper, we search for evidence of sustained magnetic reconnection far beyond the impulsive phase of the X8.2-class solar flare on 2017 September 10. Using Hinode/EIS, CoMP, SDO/AIA, K-Cor, Hinode/XRT, RHESSI, and IRIS, we study the late-stage evolution of the flare dynamics and topology, comparing signatures of reconnection with those expected from the standard solar flare model. Examining previously unpublished EIS data, we present the evolution of non-thermal velocity and temperature within the famous plasma sheet structure, for the first four hours of the flare's duration. On even longer time scales, we use Differential Emission Measures and polarization data to study the longevity of the flare's plasma sheet and cusp structure, discovering that the plasma sheet is still visible in CoMP linear polarization observations on 2017 September 11, long after its last appearance in EUV. We deduce that magnetic reconnection of some form is still ongoing at this time - 27 hours after flare onset.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2020; v1 submitted 27 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
A new facility for airborne solar astronomy: NASA's WB-57 at the 2017 total solar eclipse
Authors:
Amir Caspi,
Daniel B. Seaton,
Constantine C. C. Tsang,
Craig E. DeForest,
Paul Bryans,
Edward E. DeLuca,
Steven Tomczyk,
Joan T. Burkepile,
Thomas "Tony" Casey,
John Collier,
Donald "DD" Darrow,
Dominic Del Rosso,
Daniel D. Durda,
Peter T. Gallagher,
Leon Golub,
Matthew Jacyna,
David "DJ" Johnson,
Philip G. Judge,
Cary "Diddle" Klemm,
Glenn T. Laurent,
Johanna Lewis,
Charles J. Mallini,
Thomas "Duster" Parent,
Timothy Propp,
Andrew J. Steffl
, et al. (6 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
NASA's WB-57 High Altitude Research Program provides a deployable, mobile, stratospheric platform for scientific research. Airborne platforms are of particular value for making coronal observations during total solar eclipses because of their ability both to follow the Moon's shadow and to get above most of the atmospheric airmass that can interfere with astronomical observations. We used the 2017…
▽ More
NASA's WB-57 High Altitude Research Program provides a deployable, mobile, stratospheric platform for scientific research. Airborne platforms are of particular value for making coronal observations during total solar eclipses because of their ability both to follow the Moon's shadow and to get above most of the atmospheric airmass that can interfere with astronomical observations. We used the 2017 Aug 21 eclipse as a pathfinding mission for high-altitude airborne solar astronomy, using the existing high-speed visible-light and near-/mid-wave infrared imaging suite mounted in the WB-57 nose cone. In this paper, we describe the aircraft, the instrument, and the 2017 mission; operations and data acquisition; and preliminary analysis of data quality from the existing instrument suite. We describe benefits and technical limitations of this platform for solar and other astronomical observations. We present a preliminary analysis of the visible-light data quality and discuss the limiting factors that must be overcome with future instrumentation. We conclude with a discussion of lessons learned from this pathfinding mission and prospects for future research at upcoming eclipses, as well as an evaluation of the capabilities of the WB-57 platform for future solar astronomy and general astronomical observation.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Sun-like Stars Shed Light on Solar Climate Forcing
Authors:
P. G. Judge,
R. Egeland,
G. W. Henry
Abstract:
Recently published, precise stellar photometry of 72 Sun-like stars obtained at the Fairborn Observatory between 1993 and 2017 is used to set limits on the solar forcing of Earth's atmosphere of $\pm$ 4.5 W m$^{-2}$ since 1750. This compares with the +2.2 $\pm$ 1.1 W m$^{-2}$ IPCC estimate for anthropogenic forcing. Three critical assumptions are made. In decreasing order of importance they are: (…
▽ More
Recently published, precise stellar photometry of 72 Sun-like stars obtained at the Fairborn Observatory between 1993 and 2017 is used to set limits on the solar forcing of Earth's atmosphere of $\pm$ 4.5 W m$^{-2}$ since 1750. This compares with the +2.2 $\pm$ 1.1 W m$^{-2}$ IPCC estimate for anthropogenic forcing. Three critical assumptions are made. In decreasing order of importance they are: (a) most of the brightness variations occur within the average time-series length of $\approx$17 years; (b) the Sun seen from the ecliptic behaves as an ensemble of middle-aged solar-like stars; and (c) narrow-band photometry in the Strömgren $b$ and $y$ bands are linearly proportional to the total solar irradiance. Assumption (a) can best be relaxed and tested by obtaining more photometric data of Sun-like stars, especially those already observed. Eight stars with near-solar parameters have been observed from 1999, and two since 1993. Our work reveals the importance of continuing and expanding ground-based photometry, to complement expensive solar irradiance measurements from space.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Spectropolarimetric Insight into Plasma-Sheet Dynamics of a Solar Flare
Authors:
Ryan J. French,
Philip G. Judge,
Sarah A. Matthews,
Lidia van Driel-Gesztelyi
Abstract:
We examine spectropolarimetric data from the CoMP instrument, acquired during the evolution of the September 10th 2017 X8.2 solar flare on the western solar limb. CoMP captured linearly polarized light from two emission lines of Fe XIII at 1074.7 and 1079.8 nm, from 1.03 to 1.5 solar radii. We focus here on the hot plasma-sheet lying above the bright flare loops and beneath the ejected CME. The po…
▽ More
We examine spectropolarimetric data from the CoMP instrument, acquired during the evolution of the September 10th 2017 X8.2 solar flare on the western solar limb. CoMP captured linearly polarized light from two emission lines of Fe XIII at 1074.7 and 1079.8 nm, from 1.03 to 1.5 solar radii. We focus here on the hot plasma-sheet lying above the bright flare loops and beneath the ejected CME. The polarization has a striking and coherent spatial structure, with unexpectedly small polarization aligned with the plasma-sheet. By elimination, we find that small-scale magnetic field structure is needed to cause such significant depolarization, and suggest that plasmoid formation during reconnection (associated with the tearing mode instability) creates magnetic structure on scales below instrument resolution of 6 Mm. We conclude that polarization measurements with new coronagraphs, such as the upcoming DKIST, will further enhance our understanding of magnetic reconnection and development of turbulence in the solar corona.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Formation of the UV Spectrum of Molecular Hydrogen in the Sun
Authors:
Sarah A. Jaeggli,
Philip G. Judge,
Adrian N. Daw
Abstract:
Ultraviolet lines of molecular hydrogen have been observed in solar spectra for almost four decades, but the behavior of the molecular spectrum and its implications for solar atmospheric structure are not fully understood. Data from the HRTS instrument revealed that H2 emission forms in particular regions, selectively excited by bright UV transition region and chromospheric lines. We test the cond…
▽ More
Ultraviolet lines of molecular hydrogen have been observed in solar spectra for almost four decades, but the behavior of the molecular spectrum and its implications for solar atmospheric structure are not fully understood. Data from the HRTS instrument revealed that H2 emission forms in particular regions, selectively excited by bright UV transition region and chromospheric lines. We test the conditions under which H2 emission can originate by studying non-LTE models sampling a broad range of temperature stratifications and radiation conditions. Stratification plays the dominant role in determining the population densities of H2, which forms in greatest abundance near the continuum photosphere. However, opacity due to photoionization of silicon and other neutrals determines the depth to which UV radiation can penetrate to excite the H2. Thus the majority of H2 emission forms in a narrow region, at about 650 km in standard 1D models of the quiet-Sun, near the tau=1 opacity surface for the exciting UV radiation, generally coming from above. When irradiated from above using observed intensities of bright UV emission lines, detailed non-LTE calculations show that the spectrum of H2 seen in the quiet-Sun SUMER atlas spectrum and HRTS light bridge spectrum can be satisfactorily reproduced in 1D stratified atmospheres, without including 3D or time dependent thermal structures. A detailed comparison to observations from 1205 to 1550 Angstroms is presented, and the success of this 1D approach to modeling solar UV H2 emission is illustrated by the identification of previously unidentified lines and upper levels in HRTS spectra.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
On choosing meaningful research projects in the natural sciences
Authors:
Philip G Judge,
Isabel Lipartito,
Roberto Casini
Abstract:
Over the last few decades, the nature of scientific research has changed in response to external influences. Firstly, powerful networked computers have become a standard tool. Secondly, society presses ever harder for research to deliver something "useful" back to society, both through the kinds of funding opportunities that are made available, and through a critical public eye. Many funding agenc…
▽ More
Over the last few decades, the nature of scientific research has changed in response to external influences. Firstly, powerful networked computers have become a standard tool. Secondly, society presses ever harder for research to deliver something "useful" back to society, both through the kinds of funding opportunities that are made available, and through a critical public eye. Many funding agencies now demand "deliverables" that seem to select research of a particular kind. Lastly, teamwork, often within very large projects, has become commonplace.
Here, we step back and ask how prospective research scientists might select productive research projects in this evolving environment. We hope that our suggestions might also help to improve public understanding and thereby restore flagging faith in science.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Vector magnetic field measurements along a cooled stereo-imaged coronal loop
Authors:
Thomas A. Schad,
Matthew J. Penn,
Haosheng Lin,
Philip G. Judge
Abstract:
The variation of the vector magnetic field along structures in the solar corona remains unmeasured. Using a unique combination of spectropolarimetry and stereoscopy, we infer and compare the vector magnetic field structure and three-dimensional morphology of an individuated coronal loop structure undergoing a thermal instability. We analyze spectropolarimetric data of the He I 10830 Å triplet (…
▽ More
The variation of the vector magnetic field along structures in the solar corona remains unmeasured. Using a unique combination of spectropolarimetry and stereoscopy, we infer and compare the vector magnetic field structure and three-dimensional morphology of an individuated coronal loop structure undergoing a thermal instability. We analyze spectropolarimetric data of the He I 10830 Å triplet ($1s2s{\ }^{3}S_{1} - 1s2p{\ }^{3}P_{2,1,0}$) obtained at the Dunn Solar Telescope with the Facility Infrared Spectropolarimeter on 19 September 2011. Cool coronal loops are identified by their prominent drainage signatures in the He I data (redshifts up to 185 km sec$^{-1}$). Extinction of EUV background radiation along these loops is observed by both the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly onboard the Solar Dynamics Observatory and the Extreme Ultraviolet Imager onboard spacecraft A of the Solar Terrestrial Relations Observatory, and is used to stereoscopically triangulate the loop geometry up to heights of 70 Mm ($0.1$ $R_{sun}$) above the solar surface. The He I polarized spectra along this loop exhibit signatures indicative of atomic-level polarization as well as magnetic signatures through the Hanle and Zeeman effects. Spectropolarimetric inversions indicate that the magnetic field is generally oriented along the coronal loop axis, and provide the height dependence of the magnetic field intensity. The technique we demonstrate is a powerful one that may help better understand the thermodynamics of coronal fine structure magnetism.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
On helium line polarization during the impulsive phase of an X1 flare
Authors:
Philip G. Judge,
Lucia Kleint,
Alberto Sainz-Dalda
Abstract:
We analyze spectropolarimetric data of the He I 1083~nm multiplet ($1s2s~^3\!S_1 - 1s2p~^3\!P^o_{2,1,0}$) during the X1 flare SOL2014-03-29T17:48, obtained with the Facility Infrared Spectrometer (FIRS) at the Dunn Solar Telescope. While scanning active region NOAA 12017, the FIRS slit crossed a flare ribbon during the impulsive phase, when the helium line intensities turned into emission at $<$ t…
▽ More
We analyze spectropolarimetric data of the He I 1083~nm multiplet ($1s2s~^3\!S_1 - 1s2p~^3\!P^o_{2,1,0}$) during the X1 flare SOL2014-03-29T17:48, obtained with the Facility Infrared Spectrometer (FIRS) at the Dunn Solar Telescope. While scanning active region NOAA 12017, the FIRS slit crossed a flare ribbon during the impulsive phase, when the helium line intensities turned into emission at $<$ twice the continuum intensity. Their linear polarization profiles are of the same sign across the multiplet including 1082.9 nm, intensity-like, at $<5$\% of the continuum intensity. Weaker Zeeman-induced linear polarization is also observed. Only the strongest linear polarization coincides with hard X-ray (HXR) emission at 30-70 keV observed by the Reuven Ramaty High Energy Solar Spectroscope Imager. The polarization is generally more extended and lasts longer than the HXR emission. The upper $J=0$ level of the 1082.9~nm component is unpolarizable, thus lower level polarization is the culprit. We make non-LTE radiative transfer calculations in thermal slabs optimized to fit only intensities. The linear polarizations are naturally reproduced, through a systematic change of sign with wavelength of the radiation anisotropy when slab optical depths of the 1082.9 component are $< 1$. Collisions with beams of particles are neither needed nor can they produce the same sign of polarization of the 1082.9 and 1083.0 nm components. The He I line polarization merely requires heating sufficient to produce slabs of the required thickness. Widely different polarizations of H$α$, reported previously, are explained by different radiative anisotropies arising from slabs of different optical depths.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
UV spectra, bombs, and the solar atmosphere
Authors:
Philip G. Judge
Abstract:
A recent analysis of UV data from the Interface Region Imaging Spectrograph {\em IRIS} reports plasma "bombs" with temperatures near \hot{} within the solar photosphere. This is a curious result, firstly because most bomb plasma pressures $p$ (the largest reported case exceeds $10^3$ dyn~cm$^{-2}$) fall well below photospheric pressures ($> 7\times10^3$), and secondly, UV radiation cannot easily e…
▽ More
A recent analysis of UV data from the Interface Region Imaging Spectrograph {\em IRIS} reports plasma "bombs" with temperatures near \hot{} within the solar photosphere. This is a curious result, firstly because most bomb plasma pressures $p$ (the largest reported case exceeds $10^3$ dyn~cm$^{-2}$) fall well below photospheric pressures ($> 7\times10^3$), and secondly, UV radiation cannot easily escape from the photosphere. In the present paper the {\em IRIS} data is independently analyzed. I find that the bombs arise from plasma originally at pressures between $\lta80$ and 800 dyne~cm$^{-2}$ before explosion, i.e. between $\lta850$ and 550 km above $τ_{500}=1$. This places the phenomenon's origin in the low-mid chromosphere or above. I suggest that bomb spectra are more compatible with Alfvénic turbulence than with bi-directional reconnection jets.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Century-Long Monitoring of Solar Irradiance and Earth's Albedo Using a Stable Scattering Target in Space
Authors:
Philip G. Judge,
Ricky Egeland
Abstract:
An inert sphere of a few meters diameter, placed in a special stable geosynchronous orbit in perpetuo, can be used for a variety of scientific experiments. Ground-based observations of such a sphere, "GeoSphere", can resolve very difficult problems in measuring the long-term solar irradiance. GeoSphere measurements will also help us understand the evolution of Earth's albedo and climate over at le…
▽ More
An inert sphere of a few meters diameter, placed in a special stable geosynchronous orbit in perpetuo, can be used for a variety of scientific experiments. Ground-based observations of such a sphere, "GeoSphere", can resolve very difficult problems in measuring the long-term solar irradiance. GeoSphere measurements will also help us understand the evolution of Earth's albedo and climate over at least the next century.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
On the Origin of a Sunquake during the 29 March 2014 X1 Flare
Authors:
Philip G. Judge,
Lucia Kleint,
Alina Donea,
Alberto Sainz Dalda,
Lyndsay Fletcher
Abstract:
Helioseismic data from the HMI instrument have revealed a sunquake associated with the X1 flare SOL2014-03-29T17:48 in active region NOAA 12017. We try to discover if acoustic-like impulses or actions of the Lorentz force caused the sunquake. We analyze spectro-polarimetric data obtained with the Facility Infrared Spectrometer (FIRS) at the Dunn Solar Telescope (DST). Fortuitously the FIRS slit cr…
▽ More
Helioseismic data from the HMI instrument have revealed a sunquake associated with the X1 flare SOL2014-03-29T17:48 in active region NOAA 12017. We try to discover if acoustic-like impulses or actions of the Lorentz force caused the sunquake. We analyze spectro-polarimetric data obtained with the Facility Infrared Spectrometer (FIRS) at the Dunn Solar Telescope (DST). Fortuitously the FIRS slit crossed the flare kernel close to the acoustic source, during the impulsive phase. The infrared FIRS data remain unsaturated throughout the flare. Stokes profiles of lines of Si I 1082.7 nm and He I 1083.0 nm are analyzed. At the flare footpoint, the Si I 1082.7 nm core intensity increases by a factor of several, the IR continuum increases by 4 +/- 1%. Remarkably, the Si I core resembles the classical Ca II K line's self-reversed profile. With nLTE radiative models of H, C, Si and Fe these properties set the penetration depth of flare heating to 100 +/- 100 km, i.e. photospheric layers. Estimates of the non-magnetic energy flux are at least a factor of two less than the sunquake energy flux. Milne-Eddington inversions of the Si I line show that the local magnetic energy changes are also too small to drive the acoustic pulse. Our work raises several questions: Have we "missed" the signature of downward energy propagation? Is it intermittent in time and/or non-local? Does the 1-2 s photospheric radiative dam** time discount compressive modes?
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
A Flare Observed in Coronal, Transition Region and Helium I 10830 Å Emissions
Authors:
Zhicheng Zeng,
Jiong Qiu,
Wenda Cao,
Philip G. Judge
Abstract:
On June 17, 2012, we observed the evolution of a C-class flare associated with the eruption of a filament near a large sunspot in the active region NOAA 11504. We obtained high spatial resolution filtergrams using the 1.6 m New Solar Telescope at the Big Bear Solar Observatory in broad-band TiO at 706 nm (bandpass:10 Å) and He I 10830 Å narrow-band (bandpass: 0.5 Å, centered 0.25 Å to the blue). W…
▽ More
On June 17, 2012, we observed the evolution of a C-class flare associated with the eruption of a filament near a large sunspot in the active region NOAA 11504. We obtained high spatial resolution filtergrams using the 1.6 m New Solar Telescope at the Big Bear Solar Observatory in broad-band TiO at 706 nm (bandpass:10 Å) and He I 10830 Å narrow-band (bandpass: 0.5 Å, centered 0.25 Å to the blue). We analyze the spatio-temporal behavior of the He I 10830 Å data, which were obtained over a 90" X 90" field of view with a cadence of 10 sec. We also analyze simultaneous data from the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly and Extreme Ultraviolet Variability Experiment instruments on board the Solar Dynamics Observatory spacecraft, and data from Reuven Ramaty High Energy Solar Spectroscopic Imager and GOES spacecrafts. Non-thermal effects are ignored in this analysis. Several quantitative aspects of the data, as well as models derived using the "0D" Enthalpy-Based Thermal Evolution of Loops model (EBTEL: Klimchuk et al. 2008) code, indicate that the triplet states of the 10830 Å multiplet are populated by photoionization of chromospheric plasma followed by radiative recombination. Surprisingly, the He II 304 Å line is reasonably well matched by standard emission measure calculations, along with the C IV emission which dominates the AIA 1600 Å channel during flares. This work lends support to some of our previous work combining X-ray, EUV and UV data of flares to build models of energy transport from corona to chromosphere.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
Radiating Current Sheets in the Solar Chromosphere
Authors:
Michael L. Goodman,
Philip G. Judge
Abstract:
An MHD model of a Hydrogen plasma with flow, an energy equation, NLTE ionization and radiative cooling, and an Ohm's law with anisotropic electrical conduction and thermoelectric effects is used to self-consistently generate atmospheric layers over a $50$ km height range. A subset of these solutions contain current sheets, and have properties similar to those of the lower and middle chromosphere.…
▽ More
An MHD model of a Hydrogen plasma with flow, an energy equation, NLTE ionization and radiative cooling, and an Ohm's law with anisotropic electrical conduction and thermoelectric effects is used to self-consistently generate atmospheric layers over a $50$ km height range. A subset of these solutions contain current sheets, and have properties similar to those of the lower and middle chromosphere. The magnetic field profiles are found to be close to Harris sheet profiles, with maximum field strengths $\sim 25-150$ G. The radiative flux $F_R$ emitted by individual sheets is $\sim 4.9 \times 10^5 - 4.5 \times 10^6$ ergs-cm$^{-2}$-s$^{-1}$, to be compared with the observed chromospheric emission rate of $\sim 10^7$ ergs-cm$^{-2}$-s$^{-1}$. Essentially all emission is from regions with thicknesses $\sim 0.5 - 13$ km containing the neutral sheet. About half of $F_R$ comes from sub-regions with thicknesses 10 times smaller. A resolution $\lesssim 5-130$ m is needed to resolve the properties of the sheets. The sheets have total H densities $\sim 10^{13}-10^{15}$ cm$^{-3}$. The ionization fraction in the sheets is $\sim 2-20$ times larger, and the temperature is $\sim 2000-3000$ K higher than in the surrounding plasma. The Joule heating flux $F_J$ exceeds $F_R$ by $\sim 4-34 \%$, the difference being balanced in the energy equation mainly by a negative compressive heating flux. Proton Pedersen current dissipation generates $\sim 62-77\%$ of the positive contribution to $F_J$. The remainder of this contribution is due to electron current dissipation near the neutral sheet where the plasma is weakly magnetized.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
From Forbidden Coronal Lines to Meaningful Coronal Magnetic Fields
Authors:
Philip G. Judge,
Shadia Habbal,
Enrico Landi
Abstract:
We review methods to measure magnetic fields within the corona using the polarized light in magnetic-dipole (M1) lines. We are particularly interested in both the global magnetic-field evolution over a solar cycle, and the local storage of magnetic free energy within coronal plasmas. We address commonly held skepticisms concerning angular ambiguities and line-of-sight confusion. We argue that ambi…
▽ More
We review methods to measure magnetic fields within the corona using the polarized light in magnetic-dipole (M1) lines. We are particularly interested in both the global magnetic-field evolution over a solar cycle, and the local storage of magnetic free energy within coronal plasmas. We address commonly held skepticisms concerning angular ambiguities and line-of-sight confusion. We argue that ambiguities are in principle no worse than more familiar remotely sensed photospheric vector-fields, and that the diagnosis of M1 line data would benefit from simultaneous observations of EUV lines. Based on calculations and data from eclipses, we discuss the most promising lines and different approaches that might be used. We point to the S-like [Fe {\sc XI}] line (J=2 to J=1) at 789.2nm as a prime target line (for ATST for example) to augment the hotter 1074.7 and 1079.8 nm Si-like lines of [Fe {\sc XIII}] currently observed by the Coronal Multi-channel Polarimeter (CoMP). Significant breakthroughs will be made possible with the new generation of coronagraphs, in three distinct ways: (i) through single point inversions (which encompasses also the analysis of MHD wave modes), (ii) using direct comparisons of synthetic MHD or force-free models with polarization data, and (iii) using tomographic techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Removal of Spectro-Polarimetric Fringes by 2D Pattern Recognition
Authors:
R. Casini,
P. G. Judge,
T. A. Schad
Abstract:
We present a pattern-recognition based approach to the problem of removal of polarized fringes from spectro-polarimetric data. We demonstrate that 2D Principal Component Analysis can be trained on a given spectro-polarimetric map in order to identify and isolate fringe structures from the spectra. This allows us in principle to reconstruct the data without the fringe component, providing an effect…
▽ More
We present a pattern-recognition based approach to the problem of removal of polarized fringes from spectro-polarimetric data. We demonstrate that 2D Principal Component Analysis can be trained on a given spectro-polarimetric map in order to identify and isolate fringe structures from the spectra. This allows us in principle to reconstruct the data without the fringe component, providing an effective and clean solution to the problem. The results presented in this paper point in the direction of revising the way that science and calibration data should be planned for a typical spectro-polarimetric observing run.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
Solar and Stellar Activity: Diagnostics and Indices
Authors:
Philip G. Judge,
Michael J. Thompson
Abstract:
We summarize the fifty-year concerted effort to place the "activity" of the Sun in the context of the stars. As a working definition of solar activity in the context of stars, we adopt those globally-observable variations on time scales below thermal time scales, of ~ 100,000 yr for the convection zone. So defined, activity is dominated by magnetic-field evolution, including the 22-year Hale cycle…
▽ More
We summarize the fifty-year concerted effort to place the "activity" of the Sun in the context of the stars. As a working definition of solar activity in the context of stars, we adopt those globally-observable variations on time scales below thermal time scales, of ~ 100,000 yr for the convection zone. So defined, activity is dominated by magnetic-field evolution, including the 22-year Hale cycle, the typical time it takes for the quasi-periodic reversal in which the global magnetic-field takes place. This is accompanied by sunspot variations with 11 year periods, known since the time of Schwabe, as well as faster variations due to rotation of active regions and flaring. "Diagnostics and indices" are terms given to the indirect signatures of varying magnetic- fields, including the photometric (broad-band) variations associated with the sunspot cycle, and variations of the accompanying heated plasma in higher layers of stellar atmospheres seen at special optical wavelengths, and UV and X-ray wavelengths. Our attention is also focussed on the theme of the Symposium by examining evidence for deep and extended minima of stars, and placing the 70-year long solar Maunder Minimum into a stellar context.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2012; v1 submitted 22 January, 2012;
originally announced January 2012.
-
The connection of Type II Spicules to the Corona
Authors:
Philip G. Judge,
Bart de Pontieu,
Scott McIntosh,
Kosovare Olluri
Abstract:
We examine the hypothesis that plasma associated with "Type II" spicules is heated to coronal temperatures, and that the upward moving hot plasma constitutes a significant mass supply to the solar corona. 1D hydrodynamical models including time- dependent ionization are brought to bear on the problem. These calculations indicate that heating of field-aligned spicule flows should produce significan…
▽ More
We examine the hypothesis that plasma associated with "Type II" spicules is heated to coronal temperatures, and that the upward moving hot plasma constitutes a significant mass supply to the solar corona. 1D hydrodynamical models including time- dependent ionization are brought to bear on the problem. These calculations indicate that heating of field-aligned spicule flows should produce significant differential Doppler shifts between emission lines formed in the chromosphere, transition region, and corona. At present, observational evidence for the computed 60-90 km/s differential shifts is weak, but the data are limited by difficulties in comparing the proper motion of Type- II spicules, with spectral and kinematic properties of associated transition region and coronal emission lines. Future observations with the upcoming IRIS instrument should clarify if Doppler shifts are consistent with the dynamics modeled here.
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2012; v1 submitted 28 December, 2011;
originally announced December 2011.
-
Analysis of Seeing-Induced Polarization Cross-Talk and Modulation Scheme Performance
Authors:
Roberto Casini,
Alfred G. de Wijn,
Philip G. Judge
Abstract:
We analyze the generation of polarization cross-talk in Stokes polarimeters by atmospheric seeing, and its effects on the noise statistics of spectropolarimetric measurements for both single-beam and dual-beam instruments. We investigate the time evolution of seeing-induced correlations between different states of one modulation cycle, and compare the response to these correlations of two popular…
▽ More
We analyze the generation of polarization cross-talk in Stokes polarimeters by atmospheric seeing, and its effects on the noise statistics of spectropolarimetric measurements for both single-beam and dual-beam instruments. We investigate the time evolution of seeing-induced correlations between different states of one modulation cycle, and compare the response to these correlations of two popular polarization modulation schemes in a dual-beam system. Extension of the formalism to encompass an arbitrary number of modulation cycles enables us to compare our results with earlier work. Even though we discuss examples pertinent to solar physics, the general treatment of the subject and its fundamental results might be useful to a wider community.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2012; v1 submitted 2 July, 2011;
originally announced July 2011.
-
Thermal fine structure and magnetic fields in the solar atmosphere: spicules and fibrils
Authors:
Philip G. Judge,
Alexandra Tritschler,
Boon Chye Low
Abstract:
The relationship between observed structures in the solar atmosphere and the magnetic fields threading them is known only for the solar photosphere, even then imprecisely. We suggest that some of the fine structure in the more tenuous chromosphere and corona- specifically some populations of spicules and fibrils- correspond to warps in 2D sheet-like structures, as an alternative to conventional in…
▽ More
The relationship between observed structures in the solar atmosphere and the magnetic fields threading them is known only for the solar photosphere, even then imprecisely. We suggest that some of the fine structure in the more tenuous chromosphere and corona- specifically some populations of spicules and fibrils- correspond to warps in 2D sheet-like structures, as an alternative to conventional interpretations in terms of tube-like structures. The sheets are perhaps related to magnetic tangential discontinuities, which Parker has argued arise naturally in low-beta conditions. Some consequences of this suggestion, if it can be confirmed, are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
-
Discovery of a 1.6-year Magnetic Activity Cycle in the Exoplanet Host Star iota Horologii
Authors:
T. S. Metcalfe,
S. Basu,
T. J. Henry,
D. R. Soderblom,
P. G. Judge,
M. Knoelker,
S. Mathur,
M. Rempel
Abstract:
The Mount Wilson Ca HK survey revealed magnetic activity variations in a large sample of solar-type stars with timescales ranging from 2.5 to 25 years. This broad range of cycle periods is thought to reflect differences in the rotational properties and the depths of the surface convection zones for stars with various masses and ages. In 2007 we initiated a long-term monitoring campaign of Ca II H…
▽ More
The Mount Wilson Ca HK survey revealed magnetic activity variations in a large sample of solar-type stars with timescales ranging from 2.5 to 25 years. This broad range of cycle periods is thought to reflect differences in the rotational properties and the depths of the surface convection zones for stars with various masses and ages. In 2007 we initiated a long-term monitoring campaign of Ca II H and K emission for a sample of 57 southern solar-type stars to measure their magnetic activity cycles and their rotational properties when possible. We report the discovery of a 1.6-year magnetic activity cycle in the exoplanet host star iota Horologii, and we obtain an estimate of the rotation period that is consistent with Hyades membership. This is the shortest activity cycle so far measured for a solar-type star, and may be related to the short-timescale magnetic variations recently identified in the Sun and HD49933 from helio- and asteroseismic measurements. Future asteroseismic observations can be compared to those obtained near the magnetic minimum in 2006 to search for cycle-induced shifts in the oscillation frequencies. If such short activity cycles are common in F stars, then NASA's Kepler mission should observe their effects in many of its long-term asteroseismic targets.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2010; v1 submitted 27 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.
-
On the solar chromosphere observed at the limb with Hinode
Authors:
Philip G. Judge,
Mats Carlsson
Abstract:
Broad-band images in the Ca II H line, from the BFI instrument on the Hinode spacecraft, show emission from spicules emerging from and visible right down to the observed limb. Surprisingly, little absorption of spicule light is seen along their lengths. We present formal solutions to the transfer equation for given (ad-hoc) source functions, including a stratified chromosphere from which spicu…
▽ More
Broad-band images in the Ca II H line, from the BFI instrument on the Hinode spacecraft, show emission from spicules emerging from and visible right down to the observed limb. Surprisingly, little absorption of spicule light is seen along their lengths. We present formal solutions to the transfer equation for given (ad-hoc) source functions, including a stratified chromosphere from which spicules emanate. The model parameters are broadly compatible with earlier studies of spicules. The visibility of Ca II spicules down to the limb in Hinode data seems to require that spicule emission be Doppler shifted relative to the stratified atmosphere, either by supersonic turbulent or organized spicular motion. The non-spicule component of the chromosphere is almost invisible in the broad band BFI data, but we predict that it will be clearly visible in high spectral resolution data. Broad band Ca II H limb images give the false impression that the chromosphere is dominated by spicules. Our analysis serves as a reminder that the absence of a signature can be as significant as its presence.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2010;
originally announced April 2010.
-
Historical eclipses and the recent solar minimum corona
Authors:
P. G. Judge,
J. Burkepile,
G. de Toma,
M. Druckmueller
Abstract:
We have studied the corona as seen at the eclipses of 1878, 1900, 1901 and others. These eclipses occurred during extended sunspot minimum conditions. We compare these data with those of the recent solar minimum corona, using data from the eclipses of July 22 2009 and August 1 2008. An attempt to characterize the global solar magnetic fields is made. We speculate on the origin of the non-dipolar…
▽ More
We have studied the corona as seen at the eclipses of 1878, 1900, 1901 and others. These eclipses occurred during extended sunspot minimum conditions. We compare these data with those of the recent solar minimum corona, using data from the eclipses of July 22 2009 and August 1 2008. An attempt to characterize the global solar magnetic fields is made. We speculate on the origin of the non-dipolar structure seen in the 2008 and 2009 eclipse images.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2010;
originally announced January 2010.
-
The chromosphere: gateway to the corona, or the purgatory of solar physics?
Authors:
Philip G. Judge
Abstract:
I argue that one should attempt to understand the solar chromosphere not only for its own sake, but also if one is interested in the physics of: the corona; astrophysical dynamos; space weather; partially ionized plasmas; heliospheric UV radiation; the transition region. I outline curious observations which I personally find puzzling and deserving of attention.
I argue that one should attempt to understand the solar chromosphere not only for its own sake, but also if one is interested in the physics of: the corona; astrophysical dynamos; space weather; partially ionized plasmas; heliospheric UV radiation; the transition region. I outline curious observations which I personally find puzzling and deserving of attention.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2010;
originally announced January 2010.
-
Fabry-Perot versus slit spectropolarimetry of pores and active network. Analysis of IBIS and Hinode data
Authors:
P. G. Judge,
A. Tritschler,
H. Uitenbroek,
G. Cauzzi,
K. Reardon,
A. de Wijn
Abstract:
We discuss spectropolarimetric measurements of photospheric (Fe I 630.25 nm) and chromospheric (Ca II 854.21 nm) spectral lines. Our long-term goal is to diagnose properties of the magnetic field near the base of the corona. We compare ground-based two-dimensional spectropolarimetric measurements with (almost) simultaneous space-based slit spectropolarimetry. The ground-based observations were o…
▽ More
We discuss spectropolarimetric measurements of photospheric (Fe I 630.25 nm) and chromospheric (Ca II 854.21 nm) spectral lines. Our long-term goal is to diagnose properties of the magnetic field near the base of the corona. We compare ground-based two-dimensional spectropolarimetric measurements with (almost) simultaneous space-based slit spectropolarimetry. The ground-based observations were obtained May 20, 2008, with IBIS in spectropolarimetric mode, The space observations were obtained with the Spectro-Polarimeter aboard the HINODE satellite. The agreement between the near-simultaneous co-spatial IBIS and HINODE Stokes-V profiles at 630.25 nm is excellent, with V/I amplitudes compatible with to within 1 %. IBIS QU measurements are affected by residual crosstalk from V, arising from calibration inaccuracies, not from any inherent limitation of imaging spectroscopy. We use a PCA analysis to quantify the detected cross talk. Chromospheric magnetic fields are difficult to constrain by polarization of Ca II lines alone. However, we demonstrate that high cadence, high angular resolution monochromatic images of fibrils in Ca II and H-alpha, can be used to improve the magnetic field constraints, under conditions of high electrical conductivity. Such work is possible only with time series datasets from two-dimensional spectroscopic instruments under conditions of good seeing.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2010;
originally announced January 2010.
-
Coronal emission lines as thermometers
Authors:
Philip G Judge
Abstract:
Coronal emission line intensities are commonly used to measure electron temperatures using emission measure and/or line ratio methods. In the presence of systematic errors in atomic excitation calculations and data noise, the information on underlying temperature distributions is fundamentally limited. Increasing the number of emission lines used does not necessarily improve the ability to discr…
▽ More
Coronal emission line intensities are commonly used to measure electron temperatures using emission measure and/or line ratio methods. In the presence of systematic errors in atomic excitation calculations and data noise, the information on underlying temperature distributions is fundamentally limited. Increasing the number of emission lines used does not necessarily improve the ability to discriminate between different kinds of temperature distributions.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2009; v1 submitted 20 November, 2009;
originally announced November 2009.
-
Activity Cycles of Southern Asteroseismic Targets
Authors:
T. S. Metcalfe,
P. G. Judge,
S. Basu,
T. J. Henry,
D. R. Soderblom,
M. Knoelker,
M. Rempel
Abstract:
The Mount Wilson Ca HK survey revealed magnetic activity variations in a large sample of solar-type stars with timescales ranging from 2.5 to 25 years. This broad range of cycle periods is thought to reflect differences in the rotational properties and the depths of the surface convection zones for stars with various masses and ages. Asteroseismic data will soon provide direct measurements of th…
▽ More
The Mount Wilson Ca HK survey revealed magnetic activity variations in a large sample of solar-type stars with timescales ranging from 2.5 to 25 years. This broad range of cycle periods is thought to reflect differences in the rotational properties and the depths of the surface convection zones for stars with various masses and ages. Asteroseismic data will soon provide direct measurements of these quantities for individual stars, but many of the most promising targets are in the southern sky (e.g., alpha Cen A & B, beta Hyi, mu Ara, tau Cet, nu Ind), while long-term magnetic activity cycle surveys are largely confined to the north. In 2007 we began using the SMARTS 1.5-m telescope to conduct a long-term monitoring campaign of Ca II H & K emission for a sample of 57 southern solar-type stars to measure their magnetic activity cycles and their rotational properties when possible. This sample includes the most likely southern asteroseismic targets to be observed by the Stellar Oscillations Network Group (SONG), currently scheduled to begin operations in 2012. We present selected results from the first two years of the survey, and from the longer time baseline sampled by a single-epoch survey conducted in 1992.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
-
An explanation of the solar transition region
Authors:
Philip G. Judge
Abstract:
Prompted by high resolution observations, I propose an explanation for the 40+ year old problem of structure and energy balance in the solar transition region. The ingredients are simply cross-field diffusion of neutral atoms from cool threads extending into the corona, and the subsequent excitation, radiation and ionization of these atoms via electron impact. The processes occur whenever chromo…
▽ More
Prompted by high resolution observations, I propose an explanation for the 40+ year old problem of structure and energy balance in the solar transition region. The ingredients are simply cross-field diffusion of neutral atoms from cool threads extending into the corona, and the subsequent excitation, radiation and ionization of these atoms via electron impact. The processes occur whenever chromospheric plasma is adjacent to coronal plasma, and are efficient even when ion gyro-frequencies exceed collision frequencies. Cool threads - fibrils and spicules perhaps - grow slowly in thickness as a neutral, ionizing front expands across the magnetic field into coronal plasma. Radiative intensities estimated for H L$α$ are within an order of magnitude of those observed, with no ad-hoc parameters - only thermal parameters and geometric considerations are needed. I speculate that the subsequent dynamics of the diffused material might also explain observed properties of trace elements.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2008;
originally announced July 2008.
-
On the magnetic structure of the solar transition region
Authors:
Philip G. Judge,
Rebecca Centeno
Abstract:
We examine the hypothesis that ``cool loops'' dominate emission from solar transition region plasma below temperatures of $2\times10^5$K. We compare published VAULT images of H L$α$, a lower transition region line, with near-contemporaneous magnetograms from Kitt Peak, obtained during the second flight (VAULT-2) on 14 June 2002. The measured surface fields and potential extrapolations suggest th…
▽ More
We examine the hypothesis that ``cool loops'' dominate emission from solar transition region plasma below temperatures of $2\times10^5$K. We compare published VAULT images of H L$α$, a lower transition region line, with near-contemporaneous magnetograms from Kitt Peak, obtained during the second flight (VAULT-2) on 14 June 2002. The measured surface fields and potential extrapolations suggest that there are too few short loops, and that L$α$ emission is associated with the base regions of longer, coronal loops. VAULT-2 data of network boundaries have an asymmetry on scales larger than supergranules, also indicating an association with long loops. We complement the Kitt Peak data with very sensitive vector polarimetric data from the Spectro-Polarimeter on board Hinode, to determine the influence of very small magnetic concentrations on our analysis. From these data two classes of behavior are found: within the cores of strong magnetic flux concentrations ($> 5\times10^{18}$ Mx) associated with active network and plage, small-scale mixed fields are absent and any short loops can connect just the peripheries of the flux to cell interiors. Core fields return to the surface via longer, most likely coronal, loops. In weaker concentrations, short loops can connect between concentrations and produce mixed fields within network boundaries as suggested by Dowdy and colleagues. The VAULT-2 data which we examined are associated with strong concentrations. We conclude that the cool loop model applies only to a small fraction of the VAULT-2 emission, but we cannot discount a significant role for cool loops in quieter regions. We suggest a physical picture for how network L$α$ emission may occur through the cross-field diffusion of neutral atoms from chromospheric into coronal plasma.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2008;
originally announced May 2008.
-
Asteroseismic Signatures of Stellar Magnetic Activity Cycles
Authors:
T. S. Metcalfe,
W. A. Dziembowski,
P. G. Judge,
M. Snow
Abstract:
Observations of stellar activity cycles provide an opportunity to study magnetic dynamos under many different physical conditions. Space-based asteroseismology missions will soon yield useful constraints on the interior conditions that nurture such magnetic cycles, and will be sensitive enough to detect shifts in the oscillation frequencies due to the magnetic variations. We derive a method for…
▽ More
Observations of stellar activity cycles provide an opportunity to study magnetic dynamos under many different physical conditions. Space-based asteroseismology missions will soon yield useful constraints on the interior conditions that nurture such magnetic cycles, and will be sensitive enough to detect shifts in the oscillation frequencies due to the magnetic variations. We derive a method for predicting these shifts from changes in the Mg II activity index by scaling from solar data. We demonstrate this technique on the solar-type subgiant beta Hyi, using archival International Ultraviolet Explorer spectra and two epochs of ground-based asteroseismic observations. We find qualitative evidence of the expected frequency shifts and predict the optimal timing for future asteroseismic observations of this star.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2007;
originally announced April 2007.
-
SUMER Observations Confirm the Dynamic Nature of the Quiet Solar Outer Atmosphere: The Inter-network Chromosphere
Authors:
Mats Carlsson,
Philip G. Judge,
Klaus Wilhelm
Abstract:
On 12 March 1996 we obtained observations of the quiet Sun with the SUMER instrument. The observa- tions were sequences of 15-20 second exposures of ultraviolet emission line profiles and of the neighboring continua. These data contain signatures of the dynamics of the solar chromosphere that are uniquely useful because of wavelength coverage, moderate signal-to-noise ratios, and image stability…
▽ More
On 12 March 1996 we obtained observations of the quiet Sun with the SUMER instrument. The observa- tions were sequences of 15-20 second exposures of ultraviolet emission line profiles and of the neighboring continua. These data contain signatures of the dynamics of the solar chromosphere that are uniquely useful because of wavelength coverage, moderate signal-to-noise ratios, and image stability. The dominant observed phenomenon is an oscillatory behavior that is analogous to the 3 minute oscillations seen in Ca II lines. The oscillations appear to be coherent over 3-8". At any time they occur over approx. 50 % of the area studied, and they appear as large perturbations in the intensities of lines and continua. The oscillations are most clearly seen in intensity variations in the UV (lambda > 912 A) continua, and they are also seen in the intensities and velocities of chromospheric lines of C I, N I and O I. Intensity brightenings are accompanied by blueshifts of typically 5 km s$^{-1}$. Phase differences between continuum and line intensities also indicate the presence of upward propagating waves. Three minute intensity oscillations are occasionally seen in second spectra (C II 1335), but never in third spectra (C III and Si III). Third spectra and He I 584 show oscillations in velocity that are not simply related to the 3 minute oscillations. The continuum intensity variations are consistent with recent simulations of chromospheric dynamics (Carlsson & Stein 1994) while the line observations indicate that important ingredients are missing at higher layers in the simulations. The data show that time variations are crucial for our understanding of the chromosphere itself and for the spectral features formed there.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 1997;
originally announced June 1997.
