-
Measuring cosmic expansion with diffractive gravitational scintillation of nanoHertz gravitational waves
Authors:
Dylan L. Jow,
Ue-Li Pen
Abstract:
The recent discovery of ultra-long wavelength gravitational waves through the advent of pulsar timing arrays (PTA) has opened up new avenues for fundamental science. Here we show that every PTA source will be diffractively lensed by potentially hundreds of galactic disks transverse to its line of sight, leading to modest modulations in the strain, $Δh / h \sim 10^{-3} λ^{-1}_{1 \rm pc.}$, due to w…
▽ More
The recent discovery of ultra-long wavelength gravitational waves through the advent of pulsar timing arrays (PTA) has opened up new avenues for fundamental science. Here we show that every PTA source will be diffractively lensed by potentially hundreds of galactic disks transverse to its line of sight, leading to modest modulations in the strain, $Δh / h \sim 10^{-3} λ^{-1}_{1 \rm pc.}$, due to wave lensing effects. The induced interference, or scintillation, pattern will be resolvable by coherent PTAs and may be leveraged, alongside fore-ground redshift information, to make precise measurements of cosmic expansion. If future PTA experiments can achieve enough signal-to-noise to detect these small modulations, hundreds of redshift-distance pairs may be inferred from the diffractive lensing of an individual PTA source.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Crossing singularities in the saddle point approximation
Authors:
Job Feldbrugge,
Dylan L. Jow,
Ue-Li Pen
Abstract:
We describe a new phenomenon in the study of the real-time path integral, where complex classical paths hit singularities of the potential and need to be analytically continued beyond the space for which they solve the boundary value problem. We show that the behavior is universal and central to the problem of quantum tunneling. These analytically continued complex classical paths enrich the study…
▽ More
We describe a new phenomenon in the study of the real-time path integral, where complex classical paths hit singularities of the potential and need to be analytically continued beyond the space for which they solve the boundary value problem. We show that the behavior is universal and central to the problem of quantum tunneling. These analytically continued complex classical paths enrich the study of real-time Feynman path integrals.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Complex classical paths in quantum reflections and tunneling
Authors:
Job Feldbrugge,
Dylan L. Jow,
Ue-Li Pen
Abstract:
The real-time propagator of the symmetric Rosen-Morse, also known as the symmetric modified Pöschl-Teller, barrier is expressed in the Picard-Lefschetz path integral formalism using real and complex classical paths. We explain how the interference pattern in the real-time propagator and energy propagator is organized by caustics and Stoke's phenomena, and list the relevant real and complex classic…
▽ More
The real-time propagator of the symmetric Rosen-Morse, also known as the symmetric modified Pöschl-Teller, barrier is expressed in the Picard-Lefschetz path integral formalism using real and complex classical paths. We explain how the interference pattern in the real-time propagator and energy propagator is organized by caustics and Stoke's phenomena, and list the relevant real and complex classical paths as a function of the initial and final position. We discover the occurrence of singularity crossings, where the analytic continuation of the complex classical path no longer satisfies the boundary value problem and needs to be analytically continued. Moreover, we demonstrate how these singularity crossings play a central role in the real-time description of quantum tunneling.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Refractive lensing of scintillating FRBs by sub-parsec cloudlets in the multi-phase CGM
Authors:
Dylan L. Jow,
Xiaohan Wu,
Ue-Li Pen
Abstract:
We consider the refractive lensing effects of ionized cool ($T \sim 10^4\,{\rm K}$) gas cloudlets in the circumgalactic medium (CGM) of galaxies. In particular, we discuss the combined effects of lensing from these cloudlets and scintillation from plasma screens in the Milky Way interstellar medium (ISM). We show that, if the CGM comprises a mist of sub-parsec cloudlets with column densities of or…
▽ More
We consider the refractive lensing effects of ionized cool ($T \sim 10^4\,{\rm K}$) gas cloudlets in the circumgalactic medium (CGM) of galaxies. In particular, we discuss the combined effects of lensing from these cloudlets and scintillation from plasma screens in the Milky Way interstellar medium (ISM). We show that, if the CGM comprises a mist of sub-parsec cloudlets with column densities of order $10^{17}\,{\rm cm}^{-2}$ (as predicted by McCourt et al. (2018)), then FRBs whose sightlines pass within a virial radius of a CGM halo will generically be lensed into tens of refractive images with a $\sim 10\,{\rm ms}$ scattering timescale. These images will be resolved by scintillating screens in the Milky Way ISM, and therefore are expected to suppress scintillation. From this, we argue that positive detections of FRB scintillation can constrain the properties of these cool-gas cloudlets, with current scintillation observation disfavouring the cloudlet model. We propose that sheet-like geometries for the cool gas in the CGM can reconcile quasar absorption measurements (from which we infer the presence of the cool gas with structure on sub-parsec scales) and the unexpected lack of lensing signals from this gas thus far observed.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Scintillated microlensing: measuring cosmic distances with fast radio bursts
Authors:
Anna Tsai,
Dylan L. Jow,
Daniel Baker,
Ue-Li Pen
Abstract:
We propose a novel means of directly measuring cosmological distances using scintillated microlensing of fast radio bursts (FRBs). In standard strong lensing measurements of cosmic expansion, the main source of systematic uncertainty lies in modeling the mass profile of galactic halos. Using extra-galactic stellar microlensing to measure the Hubble constant avoids this systematic uncertainty as th…
▽ More
We propose a novel means of directly measuring cosmological distances using scintillated microlensing of fast radio bursts (FRBs). In standard strong lensing measurements of cosmic expansion, the main source of systematic uncertainty lies in modeling the mass profile of galactic halos. Using extra-galactic stellar microlensing to measure the Hubble constant avoids this systematic uncertainty as the lens potential of microlenses depends only on a single parameter: the mass of the lens. FRBs, which may achieve nanosecond precision on lensing time delays, are well-suited to precision measurements of stellar microlensing, for which the time delays are on the order of milliseconds. However, typical angular separations between the microlensed images on the order of microarcseconds make the individual images impossible to spatially resolve with ground-based telescopes. We propose leveraging scintillation in the ISM to resolve the microlensed images, effectively turning the ISM into an astrophysical-scale interferometer. Using this technique, we estimate a 6\% uncertainty on $H_0$ from a single observed scintillated microlensing event, with a sub-percent uncertainty on $H_0$ achievable with only 30 such events. With an optical depth for stellar microlensing of $10^{-3}$, this may be achievable in the near future with upcoming FRB telescopes.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2024; v1 submitted 18 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Wave Mechanics, Interference, and Decoherence in Strong Gravitational Lensing
Authors:
Calvin Leung,
Dylan Jow,
Prasenjit Saha,
Liang Dai,
Masamune Oguri,
Léon V. E. Koopmans
Abstract:
Wave-mechanical effects in gravitational lensing have long been predicted, and with the discovery of populations of compact transients such as gravitational wave events and fast radio bursts, may soon be observed. We present an observer's review of the relevant theory underlying wave-mechanical effects in gravitational lensing. Starting from the curved-spacetime scalar wave equation, we derive the…
▽ More
Wave-mechanical effects in gravitational lensing have long been predicted, and with the discovery of populations of compact transients such as gravitational wave events and fast radio bursts, may soon be observed. We present an observer's review of the relevant theory underlying wave-mechanical effects in gravitational lensing. Starting from the curved-spacetime scalar wave equation, we derive the Fresnel-Kirchoff diffraction integral, and analyze it in the eikonal and wave optics regimes. We answer the question of what makes interference effects observable in some systems but not in others, and how interference effects allow for complementary information to be extracted from lensing systems as compared to traditional measurements. We end by discussing how diffraction effects affect optical depth forecasts and lensing near caustics, and how compact, low-frequency transients like gravitational waves and fast radio bursts provide promising paths to open up the frontier of interferometric gravitational lensing.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
On the cusp of cusps: a universal model for extreme scattering events in the ISM
Authors:
Dylan L. Jow,
Ue-Li Pen,
Daniel Baker
Abstract:
The scattering structures in the ISM responsible for so-called ``extreme scattering events" (ESEs), observed in quasars and pulsars, remain enigmatic. Current models struggle to explain the high-frequency light curves of ESEs, and a recent analysis of a double lensing event in PSR\,B0834+06 reveals features of ESEs that may also be challenging to accommodate via existing models. We propose that th…
▽ More
The scattering structures in the ISM responsible for so-called ``extreme scattering events" (ESEs), observed in quasars and pulsars, remain enigmatic. Current models struggle to explain the high-frequency light curves of ESEs, and a recent analysis of a double lensing event in PSR\,B0834+06 reveals features of ESEs that may also be challenging to accommodate via existing models. We propose that these features arise naturally when the lens has a cusp-like profile, described by the elementary $A_3$ cusp catastrophe. This is an extension of previous work describing pulsar scintillation as arising from $A_2$ fold catastrophes in thin, corrugated plasma sheets along the line of sight. We call this framework of describing the lens potentials via elementary catastrophes ``doubly catastrophic lensing", as catastrophes (e.g. folds and cusps) have long been used to describe universal features in the light curves of lensing events that generically manifest, regardless of the precise details of the lens. Here, we argue that the lenses themselves may be described by these same elementary structures. If correct, the doubly catastrophic lensing framework would provide a unified description of scintillation and ESEs, where the lenses responsible for these scattering phenomena are universal and can be fully described by a small number of unfolding parameters. This could enable their application as giant cosmic lenses for precision measurements of coherent sources, including FRBs and pulsars.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2024; v1 submitted 19 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Plasma lensing near the eclipses of the Black Widow pulsar B1957+20
Authors:
Fang Xi Lin,
Robert Main,
Dylan Jow,
Dongzi Li,
Ue-Li Pen,
Marten H. van Kerkwijk
Abstract:
Recently, several eclipsing millisecond pulsars have been shown to experience strong and apparent weak lensing from the outflow of their ionized companions. Lensing can be a powerful probe of the ionized plasma, with the strongest lenses potentially resolving emission regions of pulsars. Understanding lensing in the `laboratory-like' conditions of an eclipsing pulsar may be analogously applied to…
▽ More
Recently, several eclipsing millisecond pulsars have been shown to experience strong and apparent weak lensing from the outflow of their ionized companions. Lensing can be a powerful probe of the ionized plasma, with the strongest lenses potentially resolving emission regions of pulsars. Understanding lensing in the `laboratory-like' conditions of an eclipsing pulsar may be analogously applied to fast radio bursts, many of which reside in dense, magnetized environments. We examined variable dispersion measure (DM), absorption, scattering, and flux density in the original Black Widow pulsar PSR B1957+20 through an eclipse at the Arecibo Observatory at 327 MHz. We discovered clear evidence of the two regimes of lensing, strong and apparent weak. We show that the flux density variations in the apparently weak lensing regime can be modeled directly from variations of DM, using geometric optics. The mean effective velocities in the ingress, $954\pm 99$ km/s, and egress $604\pm 47$ km/s cannot be explained by orbital motions alone, but are consistent with significant outflow velocity of material from the companion. We also show that geometric optics can predict when and where the lensing regime-change between weak and strong occurs, and argue that the apparent weak lensing is due to averaging many images. Our framework can be applied in any source with variable electron columns, measuring their relative velocities and distances. In other eclipsing pulsars, this provides a unique opportunity to measure companion outflow velocity, predict regions of weak and strong lensing, and in principle independently constrain orbital inclinations.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2022; v1 submitted 29 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Regimes in astrophysical lensing: refractive optics, diffractive optics, and the Fresnel scale
Authors:
Dylan L. Jow,
Ue-Li Pen,
Job Feldbrugge
Abstract:
Astrophysical lensing has typically been studied in two regimes: diffractive optics and refractive optics. Diffractive optics is characterized by a perturbative expansion of the Kirchhoff-Fresnel diffraction integral, while refractive optics is characterized by the stationary phase approximation. Previously, it has been assumed that the Fresnel scale, $R_F$ , is the relevant physical scale that se…
▽ More
Astrophysical lensing has typically been studied in two regimes: diffractive optics and refractive optics. Diffractive optics is characterized by a perturbative expansion of the Kirchhoff-Fresnel diffraction integral, while refractive optics is characterized by the stationary phase approximation. Previously, it has been assumed that the Fresnel scale, $R_F$ , is the relevant physical scale that separates these two regimes. With the recent introduction of Picard-Lefschetz theory to the field of lensing, it has become possible to generalize the refractive description of discrete images to all wave parameters, and, in particular, exactly evaluate the diffraction integral at all frequencies. In this work, we assess the regimes of validity of refractive and diffractive approximations for a simple one-dimensional lens model through comparison with this exact evaluation. We find that, contrary to previous assumptions, the true separation scale between these regimes is given by $R_F / \sqrtκ$, where $κ$ is the convergence of the lens. Thus, when the lens is strong, refractive optics can hold for arbitrarily small scales. We also argue that intensity variations in diffractive optics are generically small, which has implications for the study of strong diffractive scintillation (DISS).
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2023; v1 submitted 25 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Measuring lens dimensionality in extreme scattering events through wave optics
Authors:
Dylan L. Jow,
Ue-Li Pen
Abstract:
Compact radio sources have been observed to undergo large, frequency dependent changes in intensity due to lensing by structures in the interstellar medium, in so-called "extreme scattering events" (ESEs). While the study of astrophysical plasma lensing has primarily focused on the geometric limit of optics, coherent radio sources such as pulsars exhibit wave effects when lensed. The additional ph…
▽ More
Compact radio sources have been observed to undergo large, frequency dependent changes in intensity due to lensing by structures in the interstellar medium, in so-called "extreme scattering events" (ESEs). While the study of astrophysical plasma lensing has primarily focused on the geometric limit of optics, coherent radio sources such as pulsars exhibit wave effects when lensed. The additional phase information provided by interference effects in the wave regime may yield more information about the lens than could be obtained in the geometric regime. In this paper, we show that, using wave effects, one can potentially distinguish a one-dimensional lens (where "one-dimensional" includes both highly elongated lenses, as well as perfectly axisymmetric lenses) from a fully two-dimensional lens, with minimal assumptions on the form of the lensing potential.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2022; v1 submitted 13 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Imaginary images and Stokes phenomena in the weak plasma lensing of coherent sources
Authors:
Dylan L. Jow,
Fang Xi Lin,
Emily Tyhurst,
Ue-Li Pen
Abstract:
The study of astrophysical plasma lensing, such as in the case of extreme scattering events, has typically been conducted using the geometric limit of optics, neglecting wave effects. However, for the lensing of coherent sources such as pulsars and fast radio bursts (FRBs), wave effects can play an important role. Asymptotic methods, such as the so-called Eikonal limit, also known as the stationar…
▽ More
The study of astrophysical plasma lensing, such as in the case of extreme scattering events, has typically been conducted using the geometric limit of optics, neglecting wave effects. However, for the lensing of coherent sources such as pulsars and fast radio bursts (FRBs), wave effects can play an important role. Asymptotic methods, such as the so-called Eikonal limit, also known as the stationary phase approximation, have been used to include first-order wave effects; however, these methods fail at Stokes lines. Stokes lines are generic features of a variety of lens models, and are regions in parameter space where imaginary images begin to contribute to the overall intensity modulation of lensed sources. Using the mathematical framework of Picard-Lefschetz theory to compute diffraction integrals, we argue that these imaginary images contain as much information as their geometric counterparts, and may potentially be observable in data. Thus, weak-lensing events where these imaginary images are present can be as useful for inferring lens parameters as strong-lensing events in which multiple geometric images are present.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2021; v1 submitted 15 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Wave effects in the microlensing of pulsars and FRBs by point masses
Authors:
Dylan L. Jow,
Simon Foreman,
Ue-Li Pen,
Wei Zhu
Abstract:
Wave effects are often neglected in microlensing studies; however, for coherent point-like sources, such as pulsars and fast radio bursts (FRBs), wave effects will become important in their gravitational lensing. In this paper, we describe the wave optics formalism, its various limits, and the conditions for which these limits hold. Using the simple point lens as an example, we will show that the…
▽ More
Wave effects are often neglected in microlensing studies; however, for coherent point-like sources, such as pulsars and fast radio bursts (FRBs), wave effects will become important in their gravitational lensing. In this paper, we describe the wave optics formalism, its various limits, and the conditions for which these limits hold. Using the simple point lens as an example, we will show that the frequency dependence of wave effects breaks degeneracies that are present in the usual geometric optics limit, and constructive interference results in larger magnifications further from the lens. This latter fact leads to a generic increase in cross section for microlensing events in the wave-optics regime compared to the geometric optics regime. For realistic percent-level spectral sensitivities, this leads to a relative boost in lensing cross section of more than an order of magnitude. We apply the point-lens model to the lensing of FRBs and pulsars and find that these radio sources will be lensed in the full wave-optics regime by isolated masses in the range of $0.1-100\,M_\oplus$, which includes free-floating planets (FFPs), whose Einstein radius is smaller than the Fresnel scale. More generally, the interference pattern allows an instantaneous determination of lens masses, unlike traditional microlensing techniques which only yield a mass inference from the event timescale.
△ Less
Submitted 13 July, 2020; v1 submitted 4 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Re-evaluating evidence for Hawking points in the CMB
Authors:
Dylan L. Jow,
Douglas Scott
Abstract:
We investigate recent claims for a detection of "Hawking points" (positions on the sky with unusually large temperature gradients between rings) in the cosmic microwave background (CMB) temperature maps at the 99.98% confidence level. We find that, after marginalization over the size of the rings, an excess is detected in Planck satellite maps at only an 87% confidence level (i.e., little more tha…
▽ More
We investigate recent claims for a detection of "Hawking points" (positions on the sky with unusually large temperature gradients between rings) in the cosmic microwave background (CMB) temperature maps at the 99.98% confidence level. We find that, after marginalization over the size of the rings, an excess is detected in Planck satellite maps at only an 87% confidence level (i.e., little more than 1$σ$). Therefore, we conclude that there is no statistically significant evidence for the presence of Hawking points in the CMB.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2020; v1 submitted 20 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Taller in the saddle: constraining CMB physics using saddle points
Authors:
Dylan L. Jow,
Dagoberto Contreras,
Douglas Scott,
Emory F. Bunn
Abstract:
The statistics of extremal points in the cosmic microwave background (CMB) temperature (hot and cold spots) have been well explored in the literature, and have been used to constrain models of the early Universe. Here, we extend the study of critical points in the CMB to the set that remains after removing extrema, namely the saddle points. We perform stacks of temperature and polarization about t…
▽ More
The statistics of extremal points in the cosmic microwave background (CMB) temperature (hot and cold spots) have been well explored in the literature, and have been used to constrain models of the early Universe. Here, we extend the study of critical points in the CMB to the set that remains after removing extrema, namely the saddle points. We perform stacks of temperature and polarization about temperature saddle points in simulations of the CMB, as well as in data from the Planck satellite. We then compute the theoretical profile of saddle-point stacks, given the underlying power spectra of the CMB. As an example of the utility of such stacks, we constrain models of cosmic birefringence, and compare the constraining power of the saddle points with that of extremal points. We find that, in the specific example of birefringence, we can place tighter constraints using saddle points in our analysis than using extrema. In fact, we find our saddle-point analysis yields close to optimal constraints, as seen by comparing to a power spectrum analysis. We, therefore, suggest that stacking on saddle points may, in general, be a useful way of testing for non-standard physics effects that change the CMB power spectra.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2019; v1 submitted 13 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
An application of an optimal statistic for characterising relative orientations
Authors:
Dylan L. Jow,
Ryley Hill,
Douglas Scott,
J. D. Soler,
P. G. Martin,
M. J. Devlin,
L. M. Fissel,
F. Poidevin
Abstract:
We present the projected Rayleigh statistic (PRS), a modification of the classic Rayleigh statistic, as a test for non-uniform relative orientation between two pseudo-vector fields. In the application here this gives an effective way of investigating whether polarization pseudo-vectors (spin-2 quantities) are preferentially parallel or perpendicular to filaments in the interstellar medium. For exa…
▽ More
We present the projected Rayleigh statistic (PRS), a modification of the classic Rayleigh statistic, as a test for non-uniform relative orientation between two pseudo-vector fields. In the application here this gives an effective way of investigating whether polarization pseudo-vectors (spin-2 quantities) are preferentially parallel or perpendicular to filaments in the interstellar medium. For example, there are other potential applications in astrophysics, e.g., when comparing small-scale orientations with larger-scale shear patterns. We compare the efficiency of the PRS against histogram binning methods that have previously been used for characterising the relative orientations of gas column density structures with the magnetic field projected on the plane of the sky. We examine data for the Vela C molecular cloud, where the column density is inferred from Herschel submillimetre observations, and the magnetic field from observations by the Balloon-borne Large-Aperture Submillimetre Telescope in the 250-, 350-, and 500-μm wavelength bands. We find that the PRS has greater statistical power than approaches that bin the relative orientation angles, as it makes more efficient use of the information contained in the data. In particular, the use of the PRS to test for preferential alignment results in a higher statistical significance, in each of the four Vela C regions, with the greatest increase being by a factor 1.3 in the South-Nest region in the 250-μm band.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2017; v1 submitted 14 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
