-
Unifying F1TENTH Autonomous Racing: Survey, Methods and Benchmarks
Authors:
Benjamin David Evans,
Raphael Trumpp,
Marco Caccamo,
Felix Jahncke,
Johannes Betz,
Hendrik Willem Jordaan,
Herman Arnold Engelbrecht
Abstract:
The F1TENTH autonomous driving platform, consisting of 1:10-scale remote-controlled cars, has evolved into a well-established education and research platform. The many publications and real-world competitions span many domains, from classical path planning to novel learning-based algorithms. Consequently, the field is wide and disjointed, hindering direct comparison of developed methods and making…
▽ More
The F1TENTH autonomous driving platform, consisting of 1:10-scale remote-controlled cars, has evolved into a well-established education and research platform. The many publications and real-world competitions span many domains, from classical path planning to novel learning-based algorithms. Consequently, the field is wide and disjointed, hindering direct comparison of developed methods and making it difficult to assess the state-of-the-art. Therefore, we aim to unify the field by surveying current approaches, describing common methods, and providing benchmark results to facilitate clear comparisons and establish a baseline for future work. This research aims to survey past and current work with F1TENTH vehicles in the classical and learning categories and explain the different solution approaches. We describe particle filter localisation, trajectory optimisation and tracking, model predictive contouring control, follow-the-gap, and end-to-end reinforcement learning. We provide an open-source evaluation of benchmark methods and investigate overlooked factors of control frequency and localisation accuracy for classical methods as well as reward signal and training map for learning methods. The evaluation shows that the optimisation and tracking method achieves the fastest lap times, followed by the online planning approach. Finally, our work identifies and outlines the relevant research aspects to help motivate future work in the F1TENTH domain.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2024; v1 submitted 28 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
High-performance Racing on Unmapped Tracks using Local Maps
Authors:
Benjamin David Evans,
Hendrik Willem Jordaan,
Herman Arnold Engelbrecht
Abstract:
Map-based methods for autonomous racing estimate the vehicle's location, which is used to follow a high-level plan. While map-based optimisation methods demonstrate high-performance results, they are limited by requiring a map of the environment. In contrast, mapless methods can operate in unmapped contexts since they directly process raw sensor data (often LiDAR) to calculate commands. However, a…
▽ More
Map-based methods for autonomous racing estimate the vehicle's location, which is used to follow a high-level plan. While map-based optimisation methods demonstrate high-performance results, they are limited by requiring a map of the environment. In contrast, mapless methods can operate in unmapped contexts since they directly process raw sensor data (often LiDAR) to calculate commands. However, a major limitation in mapless methods is poor performance due to a lack of optimisation. In response, we propose the local map framework that uses easily extractable, low-level features to build local maps of the visible region that form the input to optimisation-based controllers. Our local map generation extracts the visible racetrack boundaries and calculates a centreline and track widths used for planning. We evaluate our method for simulated F1Tenth autonomous racing using a two-stage trajectory optimisation and tracking strategy and a model predictive controller. Our method achieves lap times that are 8.8% faster than the Follow-The-Gap method and 3.22% faster than end-to-end neural networks due to the optimisation resulting in a faster speed profile. The local map planner is 3.28% slower than global methods that have access to an entire map of the track that can be used for planning. Critically, our approach enables high-speed autonomous racing on unmapped tracks, achieving performance similar to global methods without requiring a track map.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Partial End-to-end Reinforcement Learning for Robustness Against Modelling Error in Autonomous Racing
Authors:
Andrew Murdoch,
Johannes Cornelius Schoeman,
Hendrik Willem Jordaan
Abstract:
In this paper, we address the issue of increasing the performance of reinforcement learning (RL) solutions for autonomous racing cars when navigating under conditions where practical vehicle modelling errors (commonly known as \emph{model mismatches}) are present. To address this challenge, we propose a partial end-to-end algorithm that decouples the planning and control tasks. Within this framewo…
▽ More
In this paper, we address the issue of increasing the performance of reinforcement learning (RL) solutions for autonomous racing cars when navigating under conditions where practical vehicle modelling errors (commonly known as \emph{model mismatches}) are present. To address this challenge, we propose a partial end-to-end algorithm that decouples the planning and control tasks. Within this framework, an RL agent generates a trajectory comprising a path and velocity, which is subsequently tracked using a pure pursuit steering controller and a proportional velocity controller, respectively. In contrast, many current learning-based (i.e., reinforcement and imitation learning) algorithms utilise an end-to-end approach whereby a deep neural network directly maps from sensor data to control commands. By leveraging the robustness of a classical controller, our partial end-to-end driving algorithm exhibits better robustness towards model mismatches than standard end-to-end algorithms.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
High-speed Autonomous Racing using Trajectory-aided Deep Reinforcement Learning
Authors:
Benjamin David Evans,
Herman Arnold Engelbrecht,
Hendrik Willem Jordaan
Abstract:
The classical method of autonomous racing uses real-time localisation to follow a precalculated optimal trajectory. In contrast, end-to-end deep reinforcement learning (DRL) can train agents to race using only raw LiDAR scans. While classical methods prioritise optimization for high-performance racing, DRL approaches have focused on low-performance contexts with little consideration of the speed p…
▽ More
The classical method of autonomous racing uses real-time localisation to follow a precalculated optimal trajectory. In contrast, end-to-end deep reinforcement learning (DRL) can train agents to race using only raw LiDAR scans. While classical methods prioritise optimization for high-performance racing, DRL approaches have focused on low-performance contexts with little consideration of the speed profile. This work addresses the problem of using end-to-end DRL agents for high-speed autonomous racing. We present trajectory-aided learning (TAL) that trains DRL agents for high-performance racing by incorporating the optimal trajectory (racing line) into the learning formulation. Our method is evaluated using the TD3 algorithm on four maps in the open-source F1Tenth simulator. The results demonstrate that our method achieves a significantly higher lap completion rate at high speeds compared to the baseline. This is due to TAL training the agent to select a feasible speed profile of slowing down in the corners and roughly tracking the optimal trajectory.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Bypassing the Simulation-to-reality Gap: Online Reinforcement Learning using a Supervisor
Authors:
Benjamin David Evans,
Johannes Betz,
Hongrui Zheng,
Herman A. Engelbrecht,
Rahul Mangharam,
Hendrik W. Jordaan
Abstract:
Deep reinforcement learning (DRL) is a promising method to learn control policies for robots only from demonstration and experience. To cover the whole dynamic behaviour of the robot, DRL training is an active exploration process typically performed in simulation environments. Although this simulation training is cheap and fast, applying DRL algorithms to real-world settings is difficult. If agent…
▽ More
Deep reinforcement learning (DRL) is a promising method to learn control policies for robots only from demonstration and experience. To cover the whole dynamic behaviour of the robot, DRL training is an active exploration process typically performed in simulation environments. Although this simulation training is cheap and fast, applying DRL algorithms to real-world settings is difficult. If agents are trained until they perform safely in simulation, transferring them to physical systems is difficult due to the sim-to-real gap caused by the difference between the simulation dynamics and the physical robot. In this paper, we present a method of online training a DRL agent to drive autonomously on a physical vehicle by using a model-based safety supervisor. Our solution uses a supervisory system to check if the action selected by the agent is safe or unsafe and ensure that a safe action is always implemented on the vehicle. With this, we can bypass the sim-to-real problem while training the DRL algorithm safely, quickly, and efficiently. We compare our method with conventional learning in simulation and on a physical vehicle. We provide a variety of real-world experiments where we train online a small-scale vehicle to drive autonomously with no prior simulation training. The evaluation results show that our method trains agents with improved sample efficiency while never crashing, and the trained agents demonstrate better driving performance than those trained in simulation.
△ Less
Submitted 13 July, 2023; v1 submitted 22 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Reward Signal Design for Autonomous Racing
Authors:
Benjamin Evans,
Herman A. Engelbrecht,
Hendrik W. Jordaan
Abstract:
Reinforcement learning (RL) has shown to be a valuable tool in training neural networks for autonomous motion planning. The application of RL to a specific problem is dependent on a reward signal to quantify how good or bad a certain action is. This paper addresses the problem of reward signal design for robotic control in the context of local planning for autonomous racing. We aim to design rewar…
▽ More
Reinforcement learning (RL) has shown to be a valuable tool in training neural networks for autonomous motion planning. The application of RL to a specific problem is dependent on a reward signal to quantify how good or bad a certain action is. This paper addresses the problem of reward signal design for robotic control in the context of local planning for autonomous racing. We aim to design reward signals that are able to perform well in multiple, competing, continuous metrics. Three different methodologies of position-based, velocity-based, and action-based rewards are considered and evaluated in the context of F1/10th racing. A novel method of rewarding the agent on its state relative to an optimal trajectory is presented. Agents are trained and tested in simulation and the behaviors generated by the reward signals are compared to each other on the basis of average lap time and completion rate. The results indicate that a reward based on the distance and velocity relative to a minimum curvature trajectory produces the fastest lap times.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2021; v1 submitted 18 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Learning the Subsystem of Local Planning for Autonomous Racing
Authors:
Benjamin Evans,
Hendrik W. Jordaan,
Herman A. Engelbrecht
Abstract:
The problem of autonomous racing is to navigate through a race course as quickly as possible while not colliding with any obstacles. We approach the autonomous racing problem with the added constraint of not maintaining an updated obstacle map of the environment. Several current approaches to this problem use end-to-end learning systems where an agent replaces the entire navigation pipeline. This…
▽ More
The problem of autonomous racing is to navigate through a race course as quickly as possible while not colliding with any obstacles. We approach the autonomous racing problem with the added constraint of not maintaining an updated obstacle map of the environment. Several current approaches to this problem use end-to-end learning systems where an agent replaces the entire navigation pipeline. This paper presents a hierarchical planning architecture that combines a high level planner and path following system with a reinforcement learning agent that learns that subsystem of obstacle avoidance.
The novel "modification planner" uses the path follower to track the global plan and the deep reinforcement learning agent to modify the references generated by the path follower to avoid obstacles. Importantly, our architecture does not require an updated obstacle map and only 10 laser range finders to avoid obstacles. The modification planner is evaluated in the context of F1/10th autonomous racing and compared to a end-to-end learning baseline, the Follow the Gap Method and an optimisation based planner. The results show that the modification planner can achieve faster average times compared to the baseline end-to-end planner and a 94% success rate which is similar to the baseline.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2021; v1 submitted 22 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Gyro-Control of a Solar Sailing Satellite
Authors:
Hendrik Willem Jordaan,
Willem Herman Steyn
Abstract:
Recent successes in the deployment of sails in space have reduced the risk associated with solar sailing missions. The attitude control requirements for a solar sailing mission is low with only slow attitude maneuvers needed to maintain a stable attitude and produce a required solar thrust. Future science missions will require large attitude maneuvers with a fully deployed sail. This article inves…
▽ More
Recent successes in the deployment of sails in space have reduced the risk associated with solar sailing missions. The attitude control requirements for a solar sailing mission is low with only slow attitude maneuvers needed to maintain a stable attitude and produce a required solar thrust. Future science missions will require large attitude maneuvers with a fully deployed sail. This article investigates the current options for attitude control on solar sails and proposes a gyro-controlled solar sailing. This concept uses a spinning solar sail to construct a control moment gyroscope capable to produce large torques. Steering laws for performing attitude maneuvers and simulation results are presented which demonstrates the capabilities of such a solution.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
