-
Proportional Consistency of Apportionment Methods
Authors:
Michael A. Jones,
David McCune,
Jennifer M. Wilson
Abstract:
We analyze a little-known property of apportionment methods that captures how allocations scale with the size of the house: specifically, if, for a fixed population distribution, the house size and allocation can be scaled down within the set of integers, then the apportionment should be correspondingly scaled down. Balinski and Young (2001) include this property among the minimal requirements for…
▽ More
We analyze a little-known property of apportionment methods that captures how allocations scale with the size of the house: specifically, if, for a fixed population distribution, the house size and allocation can be scaled down within the set of integers, then the apportionment should be correspondingly scaled down. Balinski and Young (2001) include this property among the minimal requirements for a "reasonable" apportionment method. We argue that this property is better understood as a consistency requirement since quota-based apportionments that are "less proportional" meet this requirement while others that are "more proportional" do not. We also show that the family of quotatone methods based on stationary divisors (including the quota method) do not satisfy this property.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Precision ground-state energy calculation for the water molecule on a superconducting quantum processor
Authors:
Michael A. Jones,
Harish J. Vallury,
Lloyd C. L. Hollenberg
Abstract:
The accurate computation of properties of large molecular systems is classically infeasible and is one of the applications in which it is hoped that quantum computers will demonstrate an advantage over classical devices. However, due to the limitations of present-day quantum hardware, variational-hybrid algorithms introduced to tackle these problems struggle to meet the accuracy and precision requ…
▽ More
The accurate computation of properties of large molecular systems is classically infeasible and is one of the applications in which it is hoped that quantum computers will demonstrate an advantage over classical devices. However, due to the limitations of present-day quantum hardware, variational-hybrid algorithms introduced to tackle these problems struggle to meet the accuracy and precision requirements of chemical applications. Here, we apply the Quantum Computed Moments (QCM) approach combined with a variety of noise-mitigation techniques to an 8 qubit/spin-orbital representation of the water molecule (H$_2$O). A noise-stable improvement on the variational result for a 4-excitation trial-state (circuit depth 25, 22 CNOTs) was obtained, with the ground-state energy computed to be within $1.4\pm1.2$ mHa of exact diagonalisation in the 14 spin-orbital basis. Thus, the QCM approach, despite an increased number of measurements and noisy quantum hardware (CNOT error rates c.1% corresponding to expected error rates on the trial-state circuit of order 20%), is able to determine the ground-state energy of a non-trivial molecular system at the required accuracy (c.0.1%). To the best of our knowledge, these results are the largest calculations performed on a physical quantum computer to date in terms of encoding individual spin-orbitals producing chemically relevant accuracy, and a promising indicator of how such hybrid approaches might scale to problems of interest in the low-error/fault-tolerant regimes as quantum computers develop.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Noise-robust ground state energy estimates from deep quantum circuits
Authors:
Harish J. Vallury,
Michael A. Jones,
Gregory A. L. White,
Floyd M. Creevey,
Charles D. Hill,
Lloyd C. L. Hollenberg
Abstract:
In the lead up to fault tolerance, the utility of quantum computing will be determined by how adequately the effects of noise can be circumvented in quantum algorithms. Hybrid quantum-classical algorithms such as the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) have been designed for the short-term regime. However, as problems scale, VQE results are generally scrambled by noise on present-day hardware. W…
▽ More
In the lead up to fault tolerance, the utility of quantum computing will be determined by how adequately the effects of noise can be circumvented in quantum algorithms. Hybrid quantum-classical algorithms such as the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) have been designed for the short-term regime. However, as problems scale, VQE results are generally scrambled by noise on present-day hardware. While error mitigation techniques alleviate these issues to some extent, there is a pressing need to develop algorithmic approaches with higher robustness to noise. Here, we explore the robustness properties of the recently introduced quantum computed moments (QCM) approach to ground state energy problems, and show through an analytic example how the underlying energy estimate explicitly filters out incoherent noise. Motivated by this observation, we implement QCM for a model of quantum magnetism on IBM Quantum hardware to examine the noise-filtering effect with increasing circuit depth. We find that QCM maintains a remarkably high degree of error robustness where VQE completely fails. On instances of the quantum magnetism model up to 20 qubits for ultra-deep trial state circuits of up to ~500 CNOTs, QCM is still able to extract reasonable energy estimates. The observation is bolstered by an extensive set of experimental results. To match these results, VQE would need hardware improvement by some 2 orders of magnitude on error rates.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2023; v1 submitted 16 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Chemistry beyond the Hartree-Fock limit via quantum computed moments
Authors:
Michael A. Jones,
Harish J. Vallury,
Charles D. Hill,
Lloyd C. L. Hollenberg
Abstract:
Quantum computers hold promise to circumvent the limitations of conventional computing for difficult molecular problems. However, the accumulation of quantum logic errors on real devices represents a major challenge, particularly in the pursuit of chemical accuracy requiring the inclusion of dynamical effects. In this work we implement the quantum computed moments (QCM) approach for hydrogen chain…
▽ More
Quantum computers hold promise to circumvent the limitations of conventional computing for difficult molecular problems. However, the accumulation of quantum logic errors on real devices represents a major challenge, particularly in the pursuit of chemical accuracy requiring the inclusion of dynamical effects. In this work we implement the quantum computed moments (QCM) approach for hydrogen chain molecular systems up to H$_6$. On a superconducting quantum processor, Hamiltonian moments, $\langle \mathcal{H}^p\rangle$ are computed with respect to the Hartree-Fock state, which are then employed in Lanczos expansion theory to determine an estimate for the ground-state energy which incorporates electronic correlations and manifestly improves on the variational result. Post-processing purification of the raw QCM data takes the estimate through the Hartree-Fock variational limit to within 99.9% of the exact electronic ground-state energy for the largest system studied, H$_6$. Calculated dissociation curves indicate precision at about 10mH for this system and as low as 0.1mH for molecular hydrogen, H$_2$, over a range of bond lengths. In the context of stringent precision requirements for chemical problems, these results provide strong evidence for the error suppression capability of the QCM method, particularly when coupled with post-processing error mitigation. Greater emphasis on more efficient representations of the Hamiltonian and classical preprocessing steps may enable the solution of larger systems on near-term quantum processors.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
A Mechanism Design Approach to Allocating Travel Funds
Authors:
Michael A. Jones
Abstract:
I explain how faculty members could exploit a method to allocate travel funds and how to use game theory to design a method that cannot be manipulated.
I explain how faculty members could exploit a method to allocate travel funds and how to use game theory to design a method that cannot be manipulated.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Quantum computed moments correction to variational estimates
Authors:
Harish J. Vallury,
Michael A. Jones,
Charles D. Hill,
Lloyd C. L. Hollenberg
Abstract:
The variational principle of quantum mechanics is the backbone of hybrid quantum computing for a range of applications. However, as the problem size grows, quantum logic errors and the effect of barren plateaus overwhelm the quality of the results. There is now a clear focus on strategies that require fewer quantum circuit steps and are robust to device errors. Here we present an approach in which…
▽ More
The variational principle of quantum mechanics is the backbone of hybrid quantum computing for a range of applications. However, as the problem size grows, quantum logic errors and the effect of barren plateaus overwhelm the quality of the results. There is now a clear focus on strategies that require fewer quantum circuit steps and are robust to device errors. Here we present an approach in which problem complexity is transferred to dynamic quantities computed on the quantum processor - Hamiltonian moments, $\langle H^n\rangle$. From these quantum computed moments, estimates of the ground-state energy are obtained using the "infinum" theorem from Lanczos cumulant expansions which manifestly correct the associated variational calculation. With system dynamics encoded in the moments the burden on the trial-state quantum circuit depth is eased. The method is introduced and demonstrated on 2D quantum magnetism models on lattices up to 5 $\times$ 5 (25 qubits) implemented on IBM Quantum superconducting qubit devices. Moments were quantum computed to fourth order with respect to a parameterised antiferromagnetic trial-state. A comprehensive comparison with benchmark variational calculations was performed, including over an ensemble of random coupling instances. The results showed that the infinum estimate consistently outperformed the benchmark variational approach for the same trial-state. These initial investigations suggest that the quantum computed moments approach has a high degree of stability against trial-state variation, quantum gate errors and shot noise, all of which bodes well for further investigation and applications of the approach.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2021; v1 submitted 28 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Correlative Synchrotron X-ray Imaging and Diffraction of Directed Energy Deposition Additive Manufacturing
Authors:
Yunhui Chen,
Samuel J. Clark,
David M. Collins,
Sebastian Marussi,
Simon A. Hunt,
Danielle M. Fenech,
Thomas Connolley,
Robert C. Atwood,
Oxana V. Magdysyuk,
Gavin J. Baxter,
Martyn A. Jones,
Chu Lun Alex Leung,
Peter D. Lee
Abstract:
The governing mechanistic behaviour of Directed Energy Deposition Additive Manufacturing (DED-AM) is revealed by a combined in situ and operando synchrotron X-ray imaging and diffraction study of a nickel-base superalloy, IN718. Using a unique process replicator, real-space phase-contrast imaging enables quantification of the melt-pool boundary and flow dynamics during solidification. This imaging…
▽ More
The governing mechanistic behaviour of Directed Energy Deposition Additive Manufacturing (DED-AM) is revealed by a combined in situ and operando synchrotron X-ray imaging and diffraction study of a nickel-base superalloy, IN718. Using a unique process replicator, real-space phase-contrast imaging enables quantification of the melt-pool boundary and flow dynamics during solidification. This imaging knowledge informed precise diffraction measurements of temporally resolved microstructural phases during transformation and stress development with a spatial resolution of 100 $μ$m. The diffraction quantified thermal gradient enabled a dendritic solidification microstructure to be predicted and coupled to the stress orientation and magnitude. The fast cooling rate entirely suppressed the formation of secondary phases or recrystallisation in the solid-state. Upon solidification, the stresses rapidly increase to the yield strength during cooling. This insight, combined with IN718 $'$s large solidification range suggests that the accumulated plasticity exhausts the alloy$'$s ductility, causing liquation cracking. This study has revealed additional fundamental mechanisms governing the formation of highly non-equilibrium microstructures during DED-AM.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
In situ and Operando X-ray Imaging of Directed Energy Deposition Additive Manufacturing
Authors:
Yunhui Chen,
Samuel J. Clark,
Lorna Sinclair,
Chu Lun Alex Leung,
Sebastian Marussi,
Thomas Connolley,
Oxana V. Magdysyuk,
Robert C. Atwood,
Gavin J. Baxter,
Martyn A. Jones,
David G. McCartney,
Iain Todd,
Peter D. Lee
Abstract:
The mechanical performance of Directed Energy Deposition Additive Manufactured (DED-AM) components can be highly material dependent. Through in situ and operando synchrotron X-ray imaging we capture the underlying phenomena controlling build quality of stainless steel (SS316) and titanium alloy (Ti6242 or Ti-6Al-2Sn-4Zr-2Mo). We reveal three mechanisms influencing the build efficiency of titanium…
▽ More
The mechanical performance of Directed Energy Deposition Additive Manufactured (DED-AM) components can be highly material dependent. Through in situ and operando synchrotron X-ray imaging we capture the underlying phenomena controlling build quality of stainless steel (SS316) and titanium alloy (Ti6242 or Ti-6Al-2Sn-4Zr-2Mo). We reveal three mechanisms influencing the build efficiency of titanium alloys compared to stainless steel: blown powder sintering; reduced melt-pool wetting due to the sinter; and pore pushing in the melt-pool. The former two directly increase lack of fusion porosity, while the later causes end of track porosity. Each phenomenon influences the melt-pool characteristics, wetting of the substrate and hence build efficacy and undesirable microstructural feature formation. We demonstrate that porosity is related to powder characteristics, pool flow, and solidification front morphology. Our results clarify DED-AM process dynamics, illustrating why each alloy builds differently, facilitating the wider application of additive manufacturing to new materials.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Formal Modelling of a Usable Identity Management Solution for Virtual Organisations
Authors:
Ali N. Haidar,
P. V. Coveney,
Ali E. Abdallah,
P. Y. A Ryan,
B. Beckles,
J. M. Brooke,
M . A. S. Jones
Abstract:
This paper attempts to accurately model security requirements for computational grid environments with particular focus on authentication. We introduce the Audited Credential Delegation (ACD) architecture as a solution to some of the virtual organisations identity management usability problems. The approach uses two complementary models: one is state based, described in Z notation, and the other…
▽ More
This paper attempts to accurately model security requirements for computational grid environments with particular focus on authentication. We introduce the Audited Credential Delegation (ACD) architecture as a solution to some of the virtual organisations identity management usability problems. The approach uses two complementary models: one is state based, described in Z notation, and the other is event-based, expressed in the Process Algebra of Hoare's Communicating Sequential Processes (CSP). The former will be used to capture the state of the WS and to model back-end operations on it whereas the latter will be used to model behavior, and in particular, front-end interactions and communications. The modelling helps to clearly and precisely understand functional and security requirements and provide a basis for verifying that the system meets its intended requirements.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2010;
originally announced January 2010.
-
Direct optical excitation of a fullerene-incarcerated metal ion
Authors:
Mark A G Jones,
Kyriakos Porfyrakis,
G Andrew D Briggs,
Robert A Taylor,
Arzhang Ardavan
Abstract:
The endohedral fullerene Er3N@C80 shows characteristic 1.5 micron photoluminescence at cryogenic temperatures associated with radiative relaxation from the crystal-field split Er3+ 4I13/2 manifold to the 4I15/2 manifold. Previous observations of this luminescence were carried out by photoexcitation of the fullerene cage states leading to relaxation via the ionic states. We present direct non-cag…
▽ More
The endohedral fullerene Er3N@C80 shows characteristic 1.5 micron photoluminescence at cryogenic temperatures associated with radiative relaxation from the crystal-field split Er3+ 4I13/2 manifold to the 4I15/2 manifold. Previous observations of this luminescence were carried out by photoexcitation of the fullerene cage states leading to relaxation via the ionic states. We present direct non-cage-mediated optical interaction with the erbium ion. We have used this interaction to complete a photoluminescence-excitation map of the Er3+ 4I13/2 manifold. This ability to interact directly with the states of an incarcerated ion suggests the possibility of coherently manipulating fullerene qubit states with light.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2006; v1 submitted 18 April, 2006;
originally announced April 2006.
-
Towards a fullerene-based quantum computer
Authors:
Simon C Benjamin,
Arzhang Ardavan,
G Andrew D Briggs,
David A Britz,
Daniel Gunlycke,
John Jefferson,
Mark A G Jones,
David F Leigh,
Brendon W Lovett,
Andrei N Khlobystov,
S A Lyon,
John J L Morton,
Kyriakos Porfyrakis,
Mark R Sambrook,
Alexei M Tyryshkin
Abstract:
Molecular structures appear to be natural candidates for a quantum technology: individual atoms can support quantum superpositions for long periods, and such atoms can in principle be embedded in a permanent molecular scaffolding to form an array. This would be true nanotechnology, with dimensions of order of a nanometre. However, the challenges of realising such a vision are immense. One must i…
▽ More
Molecular structures appear to be natural candidates for a quantum technology: individual atoms can support quantum superpositions for long periods, and such atoms can in principle be embedded in a permanent molecular scaffolding to form an array. This would be true nanotechnology, with dimensions of order of a nanometre. However, the challenges of realising such a vision are immense. One must identify a suitable elementary unit and demonstrate its merits for qubit storage and manipulation, including input / output. These units must then be formed into large arrays corresponding to an functional quantum architecture, including a mechanism for gate operations. Here we report our efforts, both experimental and theoretical, to create such a technology based on endohedral fullerenes or 'buckyballs'. We describe our successes with respect to these criteria, along with the obstacles we are currently facing and the questions that remain to be addressed.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2005;
originally announced November 2005.
-
Large-scale structure and the redshift-distance relation
Authors:
M. A. Jones,
J. N. Fry
Abstract:
In efforts to demonstrate the linear Hubble law v = Hr from galaxy observations, the underlying simplicity is often obscured by complexities arising from magnitude-limited data. In this paper we point out a simple but previously unremarked fact: that the shapes and orientations of structures in redshift space contain in themselves independent information about the cosmological redshift-distance…
▽ More
In efforts to demonstrate the linear Hubble law v = Hr from galaxy observations, the underlying simplicity is often obscured by complexities arising from magnitude-limited data. In this paper we point out a simple but previously unremarked fact: that the shapes and orientations of structures in redshift space contain in themselves independent information about the cosmological redshift-distance relation.
The orientations of voids in the CfA slice support the Hubble law, giving a redshift-distance power index p = 0.83 +/- 0.36 (void data from Slezak, de Lapparent, & Bijoui 1993) or p = 0.99 +/- 0.38 (void data from Malik & Subramanian 1997).
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 1998;
originally announced April 1998.
