-
Comment on "Capturing Phase Behavior of Ternary Lipid Mixtures with a Refined Martini Coarse-Grained Force Field"
Authors:
Matti Javanainen,
Balazs Fabian,
Hector Martinez-Seara
Abstract:
We report here on the pitfalls of the simulation model introduced in the "Capturing Phase Behavior of Ternary Lipid Mixtures with a Refined Martini Coarse-Grained Force Field" [Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2018, 14, 11, 6050-6062]. This refined Martini model was reported to reproduce experimental phase diagrams for a ternary DOPC/DPPC/cholesterol mixture, including the coexistence of…
▽ More
We report here on the pitfalls of the simulation model introduced in the "Capturing Phase Behavior of Ternary Lipid Mixtures with a Refined Martini Coarse-Grained Force Field" [Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2018, 14, 11, 6050-6062]. This refined Martini model was reported to reproduce experimental phase diagrams for a ternary DOPC/DPPC/cholesterol mixture, including the coexistence of two liquid phases. However, we demonstrate that this coexistence only emerged due to an unfortunate choice of simulation parameters, which leads to poor energy conservation. Specifically, the constraints on the cholesterol model drained energy out from the membrane, resulting in two coexisting phases at drastically different temperatures. Using the simulation parameters recommended for the used cholesterol model, this artefact is eliminated, yet so is phase coexistence, i.e. experimental phase diagrams are no longer reproduced. It is important to highlight that the present comment was submitted to Chemical Theory and Computation. However, it was rejected without peer-review by the Editor-in-Chief, who stated that the journal "rarely publishes such material".
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Towards atomistic resolution structure of phosphatidylcholine glycerol backbone and choline headgroup at different ambient conditions
Authors:
Alexandru Botan,
Andrea Catte,
Fernando Favela,
Patrick Fuchs,
Matti Javanainen,
Waldemar Kulig,
Antti Lamberg,
Markus S. Miettinen,
Luca Monticelli,
Jukka Määttä,
Vasily S. Oganesyan,
O. H. Samuli Ollila,
Marius Retegan,
Hubert Santuz,
Joona Tynkkynen
Abstract:
Phospholipids are essential building blocks of biological membranes. Despite of vast amount of accurate experimental data the atomistic resolution structures sampled by the glycerol backbone and choline headgroup in phoshatidylcholine bilayers are not known. Atomistic resolution molecular dynamics simulation model would automatically resolve the structures giving an interpretation of experimental…
▽ More
Phospholipids are essential building blocks of biological membranes. Despite of vast amount of accurate experimental data the atomistic resolution structures sampled by the glycerol backbone and choline headgroup in phoshatidylcholine bilayers are not known. Atomistic resolution molecular dynamics simulation model would automatically resolve the structures giving an interpretation of experimental results, if the model would reproduce the experimental data. In this work we compare the C-H bond vector order parameters for glycerol backbone and choline headgroup between 14 different atomistic resolution models and experiments in fully hydrated lipid bilayer. The current models are not accurately enough to resolve the structure. However, closer inspection of three best performing models (CHARMM36, GAFFlipid and MacRog) suggest that improvements in the sampled dihedral angle distributions would potentilly lead to the model which would resolve the structure. Despite of the inaccuracy in the fully hydrated structures, the response to the dehydration, i.e. P-N vector tilting more parallel to membrane normal, is qualitatively correct in all models. The CHARMM36 and MacRog models describe the interactions between lipids and cholesterol better than Berger/Höltje model. This work has been, and continues to be, progressed and discussed through the blog: nmrlipids.blogspot.fi. Everyone is invited to join the discussion and make contributions through the blog. The manuscript will be eventually submitted to an appropriate scientific journal. Everyone who has contributed to the work through the blog will be offered coauthorship. For more details see: nmrlipids.blogspot.fi.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2015; v1 submitted 9 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Anomalous diffusion of phospholipids and cholesterols in a lipid bilayer and its origins
Authors:
Jae-Hyung Jeon,
Hector Martinez-Seara Monne,
Matti Javanainen,
Ralf Metzler
Abstract:
Combining extensive molecular dynamics simulations of lipid bilayer systems of varying chemical composition with single-trajectory analyses we systematically elucidate the stochastic nature of the lipid motion. We observe subdiffusion over more than four orders of magnitude in time, clearly stretching into the sub-microsecond domain. The lipid motion delicately depends on the lipid chemistry, the…
▽ More
Combining extensive molecular dynamics simulations of lipid bilayer systems of varying chemical composition with single-trajectory analyses we systematically elucidate the stochastic nature of the lipid motion. We observe subdiffusion over more than four orders of magnitude in time, clearly stretching into the sub-microsecond domain. The lipid motion delicately depends on the lipid chemistry, the lipid phase, and especially on the presence of cholesterol. We demonstrate that fractional Langevin equation motion universally describes the lipid motion in all phases including the gel phase, and in the presence of cholesterol. The results underline the relevance of anomalous diffusion in lipid bilayers and the strong effects of the membrane composition.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
