-
$c_{\text{eff}}$ for 3d $\mathcal{N}=2$ theories
Authors:
Sergei Gukov,
Mrunmay Jagadale
Abstract:
Based on the observed behavior of the superconformal index in three-dimensional $\mathcal{N}=2$ theories, we propose a quantity that can be considered as an analogue of the "effective central charge." We discuss the general properties of this quantity and ways of computing it in a variety of different theories, including simple Lagrangian theories as well as more interesting strongly coupled examp…
▽ More
Based on the observed behavior of the superconformal index in three-dimensional $\mathcal{N}=2$ theories, we propose a quantity that can be considered as an analogue of the "effective central charge." We discuss the general properties of this quantity and ways of computing it in a variety of different theories, including simple Lagrangian theories as well as more interesting strongly coupled examples that come from 3d-3d correspondence.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Positive Geometries of S-matrix without Color
Authors:
Mrunmay Jagadale,
Alok Laddha
Abstract:
In this note, we prove that the realization of associahedron discovered by Arkani-Hamed, Bai, He, and Yun (ABHY) is a positive geometry for tree-level S-matrix of scalars which have no color and which interact via cubic coupling. More in detail, we consider diffeomorphic images of the ABHY associahedron. The diffeomorphisms are linear maps parametrized by the right cosets of the Dihedral group on…
▽ More
In this note, we prove that the realization of associahedron discovered by Arkani-Hamed, Bai, He, and Yun (ABHY) is a positive geometry for tree-level S-matrix of scalars which have no color and which interact via cubic coupling. More in detail, we consider diffeomorphic images of the ABHY associahedron. The diffeomorphisms are linear maps parametrized by the right cosets of the Dihedral group on n elements. The set of all the boundaries associated with these copies of ABHY associahedron exhaust all the simple poles. We prove that the sum over the diffeomorphic copies of ABHY associahedron is a positive geometry and the total volume obtained by summing over all the dual associahedra is proportional to the tree-level S matrix of (massive or massless) scalar particles with cubic coupling. We then provide non-trivial evidence that the projection of the planar scattering forms parametrized by the Stokes polytope on these realizations of the associahedron leads to the tree-level amplitudes of scalar particles, which interact via quartic coupling.
Our results build on ideas laid out in our previous works, leading to further evidence that a large class of positive geometries which are diffeomorphic to the ABHY associahedron defines an ``amplituhedron" for a tree-level S matrix of some local and unitary scalar theory. We also highlight a fundamental obstruction in applying these ideas to discover positive geometry for the one loop integrand when propagating states have no color.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Bound on the central charge of CFTs in large dimension
Authors:
Abhijit Gadde,
Mrunmay Jagadale,
Shraiyance Jain,
Trakshu Sharma
Abstract:
In this paper, we use crossing symmetry and unitarity constraints to put a lower bound on the central charge of conformal field theories in large space-time dimensions $D$. Specifically, we work with the four-point function of identical scalars $φ$ with scaling dimension $Δ_φ$, and use a certain class of analytic functionals to show that the OPE coefficient squared $c^2_{φφT^{μν}}$ must be exponen…
▽ More
In this paper, we use crossing symmetry and unitarity constraints to put a lower bound on the central charge of conformal field theories in large space-time dimensions $D$. Specifically, we work with the four-point function of identical scalars $φ$ with scaling dimension $Δ_φ$, and use a certain class of analytic functionals to show that the OPE coefficient squared $c^2_{φφT^{μν}}$ must be exponentially small in $D$. For this to hold, we need to make a mild assumption about the nature of the spectrum below $2Δ_φ$. Our argument is robust and can be applied to any OPE coefficient squared $c^2_{φφO}$ with $Δ_O< 2Δ_φ$. This suggests that conformal field theories in large dimensions (if they exist) must be exponentially close to generalized free field theories.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Decorated TQFTs and their Hilbert Spaces
Authors:
Mrunmay Jagadale
Abstract:
We discuss topological quantum field theories that compute topological invariants which depend on additional structures (or decorations) on three-manifolds. The $q$-series invariant $\hat{Z}(q)$ proposed by Gukov, Pei, Putrov and Vafa is an example of such an invariant. We describe how to obtain these decorated invariants by cutting and gluing, and make a proposal for Hilbert spaces that are assig…
▽ More
We discuss topological quantum field theories that compute topological invariants which depend on additional structures (or decorations) on three-manifolds. The $q$-series invariant $\hat{Z}(q)$ proposed by Gukov, Pei, Putrov and Vafa is an example of such an invariant. We describe how to obtain these decorated invariants by cutting and gluing, and make a proposal for Hilbert spaces that are assigned to two-dimensional surfaces in the $\hat{Z}$-TQFT.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Towards Positive Geometries of Massive Scalar field theories
Authors:
Mrunmay Jagadale,
Alok Laddha
Abstract:
Building on the prior work in [1] we locate a family of positive geometries in the kinematic space which are a specific class of convex realisations of the associahedron. These realisations are obtained by scaling and translating the kinematic space associahedron discovered by by Arkani-Hamed, Bai, He and Yan (ABHY). We call the resulting polytopes, deformed realisations of the associahedron. The…
▽ More
Building on the prior work in [1] we locate a family of positive geometries in the kinematic space which are a specific class of convex realisations of the associahedron. These realisations are obtained by scaling and translating the kinematic space associahedron discovered by by Arkani-Hamed, Bai, He and Yan (ABHY). We call the resulting polytopes, deformed realisations of the associahedron. The deformed realisations shed new light on the CHY formula. One of the striking discoveries in [2] was the fact that the CHY scattering equations generate diffeomorphism between the (compactified) CHY moduli space and the ABHY associahedron. As we argue, the deformed realisation of the associahedron can also be interpreted as an diffeomorphic image of the CHY moduli space under scattering equations that we call deformed scattering equations. The canonical form in the kinematic space is thus once again the push-forward of the Parke-Taylor form . A natural off-shoot of our analysis is the universality of the Parke-Taylor form as a CHY Integrand for a class of (tree-level and planar) multi-scalar field amplitudes. These ideas help us in proving the existence of positive geometries for certain specific multi-scalar interactions. We prove that in a field theory with a massless and a massive bi-adjoint scalar fields which interact via cubic interaction, the tree-level S-matrix with massless external states and at most one massive propagator is a weighted sum over the canonical forms defined by certain deformed realisations of the associahedron. Finally, we show that these ideas admit an extension to one-loop. In particular, the one loop S-matrix integrand with at most one massive propagator is a weighted sum over canonical forms of a family of deformed realisations of the type-D cluster polytope, discovered in [3,4].
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Towards Positive Geometry of Multi Scalar Field Amplitudes : Accordiohedron and Effective Field Theory
Authors:
Mrunmay Jagadale,
Alok Laddha
Abstract:
The geometric structure of S-matrix encapsulated by the "Amplituhedron program" has begun to reveal itself even in non-supersymmetric quantum field theories. Starting with the seminal work of Arkani-Hamed, Bai, He and Yan it is now understood that for a wide class of scalar quantum field theories, tree-level amplitudes are canonical forms associated to polytopes known as accordiohedra. Similarly t…
▽ More
The geometric structure of S-matrix encapsulated by the "Amplituhedron program" has begun to reveal itself even in non-supersymmetric quantum field theories. Starting with the seminal work of Arkani-Hamed, Bai, He and Yan it is now understood that for a wide class of scalar quantum field theories, tree-level amplitudes are canonical forms associated to polytopes known as accordiohedra. Similarly the higher loop scalar integrands are canonical forms associated to so called type-D cluster polytopes for cubic interactions or recently discovered class of polytopes termed pseudo-accordiohedron for higher order scalar interactions.
In this paper, we continue to probe the universality of these structures for a wider class of scalar quantum field theories. More in detail, we discover new realisations of the associahedron in planar kinematic space whose canonical forms generate (colour-ordered) tree-level S matrix of external massless particles with $n-4$ massless poles and one massive pole at $m^{2}$. The resulting amplitudes are associated to $λ_{1}\, φ_{1}^{3}\, +\, λ_{2}\, φ_{1}^{2}φ_{2}$ potential where $φ_{1}$ and $φ_{2}$ are massless and massive scalar fields with bi-adjoint colour indices respectively. We also show how in the "decoupling limit" (where $m \rightarrow \infty, λ_{2} \rightarrow \infty$ such that $g := \frac{λ_{2}}{m} = \textrm{finite}$) these associahedra project onto a specific class of accordiohedron which are known to be positive geometries of amplitudes generated by $λφ_{1}^{3} + g φ_{1}^{4}$.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
On the Positive Geometry of Quartic Interactions III : One Loop Integrands from Polytopes
Authors:
Mrunmay Jagadale,
Alok Laddha
Abstract:
Building on the seminal work of Arkani-Hamed, He, Salvatori and Thomas (AHST), we explore the positive geometry encoding one loop scattering amplitude for quartic scalar interactions. We define a new class of combinatorial polytopes that we call pseudo-accordiohedra whose poset structures are associated to singularities of the one loop integrand associated to scalar quartic interactions. Pseudo-ac…
▽ More
Building on the seminal work of Arkani-Hamed, He, Salvatori and Thomas (AHST), we explore the positive geometry encoding one loop scattering amplitude for quartic scalar interactions. We define a new class of combinatorial polytopes that we call pseudo-accordiohedra whose poset structures are associated to singularities of the one loop integrand associated to scalar quartic interactions. Pseudo-accordiohedra parametrize a family of projective forms on the abstract kinematic space defined by AHST and restriction of these forms to the type-D associahedra can be associated to one-loop integrands for quartic interactions. The restriction (of the projective form) can also be thought of as a canonical top form on certain geometric realisations of pseudo-accordiohedra. Our work explores a large class of geometric realisations of the type-D associahedra which include all the AHST realisations. These realisations are based on the pseudo-triangulation model for type-D cluster algebras discovered by Ceballos and Pilaud.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
On Positive Geometries of Quartic Interactions II : Stokes polytopes, Lower Forms on Associahedra and Worldsheet Forms
Authors:
P B Aneesh,
Pinaki Banerjee,
Mrunmay Jagadale,
Renjan Rajan John,
Alok Laddha,
Sujoy Mahato
Abstract:
In [1], two of the present authors along with P. Raman attempted to extend the Amplituhedron program for scalar field theories [2] to quartic scalar interactions. In this paper we develop various aspects of this proposal. Using recent seminal results in Representation theory [3,4], we show that projectivity of scattering forms and existence of kinematic space associahedron completely capture plana…
▽ More
In [1], two of the present authors along with P. Raman attempted to extend the Amplituhedron program for scalar field theories [2] to quartic scalar interactions. In this paper we develop various aspects of this proposal. Using recent seminal results in Representation theory [3,4], we show that projectivity of scattering forms and existence of kinematic space associahedron completely capture planar amplitudes of quartic interaction. We generalise the results of [1] and show that for any $n$-particle amplitude, the positive geometry associated to the projective scattering form is a convex realisation of Stokes polytope which can be naturally embedded inside one of the ABHY associahedra defined in [2,5]. For a special class of Stokes polytopes with hyper-cubic topology, we show that they have a canonical convex realisation in kinematic space as boundaries of kinematic space associahedra.
We then use these kinematic space geometric constructions to write worldsheet forms for $φ^{4}$ theory which are forms of lower rank on the CHY moduli space. We argue that just as in the case of bi-adjoint $φ^3$ scalar amplitudes, scattering equations can be used as diffeomorphisms between certain $\frac{n-4}{2}$ forms on the worldsheet and $\frac{n-4}{2}$ forms on ABHY associahedron that generate quartic amplitudes.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2020; v1 submitted 14 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Accordiohedra as positive geometries for generic scalar field theories
Authors:
P. B. Aneesh,
Mrunmay Jagadale,
Nikhil Kalyanapuram
Abstract:
We build upon the prior works of [1-3] to study tree-level planar amplitudes for a massless scalar field theory with polynomial interactions. Focusing on a specific example, where the interaction is given by $λ_3φ^{3}\ +λ_4 φ^{4}$, we show that a specific convex realization of a simple polytope known as the accordiohedron in kinematic space is the positive geometry for this theory. As in the previ…
▽ More
We build upon the prior works of [1-3] to study tree-level planar amplitudes for a massless scalar field theory with polynomial interactions. Focusing on a specific example, where the interaction is given by $λ_3φ^{3}\ +λ_4 φ^{4}$, we show that a specific convex realization of a simple polytope known as the accordiohedron in kinematic space is the positive geometry for this theory. As in the previous cases, there is a unique planar scattering form in kinematic space, associated to each positive geometry which yields planar scattering amplitudes.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2019; v1 submitted 28 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Additive Collatz Trajectories
Authors:
Aalok Thakkar,
Mrunmay Jagadale
Abstract:
Collatz Conjecture (also known as Ulam's conjecture and 3x+1 problem) concerns the behavior of the iterates of a particular function on natural numbers. A number of generalizations of the conjecture have been subjected to extensive study. This paper explores Additive Collatz Trajectories, a particular case of a generalization of Collatz conjecture and puts forward a sufficient and necessary condit…
▽ More
Collatz Conjecture (also known as Ulam's conjecture and 3x+1 problem) concerns the behavior of the iterates of a particular function on natural numbers. A number of generalizations of the conjecture have been subjected to extensive study. This paper explores Additive Collatz Trajectories, a particular case of a generalization of Collatz conjecture and puts forward a sufficient and necessary condition for loo** of Additive Collatz Trajectories, along with two minor results. An algorithm to compute the number of equivalence classes when natural numbers are quotiented by the limiting behavior of their corresponding trajectories is also proposed.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
