Showing 1–17 of 17 results for author: Jacquot, P

Quantum Distance Calculation for $ε$-Graph Construction

Authors: Naomi Mona Chmielewski, Nina Amini, Paulin Jacquot, Joseph Mikael

Abstract: In machine learning and particularly in topological data analysis, $ε$-graphs are important tools but are generally hard to compute as the distance calculation between n points takes time O(n^2) classically. Recently, quantum approaches for calculating distances between n quantum states have been proposed, taking advantage of quantum superposition and entanglement. We investigate the potential for… ▽ More In machine learning and particularly in topological data analysis, $ε$-graphs are important tools but are generally hard to compute as the distance calculation between n points takes time O(n^2) classically. Recently, quantum approaches for calculating distances between n quantum states have been proposed, taking advantage of quantum superposition and entanglement. We investigate the potential for quantum advantage in the case of quantum distance calculation for computing $ε$-graphs. We show that, relying on existing quantum multi-state SWAP test based algorithms, the query complexity for correctly identifying (with a given probability) that two points are not $ε$-neighbours is at least O(n^3 / ln n), showing that this approach, if used directly for $ε$-graph construction, does not bring a computational advantage when compared to a classical approach. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Random block coordinate methods for inconsistent convex optimisation problems

Authors: Mathias Staudigl, Paulin Jacquot

Abstract: We develop a novel randomised block coordinate primal-dual algorithm for a class of non-smooth ill-posed convex programs. Lying in the midway between the celebrated Chambolle-Pock primal-dual algorithm and Tseng's accelerated proximal gradient method, we establish global convergence of the last iterate as well optimal $O(1/k)$ and $O(1/k^{2})$ complexity rates in the convex and strongly convex cas… ▽ More We develop a novel randomised block coordinate primal-dual algorithm for a class of non-smooth ill-posed convex programs. Lying in the midway between the celebrated Chambolle-Pock primal-dual algorithm and Tseng's accelerated proximal gradient method, we establish global convergence of the last iterate as well optimal $O(1/k)$ and $O(1/k^{2})$ complexity rates in the convex and strongly convex case, respectively, $k$ being the iteration count. Motivated by the increased complexity in the control of distribution level electric power systems, we test the performance of our method on a second-order cone relaxation of an AC-OPF problem. Distributed control is achieved via the distributed locational marginal prices (DLMPs), which are obtained \revise{as} dual variables in our optimisation framework. △ Less

Submitted 1 August, 2023; v1 submitted 22 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Comments: Changed title and revised manuscript

MSC Class: 90C25; 90C06; 90B10

On the challenges of using D-Wave computers to sample Boltzmann Random Variables

Authors: Thomas Pochart, Paulin Jacquot, Joseph Mikael

Abstract: Sampling random variables following a Boltzmann distribution is an NP-hard problem involved in various applications such as training of \textit{Boltzmann machines}, a specific kind of neural network. Several attempts have been made to use a D-Wave quantum computer to sample such a distribution, as this could lead to significant speedup in these applications. Yet, at present, several challenges rem… ▽ More Sampling random variables following a Boltzmann distribution is an NP-hard problem involved in various applications such as training of \textit{Boltzmann machines}, a specific kind of neural network. Several attempts have been made to use a D-Wave quantum computer to sample such a distribution, as this could lead to significant speedup in these applications. Yet, at present, several challenges remain to efficiently perform such sampling. We detail the various obstacles and explain the remaining difficulties in solving the sampling problem on a D-wave machine. △ Less

Submitted 1 December, 2021; v1 submitted 30 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Hierarchically constrained blackbox optimization

Authors: Stéphane Alarie, Charles Audet, Paulin Jacquot, Sébastien Le Digabel

Abstract: In blackbox optimization, evaluation of the objective and constraint functions is time consuming. In some situations, constraint values may be evaluated independently or sequentially. The present work proposes and compares two strategies to define a hierarchical ordering of the constraints and to interrupt the evaluation process at a trial point when it is detected that it will not improve the cur… ▽ More In blackbox optimization, evaluation of the objective and constraint functions is time consuming. In some situations, constraint values may be evaluated independently or sequentially. The present work proposes and compares two strategies to define a hierarchical ordering of the constraints and to interrupt the evaluation process at a trial point when it is detected that it will not improve the current best solution. Numerical experiments are performed on a closed-form test problem. △ Less

Submitted 27 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Report number: Technical report, Les Cahiers du GERAD, G-2021-65

A privacy-preserving distributed computational approach for distributed locational marginal prices

Authors: Olivier Bilenne, Paulin Jacquot, Nadia Oudjane, Mathias Staudigl, Cheng Wan, Barbara Franci

Abstract: An important issue in today's electricity markets is the management of flexibilities offered by new practices, such as smart home appliances or electric vehicles. By inducing changes in the behavior of residential electric utilities, demand response (DR) seeks to adjust the demand of power to the supply for increased grid stability and better integration of renewable energies. A key role in DR is… ▽ More An important issue in today's electricity markets is the management of flexibilities offered by new practices, such as smart home appliances or electric vehicles. By inducing changes in the behavior of residential electric utilities, demand response (DR) seeks to adjust the demand of power to the supply for increased grid stability and better integration of renewable energies. A key role in DR is played by emergent independent entities called load aggregators (LAs). We develop a new decentralized algorithm to solve a convex relaxation of the classical Alternative Current Optimal Power Flow (ACOPF) problem, which relies on local information only. Each computational step can be performed in an entirely privacy-preserving manner, and system-wide coordination is achieved via node-specific distribution locational marginal prices (DLMPs). We demonstrate the efficiency of our approach on a 15-bus radial distribution network. △ Less

Submitted 7 September, 2022; v1 submitted 25 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: 8 pages, 3 figures; submitted for publication

MSC Class: 68P27; 68W15; 68W20 (Secondary); 91B74 (Primary); 90C25

Journal ref: 61st IEEE Conference on Decision and Control 2022

DLMP-based Coordination Procedure for Decentralized Demand Response under Distribution Network Constraints

Authors: Paulin Jacquot

Abstract: Load aggregators are independent private entities whose goal is to optimize energy consumption flexibilities offered by multiple residential consumers. Although aggregators optimize their decisions in a decentralized way, they are indirectly linked together if their respective consumers belong to the same distribution grid. This is an important issue for a distribution system operator (DSO), i… ▽ More Load aggregators are independent private entities whose goal is to optimize energy consumption flexibilities offered by multiple residential consumers. Although aggregators optimize their decisions in a decentralized way, they are indirectly linked together if their respective consumers belong to the same distribution grid. This is an important issue for a distribution system operator (DSO), in charge of the reliability of the distribution network, it has to ensure that decentralized decisions taken do not violate the grid constraints and do not increase the global system costs. From the information point of view,the network state and characteristics are confidential to the DSO, which makes a decentralized solution even more relevant. To address this issue, we propose a decentralized coordination mechanism between the DSO and multiple aggregators that computes the optimal demand response profiles while solving the optimal power flow problem. The procedure, based on distribution locational marginal prices (DLMP), preserves the decentralized structure of information and decisions, and lead to a feasible and optimal solution for both the aggregators and the DSO. The procedure is analyzed from a mechanism design perspective, and different decentralized methods that could be used to implement this procedure are presented. △ Less

Submitted 27 August, 2020; v1 submitted 13 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Comments: 25pages. Update theoretical proof of convergence of primal-dual Gauss-Seidel iterative algo, add a Mechanism design discussion over the proposed DLMP-based mechanism; add numerical results for ADMM and primal-dual GS convergence

Efficient Estimation of Equilibria in Large Aggregative Games with Coupling Constraints

Authors: Paulin Jacquot, Cheng Wan, Olivier Beaude, Nadia Oudjane

Abstract: Aggregative games have many industrial applications, and computing an equilibrium in those games is challenging when the number of players is large. In the framework of atomic aggregative games with coupling constraints, we show that variational Nash equilibria of a large aggregative game can be approximated by a Wardrop equilibrium of an auxiliary population game of smaller dimension. Each popula… ▽ More Aggregative games have many industrial applications, and computing an equilibrium in those games is challenging when the number of players is large. In the framework of atomic aggregative games with coupling constraints, we show that variational Nash equilibria of a large aggregative game can be approximated by a Wardrop equilibrium of an auxiliary population game of smaller dimension. Each population of this auxiliary game corresponds to a group of atomic players of the initial large game. This approach enables an efficient computation of an approximated equilibrium, as the variational inequality characterizing the Wardrop equilibrium is of smaller dimension than the initial one. This is illustrated on an example in the smart grid context. △ Less

Submitted 26 March, 2020; v1 submitted 21 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Comments: arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:1810.01436

A Privacy-preserving Method to Optimize Distributed Resource Allocation

Authors: Olivier Beaude, Pascal Benchimol, Stéphane Gaubert, Paulin Jacquot, Nadia Oudjane

Abstract: We consider a resource allocation problem involving a large number of agents with individual constraints subject to privacy, and a central operator whose objective is to optimize a global, possibly nonconvex, cost while satisfying the agents' constraints, for instance an energy operator in charge of the management of energy consumption flexibilities of many individual consumers. We provide a priva… ▽ More We consider a resource allocation problem involving a large number of agents with individual constraints subject to privacy, and a central operator whose objective is to optimize a global, possibly nonconvex, cost while satisfying the agents' constraints, for instance an energy operator in charge of the management of energy consumption flexibilities of many individual consumers. We provide a privacy-preserving algorithm that does compute the optimal allocation of resources, avoiding each agent to reveal her private information (constraints and individual solution profile) neither to the central operator nor to a third party. Our method relies on an aggregation procedure: we compute iteratively a global allocation of resources, and gradually ensure existence of a disaggregation, that is individual profiles satisfying agents' private constraints, by a protocol involving the generation of polyhedral cuts and secure multiparty computations (SMC). To obtain these cuts, we use an alternate projection method, which is implemented locally by each agent, preserving her privacy needs. We adress especially the case in which the local and global constraints define a transportation polytope. Then, we provide theoretical convergence estimates together with numerical results, showing that the algorithm can be effectively used to solve the allocation problem in high dimension, while addressing privacy issues. △ Less

Submitted 22 June, 2020; v1 submitted 7 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: 35 pages, revised version accepted for publication in SIAM journal on Optimization (SIOPT)

Nonatomic Aggregative Games with Infinitely Many Types

Authors: Paulin Jacquot, Cheng Wan

Abstract: We define and analyze the notion of variational Wardrop equilibrium for nonatomic aggregative games with an infinity of players types. These equilibria are characterized through an infinite-dimensional variational inequality. We show, under monotonicity conditions, a convergence theorem enables to approximate such an equilibrium with arbitrary precision. To this end, we introduce a sequence of non… ▽ More We define and analyze the notion of variational Wardrop equilibrium for nonatomic aggregative games with an infinity of players types. These equilibria are characterized through an infinite-dimensional variational inequality. We show, under monotonicity conditions, a convergence theorem enables to approximate such an equilibrium with arbitrary precision. To this end, we introduce a sequence of nonatomic games with a finite number of players types, which approximates the initial game. We show the existence of a symmetric Wardrop equilibrium in each of these games. We prove that those symmetric equilibria converge to an equilibrium of the infinite game, and that they can be computed as solutions of finite-dimensional variational inequalities. The model is illustrated through an example from smart grids: the description of a large population of electricity consumers by a parametric distribution gives a nonatomic game with an infinity of different players types, with actions subject to coupling constraints. △ Less

Submitted 4 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Comments: arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:1806.06230

A Privacy-preserving Disaggregation Algorithm for Non-intrusive Management of Flexible Energy

Authors: Paulin Jacquot, Olivier Beaude, Pascal Benchimol, Stéphane Gaubert, Nadia Oudjane

Abstract: We consider a resource allocation problem involving a large number of agents with individual constraints subject to privacy, and a central operator whose objective is to optimizing a global, possibly non-convex, cost while satisfying the agents'c onstraints. We focus on the practical case of the management of energy consumption flexibilities by the operator of a microgrid. This paper provides a pr… ▽ More We consider a resource allocation problem involving a large number of agents with individual constraints subject to privacy, and a central operator whose objective is to optimizing a global, possibly non-convex, cost while satisfying the agents'c onstraints. We focus on the practical case of the management of energy consumption flexibilities by the operator of a microgrid. This paper provides a privacy-preserving algorithm that does compute the optimal allocation of resources, avoiding each agent to reveal her private information (constraints and individual solution profile) neither to the central operator nor to a third party. Our method relies on an aggregation procedure: we maintain a global allocation of resources, and gradually disaggregate this allocation to enforce the satisfaction of private contraints, by a protocol involving the generation of polyhedral cuts and secure multiparty computations (SMC). To obtain these cuts, we use an alternate projections method à la Von Neumann, which is implemented locally by each agent, preserving her privacy needs. Our theoretical and numerical results show that the method scales well as the number of agents gets large, and thus can be used to solve the allocation problem in high dimension, while addressing privacy issues. △ Less

Submitted 7 March, 2019; originally announced March 2019.

Comments: 8 pages, 2 figures, submitted to CDC2019

Peer-to-Peer Electricity Market Analysis: From Variational to Generalized Nash Equilibrium

Authors: Hélène Le Cadre, Paulin Jacquot, Cheng Wan, Clémence Alasseur

Abstract: We consider a network of prosumers involved in peer-to-peer energy exchanges, with differentiation price preferences on the trades with their neighbors, and we analyze two market designs: (i) a centralized market, used as a benchmark, where a global market operator optimizes the flows (trades) between the nodes, local demand and flexibility activation to maximize the system overall social welfare;… ▽ More We consider a network of prosumers involved in peer-to-peer energy exchanges, with differentiation price preferences on the trades with their neighbors, and we analyze two market designs: (i) a centralized market, used as a benchmark, where a global market operator optimizes the flows (trades) between the nodes, local demand and flexibility activation to maximize the system overall social welfare; (ii) a distributed peer-to-peer market design where prosumers in local energy communities optimize selfishly their trades, demand, and flexibility activation. We first characterizethe solution of the peer-to-peer market as a Variational Equilibrium and prove that the set of Variational Equilibria coincides with the set of social welfare optimal solutions of market design (i). We give several results that help understanding the structure of the trades at an equilibriumor at the optimum. We characterize the impact of preferences on the network line congestion and renewable energy waste under both designs. We provide a reduced example for which we give the set of all possible generalized equilibria, which enables to give an approximation of the price ofanarchy. We provide a more realistic example which relies on the IEEE 14-bus network, for which we can simulate the trades under different preference prices. Our analysis shows in particular that the preferences have a large impact on the structure of the trades, but that one equilibrium(variational) is optimal. △ Less

Submitted 5 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Efficient Estimation of Equilibria of Large Congestion Games with Heterogeneous Players

Authors: Cheng Wan, Paulin Jacquot, Olivier Beaude, Nadia Oudjane

Abstract: Computing an equilibrium in congestion games can be challenging when the number of players is large. Yet, it is a problem to be addressed in practice, for instance to forecast the state of the system and be able to control it. In this work, we analyze the case of generalized atomic congestion games, with coupling constraints, and with players that are heterogeneous through their action sets and th… ▽ More Computing an equilibrium in congestion games can be challenging when the number of players is large. Yet, it is a problem to be addressed in practice, for instance to forecast the state of the system and be able to control it. In this work, we analyze the case of generalized atomic congestion games, with coupling constraints, and with players that are heterogeneous through their action sets and their utility functions. We obtain an approximation of the variational Nash equilibria---a notion generalizing Nash equilibria in the presence of coupling constraints---of a large atomic congestion game by an equilibrium of an auxiliary population game, where each population corresponds to a group of atomic players of the initial game. Because the variational inequalities characterizing the equilibrium of the auxiliary game have smaller dimension than the original problem, this approach enables the fast computation of an estimation of equilibria in a large congestion game with thousands of heterogeneous players. △ Less

Submitted 2 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 12 pages, 3 figures

Nonsmooth Aggregative Games with Coupling Constraints and Infinitely Many Classes of Players

Authors: Paulin Jacquot, Cheng Wan

Abstract: After defining a pure-action profile in a nonatomic aggregative game, where players have specific compact convex pure-action sets and nonsmooth convex cost functions, as a square-integrable function, we characterize a Wardrop equilibrium as a solution to an infinite-dimensional generalized variational inequality. We show the existence of Wardrop equilibrium and variational Wardrop equilibrium, a c… ▽ More After defining a pure-action profile in a nonatomic aggregative game, where players have specific compact convex pure-action sets and nonsmooth convex cost functions, as a square-integrable function, we characterize a Wardrop equilibrium as a solution to an infinite-dimensional generalized variational inequality. We show the existence of Wardrop equilibrium and variational Wardrop equilibrium, a concept of equilibrium adapted to the presence of coupling constraints, in monotone nonatomic aggregative games. The uniqueness of (variational) Wardrop equilibrium is proved for strictly or aggregatively strictly monotone nonatomic aggregative games. We then show that, for a sequence of finite-player aggregative games with aggregative constraints, if the players' pure-action sets converge to those of a strongly (resp. aggregatively strongly) monotone nonatomic aggregative game, and the aggregative constraints in the finite-player games converge to the aggregative constraint of the nonatomic game, then a sequence of so-called variational Nash equilibria in these finite-player games converge to the variational Wardrop equilibrium in pure-action profile (resp. aggregate-action profile). In particular, it allows the construction of an auxiliary sequence of games with finite-dimensional equilibria to approximate the infinite-dimensional equilibrium in such a nonatomic game. Finally, we show how to construct auxiliary finite-player games for two general classes of nonatomic games. △ Less

Submitted 16 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Comments: 23 pages, 2 figures

MSC Class: 90B20; 91A13

Routing Game on Parallel Networks: the Convergence of Atomic to Nonatomic

Authors: Paulin Jacquot, Cheng Wan

Abstract: We consider an instance of a nonatomic routing game. We assume that the network is parallel, that is, constituted of only two nodes, an origin and a destination. We consider infinitesimal players that have a symmetric network cost, but are heterogeneous through their set of feasible strategies and their individual utilities. We show that if an atomic routing game instance is correctly defined to a… ▽ More We consider an instance of a nonatomic routing game. We assume that the network is parallel, that is, constituted of only two nodes, an origin and a destination. We consider infinitesimal players that have a symmetric network cost, but are heterogeneous through their set of feasible strategies and their individual utilities. We show that if an atomic routing game instance is correctly defined to approximate the nonatomic instance, then an atomic Nash Equilibrium will approximate the nonatomic Wardrop Equilibrium. We give explicit bounds on the distance between the equilibria according to the parameters of the atomic instance. This approximation gives a method to compute the Wardrop equilibrium at an arbitrary precision. △ Less

Submitted 9 April, 2018; originally announced April 2018.

Comments: 20 pages, one figure, submitted to CDC 2018

Analysis and Implementation of a Hourly Billing Mechanism for Demand Response Management

Authors: Paulin Jacquot, Olivier Beaude, Stéphane Gaubert, Nadia Oudjane

Abstract: An important part of the Smart Grid literature on residential Demand Response deals with game-theoretic consumption models. Among those papers, the hourly billing model is of special interest as an intuitive and fair mechanism. We focus on this model and answer to several theoretical and practical questions. First, we prove the uniqueness of the consumption profile corresponding to the Nash equili… ▽ More An important part of the Smart Grid literature on residential Demand Response deals with game-theoretic consumption models. Among those papers, the hourly billing model is of special interest as an intuitive and fair mechanism. We focus on this model and answer to several theoretical and practical questions. First, we prove the uniqueness of the consumption profile corresponding to the Nash equilibrium, and we analyze its efficiency by providing a bound on the Price of Anarchy. Next, we address the computational issue of the equilibrium profile by providing two algorithms: the cycling best response dynamics and a projected gradient descent method, and by giving an upper bound on their convergence rate to the equilibrium. Last, we simulate this demand response framework in a stochastic environment where the parameters depend on forecasts. We show numerically the relevance of an online demand response procedure, which reduces the impact of inaccurate forecasts. △ Less

Submitted 22 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Comments: 11 pages, 3 figures, submitted to IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid

Demand Response in the Smart Grid: the Impact of Consumers Temporal Preferences

Authors: Paulin Jacquot, Olivier Beaude, Nadia Oudjane, Stephane Gaubert

Abstract: In Demand Response programs, price incentives might not be sufficient to modify residential consumers load profile. Here, we consider that each consumer has a preferred profile and a discomfort cost when deviating from it. Consumers can value this discomfort at a varying level that we take as a parameter. This work analyses Demand Response as a game theoretic environment. We study the equilibria o… ▽ More In Demand Response programs, price incentives might not be sufficient to modify residential consumers load profile. Here, we consider that each consumer has a preferred profile and a discomfort cost when deviating from it. Consumers can value this discomfort at a varying level that we take as a parameter. This work analyses Demand Response as a game theoretic environment. We study the equilibria of the game between consumers with preferences within two different dynamic pricing mechanisms, respectively the daily proportional mechanism introduced by Mohsenian-Rad et al, and an hourly proportional mechanism. We give new results about equilibria as functions of the preference level in the case of quadratic system costs and prove that, whatever the preference level, system costs are smaller with the hourly mechanism. We simulate the Demand Response environment using real consumption data from PecanStreet database. While the Price of Anarchy remains always close to one up to 0.1% with the hourly mechanism, it can be more than 10% bigger with the daily mechanism. △ Less

Submitted 30 November, 2017; originally announced November 2017.

Demand Side Management in the Smart Grid: an Efficiency and Fairness Tradeoff

Authors: Paulin Jacquot, Olivier Beaude, Stéphane Gaubert, Nadia Oudjane

Abstract: We compare two Demand Side Management (DSM) mechanisms, introduced respectively by Mohsenian-Rad et al (2010) and Baharlouei et al (2012), in terms of efficiency and fairness. Each mechanism defines a game where the consumers optimize their flexible consumption to reduce their electricity bills. Mohsenian-Rad et al propose a daily mechanism for which they prove the social optimality. Baharlouei et… ▽ More We compare two Demand Side Management (DSM) mechanisms, introduced respectively by Mohsenian-Rad et al (2010) and Baharlouei et al (2012), in terms of efficiency and fairness. Each mechanism defines a game where the consumers optimize their flexible consumption to reduce their electricity bills. Mohsenian-Rad et al propose a daily mechanism for which they prove the social optimality. Baharlouei et al propose a hourly billing mechanism for which we give theoretical results: we prove the uniqueness of an equilibrium in the associated game and give an upper bound on its price of anarchy. We evaluate numerically the two mechanisms, using real consumption data from Pecan Street Inc. The simulations show that the equilibrium reached with the hourly mechanism is socially optimal up to 0.1%, and that it achieves an important fairness property according to a quantitative indicator we define. We observe that the two DSM mechanisms avoid the synchronization effect induced by non- game theoretic mechanisms, e.g. Peak/OffPeak hours contracts. △ Less

Submitted 29 November, 2017; originally announced November 2017.

Comments: 6 pages, 6 figures, to appear in conference proceedings of IEEE PES ISGT Europe 2017