-
AvaTaR: Optimizing LLM Agents for Tool-Assisted Knowledge Retrieval
Authors:
Shirley Wu,
Shiyu Zhao,
Qian Huang,
Kexin Huang,
Michihiro Yasunaga,
Kaidi Cao,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Karthik Subbian,
Jure Leskovec,
James Zou
Abstract:
Large language model (LLM) agents have demonstrated impressive capability in utilizing external tools and knowledge to boost accuracy and reduce hallucinations. However, develo** the prompting techniques that make LLM agents able to effectively use external tools and knowledge is a heuristic and laborious task. Here, we introduce AvaTaR, a novel and automatic framework that optimizes an LLM agen…
▽ More
Large language model (LLM) agents have demonstrated impressive capability in utilizing external tools and knowledge to boost accuracy and reduce hallucinations. However, develo** the prompting techniques that make LLM agents able to effectively use external tools and knowledge is a heuristic and laborious task. Here, we introduce AvaTaR, a novel and automatic framework that optimizes an LLM agent to effectively use the provided tools and improve its performance on a given task/domain. During optimization, we design a comparator module to iteratively provide insightful and holistic prompts to the LLM agent via reasoning between positive and negative examples sampled from training data. We demonstrate AvaTaR on four complex multimodal retrieval datasets featuring textual, visual, and relational information. We find AvaTaR consistently outperforms state-of-the-art approaches across all four challenging tasks and exhibits strong generalization ability when applied to novel cases, achieving an average relative improvement of 14% on the Hit@1 metric. Code and dataset are available at https://github.com/zou-group/avatar.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2024; v1 submitted 17 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Context-Aware Clustering using Large Language Models
Authors:
Sindhu Tipirneni,
Ravinarayana Adkathimar,
Nurendra Choudhary,
Gaurush Hiranandani,
Rana Ali Amjad,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Changhe Yuan,
Chandan K. Reddy
Abstract:
Despite the remarkable success of Large Language Models (LLMs) in text understanding and generation, their potential for text clustering tasks remains underexplored. We observed that powerful closed-source LLMs provide good quality clusterings of entity sets but are not scalable due to the massive compute power required and the associated costs. Thus, we propose CACTUS (Context-Aware ClusTering wi…
▽ More
Despite the remarkable success of Large Language Models (LLMs) in text understanding and generation, their potential for text clustering tasks remains underexplored. We observed that powerful closed-source LLMs provide good quality clusterings of entity sets but are not scalable due to the massive compute power required and the associated costs. Thus, we propose CACTUS (Context-Aware ClusTering with aUgmented triplet losS), a systematic approach that leverages open-source LLMs for efficient and effective supervised clustering of entity subsets, particularly focusing on text-based entities. Existing text clustering methods fail to effectively capture the context provided by the entity subset. Moreover, though there are several language modeling based approaches for clustering, very few are designed for the task of supervised clustering. This paper introduces a novel approach towards clustering entity subsets using LLMs by capturing context via a scalable inter-entity attention mechanism. We propose a novel augmented triplet loss function tailored for supervised clustering, which addresses the inherent challenges of directly applying the triplet loss to this problem. Furthermore, we introduce a self-supervised clustering task based on text augmentation techniques to improve the generalization of our model. For evaluation, we collect ground truth clusterings from a closed-source LLM and transfer this knowledge to an open-source LLM under the supervised clustering framework, allowing a faster and cheaper open-source model to perform the same task. Experiments on various e-commerce query and product clustering datasets demonstrate that our proposed approach significantly outperforms existing unsupervised and supervised baselines under various external clustering evaluation metrics.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
STaRK: Benchmarking LLM Retrieval on Textual and Relational Knowledge Bases
Authors:
Shirley Wu,
Shiyu Zhao,
Michihiro Yasunaga,
Kexin Huang,
Kaidi Cao,
Qian Huang,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Karthik Subbian,
James Zou,
Jure Leskovec
Abstract:
Answering real-world complex queries, such as complex product search, often requires accurate retrieval from semi-structured knowledge bases that involve blend of unstructured (e.g., textual descriptions of products) and structured (e.g., entity relations of products) information. However, previous works have mostly studied textual and relational retrieval tasks as separate topics. To address the…
▽ More
Answering real-world complex queries, such as complex product search, often requires accurate retrieval from semi-structured knowledge bases that involve blend of unstructured (e.g., textual descriptions of products) and structured (e.g., entity relations of products) information. However, previous works have mostly studied textual and relational retrieval tasks as separate topics. To address the gap, we develop STARK, a large-scale Semi-structure retrieval benchmark on Textual and Relational K nowledge Bases. Our benchmark covers three domains/datasets: product search, academic paper search, and queries in precision medicine. We design a novel pipeline to synthesize realistic user queries that integrate diverse relational information and complex textual properties, together with their ground-truth answers (items). We conduct rigorous human evaluation to validate the quality of our synthesized queries. We further enhance the benchmark with high-quality human-generated queries to provide an authentic reference. STARK serves as a comprehensive testbed for evaluating the performance of retrieval systems driven by large language models (LLMs). Our experiments suggest that STARK presents significant challenges to the current retrieval and LLM systems, indicating the demand for building more capable retrieval systems. The benchmark data and code are available on https://github.com/snap-stanford/stark.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2024; v1 submitted 19 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
NetInfoF Framework: Measuring and Exploiting Network Usable Information
Authors:
Meng-Chieh Lee,
Haiyang Yu,
Jian Zhang,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Xiang Song,
Soji Adeshina,
Da Zheng,
Christos Faloutsos
Abstract:
Given a node-attributed graph, and a graph task (link prediction or node classification), can we tell if a graph neural network (GNN) will perform well? More specifically, do the graph structure and the node features carry enough usable information for the task? Our goals are (1) to develop a fast tool to measure how much information is in the graph structure and in the node features, and (2) to e…
▽ More
Given a node-attributed graph, and a graph task (link prediction or node classification), can we tell if a graph neural network (GNN) will perform well? More specifically, do the graph structure and the node features carry enough usable information for the task? Our goals are (1) to develop a fast tool to measure how much information is in the graph structure and in the node features, and (2) to exploit the information to solve the task, if there is enough. We propose NetInfoF, a framework including NetInfoF_Probe and NetInfoF_Act, for the measurement and the exploitation of network usable information (NUI), respectively. Given a graph data, NetInfoF_Probe measures NUI without any model training, and NetInfoF_Act solves link prediction and node classification, while two modules share the same backbone. In summary, NetInfoF has following notable advantages: (a) General, handling both link prediction and node classification; (b) Principled, with theoretical guarantee and closed-form solution; (c) Effective, thanks to the proposed adjustment to node similarity; (d) Scalable, scaling linearly with the input size. In our carefully designed synthetic datasets, NetInfoF correctly identifies the ground truth of NUI and is the only method being robust to all graph scenarios. Applied on real-world datasets, NetInfoF wins in 11 out of 12 times on link prediction compared to general GNN baselines.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2024; v1 submitted 12 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
BioBridge: Bridging Biomedical Foundation Models via Knowledge Graphs
Authors:
Zifeng Wang,
Zichen Wang,
Balasubramaniam Srinivasan,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Huzefa Rangwala,
Rishita Anubhai
Abstract:
Foundation models (FMs) are able to leverage large volumes of unlabeled data to demonstrate superior performance across a wide range of tasks. However, FMs developed for biomedical domains have largely remained unimodal, i.e., independently trained and used for tasks on protein sequences alone, small molecule structures alone, or clinical data alone. To overcome this limitation of biomedical FMs,…
▽ More
Foundation models (FMs) are able to leverage large volumes of unlabeled data to demonstrate superior performance across a wide range of tasks. However, FMs developed for biomedical domains have largely remained unimodal, i.e., independently trained and used for tasks on protein sequences alone, small molecule structures alone, or clinical data alone. To overcome this limitation of biomedical FMs, we present BioBridge, a novel parameter-efficient learning framework, to bridge independently trained unimodal FMs to establish multimodal behavior. BioBridge achieves it by utilizing Knowledge Graphs (KG) to learn transformations between one unimodal FM and another without fine-tuning any underlying unimodal FMs. Our empirical results demonstrate that BioBridge can beat the best baseline KG embedding methods (on average by around 76.3%) in cross-modal retrieval tasks. We also identify BioBridge demonstrates out-of-domain generalization ability by extrapolating to unseen modalities or relations. Additionally, we also show that BioBridge presents itself as a general purpose retriever that can aid biomedical multimodal question answering as well as enhance the guided generation of novel drugs.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2024; v1 submitted 5 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
TouchUp-G: Improving Feature Representation through Graph-Centric Finetuning
Authors:
**g Zhu,
Xiang Song,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Danai Koutra,
Christos Faloutsos
Abstract:
How can we enhance the node features acquired from Pretrained Models (PMs) to better suit downstream graph learning tasks? Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have become the state-of-the-art approach for many high-impact, real-world graph applications. For feature-rich graphs, a prevalent practice involves utilizing a PM directly to generate features, without incorporating any domain adaptation techniqu…
▽ More
How can we enhance the node features acquired from Pretrained Models (PMs) to better suit downstream graph learning tasks? Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have become the state-of-the-art approach for many high-impact, real-world graph applications. For feature-rich graphs, a prevalent practice involves utilizing a PM directly to generate features, without incorporating any domain adaptation techniques. Nevertheless, this practice is suboptimal because the node features extracted from PM are graph-agnostic and prevent GNNs from fully utilizing the potential correlations between the graph structure and node features, leading to a decline in GNNs performance. In this work, we seek to improve the node features obtained from a PM for downstream graph tasks and introduce TOUCHUP-G, which has several advantages. It is (a) General: applicable to any downstream graph task, including link prediction which is often employed in recommender systems; (b) Multi-modal: able to improve raw features of any modality (e.g. images, texts, audio); (c) Principled: it is closely related to a novel metric, feature homophily, which we propose to quantify the potential correlations between the graph structure and node features and we show that TOUCHUP-G can effectively shrink the discrepancy between the graph structure and node features; (d) Effective: achieving state-of-the-art results on four real-world datasets spanning different tasks and modalities.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Graph-Aware Language Model Pre-Training on a Large Graph Corpus Can Help Multiple Graph Applications
Authors:
Han Xie,
Da Zheng,
Jun Ma,
Houyu Zhang,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Xiang Song,
Qing **,
Sheng Wang,
Carl Yang,
Yi Xu,
Belinda Zeng,
Trishul Chilimbi
Abstract:
Model pre-training on large text corpora has been demonstrated effective for various downstream applications in the NLP domain. In the graph mining domain, a similar analogy can be drawn for pre-training graph models on large graphs in the hope of benefiting downstream graph applications, which has also been explored by several recent studies. However, no existing study has ever investigated the p…
▽ More
Model pre-training on large text corpora has been demonstrated effective for various downstream applications in the NLP domain. In the graph mining domain, a similar analogy can be drawn for pre-training graph models on large graphs in the hope of benefiting downstream graph applications, which has also been explored by several recent studies. However, no existing study has ever investigated the pre-training of text plus graph models on large heterogeneous graphs with abundant textual information (a.k.a. large graph corpora) and then fine-tuning the model on different related downstream applications with different graph schemas. To address this problem, we propose a framework of graph-aware language model pre-training (GALM) on a large graph corpus, which incorporates large language models and graph neural networks, and a variety of fine-tuning methods on downstream applications. We conduct extensive experiments on Amazon's real internal datasets and large public datasets. Comprehensive empirical results and in-depth analysis demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed methods along with lessons learned.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Pitfalls in Link Prediction with Graph Neural Networks: Understanding the Impact of Target-link Inclusion & Better Practices
Authors:
**g Zhu,
Yuhang Zhou,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Shengyi Qian,
Wei Ai,
Xiang Song,
Danai Koutra
Abstract:
While Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) are remarkably successful in a variety of high-impact applications, we demonstrate that, in link prediction, the common practices of including the edges being predicted in the graph at training and/or test have outsized impact on the performance of low-degree nodes. We theoretically and empirically investigate how these practices impact node-level performance acr…
▽ More
While Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) are remarkably successful in a variety of high-impact applications, we demonstrate that, in link prediction, the common practices of including the edges being predicted in the graph at training and/or test have outsized impact on the performance of low-degree nodes. We theoretically and empirically investigate how these practices impact node-level performance across different degrees. Specifically, we explore three issues that arise: (I1) overfitting; (I2) distribution shift; and (I3) implicit test leakage. The former two issues lead to poor generalizability to the test data, while the latter leads to overestimation of the model's performance and directly impacts the deployment of GNNs. To address these issues in a systematic way, we introduce an effective and efficient GNN training framework, SpotTarget, which leverages our insight on low-degree nodes: (1) at training time, it excludes a (training) edge to be predicted if it is incident to at least one low-degree node; and (2) at test time, it excludes all test edges to be predicted (thus, mimicking real scenarios of using GNNs, where the test data is not included in the graph). SpotTarget helps researchers and practitioners adhere to best practices for learning from graph data, which are frequently overlooked even by the most widely-used frameworks. Our experiments on various real-world datasets show that SpotTarget makes GNNs up to 15x more accurate in sparse graphs, and significantly improves their performance for low-degree nodes in dense graphs.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2023; v1 submitted 1 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Train Your Own GNN Teacher: Graph-Aware Distillation on Textual Graphs
Authors:
Costas Mavromatis,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Shen Wang,
Da Zheng,
Soji Adeshina,
Jun Ma,
Han Zhao,
Christos Faloutsos,
George Karypis
Abstract:
How can we learn effective node representations on textual graphs? Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) that use Language Models (LMs) to encode textual information of graphs achieve state-of-the-art performance in many node classification tasks. Yet, combining GNNs with LMs has not been widely explored for practical deployments due to its scalability issues. In this work, we tackle this challenge by deve…
▽ More
How can we learn effective node representations on textual graphs? Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) that use Language Models (LMs) to encode textual information of graphs achieve state-of-the-art performance in many node classification tasks. Yet, combining GNNs with LMs has not been widely explored for practical deployments due to its scalability issues. In this work, we tackle this challenge by develo** a Graph-Aware Distillation framework (GRAD) to encode graph structures into an LM for graph-free, fast inference. Different from conventional knowledge distillation, GRAD jointly optimizes a GNN teacher and a graph-free student over the graph's nodes via a shared LM. This encourages the graph-free student to exploit graph information encoded by the GNN teacher while at the same time, enables the GNN teacher to better leverage textual information from unlabeled nodes. As a result, the teacher and the student models learn from each other to improve their overall performance. Experiments in eight node classification benchmarks in both transductive and inductive settings showcase GRAD's superiority over existing distillation approaches for textual graphs.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
OrthoReg: Improving Graph-regularized MLPs via Orthogonality Regularization
Authors:
Hengrui Zhang,
Shen Wang,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Soji Adeshina,
Jiani Zhang,
Xiao Qin,
Christos Faloutsos,
Da Zheng,
George Karypis,
Philip S. Yu
Abstract:
Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) are currently dominating in modeling graph-structure data, while their high reliance on graph structure for inference significantly impedes them from widespread applications. By contrast, Graph-regularized MLPs (GR-MLPs) implicitly inject the graph structure information into model weights, while their performance can hardly match that of GNNs in most tasks. This motiva…
▽ More
Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) are currently dominating in modeling graph-structure data, while their high reliance on graph structure for inference significantly impedes them from widespread applications. By contrast, Graph-regularized MLPs (GR-MLPs) implicitly inject the graph structure information into model weights, while their performance can hardly match that of GNNs in most tasks. This motivates us to study the causes of the limited performance of GR-MLPs. In this paper, we first demonstrate that node embeddings learned from conventional GR-MLPs suffer from dimensional collapse, a phenomenon in which the largest a few eigenvalues dominate the embedding space, through empirical observations and theoretical analysis. As a result, the expressive power of the learned node representations is constrained. We further propose OrthoReg, a novel GR-MLP model to mitigate the dimensional collapse issue. Through a soft regularization loss on the correlation matrix of node embeddings, OrthoReg explicitly encourages orthogonal node representations and thus can naturally avoid dimensionally collapsed representations. Experiments on traditional transductive semi-supervised classification tasks and inductive node classification for cold-start scenarios demonstrate its effectiveness and superiority.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Predicting Cellular Responses with Variational Causal Inference and Refined Relational Information
Authors:
Yulun Wu,
Robert A. Barton,
Zichen Wang,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Carlo De Donno,
Layne C. Price,
Luis F. Voloch,
George Karypis
Abstract:
Predicting the responses of a cell under perturbations may bring important benefits to drug discovery and personalized therapeutics. In this work, we propose a novel graph variational Bayesian causal inference framework to predict a cell's gene expressions under counterfactual perturbations (perturbations that this cell did not factually receive), leveraging information representing biological kno…
▽ More
Predicting the responses of a cell under perturbations may bring important benefits to drug discovery and personalized therapeutics. In this work, we propose a novel graph variational Bayesian causal inference framework to predict a cell's gene expressions under counterfactual perturbations (perturbations that this cell did not factually receive), leveraging information representing biological knowledge in the form of gene regulatory networks (GRNs) to aid individualized cellular response predictions. Aiming at a data-adaptive GRN, we also developed an adjacency matrix updating technique for graph convolutional networks and used it to refine GRNs during pre-training, which generated more insights on gene relations and enhanced model performance. Additionally, we propose a robust estimator within our framework for the asymptotically efficient estimation of marginal perturbation effect, which is yet to be carried out in previous works. With extensive experiments, we exhibited the advantage of our approach over state-of-the-art deep learning models for individual response prediction.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2023; v1 submitted 30 September, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Variational Causal Inference
Authors:
Yulun Wu,
Layne C. Price,
Zichen Wang,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Robert A. Barton,
George Karypis
Abstract:
Estimating an individual's potential outcomes under counterfactual treatments is a challenging task for traditional causal inference and supervised learning approaches when the outcome is high-dimensional (e.g. gene expressions, impulse responses, human faces) and covariates are relatively limited. In this case, to construct one's outcome under a counterfactual treatment, it is crucial to leverage…
▽ More
Estimating an individual's potential outcomes under counterfactual treatments is a challenging task for traditional causal inference and supervised learning approaches when the outcome is high-dimensional (e.g. gene expressions, impulse responses, human faces) and covariates are relatively limited. In this case, to construct one's outcome under a counterfactual treatment, it is crucial to leverage individual information contained in its observed factual outcome on top of the covariates. We propose a deep variational Bayesian framework that rigorously integrates two main sources of information for outcome construction under a counterfactual treatment: one source is the individual features embedded in the high-dimensional factual outcome; the other source is the response distribution of similar subjects (subjects with the same covariates) that factually received this treatment of interest.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2023; v1 submitted 13 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Efficient and effective training of language and graph neural network models
Authors:
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Xiang Song,
Da Zheng,
Houyu Zhang,
Jun Ma,
Yi Xu,
Belinda Zeng,
Trishul Chilimbi,
George Karypis
Abstract:
Can we combine heterogenous graph structure with text to learn high-quality semantic and behavioural representations? Graph neural networks (GNN)s encode numerical node attributes and graph structure to achieve impressive performance in a variety of supervised learning tasks. Current GNN approaches are challenged by textual features, which typically need to be encoded to a numerical vector before…
▽ More
Can we combine heterogenous graph structure with text to learn high-quality semantic and behavioural representations? Graph neural networks (GNN)s encode numerical node attributes and graph structure to achieve impressive performance in a variety of supervised learning tasks. Current GNN approaches are challenged by textual features, which typically need to be encoded to a numerical vector before provided to the GNN that may incur some information loss. In this paper, we put forth an efficient and effective framework termed language model GNN (LM-GNN) to jointly train large-scale language models and graph neural networks. The effectiveness in our framework is achieved by applying stage-wise fine-tuning of the BERT model first with heterogenous graph information and then with a GNN model. Several system and design optimizations are proposed to enable scalable and efficient training. LM-GNN accommodates node and edge classification as well as link prediction tasks. We evaluate the LM-GNN framework in different datasets performance and showcase the effectiveness of the proposed approach. LM-GNN provides competitive results in an Amazon query-purchase-product application.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
A Robust Stacking Framework for Training Deep Graph Models with Multifaceted Node Features
Authors:
Jiuhai Chen,
Jonas Mueller,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Tom Goldstein,
David Wipf
Abstract:
Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) with numerical node features and graph structure as inputs have demonstrated superior performance on various supervised learning tasks with graph data. However the numerical node features utilized by GNNs are commonly extracted from raw data which is of text or tabular (numeric/categorical) type in most real-world applications. The best models for such data types in mo…
▽ More
Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) with numerical node features and graph structure as inputs have demonstrated superior performance on various supervised learning tasks with graph data. However the numerical node features utilized by GNNs are commonly extracted from raw data which is of text or tabular (numeric/categorical) type in most real-world applications. The best models for such data types in most standard supervised learning settings with IID (non-graph) data are not simple neural network layers and thus are not easily incorporated into a GNN. Here we propose a robust stacking framework that fuses graph-aware propagation with arbitrary models intended for IID data, which are ensembled and stacked in multiple layers. Our layer-wise framework leverages bagging and stacking strategies to enjoy strong generalization, in a manner which effectively mitigates label leakage and overfitting. Across a variety of graph datasets with tabular/text node features, our method achieves comparable or superior performance relative to both tabular/text and graph neural network models, as well as existing state-of-the-art hybrid strategies that combine the two.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
TempoQR: Temporal Question Reasoning over Knowledge Graphs
Authors:
Costas Mavromatis,
Prasanna Lakkur Subramanyam,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Soji Adeshina,
Phillip R. Howard,
Tetiana Grinberg,
Nagib Hakim,
George Karypis
Abstract:
Knowledge Graph Question Answering (KGQA) involves retrieving facts from a Knowledge Graph (KG) using natural language queries. A KG is a curated set of facts consisting of entities linked by relations. Certain facts include also temporal information forming a Temporal KG (TKG). Although many natural questions involve explicit or implicit time constraints, question answering (QA) over TKGs has bee…
▽ More
Knowledge Graph Question Answering (KGQA) involves retrieving facts from a Knowledge Graph (KG) using natural language queries. A KG is a curated set of facts consisting of entities linked by relations. Certain facts include also temporal information forming a Temporal KG (TKG). Although many natural questions involve explicit or implicit time constraints, question answering (QA) over TKGs has been a relatively unexplored area. Existing solutions are mainly designed for simple temporal questions that can be answered directly by a single TKG fact. This paper puts forth a comprehensive embedding-based framework for answering complex questions over TKGs. Our method termed temporal question reasoning (TempoQR) exploits TKG embeddings to ground the question to the specific entities and time scope it refers to. It does so by augmenting the question embeddings with context, entity and time-aware information by employing three specialized modules. The first computes a textual representation of a given question, the second combines it with the entity embeddings for entities involved in the question, and the third generates question-specific time embeddings. Finally, a transformer-based encoder learns to fuse the generated temporal information with the question representation, which is used for answer predictions. Extensive experiments show that TempoQR improves accuracy by 25--45 percentage points on complex temporal questions over state-of-the-art approaches and it generalizes better to unseen question types.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Does your graph need a confidence boost? Convergent boosted smoothing on graphs with tabular node features
Authors:
Jiuhai Chen,
Jonas Mueller,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Soji Adeshina,
Yangkun Wang,
Tom Goldstein,
David Wipf
Abstract:
For supervised learning with tabular data, decision tree ensembles produced via boosting techniques generally dominate real-world applications involving iid training/test sets. However for graph data where the iid assumption is violated due to structured relations between samples, it remains unclear how to best incorporate this structure within existing boosting pipelines. To this end, we propose…
▽ More
For supervised learning with tabular data, decision tree ensembles produced via boosting techniques generally dominate real-world applications involving iid training/test sets. However for graph data where the iid assumption is violated due to structured relations between samples, it remains unclear how to best incorporate this structure within existing boosting pipelines. To this end, we propose a generalized framework for iterating boosting with graph propagation steps that share node/sample information across edges connecting related samples. Unlike previous efforts to integrate graph-based models with boosting, our approach is anchored in a principled meta loss function such that provable convergence can be guaranteed under relatively mild assumptions. Across a variety of non-iid graph datasets with tabular node features, our method achieves comparable or superior performance than both tabular and graph neural network models, as well as existing hybrid strategies that combine the two. Beyond producing better predictive performance than recently proposed graph models, our proposed techniques are easy to implement, computationally more efficient, and enjoy stronger theoretical guarantees (which make our results more reproducible).
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2022; v1 submitted 26 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Scalable Consistency Training for Graph Neural Networks via Self-Ensemble Self-Distillation
Authors:
Cole Hawkins,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Soji Adeshina,
George Karypis
Abstract:
Consistency training is a popular method to improve deep learning models in computer vision and natural language processing. Graph neural networks (GNNs) have achieved remarkable performance in a variety of network science learning tasks, but to date no work has studied the effect of consistency training on large-scale graph problems. GNNs scale to large graphs by minibatch training and subsample…
▽ More
Consistency training is a popular method to improve deep learning models in computer vision and natural language processing. Graph neural networks (GNNs) have achieved remarkable performance in a variety of network science learning tasks, but to date no work has studied the effect of consistency training on large-scale graph problems. GNNs scale to large graphs by minibatch training and subsample node neighbors to deal with high degree nodes. We utilize the randomness inherent in the subsampling of neighbors and introduce a novel consistency training method to improve accuracy. For a target node we generate different neighborhood expansions, and distill the knowledge of the average of the predictions to the GNN. Our method approximates the expected prediction of the possible neighborhood samples and practically only requires a few samples. We demonstrate that our training method outperforms standard GNN training in several different settings, and yields the largest gains when label rates are low.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Unveiling Anomalous Edges and Nominal Connectivity of Attributed Networks
Authors:
Konstantinos D. Polyzos,
Costas Mavromatis,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Georgios B. Giannakis
Abstract:
Uncovering anomalies in attributed networks has recently gained popularity due to its importance in unveiling outliers and flagging adversarial behavior in a gamut of data and network science applications including {the Internet of Things (IoT)}, finance, security, to list a few. The present work deals with uncovering anomalous edges in attributed graphs using two distinct formulations with comple…
▽ More
Uncovering anomalies in attributed networks has recently gained popularity due to its importance in unveiling outliers and flagging adversarial behavior in a gamut of data and network science applications including {the Internet of Things (IoT)}, finance, security, to list a few. The present work deals with uncovering anomalous edges in attributed graphs using two distinct formulations with complementary strengths, which can be easily distributed, and hence efficient. The first relies on decomposing the graph data matrix into low rank plus sparse components to markedly improve performance. The second broadens the scope of the first by performing robust recovery of the unperturbed graph, which enhances the anomaly identification performance. The novel methods not only capture anomalous edges linking nodes of different communities, but also spurious connections between any two nodes with different features. Experiments conducted on real and synthetic data corroborate the effectiveness of both methods in the anomaly identification task.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
COVID-19 Knowledge Graph: Accelerating Information Retrieval and Discovery for Scientific Literature
Authors:
Colby Wise,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Miguel Romero Calvo,
Xiang Song,
George Price,
Ninad Kulkarni,
Ryan Brand,
Parminder Bhatia,
George Karypis
Abstract:
The coronavirus disease (COVID-19) has claimed the lives of over 350,000 people and infected more than 6 million people worldwide. Several search engines have surfaced to provide researchers with additional tools to find and retrieve information from the rapidly growing corpora on COVID-19. These engines lack extraction and visualization tools necessary to retrieve and interpret complex relations…
▽ More
The coronavirus disease (COVID-19) has claimed the lives of over 350,000 people and infected more than 6 million people worldwide. Several search engines have surfaced to provide researchers with additional tools to find and retrieve information from the rapidly growing corpora on COVID-19. These engines lack extraction and visualization tools necessary to retrieve and interpret complex relations inherent to scientific literature. Moreover, because these engines mainly rely upon semantic information, their ability to capture complex global relationships across documents is limited, which reduces the quality of similarity-based article recommendations for users. In this work, we present the COVID-19 Knowledge Graph (CKG), a heterogeneous graph for extracting and visualizing complex relationships between COVID-19 scientific articles. The CKG combines semantic information with document topological information for the application of similar document retrieval. The CKG is constructed using the latent schema of the data, and then enriched with biomedical entity information extracted from the unstructured text of articles using scalable AWS technologies to form relations in the graph. Finally, we propose a document similarity engine that leverages low-dimensional graph embeddings from the CKG with semantic embeddings for similar article retrieval. Analysis demonstrates the quality of relationships in the CKG and shows that it can be used to uncover meaningful information in COVID-19 scientific articles. The CKG helps power www.cord19.aws and is publicly available.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
PanRep: Graph neural networks for extracting universal node embeddings in heterogeneous graphs
Authors:
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Da Zheng,
George Karypis
Abstract:
Learning unsupervised node embeddings facilitates several downstream tasks such as node classification and link prediction. A node embedding is universal if it is designed to be used by and benefit various downstream tasks. This work introduces PanRep, a graph neural network (GNN) model, for unsupervised learning of universal node representations for heterogenous graphs. PanRep consists of a GNN e…
▽ More
Learning unsupervised node embeddings facilitates several downstream tasks such as node classification and link prediction. A node embedding is universal if it is designed to be used by and benefit various downstream tasks. This work introduces PanRep, a graph neural network (GNN) model, for unsupervised learning of universal node representations for heterogenous graphs. PanRep consists of a GNN encoder that obtains node embeddings and four decoders, each capturing different topological and node feature properties. Abiding to these properties the novel unsupervised framework learns universal embeddings applicable to different downstream tasks. PanRep can be furthered fine-tuned to account for possible limited labels. In this operational setting PanRep is considered as a pretrained model for extracting node embeddings of heterogenous graph data. PanRep outperforms all unsupervised and certain supervised methods in node classification and link prediction, especially when the labeled data for the supervised methods is small. PanRep-FT (with fine-tuning) outperforms all other supervised approaches, which corroborates the merits of pretraining models. Finally, we apply PanRep-FT for discovering novel drugs for Covid-19. We showcase the advantage of universal embeddings in drug repurposing and identify several drugs used in clinical trials as possible drug candidates.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2021; v1 submitted 20 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Few-shot link prediction via graph neural networks for Covid-19 drug-repurposing
Authors:
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Da Zheng,
George Karypis
Abstract:
Predicting interactions among heterogenous graph structured data has numerous applications such as knowledge graph completion, recommendation systems and drug discovery. Often times, the links to be predicted belong to rare types such as the case in repurposing drugs for novel diseases. This motivates the task of few-shot link prediction. Typically, GCNs are ill-equipped in learning such rare link…
▽ More
Predicting interactions among heterogenous graph structured data has numerous applications such as knowledge graph completion, recommendation systems and drug discovery. Often times, the links to be predicted belong to rare types such as the case in repurposing drugs for novel diseases. This motivates the task of few-shot link prediction. Typically, GCNs are ill-equipped in learning such rare link types since the relation embedding is not learned in an inductive fashion. This paper proposes an inductive RGCN for learning informative relation embeddings even in the few-shot learning regime. The proposed inductive model significantly outperforms the RGCN and state-of-the-art KGE models in few-shot learning tasks. Furthermore, we apply our method on the drug-repurposing knowledge graph (DRKG) for discovering drugs for Covid-19. We pose the drug discovery task as link prediction and learn embeddings for the biological entities that partake in the DRKG. Our initial results corroborate that several drugs used in clinical trials were identified as possible drug candidates. The method in this paper are implemented using the efficient deep graph learning (DGL)
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Tensor Graph Convolutional Networks for Multi-relational and Robust Learning
Authors:
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Antonio G. Marques,
Georgios B. Giannakis
Abstract:
The era of "data deluge" has sparked renewed interest in graph-based learning methods and their widespread applications ranging from sociology and biology to transportation and communications. In this context of graph-aware methods, the present paper introduces a tensor-graph convolutional network (TGCN) for scalable semi-supervised learning (SSL) from data associated with a collection of graphs,…
▽ More
The era of "data deluge" has sparked renewed interest in graph-based learning methods and their widespread applications ranging from sociology and biology to transportation and communications. In this context of graph-aware methods, the present paper introduces a tensor-graph convolutional network (TGCN) for scalable semi-supervised learning (SSL) from data associated with a collection of graphs, that are represented by a tensor. Key aspects of the novel TGCN architecture are the dynamic adaptation to different relations in the tensor graph via learnable weights, and the consideration of graph-based regularizers to promote smoothness and alleviate over-parameterization. The ultimate goal is to design a powerful learning architecture able to: discover complex and highly nonlinear data associations, combine (and select) multiple types of relations, scale gracefully with the graph size, and remain robust to perturbations on the graph edges. The proposed architecture is relevant not only in applications where the nodes are naturally involved in different relations (e.g., a multi-relational graph capturing family, friendship and work relations in a social network), but also in robust learning setups where the graph entails a certain level of uncertainty, and the different tensor slabs correspond to different versions (realizations) of the nominal graph. Numerical tests showcase that the proposed architecture achieves markedly improved performance relative to standard GCNs, copes with state-of-the-art adversarial attacks, and leads to remarkable SSL performance over protein-to-protein interaction networks.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Efficient and Stable Graph Scattering Transforms via Pruning
Authors:
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Siheng Chen,
Georgios B. Giannakis
Abstract:
Graph convolutional networks (GCNs) have well-documented performance in various graph learning tasks, but their analysis is still at its infancy. Graph scattering transforms (GSTs) offer training-free deep GCN models that extract features from graph data, and are amenable to generalization and stability analyses. The price paid by GSTs is exponential complexity in space and time that increases wit…
▽ More
Graph convolutional networks (GCNs) have well-documented performance in various graph learning tasks, but their analysis is still at its infancy. Graph scattering transforms (GSTs) offer training-free deep GCN models that extract features from graph data, and are amenable to generalization and stability analyses. The price paid by GSTs is exponential complexity in space and time that increases with the number of layers. This discourages deployment of GSTs when a deep architecture is needed. The present work addresses the complexity limitation of GSTs by introducing an efficient so-termed pruned (p)GST approach. The resultant pruning algorithm is guided by a graph-spectrum-inspired criterion, and retains informative scattering features on-the-fly while bypassing the exponential complexity associated with GSTs. Stability of the novel pGSTs is also established when the input graph data or the network structure are perturbed. Furthermore, the sensitivity of pGST to random and localized signal perturbations is investigated analytically and experimentally. Numerical tests showcase that pGST performs comparably to the baseline GST at considerable computational savings. Furthermore, pGST achieves comparable performance to state-of-the-art GCNs in graph and 3D point cloud classification tasks. Upon analyzing the pGST pruning patterns, it is shown that graph data in different domains call for different network architectures, and that the pruning algorithm may be employed to guide the design choices for contemporary GCNs.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Edge Dithering for Robust Adaptive Graph Convolutional Networks
Authors:
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Georgios B. Giannakis
Abstract:
Graph convolutional networks (GCNs) are vulnerable to perturbations of the graph structure that are either random, or, adversarially designed. The perturbed links modify the graph neighborhoods, which critically affects the performance of GCNs in semi-supervised learning (SSL) tasks. Aiming at robustifying GCNs conditioned on the perturbed graph, the present paper generates multiple auxiliary grap…
▽ More
Graph convolutional networks (GCNs) are vulnerable to perturbations of the graph structure that are either random, or, adversarially designed. The perturbed links modify the graph neighborhoods, which critically affects the performance of GCNs in semi-supervised learning (SSL) tasks. Aiming at robustifying GCNs conditioned on the perturbed graph, the present paper generates multiple auxiliary graphs, each having its binary 0-1 edge weights flip values with probabilities designed to enhance robustness. The resultant edge-dithered auxiliary graphs are leveraged by an adaptive (A)GCN that performs SSL. Robustness is enabled through learnable graph-combining weights along with suitable regularizers. Relative to GCN, the novel AGCN achieves markedly improved performance in tests with noisy inputs, graph perturbations, and state-of-the-art adversarial attacks. Further experiments with protein interaction networks showcase the competitive performance of AGCN for SSL over multiple graphs.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
GraphSAC: Detecting anomalies in large-scale graphs
Authors:
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Dimitris Berberidis,
Georgios B. Giannakis
Abstract:
A graph-based sampling and consensus (GraphSAC) approach is introduced to effectively detect anomalous nodes in large-scale graphs. Existing approaches rely on connectivity and attributes of all nodes to assign an anomaly score per node. However, nodal attributes and network links might be compromised by adversaries, rendering these holistic approaches vulnerable. Alleviating this limitation, Grap…
▽ More
A graph-based sampling and consensus (GraphSAC) approach is introduced to effectively detect anomalous nodes in large-scale graphs. Existing approaches rely on connectivity and attributes of all nodes to assign an anomaly score per node. However, nodal attributes and network links might be compromised by adversaries, rendering these holistic approaches vulnerable. Alleviating this limitation, GraphSAC randomly draws subsets of nodes, and relies on graph-aware criteria to judiciously filter out sets contaminated by anomalous nodes, before employing a semi-supervised learning (SSL) module to estimate nominal label distributions per node. These learned nominal distributions are minimally affected by the anomalous nodes, and hence can be directly adopted for anomaly detection. Rigorous analysis provides performance guarantees for GraphSAC, by bounding the required number of draws. The per-draw complexity grows linearly with the number of edges, which implies efficient SSL, while draws can be run in parallel, thereby ensuring scalability to large graphs. GraphSAC is tested under different anomaly generation models based on random walks, clustered anomalies, as well as contemporary adversarial attacks for graph data. Experiments with real-world graphs showcase the advantage of GraphSAC relative to state-of-the-art alternatives.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
A Recurrent Graph Neural Network for Multi-Relational Data
Authors:
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Antonio G. Marques,
Georgios B. Giannakis
Abstract:
The era of data deluge has sparked the interest in graph-based learning methods in a number of disciplines such as sociology, biology, neuroscience, or engineering. In this paper, we introduce a graph recurrent neural network (GRNN) for scalable semi-supervised learning from multi-relational data. Key aspects of the novel GRNN architecture are the use of multi-relational graphs, the dynamic adapta…
▽ More
The era of data deluge has sparked the interest in graph-based learning methods in a number of disciplines such as sociology, biology, neuroscience, or engineering. In this paper, we introduce a graph recurrent neural network (GRNN) for scalable semi-supervised learning from multi-relational data. Key aspects of the novel GRNN architecture are the use of multi-relational graphs, the dynamic adaptation to the different relations via learnable weights, and the consideration of graph-based regularizers to promote smoothness and alleviate over-parametrization. Our ultimate goal is to design a powerful learning architecture able to: discover complex and highly non-linear data associations, combine (and select) multiple types of relations, and scale gracefully with respect to the size of the graph. Numerical tests with real data sets corroborate the design goals and illustrate the performance gains relative to competing alternatives.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2019; v1 submitted 5 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Coupled Graphs and Tensor Factorization for Recommender Systems and Community Detection
Authors:
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Ahmed S. Zamzam,
Georgios B. Giannakis,
Nicholas D. Sidiropoulos
Abstract:
Joint analysis of data from multiple information repositories facilitates uncovering the underlying structure in heterogeneous datasets. Single and coupled matrix-tensor factorization (CMTF) has been widely used in this context for imputation-based recommendation from ratings, social network, and other user-item data. When this side information is in the form of item-item correlation matrices or g…
▽ More
Joint analysis of data from multiple information repositories facilitates uncovering the underlying structure in heterogeneous datasets. Single and coupled matrix-tensor factorization (CMTF) has been widely used in this context for imputation-based recommendation from ratings, social network, and other user-item data. When this side information is in the form of item-item correlation matrices or graphs, existing CMTF algorithms may fall short. Alleviating current limitations, we introduce a novel model coined coupled graph-tensor factorization (CGTF) that judiciously accounts for graph-related side information. The CGTF model has the potential to overcome practical challenges, such as missing slabs from the tensor and/or missing rows/columns from the correlation matrices. A novel alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM) is also developed that recovers the nonnegative factors of CGTF. Our algorithm enjoys closed-form updates that result in reduced computational complexity and allow for convergence claims. A novel direction is further explored by employing the interpretable factors to detect graph communities having the tensor as side information. The resulting community detection approach is successful even when some links in the graphs are missing. Results with real data sets corroborate the merits of the proposed methods relative to state-of-the-art competing factorization techniques in providing recommendations and detecting communities.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2019; v1 submitted 21 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Semi-Blind Inference of Topologies and Dynamical Processes over Graphs
Authors:
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Yanning Shen,
Georgios B. Giannakis
Abstract:
Network science provides valuable insights across numerous disciplines including sociology, biology, neuroscience and engineering. A task of major practical importance in these application domains is inferring the network structure from noisy observations at a subset of nodes. Available methods for topology inference typically assume that the process over the network is observed at all nodes. Howe…
▽ More
Network science provides valuable insights across numerous disciplines including sociology, biology, neuroscience and engineering. A task of major practical importance in these application domains is inferring the network structure from noisy observations at a subset of nodes. Available methods for topology inference typically assume that the process over the network is observed at all nodes. However, application-specific constraints may prevent acquiring network-wide observations. Alleviating the limited flexibility of existing approaches, this work advocates structural models for graph processes and develops novel algorithms for joint inference of the network topology and processes from partial nodal observations. Structural equation models (SEMs) and structural vector autoregressive models (SVARMs) have well-documented merits in identifying even directed topologies of complex graphs; while SEMs capture contemporaneous causal dependencies among nodes, SVARMs further account for time-lagged influences. This paper develops algorithms that iterate between inferring directed graphs that "best" fit the data, and estimating the network processes at reduced computational complexity by leveraging tools related to Kalman smoothing. To further accommodate delay-sensitive applications, an online joint inference approach is put forth that even tracks time-evolving topologies. Furthermore, conditions for identifying the network topology given partial observations are specified. It is proved that the required number of observations for unique identification reduces significantly when the network structure is sparse. Numerical tests with synthetic as well as real datasets corroborate the effectiveness of the novel approach.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Kernel-based Inference of Functions over Graphs
Authors:
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Meng Ma,
Athanasios N. Nikolakopoulos,
Georgios B. Giannakis,
Daniel Romero
Abstract:
The study of networks has witnessed an explosive growth over the past decades with several ground-breaking methods introduced. A particularly interesting -- and prevalent in several fields of study -- problem is that of inferring a function defined over the nodes of a network. This work presents a versatile kernel-based framework for tackling this inference problem that naturally subsumes and gene…
▽ More
The study of networks has witnessed an explosive growth over the past decades with several ground-breaking methods introduced. A particularly interesting -- and prevalent in several fields of study -- problem is that of inferring a function defined over the nodes of a network. This work presents a versatile kernel-based framework for tackling this inference problem that naturally subsumes and generalizes the reconstruction approaches put forth recently by the signal processing on graphs community. Both the static and the dynamic settings are considered along with effective modeling approaches for addressing real-world problems. The herein analytical discussion is complemented by a set of numerical examples, which showcase the effectiveness of the presented techniques, as well as their merits related to state-of-the-art methods.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2018; v1 submitted 28 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Inference of Spatio-Temporal Functions over Graphs via Multi-Kernel Kriged Kalman Filtering
Authors:
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Daniel Romero,
Georgios B. Giannakis
Abstract:
Inference of space-time varying signals on graphs emerges naturally in a plethora of network science related applications. A frequently encountered challenge pertains to reconstructing such dynamic processes, given their values over a subset of vertices and time instants. The present paper develops a graph-aware kernel-based kriged Kalman filter that accounts for the spatio-temporal variations, an…
▽ More
Inference of space-time varying signals on graphs emerges naturally in a plethora of network science related applications. A frequently encountered challenge pertains to reconstructing such dynamic processes, given their values over a subset of vertices and time instants. The present paper develops a graph-aware kernel-based kriged Kalman filter that accounts for the spatio-temporal variations, and offers efficient online reconstruction, even for dynamically evolving network topologies. The kernel-based learning framework bypasses the need for statistical information by capitalizing on the smoothness that graph signals exhibit with respect to the underlying graph. To address the challenge of selecting the appropriate kernel, the proposed filter is combined with a multi-kernel selection module. Such a data-driven method selects a kernel attuned to the signal dynamics on-the-fly within the linear span of a pre-selected dictionary. The novel multi-kernel learning algorithm exploits the eigenstructure of Laplacian kernel matrices to reduce computational complexity. Numerical tests with synthetic and real data demonstrate the superior reconstruction performance of the novel approach relative to state-of-the-art alternatives.
△ Less
Submitted 25 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Kernel-based Reconstruction of Space-time Functions on Dynamic Graphs
Authors:
Daniel Romero,
Vassilis N. Ioannidis,
Georgios B. Giannakis
Abstract:
Graph-based methods pervade the inference toolkits of numerous disciplines including sociology, biology, neuroscience, physics, chemistry, and engineering. A challenging problem encountered in this context pertains to determining the attributes of a set of vertices given those of another subset at possibly different time instants. Leveraging spatiotemporal dynamics can drastically reduce the numbe…
▽ More
Graph-based methods pervade the inference toolkits of numerous disciplines including sociology, biology, neuroscience, physics, chemistry, and engineering. A challenging problem encountered in this context pertains to determining the attributes of a set of vertices given those of another subset at possibly different time instants. Leveraging spatiotemporal dynamics can drastically reduce the number of observed vertices, and hence the cost of sampling. Alleviating the limited flexibility of existing approaches, the present paper broadens the existing kernel-based graph function reconstruction framework to accommodate time-evolving functions over possibly time-evolving topologies. This approach inherits the versatility and generality of kernel-based methods, for which no knowledge on distributions or second-order statistics is required. Systematic guidelines are provided to construct two families of space-time kernels with complementary strengths. The first facilitates judicious control of regularization on a space-time frequency plane, whereas the second can afford time-varying topologies. Batch and online estimators are also put forth, and a novel kernel Kalman filter is developed to obtain these estimates at affordable computational cost. Numerical tests with real data sets corroborate the merits of the proposed methods relative to competing alternatives.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2017; v1 submitted 12 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.