-
Chance Constrained Probability Measure Optimization: Problem Formulation, Equivalent Reduction, and Sample-based Approximation
Authors:
Xun Shen,
Yuhu Wu,
Satoshi Ito,
Jun-ichi Imura
Abstract:
Choosing decision variables deterministically (deterministic decision-making) can be regarded as a particular case of choosing decision variables probabilistically (probabilistic decision-making). It is necessary to investigate whether probabilistic decision-making can further improve the expected decision-making performance than deterministic decision-making when chance constraints exist. The pro…
▽ More
Choosing decision variables deterministically (deterministic decision-making) can be regarded as a particular case of choosing decision variables probabilistically (probabilistic decision-making). It is necessary to investigate whether probabilistic decision-making can further improve the expected decision-making performance than deterministic decision-making when chance constraints exist. The problem formulation of optimizing a probabilistic decision under chance constraints has not been formally investigated. In this paper, for the first time, the problem formulation of Chance Constrained Probability Measure Optimization (CCPMO) is presented to realize optimal probabilistic decision-making under chance constraints. We first prove the existence of the optimal solution to CCPMO. It is further shown that there is an optimal solution of CCPMO with the probability measure concentrated on two decisions, leading to an equivalently reduced problem of CCPMO. The reduced problem still has chance constraints due to random variables. We then extend the sample-based smooth approximation method to solve the reduced problem. Samples of model uncertainties are used to establish an approximate problem of the reduced problem. Algorithms for general nonlinear programming problems can solve the approximate problem. The solution of the approximate problem is an approximate solution of CCPMO. A numerical example of controlling a quadrotor in turbulent conditions has been conducted to validate the proposed probabilistic decision-making under chance constraints.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Distributed Design of Glocal Controllers via Hierarchical Model Decomposition
Authors:
Hampei Sasahara,
Takayuki Ishizaki,
Jun-ichi Imura,
Henrik Sandberg,
Karl Henrik Johansson
Abstract:
This paper proposes a distributed design method of controllers having a glocal (global/local) information structure for large-scale network systems. Distributed design, independent design of all subcontrollers that constitute a structured controller, facilitates scalable controller synthesis. While existing distributed design methods confine attention to the decentralized or distributed informatio…
▽ More
This paper proposes a distributed design method of controllers having a glocal (global/local) information structure for large-scale network systems. Distributed design, independent design of all subcontrollers that constitute a structured controller, facilitates scalable controller synthesis. While existing distributed design methods confine attention to the decentralized or distributed information structures, this study addresses distributed design of glocal-structured controllers. Glocal control exploits the nature that network system's behavior can typically be represented as a superposition of spatially local fluctuations and global interarea oscillations by incorporating a global coordinating subcontroller with local decentralized subcontrollers. The key idea to distributed design of glocal controllers is to represent the original network system as a hierarchical cascaded system composed of reduced-order models representing the global and local dynamics, referred to as hierarchical model decomposition. Distributed design is achieved by independently designing and implementing subcontrollers for the reduced-order models while preserving the cascade structure. This paper provides a condition for existence of the hierarchical model decomposition, a specific representation of the hierarchical system, a clustering method appropriate for the proposed approach, and a robust extension. Numerical examples of a power grid evidence the practical relevance of the proposed method.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Disconnection-aware Attack Detection and Isolation with Separation-based Detector Reconfiguration
Authors:
Hampei Sasahara,
Takayuki Ishizaki,
Jun-ichi Imura,
Henrik Sandberg
Abstract:
This study addresses incident handling during an adverse event for dynamical networked control systems. Incident handling can be divided into five steps: detection, analysis, containment, eradication, and recovery. For networked control systems, the containment step can be conducted through physical disconnection of an attacked subsystem. In accordance with the disconnection, the equipped attack d…
▽ More
This study addresses incident handling during an adverse event for dynamical networked control systems. Incident handling can be divided into five steps: detection, analysis, containment, eradication, and recovery. For networked control systems, the containment step can be conducted through physical disconnection of an attacked subsystem. In accordance with the disconnection, the equipped attack detection unit should be reconfigured to maintain its detection capability. In particular, separating the detection subunit associated with the disconnected subsystem is considered as a specific reconfiguration scheme in this study. This paper poses the problem of disconnection-aware attack detection and isolation with the separation-based detector reconfiguration. The objective is to find an attack detection unit that preserves its detection and isolation capability even under any possible disconnection and separation. The difficulty arises from network topology variation caused by disconnection that can possibly lead to stability loss of the distributed observer inside the attack detection unit. A solution is proposed based on an existing controller design technique referred to as retrofit control. Furthermore, an application to low-voltage power distribution networks with distributed generation is exhibited. Numerical examples evidence the practical use of the proposed method through a benchmark distribution network.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2021; v1 submitted 23 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Parameterization of All Output-Rectifying Retrofit Controllers
Authors:
Hampei Sasahara,
Takayuki Ishizaki,
Jun-ichi Imura
Abstract:
This study investigates a parameterization of all output-rectifying retrofit controllers for distributed design of a structured controller. It has been discovered that all retrofit controllers can be characterized as a constrained Youla parameterization, which is difficult to solve analytically. For synthesis, a tractable and insightful class of retrofit controllers, referred to as output-rectifyi…
▽ More
This study investigates a parameterization of all output-rectifying retrofit controllers for distributed design of a structured controller. It has been discovered that all retrofit controllers can be characterized as a constrained Youla parameterization, which is difficult to solve analytically. For synthesis, a tractable and insightful class of retrofit controllers, referred to as output-rectifying retrofit controllers, has been introduced. An unconstrained parameterization of all output-rectifying retrofit controllers can be derived under a technical assumption on measurability of particular signals. The aim of this note is to reveal the structure of all output-rectifying retrofit controllers in the general output-feedback case. It is found out that the existing developments can be generalized based on the notions of state projection and an inverse system. The result leads to the conclusion that output-rectifying retrofit controllers can readily be designed even in the general case.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2021; v1 submitted 26 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Fast Online Reinforcement Learning Control using State-Space Dimensionality Reduction
Authors:
Tomonori Sadamoto,
Aranya Chakrabortty,
Jun-ichi Imura
Abstract:
In this paper, we propose a fast reinforcement learning (RL) control algorithm that enables online control of large-scale networked dynamic systems. RL is an effective way of designing model-free linear quadratic regulator (LQR) controllers for linear time-invariant (LTI) networks with unknown state-space models. However, when the network size is large, conventional RL can result in unacceptably l…
▽ More
In this paper, we propose a fast reinforcement learning (RL) control algorithm that enables online control of large-scale networked dynamic systems. RL is an effective way of designing model-free linear quadratic regulator (LQR) controllers for linear time-invariant (LTI) networks with unknown state-space models. However, when the network size is large, conventional RL can result in unacceptably long learning times. The proposed approach is to construct a compressed state vector by projecting the measured state through a projective matrix. This matrix is constructed from online measurements of the states in a way that it captures the dominant controllable subspace of the open-loop network model. Next, a RL-controller is learned using the reduced-dimensional state instead of the original state such that the resultant cost is close to the optimal LQR cost. Numerical benefits as well as the cyber-physical implementation benefits of the approach are verified using illustrative examples including an example of wide-area control of the IEEE 68-bus benchmark power system.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2020; v1 submitted 13 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Disconnection-aware Attack Detection in Networked Control Systems
Authors:
Hampei Sasahara,
Takayuki Ishizaki,
Jun-ichi Imura,
Henrik Sandberg
Abstract:
This study deals with security issues in dynamical networked control systems. The goal is to establish a unified framework of the attack detection stage, which includes the four processes of monitoring the system state, making a decision based on the monitored signal, disconnecting the corrupted subsystem, and operating the remaining system during restoration. This paper, in particular, considers…
▽ More
This study deals with security issues in dynamical networked control systems. The goal is to establish a unified framework of the attack detection stage, which includes the four processes of monitoring the system state, making a decision based on the monitored signal, disconnecting the corrupted subsystem, and operating the remaining system during restoration. This paper, in particular, considers a disconnection-aware attack detector design problem. Traditionally, observer-based attack detectors are designed based on the system model with a fixed network topology and cannot cope with a change of the topology caused by disconnection. The disconnection-aware design problem is mathematically formulated and a solution is proposed in this paper. A numerical example demonstrates the effectiveness of the proposed detector through an inverter-based voltage control system in a benchmark model.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2020; v1 submitted 12 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Parameterization of Retrofit Controllers
Authors:
Hampei Sasahara,
Takayuki Ishizaki,
Jun-ichi Imura
Abstract:
This study investigates a parameterization of all retrofit controllers. Retrofit control can accomplish modular design of control systems, i.e., independent design of subcontrollers only with its corresponding subsystem model in a dynamical network system. In the retrofit control framework, the network system to be controlled is regarded as an interconnected system composed of the subsystem of int…
▽ More
This study investigates a parameterization of all retrofit controllers. Retrofit control can accomplish modular design of control systems, i.e., independent design of subcontrollers only with its corresponding subsystem model in a dynamical network system. In the retrofit control framework, the network system to be controlled is regarded as an interconnected system composed of the subsystem of interest and an environment. Existing studies have revealed that all retrofit controllers can be characterized as a constrained Youla parameterization under the technical assumption that the subsystem of interest is stable. It has also been discovered that all of the retrofit controllers that belong to a particular tractable class have a distinctive internal structure composed of a rectifier and an internal controller under the additional technical assumption that the interconnection signal from the environment to the subsystem of interest is measurable or that the internal state of the subsystem of interest is measurable. Due to the internal structure, the retrofit controller design problem under the assumptions can be reduced to a standard controller design problem to which existing controller synthesis techniques can be applied. The aim of this paper is to extend the above results without the technical assumptions. It is found that the existing developments can naturally be generalized through the Youla parameterization for unstable systems and an explicit description of the inverse system with the geometric control theory. The result leads to the conclusion that retrofit controllers can readily be designed even in the general case.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2020; v1 submitted 12 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Modularity-in-Design of Dynamical Network Systems: Retrofit Control Approach
Authors:
Takayuki Ishizaki,
Hampei Sasahara,
Masaki Inoue,
Takahiro Kawaguchi,
Jun-ichi Imura
Abstract:
In this paper, we develop a modular design method of decentralized controllers for linear dynamical network systems, where multiple subcontroller designers aim at individually regulating their local control performance with accessibility only to their respective subsystem models. First, we derive a constrained version of the Youla parameterization that characterizes all retrofit controllers for a…
▽ More
In this paper, we develop a modular design method of decentralized controllers for linear dynamical network systems, where multiple subcontroller designers aim at individually regulating their local control performance with accessibility only to their respective subsystem models. First, we derive a constrained version of the Youla parameterization that characterizes all retrofit controllers for a single subcontroller, defined as an add-on type subcontroller that manages a subsystem. The resultant feedback system is kept robustly stable for any variation in the neighboring subsystems, other than the subsystem of interest, provided that the original system is stable prior to implementing the retrofit control. Subsequently, we find out a unique internal structure of the retrofit controllers, assuming that the interaction input signal from the neighboring subsystems is measurable. Furthermore, we show that the simultaneous implementation of multiple retrofit controllers, designed by individual subcontroller designers, can improve the upper bound of the overall control performance. Finally, the practical significance of the method is demonstrated via an illustrative example of frequency regulation using the IEEE 68-bus power system model.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2020; v1 submitted 5 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Retrofit Control with Approximate Environment Modeling
Authors:
Takayuki Ishizaki,
Takahiro Kawaguchi,
Hampei Sasahara,
Jun-ichi Imura
Abstract:
In this paper, we develop a retrofit control method with approximate environment modeling. Retrofit control is a modular control approach for a general stable network system whose subsystems are supposed to be managed by their corresponding subsystem operators. From the standpoint of a single subsystem operator who performs the design of a retrofit controller, the subsystems managed by all other o…
▽ More
In this paper, we develop a retrofit control method with approximate environment modeling. Retrofit control is a modular control approach for a general stable network system whose subsystems are supposed to be managed by their corresponding subsystem operators. From the standpoint of a single subsystem operator who performs the design of a retrofit controller, the subsystems managed by all other operators can be regarded as an environment, the complete system model of which is assumed not to be available. The proposed retrofit control with approximate environment modeling has an advantage that the stability of the resultant control system is robustly assured regardless of not only the stability of approximate environment models, but also the magnitude of modeling errors, provided that the network system before implementing retrofit control is originally stable. This robustness property is practically significant to incorporate existing identification methods of unknown environments, because the accuracy of identified models may neither be reliable nor assurable in reality. Furthermore, we conduct a control performance analysis to show that the resultant performance can be regulated by adjusting the accuracy of approximate environment modeling. The efficiency of the proposed retrofit control is shown by numerical experiments on a network of second-order oscillators.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Dynamic Modeling, Stability, and Control of Power Systems with Distributed Energy Resources
Authors:
Tomonori Sadamoto,
Aranya Chakrabortty,
Takayuki Ishizaki,
Jun-ichi Imura
Abstract:
This article presents a suite of new control designs for next-generation electric smart grids. The future grid will consist of thousands of non-conventional renewable generation sources such as wind, solar, and energy storage. These new components are collectively referred to as distributed energy resources (DER). The article presents a comprehensive list of dynamic models for DERs, and shows thei…
▽ More
This article presents a suite of new control designs for next-generation electric smart grids. The future grid will consist of thousands of non-conventional renewable generation sources such as wind, solar, and energy storage. These new components are collectively referred to as distributed energy resources (DER). The article presents a comprehensive list of dynamic models for DERs, and shows their coupling with the conventional generators and loads. It then presents several innovative control designs that can be used for facilitating large-scale DER integration. Ideas from decentralized retrofit control and distributed sparsity-promoting optimal control are used for develo** these designs, followed by illustrations on an IEEE power system test model.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2018; v1 submitted 13 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Day-Ahead Energy Market as Adjustable Robust Optimization: Spatio-Temporal Pricing of Dispatchable Generators, Storage Batteries, and Uncertain Renewable Resources
Authors:
Takayuki Ishizaki,
Masakazu Koike,
Nobuyuki Yamaguchi,
Yuzuru Ueda,
Jun-ichi Imura
Abstract:
We present modeling and analysis of day-ahead spatio-temporal energy markets in which each competitive aggregator aims at making the highest profit by managing a complex mixture of different energy resources, such as conventional generators, storage batteries, and uncertain renewable resources. First, we develop an energy market model in terms of an adjustable robust convex program. This market mo…
▽ More
We present modeling and analysis of day-ahead spatio-temporal energy markets in which each competitive aggregator aims at making the highest profit by managing a complex mixture of different energy resources, such as conventional generators, storage batteries, and uncertain renewable resources. First, we develop an energy market model in terms of an adjustable robust convex program. This market modeling is novel in the sense that the prosumption cost function of each aggregator, which evaluates the cost to realize an amount of spatio-temporal energy prosumption, is a multi-variable function resulting from a "parameterized" max-min program, in which the variable of the prosumption cost function is involved as a continuous parameter and the variable of dispatchable resources is involved as an adjustable variable for energy balance. This formulation enables to reasonably evaluate a reward for intertemporal dispatchability enhancement and a penalty for renewable energy uncertainty in a unified way. In addition, it enables to enforce a market regulation in which every aggregator is responsible for absorbing his renewable energy uncertainty by managing his own dispatchable energy resources. Second, in view of social economy as well as personal economy, we conduct a numerical analysis on the premise of several photovoltaic penetration levels. In this numerical analysis, we demonstrate that renewable generators do not always have priority of energy supply higher than conventional generators due to their uncertainty and limited dispatchability, meaning that the merit order of conventional and renewable generators can reverse. Furthermore, we analyze long-term evolution of competitive energy markets demonstrating that there can be found a social equilibrium of battery penetration levels, at which maximum personal profit with respect to battery system enhancement is attained.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2019; v1 submitted 13 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Synchronization and Aggregation of Nonlinear Power Systems with Consideration of Bus Network Structures
Authors:
Petar Mlinarić,
Takayuki Ishizaki,
Aranya Chakrabortty,
Sara Grundel,
Peter Benner,
Jun-ichi Imura
Abstract:
We study nonlinear power systems consisting of generators, generator buses, and non-generator buses. First, looking at a generator and its bus' variables jointly, we introduce a synchronization concept for a pair of such joint generators and buses. We show that this concept is related to graph symmetry. Next, we extend, in two ways, the synchronization from a pair to a partition of all generators…
▽ More
We study nonlinear power systems consisting of generators, generator buses, and non-generator buses. First, looking at a generator and its bus' variables jointly, we introduce a synchronization concept for a pair of such joint generators and buses. We show that this concept is related to graph symmetry. Next, we extend, in two ways, the synchronization from a pair to a partition of all generators in the networks and show that they are related to either graph symmetry or equitable partitions. Finally, we show how an exact reduced model can be obtained by aggregating the generators and associated buses in the network when the original system is synchronized with respect to a partition, provided that the initial condition respects the partition. Additionally, the aggregation-based reduced model is again a power system.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Transient Response Improvement for Interconnected Linear Systems: Low-Dimensional Controller Retrofit Approach
Authors:
Takayuki Ishizaki,
Masakazu Koike,
Jun-ichi Imura
Abstract:
In this paper, we propose a method of designing low-dimensional retrofit controllers for interconnected linear systems. In the proposed method, by retrofitting an additional low-dimensional controller to a preexisting control system, we aim at improving transient responses caused by spatially local state deflections, which can be regarded as a local fault occurring at a specific subsystem. It is f…
▽ More
In this paper, we propose a method of designing low-dimensional retrofit controllers for interconnected linear systems. In the proposed method, by retrofitting an additional low-dimensional controller to a preexisting control system, we aim at improving transient responses caused by spatially local state deflections, which can be regarded as a local fault occurring at a specific subsystem. It is found that a type of state-space expansion, called hierarchical state-space expansion, is the key to systematically designing a low-dimensional retrofit controller, whose action is specialized to controlling the corresponding subsystem. Furthermore, the state-space expansion enables theoretical clarification of the fact that the performance index of the transient response control is improved by appropriately tuning the retrofit controller. The efficiency of the proposed method is shown through a motivating example of power system control where we clarify the trade-off relation between the dimension of a retrofit controller and its control performance.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2017; v1 submitted 10 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
A Retrofitting-based Supplementary Controller Design for Enhancing Dam** Performance of Wind Power Systems
Authors:
Tomonori Sadamoto,
Aranya Chakrabortty,
Takayuki Ishizaki,
Jun-ichi Imura
Abstract:
In this paper we address the growing concerns of wind power integration from the perspective of power system dynamics and stability. We propose a new retrofit control technique where an additional controller is designed at the doubly-fed induction generator site inside the wind power plant. This controller cancels the adverse impacts of the power flow from the wind side to the grid side on the dyn…
▽ More
In this paper we address the growing concerns of wind power integration from the perspective of power system dynamics and stability. We propose a new retrofit control technique where an additional controller is designed at the doubly-fed induction generator site inside the wind power plant. This controller cancels the adverse impacts of the power flow from the wind side to the grid side on the dynamics of the overall power system. The main advantage of this controller is that it can be implemented by feeding back only the wind states and wind bus voltage without depending on any of the other synchronous machines in the rest of the system. Through simulations of a 4-machine Kundur power system model we show that the retrofit can efficiently enhance the dam** performance of the system variable despite very high values of wind penetration.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Retrofit Control: Localization of Controller Design and Implementation
Authors:
Takayuki Ishizaki,
Tomonori Sadamoto,
Jun-ichi Imura,
Henrik Sandberg,
Karl Henrik Johansson
Abstract:
In this paper, we propose a retrofit control method for stable network systems. The proposed approach is a control method that, rather than an entire system model, requires a model of the subsystem of interest for controller design. To design the retrofit controller, we use a novel approach based on hierarchical state-space expansion that generates a higher-dimensional cascade realization of a giv…
▽ More
In this paper, we propose a retrofit control method for stable network systems. The proposed approach is a control method that, rather than an entire system model, requires a model of the subsystem of interest for controller design. To design the retrofit controller, we use a novel approach based on hierarchical state-space expansion that generates a higher-dimensional cascade realization of a given network system. The upstream dynamics of the cascade realization corresponds to an isolated model of the subsystem of interest, which is stabilized by a local controller. The downstream dynamics can be seen as a dynamical model representing the propagation of interference signals among subsystems, the stability of which is equivalent to that of the original system. This cascade structure enables a systematic analysis of both the stability and control performance of the resultant closed-loop system. The resultant retrofit controller is formed as a cascade interconnection of the local controller and an output rectifier that rectifies an output signal of the subsystem of interest so as to conform to an output signal of the isolated subsystem model while acquiring complementary signals neglected in the local controller design, such as interconnection signals from neighboring subsystems. Finally, the efficiency of the retrofit control method is demonstrated through numerical examples of power systems control and vehicle platoon control.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2018; v1 submitted 8 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Weak Resilience of Networked Control Systems
Authors:
Tomonori Sadamoto,
Henrik Sandberg,
Bart Besselink,
Takayuki Ishizaki,
Jun-ichi Imura,
Karl Henrik Johansson
Abstract:
In this paper, we propose a method to establish a networked control system that maintains its stability in the presence of certain undesirable incidents on local controllers. We call such networked control systems weakly resilient. We first derive a necessary and sufficient condition for the weak resilience of networked systems. Networked systems do not generally satisfy this condition. Therefore,…
▽ More
In this paper, we propose a method to establish a networked control system that maintains its stability in the presence of certain undesirable incidents on local controllers. We call such networked control systems weakly resilient. We first derive a necessary and sufficient condition for the weak resilience of networked systems. Networked systems do not generally satisfy this condition. Therefore, we provide a method for designing a compensator which ensures the weak resilience of the compensated system. Finally, we illustrate the efficiency of the proposed method by a power system example based on the IEEE 14-bus test system.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Effects of time delay in feedback control of linear quantum systems
Authors:
Kazunori Nishio,
Kenji Kashima,
Jun-ichi Imura
Abstract:
We investigate feedback control of linear quantum systems subject to feedback-loop time delays. In particular, we examine the relation between the potentially achievable control performance and the time delays, and provide theoretical guidelines for the future experimental setup in two physical systems, which are typical in this research field. The evaluation criterion for the analysis is given…
▽ More
We investigate feedback control of linear quantum systems subject to feedback-loop time delays. In particular, we examine the relation between the potentially achievable control performance and the time delays, and provide theoretical guidelines for the future experimental setup in two physical systems, which are typical in this research field. The evaluation criterion for the analysis is given by the optimal control performance formula, the derivation of which is from the classical control theoretic results about the input-output delay systems.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2008;
originally announced November 2008.
