-
Multiplicity counting using organic scintillators to distinguish neutron sources: An advanced teaching laboratory
Authors:
Flynn B. Darby,
Michael Y. Hua,
Oskari V. Pakari,
Shaun D. Clarke,
Sara A. Pozzi
Abstract:
In this advanced instructional laboratory, students explore complex detection systems and nondestructive assay techniques used in the field of nuclear physics. After setting up and calibrating a neutron detection system, students carry out timing and energy deposition analyses of radiation signals. Through the timing of prompt fission neutron signals, multiplicity counting is used to carry out a s…
▽ More
In this advanced instructional laboratory, students explore complex detection systems and nondestructive assay techniques used in the field of nuclear physics. After setting up and calibrating a neutron detection system, students carry out timing and energy deposition analyses of radiation signals. Through the timing of prompt fission neutron signals, multiplicity counting is used to carry out a special nuclear material (SNM) nondestructive assay. Our experimental setup is comprised of eight trans-stilbene organic scintillation detectors in a well-counter configuration, and measurements are taken on a spontaneous fission source as well as two (α,n) sources. By comparing each source's measured multiplicity distribution, the resulting measurements of the (α,n) sources can be distinguished from that of the spontaneous fission source. Such comparisons prevent the spoofing, i.e., intentional imitation, of a fission source by an (α,n) neutron source. This instructional laboratory is designed for nuclear engineering and physics students interested in organic scintillators, neutron sources, and nonproliferation radiation measurement techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Nonproliferation and fusion power plants
Authors:
Michael Y. Hua,
Sachin S. Desai,
Amy C. Roma,
Angela Di Fulvio,
Craig J. Mundie,
Sara A. Pozzi
Abstract:
This is an abridged abstract; please see the full paper. This paper evaluates whether the nuclear nonproliferation regime applies to fusion power plants and finds that, legally, the regime does not apply. The paper then examines whether the nonproliferation regime should apply to fusion based on a technical evaluation. The paper concludes that fusion should continue to fall outside the nonprolifer…
▽ More
This is an abridged abstract; please see the full paper. This paper evaluates whether the nuclear nonproliferation regime applies to fusion power plants and finds that, legally, the regime does not apply. The paper then examines whether the nonproliferation regime should apply to fusion based on a technical evaluation. The paper concludes that fusion should continue to fall outside the nonproliferation regime and that the global, dual-use export control regime, including potentially develo** a "controls by design" usage-based control regime, is better suited for commercial fusion energy.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2022; v1 submitted 28 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Fast Rossi-alpha Measurements of Plutonium using Organic Scintillators
Authors:
M. Y. Hua,
C. A. Bravo,
A. T. MacDonald,
J. D. Hutchinson,
G. E. McKenzie,
T. J. Grove,
J. M. Goda,
A. T. McSpaden,
S. D. Clarke,
S. A. Pozzi
Abstract:
In this work, Rossi-alpha measurements were simultaneously performed with a $^3$He-based detection system and an organic scintillator-based detection system. The assembly is 15 kg of plutonium (93 wt$\%$ $^{239}$Pu) reflected by copper and moderated by lead. The goal of Rossi-alpha measurements is to estimate the prompt neutron decay constant, alpha. Simulations estimate $k_\text{eff}$ = 0.624 and…
▽ More
In this work, Rossi-alpha measurements were simultaneously performed with a $^3$He-based detection system and an organic scintillator-based detection system. The assembly is 15 kg of plutonium (93 wt$\%$ $^{239}$Pu) reflected by copper and moderated by lead. The goal of Rossi-alpha measurements is to estimate the prompt neutron decay constant, alpha. Simulations estimate $k_\text{eff}$ = 0.624 and $α$ = 52.3 $\pm$ 2.5 ns for the measured assembly. The organic scintillator system estimated $α$ = 47.4 $\pm$ 2.0 ns, having a 9.37$\%$ error (though the 1.09 standard deviation confidence intervals overlapped). The $^3$He system estimated $α$ = 37 $μ$s. The known slowing down time of the $^3$He system is 35-40 $μ$s, which means the slowing down time dominates and obscures the prompt neutron decay constant. Subsequently, the organic scintillator system should be used for assemblies with alpha much less than 35 $μ$s.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
On the Feynman-alpha Method for Reflected Fissile Assemblies
Authors:
Michael Y. Hua,
Jesson D. Hutchinson,
George E. McKenzie,
Shaun D. Clarke,
Sara A. Pozzi
Abstract:
The Feynman-alpha method is a neutron noise technique that is used to estimate the prompt neutron period of fissile assemblies. The method and quantity are of widespread interest including in applications such as nuclear criticality safety, safeguards and nonproliferation, and stockpile stewardship; the prompt neutron period may also be used to infer the $k_\text{eff}$ multiplication factor. The F…
▽ More
The Feynman-alpha method is a neutron noise technique that is used to estimate the prompt neutron period of fissile assemblies. The method and quantity are of widespread interest including in applications such as nuclear criticality safety, safeguards and nonproliferation, and stockpile stewardship; the prompt neutron period may also be used to infer the $k_\text{eff}$ multiplication factor. The Feynman-alpha method is predicated on time-correlated neutron detections that deviate from a Poisson random variable due to multiplication. Traditionally, such measurements are diagnosed with one-region point kinetics, but two-region models are required when the fissile assembly is reflected. This paper presents a derivation of the two-region point kinetics Feynman-alpha equations based on a double integration of the Rossi-alpha equations, develops novel propagation of measurement uncertainty, and validates the theory. Validation is achieved with organic scintillator measurements of weapons-grade plutonium reflected by various amounts of copper to achieve $k_\text{eff}$ values of 0.83-0.94 and prompt periods of 5-75 ns. The results demonstrate that Feynman-alpha measurements should use the two-region model instead of the one-region model. The simplified one-region model deviates from the validated two-region models by as much as 10\% in the estimate of the prompt neutron period, and the two-region model reduces to the one-region model for small amounts of reflector. The Feynman-alpha estimates of the prompt neutron period are compared to those of the Rossi-alpha approach. The comparative results demonstrate that the Feynman-alpha method is more precise than the Rossi-alpha method and more accurate for $k_\text{eff}<0.92$, whereas the Rossi-alpha method is generally more accurate for higher multiplications.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2020; v1 submitted 22 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Rossi-alpha Uncertainty Quantification by Analytic, Bootstrap, and Sample Methods to Inform Fitting Best Practices
Authors:
M. Y. Hua,
C. A. Bravo,
R. M. Marchie,
J. D. Hutchinson,
G. E. McKenzie,
S. A. Pozzi
Abstract:
The prompt neutron period (the negative reciprocal of the prompt neutron decay constant) can be estimated using the Rossi-alpha technique that is predicated on fitting Rossi-alpha histograms and of interest in nuclear criticality safety and nonproliferation [1, 2, 3]. The histograms are traditionally fit with a one-exponential model; however, recent work has proposed a two-exponential model to acc…
▽ More
The prompt neutron period (the negative reciprocal of the prompt neutron decay constant) can be estimated using the Rossi-alpha technique that is predicated on fitting Rossi-alpha histograms and of interest in nuclear criticality safety and nonproliferation [1, 2, 3]. The histograms are traditionally fit with a one-exponential model; however, recent work has proposed a two-exponential model to account for reflector-induced phenomenon [4, 5, 6]. Until recently, the uncertainty quantification for either model was inadequate (inaccurate and demanded large measurement times). Measurement uncertainty quantification by sample and analytic methods was developed and validated in Ref. [7]. The purpose of this transaction is to (i) validate a new bootstrap method by comparing bin-by-bin error bar estimates and (ii) demonstrate how to choose bin widths and reset times to optimize precision and accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Measured Nondestructive Assay of $^{237}$Np Using Organic Scintillators and Active Neutron Multiplicity Counting
Authors:
Michael Y. Hua,
Thomas A. Plummer,
Jesson D. Hutchinson,
George E. McKenzie,
Shaun D. Clarke,
Sara A. Pozzi
Abstract:
The purpose of nondestructive assay in the context of nuclear safeguards is to precisely verify the declared mass of a sample of nuclear material in a noninhibitive amount of time. 237Np is a proliferation concern, and the capacity to efficiently assay samples of it is a missing piece in the verification and safeguards toolbox. The material is subject to the same safeguards as 235U, is reportable…
▽ More
The purpose of nondestructive assay in the context of nuclear safeguards is to precisely verify the declared mass of a sample of nuclear material in a noninhibitive amount of time. 237Np is a proliferation concern, and the capacity to efficiently assay samples of it is a missing piece in the verification and safeguards toolbox. The material is subject to the same safeguards as 235U, is reportable in gram quantities, and is classified as "other nuclear material" according to the United States Department of Energy. Given that 3000 kg of 237Np is annually produced in the US and the bare sphere critical mass is 40-60 kg, it is desirable to augment the safeguards toolbox with a system capable of distinguishing 10 g of 237Np in a 20-minute measurement. One measurement modality is neutron multiplicity counting, which relates the detected multiplicity count rates to the amount of fissionable material. Prior simulation work shows that an organic scintillator-based multiplicity counter can achieve the design criteria, whereas the flagship 3He-based system, the Epithermal Neutron Multiplicity Counter, requires much longer measurement times to achieve the same precision. In this work, simultaneous measurements of a 6-kg sphere of 237Np by organic scintillator- and 3He-based systems are used to confirm the trends in the simulation study; the organic scintillator-based system achieves 1% uncertainty in the neutron double multiplicity rate on the order of minutes, while the 3He-based system requires days to reach the same precision. In conclusion, the International Atomic Energy Agency should consider the development and deployment of an organic scintillator-based multiplicity counter
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Event-by-Event Multiplicity Correlations in $^{252}$Cf(sf)
Authors:
Stefano Marin,
Vladimir A. Protopopescu,
Ramona Vogt,
Matthew J. Marcath,
M. Stephan Okar,
Michael Y. Hua,
Patrick Talou,
Patricia F. Schuster,
Shaun D. Clarke,
Sara A. Pozzi
Abstract:
Excited nuclear fragments are emitted during nuclear fission. The de-excitation of these fission fragments takes place as sequential emission of neutrons followed by photons. A correlation between neutron and photon multiplicities accompanying fission is thus expected. Fission event generators based on established statistical nuclear physics models predict a negative event-by-event correlation in…
▽ More
Excited nuclear fragments are emitted during nuclear fission. The de-excitation of these fission fragments takes place as sequential emission of neutrons followed by photons. A correlation between neutron and photon multiplicities accompanying fission is thus expected. Fission event generators based on established statistical nuclear physics models predict a negative event-by-event correlation in neutron-photon multiplicity. A survey of published experimental results of an event-by-event covariance between the neutron and photon multiplicities emitted following the spontaneous fission of $^{252}$Cf is presented. Analytic unfolding expressions are developed in this work to determine the bias introduced by background sources, particle misclassification, pulse pileup, and inelastic photon production. The published experimental data are re-analyzed using these unfolding techniques and are found to be in qualitative agreement with the predictions of model-based calculations. In particular, we have concluded that there exists a significant event-by-event neutron-photon emission competition following the spontaneous fission of $^{252}$Cf.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 2019; v1 submitted 2 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
