Showing 1–50 of 51 results for author: Howey, D

Learning operando impedance function for battery health with aging-aware equivalent circuit model

Authors: Zihao Zhou, Antti Aitio, David Howey

Abstract: The wide usage of Lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) requires a deep understanding about battery health. Estimation of battery state-of-health (SOH) is a crucial but yet still challenging task. Pure model-based methods may suffer from inaccuracy and instability of parameter estimations in lifelong aging. While pure data-driven methods rely heavily on quality and quantity of training set, causing lack of… ▽ More The wide usage of Lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) requires a deep understanding about battery health. Estimation of battery state-of-health (SOH) is a crucial but yet still challenging task. Pure model-based methods may suffer from inaccuracy and instability of parameter estimations in lifelong aging. While pure data-driven methods rely heavily on quality and quantity of training set, causing lack of generality when extrapolating into unseen cases. In this paper, we propose an aging-aware equivalent circuit model (ECM), which combines model-based and data-driven techniques for SOH estimation. Gaussian process (GP) regression is incorporated in ECM to modelling parameters dependency on operating condition and aging time. The state space formulation of GP is used to enable a computationally efficient co-estimation framework of both parameters and states. Samples from two Open datasets are used to validate model performance, which gives accurate estimation for capacity and impedance. The learnt impedance function can be lined to the shape change of open circuit voltage (OCV) versus SOC curve and thus providing a way to further estimate changes of differential voltage (dV/dQ) curves. △ Less

Submitted 9 July, 2024; v1 submitted 9 July, 2024; originally announced July 2024.

Comments: 10 pages, 9 figures

Depreciation Cost is a Poor Proxy for Revenue Lost to Aging in Grid Storage Optimization

Authors: Volkan Kumtepeli, Holger Hesse, Thomas Morstyn, Seyyed Mostafa Nosratabadi, Marko Aunedi, David A. Howey

Abstract: Dispatch of a grid energy storage system for arbitrage is typically formulated into a rolling-horizon optimization problem that includes a battery aging model within the cost function. Quantifying degradation as a depreciation cost in the objective can increase overall profits by extending lifetime. However, depreciation is just a proxy metric for battery aging; it is used because simulating the e… ▽ More Dispatch of a grid energy storage system for arbitrage is typically formulated into a rolling-horizon optimization problem that includes a battery aging model within the cost function. Quantifying degradation as a depreciation cost in the objective can increase overall profits by extending lifetime. However, depreciation is just a proxy metric for battery aging; it is used because simulating the entire system life is challenging due to computational complexity and the absence of decades of future data. In cases where the depreciation cost does not match the loss of possible future revenue, different optimal usage profiles result and this reduces overall profit significantly compared to the best case (e.g., by 30-50%). Representing battery degradation perfectly within the rolling-horizon optimization does not resolve this - in addition, the economic cost of degradation throughout life should be carefully considered. For energy arbitrage, optimal economic dispatch requires a trade-off between overuse, leading to high return rate but short lifetime, vs. underuse, leading to a long but not profitable life. We reveal the intuition behind selecting representative costs for the objective function, and propose a simple moving average filter method to estimate degradation cost. Results show that this better captures peak revenue, assuming reliable price forecasts are available. △ Less

Submitted 15 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 6 pages, 8 figures, accepted in American Control Conference (ACC) 2024

Lead-acid battery lifetime extension in solar home systems under different operating conditions

Authors: Rebecca Perriment, Volkan Kumtepeli, Malcolm McCulloch, David Howey

Abstract: Solar home systems (SHS) provide low-cost electricity access for rural off-grid communities. Batteries are a crucial part of the system, however they are often the first point of failure due to shorter lifetimes. Using field data, this work models the degradation of lead-acid batteries for different SHS use-cases, finding the dominant ageing mechanisms in each case. Corrosion is the dominant agein… ▽ More Solar home systems (SHS) provide low-cost electricity access for rural off-grid communities. Batteries are a crucial part of the system, however they are often the first point of failure due to shorter lifetimes. Using field data, this work models the degradation of lead-acid batteries for different SHS use-cases, finding the dominant ageing mechanisms in each case. Corrosion is the dominant ageing mechanisms in all cases apart from the highest use case. This is caused by extended time at high state of charge (SOC) and hence high voltage. A new voltage control scheme is proposed for one of the use cases dominated by corrosion, whereby the number of days between full recharges varies depending on the degradation mechanisms the battery experiences. Simulating the new voltage control scheme yields a 25% increase in battery lifetime whilst ensuring no loss of load to the user. △ Less

Submitted 23 November, 2023; originally announced November 2023.

Loo** in the Human Collaborative and Explainable Bayesian Optimization

Authors: Masaki Adachi, Brady Planden, David A. Howey, Michael A. Osborne, Sebastian Orbell, Natalia Ares, Krikamol Muandet, Siu Lun Chau

Abstract: Like many optimizers, Bayesian optimization often falls short of gaining user trust due to opacity. While attempts have been made to develop human-centric optimizers, they typically assume user knowledge is well-specified and error-free, employing users mainly as supervisors of the optimization process. We relax these assumptions and propose a more balanced human-AI partnership with our Collaborat… ▽ More Like many optimizers, Bayesian optimization often falls short of gaining user trust due to opacity. While attempts have been made to develop human-centric optimizers, they typically assume user knowledge is well-specified and error-free, employing users mainly as supervisors of the optimization process. We relax these assumptions and propose a more balanced human-AI partnership with our Collaborative and Explainable Bayesian Optimization (CoExBO) framework. Instead of explicitly requiring a user to provide a knowledge model, CoExBO employs preference learning to seamlessly integrate human insights into the optimization, resulting in algorithmic suggestions that resonate with user preference. CoExBO explains its candidate selection every iteration to foster trust, empowering users with a clearer grasp of the optimization. Furthermore, CoExBO offers a no-harm guarantee, allowing users to make mistakes; even with extreme adversarial interventions, the algorithm converges asymptotically to a vanilla Bayesian optimization. We validate CoExBO's efficacy through human-AI teaming experiments in lithium-ion battery design, highlighting substantial improvements over conventional methods. Code is available https://github.com/ma921/CoExBO. △ Less

Submitted 29 February, 2024; v1 submitted 26 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: Accepted at AISTATS 2024, 24 pages, 11 figures

MSC Class: 62C10; 62F15

Predicting Battery Lifetime Under Varying Usage Conditions from Early Aging Data

Authors: Tingkai Li, Zihao Zhou, Adam Thelen, David Howey, Chao Hu

Abstract: Accurate battery lifetime prediction is important for preventative maintenance, warranties, and improved cell design and manufacturing. However, manufacturing variability and usage-dependent degradation make life prediction challenging. Here, we investigate new features derived from capacity-voltage data in early life to predict the lifetime of cells cycled under widely varying charge rates, disch… ▽ More Accurate battery lifetime prediction is important for preventative maintenance, warranties, and improved cell design and manufacturing. However, manufacturing variability and usage-dependent degradation make life prediction challenging. Here, we investigate new features derived from capacity-voltage data in early life to predict the lifetime of cells cycled under widely varying charge rates, discharge rates, and depths of discharge. Features were extracted from regularly scheduled reference performance tests (i.e., low rate full cycles) during cycling. The early-life features capture a cell's state of health and the rate of change of component-level degradation modes, some of which correlate strongly with cell lifetime. Using a newly generated dataset from 225 nickel-manganese-cobalt/graphite Li-ion cells aged under a wide range of conditions, we demonstrate a lifetime prediction of in-distribution cells with 15.1% mean absolute percentage error using no more than the first 15% of data, for most cells. Further testing using a hierarchical Bayesian regression model shows improved performance on extrapolation, achieving 21.8% mean absolute percentage error for out-of-distribution cells. Our approach highlights the importance of using domain knowledge of lithium-ion battery degradation modes to inform feature engineering. Further, we provide the community with a new publicly available battery aging dataset with cells cycled beyond 80% of their rated capacity. △ Less

Submitted 20 October, 2023; v1 submitted 17 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Journal ref: Cell Reports Physical Science. 5(4), 101891. 2024

Fast dynamic time war** and clustering in C++

Authors: Volkan Kumtepeli, Rebecca Perriment, David A. Howey

Abstract: We present an approach for computationally efficient dynamic time war** (DTW) and clustering of time-series data. The method frames the dynamic war** of time series datasets as an optimisation problem solved using dynamic programming, and then clusters time series data by solving a second optimisation problem using mixed-integer programming (MIP). There is also an option to use k-medoids clust… ▽ More We present an approach for computationally efficient dynamic time war** (DTW) and clustering of time-series data. The method frames the dynamic war** of time series datasets as an optimisation problem solved using dynamic programming, and then clusters time series data by solving a second optimisation problem using mixed-integer programming (MIP). There is also an option to use k-medoids clustering for increased speed, when a certificate for global optimality is not essential. The improved efficiency of our approach is due to task-level parallelisation of the clustering alongside DTW. Our approach was tested using the UCR Time Series Archive, and was found to be, on average, 33% faster than the next fastest option when using the same clustering method. This increases to 64% faster when considering only larger datasets (with more than 1000 time series). The MIP clustering is most effective on small numbers of longer time series, because the DTW computation is faster than other approaches, but the clustering problem becomes increasingly computationally expensive as the number of time series to be clustered increases. △ Less

Submitted 10 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Learning battery model parameter dynamics from data with recursive Gaussian process regression

Authors: Antti Aitio, Dominik Jöst, Dirk Uwe Sauer, David A. Howey

Abstract: Estimating state of health is a critical function of a battery management system but remains challenging due to the variability of operating conditions and usage requirements of real applications. As a result, techniques based on fitting equivalent circuit models may exhibit inaccuracy at extremes of performance and over long-term ageing, or instability of parameter estimates. Pure data-driven tec… ▽ More Estimating state of health is a critical function of a battery management system but remains challenging due to the variability of operating conditions and usage requirements of real applications. As a result, techniques based on fitting equivalent circuit models may exhibit inaccuracy at extremes of performance and over long-term ageing, or instability of parameter estimates. Pure data-driven techniques, on the other hand, suffer from lack of generality beyond their training dataset. In this paper, we propose a hybrid approach combining data- and model-driven techniques for battery health estimation. Specifically, we demonstrate a Bayesian data-driven method, Gaussian process regression, to estimate model parameters as functions of states, operating conditions, and lifetime. Computational efficiency is ensured through a recursive approach yielding a unified joint state-parameter estimator that learns parameter dynamics from data and is robust to gaps and varying operating conditions. Results show the efficacy of the method, on both simulated and measured data, including accurate estimates and forecasts of battery capacity and internal resistance. This opens up new opportunities to understand battery ageing in real applications. △ Less

Submitted 26 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy beyond linearity and stationarity - a critical review

Authors: Noël Hallemans, David Howey, Alberto Battistel, Nessa Fereshteh Saniee, Federico Scarpioni, Benny Wouters, Fabio La Mantia, Annick Hubin, Widanalage Dhammika Widanage, John Lataire

Abstract: Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) is a widely used experimental technique for characterising materials and electrode reactions by observing their frequency-dependent impedance. Classical EIS measurements require the electrochemical process to behave as a linear time-invariant system. However, electrochemical processes do not naturally satisfy this assumption: the relation between voltag… ▽ More Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) is a widely used experimental technique for characterising materials and electrode reactions by observing their frequency-dependent impedance. Classical EIS measurements require the electrochemical process to behave as a linear time-invariant system. However, electrochemical processes do not naturally satisfy this assumption: the relation between voltage and current is inherently nonlinear and evolves over time. Examples include the corrosion of metal substrates and the cycling of Li-ion batteries. As such, classical EIS only offers models linearised at specific operating points. During the last decade, solutions were developed for estimating nonlinear and time-varying impedances, contributing to more general models. In this paper, we review the concept of impedance beyond linearity and stationarity, and detail different methods to estimate this from measured current and voltage data, with emphasis on frequency domain approaches using multisine excitation. In addition to a mathematical discussion, we measure and provide examples demonstrating impedance estimation for a Li-ion battery, beyond linearity and stationarity, both while resting and while charging. △ Less

Submitted 18 April, 2023; v1 submitted 17 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Constrained optimal control of monotone systems with applications to battery fast-charging

Authors: Ross Drummond, Nicola E. Courtier, David A. Howey, Luis D. Couto, Chris Guiver

Abstract: Enabling fast charging for lithium ion batteries is critical to accelerating the green energy transition. As such, there has been significant interest in tailored fast-charging protocols computed from the solutions of constrained optimal control problems. Here, we derive necessity conditions for a fast charging protocol based upon monotone control systems theory. Enabling fast charging for lithium ion batteries is critical to accelerating the green energy transition. As such, there has been significant interest in tailored fast-charging protocols computed from the solutions of constrained optimal control problems. Here, we derive necessity conditions for a fast charging protocol based upon monotone control systems theory. △ Less

Submitted 30 October, 2023; v1 submitted 18 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Bayesian hierarchical modelling for battery lifetime early prediction

Authors: Zihao Zhou, David A. Howey

Abstract: Accurate prediction of battery health is essential for real-world system management and lab-based experiment design. However, building a life-prediction model from different cycling conditions is still a challenge. Large lifetime variability results from both cycling conditions and initial manufacturing variability, and this -- along with the limited experimental resources usually available for ea… ▽ More Accurate prediction of battery health is essential for real-world system management and lab-based experiment design. However, building a life-prediction model from different cycling conditions is still a challenge. Large lifetime variability results from both cycling conditions and initial manufacturing variability, and this -- along with the limited experimental resources usually available for each cycling condition -- makes data-driven lifetime prediction challenging. Here, a hierarchical Bayesian linear model is proposed for battery life prediction, combining both individual cell features (reflecting manufacturing variability) with population-wide features (reflecting the impact of cycling conditions on the population average). The individual features were collected from the first 100 cycles of data, which is around 5-10% of lifetime. The model is able to predict end of life with a root mean square error of 3.2 days and mean absolute percentage error of 8.6%, measured through 5-fold cross-validation, overperforming the baseline (non-hierarchical) model by around 12-13%. △ Less

Submitted 23 November, 2022; v1 submitted 10 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 7 pages, 8 figures

Bayesian Model Selection of Lithium-Ion Battery Models via Bayesian Quadrature

Authors: Masaki Adachi, Yannick Kuhn, Birger Horstmann, Arnulf Latz, Michael A. Osborne, David A. Howey

Abstract: A wide variety of battery models are available, and it is not always obvious which model `best' describes a dataset. This paper presents a Bayesian model selection approach using Bayesian quadrature. The model evidence is adopted as the selection metric, choosing the simplest model that describes the data, in the spirit of Occam's razor. However, estimating this requires integral computations over… ▽ More A wide variety of battery models are available, and it is not always obvious which model `best' describes a dataset. This paper presents a Bayesian model selection approach using Bayesian quadrature. The model evidence is adopted as the selection metric, choosing the simplest model that describes the data, in the spirit of Occam's razor. However, estimating this requires integral computations over parameter space, which is usually prohibitively expensive. Bayesian quadrature offers sample-efficient integration via model-based inference that minimises the number of battery model evaluations. The posterior distribution of model parameters can also be inferred as a byproduct without further computation. Here, the simplest lithium-ion battery models, equivalent circuit models, were used to analyse the sensitivity of the selection criterion to given different datasets and model configurations. We show that popular model selection criteria, such as root-mean-square error and Bayesian information criterion, can fail to select a parsimonious model in the case of a multimodal posterior. The model evidence can spot the optimal model in such cases, simultaneously providing the variance of the evidence inference itself as an indication of confidence. We also show that Bayesian quadrature can compute the evidence faster than popular Monte Carlo based solvers. △ Less

Submitted 5 April, 2023; v1 submitted 28 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: 11 pages, 2 figures, accepted at IFAC2023

MSC Class: 62C10; 62F15

Journal ref: IFAC-PapersOnLine, 56, 10521, 2023

Nonlinear electrochemical impedance spectroscopy for lithium-ion battery model parameterization

Authors: T. L. Kirk, A. Lewis-Douglas, D. A. Howey, C. P. Please, S. J. Chapman

Abstract: In this work we analyse the local nonlinear electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (NLEIS) response of a lithium-ion battery and estimate model parameters from measured NLEIS data. The analysis assumes a single-particle model including nonlinear diffusion of lithium within the electrode particles and asymmetric charge transfer kinetics at their surface. Based on this model and assuming a moderatel… ▽ More In this work we analyse the local nonlinear electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (NLEIS) response of a lithium-ion battery and estimate model parameters from measured NLEIS data. The analysis assumes a single-particle model including nonlinear diffusion of lithium within the electrode particles and asymmetric charge transfer kinetics at their surface. Based on this model and assuming a moderately-small excitation amplitude, we systematically derive analytical formulae for the impedances up to the second harmonic response, allowing the meaningful interpretation of each contribution in terms of physical processes and nonlinearities in the model. The implications of this for parameterization are explored, including structural identifiability analysis and parameter estimation using maximum likelihood, with both synthetic and experimentally measured impedance data. Accurate fits to impedance data are possible, however inconsistencies in the fitted diffusion timescales suggest that a nonlinear diffusion model may not be appropriate for the cells considered. Model validation is also demonstrated by predicting time-domain voltage response using the parameterized model and this is shown to have excellent agreement with measured voltage time-series data (11.1 mV RMSE). △ Less

Submitted 8 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: 40 pages (excluding supplementary material). Submitted to the Journal of the Electrochemical Society

Digital twin of a MWh-scale grid battery system for efficiency and degradation analysis

Authors: Jorn M. Reniers, David A. Howey

Abstract: Large-scale grid-connected lithium-ion batteries are increasingly being deployed to support renewable energy roll-out on the power grid. These battery systems consist of thousands of individual cells and various ancillary systems for monitoring and control. Although many studies have focused on the behaviour of single lithium-ion cells, the impact of system design choices and ancillary system cont… ▽ More Large-scale grid-connected lithium-ion batteries are increasingly being deployed to support renewable energy roll-out on the power grid. These battery systems consist of thousands of individual cells and various ancillary systems for monitoring and control. Although many studies have focused on the behaviour of single lithium-ion cells, the impact of system design choices and ancillary system controls on long-term degradation and efficiency of system, containing thousands of cells, has rarely been considered in detail. Here, we simulate a 1 MWh grid battery system consisting of 18900 individual cells, each represented by a separate electrochemical model, as well as the thermal management system and power electronic converters. Simulations of the impact of cell-to-cell variability, thermal effects, and degradation effects were run for up to 10000 cycles and 10 years. It is shown that electrical contact resistances and cell-to-cell variations in initial capacity and resistance have a smaller effect on performance than previously thought. Instead, the variation in degradation rate of individual cells dominates the system behaviour over the lifetime. The importance of careful thermal management system control is demonstrated, with proportional control improving overall efficiency by 5 %-pts over on-off methods, also increasing the total usable energy of the battery by 5 %-pts after 10 years. △ Less

Submitted 21 June, 2022; originally announced June 2022.

"Knees" in lithium-ion battery aging trajectories

Authors: Peter M. Attia, Alexander Bills, Ferran Brosa Planella, Philipp Dechent, Gonçalo dos Reis, Matthieu Dubarry, Paul Gasper, Richard Gilchrist, Samuel Greenbank, David Howey, Ouyang Liu, Edwin Khoo, Yuliya Preger, Abhishek Soni, Shashank Sripad, Anna G. Stefanopoulou, Valentin Sulzer

Abstract: Lithium-ion batteries can last many years but sometimes exhibit rapid, nonlinear degradation that severely limits battery lifetime. In this work, we review prior work on "knees" in lithium-ion battery aging trajectories. We first review definitions for knees and three classes of "internal state trajectories" (termed snowball, hidden, and threshold trajectories) that can cause a knee. We then discu… ▽ More Lithium-ion batteries can last many years but sometimes exhibit rapid, nonlinear degradation that severely limits battery lifetime. In this work, we review prior work on "knees" in lithium-ion battery aging trajectories. We first review definitions for knees and three classes of "internal state trajectories" (termed snowball, hidden, and threshold trajectories) that can cause a knee. We then discuss six knee "pathways", including lithium plating, electrode saturation, resistance growth, electrolyte and additive depletion, percolation-limited connectivity, and mechanical deformation -- some of which have internal state trajectories with signals that are electrochemically undetectable. We also identify key design and usage sensitivities for knees. Finally, we discuss challenges and opportunities for knee modeling and prediction. Our findings illustrate the complexity and subtlety of lithium-ion battery degradation and can aid both academic and industrial efforts to improve battery lifetime. △ Less

Submitted 8 January, 2022; originally announced January 2022.

Comments: Submitted to the Journal of the Electrochemical Society

Anisotropic thermal characterisation of large-format lithium-ion pouch cells

Authors: Jie Lin, Howie N. Chu, Charles W. Monroe, David A. Howey

Abstract: Temperature strongly impacts battery performance, safety and durability, but modelling heat transfer requires accurately measured thermal properties. Herein we propose new approaches to characterise the heat capacity and anisotropic thermal-conductivity components for lithium-ion pouch cells. Heat capacity was estimated by applying Newton's law of cooling to an insulated container within which the… ▽ More Temperature strongly impacts battery performance, safety and durability, but modelling heat transfer requires accurately measured thermal properties. Herein we propose new approaches to characterise the heat capacity and anisotropic thermal-conductivity components for lithium-ion pouch cells. Heat capacity was estimated by applying Newton's law of cooling to an insulated container within which the cell was submerged in warmed dielectric fluid. Thermal conductivity was quantified by heating one side of the cell and measuring the opposing temperature distribution with infra-red thermography, then inverse modelling with the anisotropic heat equation. Experiments were performed on commercial 20 Ah lithium iron phosphate (LFP) pouch cells. At 100% state-of-charge (SOC), the heat capacity of a 489 g, 224 mL pouch cell was 541 J/K. The through-plane and in-plane thermal conductivities were respectively 0.52 and 26.6 W/(mK). Capturing anisotropies in conductivity is important for accurate thermal simulations. State-of-charge dependence was also probed by testing at 50% SOC: the heat capacity dropped by 6% and thermal conductivity did not significantly change. △ Less

Submitted 17 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Conditional Inference and Activation of Knowledge Entities in ACT-R

Authors: Marco Wilhelm, Diana Howey, Gabriele Kern-Isberner, Kai Sauerwald, Christoph Beierle

Abstract: Activation-based conditional inference applies conditional reasoning to ACT-R, a cognitive architecture developed to formalize human reasoning. The idea of activation-based conditional inference is to determine a reasonable subset of a conditional belief base in order to draw inductive inferences in time. Central to activation-based conditional inference is the activation function which assigns to… ▽ More Activation-based conditional inference applies conditional reasoning to ACT-R, a cognitive architecture developed to formalize human reasoning. The idea of activation-based conditional inference is to determine a reasonable subset of a conditional belief base in order to draw inductive inferences in time. Central to activation-based conditional inference is the activation function which assigns to the conditionals in the belief base a degree of activation mainly based on the conditional's relevance for the current query and its usage history. Therewith, our approach integrates several aspects of human reasoning into expert systems such as focusing, forgetting, and remembering. △ Less

Submitted 28 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Parameterising continuum level Li-ion battery models & the LiionDB database

Authors: A. A. Wang, S. E. J. O'Kane, F. Brosa Planella, J. Le Houx, K. O'Regan, M. Zyskin, J. Edge, C. W. Monroe, S. J. Cooper, D. A. Howey, E. Kendrick, J. M. Foster

Abstract: The Doyle-Fuller-Newman framework is the most popular physics-based continuum-level description of the chemical and dynamical internal processes within operating lithium-ion-battery cells. With sufficient flexibility to model a wide range of battery designs and chemistries, the framework provides an effective balance between detail, needed to capture key microscopic mechanisms, and simplicity, nee… ▽ More The Doyle-Fuller-Newman framework is the most popular physics-based continuum-level description of the chemical and dynamical internal processes within operating lithium-ion-battery cells. With sufficient flexibility to model a wide range of battery designs and chemistries, the framework provides an effective balance between detail, needed to capture key microscopic mechanisms, and simplicity, needed to solve the governing equations at a relatively modest computational expense. Nevertheless, implementation requires values of numerous model parameters, whose ranges of applicability, estimation, and validation pose challenges. This article provides a critical review of the methods to measure or infer parameters for use within the isothermal DFN framework, discusses their advantages or disadvantages, and clarifies limitations attached to their practical application. Accompanying this discussion we provide a searchable database, available at www.liiondb.com, which aggregates many parameters and state functions for the standard Doyle-Fuller-Newman model that have been reported in the literature. △ Less

Submitted 19 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Multiscale coupling of surface temperature with solid diffusion in large lithium-ion pouch cells

Authors: Jie Lin, Howie N. Chu, David A. Howey, Charles W. Monroe

Abstract: Untangling the relationship between reactions, mass transfer, and temperature within lithium-ion batteries enables control approaches that mitigate thermal hot spots and slow degradation. Here, we develop an efficient physics-based pouch-cell model to simulate lock-in thermography experiments, which synchronously record the applied current, cell voltage, and surface-temperature distribution. Prior… ▽ More Untangling the relationship between reactions, mass transfer, and temperature within lithium-ion batteries enables control approaches that mitigate thermal hot spots and slow degradation. Here, we develop an efficient physics-based pouch-cell model to simulate lock-in thermography experiments, which synchronously record the applied current, cell voltage, and surface-temperature distribution. Prior modelling efforts have been confounded by experimental temperature profiles whose characteristics suggest anisotropic heat conduction. Accounting for a multiscale coupling between heat flow and solid-state diffusion rationalizes this surface-temperature nonuniformity. We extend an earlier streamlined model based on the popular Doyle--Fuller--Newman theory, augmented by a local heat balance. The reduced-order model is exploited to parametrize and simulate commercial 20 Ah lithium iron phosphate (LFP) cells at currents up to 80 A. This work highlights how microscopic intercalation processes produce distinctive macroscopic heat signatures in large-format cells, as well as how heat signatures can be exploited to fingerprint material properties. △ Less

Submitted 27 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Comments: 23 pages, 5 figures

Principles of the Battery Data Genome

Authors: Logan Ward, Susan Babinec, Eric J. Dufek, David A. Howey, Venkatasubramanian Viswanathan, Muratahan Aykol, David A. C. Beck, Ben Blaiszik, Bor-Rong Chen, George Crabtree, Valerio de Angelis, Philipp Dechent, Matthieu Dubarry, Erica E. Eggleton, Donal P. Finegan, Ian Foster, Chirranjeevi Gopal, Patrick Herring, Victor W. Hu, Noah H. Paulson, Yuliya Preger, Dirk Uwe Sauer, Kandler Smith, Seth Snyder, Shashank Sripad , et al. (2 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: Electrochemical energy storage is central to modern society -- from consumer electronics to electrified transportation and the power grid. It is no longer just a convenience but a critical enabler of the transition to a resilient, low-carbon economy. The large pluralistic battery research and development community serving these needs has evolved into diverse specialties spanning materials discover… ▽ More Electrochemical energy storage is central to modern society -- from consumer electronics to electrified transportation and the power grid. It is no longer just a convenience but a critical enabler of the transition to a resilient, low-carbon economy. The large pluralistic battery research and development community serving these needs has evolved into diverse specialties spanning materials discovery, battery chemistry, design innovation, scale-up, manufacturing and deployment. Despite the maturity and the impact of battery science and technology, the data and software practices among these disparate groups are far behind the state-of-the-art in other fields (e.g. drug discovery), which have enjoyed significant increases in the rate of innovation. Incremental performance gains and lost research productivity, which are the consequences, retard innovation and societal progress. Examples span every field of battery research , from the slow and iterative nature of materials discovery, to the repeated and time-consuming performance testing of cells and the mitigation of degradation and failures. The fundamental issue is that modern data science methods require large amounts of data and the battery community lacks the requisite scalable, standardized data hubs required for immediate use of these approaches. Lack of uniform data practices is a central barrier to the scale problem. In this perspective we identify the data- and software-sharing gaps and propose the unifying principles and tools needed to build a robust community of data hubs, which provide flexible sharing formats to address diverse needs. The Battery Data Genome is offered as a data-centric initiative that will enable the transformative acceleration of battery science and technology, and will ultimately serve as a catalyst to revolutionize our approach to innovation. △ Less

Submitted 3 December, 2021; v1 submitted 14 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Comments: corrected author list

Predicting battery end of life from solar off-grid system field data using machine learning

Authors: Antti Aitio, David A. Howey

Abstract: Hundreds of millions of people lack access to electricity. Decentralised solar-battery systems are key for addressing this whilst avoiding carbon emissions and air pollution, but are hindered by relatively high costs and rural locations that inhibit timely preventative maintenance. Accurate diagnosis of battery health and prediction of end of life from operational data improves user experience and… ▽ More Hundreds of millions of people lack access to electricity. Decentralised solar-battery systems are key for addressing this whilst avoiding carbon emissions and air pollution, but are hindered by relatively high costs and rural locations that inhibit timely preventative maintenance. Accurate diagnosis of battery health and prediction of end of life from operational data improves user experience and reduces costs. But lack of controlled validation tests and variable data quality mean existing lab-based techniques fail to work. We apply a scaleable probabilistic machine learning approach to diagnose health in 1027 solar-connected lead-acid batteries, each running for 400-760 days, totalling 620 million data rows. We demonstrate 73% accurate prediction of end of life, eight weeks in advance, rising to 82% at the point of failure. This work highlights the opportunity to estimate health from existing measurements using `big data' techniques, without additional equipment, extending lifetime and improving performance in real-world applications. △ Less

Submitted 29 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Estimation of Li-ion degradation test sample sizes required to understand cell-to-cell variability

Authors: Philipp Dechent, Samuel Greenbank, Felix Hildenbrand, Saad Jbabdi, Dirk Uwe Sauer, David A. Howey

Abstract: Ageing of lithium-ion batteries results in irreversible reduction in performance. Intrinsic variability between cells, caused by manufacturing differences, occurs throughout life and increases with age. Researchers need to know the minimum number of cells they should test to give an accurate representation of population variability, since testing many cells is expensive. In this paper, empirical c… ▽ More Ageing of lithium-ion batteries results in irreversible reduction in performance. Intrinsic variability between cells, caused by manufacturing differences, occurs throughout life and increases with age. Researchers need to know the minimum number of cells they should test to give an accurate representation of population variability, since testing many cells is expensive. In this paper, empirical capacity versus time ageing models were fitted to various degradation datasets for commercially available cells assuming the model parameters could be drawn from a larger population distribution. Using a hierarchical Bayesian approach, we estimated the number of cells required to be tested. Depending on the complexity, ageing models with 1, 2 or 3 parameters respectively required data from at least 9, 11 or 13 cells for a consistent fit. This implies researchers will need to test at least these numbers of cells at each test point in their experiment to capture manufacturing variability. △ Less

Submitted 18 August, 2021; v1 submitted 4 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: 13 pages, 9 figures

Piecewise-linear modelling with feature selection for Li-ion battery end of life prognosis

Authors: Samuel Greenbank, David A. Howey

Abstract: The complex nature of lithium-ion battery degradation has led to many machine learning based approaches to health forecasting being proposed in literature. However, machine learning can be computationally intensive. Linear approaches are faster but have previously been too inflexible for successful prognosis. For both techniques, the choice and quality of the inputs is a limiting factor of perform… ▽ More The complex nature of lithium-ion battery degradation has led to many machine learning based approaches to health forecasting being proposed in literature. However, machine learning can be computationally intensive. Linear approaches are faster but have previously been too inflexible for successful prognosis. For both techniques, the choice and quality of the inputs is a limiting factor of performance. Piecewise-linear models, combined with automated feature selection, offer a fast and flexible alternative without being as computationally intensive as machine learning. Here, a piecewise-linear approach to battery health forecasting was compared to a Gaussian process regression tool and found to perform equally well. The input feature selection process demonstrated the benefit of limiting the correlation between inputs. Further trials found that the piecewise-linear approach was robust to changing input size and availability of training data. △ Less

Submitted 30 July, 2021; v1 submitted 15 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 12 pages, 11 figures

Detection and Isolation of Small Faults in Lithium-Ion Batteries via the Asymptotic Local Approach

Authors: Luis D. Couto, Jorn M. Reniers, David A. Howey, Michel Kinnaert

Abstract: This contribution presents a diagnosis scheme for batteries to detect and isolate internal faults in the form of small parameter changes. This scheme is based on an electrochemical reduced-order model of the battery, which allows the inclusion of physically meaningful faults that might affect the battery performance. The sensitivity properties of the model are analyzed. The model is then used to c… ▽ More This contribution presents a diagnosis scheme for batteries to detect and isolate internal faults in the form of small parameter changes. This scheme is based on an electrochemical reduced-order model of the battery, which allows the inclusion of physically meaningful faults that might affect the battery performance. The sensitivity properties of the model are analyzed. The model is then used to compute residuals based on an unscented Kalman filter. Primary residuals and a limiting covariance matrix are obtained thanks to the local approach, allowing for fault detection and isolation by chi-squared statistical tests. Results show that faults resulting in limited 0.15% capacity and 0.004% power fade can be effectively detected by the local approach. The algorithm is also able to correctly isolate faults related with sensitive parameters, whereas parameters with low sensitivity or linearly correlated are more difficult to precise. △ Less

Submitted 17 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: 8 pages, 2 figures, 3 tables, conference

Automated feature extraction and selection for data-driven models of rapid battery capacity fade and end of life

Authors: Samuel Greenbank, David A. Howey

Abstract: Lithium-ion cells may experience rapid degradation in later life, especially with more extreme usage protocols. The onset of rapid degradation is called the `knee point', and forecasting it is important for the safe and economically viable use for batteries. We propose a data-driven method that uses automated feature selection to produce inputs for a Gaussian process regression model that estimate… ▽ More Lithium-ion cells may experience rapid degradation in later life, especially with more extreme usage protocols. The onset of rapid degradation is called the `knee point', and forecasting it is important for the safe and economically viable use for batteries. We propose a data-driven method that uses automated feature selection to produce inputs for a Gaussian process regression model that estimates changes in battery health, from which the entire capacity fade trajectory, knee point and end of life may be predicted. The feature selection procedure flexibly adapts to varying inputs and prioritises those that impact degradation. For the datasets considered, it was found that calendar time and time spent in specific voltage regions had a strong impact on degradation rate. The approach produced median root mean square errors on capacity estimates under 1\%, and also produced median knee point and end of life prediction errors of 2.6\% and 1.3\% respectively. △ Less

Submitted 18 August, 2021; v1 submitted 12 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Galvanalyser: A Battery Test Database

Authors: Adam Lewis-Douglas, Luke Pitt, David A. Howey

Abstract: Performance and lifetime testing of batteries requires considerable effort and expensive specialist equipment. A wide range of potentiostats and battery testers are available on the market, but there is no standardisation of data exchange and data storage between them. To address this, we present Galvanalyser, a battery test database developed to manage the growing challenges of collating, managin… ▽ More Performance and lifetime testing of batteries requires considerable effort and expensive specialist equipment. A wide range of potentiostats and battery testers are available on the market, but there is no standardisation of data exchange and data storage between them. To address this, we present Galvanalyser, a battery test database developed to manage the growing challenges of collating, managing and accessing data produced by multiple different battery testers. Collation is managed by a client-side application, the `Harvester', which pushes new data up to a PostgreSQL database on a server. Data access is possible in two ways: firstly, a web application allows data to be searched and viewed in a browser, with the option to plot data; secondly, a Python application programming interface (API) can connect directly to the database and pull requested data sets into Python. We hope to make Galvanalyser openly available soon. If you wish to test the system, please contact us for early access. △ Less

Submitted 28 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

Unlocking Extra Value from Grid Batteries Using Advanced Models

Authors: Jorn M. Reniers, Grietus Mulder, David A. Howey

Abstract: Lithium-ion batteries are increasingly being deployed in liberalised electricity systems, where their use is driven by economic optimisation in a specific market context. However, battery degradation depends strongly on operational profile, and this is particularly variable in energy trading applications. Here, we present results from a year-long experiment where pairs of batteries were cycled wit… ▽ More Lithium-ion batteries are increasingly being deployed in liberalised electricity systems, where their use is driven by economic optimisation in a specific market context. However, battery degradation depends strongly on operational profile, and this is particularly variable in energy trading applications. Here, we present results from a year-long experiment where pairs of batteries were cycled with profiles calculated by solving an economic optimisation problem for wholesale energy trading, including a physically-motivated degradation model as a constraint. The results confirm the conclusions of previous simulations and show that this approach can increase revenue by 20% whilst simultaneously decreasing degradation by 30% compared to existing methods. Analysis of the data shows that conventional approaches cannot increase the number of cycles a battery can manage over its lifetime, but the physics-based approach increases the lifetime both in terms of years and number of cycles, as well as the revenue per year, increasing the possible lifetime revenue by 70%. Finally, the results demonstrate the economic impact of model inaccuracies, showing that the physics-based model can reduce the discrepancy in the overall business case from 170% to 13%. There is potential to unlock significant extra performance using control engineering incorporating physical models of battery ageing. △ Less

Submitted 12 March, 2021; v1 submitted 24 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Bayesian Parameter Estimation Applied to the Li-ion Battery Single Particle Model with Electrolyte Dynamics

Authors: Antti Aitio, Scott G. Marquis, Pedro Ascencio, David Howey

Abstract: This paper presents a Bayesian parameter estimation approach and identifiability analysis for a lithium-ion battery model, to determine the uniqueness, evaluate the sensitivity and quantify the uncertainty of a subset of the model parameters. The analysis was based on the single particle model with electrolyte dynamics, rigorously derived from the Doyle-Fuller-Newman model using asymptotic analysi… ▽ More This paper presents a Bayesian parameter estimation approach and identifiability analysis for a lithium-ion battery model, to determine the uniqueness, evaluate the sensitivity and quantify the uncertainty of a subset of the model parameters. The analysis was based on the single particle model with electrolyte dynamics, rigorously derived from the Doyle-Fuller-Newman model using asymptotic analysis including electrode-average terms. The Bayesian approach allows complex target distributions to be estimated, which enables a global analysis of the parameter space. The analysis focuses on the identification problem (i) locally, under a set of discrete quasi-steady states of charge, and in comparison (ii) globally with a continuous excursion of state of charge. The performance of the methodology was evaluated using synthetic data from multiple numerical simulations under diverse types of current excitation. We show that various diffusivities as well as the transference number may be estimated with small variances in the global case, but with much larger uncertainty in the local estimation case. This also has significant implications for estimation where parameters might vary as a function of state of charge or other latent variables. △ Less

Submitted 27 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

A State Observer Design for Simultaneous Estimation of Charge State and Crossover in Self-Discharging Disproportionation Redox Flow Batteries

Authors: Pedro Ascencio, Kirk Smith, David Howey, Charles Monroe

Abstract: This paper presents an augmented state observer design for the simultaneous estimation of charge state and crossover flux in disproportionation redox flow batteries, which exhibits exponential estimation error convergence to a bounded residual set. The crossover flux of vanadium through the porous separator is considered as an unknown function of the battery states, model-approximated as the outpu… ▽ More This paper presents an augmented state observer design for the simultaneous estimation of charge state and crossover flux in disproportionation redox flow batteries, which exhibits exponential estimation error convergence to a bounded residual set. The crossover flux of vanadium through the porous separator is considered as an unknown function of the battery states, model-approximated as the output of a persistently excited linear system. This parametric model and the simple isothermal lumped parameter model of the battery are combined to form an augmented space state representation suitable for the observer design, which is carried out via Lyapunov stability theory including the error-uncertainty involved in the approximation of the crossover flux. The observer gain is calculated by solving a polytopic linear matrix inequality problem via convex optimization. The performance of this design is evaluated with a laboratory flow battery prototype undergoing self-discharge. △ Less

Submitted 27 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Comments: arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1903.04073

An Adaptive Observer Design for Charge-State and Crossover Estimation in Disproportionation Redox Flow Batteries undergoing Self-Discharge

Authors: Pedro Ascencio, Kirk Smith, Charles W. Monroe, David Howey

Abstract: This article considers a model formulation and an adaptive observer design for the simultaneous estimation of the state of charge and crossover flux in disproportionation redox flow batteries. This novel nonaqueous battery chemistry allows a simple isothermal lumped parameter model to be formulated. The transport of vanadium through the porous separator is a key unknown function of battery variabl… ▽ More This article considers a model formulation and an adaptive observer design for the simultaneous estimation of the state of charge and crossover flux in disproportionation redox flow batteries. This novel nonaqueous battery chemistry allows a simple isothermal lumped parameter model to be formulated. The transport of vanadium through the porous separator is a key unknown function of battery variables and it is approximated in the space of continuous functions. The state and parameter observer adaptation laws are derived using Lyapunov analysis applied to the estimation error, the stability and convergence of which are proved. Numerical values of observer gains are calculated by solving a polytopic linear matrix inequality and equality problem via convex optimization. The performance of this design is evaluated on a laboratory flow battery prototype, and it is shown that the crossover flux can be considered a linear function of state of charge for this battery configuration during self-discharge. △ Less

Submitted 10 March, 2019; originally announced March 2019.

Faster Lead-Acid Battery Simulations from Porous-Electrode Theory: II. Asymptotic Analysis

Authors: Valentin Sulzer, S. Jon Chapman, Colin P. Please, David A. Howey, Charles W. Monroe

Abstract: Electrochemical and equivalent-circuit modelling are the two most popular approaches to battery simulation, but the former is computationally expensive and the latter provides limited physical insight. A theoretical middle ground would be useful to support battery management, on-line diagnostics, and cell design. We analyse a thermodynamically consistent, isothermal porous-electrode model of a dis… ▽ More Electrochemical and equivalent-circuit modelling are the two most popular approaches to battery simulation, but the former is computationally expensive and the latter provides limited physical insight. A theoretical middle ground would be useful to support battery management, on-line diagnostics, and cell design. We analyse a thermodynamically consistent, isothermal porous-electrode model of a discharging lead-acid battery. Asymptotic analysis of this full model produces three reduced-order models, which relate the electrical behaviour to microscopic material properties, but simulate discharge at speeds approaching an equivalent circuit. A lumped-parameter model, which neglects spatial property variations, proves accurate for C-rates below 0.1C, while a spatially resolved higher-order solution retains accuracy up to 5C. The problem of parameter estimation is addressed by fitting experimental data with the reduced-order models. △ Less

Submitted 5 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: Submitted to Journal of the Electrochemical Society. Second part of a two-part paper. Part I: "Faster Lead-Acid Battery Simulations from Porous-Electrode Theory: I. Physical Model"

Faster Lead-Acid Battery Simulations from Porous-Electrode Theory: I. Physical Model

Authors: Valentin Sulzer, S. Jon Chapman, Colin P. Please, David A. Howey, Charles W. Monroe

Abstract: An isothermal porous-electrode model of a discharging lead-acid battery is presented, which includes an extension of concentrated-solution theory that accounts for excluded-volume effects, local pressure variation, and a detailed microscopic water balance. The approach accounts for three typically neglected physical phenomena: convection, pressure diffusion, and variation of liquid volume with sta… ▽ More An isothermal porous-electrode model of a discharging lead-acid battery is presented, which includes an extension of concentrated-solution theory that accounts for excluded-volume effects, local pressure variation, and a detailed microscopic water balance. The approach accounts for three typically neglected physical phenomena: convection, pressure diffusion, and variation of liquid volume with state of charge. Rescaling of the governing equations uncovers a set of fundamental dimensionless parameters that control the battery's response. Total volume change during discharge and nonuniform pressure prove to be higher-order effects in cells where variations occur in just one spatial dimension. A numerical solution is developed and exploited to predict transient cell voltages and internal concentration profiles in response to a range of C-rates. The dependence of discharge capacity on C-rate deviates substantially from Peukert's simple power law: charge capacity is concentration-limited at low C-rates, and voltage-limited at high C-rates. The model is fit to experimental data, showing good agreement. △ Less

Submitted 5 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: Submitted to Journal of the Electrochemical Society. First part of a two-part paper. Part II: "Faster Lead-Acid Battery Simulations from Porous-Electrode Theory: II. Asymptotic Analysis"

Battery health prediction under generalized conditions using a Gaussian process transition model

Authors: Robert R. Richardson, Michael A. Osborne, David A. Howey

Abstract: Accurately predicting the future health of batteries is necessary to ensure reliable operation, minimise maintenance costs, and calculate the value of energy storage investments. The complex nature of degradation renders data-driven approaches a promising alternative to mechanistic modelling. This study predicts the changes in battery capacity over time using a Bayesian non-parametric approach bas… ▽ More Accurately predicting the future health of batteries is necessary to ensure reliable operation, minimise maintenance costs, and calculate the value of energy storage investments. The complex nature of degradation renders data-driven approaches a promising alternative to mechanistic modelling. This study predicts the changes in battery capacity over time using a Bayesian non-parametric approach based on Gaussian process regression. These changes can be integrated against an arbitrary input sequence to predict capacity fade in a variety of usage scenarios, forming a generalised health model. The approach naturally incorporates varying current, voltage and temperature inputs, crucial for enabling real world application. A key innovation is the feature selection step, where arbitrary length current, voltage and temperature measurement vectors are mapped to fixed size feature vectors, enabling them to be efficiently used as exogenous variables. The approach is demonstrated on the open-source NASA Randomised Battery Usage Dataset, with data of 26 cells aged under randomized operational conditions. Using half of the cells for training, and half for validation, the method is shown to accurately predict non-linear capacity fade, with a best case normalised root mean square error of 4.3%, including accurate estimation of prediction uncertainty. △ Less

Submitted 17 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Gaussian Process Regression for In-situ Capacity Estimation of Lithium-ion Batteries

Authors: Robert R. Richardson, Christoph R. Birkl, Michael A. Osborne, David A. Howey

Abstract: Accurate on-board capacity estimation is of critical importance in lithium-ion battery applications. Battery charging/discharging often occurs under a constant current load, and hence voltage vs. time measurements under this condition may be accessible in practice. This paper presents a data-driven diagnostic technique, Gaussian Process regression for In-situ Capacity Estimation (GP-ICE), which es… ▽ More Accurate on-board capacity estimation is of critical importance in lithium-ion battery applications. Battery charging/discharging often occurs under a constant current load, and hence voltage vs. time measurements under this condition may be accessible in practice. This paper presents a data-driven diagnostic technique, Gaussian Process regression for In-situ Capacity Estimation (GP-ICE), which estimates battery capacity using voltage measurements over short periods of galvanostatic operation. Unlike previous works, GP-ICE does not rely on interpreting the voltage-time data as Incremental Capacity (IC) or Differential Voltage (DV) curves. This overcomes the need to differentiate the voltage-time data (a process which amplifies measurement noise), and the requirement that the range of voltage measurements encompasses the peaks in the IC/DV curves. GP-ICE is applied to two datasets, consisting of 8 and 20 cells respectively. In each case, within certain voltage ranges, as little as 10 seconds of galvanostatic operation enables capacity estimates with approximately 2-3% RMSE. △ Less

Submitted 18 December, 2017; v1 submitted 7 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Comments: 12 pages, 10 figures, submitted to IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics

Report number: TII-17-1314 MSC Class: 62P30 ACM Class: J.2; G.3

Improving optimal control of grid-connected lithium-ion batteries through more accurate battery and degradation modelling

Authors: Jorn M. Reniers, Grietus Mulder, Sina Ober-Blobaum, David A. Howey

Abstract: The increased deployment of intermittent renewable energy generators opens up opportunities for grid-connected energy storage. Batteries offer significant flexibility but are relatively expensive at present. Battery lifetime is a key factor in the business case, and it depends on usage, but most techno-economic analyses do not account for this. For the first time, this paper quantifies the annual… ▽ More The increased deployment of intermittent renewable energy generators opens up opportunities for grid-connected energy storage. Batteries offer significant flexibility but are relatively expensive at present. Battery lifetime is a key factor in the business case, and it depends on usage, but most techno-economic analyses do not account for this. For the first time, this paper quantifies the annual benefits of grid-connected batteries including realistic physical dynamics and nonlinear electrochemical degradation. Three lithium-ion battery models of increasing realism are formulated, and the predicted degradation of each is compared with a large-scale experimental degradation data set (Mat4Bat). A respective improvement in RMS capacity prediction error from 11\% to 5\% is found by increasing the model accuracy. The three models are then used within an optimal control algorithm to perform price arbitrage over one year, including degradation. Results show that the revenue can be increased substantially while degradation can be reduced by using more realistic models. The estimated best case profit using a sophisticated model is a 175% improvement compared with the simplest model. This illustrates that using a simplistic battery model in a techno-economic assessment of grid-connected batteries might substantially underestimate the business case and lead to erroneous conclusions. △ Less

Submitted 17 January, 2018; v1 submitted 12 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Gaussian process regression for forecasting battery state of health

Authors: Robert R. Richardson, Michael A. Osborne, David A. Howey

Abstract: Accurately predicting the future capacity and remaining useful life of batteries is necessary to ensure reliable system operation and to minimise maintenance costs. The complex nature of battery degradation has meant that mechanistic modelling of capacity fade has thus far remained intractable; however, with the advent of cloud-connected devices, data from cells in various applications is becoming… ▽ More Accurately predicting the future capacity and remaining useful life of batteries is necessary to ensure reliable system operation and to minimise maintenance costs. The complex nature of battery degradation has meant that mechanistic modelling of capacity fade has thus far remained intractable; however, with the advent of cloud-connected devices, data from cells in various applications is becoming increasingly available, and the feasibility of data-driven methods for battery prognostics is increasing. Here we propose Gaussian process (GP) regression for forecasting battery state of health, and highlight various advantages of GPs over other data-driven and mechanistic approaches. GPs are a type of Bayesian non-parametric method, and hence can model complex systems whilst handling uncertainty in a principled manner. Prior information can be exploited by GPs in a variety of ways: explicit mean functions can be used if the functional form of the underlying degradation model is available, and multiple-output GPs can effectively exploit correlations between data from different cells. We demonstrate the predictive capability of GPs for short-term and long-term (remaining useful life) forecasting on a selection of capacity vs. cycle datasets from lithium-ion cells. △ Less

Submitted 31 May, 2017; v1 submitted 16 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.

Comments: 13 pages, 7 figures, published in the Journal of Power Sources, 2017

MSC Class: 62P30 ACM Class: J.2; G.3

Journal ref: Journal of Power Sources, Volume 357, 31 July 2017, Pages 209 to 219

Identifiability and parameter estimation of the single particle lithium-ion battery model

Authors: Adrien M. Bizeray, **-Ho Kim, Stephen R. Duncan, David A. Howey

Abstract: This paper investigates the identifiability and estimation of the parameters of the single particle model (SPM) for lithium-ion battery simulation. Identifiability is addressed both in principle and in practice. The approach begins by grou** parameters and partially non-dimensionalising the SPM to determine the maximum expected degrees of freedom in the problem. We discover that, excluding open… ▽ More This paper investigates the identifiability and estimation of the parameters of the single particle model (SPM) for lithium-ion battery simulation. Identifiability is addressed both in principle and in practice. The approach begins by grou** parameters and partially non-dimensionalising the SPM to determine the maximum expected degrees of freedom in the problem. We discover that, excluding open circuit voltage, there are only six independent parameters. We then examine the structural identifiability by considering whether the transfer function of the linearised SPM is unique. It is found that the model is unique provided that the electrode open circuit voltage functions have a known non-zero gradient, the parameters are ordered, and the electrode kinetics are lumped into a single charge transfer resistance parameter. We then demonstrate the practical estimation of model parameters from measured frequency-domain experimental electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) data, and show additionally that the parametrised model provides good predictive capabilities in the time domain, exhibiting a maximum voltage error of 20 mV between model and experiment over a 10 minute dynamic discharge. △ Less

Submitted 24 January, 2018; v1 submitted 8 February, 2017; originally announced February 2017.

Comments: 16 pages, 9 figures, pre-print submitted to the IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology

On-board monitoring of 2-D spatially-resolved temperatures in cylindrical lithium-ion batteries: Part I. Low-order thermal modelling

Authors: Robert R. Richardson, Shi Zhao, David A. Howey

Abstract: Estimating the temperature distribution within Li-ion batteries during operation is critical for safety and control purposes. Although existing control-oriented thermal models - such as thermal equivalent circuits (TEC) - are computationally efficient, they only predict average temperatures, and are unable to predict the spatially resolved temperature distribution throughout the cell. We present a… ▽ More Estimating the temperature distribution within Li-ion batteries during operation is critical for safety and control purposes. Although existing control-oriented thermal models - such as thermal equivalent circuits (TEC) - are computationally efficient, they only predict average temperatures, and are unable to predict the spatially resolved temperature distribution throughout the cell. We present a low-order 2D thermal model of a cylindrical battery based on a Chebyshev spectral-Galerkin (SG) method, capable of predicting the full temperature distribution with a similar efficiency to a TEC. The model accounts for transient heat generation, anisotropic heat conduction, and non-homogeneous convection boundary conditions. The accuracy of the model is validated through comparison with finite element simulations, which show that the 2-D temperature field (r, z) of a large format (64 mm diameter) cell can be accurately modelled with as few as 4 states. Furthermore, the performance of the model for a range of Biot numbers is investigated via frequency analysis. For larger cells or highly transient thermal dynamics, the model order can be increased for improved accuracy. The incorporation of this model in a state estimation scheme with experimental validation against thermocouple measurements is presented in the companion contribution (Part II). △ Less

Submitted 6 June, 2016; originally announced June 2016.

Comments: 13 pages, 6 figures, submitted to the Journal of Power Sources, 2016

MSC Class: 93

On-board monitoring of 2-D spatially-resolved temperatures in cylindrical lithium-ion batteries: Part II. State estimation via impedance-based temperature sensing

Authors: Robert R. Richardson, Shi Zhao, David A. Howey

Abstract: Impedance-based temperature detection (ITD) is a promising approach for rapid estimation of internal cell temperature based on the correlation between temperature and electrochemical impedance. Previously, ITD was used as part of an Extended Kalman Filter (EKF) state-estimator in conjunction with a thermal model to enable estimation of the 1-D temperature distribution of a cylindrical lithium-ion… ▽ More Impedance-based temperature detection (ITD) is a promising approach for rapid estimation of internal cell temperature based on the correlation between temperature and electrochemical impedance. Previously, ITD was used as part of an Extended Kalman Filter (EKF) state-estimator in conjunction with a thermal model to enable estimation of the 1-D temperature distribution of a cylindrical lithium-ion battery. Here, we extend this method to enable estimation of the 2-D temperature field of a battery with temperature gradients in both the radial and axial directions. An EKF using a parameterised 2-D spectral-Galerkin model with ITD measurement input (the imaginary part of the impedance at 215 Hz) is shown to accurately predict the core temperature and multiple surface temperatures of a 32113 LiFePO$_4$ cell, using current excitation profiles based on an Artemis HEV drive cycle. The method is validated experimentally on a cell fitted with a heat sink and asymmetrically cooled via forced air convection. A novel approach to impedance-temperature calibration is also presented, which uses data from a single drive cycle, rather than measurements at multiple uniform cell temperatures as in previous studies. This greatly reduces the time required for calibration, since it overcomes the need for repeated cell thermal equalization. △ Less

Submitted 6 June, 2016; originally announced June 2016.

Comments: 11 pages, 8 figures, submitted to the Journal of Power Sources

MSC Class: 93

Global sensitivity analysis of battery equivalent circuit model parameters

Authors: Shi Zhao, David A. Howey

Abstract: This paper considers one of the most commonly used equivalent circuit models (ECMs) for lithium-ion batteries and investigates the sensitivity of the model output to changes of model parameters using the Morris method. Experiments are carried out on a lithium-ion cell with nickel manganese cobalt oxide (NMC) electrode and parameters of the model are identified in the state of charge (SOC) range [1… ▽ More This paper considers one of the most commonly used equivalent circuit models (ECMs) for lithium-ion batteries and investigates the sensitivity of the model output to changes of model parameters using the Morris method. Experiments are carried out on a lithium-ion cell with nickel manganese cobalt oxide (NMC) electrode and parameters of the model are identified in the state of charge (SOC) range [100%,10%]. Although all the model parameters do vary with SOC, global sensitivity analysis reveals that the uncertainties of some of the parameters generate very little uncertainty in the voltage output, implying that those parameters can be taken as constants without compromising the accuracy of the model. This is further confirmed by experimental validation. △ Less

Submitted 5 April, 2016; originally announced April 2016.

Circuit Synthesis of Electrochemical Supercapacitor Models

Authors: Ross Drummond, Shi Zhao, David A. Howey, Stephen R. Duncan

Abstract: This paper is concerned with the synthesis of RC electrical circuits from physics-based supercapacitor models describing conservation and diffusion relationships. The proposed synthesis procedure uses model discretisation, linearisation, balanced model order reduction and passive network synthesis to form the circuits. Circuits with different topologies are synthesized from several physical models… ▽ More This paper is concerned with the synthesis of RC electrical circuits from physics-based supercapacitor models describing conservation and diffusion relationships. The proposed synthesis procedure uses model discretisation, linearisation, balanced model order reduction and passive network synthesis to form the circuits. Circuits with different topologies are synthesized from several physical models. This work will give greater understanding to the physical interpretation of electrical circuits and will enable the development of more generalised circuits, since the synthesized impedance functions are generated by considering the physics, not from experimental fitting which may ignore certain dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 30 March, 2016; originally announced March 2016.

Bayesian inference in non-Markovian state-space models with applications to fractional order systems

Authors: Pierre E. Jacob, S. M. Mahdi Alavi, Adam Mahdi, Stephen J. Payne, David A. Howey

Abstract: Battery impedance spectroscopy models are given by fractional order (FO) differential equations. In the discrete-time domain, they give rise to state-space models where the latent process is not Markovian. Parameter estimation for these models is therefore challenging, especially for non-commensurate FO models. In this paper, we propose a Bayesian approach to identify the parameters of generic FO… ▽ More Battery impedance spectroscopy models are given by fractional order (FO) differential equations. In the discrete-time domain, they give rise to state-space models where the latent process is not Markovian. Parameter estimation for these models is therefore challenging, especially for non-commensurate FO models. In this paper, we propose a Bayesian approach to identify the parameters of generic FO systems. The computational challenge is tackled with particle Markov chain Monte Carlo methods, with an implementation specifically designed for the non-Markovian setting. The approach is then applied to estimate the parameters of a battery non-commensurate FO equivalent circuit model. Extensive simulations are provided to study the practical identifiability of model parameters and their sensitivity to the choice of prior distributions, the number of observations, the magnitude of the input signal and the measurement noise. △ Less

Submitted 27 January, 2016; originally announced January 2016.

Structural Identifiability Analysis of Fractional Order Models with Applications in Battery Systems

Authors: S. M. Mahdi Alavi, Adam Mahdi, Pierre E. Jacob, Stephen J. Payne, David A. Howey

Abstract: This paper presents a method for structural identifiability analysis of fractional order systems by using the coefficient map** concept to determine whether the model parameters can uniquely be identified from input-output data. The proposed method is applicable to general non-commensurate fractional order models. Examples are chosen from battery fractional order equivalent circuit models (FO-EC… ▽ More This paper presents a method for structural identifiability analysis of fractional order systems by using the coefficient map** concept to determine whether the model parameters can uniquely be identified from input-output data. The proposed method is applicable to general non-commensurate fractional order models. Examples are chosen from battery fractional order equivalent circuit models (FO-ECMs). The battery FO-ECM consists of a series of parallel resistors and constant phase elements (CPEs) with fractional derivatives appearing in the CPEs. The FO-ECM is non-commensurate if more than one CPE is considered in the model. Currently, estimation of battery FO-ECMs is performed mainly by fitting in the frequency domain, requiring costly electrochemical impedance spectroscopy equipment. This paper aims to analyse the structural identifiability of battery FO-ECMs directly in the time domain. It is shown that FO-ECMs with finite numbers of CPEs are structurally identifiable. In particular, the FO-ECM with a single CPE is structurally globally identifiable. △ Less

Submitted 4 November, 2015; originally announced November 2015.

Observability analysis and state estimation of lithium-ion batteries in the presence of sensor biases

Authors: Shi Zhao, Stephen R. Duncan, David A. Howey

Abstract: This paper investigates the observability of one of the most commonly used equivalent circuit models (ECMs) for lithium-ion batteries and presents a method to estimate the state of charge (SOC) in the presence of sensor biases, highlighting the importance of observability analysis for choosing appropriate state estimation algorithms. Using a differential geometric approach, necessary and sufficien… ▽ More This paper investigates the observability of one of the most commonly used equivalent circuit models (ECMs) for lithium-ion batteries and presents a method to estimate the state of charge (SOC) in the presence of sensor biases, highlighting the importance of observability analysis for choosing appropriate state estimation algorithms. Using a differential geometric approach, necessary and sufficient conditions for the nonlinear ECM to be observable are derived and are shown to be different from the conditions for the observability of the linearised model. It is then demonstrated that biases in the measurements, due to sensor ageing or calibration errors, can be estimated by applying a nonlinear Kalman filter to an augmented model where the biases are incorporated into the state vector. Experiments are carried out on a lithium-ion pouch cell and three types of nonlinear filters, the first-order extended Kalman filter (EKF), the second-order EKF and the unscented Kalman filter (UKF) are applied using experimental data. The different performances of the filters are explained from the point of view of observability. △ Less

Submitted 11 March, 2016; v1 submitted 22 October, 2015; originally announced October 2015.

High Speed Peltier Calorimeter for the Calibration of High Bandwidth Power Measurement Equipment

Authors: Damien F. Frost, David A. Howey

Abstract: Accurate power measurements of electronic components operating at high frequencies are vital in determining where power losses occur in a system such as a power converter. Such power measurements must be carried out with equipment that can accurately measure real power at high frequency. We present the design of a high speed calorimeter to address this requirement, capable of reaching a steady sta… ▽ More Accurate power measurements of electronic components operating at high frequencies are vital in determining where power losses occur in a system such as a power converter. Such power measurements must be carried out with equipment that can accurately measure real power at high frequency. We present the design of a high speed calorimeter to address this requirement, capable of reaching a steady state in less than 10 minutes. The system uses Peltier thermoelectric coolers to remove heat generated in a load resistance, and was calibrated against known real power measurements using an artificial neural network. A dead zone controller was used to achieve stable power measurements. The calibration was validated and shown to have an absolute accuracy of +/-8 mW (95% confidence interval) for measurements of real power from 0.1 to 5 W. △ Less

Submitted 14 August, 2015; originally announced August 2015.

Lithium-ion battery thermal-electrochemical model-based state estimation using orthogonal collocation and a modified extended Kalman filter

Authors: A. M. Bizeray, S. Zhao, S. R. Duncan, D. A. Howey

Abstract: This paper investigates the state estimation of a high-fidelity spatially resolved thermal- electrochemical lithium-ion battery model commonly referred to as the pseudo two-dimensional model. The partial-differential algebraic equations (PDAEs) constituting the model are spatially discretised using Chebyshev orthogonal collocation enabling fast and accurate simulations up to high C-rates. This imp… ▽ More This paper investigates the state estimation of a high-fidelity spatially resolved thermal- electrochemical lithium-ion battery model commonly referred to as the pseudo two-dimensional model. The partial-differential algebraic equations (PDAEs) constituting the model are spatially discretised using Chebyshev orthogonal collocation enabling fast and accurate simulations up to high C-rates. This implementation of the pseudo-2D model is then used in combination with an extended Kalman filter algorithm for differential-algebraic equations to estimate the states of the model. The state estimation algorithm is able to rapidly recover the model states from current, voltage and temperature measurements. Results show that the error on the state estimate falls below 1 % in less than 200 s despite a 30 % error on battery initial state-of-charge and additive measurement noise with 10 mV and 0.5 K standard deviations. △ Less

Submitted 29 June, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Comments: Submitted to the Journal of Power Sources

Journal ref: Journal of Power Sources 296 (2015) 400-412

Identifiability of generalised Randles circuit models

Authors: S. M. M. Alavi, A. Mahdi, S. J. Payne, D. A. Howey

Abstract: The Randles circuit (including a parallel resistor and capacitor in series with another resistor) and its generalised topology have widely been employed in electrochemical energy storage systems such as batteries, fuel cells and supercapacitors, also in biomedical engineering, for example, to model the electrode-tissue interface in electroencephalography and baroreceptor dynamics. This paper studi… ▽ More The Randles circuit (including a parallel resistor and capacitor in series with another resistor) and its generalised topology have widely been employed in electrochemical energy storage systems such as batteries, fuel cells and supercapacitors, also in biomedical engineering, for example, to model the electrode-tissue interface in electroencephalography and baroreceptor dynamics. This paper studies identifiability of generalised Randles circuit models, that is, whether the model parameters can be estimated uniquely from the input-output data. It is shown that generalised Randles circuit models are structurally locally identifiable. The condition that makes the model structure globally identifiable is then discussed. Finally, the estimation accuracy is evaluated through extensive simulations. △ Less

Submitted 25 May, 2016; v1 submitted 1 May, 2015; originally announced May 2015.

Air-Gap Convection in a Switched Reluctance Machine

Authors: Pietro Romanazzi, David A. Howey

Abstract: Switched reluctance machines (SRMs) have recently become popular in the automotive market as they are a good alternative to the permanent magnet machines commonly employed for an electric powertrain. Lumped parameter thermal networks are usually used for thermal analysis of motors due to their low computational cost and relatively accurate results. A critical aspect to be modelled is the rotor-sta… ▽ More Switched reluctance machines (SRMs) have recently become popular in the automotive market as they are a good alternative to the permanent magnet machines commonly employed for an electric powertrain. Lumped parameter thermal networks are usually used for thermal analysis of motors due to their low computational cost and relatively accurate results. A critical aspect to be modelled is the rotor-stator air-gap heat transfer, and this is particularly challenging in an SRM due to the salient pole geometry. This work presents firstly a review of the literature including the most relevant correlations for this geometry, and secondly, numerical CFD simulations of air-gap heat transfer for a typical configuration. A new correlation has been derived: $\mathbf{Nu=0.181\ Ta_m^{0.207}}$ △ Less

Submitted 20 February, 2015; originally announced February 2015.

Comments: 2015 Tenth International Conference on Ecological Vehicles and Renewable Energies (EVER), 10 figures, 7 pages

Sensorless Battery Internal Temperature Estimation using a Kalman Filter with Impedance Measurement

Authors: Robert R. Richardson, David A. Howey

Abstract: This study presents a method of estimating battery cell core and surface temperature using a thermal model coupled with electrical impedance measurement, rather than using direct surface temperature measurements. This is advantageous over previous methods of estimating temperature from impedance, which only estimate the average internal temperature. The performance of the method is demonstrated ex… ▽ More This study presents a method of estimating battery cell core and surface temperature using a thermal model coupled with electrical impedance measurement, rather than using direct surface temperature measurements. This is advantageous over previous methods of estimating temperature from impedance, which only estimate the average internal temperature. The performance of the method is demonstrated experimentally on a 2.3 Ah lithium-ion iron phosphate cell fitted with surface and core thermocouples for validation. An extended Kalman filter, consisting of a reduced order thermal model coupled with current, voltage and impedance measurements, is shown to accurately predict core and surface temperatures for a current excitation profile based on a vehicle drive cycle. A dual extended Kalman filter (DEKF) based on the same thermal model and impedance measurement input is capable of estimating the convection coefficient at the cell surface when the latter is unknown. The performance of the DEKF using impedance as the measurement input is comparable to an equivalent dual Kalman filter using a conventional surface temperature sensor as measurement input. △ Less

Submitted 25 January, 2015; originally announced January 2015.

Comments: 10 pages, 9 figures, accepted for publication in IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy, 2015

MSC Class: 93

Low-Order Mathematical Modelling of Electric Double Layer Supercapacitors Using Spectral Methods

Authors: Ross Drummond, David A. Howey, Stephen R. Duncan

Abstract: This work investigates two physics-based models that simulate the non-linear partial differential algebraic equations describing an electric double layer supercapacitor. In one model the linear dependence between electrolyte concentration and conductivity is accounted for, while in the other model it is not. A spectral element method is used to discretise the model equations and it is found that t… ▽ More This work investigates two physics-based models that simulate the non-linear partial differential algebraic equations describing an electric double layer supercapacitor. In one model the linear dependence between electrolyte concentration and conductivity is accounted for, while in the other model it is not. A spectral element method is used to discretise the model equations and it is found that the error convergence rate with respect to the number of elements is faster compared to a finite difference method. The increased accuracy of the spectral element approach means that, for a similar level of solution accuracy, the model simulation computing time is approximately 50% of that of the finite difference method. This suggests that the spectral element model could be used for control and state estimation purposes. For a typical supercapacitor charging profile, the numerical solutions from both models closely match experimental voltage and current data. However, when the electrolyte is dilute or where there is a long charging time, a noticeable difference between the numerical solutions of the two models is observed. Electrical impedance spectroscopy simulations show that the capacitance of the two models rapidly decreases when the frequency of the perturbation current exceeds an upper threshold. △ Less

Submitted 28 November, 2014; originally announced December 2014.

Comments: Pre-print submitted to Journal of Power Sources

Modular converter system for low-cost off-grid energy storage using second life Li-ion batteries

Authors: Christoph R. Birkl, Damien F. Frost, Adrien M. Bizeray, Robert R. Richardson, David A. Howey

Abstract: Lithium ion batteries are promising for small off- grid energy storage applications in develo** countries because of their high energy density and long life. However, costs are prohibitive. Instead, we consider 'used' Li-ion batteries for this application, finding experimentally that many discarded laptop cells, for example, still have good capacity and cycle life. In order to make safe and opti… ▽ More Lithium ion batteries are promising for small off- grid energy storage applications in develo** countries because of their high energy density and long life. However, costs are prohibitive. Instead, we consider 'used' Li-ion batteries for this application, finding experimentally that many discarded laptop cells, for example, still have good capacity and cycle life. In order to make safe and optimal use of such cells, we present a modular power management system using a separate power converter for every cell. This novel approach allows individual batteries to be used to their full capacity. The power converters operate in voltage droop control mode to provide easy charge balancing and implement a battery management system to estimate the capacity of each cell, as we demonstrate experimentally. △ Less

Submitted 16 October, 2014; originally announced October 2014.

Comments: Presented at IEEE GHTC Oct 10-14, 2014, Silicon Valley