-
Additive Spanner Lower Bounds with Optimal Inner Graph Structure
Authors:
Greg Bodwin,
Gary Hoppenworth,
Virginia Vassilevska Williams,
Nicole Wein,
Zixuan Xu
Abstract:
We construct $n$-node graphs on which any $O(n)$-size spanner has additive error at least $+Ω(n^{3/17})$, improving on the previous best lower bound of $Ω(n^{1/7})$ [Bodwin-Hoppenworth FOCS '22]. Our construction completes the first two steps of a particular three-step research program, introduced in prior work and overviewed here, aimed at producing tight bounds for the problem by aligning aspect…
▽ More
We construct $n$-node graphs on which any $O(n)$-size spanner has additive error at least $+Ω(n^{3/17})$, improving on the previous best lower bound of $Ω(n^{1/7})$ [Bodwin-Hoppenworth FOCS '22]. Our construction completes the first two steps of a particular three-step research program, introduced in prior work and overviewed here, aimed at producing tight bounds for the problem by aligning aspects of the upper and lower bound constructions. More specifically, we develop techniques that enable the use of inner graphs in the lower bound framework whose technical properties are provably tight with the corresponding assumptions made in the upper bounds. As an additional application of our techniques, we improve the corresponding lower bound for $O(n)$-size additive emulators to $+Ω(n^{1/14})$.
△ Less
Submitted 28 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
The Discrepancy of Shortest Paths
Authors:
Greg Bodwin,
Chengyuan Deng,
Jie Gao,
Gary Hoppenworth,
Jalaj Upadhyay,
Chen Wang
Abstract:
The hereditary discrepancy of a set system is a certain quantitative measure of the pseudorandom properties of the system. Roughly, hereditary discrepancy measures how well one can $2$-color the elements of the system so that each set contains approximately the same number of elements of each color. Hereditary discrepancy has well-studied applications e.g. in communication complexity and derandomi…
▽ More
The hereditary discrepancy of a set system is a certain quantitative measure of the pseudorandom properties of the system. Roughly, hereditary discrepancy measures how well one can $2$-color the elements of the system so that each set contains approximately the same number of elements of each color. Hereditary discrepancy has well-studied applications e.g. in communication complexity and derandomization. More recently, the hereditary discrepancy of set systems of shortest paths has found applications in differential privacy [Chen et al.~SODA 23].
The contribution of this paper is to improve the upper and lower bounds on the hereditary discrepancy of set systems of unique shortest paths in graphs. In particular, we show that any system of unique shortest paths in an undirected weighted graph has hereditary discrepancy $\widetilde{O}(n^{1/4})$, and we construct lower bound examples demonstrating that this bound is tight up to hidden $\text{polylog } n$ factors. Our lower bounds apply even in the planar and bipartite settings, and they improve on a previous lower bound of $Ω(n^{1/6})$ obtained by applying the trace bound of Chazelle and Lvov [SoCG'00] to a classical point-line system of Erdős.
As applications, we improve the lower bound on the additive error for differentially-private all pairs shortest distances from $Ω(n^{1/6})$ [Chen et al.~SODA 23] to $Ω(n^{1/4})$, and we improve the lower bound on additive error for the differentially-private all sets range queries problem to $Ω(n^{1/4})$, which is tight up to hidden $\text{polylog } n$ factors [Deng et al.~WADS 23].
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2024; v1 submitted 28 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Simple Linear-Size Additive Emulators
Authors:
Gary Hoppenworth
Abstract:
Given an input graph $G = (V, E)$, an additive emulator $H = (V, E', w)$ is a sparse weighted graph that preserves all distances in $G$ with small additive error. A recent line of inquiry has sought to determine the best additive error achievable in the sparsest setting, when $H$ has a linear number of edges. In particular, the work of [Kogan and Parter, ICALP 2023], following [Pettie, ICALP 2007]…
▽ More
Given an input graph $G = (V, E)$, an additive emulator $H = (V, E', w)$ is a sparse weighted graph that preserves all distances in $G$ with small additive error. A recent line of inquiry has sought to determine the best additive error achievable in the sparsest setting, when $H$ has a linear number of edges. In particular, the work of [Kogan and Parter, ICALP 2023], following [Pettie, ICALP 2007], constructed linear size emulators with $+O(n^{0.222})$ additive error. It is known that the worst-case additive error must be at least $+Ω(n^{2/29})$ due to [Lu, Vassilevska Williams, Wein, and Xu, SODA 2022].
We present a simple linear-size emulator construction that achieves additive error $+O(n^{0.191})$. Our approach extends the path-buying framework developed by [Baswana, Kavitha, Mehlhorn, and Pettie, SODA 2005] and [Vassilevska Williams and Bodwin, SODA 2016] to the setting of sparse additive emulators.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2024; v1 submitted 27 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Folklore Sampling is Optimal for Exact Hopsets: Confirming the $\sqrt{n}$ Barrier
Authors:
Greg Bodwin,
Gary Hoppenworth
Abstract:
For a graph $G$, a $D$-diameter-reducing exact hopset is a small set of additional edges $H$ that, when added to $G$, maintains its graph metric but guarantees that all node pairs have a shortest path in $G \cup H$ using at most $D$ edges. A shortcut set is the analogous concept for reachability. These objects have been studied since the early '90s due to applications in parallel, distributed, dyn…
▽ More
For a graph $G$, a $D$-diameter-reducing exact hopset is a small set of additional edges $H$ that, when added to $G$, maintains its graph metric but guarantees that all node pairs have a shortest path in $G \cup H$ using at most $D$ edges. A shortcut set is the analogous concept for reachability. These objects have been studied since the early '90s due to applications in parallel, distributed, dynamic, and streaming graph algorithms.
For most of their history, the state-of-the-art construction for either object was a simple folklore algorithm, based on randomly sampling nodes to hit long paths in the graph. However, recent breakthroughs of Kogan and Parter [SODA '22] and Bernstein and Wein [SODA '23] have finally improved over the folklore diameter bound of $\widetilde{O}(n^{1/2})$ for shortcut sets and for $(1+ε)$-approximate hopsets. For both objects it is now known that one can use $O(n)$ hop-edges to reduce diameter to $\widetilde{O}(n^{1/3})$. The only setting where folklore sampling remains unimproved is for exact hopsets. Can these improvements be continued?
We settle this question negatively by constructing graphs on which any exact hopset of $O(n)$ edges has diameter $\widetildeΩ(n^{1/2})$. This improves on the previous lower bound of $\widetildeΩ(n^{1/3})$ by Kogan and Parter [FOCS '22]. Using similar ideas, we also polynomially improve the current lower bounds for shortcut sets, constructing graphs on which any shortcut set of $O(n)$ edges reduces diameter to $\widetildeΩ(n^{1/4})$. This improves on the previous lower bound of $Ω(n^{1/6})$ by Huang and Pettie [SIAM J. Disc. Math. '18]. We also extend our constructions to provide lower bounds against $O(p)$-size exact hopsets and shortcut sets for other values of $p$; in particular, we show that folklore sampling is near-optimal for exact hopsets in the entire range of $p \in [1, n^2]$.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2024; v1 submitted 4 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Bridge Girth: A Unifying Notion in Network Design
Authors:
Greg Bodwin,
Gary Hoppenworth,
Ohad Trabelsi
Abstract:
A classic 1993 paper by Althőfer et al. proved a tight reduction from spanners, emulators, and distance oracles to the extremal function $γ$ of high-girth graphs. This paper initiated a large body of work in network design, in which problems are attacked by reduction to $γ$ or the analogous extremal function for other girth concepts. In this paper, we introduce and study a new girth concept that w…
▽ More
A classic 1993 paper by Althőfer et al. proved a tight reduction from spanners, emulators, and distance oracles to the extremal function $γ$ of high-girth graphs. This paper initiated a large body of work in network design, in which problems are attacked by reduction to $γ$ or the analogous extremal function for other girth concepts. In this paper, we introduce and study a new girth concept that we call the bridge girth of path systems, and we show that it can be used to significantly expand and improve this web of connections between girth problems and network design. We prove two kinds of results:
1) We write the maximum possible size of an $n$-node, $p$-path system with bridge girth $>k$ as $β(n, p, k)$, and we write a certain variant for "ordered" path systems as $β^*(n, p, k)$. We identify several arguments in the literature that implicitly show upper or lower bounds on $β, β^*$, and we provide some polynomially improvements to these bounds. In particular, we construct a tight lower bound for $β(n, p, 2)$, and we polynomially improve the upper bounds for $β(n, p, 4)$ and $β^*(n, p, \infty)$.
2) We show that many state-of-the-art results in network design can be recovered or improved via black-box reductions to $β$ or $β^*$. Examples include bounds for distance/reachability preservers, exact hopsets, shortcut sets, the flow-cut gaps for directed multicut and sparsest cut, an integrality gap for directed Steiner forest.
We believe that the concept of bridge girth can lead to a stronger and more organized map of the research area. Towards this, we leave many open problems, related to both bridge girth reductions and extremal bounds on the size of path systems with high bridge girth.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2023; v1 submitted 22 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
New Additive Spanner Lower Bounds by an Unlayered Obstacle Product
Authors:
Greg Bodwin,
Gary Hoppenworth
Abstract:
For an input graph $G$, an additive spanner is a sparse subgraph $H$ whose shortest paths match those of $G$ up to small additive error. We prove two new lower bounds in the area of additive spanners:
1) We construct $n$-node graphs $G$ for which any spanner on $O(n)$ edges must increase a pairwise distance by $+Ω(n^{1/7})$. This improves on a recent lower bound of $+Ω(n^{1/10.5})$ by Lu, Wein,…
▽ More
For an input graph $G$, an additive spanner is a sparse subgraph $H$ whose shortest paths match those of $G$ up to small additive error. We prove two new lower bounds in the area of additive spanners:
1) We construct $n$-node graphs $G$ for which any spanner on $O(n)$ edges must increase a pairwise distance by $+Ω(n^{1/7})$. This improves on a recent lower bound of $+Ω(n^{1/10.5})$ by Lu, Wein, Vassilevska Williams, and Xu [SODA '22].
2) A classic result by Coppersmith and Elkin [SODA '05] proves that for any $n$-node graph $G$ and set of $p = O(n^{1/2})$ demand pairs, one can exactly preserve all pairwise distances among demand pairs using a spanner on $O(n)$ edges. They also provided a lower bound construction, establishing that that this range $p = O(n^{1/2})$ cannot be improved. We strengthen this lower bound by proving that, for any constant $k$, this range of $p$ is still unimprovable even if the spanner is allowed $+k$ additive error among the demand pairs. This negatively resolves an open question asked by Coppersmith and Elkin [SODA '05] and again by Cygan, Grandoni, and Kavitha [STACS '13] and Abboud and Bodwin [SODA '16].
At a technical level, our lower bounds are obtained by an improvement to the entire obstacle product framework used to compose "inner" and "outer" graphs into lower bound instances. In particular, we develop a new strategy for analysis that allows certain non-layered graphs to be used in the product, and we use this freedom to design better inner and outer graphs that lead to our new lower bounds.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2022; v1 submitted 24 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Quantifying Membership Inference Vulnerability via Generalization Gap and Other Model Metrics
Authors:
Jason W. Bentley,
Daniel Gibney,
Gary Hoppenworth,
Sumit Kumar Jha
Abstract:
We demonstrate how a target model's generalization gap leads directly to an effective deterministic black box membership inference attack (MIA). This provides an upper bound on how secure a model can be to MIA based on a simple metric. Moreover, this attack is shown to be optimal in the expected sense given access to only certain likely obtainable metrics regarding the network's training and perfo…
▽ More
We demonstrate how a target model's generalization gap leads directly to an effective deterministic black box membership inference attack (MIA). This provides an upper bound on how secure a model can be to MIA based on a simple metric. Moreover, this attack is shown to be optimal in the expected sense given access to only certain likely obtainable metrics regarding the network's training and performance. Experimentally, this attack is shown to be comparable in accuracy to state-of-art MIAs in many cases.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Simple Reductions from Formula-SAT to Pattern Matching on Labeled Graphs and Subtree Isomorphism
Authors:
Daniel Gibney,
Gary Hoppenworth,
Sharma V. Thankachan
Abstract:
The CNF formula satisfiability problem (CNF-SAT) has been reduced to many fundamental problems in P to prove tight lower bounds under the Strong Exponential Time Hypothesis (SETH). Recently, the works of Abboud, Hansen, Vassilevska W. and Williams (STOC 16), and later, Abboud and Bringmann (ICALP 18) have proposed basing lower bounds on the hardness of general boolean formula satisfiability (Formu…
▽ More
The CNF formula satisfiability problem (CNF-SAT) has been reduced to many fundamental problems in P to prove tight lower bounds under the Strong Exponential Time Hypothesis (SETH). Recently, the works of Abboud, Hansen, Vassilevska W. and Williams (STOC 16), and later, Abboud and Bringmann (ICALP 18) have proposed basing lower bounds on the hardness of general boolean formula satisfiability (Formula-SAT). Reductions from Formula-SAT have two advantages over the usual reductions from CNF-SAT: (1) conjectures on the hardness of Formula-SAT are arguably much more plausible than those of CNF-SAT, and (2) these reductions give consequences even for logarithmic improvements in a problems upper bounds.
Here we give tight reductions from Formula-SAT to two more problems: pattern matching on labeled graphs (PMLG) and subtree isomorphism. Previous reductions from Formula-SAT were to sequence alignment problems such as Edit Distance, LCS, and Frechet Distance and required some technical work. This paper uses ideas similar to those used previously, but in a decidedly simpler setting, hel** to illustrate the most salient features of the underlying techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.