-
Universality for first passage percolation on sparse random graphs
Authors:
Shankar Bhamidi,
Remco van der Hofstad,
Gerard Hooghiemstra
Abstract:
We consider first passage percolation on sparse random graphs with prescribed degree distributions and general independent and identically distributed edge weights assumed to have a density. Assuming that the degree distribution satisfies a uniform X^2\log{X}-condition, we analyze the asymptotic distribution for the minimal weight path between a pair of typical vertices, as well the number of edge…
▽ More
We consider first passage percolation on sparse random graphs with prescribed degree distributions and general independent and identically distributed edge weights assumed to have a density. Assuming that the degree distribution satisfies a uniform X^2\log{X}-condition, we analyze the asymptotic distribution for the minimal weight path between a pair of typical vertices, as well the number of edges on this path or hopcount.
The hopcount satisfies a central limit theorem where the norming constants are expressible in terms of the parameters of an associated continuous-time branching process. Centered by a multiple of \log{n}, where the constant is the inverse of the Malthusian rate of growth of the associated branching process, the minimal weight converges in distribution. The limiting random variable equals the sum of the logarithms of the martingale limits of the branching processes that measure the relative growth of neighborhoods about the two vertices, and a Gumbel random variable, and thus shows a remarkably universal behavior.
The proofs rely on a refined coupling between the shortest path problems on these graphs and continuous-time branching processes, and on a Poisson point process limit for the potential closing edges of shortest-weight paths between the source and destination.
The results extend to a host of related random graph models, ranging from random r-regular graphs, inhomogeneous random graphs and uniform random graphs with a prescribed degree sequence.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Scale-free percolation
Authors:
Maria Deijfen,
Remco van der Hofstad,
Gerard Hooghiemstra
Abstract:
We formulate and study a model for inhomogeneous long-range percolation on $\Zbold^d$. Each vertex $x\in\Zbold^d$ is assigned a non-negative weight $W_x$, where $(W_x)_{x\in\Zbold^d}$ are i.i.d.\ random variables. Conditionally on the weights, and given two parameters $α,λ>0$, the edges are independent and the probability that there is an edge between $x$ and $y$ is given by…
▽ More
We formulate and study a model for inhomogeneous long-range percolation on $\Zbold^d$. Each vertex $x\in\Zbold^d$ is assigned a non-negative weight $W_x$, where $(W_x)_{x\in\Zbold^d}$ are i.i.d.\ random variables. Conditionally on the weights, and given two parameters $α,λ>0$, the edges are independent and the probability that there is an edge between $x$ and $y$ is given by $p_{xy}=1-\exp\{-λW_xW_y/|x-y|^α\}$. The parameter $λ$ is the percolation parameter, while $α$ describes the long-range nature of the model. We focus on the degree distribution in the resulting graph, on whether there exists an infinite component and on graph distance between remote pairs of vertices.
First, we show that the tail behavior of the degree distribution is related to the tail behavior of the weight distribution. When the tail of the distribution of $W_x$ is regularly varying with exponent $τ-1$, then the tail of the degree distribution is regularly varying with exponent $γ=α(τ-1)/d$. The parameter $γ$ turns out to be crucial for the behavior of the model. Conditions on the weight distribution and $γ$ are formulated for the existence of a critical value $λ_c\in(0,\infty)$ such that the graph contains an infinite component when $λ>λ_c$ and no infinite component when $λ<λ_c$. Furthermore, a phase transition is established for the graph distances between vertices in the infinite component at the point $γ=2$, that is, at the point where the degrees switch from having finite to infinite second moment.
The model can be viewed as an interpolation between long-range percolation and models for inhomogeneous random graphs, and we show that the behavior shares the interesting features of both these models.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2011;
originally announced March 2011.
-
Weak disorder in the stochastic mean-field model of distance II
Authors:
Shankar Bhamidi,
Remco van der Hofstad,
Gerard Hooghiemstra
Abstract:
In this paper, we study the complete graph $K_n$ with n vertices, where we attach an independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) weight to each of the n(n-1)/2 edges. We focus on the weight $W_n$ and the number of edges $H_n$ of the minimal weight path between vertex 1 and vertex n. It is shown in (Ann. Appl. Probab. 22 (2012) 29-69) that when the weights on the edges are i.i.d. with distribu…
▽ More
In this paper, we study the complete graph $K_n$ with n vertices, where we attach an independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) weight to each of the n(n-1)/2 edges. We focus on the weight $W_n$ and the number of edges $H_n$ of the minimal weight path between vertex 1 and vertex n. It is shown in (Ann. Appl. Probab. 22 (2012) 29-69) that when the weights on the edges are i.i.d. with distribution equal to that of $E^s$, where $s>0$ is some parameter, and E has an exponential distribution with mean 1, then $H_n$ is asymptotically normal with asymptotic mean $s\log n$ and asymptotic variance $s^2\log n$. In this paper, we analyze the situation when the weights have distribution $E^{-s},s>0$, in which case the behavior of $H_n$ is markedly different as $H_n$ is a tight sequence of random variables. More precisely, we use the method of Stein-Chen for Poisson approximations to show that, for almost all $s>0$, the hopcount $H_n$ converges in probability to the nearest integer of s+1 greater than or equal to 2, and identify the limiting distribution of the recentered and rescaled minimal weight. For a countable set of special s values denoted by $\mathcal{S}=\{s_j\}_{j\geq2}$, the hopcount $H_n$ takes on the values j and j+1 each with positive probability.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2013; v1 submitted 21 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.
-
First passage percolation on the Erdős-Rényi random graph
Authors:
Shankar Bhamidi,
Remco van der Hofstad,
Gerard Hooghiemstra
Abstract:
In this paper we explore first passage percolation (FPP) on the Erdős-Rényi random graph $G_n(p_n)$, where each edge is given an independent exponential edge weight with rate 1. In the sparse regime, i.e., when $np_n\to λ>1,$ we find refined asymptotics both for the minimal weight of the path between uniformly chosen vertices in the giant component, as well as for the hopcount (i.e., the number of…
▽ More
In this paper we explore first passage percolation (FPP) on the Erdős-Rényi random graph $G_n(p_n)$, where each edge is given an independent exponential edge weight with rate 1. In the sparse regime, i.e., when $np_n\to λ>1,$ we find refined asymptotics both for the minimal weight of the path between uniformly chosen vertices in the giant component, as well as for the hopcount (i.e., the number of edges) on this minimal weight path. More precisely, we prove a central limit theorem for the hopcount, with asymptotic mean and variance both equal to $λ/(λ-1)\log{n}$. Furthermore, we prove that the minimal weight centered by $\log{n}/(λ-1)$ converges in distribution. We also investigate the dense regime, where $np_n \to \infty$. We find that although the base graph is a {\it ultra small} (meaning that graph distances between uniformly chosen vertices are $o(\log{n})$), attaching random edge weights changes the geometry of the network completely. Indeed, the hopcount $H_n$ satisfies the universality property that whatever be the value of $p_n$, \ $H_n/\log{n}\to 1$ in probability and, more precisely, $(H_n-β_n\log{n})/\sqrt{\log{n}}$, where $β_n=λ_n/(λ_n-1)$, has a limiting standard normal distribution. The constant $β_n$ can be replaced by 1 precisely when $λ_n\gg \sqrt{\log{n}}$, a case that has appeared in the literature (under stronger conditions on $λ_n$). We also find bounds for the maximal weight and maximal hopcount between vertices in the graph. This paper continues the investigation of FPP initiated by the authors. Compared to the setting on the configuration model studied in \cite{BHHS08}, the proofs presented here are much simpler due to a direct relation between FPP on the Erdős-Rényi random graph and thinned continuous-time branching processes.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2010;
originally announced May 2010.
-
Extreme value theory, Poisson-Dirichlet distributions and FPP on random networks
Authors:
Shankar Bhamidi,
Remco van der Hofstad,
Gerard Hooghiemstra
Abstract:
We study first passage percolation on the configuration model (CM) having power-law degrees with exponent $τ\in [1,2)$. To this end we equip the edges with exponential weights. We derive the distributional limit of the minimal weight of a path between typical vertices in the network and the number of edges on the minimal weight path, which can be computed in terms of the Poisson-Dirichlet distri…
▽ More
We study first passage percolation on the configuration model (CM) having power-law degrees with exponent $τ\in [1,2)$. To this end we equip the edges with exponential weights. We derive the distributional limit of the minimal weight of a path between typical vertices in the network and the number of edges on the minimal weight path, which can be computed in terms of the Poisson-Dirichlet distribution. We explicitly describe these limits via the construction of an infinite limiting object describing the FPP problem in the densely connected core of the network. We consider two separate cases, namely, the {\it original CM}, in which each edge, regardless of its multiplicity, receives an independent exponential weight, as well as the {\it erased CM}, for which there is an independent exponential weight between any pair of direct neighbors. While the results are qualitatively similar, surprisingly the limiting random variables are quite different.
Our results imply that the flow carrying properties of the network are markedly different from either the mean-field setting or the locally tree-like setting, which occurs as $τ>2$, and for which the hopcount between typical vertices scales as $\log{n}$. In our setting the hopcount is tight and has an explicit limiting distribution, showing that one can transfer information remarkably quickly between different vertices in the network. This efficiency has a down side in that such networks are remarkably fragile to directed attacks. These results continue a general program by the authors to obtain a complete picture of how random disorder changes the inherent geometry of various random network models.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2009;
originally announced May 2009.
-
First passage percolation on random graphs with finite mean degrees
Authors:
Shankar Bhamidi,
Remco van der Hofstad,
Gerard Hooghiemstra
Abstract:
We study first passage percolation on the configuration model. Assuming that each edge has an independent exponentially distributed edge weight, we derive explicit distributional asymptotics for the minimum weight between two randomly chosen connected vertices in the network, as well as for the number of edges on the least weight path, the so-called hopcount. We analyze the configuration model wit…
▽ More
We study first passage percolation on the configuration model. Assuming that each edge has an independent exponentially distributed edge weight, we derive explicit distributional asymptotics for the minimum weight between two randomly chosen connected vertices in the network, as well as for the number of edges on the least weight path, the so-called hopcount. We analyze the configuration model with degree power-law exponent $τ>2$, in which the degrees are assumed to be i.i.d. with a tail distribution which is either of power-law form with exponent $τ-1>1$, or has even thinner tails ($τ=\infty$). In this model, the degrees have a finite first moment, while the variance is finite for $τ>3$, but infinite for $τ\in(2,3)$. We prove a central limit theorem for the hopcount, with asymptotically equal means and variances equal to $α\log{n}$, where $α\in(0,1)$ for $τ\in(2,3)$, while $α>1$ for $τ>3$. Here $n$ denotes the size of the graph. For $τ\in (2,3)$, it is known that the graph distance between two randomly chosen connected vertices is proportional to $\log \log{n}$ [Electron. J. Probab. 12 (2007) 703--766], that is, distances are ultra small. Thus, the addition of edge weights causes a marked change in the geometry of the network. We further study the weight of the least weight path and prove convergence in distribution of an appropriately centered version. This study continues the program initiated in [J. Math. Phys. 49 (2008) 125218] of showing that $\log{n}$ is the correct scaling for the hopcount under i.i.d. edge disorder, even if the graph distance between two randomly chosen vertices is of much smaller order. The case of infinite mean degrees ($τ\in[1,2)$) is studied in [Extreme value theory, Poisson--Dirichlet distributions and first passage percolation on random networks (2009) Preprint] where it is proved that the hopcount remains uniformly bounded and converges in distribution.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2010; v1 submitted 30 March, 2009;
originally announced March 2009.
-
Diameters in preferential attachment models
Authors:
Sander Dommers,
Remco van der Hofstad,
Gerard Hooghiemstra
Abstract:
In this paper, we investigate the diameter in preferential attachment (PA-) models, thus quantifying the statement that these models are small worlds. The models studied here are such that edges are attached to older vertices proportional to the degree plus a constant, i.e., we consider affine PA-models. There is a substantial amount of literature proving that, quite generally, PA-graphs possess…
▽ More
In this paper, we investigate the diameter in preferential attachment (PA-) models, thus quantifying the statement that these models are small worlds. The models studied here are such that edges are attached to older vertices proportional to the degree plus a constant, i.e., we consider affine PA-models. There is a substantial amount of literature proving that, quite generally, PA-graphs possess power-law degree sequences with a power-law exponent τ>2.
We prove that the diameter of the PA-model is bounded above by a constant times \log{t}, where t is the size of the graph. When the power-law exponent τexceeds 3, then we prove that \log{t} is the right order, by proving a lower bound of this order, both for the diameter as well as for the typical distance. This shows that, for τ>3, distances are of the order \log{t}. For τ\in (2,3), we improve the upper bound to a constant times \log\log{t}, and prove a lower bound of the same order for the diameter. Unfortunately, this proof does not extend to typical distances. These results do show that the diameter is of order \log\log{t}.
These bounds partially prove predictions by physicists that the typical distance in PA-graphs are similar to the ones in other scale-free random graphs, such as the configuration model and various inhomogeneous random graph models, where typical distances have been shown to be of order \log\log{t} when τ\in (2,3), and of order \log{t} when τ>3.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2010; v1 submitted 29 May, 2007;
originally announced May 2007.
-
A preferential attachment model with random initial degrees
Authors:
Maria Deijfen,
Henri van den Esker,
Remco van der Hofstad,
Gerard Hooghiemstra
Abstract:
In this paper, a random graph process ${G(t)}_{t\geq 1}$ is studied and its degree sequence is analyzed. Let $(W_t)_{t\geq 1}$ be an i.i.d. sequence. The graph process is defined so that, at each integer time $t$, a new vertex, with $W_t$ edges attached to it, is added to the graph. The new edges added at time t are then preferentially connected to older vertices, i.e., conditionally on $G(t-1)$,…
▽ More
In this paper, a random graph process ${G(t)}_{t\geq 1}$ is studied and its degree sequence is analyzed. Let $(W_t)_{t\geq 1}$ be an i.i.d. sequence. The graph process is defined so that, at each integer time $t$, a new vertex, with $W_t$ edges attached to it, is added to the graph. The new edges added at time t are then preferentially connected to older vertices, i.e., conditionally on $G(t-1)$, the probability that a given edge is connected to vertex i is proportional to $d_i(t-1)+δ$, where $d_i(t-1)$ is the degree of vertex $i$ at time $t-1$, independently of the other edges. The main result is that the asymptotical degree sequence for this process is a power law with exponent $τ=\min\{τ_{W}, τ_{P}\}$, where $τ_{W}$ is the power-law exponent of the initial degrees $(W_t)_{t\geq 1}$ and $τ_{P}$ the exponent predicted by pure preferential attachment. This result extends previous work by Cooper and Frieze, which is surveyed.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2020; v1 submitted 29 May, 2007;
originally announced May 2007.
-
Universality for the distance in finite variance random graphs: Extended version
Authors:
Henri van den Esker,
Remco van der Hofstad,
Gerard Hooghiemstra
Abstract:
We generalize the asymptotic behavior of the graph distance between two uniformly chosen nodes in the configuration model to a wide class of random graphs. Among others, this class contains the Poissonian random graph, the expected degree random graph and the generalized random graph (including the classical Erdos-Renyi graph).
In the paper we assign to each node a deterministic capacity and t…
▽ More
We generalize the asymptotic behavior of the graph distance between two uniformly chosen nodes in the configuration model to a wide class of random graphs. Among others, this class contains the Poissonian random graph, the expected degree random graph and the generalized random graph (including the classical Erdos-Renyi graph).
In the paper we assign to each node a deterministic capacity and the probability that there exists an edge between a pair of nodes is equal to a function of the product of the capacities of the pair divided by the total capacity of all the nodes. We consider capacities which are such that the degrees of a node has uniformly bounded moments of order strictly larger than two, so that, in particular, the degrees have finite variance. We prove that the graph distance grows like \log_νN, where the νdepends on the capacities. In addition, the random fluctuations around this asymptotic mean \log_νN are shown to be tight. We also consider the case where the capacities are independent copies of a positive random Λwith \prob{Λ> x}\leq cx^{1-τ}, for some constant c and τ>3, again resulting in graphs where the degrees have finite variance.
The method of proof of these results is to couple each member of the class to the Poissonian random graph, for which we then give the complete proof by adapting the arguments of the corresponding result for the configuration model.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2008; v1 submitted 16 May, 2006;
originally announced May 2006.
-
Distances in random graphs with finite mean and infinite variance degrees
Authors:
Remco van der Hofstad,
Gerard Hooghiemstra,
Dmitri Znamenski
Abstract:
In this paper we study random graphs with independent and identically distributed degrees of which the tail of the distribution function is regularly varying with exponent $τ\in (2,3)$.
The number of edges between two arbitrary nodes, also called the graph distance or hopcount, in a graph with $N$ nodes is investigated when $N\to \infty$. When $τ\in (2,3)$, this graph distance grows like…
▽ More
In this paper we study random graphs with independent and identically distributed degrees of which the tail of the distribution function is regularly varying with exponent $τ\in (2,3)$.
The number of edges between two arbitrary nodes, also called the graph distance or hopcount, in a graph with $N$ nodes is investigated when $N\to \infty$. When $τ\in (2,3)$, this graph distance grows like $2\frac{\log\log N}{|\log(τ-2)|}$. In different papers, the cases $τ>3$ and $τ\in (1,2)$ have been studied. We also study the fluctuations around these asymptotic means, and describe their distributions. The results presented here improve upon results of Reittu and Norros, who prove an upper bound only.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2005;
originally announced February 2005.
-
Random graphs with arbitrary i.i.d. degrees
Authors:
Remco van der Hofstad,
Gerard Hooghiemstra,
Dmitri Znamenski
Abstract:
In this paper we derive results concerning the connected components and the diameter of random graphs with an arbitrary i.i.d. degree sequence. We study these properties primarily, but not exclusively, when the tail of the degree distribution is regularly varying with exponent $1-τ$. There are three distinct cases: (i) $τ>3$, where the degrees have finite variance, (ii) $τ\in (2,3)$, where the d…
▽ More
In this paper we derive results concerning the connected components and the diameter of random graphs with an arbitrary i.i.d. degree sequence. We study these properties primarily, but not exclusively, when the tail of the degree distribution is regularly varying with exponent $1-τ$. There are three distinct cases: (i) $τ>3$, where the degrees have finite variance, (ii) $τ\in (2,3)$, where the degrees have infinite variance, but finite mean, and (iii) $τ\in (1,2)$, where the degrees have infinite mean. These random graphs can serve as models for complex networks where degree power laws are observed.
Our results are twofold. First, we give a criterion when there exists a unique largest connected component of size proportional to the size of the graph, and study sizes of the other connected components. Secondly, we establish a phase transition for the diameter when $τ\in (2,3)$. Indeed, we show that for $τ>2$ and when nodes with degree 2 are present with positive probability, the diameter of the random graph is, with high probability, bounded below by a constant times the logarithm of the size of the graph. On the other hand, assuming that all degrees are at least 3 or more, we show that, for $τ\in (2,3)$, the diameter of the graph is with high probability bounded from above by a constant times the $\log \log$ of the size of the graph.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2006; v1 submitted 28 February, 2005;
originally announced February 2005.
-
Distances in random graphs with finite variance degrees
Authors:
Remco van der Hofstad,
Gerard Hooghiemstra,
Piet Van Mieghem
Abstract:
In this paper we study a random graph with $N$ nodes, where node $j$ has degree $D_j$ and $\{D_j\}_{j=1}^N$ are i.i.d. with $\prob(D_j\leq x)=F(x)$. We assume that $1-F(x)\leq c x^{-τ+1}$ for some $τ>3$ and some constant $c>0$. This graph model is a variant of the so-called configuration model, and includes heavy tail degrees with finite variance.
The minimal number of edges between two arbitr…
▽ More
In this paper we study a random graph with $N$ nodes, where node $j$ has degree $D_j$ and $\{D_j\}_{j=1}^N$ are i.i.d. with $\prob(D_j\leq x)=F(x)$. We assume that $1-F(x)\leq c x^{-τ+1}$ for some $τ>3$ and some constant $c>0$. This graph model is a variant of the so-called configuration model, and includes heavy tail degrees with finite variance.
The minimal number of edges between two arbitrary connected nodes, also known as the graph distance or the hopcount, is investigated when $N\to \infty$. We prove that the graph distance grows like $\log_νN$, when the base of the logarithm equals $ν=\expec[D_j(D_j -1)]/\expec[D_j]>1$. This confirms the heuristic argument of Newman, Strogatz and Watts \cite{NSW00}. In addition, the random fluctuations around this asymptotic mean $\log_ν{N}$ are characterized and shown to be uniformly bounded. In particular, we show convergence in distribution of the centered graph distance along exponentially growing subsequences.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2004;
originally announced July 2004.
-
Distances in random graphs with infinite mean degrees
Authors:
Remco van der Hofstad,
Gerard Hooghiemstra,
Dmitri Znamenski
Abstract:
We study random graphs with an i.i.d. degree sequence of which the tail of the distribution function $F$ is regularly varying with exponent $τ\in (1,2)$. Thus, the degrees have infinite mean. Such random graphs can serve as models for complex networks where degree power laws are observed.
The minimal number of edges between two arbitrary nodes, also called the graph distance or the hopcount, i…
▽ More
We study random graphs with an i.i.d. degree sequence of which the tail of the distribution function $F$ is regularly varying with exponent $τ\in (1,2)$. Thus, the degrees have infinite mean. Such random graphs can serve as models for complex networks where degree power laws are observed.
The minimal number of edges between two arbitrary nodes, also called the graph distance or the hopcount, in a graph with $N$ nodes is investigated when $N\to \infty$. The paper is part of a sequel of three papers. The other two papers study the case where $τ\in (2,3)$, and $τ\in (3,\infty),$ respectively.
The main result of this paper is that the graph distance converges for $τ\in (1,2)$ to a limit random variable with probability mass exclusively on the points 2 and 3. We also consider the case where we condition the degrees to be at most $N^α$ for some $α>0.$ For $τ^{-1}<α<(τ-1)^{-1}$, the hopcount converges to 3 in probability, while for $α>(τ-1)^{-1}$, the hopcount converges to the same limit as for the unconditioned degrees. Our results give convincing asymptotics for the hopcount when the mean degree is infinite, using extreme value theory.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2004;
originally announced July 2004.
