-
Two regimes of dilute turbulent settling suspensions under shear
Authors:
Jake Langham,
Andrew J. Hogg
Abstract:
When turbulent flow is laden with negatively buoyant particles, their mean distribution over the direction of gravity can induce stable density gradients that penalize turbulent fluctuations. This effect is studied numerically for shear-driven flow with dilute non-inertial sediment. The turbulent dynamics and sediment transport depend critically on particle settling velocity $v_s$, splitting into…
▽ More
When turbulent flow is laden with negatively buoyant particles, their mean distribution over the direction of gravity can induce stable density gradients that penalize turbulent fluctuations. This effect is studied numerically for shear-driven flow with dilute non-inertial sediment. The turbulent dynamics and sediment transport depend critically on particle settling velocity $v_s$, splitting into two regimes: homogeneous weakly stratified turbulence and flow with developed turbulence atop an intermittent boundary layer. At intermediate $v_s$, neither state can be sustained and the flow laminarizes.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Simulating shallow morphodynamic flows on evolving topographies
Authors:
Jake Langham,
Mark J. Woodhouse,
Andrew J. Hogg,
Luke T. Jenkins,
Jeremy C. Phillips
Abstract:
We derive general depth-integrated model equations for overland flows featuring the evolution of suspended sediment that may be eroded from or deposited onto the underlying topography ('morphodynamics'). The resulting equations include geometric corrections that account for large variations in slope angle. These are often non-negligible for Earth-surface flows and may consequently be important for…
▽ More
We derive general depth-integrated model equations for overland flows featuring the evolution of suspended sediment that may be eroded from or deposited onto the underlying topography ('morphodynamics'). The resulting equations include geometric corrections that account for large variations in slope angle. These are often non-negligible for Earth-surface flows and may consequently be important for simulating natural hazards. We also show how to adapt existing finite volume schemes for the classical shallow water equations, to simulate our new equations in a way that preserves uniform steady states and exactly conserves the combined mass of the flow and bed. Finally, to demonstrate our formulation, we present computations using simple example model closures, fed by point flux sources. On initially constant slopes, flows exhibit different behaviours depending on the grade. Shallow slopes lead to weakly morphodynamic spreading flows that agree well with analytical similarity solutions. On more severe slopes, rapid erosion occurs, leading to self-channelising flows and ultimately a 'super-erosive' state, in which sediment entrainment and gravitational acceleration perpetually reinforce each other.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
The unsteady overtop** of barriers by gravity currents and dam-break flows
Authors:
Edward W. G. Skevington,
Andrew J. Hogg
Abstract:
The collision of a gravitationally-driven horizontal current with a barrier following release from a confining lock is investigated using a shallow water model of the motion, together with a sophisticated boundary condition capturing the local interaction. The boundary condition permits several overtop** modes: supercritical, subcritical, and blocked flow. The model is analysed both mathematical…
▽ More
The collision of a gravitationally-driven horizontal current with a barrier following release from a confining lock is investigated using a shallow water model of the motion, together with a sophisticated boundary condition capturing the local interaction. The boundary condition permits several overtop** modes: supercritical, subcritical, and blocked flow. The model is analysed both mathematically and numerically to reveal aspects of the unsteady motion and to compute the proportion of the fluid trapped upstream of the barrier. Several problems are treated. Firstly, the idealised problem of a uniform incident current is analysed to classify the unsteady dynamical regimes. Then, the extreme regimes of a very close or distant barrier are tackled, showing the progression of the interaction through the overtop** modes. Next, the trapped volume of fluid at late times is investigated numerically, demonstrating regimes in which the volume is determined purely by volumetric considerations, and others where transient inertial effects are significant. For a Boussinesq gravity current, even when the volume of the confined region behind the barrier is equal to the fluid volume, $30\%$ of the fluid escapes the domain, and a confined volume $3$ times larger is required for the overtopped volume to be negligible. For a subaerial dam-break flow, the proportion that escapes is in excess of $60\%$ when the confined volume equals the fluid volume, and a barrier as tall as the initial release is required for negligible overtop**. Finally, we compare our predictions to experiments, showing a good agreement across a range of parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2023; v1 submitted 14 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
General linear stability properties of monoclinal shallow waves
Authors:
Jake Langham,
Andrew J. Hogg
Abstract:
We analyze the linear stability of monoclinal traveling waves on a constant incline, which connect uniform flowing regions of differing depths. The classical shallow-water equations are employed, subject to a general resistive drag term. This approach incorporates many flow rheologies into a single setting and enables us to investigate the features that set different systems apart. We derive simpl…
▽ More
We analyze the linear stability of monoclinal traveling waves on a constant incline, which connect uniform flowing regions of differing depths. The classical shallow-water equations are employed, subject to a general resistive drag term. This approach incorporates many flow rheologies into a single setting and enables us to investigate the features that set different systems apart. We derive simple formulae for the onset of linear instability, the corresponding linear growth rates and related properties including the existence of monoclinal waves, development of shocks and whether instability is initially triggered up- or downstream of the wave front. Also included within our framework is the presence of shear in the flow velocity profile, which is often neglected in depth-averaged studies. We find that it can significantly modify the threshold for instability. Constant corrections to the governing equations to account for sheared profiles via a 'momentum shape factor' act to stabilize traveling waves. More general correction terms are found to have a nontrivial and potentially important quantitative effect on the properties explored. Finally, we have investigated the spatial properties of the dominant (fastest growing) linear modes. We derive equations for their amplitude and frequency and find that both features can become severely amplified near the front of the traveling wave. For flood waves that propagate into a dry downstream region, this amplification is unbounded in the limit of high disturbance frequency. We show that the rate of divergence is a function of the spatial dependence of the wave depth profile at the front, which may be determined straightforwardly from the drag law.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2022; v1 submitted 2 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Linear stability of shallow morphodynamic flows
Authors:
Jake Langham,
Mark J. Woodhouse,
Andrew J. Hogg,
Jeremy C. Phillips
Abstract:
It is increasingly common for models of shallow-layer overland flows to include equations for the evolution of the underlying bed (morphodynamics) and the motion of an associated sedimentary phase. We investigate the linear stability properties of these systems in considerable generality. Naive formulations of the morphodynamics, featuring exchange of sediment between a well-mixed suspended load a…
▽ More
It is increasingly common for models of shallow-layer overland flows to include equations for the evolution of the underlying bed (morphodynamics) and the motion of an associated sedimentary phase. We investigate the linear stability properties of these systems in considerable generality. Naive formulations of the morphodynamics, featuring exchange of sediment between a well-mixed suspended load and the bed, lead to mathematically ill-posed governing equations. This is traced to a singularity in the linearised system at Froude number $Fr = 1$ that causes unbounded unstable growth of short-wavelength disturbances. The inclusion of neglected physical processes can restore well posedness. Turbulent momentum diffusion (eddy viscosity) and a suitably parametrised bed load sediment transport are shown separately to be sufficient in this regard. However, we demonstrate that such models typically inherit an associated instability that is absent from non-morphodynamic settings. Implications of our analyses are considered for simple generic closures, including a drag law that switches between fluid and granular behaviour, depending on the sediment concentration. Steady morphodynamic flows bifurcate into two states: dilute flows, which are stable at low $Fr$, and concentrated flows which are always unstable to disturbances in concentration. By computing the growth rates of linear modes across a wide region of parameter space, we examine in detail the effects of specific model parameters including the choices of sediment erodibility, eddy viscosity and bed load flux. These analyses may be used to inform the ongoing development of operational models in engineering and geosciences.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2021; v1 submitted 31 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Steady \& unsteady fluidised granular flows down slopes
Authors:
D. E. Jessop,
A. J. Hogg,
M. A. Gilbertson,
C. Schoof
Abstract:
Fluidisation is the process by which the weight of a bed of particles is supported by a gas flow passing through it from below. When fluidised materials flow down an incline, the dynamics of the motion differ from their non-fluidised counterparts because the granular agitation is no longer required to support the weight of the flowing layer. Instead, the weight is borne by the imposed gas flow and…
▽ More
Fluidisation is the process by which the weight of a bed of particles is supported by a gas flow passing through it from below. When fluidised materials flow down an incline, the dynamics of the motion differ from their non-fluidised counterparts because the granular agitation is no longer required to support the weight of the flowing layer. Instead, the weight is borne by the imposed gas flow and this leads to a greatly increased flow mobility. In this paper, a framework is developed to model this two phase motion by incorporating a kinetic theory description for the particulate stresses generated by the flow. In addition to calculating numerical solutions for fully developed flows, it is shown that for sufficiently thick flows there is often a local balance between the production and dissipation of the granular temperature. This phenomenon permits an asymptotic reduction of the full governing equations and the identification of a simple state in which the volume fraction of the flow is uniform. The results of the model are compared with new experimental measurements of the internal velocity profiles of steady granular flows down slopes. The distance covered with time by unsteady granular flows down slopes and along horizontal surfaces and their shapes are also measured and compared with theoretical predictions developed for flows that are thin relative to their streamwise extent. For the horizontal flows, it was found that resistance from the sidewalls was required in addition to basal resistance to capture accurately the unsteady evolution of the front position and the depth of the current and for situations in which side-wall drag dominates, similarity solutions are found for the experimentally-measured motion.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Unsteady turbulent buoyant plumes
Authors:
Mark J. Woodhouse,
Jeremy C. Phillips,
Andrew J. Hogg
Abstract:
We model the unsteady evolution of turbulent buoyant plumes following temporal changes to the source conditions. The integral model is derived from radial integration of the governing equations expressing the conservation of mass, axial momentum and buoyancy. The non-uniform radial profiles of the axial velocity and density deficit in the plume are explicitly described by shape factors in the inte…
▽ More
We model the unsteady evolution of turbulent buoyant plumes following temporal changes to the source conditions. The integral model is derived from radial integration of the governing equations expressing the conservation of mass, axial momentum and buoyancy. The non-uniform radial profiles of the axial velocity and density deficit in the plume are explicitly described by shape factors in the integral equations; the commonly-assumed top-hat profiles lead to shape factors equal to unity. The resultant model is hyperbolic when the momentum shape factor, determined from the radial profile of the mean axial velocity, differs from unity. The solutions of the model when source conditions are maintained at constant values retain the form of the well-established steady plume solutions. We demonstrate that the inclusion of a momentum shape factor that differs from unity leads to a well-posed integral model. Therefore, our model does not exhibit the mathematical pathologies that appear in previously proposed unsteady integral models of turbulent plumes. A stability threshold for the value of the shape factor is identified, resulting in a range of its values where the amplitude of small perturbations to the steady solutions decay with distance from the source. The hyperbolic character of the system allows the formation of discontinuities in the fields describing the plume properties during the unsteady evolution. We compute numerical solutions to illustrate the transient development following an abrupt change in the source conditions. The adjustment to the new source conditions occurs through the propagation of a pulse of fluid through the plume. The dynamics of this pulse are described by a similarity solution and, by constructing this new similarity solution, we identify three regimes in which the evolution of the transient pulse following adjustment of the source qualitatively differ.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
