Showing 1–50 of 63 results for author: Hoelzl, M

3D MHD modelling of plasmoid drift following massive material injection in a tokamak

Authors: M. Kong, E. Nardon, D. Bonfiglio, M. Hoelzl, D. Hu, the JOREK team, the EUROfusion Tokamak Exploitation Team

Abstract: Mechanisms of plasmoid drift in the presence of massive material injection are studied via 3D non-linear MHD modelling with the JOREK code, using a transient neutral source deposited on the low field side midplane of a JET H-mode plasma to clarify basic processes and compare with existing theory. The simulations confirm the important role of the propagation of shear Alfvén waves (SAWs) from both e… ▽ More Mechanisms of plasmoid drift in the presence of massive material injection are studied via 3D non-linear MHD modelling with the JOREK code, using a transient neutral source deposited on the low field side midplane of a JET H-mode plasma to clarify basic processes and compare with existing theory. The simulations confirm the important role of the propagation of shear Alfvén waves (SAWs) from both ends of the plasmoid ("SAW braking") and the development of external resistive currents along magnetic field lines ("Pégourié braking") in limiting charge separation and thus the $\mathbf{E}\times \mathbf{B}$ plasmoid drift, where $\mathbf{E}$ and $\mathbf{B}$ are the electric and magnetic fields, respectively. The drift velocity is found to be limited by the SAW braking for cases with relatively small source amplitude while the Pégourié braking is shown to be stronger with larger toroidal extent of the source, both in good agreement with existing theory. The simulations also identity the key role of the size of the $\mathbf{E}\times \mathbf{B}$ flow region on plasmoid drift and show that the saturated velocity caused by dominant SAW braking agrees well with theory when considering an effective pressure within the $\mathbf{E}\times \mathbf{B}$ flow region. The existence of SAWs in the simulations is demonstrated and the 3D picture of plasmoid drift is also discussed. △ Less

Submitted 1 July, 2024; originally announced July 2024.

Comments: To be submitted to Nuclear Fusion

Understanding Large-Scale Plasma Simulation Challenges for Fusion Energy on Supercomputers

Authors: Jeremy J. Williams, Ashish Bhole, Dylan Kierans, Matthias Hoelzl, Ihor Holod, Weikang Tang, David Tskhakaya, Stefan Costea, Leon Kos, Ales Podolnik, Jakub Hromadka, JOREK Team, Erwin Laure, Stefano Markidis

Abstract: Understanding plasma instabilities is essential for achieving sustainable fusion energy, with large-scale plasma simulations playing a crucial role in both the design and development of next-generation fusion energy devices and the modelling of industrial plasmas. To achieve sustainable fusion energy, it is essential to accurately model and predict plasma behavior under extreme conditions, requiri… ▽ More Understanding plasma instabilities is essential for achieving sustainable fusion energy, with large-scale plasma simulations playing a crucial role in both the design and development of next-generation fusion energy devices and the modelling of industrial plasmas. To achieve sustainable fusion energy, it is essential to accurately model and predict plasma behavior under extreme conditions, requiring sophisticated simulation codes capable of capturing the complex interaction between plasma dynamics, magnetic fields, and material surfaces. In this work, we conduct a comprehensive HPC analysis of two prominent plasma simulation codes, BIT1 and JOREK, to advance understanding of plasma behavior in fusion energy applications. Our focus is on evaluating JOREK's computational efficiency and scalability for simulating non-linear MHD phenomena in tokamak fusion devices. The motivation behind this work stems from the urgent need to advance our understanding of plasma instabilities in magnetically confined fusion devices. Enhancing JOREK's performance on supercomputers improves fusion plasma code predictability, enabling more accurate modelling and faster optimization of fusion designs, thereby contributing to sustainable fusion energy. In prior studies, we analysed BIT1, a massively parallel Particle-in-Cell (PIC) code for studying plasma-material interactions in fusion devices. Our investigations into BIT1's computational requirements and scalability on advanced supercomputing architectures yielded valuable insights. Through detailed profiling and performance analysis, we have identified the primary bottlenecks and implemented optimization strategies, significantly enhancing parallel performance. This previous work serves as a foundation for our present endeavours. △ Less

Submitted 29 June, 2024; originally announced July 2024.

Comments: Accepted by EPS PLASMA 2024 (50th European Physical Society Conference on Plasma Physics), prepared in the standardized EPS conference proceedings format and consists of 4 pages, which includes the main text, references, and figures

Axisymmetric predictions for mitigated and vertically unstable disruptions in ITER with runaway electrons

Authors: V. Bandaru, M. Hoelzl, F. J. Artola, M. Lehnen, JOREK team

Abstract: We present two-dimensional global simulations of mitigated and vertically unstable disruptions in ITER in the presence of runaway electrons. An elongated plasma in free-boundary equilibrium is subjected to an artificial thermal quench and current-profile flattening, followed by one or more massive material injections and RE avalanche. Scenarios of major disruptions as well as upward and downward v… ▽ More We present two-dimensional global simulations of mitigated and vertically unstable disruptions in ITER in the presence of runaway electrons. An elongated plasma in free-boundary equilibrium is subjected to an artificial thermal quench and current-profile flattening, followed by one or more massive material injections and RE avalanche. Scenarios of major disruptions as well as upward and downward vertical displacement events are considered. Results provide important insights into the effects of runaway electron formation, post thermal quench current-profile, injection quantities and timings, and impurity flushout on the overall evolution of disruption and the plasma vertical motion thereof. Interplay between the various effects offers scope for potentially beneficial runaway electron mitigation scenarios. △ Less

Submitted 14 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

Plasmoid drift and first wall heat deposition during ITER H-mode dual-SPIs in JOREK simulations

Authors: D. Hu, F. J. Artola, E. Nardon, M. Lehnen, M. Kong, D. Bonfiglio, M. Hoelzl, G. T. A. Huijsmans, JOREK Team

Abstract: The heat flux mitigation during the Thermal Quench (TQ) by the Shattered Pellet Injection (SPI) is one of the major elements of disruption mitigation strategy for ITER. It's efficiency greatly depends on the SPI and the target plasma, and is ultimately checked by the heat deposition on to the PFCs. To investigate this, JOREK simulations of neon-mixed dual-SPIs into ITER baseline H-mode and a "degr… ▽ More The heat flux mitigation during the Thermal Quench (TQ) by the Shattered Pellet Injection (SPI) is one of the major elements of disruption mitigation strategy for ITER. It's efficiency greatly depends on the SPI and the target plasma, and is ultimately checked by the heat deposition on to the PFCs. To investigate this, JOREK simulations of neon-mixed dual-SPIs into ITER baseline H-mode and a "degraded H-mode" with and without good injector synchronization are performed with focus on the first wall heat flux and its energy impact. It is found that low neon fraction SPIs into the baseline H-mode plasmas exhibit strong major radial plasmoid drift as the fragments arrive at the pedestal, accompanied by edge stochasticity. Significant density expulsion and outgoing heat flux occurs as a result, reducing the mitigation efficiency. Such drift motion could be mitigated by injecting higher neon fraction pellets', or by considering the pre-disruption confinement degradation, thus improving the radiation fraction. The radiation heat flux is found to peak in the vicinity of the fragment injection location in the early injection phase, while it relaxes later on due to parallel impurity transport. The overall radiation asymmetry could be significantly mitigated by good synchronization. Time integration of the local heat flux is carried out to provide its energy impact for wall heat damage assessment. For the baseline H-mode case with full pellet injection, melting of the stainless steel of the diagnostic port could occur near the injection port, which is acceptable, without any melting of the first wall tungsten tiles. For the degraded H-mode cases with quarter-pellet SPIs, which have 1/4 total volume of a full pellet, the maximum energy impact approaches the tolerable limit of the stainless steel with un-synchronized SPIs, and stays well below such limit for the perfectly synchronized ones. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

Neural-Parareal: Dynamically Training Neural Operators as Coarse Solvers for Time-Parallelisation of Fusion MHD Simulations

Authors: S. J. P. Pamela, N. Carey, J. Brandstetter, R. Akers, L. Zanisi, J. Buchanan, V. Gopakumar, M. Hoelzl, G. Huijsmans, K. Pentland, T. James, G. Antonucci, the JOREK Team

Abstract: The fusion research facility ITER is currently being assembled to demonstrate that fusion can be used for industrial energy production, while several other programmes across the world are also moving forward, such as EU-DEMO, CFETR, SPARC and STEP. The high engineering complexity of a tokamak makes it an extremely challenging device to optimise, and test-based optimisation would be too slow and to… ▽ More The fusion research facility ITER is currently being assembled to demonstrate that fusion can be used for industrial energy production, while several other programmes across the world are also moving forward, such as EU-DEMO, CFETR, SPARC and STEP. The high engineering complexity of a tokamak makes it an extremely challenging device to optimise, and test-based optimisation would be too slow and too costly. Instead, digital design and optimisation must be favored, which requires strongly-coupled suites of High-Performance Computing calculations. In this context, having surrogate models to provide quick estimates with uncertainty quantification is essential to explore and optimise new design options. Furthermore, these surrogates can in turn be used to accelerate simulations in the first place. This is the case of Parareal, a time-parallelisation method that can speed-up large HPC simulations, where the coarse-solver can be replaced by a surrogate. A novel framework, Neural-Parareal, is developed to integrate the training of neural operators dynamically as more data becomes available. For a given input-parameter domain, as more simulations are being run with Parareal, the large amount of data generated by the algorithm is used to train new surrogate models to be used as coarse-solvers for future Parareal simulations, leading to progressively more accurate coarse-solvers, and thus higher speed-up. It is found that such neural network surrogates can be much more effective than traditional coarse-solver in providing a speed-up with Parareal. This study is a demonstration of the convergence of HPC and AI which simply has to become common practice in the world of digital engineering design. △ Less

Submitted 2 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Implementation of matrix compression in the coupling of JOREK to realistic 3D conducting wall structures

Authors: Federico Cipolletta, Nina Schwarz, Matthias Hoelzl, Salvatore Ventre, Nicola Isernia, Guglielmo Rubinacci, Alejandro Soba, Mervi Johanna Mantsinen, the JOREK Team

Abstract: JOREK is an advanced non-linear simulation code for studying MHD instabilities in magnetically confined fusion plasmas and their control and/or mitigation. A free-boundary and resistive wall extension was introduced via coupling to the STARWALL and CARIDDI codes, both able to provide dense response matrices describing the electromagnetic interactions between plasma and conducting structures. For d… ▽ More JOREK is an advanced non-linear simulation code for studying MHD instabilities in magnetically confined fusion plasmas and their control and/or mitigation. A free-boundary and resistive wall extension was introduced via coupling to the STARWALL and CARIDDI codes, both able to provide dense response matrices describing the electromagnetic interactions between plasma and conducting structures. For detailed CAD representations of the conducting structures and high resolutions for the plasma region, memory and computing time limitations restrict the possibility of simulating the ITER tokamak. In the present work, the Singular Value Decomposition provided by routines from the ScaLAPACK library has been successfully applied to compress some of the dense response matrices and thus optimize memory usage. This is demonstrated for simulations of Tearing Mode and Vertical Displacement Event instabilities. An outlook to future applications on large production cases and further extensions of the method are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 25 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Comments: 19 pages, 9 figures, firstly presented at the 4th Fusion HPC Workshop in November 2023, submitted to Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion in April 2024

RMP screening in JOREK-CARIDDI

Authors: Bas Slotema, Matthias Hoelzl, Verena Mitterauer

Abstract: Edge localized modes (ELMs) are instabilities at the tokamak edge that can have short outbursts of highly energetic particles and heat, which can severely damage the walls of a plasma reactor. Resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) are used to mitigate or eliminate ELMs from the plasma. One effect that can reduce the intensity of the RMP is screening, which is caused by eddy currents in conducting… ▽ More Edge localized modes (ELMs) are instabilities at the tokamak edge that can have short outbursts of highly energetic particles and heat, which can severely damage the walls of a plasma reactor. Resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) are used to mitigate or eliminate ELMs from the plasma. One effect that can reduce the intensity of the RMP is screening, which is caused by eddy currents in conducting structures or a plasma that are induced by a time-varying magnetic field. The eddy current code CARIDDI was recently coupled with the magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) code JOREK, and is able to capture the behavior of volumetric conducting structures that surround a plasma. The objective of this study is to characterize screening behavior in the JOREK-CARIDDI coupling. The analysis is divided in three parts. First, CARIDDI results are benchmarked against results from STARWALL, another JOREK extension that captures interactions of (two-dimensional) conducting structures. It is found that CARIDDI and STARWALL show good agreement, with slight variations. The second part covers the screening of time-varying RMP fields by conducting structures, oscillating at frequencies from 3 Hz to 10 kHz. The overall trends in screening behavior align qualitatively with findings from a previous analysis. However, an additional contribution to the screening at frequencies above 1 kHz was not observed, because the simulation in this report does not include screening by the RMP coil casing. Finally, a few tests were performed using a plasma configuration, to study the effect of plasma screening, including realistic plasma background flows. The results demonstrated the induction of eddy currents at rational surfaces within the plasma. These results contribute to an improved understanding of the screening of RMP fields, which is relevant for several applications to the operation of fusion reactors. △ Less

Submitted 29 February, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Nonlinear MHD modeling of soft $β$ limits in W7-AS

Authors: Rohan Ramasamy, Ksenia Aleynikova, Nikita Nikulsin, Florian Hindenlang, Ihor Holod, Erika Strumberger, Matthias Hoelzl, the JOREK team

Abstract: An important question for the outlook of stellarator reactors is their robustness against pressure driven modes, and the underlying mechanism behind experimentally observed soft $β$ limits. Towards building a robust answer to these questions, simulation studies are presented using a recently derived reduced nonlinear MHD model. First, the initial model implementation is extended to capture fluid c… ▽ More An important question for the outlook of stellarator reactors is their robustness against pressure driven modes, and the underlying mechanism behind experimentally observed soft $β$ limits. Towards building a robust answer to these questions, simulation studies are presented using a recently derived reduced nonlinear MHD model. First, the initial model implementation is extended to capture fluid compression by including the influence of parallel flows. Linear benchmarks of a (2, 1) tearing mode in W7-AS geometry, and interchange modes in a finite $β$, net-zero current carrying stellarator with low magnetic shear are then used to demonstrate the modeling capabilities. Finally, a validation study is conducted on experimental reconstructions of finite $β$ W7-AS discharges. In agreement with past experimental analysis, it is shown that (i) the MHD activity is resistive, (ii) a soft $β$ limit is observed, when the plasma resistivity approaches the estimated experimental value, and (iii) low $n$ MHD activity is observed at intermediate $β$ values, particularly a nonlinearly dominant (2, 1) mode. The MHD activity is mild, explaining the soft $β$ limit, because the plasma volume remains separated into distinct sub-volumes in which field lines are ergodically confined. For the assumed transport parameters, the enhanced perpendicular transport along stochastic magnetic field lines can be overcome with the experimental heating power. The limitations in the current modeling are described, alongside an outlook for characterising soft $β$ limits in more detail in future work. △ Less

Submitted 5 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: Submitted to Nuclear Fusion

Towards Robust Solvers for Nuclear Fusion Simulations Using JOREK: A Numerical Analysis Perspective

Authors: Alex Quinlan, Vandana Dwarka, Ihor Holod, Matthias Hoelzl

Abstract: One of the most well-established codes for modeling non-linear Magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) for tokamak reactors is JOREK, which solves these equations with a Bézier surface based finite element method. This code produces a highly sparse but also very large linear system. The main solver behind the code uses the Generalized Minimum Residual Method (GMRES) with a physics-based preconditioner, but eve… ▽ More One of the most well-established codes for modeling non-linear Magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) for tokamak reactors is JOREK, which solves these equations with a Bézier surface based finite element method. This code produces a highly sparse but also very large linear system. The main solver behind the code uses the Generalized Minimum Residual Method (GMRES) with a physics-based preconditioner, but even with the preconditioner there are issues with memory and computation costs and the solver does not always converge well. This work contains the first thorough study of the mathematical properties of the underlying linear system. It enables us to diagnose and pinpoint the cause of hampered convergence. In particular, analyzing the spectral properties of the matrix and the preconditioned system with numerical linear algebra techniques, will open the door to research and investigate more performant solver strategies, such as projection methods. △ Less

Submitted 30 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

MSC Class: 65M12; 65M60; 65M25 ACM Class: G.1.3; G.1.8

Gyrokinetic simulations of neoclassical electron transport and bootstrap current generation in tokamak plasmas in the TRIMEG code

Authors: Lana Rekhviashvili, Zhixin Lu, Matthias Hoelzl, Andreas Bergmann, Philipp Lauber

Abstract: For magnetic confinement fusion in tokamak plasmas, some of the limitations to the particle and energy confinement times are caused by turbulence and collisions between particles in toroidal geometry, which determine the "anomalous" and the neoclassical transport, respectively. In this work, we focus on the implementation of neoclassical physics in the gyrokinetic code TRIMEG, which is a TRIangula… ▽ More For magnetic confinement fusion in tokamak plasmas, some of the limitations to the particle and energy confinement times are caused by turbulence and collisions between particles in toroidal geometry, which determine the "anomalous" and the neoclassical transport, respectively. In this work, we focus on the implementation of neoclassical physics in the gyrokinetic code TRIMEG, which is a TRIangular MEsh-based Gyrokinetic code that can handle both the closed and open field line geometries of a divertor tokamak. We report on the implementation of a simplified Lorentz collision operator in TRIMEG. Since the code uses an unstructured mesh, a procedure for calculating the flux surface averages of particle and energy fluxes and the bootstrap current is derived without relying on the poloidal coordinate, which is useful also for other simulations in unstructured meshes. With the newly implemented collision operator, we study electron transport and bootstrap current generation for various simplified and realistic geometries. In comparison to neoclassical theory, good agreement is obtained for the large aspect ratio case regarding the particle and energy fluxes as well as the bootstrap current. However, some discrepancies are observed at moderate aspect ratio and for a case with the realistic geometry of the ASDEX Upgrade tokamak. These deviations can be explained by different treatments and approximations in theory and simulation. In this paper, we demonstrate the capability to calculate the electron transport and bootstrap current generation in TRIMEG, which will allow for the self-consistent inclusion of neoclassical effects in gyrokinetic simulations in the future. △ Less

Submitted 13 June, 2023; v1 submitted 1 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

How well can VMEC predict the initial saturation of external kink modes in near circular tokamaks and $l=2$ stellarators?

Authors: Rohan Ramasamy, Matthias Hoelzl, Sophia Henneberg, Erika Strumberger, Karl Lackner, Sibylle Günter

Abstract: The equilibrium code, VMEC, is used to study external kinks in low $β$ tokamaks and $l=2$ stellarators. The applicability of the code when modelling nonlinear MHD effects is explored in an attempt to understand and predict how the initial saturation of the MHD mode depends on the external rotational transform. It is shown that helicity preserving, free boundary VMEC computations do not converge to… ▽ More The equilibrium code, VMEC, is used to study external kinks in low $β$ tokamaks and $l=2$ stellarators. The applicability of the code when modelling nonlinear MHD effects is explored in an attempt to understand and predict how the initial saturation of the MHD mode depends on the external rotational transform. It is shown that helicity preserving, free boundary VMEC computations do not converge to a single perturbed solution with increasing spectral resolution. Additional constraints are therefore applied to narrow down the numerical resolution parameters appropriate for physical scans. The dependence of the modelled (4, 1) kink mode on the external rotational transform and field periodicity is then studied. While saturated states can be identified which decrease in amplitude with increasing external rotational transform, bifurcated states are found that contradict this trend. It was therefore not possible to use VMEC alone to identify the physical dependency of the nonlinear mode amplitude on the magnetic geometry. The accuracy of the VMEC solutions is nevertheless demonstrated by showing that the expected toroidal mode coupling is captured in the magnetic energy spectrum for stellarator cases. Comparing with the initial value code, JOREK, the predicted redistribution of poloidal magnetic energy from the vacuum to plasma region in VMEC is shown to be physical. This work is a first step towards using VMEC to study MHD modes in stellarator geometry. △ Less

Submitted 28 May, 2023; v1 submitted 26 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

Comments: Submitted to Physics of Plasmas. The submission has been modified according to reviewer comments

Probing non-linear MHD stability of the EDA H-mode in ASDEX Upgrade

Authors: A Cathey, M Hoelzl, L Gil, MG Dunne, GF Harrer, GTA Huijsmans, J Kalis, K Lackner, SJP Pamela, E Wolfrum, S Günter, the JOREK team, the ASDEX Upgrade Team, the EUROfusion MST1 Team

Abstract: Regimes of operation in tokamaks that are devoid of large ELMs have to be better understood to extrapolate their applicability to reactor-relevant devices. This paper describes non-linear extended MHD simulations that use an experimental equilibrium from an EDA H-mode in ASDEX Upgrade. Linear ideal MHD analysis indicates that the operational point lies slightly inside of the stable region. The non… ▽ More Regimes of operation in tokamaks that are devoid of large ELMs have to be better understood to extrapolate their applicability to reactor-relevant devices. This paper describes non-linear extended MHD simulations that use an experimental equilibrium from an EDA H-mode in ASDEX Upgrade. Linear ideal MHD analysis indicates that the operational point lies slightly inside of the stable region. The non-linear simulations with the visco-resistive extended MHD code, JOREK, sustain non-axisymmetric perturbations that are linearly most unstable with toroidal mode numbers of n = \{6 \dots 9\}, but non-linearly higher and lower n become driven and the low-n become dominant. The poloidal mode velocity during the linear phase is found to correspond to the expected velocity for resistive ballooning modes. The perturbations that exist in the simulations have somewhat smaller poloidal wavenumbers (k_θ \sim 0.1 to 0.5 cm^{-1} ) than the experimental expectations for the quasi-coherent mode in EDA, and cause non-negligible transport in both the heat and particle channels. In the transition from linear to non-linear phase, the mode frequency chirps down from approximately 35 kHz to 13 kHz, which corresponds approximately to the lower end of frequencies that are typically observed in EDA H-modes in ASDEX Upgrade. △ Less

Submitted 22 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

MHD simulations of formation, sustainment and loss of Quiescent H-mode in the all-tungsten ASDEX Upgrade

Authors: Lorenz Meier, Matthias Hoelzl, Andres Cathey, Guido Huijsmans, Eleonora Viezzer, Mike Dunne, Jan van Dijk, Diego José Cruz Zabala, Karl Lackner, Sibylle Günter, ASDEX Upgrade Team, EUROfusion MST1 Team, JOREK Team

Abstract: Periodic edge localized modes (ELMs) are the non-linear consequences of pressure-gradient-driven ballooning modes and current-driven peeling modes becoming unstable in the pedestal region of high confinement fusion plasmas. In future tokamaks like ITER, large ELMs are foreseen to severely affect the lifetime of wall components as they transiently deposit large amounts of heat onto a narrow region… ▽ More Periodic edge localized modes (ELMs) are the non-linear consequences of pressure-gradient-driven ballooning modes and current-driven peeling modes becoming unstable in the pedestal region of high confinement fusion plasmas. In future tokamaks like ITER, large ELMs are foreseen to severely affect the lifetime of wall components as they transiently deposit large amounts of heat onto a narrow region at the divertor targets. Several strategies exist for avoidance, suppression, or mitigation of these instabilities, such as the naturally ELM-free quiescent H-mode (QH-mode). In the present article, an ASDEX Upgrade equilibrium that features a QH-mode is investigated through non-linear extended MHD simulations covering the dynamics over tens of milliseconds. The equilibrium is close to the ideal peeling limit and non-linearly develops saturated modes at the edge of the plasma. A dominant toroidal mode number of $n=1$ is found, for which the characteristic features of the edge harmonic oscillation are recovered. The saturated modes contribute to heat and particle transport preventing pedestal build-up to the ELM triggering threshold. The non-linear dynamics of the mode, in particular its interaction with the evolution of the edge safety factor is studied, which suggest a possible new saturation mechanism for the QH-mode. The simulations show good qualitative and quantitative agreement to experiments in AUG. In particular, the processes leading to the termination of QH-mode above a density threshold is studied, which results in the transition into an ELM regime. In the vicinity of this threshold, limit cycle oscillations are observed. △ Less

Submitted 12 July, 2023; v1 submitted 18 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Comments: Revised version with modifications from review process included

Journal ref: Nuclear Fusion 63, 086026 (2023)

Full $f$ and $δf$ gyrokinetic particle simulations of Alfvén waves and energetic particle physics

Authors: Zhixin Lu, Guo Meng, Roman Hatzky, Matthias Hoelzl, Philipp Lauber

Abstract: In this work, we focus on the development of the particle-in-cell scheme and the application to the studies of Alfvén waves and energetic particle physics in tokamak plasmas. The $δf$ and full $f$ schemes are formulated on the same footing adopting mixed variables and the pullback scheme for electromagnetic problems. The TRIMEG-GKX code [Lu et al. J. Comput. Phys. 440 (2021) 110384] has been upgra… ▽ More In this work, we focus on the development of the particle-in-cell scheme and the application to the studies of Alfvén waves and energetic particle physics in tokamak plasmas. The $δf$ and full $f$ schemes are formulated on the same footing adopting mixed variables and the pullback scheme for electromagnetic problems. The TRIMEG-GKX code [Lu et al. J. Comput. Phys. 440 (2021) 110384] has been upgraded using cubic spline finite elements and full $f$ and $δf$ schemes. The EP-driven TAE has been simulated for the ITPA-TAE case featured by a small electron skin depth $\sim 1.18\times10^{-3}\;{\rm m}$, which is a challenging parameter regime of electromagnetic simulations, especially for the full $f$ model. The simulation results using the $δf$ scheme are in good agreement with previous work. Excellent performance of the mixed variable/pullback scheme has been observed for both full $f$ and $δf$ schemes. Simulations with mixed full $f$ EPs and $δf$ electrons and thermal ions demonstrate the good features of this novel scheme in mitigating the noise level. The full $f$ scheme is a natural choice for EP physics studies which allows a large variation of EP profiles and distributions in velocity space, providing a powerful tool for kinetic studies using realistic experimental distributions related to intermittent and transient plasma activities. △ Less

Submitted 9 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: 27 pages, 8 figures

Filamentary plasma eruptions and the heating and acceleration of electrons

Authors: Heinz Isliker, Andres Cathey, Matthias Hoelzl, Stanislas Pamela, Loukas Vlahos

Abstract: We present test-particle simulations of electrons during a nonlinear MHD simulation of a type-I edge localized mode (ELM) to explore the effect of an eruptive plasma filament on the kinetic level. The electrons are moderately heated and accelerated during the filamentary eruption on a fast time scale of the order of 0.5 ms. A clearly non-thermal tail is formed in the distribution of the kinetic en… ▽ More We present test-particle simulations of electrons during a nonlinear MHD simulation of a type-I edge localized mode (ELM) to explore the effect of an eruptive plasma filament on the kinetic level. The electrons are moderately heated and accelerated during the filamentary eruption on a fast time scale of the order of 0.5 ms. A clearly non-thermal tail is formed in the distribution of the kinetic energy that is of power-law shape and reaches 90 keV for some particles. The acceleration is exclusively observed in the direction parallel to the magnetic field, i.e. with a clear preference in counter-current direction, and we show that the parallel electric field is the cause of the observed acceleration. Most particles that escape from the system leave at one distinct strike-line in the outer divertor leg at some time during their energization. The esca** high energy electrons in the tail of the energy distribution are not affected by collisions, they thus show characteristics of runaway electrons. The mean square displacement indicates that transport in energy space clearly is super-diffusive, and interpreting the acceleration process as a random walk, we find that the distributions of energy-increments exhibit exponential tails, and transport in energy space is equally important of convective (systematic) and diffusive (stochastic) nature. By analyzing the MHD simulations per se, it turns out that the histograms of the parallel electric field in the edge region exhibit power-law shapes, and this clearly non-Gaussian statistics is ultimately one of the reasons for the moderately anomalous phenomena of particle transport that we find in energy space. △ Less

Submitted 21 October, 2022; v1 submitted 5 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Comments: Accepted for publication in Physics of Plasmas, Oct. 19, 2022. Regular article, 21 pages, 24 figures

Development and application of a hybrid MHD-kinetic model in JOREK

Authors: T. J. Bogaarts, M. Hoelzl, G. T. A. Huijsmans, X. Wang

Abstract: Energetic particle (EP) driven instabilities will be of strongly increased relevance in future burning plasmas as the EP pressure will be very large compared to the thermal plasma. Understanding the interaction of EPs and bulk plasma is crucial for develo** next-generation fusion devices. In this work, the JOREK MHD code is extended to allow for the simulation of EP instabilities at high EP pres… ▽ More Energetic particle (EP) driven instabilities will be of strongly increased relevance in future burning plasmas as the EP pressure will be very large compared to the thermal plasma. Understanding the interaction of EPs and bulk plasma is crucial for develo** next-generation fusion devices. In this work, the JOREK MHD code is extended to allow for the simulation of EP instabilities at high EP pressures using realistic plasma and EP parameter in a full-f formulation with anisotropic pressure coupling to the bluid background. The code is first benchmarked linearly for the ITPA-TAE as well as the experiment based AUG-NLED cases, obtaining good agreement to other codes. Then, it is applied to a high energetic particle pressure discharge in the ASDEX Upgrade tokamak using a realistic non-Maxwellian distribution of EPs, reproducing aspects of the experimentally observed instabilities. Non-linear applications are possible based on the implentation, but will require dedicated verification and validation left for future work. △ Less

Submitted 10 November, 2022; v1 submitted 3 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Confinement of passing and trapped runaway electrons in the simulation of an ITER current quench

Authors: Konsta Särkimäki, Javier Artola, Matthias Hoelzl

Abstract: Runaway electrons (REs) present a high-priority issue for ITER but little is known about the extent to which RE generation is affected by the stochastic field intrinsic to disrupting plasmas. RE generation can be modelled with reduced kinetic models and there has been recent progress in involving losses due to field stochasticity, either via a loss-time parameter or radial transport coefficients w… ▽ More Runaway electrons (REs) present a high-priority issue for ITER but little is known about the extent to which RE generation is affected by the stochastic field intrinsic to disrupting plasmas. RE generation can be modelled with reduced kinetic models and there has been recent progress in involving losses due to field stochasticity, either via a loss-time parameter or radial transport coefficients which can be estimated by tracing test electrons in 3D fields. We evaluate these terms in ITER using a recent JOREK 3D MHD simulation of plasma disruption to provide the stochastic magnetic fields where RE markers are traced with the built-in particle tracing module. While the MHD simulation modelled only the current quench phase, the case is MHD unstable and exhibits similar relaxation as would be expected during the thermal quench. Therefore, the RE simulations can be considered beginning right after the thermal quench but before the MHD relaxation is complete. The plasma is found to become fully stochastic for 8 ms and the resulting transport is sufficient to overcome RE avalanche before flux surfaces are reformed. We also study transport mechanisms for trapped REs and find those to be deconfined as well during this phase. While the results presented here are not sufficient to assess the magnitude of the formed RE beam, we show that significant RE losses could be expected to arise due to field stochasticity. △ Less

Submitted 17 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Modelling of saturated external MHD instabilities in tokamaks: a comparison of 3D free boundary equilibria and nonlinear stability calculations

Authors: Rohan Ramasamy, Guillermo Bustos Ramirez, Matthias Hoelzl, Jonathan Graves, Guillermo Suárez López, Karl Lackner, Sibylle Günter, the JOREK team

Abstract: 3D free boundary equilibrium computations have recently been used to model external kinks and edge harmonic oscillations (EHOs), comparing with linear MHD stability codes, and nonlinear analytic theory [Kleiner et al, PPCF 61 084005 (2019)]. In this study, results of the VMEC equilibrium code are compared further with nonlinear reduced MHD simulations, using the JOREK code. The purpose of this inv… ▽ More 3D free boundary equilibrium computations have recently been used to model external kinks and edge harmonic oscillations (EHOs), comparing with linear MHD stability codes, and nonlinear analytic theory [Kleiner et al, PPCF 61 084005 (2019)]. In this study, results of the VMEC equilibrium code are compared further with nonlinear reduced MHD simulations, using the JOREK code. The purpose of this investigation is to understand the extent to which the modelling approaches agree, and identify the important physical effects which can modify the dynamics. For the simulated external kink, which is dominated by a single toroidal harmonic, good agreement is found when a large Lundquist number is used in the JOREK simulation, such that resistive effects are sub-dominant. Modelling EHOs where multiple toroidal harmonics are linearly unstable, the saturated perturbation observed can differ in the dominant toroidal harmonic. On the ideal timescale, a n=2 EHO is observed in JOREK, while the saturated perturbation predicted by VMEC is a n=1 mode. Extending simulations into timescales where resistive effects can play a role, similar n=1 perturbations can be found. The coupling of different linearly unstable toroidal harmonics in the JOREK simulation broadens the magnetic energy spectrum and ergodises the plasma edge region, resulting in a more localised pressure perturbation. These effects are not observed in VMEC, because closed magnetic flux surfaces are enforced. Despite the sensitivity of JOREK results on the assumed resistivity, saturated states can be found using both approaches that are in reasonable agreement, even for this more advanced case. △ Less

Submitted 3 June, 2022; v1 submitted 9 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: Submitted to Physics of Plasmas, with revisions from review process included

JOREK3D: An extension of the JOREK nonlinear MHD code to stellarators

Authors: Nikita Nikulsin, Rohan Ramasamy, Matthias Hoelzl, Florian Hindenlang, Erika Strumberger, Karl Lackner, Sibylle Günter

Abstract: Although the basic concept of a stellarator was known since the early days of fusion research, advances in computational technology have enabled the modelling of increasingly complicated devices, leading up to the construction of Wendelstein 7-X, which has recently shown promising results. This recent success has revived interest in the nonlinear 3D MHD modelling of stellarators in order to better… ▽ More Although the basic concept of a stellarator was known since the early days of fusion research, advances in computational technology have enabled the modelling of increasingly complicated devices, leading up to the construction of Wendelstein 7-X, which has recently shown promising results. This recent success has revived interest in the nonlinear 3D MHD modelling of stellarators in order to better understand their performance and operational limits. This paper reports on the extension of the JOREK code to 3D geometries and on the first stellarator simulations carried out with it. The first simple simulations shown here address the classic Wendelstein 7-A stellarator using a reduced MHD model previously derived by us. The results demonstrate that stable full MHD equilibria are preserved in the reduced model: the flux surfaces do not move throughout the simulation, and closely match the flux surfaces of the full MHD equilibrium. Further, both tearing and ballooning modes were simulated, and the linear growth rates measured in JOREK are in reasonable agreement with the growth rates from the CASTOR3D linear MHD code. △ Less

Submitted 12 May, 2022; v1 submitted 28 January, 2022; originally announced January 2022.

Comments: 16 pages, 12 figures. Based mostly on the last chapter of the first author's doctoral thesis, with some data new data that was not included in the thesis. The article was submitted to Physics of Plasmas

Journal ref: Phys. Plasmas 29, 063901 (2022)

Complete 3D MHD simulations of the current quench phase of ITER mitigated disruptions

Authors: F. J. Artola, A. Loarte, M. Hoelzl, M. Lehnen, N. Schwarz, the JOREK team

Abstract: Complete 3D simulations of the current quench phase of ITER disruptions are key to predict asymmetric forces acting into the ITER wall. We present for the first time such simulations for ITER mitigated disruptions at realistic Lundquist numbers. For these strongly mitigated disruptions, we find that the edge safety factor remains above 2 and the maximal integral horizontal forces remain below 1 MN… ▽ More Complete 3D simulations of the current quench phase of ITER disruptions are key to predict asymmetric forces acting into the ITER wall. We present for the first time such simulations for ITER mitigated disruptions at realistic Lundquist numbers. For these strongly mitigated disruptions, we find that the edge safety factor remains above 2 and the maximal integral horizontal forces remain below 1 MN. The maximal integral vertical force is found to be 13 MN and arises in a time scale given by the resistive wall time as expected from theoretical considerations. In this respect, the vertical force arises after the plasma current has completely decayed, showing the importance of continuing the simulations also in the absence of plasma current. We conclude that the horizontal wall force rotation is not a concern for these strongly mitigated disruptions in ITER, since when the wall forces form, there are no remaining sources of rotation. △ Less

Submitted 10 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Comments: to be submitted to Nuclear Fusion

Journal ref: Nuclear Fusion 2021

An E & B Gyrokinetic Simulation Model for Kinetic Alfvén Waves inTokamak Plasmas

Authors: Maxwell Rosen, Zhixin Lu, Matthias Hoelzl

Abstract: The gyrokinetic particle simulation serves as a powerful tool for the studies of transport, nonlinear phenomenon, and energetic particle physics in tokamak plasmas. While most gyrokinetic simulations make use of the scalar and vector potentials, a new model (GK-E&B) has been developed by using the E and B field in a general and comprehensive form and has been implemented in simulating kinetic Alfv… ▽ More The gyrokinetic particle simulation serves as a powerful tool for the studies of transport, nonlinear phenomenon, and energetic particle physics in tokamak plasmas. While most gyrokinetic simulations make use of the scalar and vector potentials, a new model (GK-E&B) has been developed by using the E and B field in a general and comprehensive form and has been implemented in simulating kinetic Alfvén waves in uniform plasma [Chen et al, Science China Phys. Mechanics & Astronomy 64 (2021)]. In our work, the Chen et al. GK-E&B model has been expressed in general tokamak geometry explicitly using specific coordinates. Its reduction to the uniform plasma is verified and the numerical results show good agreement with the work by Chen et al. The theoretical dispersion relation and numerical results in the local screw pinch model are in excellent agreement. Numerical results show excellent performance in a realistic parameter regime of burning plasmas in terms of high values of $β/( M_e k_\perp^2 ρ_i^2)$, which is challenging for traditional methods due to the ``cancellation' problem. As one application, the GK-E&B model is implemented with kinetic electrons in the local limit. With the matched ITPA-TAE parameters, numerical results show the capability of the GK-E&B in treating the parallel electron Landau dam** for realistic tokamak plasma parameters. As another application, the global GK-E&B model is implemented with the dominant electron contribution to $E_\|$ in the cold electron limit. Its capability in simulating the finite $E_\|$ due to the finite electron mass is demonstrated. △ Less

Submitted 11 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: 12 pages, 11 figures

A quasi-continuous exhaust scenario for a fusion reactor: the renaissance of small edge localized modes

Authors: G. F. Harrer, M. Faitsch, L. Radovanovic, E. Wolfrum, C. Albert, A. Cathey, M. Cavedon, M. Dunne, T. Eich, R. Fischer, M. Hoelzl, B. Labit, H. Meyer, F. Aumayr, the ASDEX Upgrade Team, the EUROfusion MST1 Team

Abstract: Tokamak operational regimes with small edge localized modes (ELMs) could be a solution to the problem of large transient heat loads in future fusion reactors because they provide quasi-continuous exhaust while kee** a good plasma confinement. A ballooning mode mechanism near the last closed flux surface (LCFS) governed by an interplay of the pressure gradient and the magnetic shear there has bee… ▽ More Tokamak operational regimes with small edge localized modes (ELMs) could be a solution to the problem of large transient heat loads in future fusion reactors because they provide quasi-continuous exhaust while kee** a good plasma confinement. A ballooning mode mechanism near the last closed flux surface (LCFS) governed by an interplay of the pressure gradient and the magnetic shear there has been proposed for small ELMs in high density ASDEX Upgrade and TCV discharges. In this manuscript we explore different factors relevant for plasma edge stability in a wide range of edge safety factors by changing the connection length between the good and the bad curvature side. Simultaneously this influences the stabilizing effect of the local magnetic shear close to the LCFS as well as the $E \times B$ flow shear. Ideal ballooning stability calculations with the HELENA code reveal that small ELM plasmas are indeed unstable against ballooning modes very close to the LCFS but can exhibit second ballooning stability in the steep gradient region which correlates with enhanced confinement. We also present first non-linear simulations of small ELM regimes with the JOREK code including the $E \times B$ shear which indeed develop ballooning like fluctuations in the high triangularity limit. In the region where the small ELMs originate the dimensionless parameters are very similar in our investigated discharges and in a reactor, making this regime the ideal exhaust scenario for a future reactor. △ Less

Submitted 25 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

MHD simulations of small ELMs at low triangularity in ASDEX Upgrade

Authors: A. Cathey, M. Hoelzl, G. Harrer, M. G. Dunne, G. T. A. Huijsmans, K. Lackner, S. J. P. Pamela, E. Wolfrum, S. Günter, the JOREK team, the ASDEX Upgrade Team, the EUROfusion MST1 Team

Abstract: The development of small- and no-ELM regimes for ITER is a high priority topic due to the risks associated to type-I ELMs. By considering non-linear extended MHD simulations of the ASDEX Upgrade tokamak with the JOREK code, we probe a regime that avoids type-I ELMs completely provided that the separatrix density is high enough. The dynamics of the pedestal in this regime are observed to be qualita… ▽ More The development of small- and no-ELM regimes for ITER is a high priority topic due to the risks associated to type-I ELMs. By considering non-linear extended MHD simulations of the ASDEX Upgrade tokamak with the JOREK code, we probe a regime that avoids type-I ELMs completely provided that the separatrix density is high enough. The dynamics of the pedestal in this regime are observed to be qualitatively similar to the so-called quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE) regime in several ways. Repetitive type-I ELMs are substituted by roughly constant levels of outwards transport caused by peeling-ballooning modes (with dominant ballooning characteristics) which are localised in the last 5\% of the confined region (in normalised poloidal flux). The simulated low triangularity plasma transitions to a type-I ELMy H-mode if the separatrix density is sufficiently reduced or if the input heating power is sufficiently increased. The stabilising factors that play a role in the suppression of the small ELMs are also investigated by analysing the simulations, and the importance of including diamagnetic effects in the simulations is highlighted. By considering a scan in the pedestal resistivity and by measuring the poloidal velocity of the modes (and comparing to theoretical estimates for ideal and resistive modes), we identify the underlying instabilities as resistive peeling-ballooning modes. Decreasing the resistivity below experimentally-relevant conditions (i.e., going towards ideal MHD), the peeling-ballooning modes that constrain the pedestal below the type-I ELM stability boundary display sharply decreasing growth rates. △ Less

Submitted 15 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Collisional-radiative non-equilibrium impurity treatment for JOREK simulations

Authors: D. Hu, G. T. A. Huijsmans, E. Nardon, M. Hoelzl, M. Lehnen, D. Bonfiglio, JOREK Team

Abstract: A collisional-radiative non-equilibrium impurity treatment for JOREK 3D nonlinear magneto-hydrodynamic (MHD) simulations has been developed. The impurities are represented by super-particles flowing along the fluid velocity field lines, while ionizing and recombining independently according to ADAS data and local fluid density and temperature. The non-equilibrium impurity contributions are then pr… ▽ More A collisional-radiative non-equilibrium impurity treatment for JOREK 3D nonlinear magneto-hydrodynamic (MHD) simulations has been developed. The impurities are represented by super-particles flowing along the fluid velocity field lines, while ionizing and recombining independently according to ADAS data and local fluid density and temperature. The non-equilibrium impurity contributions are then projected back to the fluid field for self-consistent time evolution. A 2D test case is used to compare the new non-equilibrium impurity model against previous Coronal Equilibrium (CE) impurity treatment, as well as to compare the non-equilibrium impurity behavior between the single and the two temperature model. Further, we conduct benchmark with previously published coronal non-equilibrium results by other 3D nonlinear MHD codes such as M3D-C1 and NIMROD. The new non-equilibrium treatment is shown to successfully capture the early phase cooling by weakly ionized impurities which the CE model missed. The benchmarks with M3D-C1 and NIMROD show general agreement in both the integrated quantities and the 2D profile evolution, despite the difference in the atomic model used. The above comparison and benchmark cases demonstrate the capability of the non-equilibrium impurity model for JOREK, paving the way for more sophisticated 3D non-linear Massive Material Injection (MMI) simulations which have important applications in disruption mitigation studies. △ Less

Submitted 24 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: 31 pages, 19 figures

Comparing spontaneous and pellet-triggered ELMs via non-linear extended MHD simulations

Authors: A. Cathey, M. Hoelzl, S. Futatani, P. T. Lang, K. Lackner, G. T. A. Huijsmans, S. J. P. Pamela, S. Günter, the JOREK team, the ASDEX Upgrade Team, the EUROfusion MST1 Team

Abstract: Injecting frozen deuterium pellets into an ELMy H-mode plasma is a well established scheme for triggering edge localized modes (ELMs) before they naturally occur. Based on an ASDEX Upgrade H-mode plasma, this article presents a comparison of extended MHD simulations of spontaneous type-I ELMs and pellet-triggered ELMs allowing to study their non-linear dynamics in detail. In particular, pellet-tri… ▽ More Injecting frozen deuterium pellets into an ELMy H-mode plasma is a well established scheme for triggering edge localized modes (ELMs) before they naturally occur. Based on an ASDEX Upgrade H-mode plasma, this article presents a comparison of extended MHD simulations of spontaneous type-I ELMs and pellet-triggered ELMs allowing to study their non-linear dynamics in detail. In particular, pellet-triggered ELMs are simulated by injecting deuterium pellets into different time points during the pedestal build-up described in [A. Cathey et al. Nuclear Fusion 60, 124007 (2020)]. Realistic ExB and diamagnetic background plasma flows as well as the time dependent bootstrap current evolution are included during the build-up to capture the balance between stabilising and destabilising terms for the edge instabilities accurately. Dependencies on the pellet size and injection times are studied. The spatio-temporal structures of the modes and the resulting divertor heat fluxes are compared in detail between spontaneous and triggered ELMs. We observe that the premature excitation of ELMs by means of pellet injection is caused by a helical perturbation described by a toroidal mode number of n = 1. In accordance with experimental observations, the pellet-triggered ELMs show reduced thermal energy losses and narrower divertor wetted area with respect to spontaneous ELMs. The peak divertor energy fluency is seen to decrease when ELMs are triggered by pellets injected earlier during the pedestal build-up. △ Less

Submitted 11 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Nonlinear MHD simulations of external kinks in quasi-axisymmetric stellarators using an axisymmetric external rotational transform approximation

Authors: Rohan Ramasamy, Matthias Hoelzl, Erika Strumberger, Karl Lackner, Sibylle Günter

Abstract: Reduced magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) equations are used to study the nonlinear dynamics of external kinks in a quasi-axisymmetric (QA) stellarator with varying fractions of external rotational transform. The large bootstrap currents associated with high beta plasmas may make QA configurations susceptible to low n external modes, limiting their operational space. The violence of the nonlinear dynamics… ▽ More Reduced magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) equations are used to study the nonlinear dynamics of external kinks in a quasi-axisymmetric (QA) stellarator with varying fractions of external rotational transform. The large bootstrap currents associated with high beta plasmas may make QA configurations susceptible to low n external modes, limiting their operational space. The violence of the nonlinear dynamics, and, in particular, when these modes lead to a disruption, is not yet understood. In this paper, the nonlinear phase of external kinks in an unstable QA configuration with an edge safety factor below two is simulated. An axisymmetric approximation of this stellarator is constructed in the nonlinear MHD code, JOREK, capturing the influence of the external rotational transform. The use of this approximation for the considered stellarator is validated by comparing the linear dynamics against the linear viscoresistive MHD code, CASTOR3D. The nonlinear dynamics of this stellarator approximation are compared with an equivalent tokamak to understand the influence of a relatively small external rotational transform. While the external rotational transform does have a stabilising influence on the MHD activity, it remains violent. To explore the first order influence of a larger external rotational transform, this equilibrium parameter is artificially increased for the considered stellarator, reducing the effective plasma current. The violence of the kink instability is quantified, and shown to reduce with the increasing external rotational transform. At the same time, the external kink triggers internal modes that exacerbate the loss in confinement during the nonlinear phase, such that it remains large over much of the parameter space. It is only with a significant fraction of external rotational transform that these subsequent modes are stabilised. △ Less

Submitted 2 May, 2021; v1 submitted 5 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Comments: This article has been submitted to Nuclear Fusion. This version includes revisions to take into account reviewer comments

Enhanced Preconditioner for JOREK MHD Solver

Authors: I Holod, M Hoelzl, P S Verma, GTA Huijsmans, R Nies, JOREK Team

Abstract: The JOREK extended magneto-hydrodynamic (MHD) code is a widely used simulation code for studying the non-linear dynamics of large-scale instabilities in divertor tokamak plasmas. Due to the large scale-separation intrinsic to these phenomena both in space and time, the computational costs for simulations in realistic geometry and with realistic parameters can be very high, motivating the investmen… ▽ More The JOREK extended magneto-hydrodynamic (MHD) code is a widely used simulation code for studying the non-linear dynamics of large-scale instabilities in divertor tokamak plasmas. Due to the large scale-separation intrinsic to these phenomena both in space and time, the computational costs for simulations in realistic geometry and with realistic parameters can be very high, motivating the investment of considerable effort for optimization. In this article, a set of developments regarding the JOREK solver and preconditioner is described, which lead to overall significant benefits for large production simulations. This comprises in particular enhanced convergence in highly non-linear scenarios and a general reduction of memory consumption and computational costs. The developments include faster construction of preconditioner matrices, a domain decomposition of preconditioning matrices for solver libraries that can handle distributed matrices, interfaces for additional solver libraries, an option to use matrix compression methods, and the implementation of a complex solver interface for the preconditioner. The most significant development presented consists in a generalization of the physics based preconditioner to "mode groups", which allows to account for the dominant interactions between toroidal Fourier modes in highly non-linear simulations. At the cost of a moderate increase of memory consumption, the technique can strongly enhance convergence in suitable cases allowing to use significantly larger time steps. For all developments, benchmarks based on typical simulation cases demonstrate the resulting improvements. △ Less

Submitted 31 March, 2021; v1 submitted 20 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Simulations of COMPASS Vertical Displacement Events with a self-consistent model for halo currents including neutrals and sheath boundary conditions

Authors: F. J. Artola, A. Loarte, E. Matveeva, J. Havlicek, T. Markovic, J. Adamek, J. Cavalier, L. Kripner, G. T. A. Huijsmans, M. Lehnen, M. Hoelzl, R. Panek, COMPASS team, JOREK team

Abstract: The understanding of the halo current properties during disruptions is key to design and operate large scale tokamaks in view of the large thermal and electromagnetic loads that they entail. For the first time, we present a fully self-consistent model for halo current simulations including neutral particles and sheath boundary conditions. The model is used to simulate Vertical Displacement Events… ▽ More The understanding of the halo current properties during disruptions is key to design and operate large scale tokamaks in view of the large thermal and electromagnetic loads that they entail. For the first time, we present a fully self-consistent model for halo current simulations including neutral particles and sheath boundary conditions. The model is used to simulate Vertical Displacement Events (VDEs) occurring in the COMPASS tokamak. Recent COMPASS experiments have shown that the parallel halo current density at the plasma-wall interface is limited by the ion saturation current during VDE-induced disruptions. We show that usual MHD boundary conditions can lead to the violation of this physical limit and we implement this current density limitation through a boundary condition for the electrostatic potential. Sheath boundary conditions for the density, the heat flux, the parallel velocity and a realistic parameter choice (e.g. Spitzer $η$ and Spitzer-Härm $χ_\parallel$ values) extend present VDE simulations beyond the state of the art. Experimental measurements of the current density, temperature and heat flux profiles at the COMPASS divertor are compared with the results obtained from axisymmetric simulations. Since the ion saturation current density ($J_{sat}$) is shown to be essential to determine the halo current profile, parametric scans are performed to study its dependence on different quantities such as the plasma resistivity and the particle and heat diffusion coefficients. In this respect, the plasma resistivity in the halo region broadens significantly the $J_{sat}$ profile, increasing the halo width at a similar total halo current. △ Less

Submitted 5 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: Submitted to Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion via the special issue of the Joint Varenna-Lausanne international workshop (October 12-16, 2020)

Testing of the new JOREK stellarator-capable model in the tokamak limit

Authors: Nikita Nikulsin, Matthias Hoelzl, Alessandro Zocco, Karl Lackner, Sibylle Guenter

Abstract: In preparation for extending the JOREK nonlinear MHD code to stellarators, a hierarchy of stellarator-capable reduced and full MHD models has been derived and tested. The derivation was presented at the EFTC 2019 conference. Continuing this line of work, we have implemented the reduced MHD model (arXiv:1907.12486) as well as an alternative model which was newly derived using a different set of pro… ▽ More In preparation for extending the JOREK nonlinear MHD code to stellarators, a hierarchy of stellarator-capable reduced and full MHD models has been derived and tested. The derivation was presented at the EFTC 2019 conference. Continuing this line of work, we have implemented the reduced MHD model (arXiv:1907.12486) as well as an alternative model which was newly derived using a different set of projection operators for obtaining the scalar momentum equations from the full MHD vector momentum equation. With the new operators, the reduced model matches the standard JOREK reduced models for tokamaks in the tokamak limit and conserves energy exactly, while momentum conservation is less accurate than in the original model whenever field-aligned flow is present. △ Less

Submitted 30 March, 2021; v1 submitted 27 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: 23 pages, 1 table, 7 figures. Submitted to Journal of Plasma Physics

Journal ref: J. Plasma Phys. 87 (2021) 855870301

The JOREK non-linear extended MHD code and applications to large-scale instabilities and their control in magnetically confined fusion plasmas

Authors: M Hoelzl, GTA Huijsmans, SJP Pamela, M Becoulet, E Nardon, FJ Artola, B Nkonga, CV Atanasiu, V Bandaru, A Bhole, D Bonfiglio, A Cathey, O Czarny, A Dvornova, T Feher, A Fil, E Franck, S Futatani, M Gruca, H Guillard, JW Haverkort, I Holod, D Hu, SK Kim, SQ Korving , et al. (28 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: JOREK is a massively parallel fully implicit non-linear extended MHD code for realistic tokamak X-point plasmas. It has become a widely used versatile code for studying large-scale plasma instabilities and their control developed in an international community. This article gives a comprehensive overview of the physics models implemented, numerical methods applied for solving the equations and phys… ▽ More JOREK is a massively parallel fully implicit non-linear extended MHD code for realistic tokamak X-point plasmas. It has become a widely used versatile code for studying large-scale plasma instabilities and their control developed in an international community. This article gives a comprehensive overview of the physics models implemented, numerical methods applied for solving the equations and physics studies performed with the code. A dedicated section highlights some of the verification work done for the code. A hierarchy of different physics models is available including a free boundary and resistive wall extension and hybrid kinetic-fluid models. The code allows for flux-surface aligned iso-parametric finite element grids in single and double X-point plasmas which can be extended to the true physical walls and uses a robust fully implicit time step**. Particular focus is laid on plasma edge and scrape-off layer (SOL) physics as well as disruption related phenomena. Among the key results obtained with JOREK regarding plasma edge and SOL, are deep insights into the dynamics of edge localized modes (ELMs), ELM cycles, and ELM control by resonant magnetic perturbations, pellet injection, as well as by vertical magnetic kicks. Also ELM free regimes, detachment physics, the generation and transport of impurities during an ELM, and electrostatic turbulence in the pedestal region are investigated. Regarding disruptions, the focus is on the dynamics of the thermal quench and current quench triggered by massive gas injection (MGI) and shattered pellet injection (SPI), runaway electron (RE) dynamics as well as the RE interaction with MHD modes, and vertical displacement events (VDEs). Also the seeding and suppression of tearing modes (TMs), the dynamics of naturally occurring thermal quenches triggered by locked modes, and radiative collapses are being studied. △ Less

Submitted 21 April, 2021; v1 submitted 18 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: Comprehensive review published as special topic article in Nuclear Fusion

3D simulations of vertical displacement events in tokamaks: A benchmark of M3D-C$^1$, NIMROD and JOREK

Authors: F. J. Artola, C. R. Sovinec, S. C. Jardin, M. Hoelzl, I. Krebs, C. Clauser

Abstract: In recent years, the nonlinear 3D magnetohydrodynamic codes JOREK, M3D-C$^1$ and NIMROD developed the capability of modelling realistic 3D vertical displacement events (VDEs) including resistive walls. In this paper, a comprehensive 3D VDE benchmark is presented between these state of the art codes. The simulated case is based on an experimental NSTX plasma but with a simplified rectangular wall.… ▽ More In recent years, the nonlinear 3D magnetohydrodynamic codes JOREK, M3D-C$^1$ and NIMROD developed the capability of modelling realistic 3D vertical displacement events (VDEs) including resistive walls. In this paper, a comprehensive 3D VDE benchmark is presented between these state of the art codes. The simulated case is based on an experimental NSTX plasma but with a simplified rectangular wall. In spite of pronounced differences between physics models and numerical methods, the comparison shows very good agreement in the relevant quantities used to characterize disruptions such as the 3D wall forces and energy decay. This benchmark does not only bring confidence regarding the use of the mentioned codes for disruption studies, but also shows differences with respect to the used models (e.g. reduced versus full MHD models). The simulations show important 3D features for a NSTX plasma such as the self-consistent evolution of the halo current and the origin of the wall forces. In contrast to other reduced MHD models based on an ordering in the aspect ratio, the ansatz based JOREK reduced MHD model allows capturing the 3D dynamics even in the spherical tokamak limit considered here. △ Less

Submitted 9 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Towards Reconstructing Multi-Step Cyber Attacks in Modern Cloud Environments with Tripwires

Authors: Mario Kahlhofer, Michael Hölzl, Andreas Berger

Abstract: Rapidly-changing cloud environments that consist of heavily interconnected components are difficult to secure. Existing solutions often try to correlate many weak indicators to identify and reconstruct multi-step cyber attacks. The lack of a true, causal link between most of these indicators still leaves administrators with a lot of false-positives to browse through. We argue that cyber deception… ▽ More Rapidly-changing cloud environments that consist of heavily interconnected components are difficult to secure. Existing solutions often try to correlate many weak indicators to identify and reconstruct multi-step cyber attacks. The lack of a true, causal link between most of these indicators still leaves administrators with a lot of false-positives to browse through. We argue that cyber deception can improve the precision of attack detection systems, if used in a structured, and automatic way, i.e., in the form of so-called tripwires that ultimately span an attack graph, which assists attack reconstruction algorithms. This paper proposes an idea for a framework that combines cyber deception, automatic tripwire injection and attack graphs, which eventually enables us to reconstruct multi-step cyber attacks in modern cloud environments. △ Less

Submitted 25 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: To be published in European Interdisciplinary Cybersecurity Conference (EICC 2020)

Transition from no-ELM response to pellet ELM triggering during pedestal build-up -- insights from extended MHD simulations

Authors: S Futatani, A Cathey, M Hoelzl, P T Lang, G T A Huijsmans, M. Dunne, JOREK Team, ASDEX Upgrade Team, EUROfusion MST1 Team

Abstract: Pellet ELM triggering is a well established scheme for decreasing the time between two successive ELM crashes below its natural value. Reliable ELM pacing has been demonstrated experimentally in several devices increasing the ELM frequency considerably. However, it was also shown that the frequency cannot be increased arbitrarily due to a so-called lag-time. During this time after a preceding natu… ▽ More Pellet ELM triggering is a well established scheme for decreasing the time between two successive ELM crashes below its natural value. Reliable ELM pacing has been demonstrated experimentally in several devices increasing the ELM frequency considerably. However, it was also shown that the frequency cannot be increased arbitrarily due to a so-called lag-time. During this time after a preceding natural or triggered ELM crash, neither a natural ELM crash occurs nor the triggering of an ELM crash by pellet injection is possible. For this article, pellet ELM triggering simulations are advanced beyond previous studies in two ways. Firstly, realistic ExB and diamagnetic background flows are included. And secondly, the pellet is injected at different stages of the pedestal build-up. This allows to recover the lag-time for the first time in simulations and investigate it in detail. A series of non-linear extended MHD simulations is performed to investigate the plasma dynamics resulting from an injection at different time points during the pedestal build-up. The experimentally observed lag-time is qualitatively reproduced well. In particular, a sharp transition is observed between the regime where no ELMs can be triggered and the regime where pellet injection causes an ELM crash. Via variations of pellet parameters and injection time, the two regimes are studied and compared in detail revealing pronounced differences in the non-linear dynamics. The toroidal mode spectrum is significantly broader when an ELM crash is triggered enhancing the stochasticity and therefore also the losses of thermal energy along magnetic field lines. In the heat fluxes to the divertor targets, pronounced toroidal asymmetries are observed. In case of high injection velocities leading to deep penetration, also the excitation of core modes like the $2/1$ neoclassical tearing mode is observed. △ Less

Submitted 24 December, 2020; v1 submitted 16 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: 45 pages

Radiation asymmetry and MHD destabilization during the thermal quench after impurity Shattered Pellet Injection

Authors: D. Hu, E. Nardon, M. Hoelzl, F. Wieschollek, M. Lehnen, G. T. A. Huijsmans, D. C. van Vugt, S. -H. Kim, JET contributors, JOREK Team

Abstract: The radiation response and the MHD destabilization during the thermal quench after a mixed species Shattered Pellet Injection (SPI) with impurity species neon and argon are investigated via 3D non-linear MHD simulation using the JOREK code. Both the $n=0$ global current profile contraction and the local helical cooling at each rational surface caused by the pellet fragments are found to be respons… ▽ More The radiation response and the MHD destabilization during the thermal quench after a mixed species Shattered Pellet Injection (SPI) with impurity species neon and argon are investigated via 3D non-linear MHD simulation using the JOREK code. Both the $n=0$ global current profile contraction and the local helical cooling at each rational surface caused by the pellet fragments are found to be responsible for MHD destabilization after the injection. Significant current driven mode growth is observed as the fragments cross low order rational surfaces, resulting in rapidly inward propagating stochastic magnetic field, ultimately causing the core temperature collapse. The Thermal Quench (TQ) is triggered as the fragments arrive on the $q=1$ or $q=2$ surface depending on the exact $q$ profile and thus mode structure. When injecting from a single toroidal location, strong radiation asymmetry is found before and during the TQ as a result of the unrelaxed impurity density profile along the field line and asymmetric outward heat flux. Such asymmetry gradually relaxes over the course of the TQ, and is entirely eliminated by the end of it. Simulation results indicate that the aforementioned asymmetric radiation behavior could be significantly mitigated by injection from toroidally opposite locations, provided that the time delay between the two injectors is shorter than $1ms$. It is also found that the MHD response are sensitive to the relative timing and injection configuration in these multiple injection cases. △ Less

Submitted 25 November, 2020; v1 submitted 6 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: 35 pages, 21 figures

Non-linear extended MHD simulations of type-I edge localised mode cycles in ASDEX Upgrade and their underlying triggering mechanism

Authors: Andres Cathey, M. Hoelzl, K. Lackner, G. T. A. Huijsmans, M. G. Dunne, E. Wolfrum, S. J. P. Pamela, F. Orain, S. Günter, the JOREK team, the ASDEX Upgrade Team, the EUROfusion MST1 Team

Abstract: A triggering mechanism responsible for the explosive onset of edge localised modes (ELMs) in fusion plasmas is identified by performing, for the first time, non-linear magnetohydrodynamic simulations of repetitive type-I ELMs. Briefly prior to the ELM crash, destabilising and stabilising terms are affected at different timescales by an increasingly ergodic magnetic field caused by non-linear inter… ▽ More A triggering mechanism responsible for the explosive onset of edge localised modes (ELMs) in fusion plasmas is identified by performing, for the first time, non-linear magnetohydrodynamic simulations of repetitive type-I ELMs. Briefly prior to the ELM crash, destabilising and stabilising terms are affected at different timescales by an increasingly ergodic magnetic field caused by non-linear interactions between the axisymmetric background plasma and growing non-axisymmetric perturbations. The separation of timescales prompts the explosive, i.e. faster than exponential, growth of an ELM crash which lasts ${\sim}$ 500 $μ$s. The duration and size of the simulated ELM crashes compare qualitatively well with type-I ELMs in ASDEX Upgrade. As expected for type-I ELMs, a direct proportionality between the heating power in the simulations and the ELM repetition frequency is obtained. The simulations presented here are a major step forward towards predictive modelling of ELMs and of the assessment of mitigation techniques in ITER and other future tokamaks. △ Less

Submitted 26 October, 2020; v1 submitted 20 July, 2020; originally announced July 2020.

The development of an implicit full f method for electromagnetic particle simulations of Alfvén waves and energetic particle physics

Authors: Z. X. Lu, G. Meng, M. Hoelzl, Ph. Lauber

Abstract: In this work, an implicit scheme for particle-in-cell/Fourier electromagnetic simulations is developed and applied to studies of Alfvén waves in one dimension and three-dimensional tokamak plasmas. An analytical treatment is introduced to achieve efficient convergence of the iterative solution of the implicit field-particle system. First, its application to the one-dimensional uniform plasma demon… ▽ More In this work, an implicit scheme for particle-in-cell/Fourier electromagnetic simulations is developed and applied to studies of Alfvén waves in one dimension and three-dimensional tokamak plasmas. An analytical treatment is introduced to achieve efficient convergence of the iterative solution of the implicit field-particle system. First, its application to the one-dimensional uniform plasma demonstrates its applicability in a broad range of $β/m_e$ values. Second, toroidicity induced Alfvén eigenmodes (TAE) are simulated in a three-dimensional axisymmetric tokamak plasma, using the widely studied case defined by the International Tokamak Physics Activity (ITPA) Energetic Particle (EP) Topical Group. The real frequency and the growth (or dam**) rate of the TAE with (or without) EPs agree with previous results reasonably well. The full f electromagnetic particle scheme established in this work provides a possible natural choice for EP transport studies where large profile variation and arbitrary particle distribution functions need to be treated in kinetic simulations. △ Less

Submitted 2 February, 2021; v1 submitted 14 July, 2020; originally announced July 2020.

Comments: 30 pages, 8 figures

Fast plasma dilution in ITER with pure Deuterium Shattered Pellet Injection

Authors: E. Nardon, D. Hu, M. Hoelzl, D. Bonfiglio

Abstract: JOREK 3D non-linear MagnetoHydroDynamic (MHD) simulations of pure Deuterium Shattered Pellet Injection in ITER are presented. It is shown that such a scheme could allow diluting the plasma by more than a factor 10 without immediately triggering large MHD activity, provided the background impurity density is low enough. This appears as a promising strategy to reduce the risk of hot tail Runaway Ele… ▽ More JOREK 3D non-linear MagnetoHydroDynamic (MHD) simulations of pure Deuterium Shattered Pellet Injection in ITER are presented. It is shown that such a scheme could allow diluting the plasma by more than a factor 10 without immediately triggering large MHD activity, provided the background impurity density is low enough. This appears as a promising strategy to reduce the risk of hot tail Runaway Electron (RE) generation and to avoid RE beams altogether in ITER, motivating further studies in this direction. △ Less

Submitted 14 September, 2020; v1 submitted 29 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: Published in Nuclear Fusion

Journal ref: E. Nardon et al 2020 Nucl. Fusion 60 126040

Understanding the reduction of the edge safety factor during hot VDEs and fast edge cooling events

Authors: F. J. Artola, K. Lackner, G. T. A. Huijsmans, M. Hoelzl, E. Nardon, A. Loarte

Abstract: In the present work a simple analytical approach is presented in order to clarify the physics behind the edge current density behaviour of a hot plasma entering in contact with a resistive conductor. When a plasma enters in contact with a highly resistive wall, large current densities appear at the edge of the plasma. The model shows that this edge current originates from the plasma response, whic… ▽ More In the present work a simple analytical approach is presented in order to clarify the physics behind the edge current density behaviour of a hot plasma entering in contact with a resistive conductor. When a plasma enters in contact with a highly resistive wall, large current densities appear at the edge of the plasma. The model shows that this edge current originates from the plasma response, which attempts to conserve the poloidal magnetic flux ($Ψ$) when the outer current is being lost. The loss of outer current is caused by the high resistance of the outer current path compared to the plasma core resistance. The resistance of the outer path may be given by plasma contact with a very resistive structure or by a sudden decrease of the outer plasma temperature (e.g. due to a partial thermal quench or due to a cold front penetration caused by massive gas injection). For general plasma geometries and current density profiles the model shows that given a small change of minor radius ($δa$) the plasma current is conserved to first order ($δI_p = 0 + \mathcal{O}(δa^2)$). This conservation comes from the fact that total inductance remains constant ($δL = 0$) due to an exact compensation of the change of external inductance with the change of internal inductance ($δL_\text{ext}+δL_\text{int} = 0$). As the total current is conserved and the plasma volume is reduced, the edge safety factor drops according to $q_a \propto a^2/I_p$. Finally the consistency of the resulting analytical predictions is checked with the help of free-boundary MHD simulations. △ Less

Submitted 9 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Comments: 10 pages, 7 figures

Journal ref: Physics of Plasmas 27, 032501 (2020)

First predictive simulations for deuterium shattered pellet injection in ASDEX Upgrade

Authors: M. Hoelzl, D. Hu, E. Nardon, G. T. A. Huijsmans

Abstract: First simulations of deuterium shattered pellet injection (SPI) into an ASDEX Upgrade H-Mode plasma with the JOREK MHD code are presented. Resistivity is increased by one order of magnitude in most simulations to reduce computational costs and allow for extensive parameter scans. The effect of various physical parameters onto MHD activity and thermal quench (TQ) dynamics is studied and the influen… ▽ More First simulations of deuterium shattered pellet injection (SPI) into an ASDEX Upgrade H-Mode plasma with the JOREK MHD code are presented. Resistivity is increased by one order of magnitude in most simulations to reduce computational costs and allow for extensive parameter scans. The effect of various physical parameters onto MHD activity and thermal quench (TQ) dynamics is studied and the influence of MHD onto ablation is shown. TQs are obtained quickly after injection in most simulations with a typical duration of 100 microseconds, which slows down at lower resistivity. Although the n=1 magnetic perturbation dominates in the simulations, toroidal harmonics up to n=10 contribute to stochastization and stochastic transport in the plasma core. The post-TQ density profile remains hollow for a few hundred microseconds. However, when flux surfaces re-form around the magnetic axis, the density has become monotonic again suggesting a beneficial behaviour for runaway electron avoidance/mitigation. With $10^{21}$ atoms injected, the TQ is typically incomplete and triggered when the shards reach the q=2 rational surface. At a larger number of injected atoms, the TQ can set in even before the shards reach this surface. For low field side injection considered here, repeated formation of outward convection cells is observed in the ablation region reducing material assimilation. Responsible is a sudden rise of pressure in the high density cloud when the stochastic region expands further releasing heat from the hot core. After the TQ, strong sheared poloidal rotation is created by Maxwell stress, which contributes to re-formation of flux surfaces. △ Less

Submitted 29 December, 2019; v1 submitted 14 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Comments: Accepted for publication in Physics of Plasmas (this is the revised version after referee comments)

Journal ref: Phys. Plasmas 27, 022510 (2020)

Development and testing of an unstructured mesh method for whole plasma gyrokinetic simulations in realistic tokamak geometry

Authors: Z. X. Lu, Ph. Lauber, T. Hayward-Schneider, A. Bottino, M. Hoelzl

Abstract: In this work, we have formulated and implemented a mixed unstructured mesh-based finite element (FE)-Fourier decomposition scheme for gyrokinetic simulations in realistic tokamak geometry. An efficient particle positioning (particle-triangle map**) scheme for the charge deposition and field scattering using an intermediate grid as the search index for triangles has been implemented and a signifi… ▽ More In this work, we have formulated and implemented a mixed unstructured mesh-based finite element (FE)-Fourier decomposition scheme for gyrokinetic simulations in realistic tokamak geometry. An efficient particle positioning (particle-triangle map**) scheme for the charge deposition and field scattering using an intermediate grid as the search index for triangles has been implemented and a significant speed-up by a factor of $\sim30$ is observed as compared with the brute force scheme for a medium-size simulation. The TRIMEG (TRIangular MEsh based Gyrokinetic) code has been developed. As an application, the ion temperature gradient (ITG) mode is simulated using the simplified gyrokinetic Vlasov-Poisson model. Our simulation and that using the ORB5 code for the DIII-D Cyclone case show reasonable agreement. As an additional application, ITG simulations using an ASDEX Upgrade equilibrium have been performed with density and temperature gradient profiles similar to the Cyclone case. Capabilities of the TRIMEG code for simulations with realistic experimental equilibria in the plasma core and in the whole plasma volume with open field lines are demonstrated. △ Less

Submitted 14 July, 2020; v1 submitted 10 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: 11 pages, 8 figures

Journal ref: Physics of Plasmas 26, 122503 (2019)

Axisymmetric simulations of vertical displacement events in tokamaks: A benchmark of M3D-C$^1$, NIMROD and JOREK

Authors: I. Krebs, F. J. Artola, C. R. Sovinec, S. C. Jardin, K. J. Bunkers, M. Hoelzl, N. M. Ferraro

Abstract: A benchmark exercise for the modeling of vertical displacement events (VDEs) is presented and applied to the 3D nonlinear magneto-hydrodynamic codes M3D-C$^1$, JOREK and NIMROD. The simulations are based on a vertically unstable NSTX equilibrium enclosed by an axisymmetric resistive wall with rectangular cross section. A linear dependence of the linear VDE growth rates on the resistivity of the wa… ▽ More A benchmark exercise for the modeling of vertical displacement events (VDEs) is presented and applied to the 3D nonlinear magneto-hydrodynamic codes M3D-C$^1$, JOREK and NIMROD. The simulations are based on a vertically unstable NSTX equilibrium enclosed by an axisymmetric resistive wall with rectangular cross section. A linear dependence of the linear VDE growth rates on the resistivity of the wall is recovered for sufficiently large wall conductivity and small temperatures in the open field line region. The benchmark results show good agreement between the VDE growth rates obtained from linear NIMROD and M3D-C$^1$ simulations as well as from the linear phase of axisymmetric nonlinear JOREK, NIMROD and M3D-C$^1$ simulations. Axisymmetric nonlinear simulations of a full VDE performed with the three codes are compared and excellent agreement is found regarding plasma location and plasma currents as well as eddy and halo currents in the wall. △ Less

Submitted 19 August, 2019; v1 submitted 6 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: The following article will be submitted to Physics of Plasmas

Testing performance with and without Block Low Rank Compression in MUMPS and the new PaStiX 6.0 for JOREK nonlinear MHD simulations

Authors: Richard Nies, Matthias Hoelzl

Abstract: The interface to the MUMPS solver was updated in the JOREK MHD code to support Block Low Rank (BLR) compression and an interface to the new PaStiX solver version 6 has been implemented supporting BLR as well. First tests were carried out with JOREK, which solves a large sparse matrix system iteratively in each time step. For the preconditioning, a direct solver is applied in the code to sub-matric… ▽ More The interface to the MUMPS solver was updated in the JOREK MHD code to support Block Low Rank (BLR) compression and an interface to the new PaStiX solver version 6 has been implemented supporting BLR as well. First tests were carried out with JOREK, which solves a large sparse matrix system iteratively in each time step. For the preconditioning, a direct solver is applied in the code to sub-matrices, and at this point BLR was applied with the results being summarized in this report. For a simple case with a linearly growing mode, results with both solvers look promising with a considerable reduction of the memory consumption by several ten percent was obtained. A direct increase in performance was seen in particular configurations already. The choice of the BLR accuracy parameter $ε$ proves to be critical in this simple test and also in more realistic simulations, which were carried out only with MUMPS due to the limited time available. The more realistic test showed an increase in run time when using BLR, which was mitigated when using larger values of $ε$. However, the GMRes iterative solver does not reach convergence anymore when $ε$ is too large, since the preconditioner becomes too inaccurate in that case. It is thus critical to use an $ε$ as large as possible, while still reaching convergence. More tests regarding this optimum will be necessary in the future. BLR can also lead to an indirect speed-up in particular cases, when the simulation can be run on a smaller number of compute nodes due to the reduced memory consumption. △ Less

Submitted 31 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: 21 pages, 14 figures

MSC Class: 65F50

A three-dimensional reduced MHD model consistent with full MHD

Authors: Nikita Nikulsin, Matthias Hoelzl, Alessandro Zocco, Karl Lackner, Sibylle Günter

Abstract: Within the context of a viscoresistive magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) model with anisotropic heat transport and cross-field mass diffusion, we introduce novel three-term representations for the magnetic field (background vacuum field, field line bending and field compression) and velocity ($\vec E\times\vec B$ flow, field-aligned flow and fluid compression), which are amenable to three-dimensional trea… ▽ More Within the context of a viscoresistive magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) model with anisotropic heat transport and cross-field mass diffusion, we introduce novel three-term representations for the magnetic field (background vacuum field, field line bending and field compression) and velocity ($\vec E\times\vec B$ flow, field-aligned flow and fluid compression), which are amenable to three-dimensional treatment. Once the representations are inserted into the MHD equations, appropriate projection operators are applied to Faraday's law and the Navier-Stokes equation to obtain a system of scalar equations that is closed by the continuity and energy equations. If the background vacuum field is sufficiently strong and the $β$ is low, MHD waves are approximately separated by the three terms in the velocity representation, with each term containing a specific wave. Thus, by setting the appropriate term to zero, we eliminate fast magnetosonic waves, obtaining a reduced MHD model. We also show that the other two velocity terms do not compress the magnetic field, which allows us to set the field compression term to zero within the same reduced model. Drop** also the field-aligned flow, a further simplified model is obtained, leading to a fully consistent hierarchy of reduced and full MHD models for 3D plasma configurations. Finally, we discuss the conservation properties and derive the conditions under which the reduction approximation is valid. We also show that by using an ordering approach, reduced MHD equations similar to what we got from the ansatz approach can be obtained by means of a physics-based asymptotic expansion. △ Less

Submitted 14 October, 2019; v1 submitted 29 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: 18 pages. This article was published in Physics of Plasmas

Journal ref: Phys. Plasmas 26, 102109 (2019)

Simulating the nonlinear interaction of relativistic electrons and tokamak plasma instabilities: Implementation and validation of a fluid model

Authors: V. Bandaru, M. Hoelzl, F. J. Artola, G. Papp, G. T. A. Huijsmans

Abstract: For the simulation of disruptions in tokamak fusion plasmas, a fluid model describing the evolution of relativistic runaway electrons and their interaction with the background plasma is presented. The overall aim of the model is to self-consistently describe the nonlinear coupled evolution of runaway electrons (REs) and plasma instabilities during disruptions. In this model, the runaway electrons… ▽ More For the simulation of disruptions in tokamak fusion plasmas, a fluid model describing the evolution of relativistic runaway electrons and their interaction with the background plasma is presented. The overall aim of the model is to self-consistently describe the nonlinear coupled evolution of runaway electrons (REs) and plasma instabilities during disruptions. In this model, the runaway electrons are considered as a separate fluid species in which the initial seed is generated through the Dreicer source, which eventually grows by the avalanche mechanism (further relevant source mechanisms can easily be added). Advection of the runaway electrons is considered primarily along field lines, but also taking into account the ExB drift. The model is implemented in the nonlinear magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) code JOREK based on Bezier finite elements, with current coupling to the thermal plasma. Benchmarking of the code with the one-dimensional runaway electron code GO is done using an artificial thermal quench on a circular plasma. As a first demonstration, the code is applied to the problem of an axisymmetric cold vertical displacement event in an ITER plasma, revealing significantly different dynamics between cases computed with and without runaway electrons. Though it is not yet feasible to achieve fully realistic runaway electron velocities close to the speed of light in complete simulations of slowly evolving plasma instabilities, the code is demonstrated to be suitable to study various kinds of MHD-RE interactions in MHD-active and disruption relevant plasmas. △ Less

Submitted 28 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Comments: 9 figures

Journal ref: Physical Review E 99, 063317 (2019)

Numerical study of tearing mode seeding in tokamak X-point plasma

Authors: Dmytro Meshcheriakov, Matthias Hoelzl, Valentin Igochine, Sina Fietz, Francois Orain, Guido T. A. Huijsmans, Marc Maraschek, Mike Dunne, Rachael McDermott, Hartmut Zohm, Karl Lackner, Sibylle Guenter, ASDEX Upgrade Team, EUROfusion MST1 Team

Abstract: A detailed understanding of island seeding is crucial to avoid (N)TMs and their negative consequences like confinement degradation and disruptions. In the present work, we investigate the growth of 2/1 islands in response to magnetic perturbations. Although we use externally applied perturbations produced by resonant magnetic perturbation (RMP) coils for this study, results are directly transferab… ▽ More A detailed understanding of island seeding is crucial to avoid (N)TMs and their negative consequences like confinement degradation and disruptions. In the present work, we investigate the growth of 2/1 islands in response to magnetic perturbations. Although we use externally applied perturbations produced by resonant magnetic perturbation (RMP) coils for this study, results are directly transferable to island seeding by other MHD instabilities creating a resonant magnetic field component at the rational surface. Experimental results for 2/1 island penetration from ASDEX Upgrade are presented extending previous studies. Simulations are based on an ASDEX Upgrade L-mode discharge with low collisionality and active RMP coils. Our numerical studies are performed with the 3D, two fluid, non-linear MHD code JOREK. All three phases of mode seeding observed in the experiment are also seen in the simulations: first a weak response phase characterized by large perpendicular electron flow velocities followed by a fast growth of the magnetic island size accompanied by a reduction of the perpendicular electron velocity, and finally the saturation to a fully formed island state with perpendicular electron velocity close to zero. Thresholds for mode penetration are observed in the plasma rotation as well as in the RMP coil current. A hysteresis of the island size and electron perpendicular velocity is observed between the ram** up and down of the RMP amplitude consistent with an analytically predicted bifurcation. The transition from dominant kink/bending to tearing parity during the penetration is investigated. △ Less

Submitted 16 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Journal ref: Phys. Plasmas 26, 042504 (2019)

Non-linear modeling of the threshold between ELM mitigation and ELM suppression by Resonant Magnetic Perturbations in ASDEX Upgrade

Authors: François Orain, M. Hoelzl, F. Mink, M. Willensdorfer, M. Bécoulet, M. Dunne, S. Günter, G. T. A. Huijsmans, K. Lackner, S. Pamela, W. Suttrop, E. Viezzer

Abstract: The interaction between Edge Localized Modes (ELMs) and Resonant Magnetic Perturbations (RMPs) is modeled with the magnetohydrodynamic code JOREK using experimental parameters from ASDEX Upgrade discharges. The ELM mitigation or suppression is optimal when the amplification of both tearing and peeling-kink responses result in a better RMP penetration. The ELM mitigation or suppression is not only… ▽ More The interaction between Edge Localized Modes (ELMs) and Resonant Magnetic Perturbations (RMPs) is modeled with the magnetohydrodynamic code JOREK using experimental parameters from ASDEX Upgrade discharges. The ELM mitigation or suppression is optimal when the amplification of both tearing and peeling-kink responses result in a better RMP penetration. The ELM mitigation or suppression is not only due to the reduction of the pressure gradient, but predominantly arises from the toroidal coupling between the ELMs and the RMP-induced mode at the plasma edge, forcing the edge modes to saturate at a low level. The bifurcation from ELM mitigation to ELM suppression is observed when the RMP amplitude is increased. ELM mitigation is characterized by rotating modes at the edge, while the mode locking to RMPs is induced by the resonant braking of the electron perpendicular flow in the ELM suppression regime. △ Less

Submitted 3 June, 2019; v1 submitted 1 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Journal ref: Physics of Plasmas 26, 042503 (2019)

Simulation of the electromagnetic wall response during Vertical Displacement Events (VDE) in ITER tokamak

Authors: Cǎlin V. Atanasiu, Leonid E. Zakharov, Karl Lackner, Matthias Hoelzl

Abstract: The key basis for tokamak plasma disruption modeling is to understand how currents flow to the plasma facing surfaces during plasma disruption events. In ITER tokamak, the occurrence of a limited number of major disruptions will definitively damage the chamber with no possibility to restore the device. In the current exchange plasma-wall-plasma, according to the Helmholtz decomposition theorem, ou… ▽ More The key basis for tokamak plasma disruption modeling is to understand how currents flow to the plasma facing surfaces during plasma disruption events. In ITER tokamak, the occurrence of a limited number of major disruptions will definitively damage the chamber with no possibility to restore the device. In the current exchange plasma-wall-plasma, according to the Helmholtz decomposition theorem, our surface current density in the conducting shell - the unknown of our problem - being a vector field twice continuously differentiable in 3D, has been splited into two components: an irrotational (curl-free) vector field and a solenoidal (divergence-free) vector field. Develo** a weak formulation form and minimizing the correspondent energy functionals in a Finite Element approach, we have obtained the space and time distribution of the surface currents. We verified successfully our numerical simulation with an analytical solution with pure homogeneous Neumann B.C. and satisfying the necessary existence condition. By considering the iron core presence in JET tokamak, we have split the magnetization currents - the unknowns in some integral equations - into two components, the first producing a magnetic field in the iron region only and the second producing a magnetic field in the vacuum, obtaining thus a better evaluation of the influence of the iron core on the plasma equilibrium. To reduce the influence of the singularities appearing during the surface currents determination in multiply connected domains (L-shaped domains) we have used a conformal transformation method. △ Less

Submitted 24 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 9 pages, 7 figures, 7$^{th}$ Int'l Conference on Mathematical Modeling in Physical Sciences, Moscow, Russia

Performance analysis and optimization of the JOREK code for many-core CPUs

Authors: T. B. Fehér, M. Hölzl, G. Latu, G. T. A. Huijsmans

Abstract: This report investigates the performance of the JOREK code on the Intel Knights Landing and Skylake processor architectures. The OpenMP scaling of the matrix construction part of the code was analyzed and improved synchronization methods were implemented. A new switch was implemented to control the number of threads used for the linear equation solver independently from other parts of the code. Th… ▽ More This report investigates the performance of the JOREK code on the Intel Knights Landing and Skylake processor architectures. The OpenMP scaling of the matrix construction part of the code was analyzed and improved synchronization methods were implemented. A new switch was implemented to control the number of threads used for the linear equation solver independently from other parts of the code. The matrix construction subroutine was vectorized, and the data locality was also improved. These steps led to a factor of two speedup for the matrix construction. △ Less

Submitted 10 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Electron acceleration in a JET disruption simulation

Authors: Cristian Sommariva, Eric Nardon, Peter Beyer, Matthias Hoelzl, Guido Huijsman

Abstract: Runaways are suprathermal electrons having sufficiently high energy to be continuously accelerated up to tens of MeV by a driving electric field [1]. Highly energetic runaway electron (RE) beams capable of damaging the tokamak first wall can be observed after a plasma disruption [2]. Therefore, it is of primary importance to fully understand their generation mechanisms in order to design mitigatio… ▽ More Runaways are suprathermal electrons having sufficiently high energy to be continuously accelerated up to tens of MeV by a driving electric field [1]. Highly energetic runaway electron (RE) beams capable of damaging the tokamak first wall can be observed after a plasma disruption [2]. Therefore, it is of primary importance to fully understand their generation mechanisms in order to design mitigation systems able to guarantee safe tokamak operations. In a previous work, [3], a test particle tracker was introduced in the JOREK 3D non-linear MHD code and used for studying the electron confinement during a simulated JET-like disruption. It was found in [3] that relativistic electrons are not completely deconfined by the stochastic magnetic field taking place during the disruption thermal quench (TQ). This is due to the reformation of closed magnetic surfaces at the beginning of the current quench (CQ). This result was obtained neglecting the inductive electric field in order to avoid the unrealistic particle acceleration which otherwise would have happened due to the absence of collision effects. The present paper extends [3] analysing test electron dynamics in the same simulated JET-like disruption using the complete electric field. For doing so, a simplified collision model is introduced in the particle tracker guiding center equations. We show that electrons at thermal energies can become RE during or promptly after the TQ due to a combination of three phenomena: a first REs acceleration during the TQ due to the presence of a complex MHD-induced electric field, particle reconfinement caused by the fast reformation of closed magnetic surfaces after the TQ and a secondary acceleration induced by the CQ electric field. △ Less

Submitted 13 August, 2018; v1 submitted 15 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.

Journal ref: Nuclear Fusion, vol. 58, p. 106022, 2018

Magnetic flux pum** in 3D nonlinear magnetohydrodynamic simulations

Authors: I. Krebs, S. C. Jardin, S. Günter, K. Lackner, M. Hoelzl, E. Strumberger, N. Ferraro

Abstract: A self-regulating magnetic flux pum** mechanism in tokamaks that maintains the core safety factor at $q\approx 1$, thus preventing sawteeth, is analyzed in nonlinear 3D magnetohydrodynamic simulations using the M3D-C$^1$ code. In these simulations, the most important mechanism responsible for the flux pum** is that a saturated $(m=1,n=1)$ quasi-interchange instability generates an effective ne… ▽ More A self-regulating magnetic flux pum** mechanism in tokamaks that maintains the core safety factor at $q\approx 1$, thus preventing sawteeth, is analyzed in nonlinear 3D magnetohydrodynamic simulations using the M3D-C$^1$ code. In these simulations, the most important mechanism responsible for the flux pum** is that a saturated $(m=1,n=1)$ quasi-interchange instability generates an effective negative loop voltage in the plasma center via a dynamo effect. It is shown that sawtoothing is prevented in the simulations if $β$ is sufficiently high to provide the necessary drive for the $(m=1,n=1)$ instability that generates the dynamo loop voltage. The necessary amount of dynamo loop voltage is determined by the tendency of the current density profile to centrally peak which, in our simulations, is controlled by the peakedness of the applied heat source profile. △ Less

Submitted 20 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Comments: submitted to Physics of Plasmas (23 pages, 15 Figures)