Human-centered Benchmarking for Socially-compliant Robot Navigation
Authors:
Iaroslav Okunevich,
Vincent Hilaire,
Stephane Galland,
Olivier Lamotte,
Liubov Shilova,
Yassine Ruichek,
Zhi Yan
Abstract:
Social compatibility is one of the most important parameters for service robots. It characterizes the quality of interaction between a robot and a human. In this paper, a human-centered benchmarking framework is proposed for socially-compliant robot navigation. In an end-to-end manner, four open-source robot navigation methods are benchmarked, two of which are socially-compliant. All aspects of th…
▽ More
Social compatibility is one of the most important parameters for service robots. It characterizes the quality of interaction between a robot and a human. In this paper, a human-centered benchmarking framework is proposed for socially-compliant robot navigation. In an end-to-end manner, four open-source robot navigation methods are benchmarked, two of which are socially-compliant. All aspects of the benchmarking are clarified to ensure the reproducibility and replicability of the experiments. The social compatibility of robot navigation methods with the Robotic Social Attributes Scale (RoSAS) is measured. After that, the correspondence between RoSAS and the robot-centered metrics is validated. Based on experiments, the extra robot time ratio and the extra distance ratio are the most suitable to judge social compatibility.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2023; v1 submitted 27 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
An Ontology to Support Collective Intelligence in Decentralised Multi-Robot Systems
Authors:
Pragna Das,
Vincent Hilaire,
Lluis Ribas-Xirgo
Abstract:
In most multi-robot systems, conditions of the floor, battery and mechanical parts are important and impact cost-efficiency. The costs are generally interpreted through performance times. The relation between performance times andthese factors are not directly derivable, though, performance time has a direct correlation with discharge of batteries. Inroute planning, travel time of an edge is the p…
▽ More
In most multi-robot systems, conditions of the floor, battery and mechanical parts are important and impact cost-efficiency. The costs are generally interpreted through performance times. The relation between performance times andthese factors are not directly derivable, though, performance time has a direct correlation with discharge of batteries. Inroute planning, travel time of an edge is the performance time and may be required to be estimated for multiple times.These estimated travel times are different than heuristics costs as they depict the real states which are impossible toknow from heuristics. This facilitates path planning algorithms to choose the edges with least real travel times or coststo form the path. Nevertheless, a good estimation is dependent on historical data which are close in time. But, there aresituations when all the travel times for one or more edge(s) are not available for the entire duration of operation of theMRS to an individual robot. Then, it is imperative for that robot to gather the necessary travel times from others inthe system as a reference observation. The mechanism of information sharing between one robot to others in the systemhas been devised in a form of a common ontology-based knowledge. This ontology helps to fetch and share informationforming a collective knowledge base facilitating a comprehensive control and planning for the system. This greatly helpsthe MR to estimate travel times more accurately and precisely. Also, accurate estimation affects route planning to bemore precise with reduced cost. The total cost of paths generated through the travel times estimated through sharingis 40% less on average than that of paths generated through travel times without sharing.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
