-
Demystifying Statistical Matching Algorithms for Big Data
Authors:
Sanjeewani Weerasingha,
Michael J. Higgins
Abstract:
Statistical matching is an effective method for estimating causal effects in which treated units are paired with control units with ``similar'' values of confounding covariates prior to performing estimation. In this way, matching helps isolate the effect of treatment on response from effects due to the confounding covariates. While there are a large number of software packages to perform statisti…
▽ More
Statistical matching is an effective method for estimating causal effects in which treated units are paired with control units with ``similar'' values of confounding covariates prior to performing estimation. In this way, matching helps isolate the effect of treatment on response from effects due to the confounding covariates. While there are a large number of software packages to perform statistical matching, the algorithms and techniques used to solve statistical matching problems -- especially matching without replacement -- are not widely understood. In this paper, we describe in detail commonly-used algorithms and techniques for solving statistical matching problems. We focus in particular on the efficiency of these algorithms as the number of observations grow large. We advocate for the further development of statistical matching methods that impose and exploit ``sparsity'' -- by greatly restricting the available matches for a given treated unit -- as this may be critical to ensure scalability of matching methods as data sizes grow large.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Estimation of Causal Effects Under K-Nearest Neighbors Interference
Authors:
Samirah Alzubaidi,
Michael J. Higgins
Abstract:
Considerable recent work has focused on methods for analyzing experiments which exhibit treatment interference -- that is, when the treatment status of one unit may affect the response of another unit. Such settings are common in experiments on social networks. We consider a model of treatment interference -- the K-nearest neighbors interference model (KNNIM) -- for which the response of one unit…
▽ More
Considerable recent work has focused on methods for analyzing experiments which exhibit treatment interference -- that is, when the treatment status of one unit may affect the response of another unit. Such settings are common in experiments on social networks. We consider a model of treatment interference -- the K-nearest neighbors interference model (KNNIM) -- for which the response of one unit depends not only on the treatment status given to that unit, but also the treatment status of its $K$ ``closest'' neighbors. We derive causal estimands under KNNIM in a way that allows us to identify how each of the $K$-nearest neighbors contributes to the indirect effect of treatment. We propose unbiased estimators for these estimands and derive conservative variance estimates for these unbiased estimators. We then consider extensions of these estimators under an assumption of no weak interaction between direct and indirect effects. We perform a simulation study to determine the efficacy of these estimators under different treatment interference scenarios. We apply our methodology to an experiment designed to assess the impact of a conflict-reducing program in middle schools in New Jersey, and we give evidence that the effect of treatment propagates primarily through a unit's closest connection.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Detecting Treatment Interference under the K-Nearest-Neighbors Interference Model
Authors:
Samirah H. Alzubaidi,
Michael J. Higgins
Abstract:
We propose a model of treatment interference where the response of a unit depends only on its treatment status and the statuses of units within its K-neighborhood. Current methods for detecting interference include carefully designed randomized experiments and conditional randomization tests on a set of focal units. We give guidance on how to choose focal units under this model of interference. We…
▽ More
We propose a model of treatment interference where the response of a unit depends only on its treatment status and the statuses of units within its K-neighborhood. Current methods for detecting interference include carefully designed randomized experiments and conditional randomization tests on a set of focal units. We give guidance on how to choose focal units under this model of interference. We then conduct a simulation study to evaluate the efficacy of existing methods for detecting network interference. We show that this choice of focal units leads to powerful tests of treatment interference which outperform current experimental methods.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2023; v1 submitted 30 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
The Benefits of Probability-Proportional-to-Size Sampling in Cluster-Randomized Experiments
Authors:
Yeng Xiong,
Michael J. Higgins
Abstract:
In a cluster-randomized experiment, treatment is assigned to clusters of individual units of interest--households, classrooms, villages, etc.--instead of the units themselves. The number of clusters sampled and the number of units sampled within each cluster is typically restricted by a budget constraint. Previous analysis of cluster randomized experiments under the Neyman-Rubin potential outcomes…
▽ More
In a cluster-randomized experiment, treatment is assigned to clusters of individual units of interest--households, classrooms, villages, etc.--instead of the units themselves. The number of clusters sampled and the number of units sampled within each cluster is typically restricted by a budget constraint. Previous analysis of cluster randomized experiments under the Neyman-Rubin potential outcomes model of response have assumed a simple random sample of clusters. Estimators of the population average treatment effect (PATE) under this assumption are often either biased or not invariant to location shifts of potential outcomes. We demonstrate that, by sampling clusters with probability proportional to the number of units within a cluster, the Horvitz-Thompson estimator (HT) is invariant to location shifts and unbiasedly estimates PATE. We derive standard errors of HT and discuss how to estimate these standard errors. We also show that results hold for stratified random samples when samples are drawn proportionally to cluster size within each stratum. We demonstrate the efficacy of this sampling scheme using a simulation based on data from an experiment measuring the efficacy of the National Solidarity Programme in Afghanistan.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
A new method for quantifying network cyclic structure to improve community detection
Authors:
Behnaz Moradi-Jamei,
Heman Shakeri,
Pietro Poggi-Corradini,
Michael J. Higgins
Abstract:
A distinguishing property of communities in networks is that cycles are more prevalent within communities than across communities. Thus, the detection of these communities may be aided through the incorporation of measures of the local "richness" of the cyclic structure. In this paper, we introduce renewal non-backtracking random walks (RNBRW) as a way of quantifying this structure. RNBRW gives a…
▽ More
A distinguishing property of communities in networks is that cycles are more prevalent within communities than across communities. Thus, the detection of these communities may be aided through the incorporation of measures of the local "richness" of the cyclic structure. In this paper, we introduce renewal non-backtracking random walks (RNBRW) as a way of quantifying this structure. RNBRW gives a weight to each edge equal to the probability that a non-backtracking random walk completes a cycle with that edge. Hence, edges with larger weights may be thought of as more important to the formation of cycles. Of note, since separate random walks can be performed in parallel, RNBRW weights can be estimated very quickly, even for large graphs. We give simulation results showing that pre-weighting edges through RNBRW may substantially improve the performance of common community detection algorithms. Our results suggest that RNBRW is especially efficient for the challenging case of detecting communities in sparse graphs.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2019; v1 submitted 2 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
From one environment to many: The problem of replicability of statistical inferences
Authors:
James J. Higgins,
Michael J. Higgins,
**guang Lin
Abstract:
Among plausible causes for replicability failure, one that has not received sufficient attention is the environment in which the research is conducted. Consisting of the population, equipment, personnel, and various conditions such as location, time, and weather, the research environment can affect treatments and outcomes, and changes in the research environment that occur when an experiment is re…
▽ More
Among plausible causes for replicability failure, one that has not received sufficient attention is the environment in which the research is conducted. Consisting of the population, equipment, personnel, and various conditions such as location, time, and weather, the research environment can affect treatments and outcomes, and changes in the research environment that occur when an experiment is redone can affect replicability. We examine the extent to which such changes contribute to replicability failure. Our framework is that of an initial experiment that generates the data and a follow-up experiment that is done the same way except for a change in the research environment. We assume that the initial experiment satisfies the assumptions of the two-sample t-statistic and that the follow-up experiment is described by a mixed model which includes environmental parameters. We derive expressions for the effect that the research environment has on power, sample size selection, p-values, and confidence levels. We measure the size of the environmental effect with the environmental effect ratio EER which is the ratio of the standard deviations of environment by treatment interaction and error. By varying EER, it is possible to determine conditions that favor replicability and those that do not.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2020; v1 submitted 22 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Generalized full matching and extrapolation of the results from a large-scale voter mobilization experiment
Authors:
Fredrik Sävje,
Michael J. Higgins,
Jasjeet S. Sekhon
Abstract:
Matching is an important tool in causal inference. The method provides a conceptually straightforward way to make groups of units comparable on observed characteristics. The use of the method is, however, limited to situations where the study design is fairly simple and the sample is moderately sized. We illustrate the issue by revisiting a large-scale voter mobilization experiment that took place…
▽ More
Matching is an important tool in causal inference. The method provides a conceptually straightforward way to make groups of units comparable on observed characteristics. The use of the method is, however, limited to situations where the study design is fairly simple and the sample is moderately sized. We illustrate the issue by revisiting a large-scale voter mobilization experiment that took place in Michigan for the 2006 election. We ask what the causal effects would have been if the treatments in the experiment were scaled up to the full population. Matching could help us answer this question, but no existing matching method can accommodate the six treatment arms and the 6,762,701 observations involved in the study. To offer a solution this and similar empirical problems, we introduce a generalization of the full matching method and an associated algorithm. The method can be used with any number of treatment conditions, and it is shown to produce near-optimal matchings. The worst case maximum within-group dissimilarity is no worse than four times the optimal solution, and simulation results indicate that its performance is considerably closer to the optimal solution on average. Despite its performance, the algorithm is fast and uses little memory. It terminates, on average, in linearithmic time using linear space. This enables investigators to construct well-performing matchings within minutes even in complex studies with samples of several million units.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2019; v1 submitted 10 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
A virtual instrument to standardise the calibration of atomic force microscope cantilevers
Authors:
John E. Sader,
Riccardo Borgani,
Christopher T. Gibson,
David B. Haviland,
Michael J. Higgins,
Jason I. Kilpatrick,
Jianing Lu,
Paul Mulvaney,
Cameron J. Shearer,
Ashley D. Slattery,
Per-Anders Thorén,
Jim Tran,
Heyou Zhang,
Hongrui Zhang,
Tian Zheng
Abstract:
Atomic force microscope (AFM) users often calibrate the spring constants of cantilevers using functionality built into individual instruments. This is performed without reference to a global standard, which hinders robust comparison of force measurements reported by different laboratories. In this article, we describe a virtual instrument (an internet-based initiative) whereby users from all labor…
▽ More
Atomic force microscope (AFM) users often calibrate the spring constants of cantilevers using functionality built into individual instruments. This is performed without reference to a global standard, which hinders robust comparison of force measurements reported by different laboratories. In this article, we describe a virtual instrument (an internet-based initiative) whereby users from all laboratories can instantly and quantitatively compare their calibration measurements to those of others - standardising AFM force measurements - and simultaneously enabling non-invasive calibration of AFM cantilevers of any geometry. This global calibration initiative requires no additional instrumentation or data processing on the part of the user. It utilises a single website where users upload currently available data. A proof-of-principle demonstration of this initiative is presented using measured data from five independent laboratories across three countries, which also allows for an assessment of current calibration.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Blocking estimators and inference under the Neyman-Rubin model
Authors:
Michael J. Higgins,
Fredrik Sävje,
Jasjeet S. Sekhon
Abstract:
We derive the variances of estimators for sample average treatment effects under the Neyman-Rubin potential outcomes model for arbitrary blocking assignments and an arbitrary number of treatments.
We derive the variances of estimators for sample average treatment effects under the Neyman-Rubin potential outcomes model for arbitrary blocking assignments and an arbitrary number of treatments.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Suppression of the Melting Line in a Weakly Disordered Flux-line System
Authors:
Gautam I. Menon,
G. Ravikumar,
M. J. Higgins,
S. Bhattacharya
Abstract:
An analytic formula describing the suppression of the equilibrium melting line by quenched point pinning disorder is compared to data from ac susceptibility and magnetization measurements in the mixed phase of the layered dichalcogenide low T_c superconductor 2H-NbSe_2. This material exhibits a sharp peak effect in the critical current close to the upper critical field H_c2(T). Arguing that the di…
▽ More
An analytic formula describing the suppression of the equilibrium melting line by quenched point pinning disorder is compared to data from ac susceptibility and magnetization measurements in the mixed phase of the layered dichalcogenide low T_c superconductor 2H-NbSe_2. This material exhibits a sharp peak effect in the critical current close to the upper critical field H_c2(T). Arguing that the disorder-suppressed melting line in this system is to be identified with the locus of peak positions of the critical current as magnetic field and temperature are varied, we demonstrate that this formula provides a remarkably accurate fit to the experimental data over three orders of magnitude in magnetic field.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
Imaging ferroelectric hysteresis and domain wall pinning
Authors:
S. Bhattacharya,
M. J. Higgins
Abstract:
Simultaneous imaging of the piezoresponse phase, amplitude and bare surface topography of displacive ferroelectric thin films by scanning probe microscopy directly shows the nature of domain wall pinning and its relation to morphological disorder. Strong and stable pinning of walls occurs at grain boundaries while weak and unstable pinning occurs within the grains. The results show that polariza…
▽ More
Simultaneous imaging of the piezoresponse phase, amplitude and bare surface topography of displacive ferroelectric thin films by scanning probe microscopy directly shows the nature of domain wall pinning and its relation to morphological disorder. Strong and stable pinning of walls occurs at grain boundaries while weak and unstable pinning occurs within the grains. The results show that polarization reversal consists of both nucleation of domains and spreading of domain walls, the latter being the dominant process in multi-grain regions. A characteristic single-grain switching in faceted grains is observed as the motion of a single domain wall parallel to one of the facets.
△ Less
Submitted 31 December, 2009;
originally announced January 2010.
-
Structure of the flux lines lattice in NbSe2: Equilibrium state and influence of the magnetic history
Authors:
A. Pautrat,
M. Aburas,
Ch. Simon,
P. Mathieu,
A. Brulet,
C. D. Dewhurst,
S. Bhattacharya,
M. J. Higgins
Abstract:
We have performed small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) of the flux line lattice (FLL) in a Fe doped NbSe_2 sample which presents a large peak effect in the critical current. The scattered intensity and the width of the Bragg peaks of the equilibrium FLL indicate an ordered structure in the peak effect zone. The history dependence in the FLL structure has been studied using field cooled and zero…
▽ More
We have performed small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) of the flux line lattice (FLL) in a Fe doped NbSe_2 sample which presents a large peak effect in the critical current. The scattered intensity and the width of the Bragg peaks of the equilibrium FLL indicate an ordered structure in the peak effect zone. The history dependence in the FLL structure has been studied using field cooled and zero field cooled procedures, and each state shows the same intensity of Bragg scattering and good orientational order. These results strongly suggest that the peak effect is unrelated to a bulk disordering transition, and confirm the role of a heterogeneous distribution of screening current.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2009;
originally announced April 2009.
-
Manifestation of modulation in spatial order of flux line lattice in weakly pinned superconductors : a vibrating sample magnetometer study
Authors:
A. D. Thakur,
D. Pal,
M. J. Higgins,
S. Ramakrishnan,
A. K. Grover
Abstract:
We have investigated the healing of transient disordered vortex states injected into a superconducting sample during the field ram** process in isothermal M-H measurements as a prescription to comprehend the modulation in the state of order of the underlying equilibrium vortex state in weakly pinned single crystals of $2H$-NbSe$_2$ (zero field transition temperature, $T_c(0) \sim 6 K$) and Ca…
▽ More
We have investigated the healing of transient disordered vortex states injected into a superconducting sample during the field ram** process in isothermal M-H measurements as a prescription to comprehend the modulation in the state of order of the underlying equilibrium vortex state in weakly pinned single crystals of $2H$-NbSe$_2$ (zero field transition temperature, $T_c(0) \sim 6 K$) and Ca$_3$Rh$_4$Sn$_{13}$ ($T_c(0) \sim 8.2 K$), which display order-disorder transition(s). Our results reaffirm the notion that spatial order in the flux line lattice proceeds to the amorphous state in two distinct steps as evidenced by the presence of second magnetization peak (SMP) anomaly and the peak effect (PE) phenomenon. Disordering commencing at the onset field of SMP has a window to heal between its peak field ($H_{smp}^p$) and the onset field ($H_p^{on}$) of the PE. A comparison of the scan rate dependence of magnetization hysteresis widths in two different crystals of $2H$-NbSe$_2$, one of which displays only the PE phenomenon and the other one that displays both SMP and PE anomalies, show that while enhancment in quenched random pinning invokes the occurence of SMP anomaly, it slows down the temporal decay of currents across the PE region.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2006; v1 submitted 9 May, 2006;
originally announced May 2006.
-
Why pinning by surface irregularities can explain the peak effect in transport properties and neutron diffraction results in NbSe2 and Bi-2212 crystals?
Authors:
Charles Simon,
Alain Pautrat,
Christophe Goupil,
Joseph Scola,
Patrice Mathieu,
Annie Brulet,
Antoine Ruyter,
M. J. Higgins,
Shobo Battacharya
Abstract:
The existence of a peak effect in transport properties (a maximum of the critical current as function of magnetic field) is a well-known but still intriguing feature of type II superconductors such as NbSe2 and Bi-2212. Using a model of pinning by surface irregularities in anisotropic superconductors, we have developed a calculation of the critical current which allows estimating quantitatively…
▽ More
The existence of a peak effect in transport properties (a maximum of the critical current as function of magnetic field) is a well-known but still intriguing feature of type II superconductors such as NbSe2 and Bi-2212. Using a model of pinning by surface irregularities in anisotropic superconductors, we have developed a calculation of the critical current which allows estimating quantitatively the critical current in both the high critical current phase and in the low critical current phase. The only adjustable parameter of this model is the angle of the vortices at the surface. The agreement between the measurements and the model is really very impressive. In this framework, the anomalous dynamical properties close to the peak effect is due to co-existence of two different vortex states with different critical currents. Recent neutron diffraction data in NbSe2 crystals in presence of transport current support this point of view.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2006;
originally announced February 2006.
-
Evolution in the split-peak structure across the Peak Effect region in single crystals of $2H$-NbSe$_2$
Authors:
A. D. Thakur,
T. V. Chandrasekhar Rao,
S. Uji,
T. Terashima,
M. J. Higgins,
S. Ramakrishnan,
A. K. Grover
Abstract:
We have explored the presence of a two-peak feature spanning the peak effect (PE) region in the ac susceptibility data and the magnetization hysteresis measurements over a wide field-temperature regime in few weakly pinned single crystals of $2H$-NbSe$_2$, which display reentrant characteristic in the PE curve near $T_c$(0). We believe that the two-peak feature evolves into distinct second magne…
▽ More
We have explored the presence of a two-peak feature spanning the peak effect (PE) region in the ac susceptibility data and the magnetization hysteresis measurements over a wide field-temperature regime in few weakly pinned single crystals of $2H$-NbSe$_2$, which display reentrant characteristic in the PE curve near $T_c$(0). We believe that the two-peak feature evolves into distinct second magnetization peak anomaly well separated from the PE with gradual enhancement in the quenched random pinning.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2006; v1 submitted 16 February, 2006;
originally announced February 2006.
-
Effect of pinning and driving force on the metastability effects in weakly pinned superconductors and the determination of spinodal line pertaining to order-disorder transition
Authors:
A. D. Thakur,
S. S. Banerjee,
M. J. Higgins,
S. Ramakrishnan,
A. K. Grover
Abstract:
We explore the effect of varying drive on metastability features exhibited by the vortex matter in single crystals of 2H-NbSe$_2$ and CeRu$_2$ with varying degree of random pinning. An optimal balance between the pinning and driving force is needed to view the metastability effects in typically weakly pinned specimen of low temperature superconductors. As one uses samples with larger pinning in…
▽ More
We explore the effect of varying drive on metastability features exhibited by the vortex matter in single crystals of 2H-NbSe$_2$ and CeRu$_2$ with varying degree of random pinning. An optimal balance between the pinning and driving force is needed to view the metastability effects in typically weakly pinned specimen of low temperature superconductors. As one uses samples with larger pinning in order to differentiate the response of different metastable vortex states, one encounters a new phenomena, viz., the second magnetization peak (SMP) anomaly prior to the PE. Interplay between the path dependence in the critical current density and the non-linearity in the electromagnetic response determine the metastability effects seen in first and the third harmonic response of the ac susceptibility across the temperature regions of the SMP and the PE. The limiting temperature above which metastability effects cease can be conveniently located in the third harmonic data, and the observed behavior can be rationalized within the Beans Critical State model. A vortex phase diagram showing the different vortex phases for a typically weakly pinned specimen has been constructed via the ac susceptibility data in a crystal of 2H-NbSe$_2$ which shows the SMP and the PE anomalies. The phase space of coexisting weaker and stronger pinned regions has been identified. It can be bifurcated into two parts, where the order and disorder dominate, respectively. The former part continuously connects to the reentrant disordered vortex phase pertaining to the small bundle pinning regime, where the vortices are far apart, interaction effects are weak and the polycrystalline form of flux line lattice prevails.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2005;
originally announced October 2005.
-
Exploring metastability via the third harmonic measurements in single crystals of $2H$-$NbSe_2$ showing anomalous Peak effect
Authors:
A. D. Thakur,
S. S. Banerjee,
M. J. Higgins,
S. Ramakrishnan,
A. K. Grover
Abstract:
We explore the metastability effects across the order-disorder transition pertaining to the peak effect phenomenonon in critical current density ($J_c$) via the first and the third harmonic ac susceptibility measurements in the weakly pinned single crystals of $2H$-$NbSe_2$. An analysis of our data suggests that an imprint of the limiting (spinodal) temperature above which $J_c$ is path independ…
▽ More
We explore the metastability effects across the order-disorder transition pertaining to the peak effect phenomenonon in critical current density ($J_c$) via the first and the third harmonic ac susceptibility measurements in the weakly pinned single crystals of $2H$-$NbSe_2$. An analysis of our data suggests that an imprint of the limiting (spinodal) temperature above which $J_c$ is path independent can be conveniently located in the third harmonic data ($χ_{3ω}^{\prime}$).
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2005;
originally announced September 2005.
-
Percolation Transition in the Heterogeneous Vortex State in NbSe2
Authors:
O. Dogru,
E. Y. Andrei,
M. J. Higgins,
S. Bhattacharya
Abstract:
A percolation transition in the vortex state of a superconducting 2H-NbSe2 crystal is observed in the regime where vortices form a heterogeneous phase consisting of ordered and disordered domains. The transition is signaled by a sharp increase in critical current that occurs when the volume fraction of disordered domains, obtained from pulsed measurements of the current-voltage characteristics,…
▽ More
A percolation transition in the vortex state of a superconducting 2H-NbSe2 crystal is observed in the regime where vortices form a heterogeneous phase consisting of ordered and disordered domains. The transition is signaled by a sharp increase in critical current that occurs when the volume fraction of disordered domains, obtained from pulsed measurements of the current-voltage characteristics, reaches the value Pc= 0.26. Measurements on different vortex states show that while the temperature of the transition depends on history and measurement speed, the value of Pc and the critical exponent characterizing the approach to it, r =1.97 $\pm$ 0.66, are universal.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2005;
originally announced March 2005.
-
Metastable states of a flux line lattice studied by transport and Small Angle Neutron Scattering
Authors:
A. Pautrat,
J. Scola,
Ch. Simon,
P. Mathieu,
C. Goupil,
A. Brulet,
M. J. Higgins,
S. Bhattacharya
Abstract:
Flux Lines Lattice (FLL) states have been studied using transport measurements and Small Angle Neutron Scattering in low T$_c$ materials. In Pb-In, the bulk dislocations in the FLL do not influence the transport properties. In Fe doped NbSe$_{2}$, transport properties can differ after a Field Cooling (FC) or a Zero Field Cooling (ZFC) procedure, as previously reported. The ZFC FLL is found order…
▽ More
Flux Lines Lattice (FLL) states have been studied using transport measurements and Small Angle Neutron Scattering in low T$_c$ materials. In Pb-In, the bulk dislocations in the FLL do not influence the transport properties. In Fe doped NbSe$_{2}$, transport properties can differ after a Field Cooling (FC) or a Zero Field Cooling (ZFC) procedure, as previously reported. The ZFC FLL is found ordered with narrow Bragg Peaks and is linked to a linear V(I) curve and to a superficial critical current. The FC FLL pattern exhibits two Bragg peaks and the corresponding V(I) curve shows a S-shape. This can be explained by the coexistence of two ordered FLL slightly tilted from the applied field direction by different superficial currents. These currents are wiped out when the transport current is increased.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2004;
originally announced November 2004.
-
V-I characteristics in the vicinity of order-disorder transition in vortex matter
Authors:
Y. Paltiel,
Y. Myasoedov,
E. Zeldov,
G. Jung,
M. L. Rappaport,
D. E. Feldman,
M. J. Higgins,
S. Bhattacharya
Abstract:
The shape of the V-I characteristics leading to a peak in the differential resistance r_d=dV/dI in the vicinity of the order-disorder transition in NbSe2 is investigated. r_d is large when measured by dc current. However, for a small Iac on a dc bias r_d decreases rapidly with frequency, even at a few Hz, and displays a large out-of-phase signal. In contrast, the ac response increases with frequ…
▽ More
The shape of the V-I characteristics leading to a peak in the differential resistance r_d=dV/dI in the vicinity of the order-disorder transition in NbSe2 is investigated. r_d is large when measured by dc current. However, for a small Iac on a dc bias r_d decreases rapidly with frequency, even at a few Hz, and displays a large out-of-phase signal. In contrast, the ac response increases with frequency in the absence of dc bias. These surprisingly opposite phenomena and the peak in r_d are shown to result from a dynamic coexistence of two vortex matter phases rather than from the commonly assumed plastic depinning.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2002; v1 submitted 1 July, 2002;
originally announced July 2002.
-
Dynamic Creation and Annihilation of Metastable Vortex Phase as a Source of Excess Noise
Authors:
Y. Paltiel,
G. Jung,
Y. Myasoedov,
M. L. Rappaport,
E. Zeldov,
M. J. Higgins,
S. Bhattacharya
Abstract:
The large increase in voltage noise, commonly observed in the vicinity of the peak-effect in superconductors, is ascribed to a novel noise mechanism. A strongly pinned metastable disordered vortex phase, which is randomly generated at the edges and annealed into ordered phase in the bulk, causes large fluctuations in the integrated critical current of the sample. The excess noise due to this dyn…
▽ More
The large increase in voltage noise, commonly observed in the vicinity of the peak-effect in superconductors, is ascribed to a novel noise mechanism. A strongly pinned metastable disordered vortex phase, which is randomly generated at the edges and annealed into ordered phase in the bulk, causes large fluctuations in the integrated critical current of the sample. The excess noise due to this dynamic admixture of two distinct phases is found to display pronounced reentrant behavior. In the Corbino geometry the injection of the metastable phase is prevented and, accordingly, the excess noise disappears
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2002; v1 submitted 14 March, 2002;
originally announced March 2002.
-
Comparison of Phase Boundaries between Kagome and Honeycomb Superconducting Wire Networks
Authors:
Yi Xiao,
David A. Huse,
Paul M. Chaikin,
Mark J. Higgins,
Shobo Bhattacharya,
David Spencer
Abstract:
We measure resistively the mean-field superconducting-normal phase boundaries of both kagome and honeycomb wire networks immersed in a transverse magnetic field. In addition to their agreement with theory about the overall shapes of phase diagrams, they show striking one-to-one correspondence between the cusps in the honeycomb and kagome phase boundaries. This correspondence is due to their geom…
▽ More
We measure resistively the mean-field superconducting-normal phase boundaries of both kagome and honeycomb wire networks immersed in a transverse magnetic field. In addition to their agreement with theory about the overall shapes of phase diagrams, they show striking one-to-one correspondence between the cusps in the honeycomb and kagome phase boundaries. This correspondence is due to their geometric arrangements and agrees with Lin and Nori's recent calculation. We also find that for the frustrated honeycomb network at f=1/2, the current patterns in the superconducting phase differ between the low-temperature London regime and the higher-temperature Ginzburg-Landau regime near T_c.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2001;
originally announced December 2001.
-
Instabilities and disorder-driven first-order transition of the vortex lattice
Authors:
Y. Paltiel,
E. Zeldov,
Y. Myasoedov,
M. L. Rappaport,
G. Jung,
S. Bhattacharya,
M. J. Higgins,
Z. L. Xiao,
E. Y. Andrei,
P. L. Gammel,
D. J. Bishop
Abstract:
Transport studies in a Corbino disk geometry suggest that the Bragg glass phase undergoes a first-order transition into a disordered solid. This transition shows a sharp reentrant behavior at low fields. In contrast, in the conventional strip configuration, the phase transition is obscured by the injection of the disordered vortices through the sample edges, which results in the commonly observe…
▽ More
Transport studies in a Corbino disk geometry suggest that the Bragg glass phase undergoes a first-order transition into a disordered solid. This transition shows a sharp reentrant behavior at low fields. In contrast, in the conventional strip configuration, the phase transition is obscured by the injection of the disordered vortices through the sample edges, which results in the commonly observed vortex instabilities and smearing of the peak effect in NbSe2 crystals. These features are found to be absent in the Corbino geometry, in which the circulating vortices do not cross the sample edges.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2000;
originally announced August 2000.
-
Disordered Type-II Superconductors: A Universal Phase Diagram for Low-T$_c$ Systems
Authors:
S. S. Banerjee,
A. K. Grover,
M. J. Higgins,
G. I. Menon,
P. K. Mishra,
D. Pal,
S. Ramakrishnan,
T. V. C. Rao,
G. Ravikumar,
V. C. Sahni,
S. Sarkar,
C. V. Tomy
Abstract:
A universal phase diagram for weakly pinned low-T$_c$ type-II superconductors is revisited and extended with new proposals. The low-temperature ``Bragg glass'' phase is argued to transform first into a disordered, glassy phase upon heating. This glassy phase, a continuation of the high-field equilibrium vortex glass phase, then melts at higher temperatures into a liquid. This proposal provides a…
▽ More
A universal phase diagram for weakly pinned low-T$_c$ type-II superconductors is revisited and extended with new proposals. The low-temperature ``Bragg glass'' phase is argued to transform first into a disordered, glassy phase upon heating. This glassy phase, a continuation of the high-field equilibrium vortex glass phase, then melts at higher temperatures into a liquid. This proposal provides an explanation for the anomalies observed in the peak effect regime of 2H-NbSe$_2$ and several other low-T$_c$ materials which is independent of the microscopic mechanisms of superconductivity in these systems.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2000;
originally announced July 2000.
-
Stable and Metastable vortex states and the first order transition across the peak effect region in weakly pinned 2H-NbSe_2
Authors:
G. Ravikumar,
V. C. Sahni,
A. K. Grover,
S. Ramakrishnan,
P. L. Gammel,
D. J. Bishop,
E. Bücher,
M. J. Higgins,
S. Bhattacharya
Abstract:
The peak effect in weakly pinned superconductors is accompanied by metastable vortex states. Each metastable vortex configuration is characterized by a different critical current density J_c, which mainly depends on the past thermomagnetic history of the superconductor. A recent model [G. Ravikumar, et al, Phys. Rev. B 61, R6479 (2000)] proposed to explain the history dependent J_c postulates a…
▽ More
The peak effect in weakly pinned superconductors is accompanied by metastable vortex states. Each metastable vortex configuration is characterized by a different critical current density J_c, which mainly depends on the past thermomagnetic history of the superconductor. A recent model [G. Ravikumar, et al, Phys. Rev. B 61, R6479 (2000)] proposed to explain the history dependent J_c postulates a stable state of vortex lattice with a critical current density J_c^{st}, determined uniquely by the field and temperature. In this paper, we present evidence for the existence of the stable state of the vortex lattice in the peak effect region of 2H-NbSe_2. It is shown that this stable state can be reached from any metastable vortex state by cycling the applied field by a small amplitude. The minor magnetization loops obtained by repeated field cycling allow us to determine the pinning and "equilibrium" properties of the stable state of the vortex lattice at a given field and temperature unambiguously. The data imply the occurence of a first order phase transition from an ordered phase to a disordered vortex phase across the peak effect.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2000;
originally announced July 2000.
-
Dynamic instabilities and memory effects in vortex matter
Authors:
Y. Paltiel,
E. Zeldov,
Y. N. Myasoedov,
H. Shtrikman,
S. Bhattacharya,
M. J. Higgins,
Z. L. Xiao,
E. Y. Andrei,
P. L. Gammel,
D. J. Bishop
Abstract:
Recent studies have shown a number of surprising vortex dynamics phenomena both in low and high temperature superconductors, which include: low frequency noise, slow voltage oscillations, history dependent dynamic response, memory of the direction, amplitude, duration, and frequency of the previously applied current, suppression of a large ac vortex response by a very small dc bias, and a strong…
▽ More
Recent studies have shown a number of surprising vortex dynamics phenomena both in low and high temperature superconductors, which include: low frequency noise, slow voltage oscillations, history dependent dynamic response, memory of the direction, amplitude, duration, and frequency of the previously applied current, suppression of a large ac vortex response by a very small dc bias, and a strong frequency dependence. Taken together, these phenomena are incompatible with the current understanding of bulk vortex dynamics. We propose a generic mechanism to account for these observations in terms of the competition between the injection of a disordered vortex phase through the surface barriers at the sample edges, and the annealing of this metastable disorder by the transport current. The model is confirmed by investigating the current distribution across NbSe2 single crystals using arrays of Hall sensors. For an ac current only narrow regions near the edges are in the pinned disordered phase resulting in a large response. In the presence of a dc bias a wide region of the sample is filled by the disordered phase preventing vortex motion. The resulting spatial variation of the disorder across the sample acts as an active memory of the previously applied current sequence.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 1999;
originally announced December 1999.
-
Flow Induced Organization and Memory of a Vortex Lattice
Authors:
Z. L. Xiao,
E. Y. Andrei,
M. J. Higgins
Abstract:
We report on experiments probing the evolution of a vortex state in response to a driving current in 2H-NbSe$_2$ crystals. By following the vortex motion with fast transport measurements we find that the current enables the system to reorganize and access new configurations. During this process the system exhibits a long-term memory: if the current is turned off the vortices freeze in place reme…
▽ More
We report on experiments probing the evolution of a vortex state in response to a driving current in 2H-NbSe$_2$ crystals. By following the vortex motion with fast transport measurements we find that the current enables the system to reorganize and access new configurations. During this process the system exhibits a long-term memory: if the current is turned off the vortices freeze in place remembering their prior motion. When the current is restored the motion resumes where it stopped. The experiments provide evidence for a dynamically driven structural change of the vortex lattice and a corresponding dynamic phase diagram that contains a previously unknown regime where the critical current can be either $increased$ or $decreased$ by applying an appropriate driving current.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 1999; v1 submitted 9 April, 1999;
originally announced April 1999.
-
Plastic Motion of a Flux-line Lattice Driven by Alternating Current
Authors:
W. Henderson,
M. J. Higgins,
E. Y. Andrei
Abstract:
We have measured the response of the flux-line lattice in the low T$_c$ superconductor, 2H-NbSe$_2$, to finite frequency drives. In a well-defined range of fields, temperatures, and driving amplitudes the system exhibits a variety of novel non-linear phenomena. Most strikingly, the flux-lines can move easily in response to currents that are significantly lower than the DC critical current if the…
▽ More
We have measured the response of the flux-line lattice in the low T$_c$ superconductor, 2H-NbSe$_2$, to finite frequency drives. In a well-defined range of fields, temperatures, and driving amplitudes the system exhibits a variety of novel non-linear phenomena. Most strikingly, the flux-lines can move easily in response to currents that are significantly lower than the DC critical current if the direction of the current is reversed periodically while the amplitude, I, is kept fixed, but they do not respond to a current that periodically switches between zero and I, while the direction is kept fixed. Pronounced memory effects associated with these phenomena indicate the presence of dynamically generated structural changes in the flux lattice.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 1998;
originally announced May 1998.
-
AC Dynamics and Metastability of a Flux-Line Lattice
Authors:
W. Henderson,
E. Y. Andrei,
M. J. Higgins,
S. Bhattacharya
Abstract:
We have measured the complex surface impedance of 2H-NbSe_2 in the mixed state over a wide range of magnetic field(0-2T) and frequency(10-3000MHz). A crossover between pinned and viscous dynamics of flux-lines is observed at a pinning frequency, $ω_p$. The measured $ω_p$ is compared to that predicted by a single-particle "washboard potential" model for the pinning interaction. When the flux latt…
▽ More
We have measured the complex surface impedance of 2H-NbSe_2 in the mixed state over a wide range of magnetic field(0-2T) and frequency(10-3000MHz). A crossover between pinned and viscous dynamics of flux-lines is observed at a pinning frequency, $ω_p$. The measured $ω_p$ is compared to that predicted by a single-particle "washboard potential" model for the pinning interaction. When the flux lattice is prepared in an ordered state by zero-field cooling or by driving it with a large current, $ω_p$ is in good agreement with the predicted value. However, when it is prepared in a metastable disordered state by field cooling, $ω_p$ is nearly two orders of magnitude higher than expected indicating a complete break-down of the single-particle model.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 1997;
originally announced March 1997.
-
Metastability and Glassy Behavior of a Driven Flux-Line Lattice
Authors:
W. Henderson,
E. Y. Andrei,
M. J. Higgins,
S. Bhattacharya
Abstract:
Strong metastability and history dependence are observed in DC and pulsed transport studies of flux-line lattices in 2H-$NbSe_{2}$, leading to the identification of two distinct states of the lattice with different spatial ordering. The metastability is most pronounced upon crossing a transition line marked by a large jump in the critical current (the peak effect). Current induced annealing of t…
▽ More
Strong metastability and history dependence are observed in DC and pulsed transport studies of flux-line lattices in 2H-$NbSe_{2}$, leading to the identification of two distinct states of the lattice with different spatial ordering. The metastability is most pronounced upon crossing a transition line marked by a large jump in the critical current (the peak effect). Current induced annealing of the metastable state towards the stable state is observed with a strongly current dependent annealing time, which diverges as a threshold current is approached from above.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 1996; v1 submitted 11 June, 1996;
originally announced June 1996.
-
Nature of Phase Transitions of Superconducting Wire Networks in a Magnetic Field
Authors:
X. S. Ling,
M. J. Higgins,
Chao Tang,
P. M. Chaikin,
S. Bhattacharya,
H. J. Lezec,
J. S. Tsai,
J. Fujita,
H. Numata,
Y. Nakamura,
Y. Ochiai
Abstract:
We study $I$-$V$ characteristics of periodic square Nb wire networks as a function of temperature in a transverse magnetic field, with a focus on three fillings 2/5, 1/2, and 0.618 that represent very different levels of incommensurability. For all three fillings, a scaling behavior of $I$-$V$ characteristics is found, suggesting a finite temperature continuous superconducting phase transition.…
▽ More
We study $I$-$V$ characteristics of periodic square Nb wire networks as a function of temperature in a transverse magnetic field, with a focus on three fillings 2/5, 1/2, and 0.618 that represent very different levels of incommensurability. For all three fillings, a scaling behavior of $I$-$V$ characteristics is found, suggesting a finite temperature continuous superconducting phase transition. The low-temperature $I$-$V$ characteristics are found to have an exponential form, indicative of the domain-wall excitations.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 1995;
originally announced December 1995.
