Showing 1–15 of 15 results for author: Heydarnoori, A

Predicting the Understandability of Computational Notebooks through Code Metrics Analysis

Authors: Mojtaba Mostafavi Ghahfarokhi, Alireza Asadi, Arash Asgari, Bardia Mohammadi, Masih Beigi Rizi, Abbas Heydarnoori

Abstract: Computational notebooks have become the primary coding environment for data scientists. However, research on their code quality is still emerging, and the code shared is often of poor quality. Given the importance of maintenance and reusability, understanding the metrics that affect notebook code comprehensibility is crucial. Code understandability, a qualitative variable, is closely tied to user… ▽ More Computational notebooks have become the primary coding environment for data scientists. However, research on their code quality is still emerging, and the code shared is often of poor quality. Given the importance of maintenance and reusability, understanding the metrics that affect notebook code comprehensibility is crucial. Code understandability, a qualitative variable, is closely tied to user opinions. Traditional approaches to measuring it either use limited questionnaires to review a few code pieces or rely on metadata such as likes and votes in software repositories. Our approach enhances the measurement of Jupyter notebook understandability by leveraging user comments related to code understandability. As a case study, we used 542,051 Kaggle Jupyter notebooks from our previous research, named DistilKaggle. We employed a fine-tuned DistilBERT transformer to identify user comments associated with code understandability. We established a criterion called User Opinion Code Understandability (UOCU), which considers the number of relevant comments, upvotes on those comments, total notebook views, and total notebook upvotes. UOCU proved to be more effective than previous methods. Furthermore, we trained machine learning models to predict notebook code understandability based solely on their metrics. We collected 34 metrics for 132,723 final notebooks as features in our dataset, using UOCU as the label. Our predictive model, using the Random Forest classifier, achieved 89% accuracy in predicting the understandability levels of computational notebooks. △ Less

Submitted 16 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

GIRT-Model: Automated Generation of Issue Report Templates

Authors: Nafiseh Nikeghbal, Amir Hossein Kargaran, Abbas Heydarnoori

Abstract: Platforms such as GitHub and GitLab introduce Issue Report Templates (IRTs) to enable more effective issue management and better alignment with developer expectations. However, these templates are not widely adopted in most repositories, and there is currently no tool available to aid developers in generating them. In this work, we introduce GIRT-Model, an assistant language model that automatical… ▽ More Platforms such as GitHub and GitLab introduce Issue Report Templates (IRTs) to enable more effective issue management and better alignment with developer expectations. However, these templates are not widely adopted in most repositories, and there is currently no tool available to aid developers in generating them. In this work, we introduce GIRT-Model, an assistant language model that automatically generates IRTs based on the developer's instructions regarding the structure and necessary fields. We create GIRT-Instruct, a dataset comprising pairs of instructions and IRTs, with the IRTs sourced from GitHub repositories. We use GIRT-Instruct to instruction-tune a T5-base model to create the GIRT-Model. In our experiments, GIRT-Model outperforms general language models (T5 and Flan-T5 with different parameter sizes) in IRT generation by achieving significantly higher scores in ROUGE, BLEU, METEOR, and human evaluation. Additionally, we analyze the effectiveness of GIRT-Model in a user study in which participants wrote short IRTs with GIRT-Model. Our results show that the participants find GIRT-Model useful in the automated generation of templates. We hope that through the use of GIRT-Model, we can encourage more developers to adopt IRTs in their repositories. We publicly release our code, dataset, and model at https://github.com/ISE-Research/girt-model. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2024; v1 submitted 4 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: Accepted to be published at the 21st IEEE/ACM International Conference on Mining Software Repositories (MSR 2024)

Can GitHub Issues Help in pp Review Classifications?

Authors: Yasaman Abedini, Abbas Heydarnoori

Abstract: App reviews reflect various user requirements that can aid in planning maintenance tasks. Recently, proposed approaches for automatically classifying user reviews rely on machine learning algorithms. A previous study demonstrated that models trained on existing labeled datasets exhibit poor performance when predicting new ones. Therefore, a comprehensive labeled dataset is essential to train a mor… ▽ More App reviews reflect various user requirements that can aid in planning maintenance tasks. Recently, proposed approaches for automatically classifying user reviews rely on machine learning algorithms. A previous study demonstrated that models trained on existing labeled datasets exhibit poor performance when predicting new ones. Therefore, a comprehensive labeled dataset is essential to train a more precise model. In this paper, we propose a novel approach that assists in augmenting labeled datasets by utilizing information extracted from an additional source, GitHub issues, that contains valuable information about user requirements. First, we identify issues concerning review intentions (bug reports, feature requests, and others) by examining the issue labels. Then, we analyze issue bodies and define 19 language patterns for extracting targeted information. Finally, we augment the manually labeled review dataset with a subset of processed issues through the \emph{Within-App}, \emph{Within-Context}, and \emph{Between-App Analysis} methods. We conducted several experiments to evaluate the proposed approach. Our results demonstrate that using labeled issues for data augmentation can improve the F1-score to 6.3 in bug reports and 7.2 in feature requests. Furthermore, we identify an effective range of 0.3 to 0.7 for the auxiliary volume, which provides better performance improvements. △ Less

Submitted 3 July, 2024; v1 submitted 27 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

GIRT-Data: Sampling GitHub Issue Report Templates

Authors: Nafiseh Nikeghbal, Amir Hossein Kargaran, Abbas Heydarnoori, Hinrich Schütze

Abstract: GitHub's issue reports provide developers with valuable information that is essential to the evolution of a software development project. Contributors can use these reports to perform software engineering tasks like submitting bugs, requesting features, and collaborating on ideas. In the initial versions of issue reports, there was no standard way of using them. As a result, the quality of issue r… ▽ More GitHub's issue reports provide developers with valuable information that is essential to the evolution of a software development project. Contributors can use these reports to perform software engineering tasks like submitting bugs, requesting features, and collaborating on ideas. In the initial versions of issue reports, there was no standard way of using them. As a result, the quality of issue reports varied widely. To improve the quality of issue reports, GitHub introduced issue report templates (IRTs), which pre-fill issue descriptions when a new issue is opened. An IRT usually contains greeting contributors, describing project guidelines, and collecting relevant information. However, despite of effectiveness of this feature which was introduced in 2016, only nearly 5% of GitHub repositories (with more than 10 stars) utilize it. There are currently few articles on IRTs, and the available ones only consider a small number of repositories. In this work, we introduce GIRT-Data, the first and largest dataset of IRTs in both YAML and Markdown format. This dataset and its corresponding open-source crawler tool are intended to support research in this area and to encourage more developers to use IRTs in their repositories. The stable version of the dataset contains 1,084,300 repositories and 50,032 of them support IRTs. The stable version of the dataset and crawler is available here: https://github.com/kargaranamir/girt-data △ Less

Submitted 21 March, 2023; v1 submitted 16 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: Accepted to be published at the 20th IEEE/ACM International Conference on Mining Software Repositories (MSR 2023)

MenuCraft: Interactive Menu System Design with Large Language Models

Authors: Amir Hossein Kargaran, Nafiseh Nikeghbal, Abbas Heydarnoori, Hinrich Schütze

Abstract: Menu system design is a challenging task involving many design options and various human factors. For example, one crucial factor that designers need to consider is the semantic and systematic relation of menu commands. However, capturing these relations can be challenging due to limited available resources. With the advancement of neural language models, large language models can utilize their va… ▽ More Menu system design is a challenging task involving many design options and various human factors. For example, one crucial factor that designers need to consider is the semantic and systematic relation of menu commands. However, capturing these relations can be challenging due to limited available resources. With the advancement of neural language models, large language models can utilize their vast pre-existing knowledge in designing and refining menu systems. In this paper, we propose MenuCraft, an AI-assisted designer for menu design that enables collaboration between the designer and a dialogue system to design menus. MenuCraft offers an interactive language-based menu design tool that simplifies the menu design process and enables easy customization of design options. MenuCraft supports a variety of interactions through dialog that allows performing zero/few-shot learning. △ Less

Submitted 23 July, 2023; v1 submitted 8 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Semantically-enhanced Topic Recommendation System for Software Projects

Authors: Maliheh Izadi, Mahtab Nejati, Abbas Heydarnoori

Abstract: Software-related platforms have enabled their users to collaboratively label software entities with topics. Tagging software repositories with relevant topics can be exploited for facilitating various downstream tasks. For instance, a correct and complete set of topics assigned to a repository can increase its visibility. Consequently, this improves the outcome of tasks such as browsing, searching… ▽ More Software-related platforms have enabled their users to collaboratively label software entities with topics. Tagging software repositories with relevant topics can be exploited for facilitating various downstream tasks. For instance, a correct and complete set of topics assigned to a repository can increase its visibility. Consequently, this improves the outcome of tasks such as browsing, searching, navigation, and organization of repositories. Unfortunately, assigned topics are usually highly noisy, and some repositories do not have well-assigned topics. Thus, there have been efforts on recommending topics for software projects, however, the semantic relationships among these topics have not been exploited so far. We propose two recommender models for tagging software projects that incorporate the semantic relationship among topics. Our approach has two main phases; (1) we first take a collaborative approach to curate a dataset of quality topics specifically for the domain of software engineering and development. We also enrich this data with the semantic relationships among these topics and encapsulate them in a knowledge graph we call SED-KGraph. Then, (2) we build two recommender systems; The first one operates only based on the list of original topics assigned to a repository and the relationships specified in our knowledge graph. The second predictive model, however, assumes there are no topics available for a repository, hence it proceeds to predict the relevant topics based on both textual information of a software project and SED-KGraph. We built SED-KGraph in a crowd-sourced project with 170 contributors from both academia and industry. The experiment results indicate that our solutions outperform baselines that neglect the semantic relationships among topics by at least 25% and 23% in terms of ASR and MAP metrics. △ Less

Submitted 7 December, 2022; v1 submitted 31 May, 2022; originally announced June 2022.

Comments: To appear in the Empirical Software Engineering Journal

Automated Recovery of Issue-Commit Links Leveraging Both Textual and Non-textual Data

Authors: Pooya Rostami Mazrae, Maliheh Izadi, Abbas Heydarnoori

Abstract: An issue documents discussions around required changes in issue-tracking systems, while a commit contains the change itself in the version control systems. Recovering links between issues and commits can facilitate many software evolution tasks such as bug localization, and software documentation. A previous study on over half a million issues from GitHub reports only about 42.2% of issues are man… ▽ More An issue documents discussions around required changes in issue-tracking systems, while a commit contains the change itself in the version control systems. Recovering links between issues and commits can facilitate many software evolution tasks such as bug localization, and software documentation. A previous study on over half a million issues from GitHub reports only about 42.2% of issues are manually linked by developers to their pertinent commits. Automating the linking of commit-issue pairs can contribute to the improvement of the said tasks. By far, current state-of-the-art approaches for automated commit-issue linking suffer from low precision, leading to unreliable results, sometimes to the point that imposes human supervision on the predicted links. The low performance gets even more severe when there is a lack of textual information in either commits or issues. Current approaches are also proven computationally expensive. We propose Hybrid-Linker to overcome such limitations by exploiting two information channels; (1) a non-textual-based component that operates on non-textual, automatically recorded information of the commit-issue pairs to predict a link, and (2) a textual-based one which does the same using textual information of the commit-issue pairs. Then, combining the results from the two classifiers, Hybrid-Linker makes the final prediction. Thus, every time one component falls short in predicting a link, the other component fills the gap and improves the results. We evaluate Hybrid-Linker against competing approaches, namely FRLink and DeepLink on a dataset of 12 projects. Hybrid-Linker achieves 90.1%, 87.8%, and 88.9% based on recall, precision, and F-measure, respectively. It also outperforms FRLink and DeepLink by 31.3%, and 41.3%, regarding the F-measure. Moreover, Hybrid-Linker exhibits extensive improvements in terms of performance as well. △ Less

Submitted 5 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: To appear in the Proceedings of the 37th IEEE Conference on Software Maintenance and Evolution (ICSME)

Predicting the Objective and Priority of Issue Reports in Software Repositories

Authors: Maliheh Izadi, Kiana Akbari, Abbas Heydarnoori

Abstract: Developers collaboratively discuss, implement, use, and share software entities hosted on software repositories. Proper documentation plays an important role in successful software management and maintenance. Users exploit Issue Tracking Systems, a facility of software repositories, to keep track of issue reports, to manage the workload and processes, and finally, to document the highlight of thei… ▽ More Developers collaboratively discuss, implement, use, and share software entities hosted on software repositories. Proper documentation plays an important role in successful software management and maintenance. Users exploit Issue Tracking Systems, a facility of software repositories, to keep track of issue reports, to manage the workload and processes, and finally, to document the highlight of their team's effort. An issue report is a rich source of collaboratively curated software knowledge, and can contain a reported problem, a request for new features, or merely a question about the software product. As the number of these issues increases, it becomes harder to manage them manually. GitHub provides labels for tagging issues, as a means of issue management. However, about half of the issues in GitHub's top 1000 repositories do not have any labels. We aim at automating the process of managing issue reports for software teams. We propose a two-stage approach to predict both the objective behind opening an issue and its priority level using feature engineering methods and state-of-the-art text classifiers. To the best of our knowledge, we are the first to fine-tune a Transformer for issue classification. We train and evaluate our models in both project-based and cross-project settings. The latter approach provides a generic prediction model applicable for any unseen software project or projects with little historical data. Our proposed approach can successfully predict the objective and priority level of issue reports with 82% and 75% accuracy, respectively. Moreover, we conducted human labeling and evaluation on unlabeled issues from six unseen GitHub projects to assess the performance of the cross-project model on new data. The model achieves 90% accuracy. We obtain 85% average Percent Agreement and 71% Randolph's free-marginal Kappa translating to substantial agreement among labelers. △ Less

Submitted 28 September, 2021; v1 submitted 20 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Bias-Resistant Social News Aggregator Based on Blockchain

Authors: Amir Ziashahabi, Mohammad Ali Maddah-Ali, Abbas Heydarnoori

Abstract: In today's world, social networks have become one of the primary sources for creation and propagation of news. Social news aggregators are one of the actors in this area in which users post news items and use positive or negative votes to indicate their preference toward a news item. News items will be ordered and displayed according to their aggregated votes. This approach suffers from several pr… ▽ More In today's world, social networks have become one of the primary sources for creation and propagation of news. Social news aggregators are one of the actors in this area in which users post news items and use positive or negative votes to indicate their preference toward a news item. News items will be ordered and displayed according to their aggregated votes. This approach suffers from several problems raging from being prone to the dominance of the majority to difficulty in discerning between correct and fake news, and lack of incentive for honest behaviors. In this paper, we propose a graph-based news aggregator in which instead of voting on the news items, users submit their votes on the relations between pairs of news items. More precisely, if a user believes two news items support each other, he will submit a positive vote on the link between the two items, and if he believes that two news items undermine each other, he will submit a negative vote on the corresponding link. This approach has mainly two desirable features: (1) mitigating the effect of personal preferences on voting, (2) connection of new items to endorsing and disputing evidence. This approach helps the newsreaders to understand different aspects of a news item better. We also introduce an incentive layer that uses blockchain as a distributed transparent manager to encourages users to behave honestly and abstain from adversary behaviors. The incentive layer takes into account that users can have different viewpoints toward news, enabling users from a wide range of viewpoints to contribute to the network and benefit from its rewards. In addition, we introduce a protocol that enables us to prove fraud in computations of the incentive layer model on the blockchain. Ultimately, we will analyze the fraud proof protocol and examine our incentive layer on a wide range of synthesized datasets. △ Less

Submitted 20 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

Comments: 23 page, 8 figures, Abstract abridged due to arXiv limits

Topic Recommendation for Software Repositories using Multi-label Classification Algorithms

Authors: Maliheh Izadi, Abbas Heydarnoori, Georgios Gousios

Abstract: Many platforms exploit collaborative tagging to provide their users with faster and more accurate results while searching or navigating. Tags can communicate different concepts such as the main features, technologies, functionality, and the goal of a software repository. Recently, GitHub has enabled users to annotate repositories with topic tags. It has also provided a set of featured topics, and… ▽ More Many platforms exploit collaborative tagging to provide their users with faster and more accurate results while searching or navigating. Tags can communicate different concepts such as the main features, technologies, functionality, and the goal of a software repository. Recently, GitHub has enabled users to annotate repositories with topic tags. It has also provided a set of featured topics, and their possible aliases carefully curated with the help of the community. This creates the opportunity to use this initial seed of topics to automatically annotate all remaining repositories, by training models that recommend high-quality topic tags to developers. In this work, we study the application of multi-label classification techniques to predict software repositories' topics. First, we map the large space of user-defined topics to those featured by GitHub. The core idea is to derive more information from projects' available documentation. Our data contains about $152$K GitHub repositories and $228$ featured topics. Then, we apply supervised models on repositories' textual information such as descriptions, README files, wiki pages, and file names. We assess the performance of our approach both quantitatively and qualitatively. Our proposed model achieves Recall@5 and LRAP scores of $0.890$ and $0.805$, respectively. Moreover, based on users' assessment, our approach is highly capable of recommending a correct and complete set of topics. Finally, we use our models to develop an online tool named \texttt{Repository Catalogue}, that automatically predicts topics for GitHub repositories and is publicly available. △ Less

Submitted 13 June, 2021; v1 submitted 18 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

Improving Quality of a Post's Set of Answers in Stack Overflow

Authors: Mohammadrezar Tavakoli, Maliheh Izadi, Abbas Heydarnoori

Abstract: Community Question Answering platforms such as Stack Overflow help a wide range of users solve their challenges online. As the popularity of these communities has grown over the years, both the number of members and posts have escalated. Also, due to the diverse backgrounds, skills, expertise, and viewpoints of users, each question may obtain more than one answers. Therefore, the focus has changed… ▽ More Community Question Answering platforms such as Stack Overflow help a wide range of users solve their challenges online. As the popularity of these communities has grown over the years, both the number of members and posts have escalated. Also, due to the diverse backgrounds, skills, expertise, and viewpoints of users, each question may obtain more than one answers. Therefore, the focus has changed toward producing posts that have a set of answers more valuable for the community as a whole, not just one accepted-answer aimed at satisfying only the question-asker. Same as every universal community, a large number of low-quality posts on Stack Overflow require improvement. We call these posts deficient and define them as posts with questions that either have no answer yet or can be improved by other ones. In this paper, we propose an approach to automate the identification process of such posts and boost their set of answers, utilizing the help of related experts. With the help of 60 participants, we trained a classification model to identify deficient posts by investigating the relationship between characteristics of 3075 questions posted on Stack Overflow and their need for better answers set. Then, we developed an Eclipse plugin named SOPI and integrated the prediction model in the plugin to link these deficient posts to related developers and help them improve the answer set. We evaluated both the functionality of our plugin and the impact of answers submitted to Stack Overflow with the help of 10 and 15 expert industrial developers, respectively. Our results indicate that decision trees, specifically J48, predicts a deficient question better than the other methods with 0.945 precision and 0.903 recall. We conclude that not only our plugin helps programmers contribute more easily to Stack Overflow, but also it improves the quality of answers. △ Less

Submitted 30 May, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: Accepted at Euromicro DSD/SEAA 2020

An Analysis of Python's Topics, Trends, and Technologies Through Mining Stack Overflow Discussions

Authors: Hamed Tahmooresi, Abbas Heydarnoori, Alireza Aghamohammadi

Abstract: Python is a popular, widely used, and general-purpose programming language. In spite of its ever-growing community, researchers have not performed much analysis on Python's topics, trends, and technologies which provides insights for developers about Python community trends and main issues. In this article, we examine the main topics related to this language being discussed by developers on one of… ▽ More Python is a popular, widely used, and general-purpose programming language. In spite of its ever-growing community, researchers have not performed much analysis on Python's topics, trends, and technologies which provides insights for developers about Python community trends and main issues. In this article, we examine the main topics related to this language being discussed by developers on one of the most popular Q\&A websites, Stack Overflow, as well as temporal trends through mining 2461876 posts. To be more useful for the software engineers, we study what Python provides as the alternative to popular technologies offered by common programming languages like Java. Our results indicate that discussions about Python standard features, web programming, and scientific programming. Programming in areas such as mathematics, data science, statistics, machine learning, natural language processing (NLP), and so forth. are the most popular areas in the Python community. At the same time, areas related to scientific programming are steadily receiving more attention from the Python developers. △ Less

Submitted 13 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Generating Summaries for Methods of Event-Driven Programs: an Android Case Study

Authors: Alireza Aghamohammadi, Maliheh Izadi, Abbas Heydarnoori

Abstract: The lack of proper documentation makes program comprehension a cumbersome process for developers. Source code summarization is one of the existing solutions to this problem. Lots of approaches have been proposed to summarize source code in recent years. A prevalent weakness of these solutions is that they do not pay much attention to interactions among elements of a software. An element is simply… ▽ More The lack of proper documentation makes program comprehension a cumbersome process for developers. Source code summarization is one of the existing solutions to this problem. Lots of approaches have been proposed to summarize source code in recent years. A prevalent weakness of these solutions is that they do not pay much attention to interactions among elements of a software. An element is simply a callable code snippet such as a method or even a clickable button. As a result, these approaches cannot be applied to event-driven programs, such as Android applications, because they have specific features such as numerous interactions between their elements. To tackle this problem, we propose a novel approach based on deep neural networks and dynamic call graphs to generate summaries for methods of event-driven programs. First, we collect a set of comment/code pairs from Github and train a deep neural network on the set. Afterward, by exploiting a dynamic call graph, the Pagerank algorithm, and the pre-trained deep neural network, we generate summaries. An empirical evaluation with 14 real-world Android applications and 42 participants indicates 32.3% BLEU4 which is a definite improvement compared to the existing state-of-the-art techniques. We also assessed the informativeness and naturalness of our generated summaries from developers' perspectives and showed they are sufficiently understandable and informative. △ Less

Submitted 1 August, 2020; v1 submitted 11 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Generating Code Summaries Using the Power of the Crowd

Authors: Sahar Badihi, Abbas Heydarnoori

Abstract: One of the first steps to perform most of the software maintenance activities, such as updating features or fixing bugs, is to have a relatively good understanding of the program's source code which is often written by other developers. A code summary is a description about a program's entities (e.g., its methods) which helps developers have a better comprehension of the code in a shorter period o… ▽ More One of the first steps to perform most of the software maintenance activities, such as updating features or fixing bugs, is to have a relatively good understanding of the program's source code which is often written by other developers. A code summary is a description about a program's entities (e.g., its methods) which helps developers have a better comprehension of the code in a shorter period of time. However, generating code summaries can be a challenging task. To mitigate this problem, in this article, we introduce CrowdSummarizer, a code summarization platform that benefits from the concepts of crowdsourcing, gamification, and natural language processing to automatically generate a high level summary for the methods of a Java program. We have implemented CrowdSummarizer as an Eclipse plugin together with a web-based code summarization game that can be played by the crowd. The results of two empirical studies that evaluate the applicability of the approach and the quality of generated summaries indicate that CrowdSummarizer is effective in generating quality results. △ Less

Submitted 12 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: 28 pages, 11 figures, 9 tables

Migrating to Cloud-Native Architectures Using Microservices: An Experience Report

Authors: Armin Balalaie, Abbas Heydarnoori, Pooyan Jamshidi

Abstract: Migration to the cloud has been a popular topic in industry and academia in recent years. Despite many benefits that the cloud presents, such as high availability and scalability, most of the on-premise application architectures are not ready to fully exploit the benefits of this environment, and adapting them to this environment is a non-trivial task. Microservices have appeared recently as novel… ▽ More Migration to the cloud has been a popular topic in industry and academia in recent years. Despite many benefits that the cloud presents, such as high availability and scalability, most of the on-premise application architectures are not ready to fully exploit the benefits of this environment, and adapting them to this environment is a non-trivial task. Microservices have appeared recently as novel architectural styles that are native to the cloud. These cloud-native architectures can facilitate migrating on-premise architectures to fully benefit from the cloud environments because non-functional attributes, like scalability, are inherent in this style. The existing approaches on cloud migration does not mostly consider cloud-native architectures as their first-class citizens. As a result, the final product may not meet its primary drivers for migration. In this paper, we intend to report our experience and lessons learned in an ongoing project on migrating a monolithic on-premise software architecture to microservices. We concluded that microservices is not a one-fit-all solution as it introduces new complexities to the system, and many factors, such as distribution complexities, should be considered before adopting this style. However, if adopted in a context that needs high flexibility in terms of scalability and availability, it can deliver its promised benefits. △ Less

Submitted 29 July, 2015; originally announced July 2015.