-
Comparing Foundation Models using Data Kernels
Authors:
Brandon Duderstadt,
Hayden S. Helm,
Carey E. Priebe
Abstract:
Recent advances in self-supervised learning and neural network scaling have enabled the creation of large models, known as foundation models, which can be easily adapted to a wide range of downstream tasks. The current paradigm for comparing foundation models involves evaluating them with aggregate metrics on various benchmark datasets. This method of model comparison is heavily dependent on the c…
▽ More
Recent advances in self-supervised learning and neural network scaling have enabled the creation of large models, known as foundation models, which can be easily adapted to a wide range of downstream tasks. The current paradigm for comparing foundation models involves evaluating them with aggregate metrics on various benchmark datasets. This method of model comparison is heavily dependent on the chosen evaluation metric, which makes it unsuitable for situations where the ideal metric is either not obvious or unavailable. In this work, we present a methodology for directly comparing the embedding space geometry of foundation models, which facilitates model comparison without the need for an explicit evaluation metric. Our methodology is grounded in random graph theory and enables valid hypothesis testing of embedding similarity on a per-datum basis. Further, we demonstrate how our methodology can be extended to facilitate population level model comparison. In particular, we show how our framework can induce a manifold of models equipped with a distance function that correlates strongly with several downstream metrics. We remark on the utility of this population level model comparison as a first step towards a taxonomic science of foundation models.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2024; v1 submitted 8 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Approximately optimal domain adaptation with Fisher's Linear Discriminant
Authors:
Hayden S. Helm,
Ashwin De Silva,
Joshua T. Vogelstein,
Carey E. Priebe,
Weiwei Yang
Abstract:
We propose a class of models based on Fisher's Linear Discriminant (FLD) in the context of domain adaptation. The class is the convex combination of two hypotheses: i) an average hypothesis representing previously seen source tasks and ii) a hypothesis trained on a new target task. For a particular generative setting we derive the optimal convex combination of the two models under 0-1 loss, propos…
▽ More
We propose a class of models based on Fisher's Linear Discriminant (FLD) in the context of domain adaptation. The class is the convex combination of two hypotheses: i) an average hypothesis representing previously seen source tasks and ii) a hypothesis trained on a new target task. For a particular generative setting we derive the optimal convex combination of the two models under 0-1 loss, propose a computable approximation, and study the effect of various parameter settings on the relative risks between the optimal hypothesis, hypothesis i), and hypothesis ii). We demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed optimal classifier in the context of EEG- and ECG-based classification settings and argue that the optimal classifier can be computed without access to direct information from any of the individual source tasks. We conclude by discussing further applications, limitations, and possible future directions.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2024; v1 submitted 27 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Deep Learning with Label Noise: A Hierarchical Approach
Authors:
Li Chen,
Ningyuan Huang,
Cong Mu,
Hayden S. Helm,
Kate Lytvynets,
Weiwei Yang,
Carey E. Priebe
Abstract:
Deep neural networks are susceptible to label noise. Existing methods to improve robustness, such as meta-learning and regularization, usually require significant change to the network architecture or careful tuning of the optimization procedure. In this work, we propose a simple hierarchical approach that incorporates a label hierarchy when training the deep learning models. Our approach requires…
▽ More
Deep neural networks are susceptible to label noise. Existing methods to improve robustness, such as meta-learning and regularization, usually require significant change to the network architecture or careful tuning of the optimization procedure. In this work, we propose a simple hierarchical approach that incorporates a label hierarchy when training the deep learning models. Our approach requires no change of the network architecture or the optimization procedure. We investigate our hierarchical network through a wide range of simulated and real datasets and various label noise types. Our hierarchical approach improves upon regular deep neural networks in learning with label noise. Combining our hierarchical approach with pre-trained models achieves state-of-the-art performance in real-world noisy datasets.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Mental State Classification Using Multi-graph Features
Authors:
Guodong Chen,
Hayden S. Helm,
Kate Lytvynets,
Weiwei Yang,
Carey E. Priebe
Abstract:
We consider the problem of extracting features from passive, multi-channel electroencephalogram (EEG) devices for downstream inference tasks related to high-level mental states such as stress and cognitive load. Our proposed method leverages recently developed multi-graph tools and applies them to the time series of graphs implied by the statistical dependence structure (e.g., correlation) amongst…
▽ More
We consider the problem of extracting features from passive, multi-channel electroencephalogram (EEG) devices for downstream inference tasks related to high-level mental states such as stress and cognitive load. Our proposed method leverages recently developed multi-graph tools and applies them to the time series of graphs implied by the statistical dependence structure (e.g., correlation) amongst the multiple sensors. We compare the effectiveness of the proposed features to traditional band power-based features in the context of three classification experiments and find that the two feature sets offer complementary predictive information. We conclude by showing that the importance of particular channels and pairs of channels for classification when using the proposed features is neuroscientifically valid.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Towards a theory of out-of-distribution learning
Authors:
Jayanta Dey,
Ali Geisa,
Ronak Mehta,
Tyler M. Tomita,
Hayden S. Helm,
Haoyin Xu,
Eric Eaton,
Jeffery Dick,
Carey E. Priebe,
Joshua T. Vogelstein
Abstract:
Learning is a process wherein a learning agent enhances its performance through exposure of experience or data. Throughout this journey, the agent may encounter diverse learning environments. For example, data may be presented to the leaner all at once, in multiple batches, or sequentially. Furthermore, the distribution of each data sample could be either identical and independent (iid) or non-iid…
▽ More
Learning is a process wherein a learning agent enhances its performance through exposure of experience or data. Throughout this journey, the agent may encounter diverse learning environments. For example, data may be presented to the leaner all at once, in multiple batches, or sequentially. Furthermore, the distribution of each data sample could be either identical and independent (iid) or non-iid. Additionally, there may exist computational and space constraints for the deployment of the learning algorithms. The complexity of a learning task can vary significantly, depending on the learning setup and the constraints imposed upon it. However, it is worth noting that the current literature lacks formal definitions for many of the in-distribution and out-of-distribution learning paradigms. Establishing proper and universally agreed-upon definitions for these learning setups is essential for thoroughly exploring the evolution of ideas across different learning scenarios and deriving generalized mathematical bounds for these learners. In this paper, we aim to address this issue by proposing a chronological approach to defining different learning tasks using the provably approximately correct (PAC) learning framework. We will start with in-distribution learning and progress to recently proposed lifelong or continual learning. We employ consistent terminology and notation to demonstrate how each of these learning frameworks represents a specific instance of a broader, more generalized concept of learnability. Our hope is that this work will inspire a universally agreed-upon approach to quantifying different types of learning, fostering greater understanding and progress in the field.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2024; v1 submitted 29 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Leveraging semantically similar queries for ranking via combining representations
Authors:
Hayden S. Helm,
Marah Abdin,
Benjamin D. Pedigo,
Shweti Mahajan,
Vince Lyzinski,
Youngser Park,
Amitabh Basu,
Piali~Choudhury,
Christopher M. White,
Weiwei Yang,
Carey E. Priebe
Abstract:
In modern ranking problems, different and disparate representations of the items to be ranked are often available. It is sensible, then, to try to combine these representations to improve ranking. Indeed, learning to rank via combining representations is both principled and practical for learning a ranking function for a particular query. In extremely data-scarce settings, however, the amount of l…
▽ More
In modern ranking problems, different and disparate representations of the items to be ranked are often available. It is sensible, then, to try to combine these representations to improve ranking. Indeed, learning to rank via combining representations is both principled and practical for learning a ranking function for a particular query. In extremely data-scarce settings, however, the amount of labeled data available for a particular query can lead to a highly variable and ineffective ranking function. One way to mitigate the effect of the small amount of data is to leverage information from semantically similar queries. Indeed, as we demonstrate in simulation settings and real data examples, when semantically similar queries are available it is possible to gainfully use them when ranking with respect to a particular query. We describe and explore this phenomenon in the context of the bias-variance trade off and apply it to the data-scarce settings of a Bing navigational graph and the Drosophila larva connectome.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Inducing a hierarchy for multi-class classification problems
Authors:
Hayden S. Helm,
Weiwei Yang,
Sujeeth Bharadwaj,
Kate Lytvynets,
Oriana Riva,
Christopher White,
Ali Geisa,
Carey E. Priebe
Abstract:
In applications where categorical labels follow a natural hierarchy, classification methods that exploit the label structure often outperform those that do not. Un-fortunately, the majority of classification datasets do not come pre-equipped with a hierarchical structure and classical flat classifiers must be employed. In this paper, we investigate a class of methods that induce a hierarchy that c…
▽ More
In applications where categorical labels follow a natural hierarchy, classification methods that exploit the label structure often outperform those that do not. Un-fortunately, the majority of classification datasets do not come pre-equipped with a hierarchical structure and classical flat classifiers must be employed. In this paper, we investigate a class of methods that induce a hierarchy that can similarly improve classification performance over flat classifiers. The class of methods follows the structure of first clustering the conditional distributions and subsequently using a hierarchical classifier with the induced hierarchy. We demonstrate the effectiveness of the class of methods both for discovering a latent hierarchy and for improving accuracy in principled simulation settings and three real data applications.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Subgraph nomination: Query by Example Subgraph Retrieval in Networks
Authors:
Al-Fahad M. Al-Qadhi,
Carey E. Priebe,
Hayden S. Helm,
Vince Lyzinski
Abstract:
This paper introduces the subgraph nomination inference task, in which example subgraphs of interest are used to query a network for similarly interesting subgraphs. This type of problem appears time and again in real world problems connected to, for example, user recommendation systems and structural retrieval tasks in social and biological/connectomic networks. We formally define the subgraph no…
▽ More
This paper introduces the subgraph nomination inference task, in which example subgraphs of interest are used to query a network for similarly interesting subgraphs. This type of problem appears time and again in real world problems connected to, for example, user recommendation systems and structural retrieval tasks in social and biological/connectomic networks. We formally define the subgraph nomination framework with an emphasis on the notion of a user-in-the-loop in the subgraph nomination pipeline. In this setting, a user can provide additional post-nomination light supervision that can be incorporated into the retrieval task. After introducing and formalizing the retrieval task, we examine the nuanced effect that user-supervision can have on performance, both analytically and across real and simulated data examples.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2022; v1 submitted 29 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
A partition-based similarity for classification distributions
Authors:
Hayden S. Helm,
Ronak D. Mehta,
Brandon Duderstadt,
Weiwei Yang,
Christoper M. White,
Ali Geisa,
Joshua T. Vogelstein,
Carey E. Priebe
Abstract:
Herein we define a measure of similarity between classification distributions that is both principled from the perspective of statistical pattern recognition and useful from the perspective of machine learning practitioners. In particular, we propose a novel similarity on classification distributions, dubbed task similarity, that quantifies how an optimally-transformed optimal representation for a…
▽ More
Herein we define a measure of similarity between classification distributions that is both principled from the perspective of statistical pattern recognition and useful from the perspective of machine learning practitioners. In particular, we propose a novel similarity on classification distributions, dubbed task similarity, that quantifies how an optimally-transformed optimal representation for a source distribution performs when applied to inference related to a target distribution. The definition of task similarity allows for natural definitions of adversarial and orthogonal distributions. We highlight limiting properties of representations induced by (universally) consistent decision rules and demonstrate in simulation that an empirical estimate of task similarity is a function of the decision rule deployed for inference. We demonstrate that for a given target distribution, both transfer efficiency and semantic similarity of candidate source distributions correlate with empirical task similarity.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Correcting a Nonparametric Two-sample Graph Hypothesis Test for Graphs with Different Numbers of Vertices with Applications to Connectomics
Authors:
Anton A. Alyakin,
Joshua Agterberg,
Hayden S. Helm,
Carey E. Priebe
Abstract:
Random graphs are statistical models that have many applications, ranging from neuroscience to social network analysis. Of particular interest in some applications is the problem of testing two random graphs for equality of generating distributions. Tang et al. (2017) propose a test for this setting. This test consists of embedding the graph into a low-dimensional space via the adjacency spectral…
▽ More
Random graphs are statistical models that have many applications, ranging from neuroscience to social network analysis. Of particular interest in some applications is the problem of testing two random graphs for equality of generating distributions. Tang et al. (2017) propose a test for this setting. This test consists of embedding the graph into a low-dimensional space via the adjacency spectral embedding (ASE) and subsequently using a kernel two-sample test based on the maximum mean discrepancy. However, if the two graphs being compared have an unequal number of vertices, the test of Tang et al. (2017) may not be valid. We demonstrate the intuition behind this invalidity and propose a correction that makes any subsequent kernel- or distance-based test valid. Our method relies on sampling based on the asymptotic distribution for the ASE. We call these altered embeddings the corrected adjacency spectral embeddings (CASE). We also show that CASE remedies the exchangeability problem of the original test and demonstrate the validity and consistency of the test that uses CASE via a simulation study. Lastly, we apply our proposed test to the problem of determining equivalence of generating distributions in human connectomes extracted from diffusion magnetic resonance imaging (dMRI) at different scales.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2023; v1 submitted 21 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Distance-based Positive and Unlabeled Learning for Ranking
Authors:
Hayden S. Helm,
Amitabh Basu,
Avanti Athreya,
Youngser Park,
Joshua T. Vogelstein,
Carey E. Priebe,
Michael Winding,
Marta Zlatic,
Albert Cardona,
Patrick Bourke,
Jonathan Larson,
Marah Abdin,
Piali Choudhury,
Weiwei Yang,
Christopher W. White
Abstract:
Learning to rank -- producing a ranked list of items specific to a query and with respect to a set of supervisory items -- is a problem of general interest. The setting we consider is one in which no analytic description of what constitutes a good ranking is available. Instead, we have a collection of representations and supervisory information consisting of a (target item, interesting items set)…
▽ More
Learning to rank -- producing a ranked list of items specific to a query and with respect to a set of supervisory items -- is a problem of general interest. The setting we consider is one in which no analytic description of what constitutes a good ranking is available. Instead, we have a collection of representations and supervisory information consisting of a (target item, interesting items set) pair. We demonstrate analytically, in simulation, and in real data examples that learning to rank via combining representations using an integer linear program is effective when the supervision is as light as "these few items are similar to your item of interest." While this nomination task is quite general, for specificity we present our methodology from the perspective of vertex nomination in graphs. The methodology described herein is model agnostic.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2022; v1 submitted 19 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
A Simple Lifelong Learning Approach
Authors:
Joshua T. Vogelstein,
Jayanta Dey,
Hayden S. Helm,
Will LeVine,
Ronak D. Mehta,
Tyler M. Tomita,
Haoyin Xu,
Ali Geisa,
Qingyang Wang,
Gido M. van de Ven,
Chenyu Gao,
Weiwei Yang,
Bryan Tower,
Jonathan Larson,
Christopher M. White,
Carey E. Priebe
Abstract:
In lifelong learning, data are used to improve performance not only on the present task, but also on past and future (unencountered) tasks. While typical transfer learning algorithms can improve performance on future tasks, their performance on prior tasks degrades upon learning new tasks (called forgetting). Many recent approaches for continual or lifelong learning have attempted to maintain perf…
▽ More
In lifelong learning, data are used to improve performance not only on the present task, but also on past and future (unencountered) tasks. While typical transfer learning algorithms can improve performance on future tasks, their performance on prior tasks degrades upon learning new tasks (called forgetting). Many recent approaches for continual or lifelong learning have attempted to maintain performance on old tasks given new tasks. But striving to avoid forgetting sets the goal unnecessarily low. The goal of lifelong learning should be to use data to improve performance on both future tasks (forward transfer) and past tasks (backward transfer). In this paper, we show that a simple approach -- representation ensembling -- demonstrates both forward and backward transfer in a variety of simulated and benchmark data scenarios, including tabular, vision (CIFAR-100, 5-dataset, Split Mini-Imagenet, and Food1k), and speech (spoken digit), in contrast to various reference algorithms, which typically failed to transfer either forward or backward, or both. Moreover, our proposed approach can flexibly operate with or without a computational budget.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2024; v1 submitted 27 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
GraSPy: Graph Statistics in Python
Authors:
Jaewon Chung,
Benjamin D. Pedigo,
Eric W. Bridgeford,
Bijan K. Varjavand,
Hayden S. Helm,
Joshua T. Vogelstein
Abstract:
We introduce GraSPy, a Python library devoted to statistical inference, machine learning, and visualization of random graphs and graph populations. This package provides flexible and easy-to-use algorithms for analyzing and understanding graphs with a scikit-learn compliant API. GraSPy can be downloaded from Python Package Index (PyPi), and is released under the Apache 2.0 open-source license. The…
▽ More
We introduce GraSPy, a Python library devoted to statistical inference, machine learning, and visualization of random graphs and graph populations. This package provides flexible and easy-to-use algorithms for analyzing and understanding graphs with a scikit-learn compliant API. GraSPy can be downloaded from Python Package Index (PyPi), and is released under the Apache 2.0 open-source license. The documentation and all releases are available at https://neurodata.io/graspy.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2019; v1 submitted 29 March, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.