-
Lopsided distribution of MATLAS and ELVES dwarf satellite systems around isolated host galaxies
Authors:
Nick Heesters,
Helmut Jerjen,
Oliver Müller,
Marcel S. Pawlowski,
Kosuke Jamie Kanehisa
Abstract:
The properties of satellite dwarf galaxies pose important empirical constraints to verify cosmological models on galaxy scales. Their phase-space correlations, in particular, offer interesting insights into various models. Next to the planes-of-satellites phenomenon, the lopsided distribution of satellites relative to their host galaxy has been studied observationally and in cosmological simulatio…
▽ More
The properties of satellite dwarf galaxies pose important empirical constraints to verify cosmological models on galaxy scales. Their phase-space correlations, in particular, offer interesting insights into various models. Next to the planes-of-satellites phenomenon, the lopsided distribution of satellites relative to their host galaxy has been studied observationally and in cosmological simulations. It is still unclear how observed lopsidedness aligns with expectations from simulations. We measure lopsidedness in observed isolated satellite systems using six different metrics. We study 47 systems from the MATLAS survey beyond the Local Volume (LV) as well as 21 LV satellite systems from the ELVES survey. We find that the so-called wedge metric, counting the number of dwarfs in wedges with varying opening angles, is best suited to capture a system's overall lopsidedness. Under this metric, our analysis reveals that ~16 percent of the tested satellite systems exhibit a statistically significant degree of lopsidedness when compared to systems with randomly generated satellite position angles. This presents a notable excess over the expected 5% (2 sigma level) of significantly lopsided systems in a sample with no overall inherent lopsidedness. However, using multiple metrics provides a more complete picture. Combining all tested metrics, the number of significantly lopsided systems increases to ~21 percent. Contrary to recent results from the literature, we find more lopsided systems among the red early-type galaxies in the MATLAS survey compared to the mostly blue late-type hosts in ELVES. We further find that satellite galaxies at larger distances from the host, potentially recently accreted, are likely the primary contributors to the reported excess of lopsidedness. Our results enable comparisons with similar systems in simulations to assess consistency with the standard model.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
The satellite galaxy plane of NGC 4490 in light of ΛCDM - Sparsity of similarly extreme analogs and a possible role of satellite pairs
Authors:
Marcel S. Pawlowski,
Oliver Müller,
Salvatore Taibi,
Mariana P. Júlio,
Kosuke Jamie Kanehisa,
Nick Heesters
Abstract:
The galaxy system around NGC4490 was recently highlighted to display a flattened, kinematically correlated structure reminiscent of satellite galaxy planes around other hosts. Since known satellite planes are in tension with $Λ$CDM expectations from cosmological simulations, we quantitatively assess for the first time the tension posed by the NGC4490 system. We measure the on-sky flattening as the…
▽ More
The galaxy system around NGC4490 was recently highlighted to display a flattened, kinematically correlated structure reminiscent of satellite galaxy planes around other hosts. Since known satellite planes are in tension with $Λ$CDM expectations from cosmological simulations, we quantitatively assess for the first time the tension posed by the NGC4490 system. We measure the on-sky flattening as the major-to-minor axis ratio b/a of the satellite distribution and their line-of-sight kinematic correlation. Analogs are selected in the IllustrisTNG-50 simulation and their flattening and correlation are similarly measured. We confirm the strong kinematic coherence of all 12 observed objects with available line-of-sight velocities (of 14 in total): the northern ones approach and the southern ones recede relative to the host. The spatial distribution of all 14 objects is substantially flattened with b/a=0.38 (0.26 considering only the 12 objects with velocities). Such extreme arrangements are rare in the simulation at 0.21-0.35%. This would drop further if at least one of the two satellite objects without velocities is confirmed to follow the kinematic trend, and would become zero if both are rejected as non-members. We also identify a likely galaxy pair in the observed system, and find a similar pair in the best-matching simulated analog. Our findings establish NGC4490 as another strong example of a satellite plane in the Local Volume. This emphasizes that planes of satellites are a more general issue faced by $Λ$CDM also beyond the Local Group. The tension with typical systems in simulations suggests that the observed one requires a specific formation scenario, potentially connected to the larger-scale galaxy alignment in its vicinity. The presence of galaxy pairs in the observed and a simulated system hints at the importance such grou**s may have to understand satellite planes.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
A too-many dwarf satellite galaxies problem in the MATLAS low-to-moderate density fields
Authors:
Kosuke Jamie Kanehisa,
Marcel S. Pawlowski,
Nick Heesters,
Oliver Müller
Abstract:
Dwarf galaxy abundances can serve as discernment tests for models of structure formation. Previous small-scale tensions between observations and dark matter-only cosmological simulations may have been resolved with the inclusion of baryonic processes; however, these successes have been largely concentrated on the Local Group dwarfs the feedback models were initially calibrated on. We investigate w…
▽ More
Dwarf galaxy abundances can serve as discernment tests for models of structure formation. Previous small-scale tensions between observations and dark matter-only cosmological simulations may have been resolved with the inclusion of baryonic processes; however, these successes have been largely concentrated on the Local Group dwarfs the feedback models were initially calibrated on. We investigate whether the $Λ$CDM model can reliably reproduce dwarf abundances in the MATLAS low-to-moderate density fields that are centred upon early-type host galaxies beyond the Local Volume. We carried out mock observations of MATLAS-like fields with the high-resolution hydrodynamic simulation IllustrisTNG-50. We used matching selection criteria and compared the properties of dwarfs contained within them with their MATLAS analogues. Although simulated MATLAS-like dwarfs demonstrate photometric properties that are consistent with the observed galaxy population and follow the same scaling relations, TNG50 underestimates the number of dwarf galaxies in isolated MATLAS fields at the 6 sigma level. This significance is maintained within crowded fields containing more than a single bright host. Our 55-62% estimate of the fraction of background galaxies is in agreement with estimates by MATLAS, but is wholly insufficient to alleviate this discrepancy in dwarf abundances. Any incompleteness in the observed fields further exacerbates this tension. We identified a "too-many-satellites" problem in $Λ$CDM, emphasising the need for the continued testing and refining of current models of galaxy formation in environments beyond the Local Group.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
The phase-space distribution of the M81 satellite system
Authors:
Oliver Müller,
Nick Heesters,
Marcel S. Pawlowski,
Kosuke Jamie Kanehisa,
Federico Lelli,
Noam I. Libeskind
Abstract:
The spatial distribution of dwarf galaxies around their host galaxies is a critical test for the standard model of cosmology because it probes the dynamics of dark matter halos and is independent of the internal baryonic processes of galaxies. Co-moving planes-of-satellites have been found around the Milky Way, the Andromeda galaxy, and the nearby CenA galaxy, which seem to be at odds with the sta…
▽ More
The spatial distribution of dwarf galaxies around their host galaxies is a critical test for the standard model of cosmology because it probes the dynamics of dark matter halos and is independent of the internal baryonic processes of galaxies. Co-moving planes-of-satellites have been found around the Milky Way, the Andromeda galaxy, and the nearby CenA galaxy, which seem to be at odds with the standard model of galaxy formation. Another nearby galaxy group, with a putative flattened distribution of dwarfs, is the M81 group. We present a quantitative analysis of the distribution of the M81 satellites using a Hough transform to detect linear structures. We confirm a flattened distribution of dwarf galaxies. Depending on the morphological type, we find a minor-to-major axis ratio of the satellite distribution to be 0.5 (all types) or 0.3 (dSph), which is in line with previous results for the M81 group. Comparing the orientation of this flattened structure in 3D with the surrounding large-scale matter distribution, we find a strong alignment with the local sheet and the planes-of-satellites around the Andromeda galaxy and Cen A. Employing velocities for a sub-sample of the dwarfs, we find no signal of co-rotation. Comparing the flattening and motion of the M81 dwarf galaxy system with IllustrisTNG50 we find good agreement between observations and simulations, but caution that i) velocity information of half of the satellites is missing, ii) velocities are coming mainly from dwarf irregulars clustered around NGC3077, which may hint towards an infall of a dwarf galaxy group and iii) some of the dwarfs may actually be tidal dwarf galaxies. From the missing velocities, we predict that the observed frequency within TNG may range between 2 to 29 per cent. Any conclusions about the agreement/disagreement with cosmological models needs to wait for a more complete picture of the dwarf galaxy system.
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
The creation of a massive UCD by tidal threshing from NGC 936
Authors:
Sanjaya Paudel,
Pierre-Alain Duc,
Sungsoon Lim,
Mélina Poulain,
Francine R. Marleau,
Oliver Müller,
Rubén Sánchez-Janssen,
Rebecca Habas,
Patrick R. Durrell,
Nick Heesters,
Daya Nidhi Chhatkuli,
Suk-** Yoon
Abstract:
We study a compact nucleus embedded in an early-type dwarf galaxy, MATLAS-167, which is in the process of disruption by the tidal force of the neighboring giant S0 galaxy, NGC 936, in a group environment. Using the imaging data of the MATLAS survey, we analyze the stellar tidal tail of MATLAS-167 and its central compact nucleus, designated as NGC 936_UCD. We find that NGC 936_UCD has a luminosity…
▽ More
We study a compact nucleus embedded in an early-type dwarf galaxy, MATLAS-167, which is in the process of disruption by the tidal force of the neighboring giant S0 galaxy, NGC 936, in a group environment. Using the imaging data of the MATLAS survey, we analyze the stellar tidal tail of MATLAS-167 and its central compact nucleus, designated as NGC 936_UCD. We find that NGC 936_UCD has a luminosity of M$_{g}$ = $-$11.43$\pm$0.01 mag and a size of 66.5$\pm$17 pc, sharing the global properties of Ultra Compact Dwarf galaxies (UCDs) but significantly larger and brighter compared to the typical UCD populations observed in the Virgo cluster. By integrating the total luminosity of both the tidal stream and MATLAS-167, we estimate that the disrupted dwarf progenitor possesses a luminosity of M$_{g}$ = $-$15.92$\pm$0.06 mag, a typical bright dE luminosity. With the help of the optical spectrum observed by the SDSS survey, we derive the simple stellar population properties of NGC 936_UCD: a light-weighted age of 5.6$\pm$0.7 Gyr and metallicity of [Z/H] = $-$0.83$\pm$0.3 dex. Our findings suggest that tidal threshing is a possible formation mechanism of bright UCD populations in close proximity to giant galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Radial velocities and stellar population properties of 56 MATLAS dwarf galaxies observed with MUSE
Authors:
Nick Heesters,
Oliver Müller,
Francine R. Marleau,
Pierre-Alain Duc,
Rubén Sánchez-Janssen,
Mélina Poulain,
Rebecca Habas,
Sungsoon Lim,
Patrick R. Durrell
Abstract:
Dwarf galaxies have been extensively studied in the Local Group, in nearby groups, and selected clusters, giving us a robust picture of their global stellar and dynamical properties in particular locations in the Universe. Intense study of these properties has revealed correlations between them, including the well known universal stellar mass-metallicity relation. However, since dwarfs play a role…
▽ More
Dwarf galaxies have been extensively studied in the Local Group, in nearby groups, and selected clusters, giving us a robust picture of their global stellar and dynamical properties in particular locations in the Universe. Intense study of these properties has revealed correlations between them, including the well known universal stellar mass-metallicity relation. However, since dwarfs play a role in a vast range of different environments, much can be learned about galaxy formation and evolution through extending the study of these objects to various locations. We present MUSE spectroscopy of a sample of 56 dwarf galaxies as a follow-up to the MATLAS survey in low-to-moderate density environments beyond the Local Volume. The dwarfs have stellar masses in the range of $M_{*}/M_{\odot}$ = 10$^{6.1}$-10$^{9.4}$ and show a distance range of D = 14-148 Mpc, the majority (75%) of which are located in the range targeted by the MATLAS survey (10-45 Mpc). We thus report a 75% (79% for dwarf ellipticals) success rate for the semi-automatic identification of dwarf galaxies in the MATLAS survey on the here presented subsample. Using pPXF full spectrum fitting, we determine their line-of-sight velocity and can match the majority of them with their massive host galaxy. Close inspection of their spectra reveals that ~30% show clear emission lines and thus star formation activity. We estimate their stellar population properties (age and metallicity) and compare our results with other works investigating Local Volume and cluster dwarf galaxies. We find that the dwarf galaxies presented in this work show a systematic offset from the stellar mass-metallicity relation towards lower metallicities at the same stellar mass. A similar deviation is present in other works in the stellar mass range probed in this work and might be attributed to the use of different methodologies for deriving the metallicity.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Is there a dwarf galaxy satellite-of-satellite problem in $Λ$CDM?
Authors:
Oliver Müller,
Nick Heesters,
Helmut Jerjen,
Gagandeep Anand,
Yves Revaz
Abstract:
Dark matter clusters on all scales, therefore it is expected that even substructure should host its own substructure. Using the Extragalactic Distance Database, we searched for dwarf galaxy satellites of dwarf galaxies, i.e. satellite-of-satellite galaxies, corresponding to these substructures-of-substructure. Going through HST data of 117 dwarf galaxies, we report the discovery of a dwarf galaxy…
▽ More
Dark matter clusters on all scales, therefore it is expected that even substructure should host its own substructure. Using the Extragalactic Distance Database, we searched for dwarf galaxy satellites of dwarf galaxies, i.e. satellite-of-satellite galaxies, corresponding to these substructures-of-substructure. Going through HST data of 117 dwarf galaxies, we report the discovery of a dwarf galaxy around the ultra-diffuse M96 companion M96-DF6 at 10 Mpc. Modelling its structural parameters, we find that it is an ultra-faint dwarf galaxy which is 135 times fainter than its host. Based on its close projection to M96-DF6 it is unlikely that their association occurs by chance. We compare the luminosity ratio of this and three other known satellite-of-satellite systems with results from two different cosmological sets of CDM simulations. For the observed stellar mass range of the central dwarf galaxies, the simulated dwarfs have a higher luminosity ratio between the central dwarf and its first satellite ($\approx$10'000) than observed ($\approx$100), excluding the LMC system. No simulated dwarf analog at these observed stellar masses has the observed luminosity ratio. This cannot be due to missing resolution, because it is the brightest subhalos that are missing. This may indicate that there is a satellite-of-satellite (SoS) problem for CDM in the stellar mass range between 10$^6$ and 10$^8$ M$_\odot$ - the regime of the classical dwarf galaxies. However, simulated dwarf models at both a lower ($<10^6$ M$_\odot$) and higher ($>10^8$ M$_\odot$) stellar mass have comparable luminosity ratios. For the higher stellar mass systems, the LMC system is reproduced by simulations, for the lower stellar masses, no observed SoS system has been observed to date. More observations and simulations of SoS systems are needed to assess whether the luminosity ratio is at odds with CDM.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Flattened structures of dwarf satellites around massive host galaxies in the MATLAS low-to-moderate density fields
Authors:
N. Heesters,
R. Habas,
F. R. Marleau,
O. Müller,
P. -A. Duc,
M. Poulain,
P. Durrell,
R. Sánchez-Janssen,
S. Paudel
Abstract:
It was first observed in the 1970s that the dwarf galaxies surrounding our Milky Way, so-called satellites, appear to be arranged in a thin, vast plane. Similar discoveries have been made around additional galaxies in the local Universe such as Andromeda, Centaurus A, and potentially M83. In the specific cases with available kinematic data, the dwarf satellites also appear to preferentially co-orb…
▽ More
It was first observed in the 1970s that the dwarf galaxies surrounding our Milky Way, so-called satellites, appear to be arranged in a thin, vast plane. Similar discoveries have been made around additional galaxies in the local Universe such as Andromeda, Centaurus A, and potentially M83. In the specific cases with available kinematic data, the dwarf satellites also appear to preferentially co-orbit their massive host galaxy. Planes of satellites are rare in the lambda cold dark matter ($Λ$CDM) paradigm, although they may be a natural consequence of projection effects. Such a phase-space correlation, however, remains difficult to explain. In this work we analyzed the 2D spatial distribution of 2210 dwarf galaxies around early-type galaxies (ETGs) in the low-to-medium density fields of the "Mass Assembly of early-Type GaLAxies with their fine Structures" (MATLAS) survey. Under the assumption that the dwarfs are satellite members of the central massive ETG, we identified flattened structures using both a variation in the Hough transform and total least square (TLS) fitting. In 119 satellite systems, we find 31 statistically significant flattened dwarf structures using a combination of both methods with subsequent Monte Carlo (MC) simulations with random data. The vast majority of these dwarf structures lie within the estimated virial radii of the massive host. The major axes of these systems are aligned better than 30° with the estimated orientation of the large-scale structure in nine (50%) cases. Additional distance measurements and future kinematic studies will be required to confirm the planar nature of these structures and to determine if they are corotating systems.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
