-
A Tale of Two Curricula: The performance of two thousand students in introductory electromagnetism
Authors:
Matthew A. Kohlmyer,
Marcos D. Caballero,
Richard Catrambone,
Ruth W. Chabay,
Lin Ding,
Mark P. Haugan,
M. Jackson Marr,
Bruce A. Sherwood,
Michael F. Schatz
Abstract:
The performance of over 2000 students in introductory calculus-based electromagnetism (E&M) courses at four large research universities was measured using the Brief Electricity and Magnetism Assessment (BEMA). Two different curricula were used at these universities: a traditional E&M curriculum and the Matter & Interactions (M&I) curriculum. At each university, post-instruction BEMA test average…
▽ More
The performance of over 2000 students in introductory calculus-based electromagnetism (E&M) courses at four large research universities was measured using the Brief Electricity and Magnetism Assessment (BEMA). Two different curricula were used at these universities: a traditional E&M curriculum and the Matter & Interactions (M&I) curriculum. At each university, post-instruction BEMA test averages were significantly higher for the M&I curriculum than for the traditional curriculum. The differences in post-test averages cannot be explained by differences in variables such as pre-instruction BEMA scores, grade point average, or SAT scores. BEMA performance on categories of items organized by subtopic was also compared at one of the universities; M&I averages were significantly higher in each topic. The results suggest that the M&I curriculum is more effective than the traditional curriculum at teaching E&M concepts to students, possibly because the learning progression in M&I reorganizes and augments the traditional sequence of topics, for example, by increasing early emphasis on the vector field concept and by emphasizing the effects of fields on matter at the microscopic level.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2009;
originally announced June 2009.
-
Gravity-induced birefringence within the framework of Poincare gauge theory
Authors:
Oliver Preuss,
Sami K. Solanki,
M. P. Haugan,
Stefan Jordan
Abstract:
Gauge theories of gravity provide an elegant and promising extension of general relativity. In this paper we show that the Poincaré gauge theory exhibits gravity-induced birefringence under the assumption of a specific gauge invariant nonminimal coupling between torsion and Maxwell's field. Furthermore we give for the first time an explicit expression for the induced phaseshift between two ortho…
▽ More
Gauge theories of gravity provide an elegant and promising extension of general relativity. In this paper we show that the Poincaré gauge theory exhibits gravity-induced birefringence under the assumption of a specific gauge invariant nonminimal coupling between torsion and Maxwell's field. Furthermore we give for the first time an explicit expression for the induced phaseshift between two orthogonal polarization modes within the Poincaré framework. Since such a phaseshift can lead to a depolarization of light emitted from an extended source this effect is, in principle, observable. We use white dwarf polarimetric data to constrain the essential coupling constant responsible for this effect.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2005; v1 submitted 16 July, 2005;
originally announced July 2005.
-
Constraining Gravitational Theories by Observing Magnetic White Dwarfs
Authors:
Oliver Preuss,
Stefan Jordan,
Mark P. Haugan,
Sami K. Solanki
Abstract:
Under the assumption of a specific nonminimal coupling of torsion to Under the assumption of a specific nonminimal coupling of torsion to electromagnetism, spacetime is birefringent in the presence of a gravitational field leading to depolarization of light emitted from extended astrophysical sources. We use polarimetric data of the magnetic white dwarf RE J0317-853 to set for the very first tim…
▽ More
Under the assumption of a specific nonminimal coupling of torsion to Under the assumption of a specific nonminimal coupling of torsion to electromagnetism, spacetime is birefringent in the presence of a gravitational field leading to depolarization of light emitted from extended astrophysical sources. We use polarimetric data of the magnetic white dwarf RE J0317-853 to set for the very first time constraints on the essential coupling constant for this effect, giving k^2 <22 m^2. electromagnetism, spacetime is birefringent in the presence of a gravitational field leading to depolarization of light emitted from extended astrophysical sources. We use polarimetric data of the magnetic white dwarf RE J0317-853 to set for the very first time constraints on the essential coupling constant for this effect, giving k^2 <22 m^2.
△ Less
Submitted 25 November, 2004;
originally announced November 2004.
-
An astronomical search for evidence of new physics: Limits on gravity-induced birefringence from the magnetic white dwarf RE J0317-853
Authors:
Oliver Preuss,
Mark P. Haugan,
Sami K. Solanki,
Stefan Jordan
Abstract:
The coupling of the electromagnetic field directly with gravitational gauge fields leads to new physical effects that can be tested using astronomical data. Here we consider a particular case for closer scrutiny, a specific nonminimal coupling of torsion to electromagnetism, which enters into a metric-affine geometry of space-time. We show that under the assumption of this nonminimal coupling, s…
▽ More
The coupling of the electromagnetic field directly with gravitational gauge fields leads to new physical effects that can be tested using astronomical data. Here we consider a particular case for closer scrutiny, a specific nonminimal coupling of torsion to electromagnetism, which enters into a metric-affine geometry of space-time. We show that under the assumption of this nonminimal coupling, spacetime is birefringent in the presence of such a gravitational field. This leads to the depolarization of light emitted from extended astrophysical sources. We use polarimetric data of the magnetic white dwarf ${RE J0317-853}$ to set strong constraints on the essential coupling constant for this effect, giving $k^2 \lsim (19 {m})^2 $.
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2004; v1 submitted 13 May, 2004;
originally announced May 2004.
-
Solar constraints on new couplings between electromagnetism and gravity
Authors:
S. K. Solanki,
O. Preuss,
M. P. Haugan,
A. Gandorfer,
H. P. Povel,
P. Steiner,
K. Stucki,
P. N. Bernasconi,
D. Soltau
Abstract:
The unification of quantum field theory and general relativity is a fundamental goal of modern physics. In many cases, theoretical efforts to achieve this goal introduce auxiliary gravitational fields, ones in addition to the familiar symmetric second-rank tensor potential of general relativity, and lead to nonmetric theories because of direct couplings between these auxiliary fields and matter.…
▽ More
The unification of quantum field theory and general relativity is a fundamental goal of modern physics. In many cases, theoretical efforts to achieve this goal introduce auxiliary gravitational fields, ones in addition to the familiar symmetric second-rank tensor potential of general relativity, and lead to nonmetric theories because of direct couplings between these auxiliary fields and matter. Here, we consider an example of a metric-affine gauge theory of gravity in which torsion couples nonminimally to the electromagnetic field. This coupling causes a phase difference to accumulate between different polarization states of light as they propagate through the metric-affine gravitational field. Solar spectropolarimetric observations are reported and used to set strong constraints on the relevant coupling constant k: k^2 < (2.5 km)^2.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2004;
originally announced February 2004.
-
Principles of Equivalence: Their Role in Gravitation Physics and Experiments that Test Them
Authors:
Mark P. Haugan,
C. Lämmerzahl
Abstract:
Modern formulations of equivalence principles provide the foundation for an efficient approach to understanding and organizing the structural features of gravitation field theories. Since theories' predictions reflect differences in their structures, principles of equivalence also support an efficient experimental strategy for testing gravitation theories and for exploring the range of conceivab…
▽ More
Modern formulations of equivalence principles provide the foundation for an efficient approach to understanding and organizing the structural features of gravitation field theories. Since theories' predictions reflect differences in their structures, principles of equivalence also support an efficient experimental strategy for testing gravitation theories and for exploring the range of conceivable gravitation physics. These principles focus attention squarely on empirical consequences of the fundamental structural differences that distinguish one gravitation theory from another. Interestingly, the variety of such consequences makes it possible to design and perform experiments that test equivalence principles stringently but do so in markedly different ways than the most familiar experimental tests.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2001;
originally announced March 2001.
-
On the interpretation of Michelson-Morley experiments
Authors:
Claus Lämmerzahl,
Mark P. Haugan
Abstract:
Recent proposals for improved optical tests of Special Relativity have renewed interest in the interpretation of such tests. In this paper we discuss the interpretation of modern realizations of the Michelson-Morley experiment in the context of a new model of electrodynamics featuring a vector-valued photon mass. This model is gauge invariant, unlike massive-photon theories based on the Proca eq…
▽ More
Recent proposals for improved optical tests of Special Relativity have renewed interest in the interpretation of such tests. In this paper we discuss the interpretation of modern realizations of the Michelson-Morley experiment in the context of a new model of electrodynamics featuring a vector-valued photon mass. This model is gauge invariant, unlike massive-photon theories based on the Proca equation, and it predicts anisotropy of both the speed of light and the electric field of a point charge. The latter leads to an orientation dependence of the length of solid bodies which must be accounted for when interpreting the results of a Michelson-Morley experiment. Using a simple model of ionic solids we show that, in principle, the effect of orientation dependent length can conspire to cancel the effect of an anisotropic speed of light in a Michelson-Morley experiment, thus, complicating the interpretation of the results.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2001;
originally announced March 2001.
-
A New Test of the Einstein Equivalence Principle and the Isotropy of Space
Authors:
Mark P. Haugan,
Thierry F. Kauffmann
Abstract:
Recent research has established that nonsymmetric gravitation theories like Moffat's NGT predict that a gravitational field singles out an orthogonal pair of polarization states of light that propagate with different phase velocities. We show that a much wider class of nonmetric theories encompassed by the $χg$ formalism predict such violations of the Einstein equivalence principle. This gravity…
▽ More
Recent research has established that nonsymmetric gravitation theories like Moffat's NGT predict that a gravitational field singles out an orthogonal pair of polarization states of light that propagate with different phase velocities. We show that a much wider class of nonmetric theories encompassed by the $χg$ formalism predict such violations of the Einstein equivalence principle. This gravity-induced birefringence of space implies that propagation through a gravitational field can alter the polarization of light. We use data from polarization measurements of extragalactic sources to constrain birefringence induced by the field of the Galaxy. Our new constraint is $10^8$ times sharper than previous ones.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 1995;
originally announced April 1995.
