-
Refining resource estimation for the quantum computation of vibrational molecular spectra through Trotter error analysis
Authors:
Dimitar Trenev,
Pauline J Ollitrault,
Stuart M. Harwood,
Tanvi P. Gujarati,
Sumathy Raman,
Antonio Mezzacapo,
Sarah Mostame
Abstract:
Accurate simulations of vibrational molecular spectra are expensive on conventional computers. Compared to the electronic structure problem, the vibrational structure problem with quantum computers is less investigated. In this work we accurately estimate quantum resources, such as number of qubits and quantum gates, required for vibrational structure calculations on a programmable quantum compute…
▽ More
Accurate simulations of vibrational molecular spectra are expensive on conventional computers. Compared to the electronic structure problem, the vibrational structure problem with quantum computers is less investigated. In this work we accurately estimate quantum resources, such as number of qubits and quantum gates, required for vibrational structure calculations on a programmable quantum computer. Our approach is based on quantum phase estimation and focuses on fault-tolerant quantum devices. In addition to asymptotic estimates for generic chemical compounds, we present a more detailed analysis of the quantum resources needed for the simulation of the Hamiltonian arising in the vibrational structure calculation of acetylene-like polyynes of interest. Leveraging nested commutators, we provide an in-depth quantitative analysis of trotter errors compared to the prior investigations. Ultimately, this work serves as a guide for analyzing the potential quantum advantage within vibrational structure simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Enhancing interval observers for state estimation using constraints
Authors:
Stuart M. Harwood,
Paul I. Barton
Abstract:
This work considers the problem of calculating an interval-valued state estimate for a nonlinear system subject to bounded inputs and measurement errors. Such state estimators are often called interval observers. Interval observers can be constructed using methods from reachability theory. Recent advances in the construction of interval enclosures of reachable sets for nonlinear systems inspire th…
▽ More
This work considers the problem of calculating an interval-valued state estimate for a nonlinear system subject to bounded inputs and measurement errors. Such state estimators are often called interval observers. Interval observers can be constructed using methods from reachability theory. Recent advances in the construction of interval enclosures of reachable sets for nonlinear systems inspire the present work. These advances can incorporate constraints on the states to produce tighter interval enclosures. When applied to the state estimation problem, bounded-error measurements may be used as state constraints in these new theories. The result is a method that is easily implementable and which generally produces better, tighter interval state estimates. Furthermore, a novel linear programming-based method is proposed for calculating the observer gain, which must be tuned in practice. In contrast with previous approaches, this method does not rely on special system structure. The new approaches are demonstrated with numerical examples.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Pooling problems under perfect and imperfect competition
Authors:
Dimitri J. Papageorgiou,
Stuart M. Harwood,
Francisco Trespalacios
Abstract:
We investigate pooling problems in which multiple players vie with one another to maximize individual profit in a non-cooperative competitive market. This competitive setting is interesting and worthy of study because the majority of prevailing process systems engineering models largely overlook the non-cooperative strategies that exist in real-world markets. In this work, each player controls a p…
▽ More
We investigate pooling problems in which multiple players vie with one another to maximize individual profit in a non-cooperative competitive market. This competitive setting is interesting and worthy of study because the majority of prevailing process systems engineering models largely overlook the non-cooperative strategies that exist in real-world markets. In this work, each player controls a processing network involving intermediate tanks (or pools) where raw materials are blended together before being further combined into final products. Each player then solves a pure or mixed-integer bilinear optimization problem whose profit is influenced by other players. We present several bilevel formulations and numerical results of a novel decomposition algorithm.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2022; v1 submitted 6 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Improving the variational quantum eigensolver using variational adiabatic quantum computing
Authors:
Stuart M. Harwood,
Dimitar Trenev,
Spencer T. Stober,
Panagiotis Barkoutsos,
Tanvi P. Gujarati,
Sarah Mostame,
Donny Greenberg
Abstract:
The variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) is a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm for finding the minimum eigenvalue of a Hamiltonian that involves the optimization of a parameterized quantum circuit. Since the resulting optimization problem is in general nonconvex, the method can converge to suboptimal parameter values which do not yield the minimum eigenvalue. In this work, we address this short…
▽ More
The variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) is a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm for finding the minimum eigenvalue of a Hamiltonian that involves the optimization of a parameterized quantum circuit. Since the resulting optimization problem is in general nonconvex, the method can converge to suboptimal parameter values which do not yield the minimum eigenvalue. In this work, we address this shortcoming by adopting the concept of variational adiabatic quantum computing (VAQC) as a procedure to improve VQE. In VAQC, the ground state of a continuously parameterized Hamiltonian is approximated via a parameterized quantum circuit. We discuss some basic theory of VAQC to motivate the development of a hybrid quantum-classical homotopy continuation method. The proposed method has parallels with a predictor-corrector method for numerical integration of differential equations. While there are theoretical limitations to the procedure, we see in practice that VAQC can successfully find good initial circuit parameters to initialize VQE. We demonstrate this with two examples from quantum chemistry. Through these examples, we provide empirical evidence that VAQC, combined with other techniques (an adaptive termination criteria for the classical optimizer and a variance-based resampling method for the expectation evaluation), can provide more accurate solutions than "plain" VQE, for the same amount of effort.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2021; v1 submitted 4 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Considerations for evaluating thermodynamic properties with hybrid quantum-classical computing work-flows
Authors:
Spencer T. Stober,
Stuart M. Harwood,
Donny Greenberg,
Tanvi P. Gujarati,
Sarah Mostame,
Dimitar Trenev
Abstract:
Quantum chemistry applications on quantum computers currently rely heavily on the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) algorithm. This hybrid quantum-classical algorithm aims at finding ground state solutions of molecular systems based on the variational principle. VQE calculations can be systematically implemented for perturbations to each molecular degree of freedom, generating a Born-Oppenheim…
▽ More
Quantum chemistry applications on quantum computers currently rely heavily on the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) algorithm. This hybrid quantum-classical algorithm aims at finding ground state solutions of molecular systems based on the variational principle. VQE calculations can be systematically implemented for perturbations to each molecular degree of freedom, generating a Born-Oppenheimer potential energy surface (PES) for the molecule. The PES can then be used to derive thermodynamic properties, which are often desirable for applications in chemical engineering and materials design. It is clear from this process that quantum chemistry applications contain a substantial classical computing component in addition to steps that can be performed using a quantum computer. In order to design efficient work-flows that take full advantage of each hardware-type, it is critical to consider the entire process so that the high-accuracy electronic energies possible from quantum computing are not squandered in the process of calculating thermodynamic properties. We present a summary of the hybrid quantum-classical work-flow to compute thermodynamic properties. This work-flow contains many options that can significantly affect the efficiency and the accuracy of the results, including classical optimizer attributes, number of ansatz repetitions, and how the vibrational Schroedinger equation is solved to determine vibrational modes. We also analyze the effects of these options by employing robust statistics along with simulations and experiments on actual quantum hardware. We show that through careful selection of work-flow options, nearly order-of-magnitude increases in accuracy are possible at equivalent computing time.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2021; v1 submitted 4 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
A note on semi-infinite program bounding methods
Authors:
Stuart M. Harwood,
Dimitri J. Papageorgiou,
Francisco Trespalacios
Abstract:
Semi-infinite programs are a class of mathematical optimization problems with a finite number of decision variables and infinite constraints. As shown by Blankenship and Falk (Blankenship and Falk. "Infinitely constrained optimization problems." Journal of Optimization Theory and Applications 19.2 (1976): 261-281.), a sequence of lower bounds which converges to the optimal objective value may be o…
▽ More
Semi-infinite programs are a class of mathematical optimization problems with a finite number of decision variables and infinite constraints. As shown by Blankenship and Falk (Blankenship and Falk. "Infinitely constrained optimization problems." Journal of Optimization Theory and Applications 19.2 (1976): 261-281.), a sequence of lower bounds which converges to the optimal objective value may be obtained with specially constructed finite approximations of the constraint set. In (Mitsos. "Global optimization of semi-infinite programs via restriction of the right-hand side." Optimization 60.10-11 (2011): 1291-1308.), it is claimed that a modification of this lower bounding method involving approximate solution of the lower-level program yields convergent lower bounds. We show with a counterexample that this claim is false, and discuss what kind of approximate solution of the lower-level program is sufficient for correct behavior.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
A note on generalized semi-infinite program bounding methods
Authors:
Stuart M. Harwood
Abstract:
Generalized semi-infinite programs (GSIP) are a class of mathematical optimization problems that generalize semi-infinite programs, which have a finite number of decision variables and infinite constraints. Mitsos et al. (Mitsos and Tsoukalas. "Global optimization of generalized semi-infinite programs via restriction of the right hand side." Journal of Global Optimization 61.1 (2015): 1-17.) prese…
▽ More
Generalized semi-infinite programs (GSIP) are a class of mathematical optimization problems that generalize semi-infinite programs, which have a finite number of decision variables and infinite constraints. Mitsos et al. (Mitsos and Tsoukalas. "Global optimization of generalized semi-infinite programs via restriction of the right hand side." Journal of Global Optimization 61.1 (2015): 1-17.) present a method for global optimization of GSIP. This method involves a lower bounding method, and they claim that these lower bounds converge to the optimal objective value of the GSIP. A counterexample is presented that shows that this claim is false.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Analysis of the alternating direction method of multipliers for nonconvex problems
Authors:
Stuart M. Harwood
Abstract:
This work investigates the theoretical performance of the alternating-direction method of multipliers (ADMM) as it applies to nonconvex optimization problems, and in particular, problems with nonconvex constraint sets. The alternating direction method of multipliers is an optimization method that has largely been analyzed for convex problems. The ultimate goal is to assess what kind of theoretical…
▽ More
This work investigates the theoretical performance of the alternating-direction method of multipliers (ADMM) as it applies to nonconvex optimization problems, and in particular, problems with nonconvex constraint sets. The alternating direction method of multipliers is an optimization method that has largely been analyzed for convex problems. The ultimate goal is to assess what kind of theoretical convergence properties the method has in the nonconvex case, and to this end, theoretical contributions are two-fold. First, this work analyzes the method with local solution of the ADMM subproblems, which contrasts with much analysis that requires global solutions of the subproblems. Such a consideration is important to practical implementations. Second, it is established that the method still satisfies a local convergence result. The work concludes with some more detailed discussion of how the analysis relates to previous work.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2022; v1 submitted 20 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
