Showing 1–50 of 84 results for author: Harrow, A W

Optimal quantum circuit cuts with application to clustered Hamiltonian simulation

Authors: Aram W. Harrow, Angus Lowe

Abstract: We study methods to replace entangling operations with random local operations in a quantum computation, at the cost of increasing the number of required executions. First, we consider "space-like cuts" where an entangling unitary is replaced with random local unitaries. We propose an entanglement measure for quantum dynamics, the product extent, which bounds the cost in a procedure for this repla… ▽ More We study methods to replace entangling operations with random local operations in a quantum computation, at the cost of increasing the number of required executions. First, we consider "space-like cuts" where an entangling unitary is replaced with random local unitaries. We propose an entanglement measure for quantum dynamics, the product extent, which bounds the cost in a procedure for this replacement based on two copies of the Hadamard test. In the terminology of prior work, this procedure yields a quasiprobability decomposition with minimal 1-norm in a number of cases, which addresses an open question of Piveteau and Sutter. As an application, we give dramatically improved bounds on clustered Hamiltonian simulation. Specifically we show that interactions can be removed at a cost exponential in the sum of their strengths times the evolution time. We also give an improved upper bound on the cost of replacing wires with measure-and-prepare channels using "time-like cuts". We prove a matching information-theoretic lower bound when estimating output probabilities. △ Less

Submitted 1 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 33 pages, 3 figures

Approximate orthogonality of permutation operators, with application to quantum information

Authors: Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: Consider the $n!$ different unitary matrices that permute $n$ $d$-dimensional quantum systems. If $d\geq n$ then they are linearly independent. This paper discusses a sense in which they are approximately orthogonal (with respect to the Hilbert-Schmidt inner product) if $d\gg n^2$, or, in a different sense, if $d\gg n$. Previous work had shown pairwise approximate orthogonality of these matrices,… ▽ More Consider the $n!$ different unitary matrices that permute $n$ $d$-dimensional quantum systems. If $d\geq n$ then they are linearly independent. This paper discusses a sense in which they are approximately orthogonal (with respect to the Hilbert-Schmidt inner product) if $d\gg n^2$, or, in a different sense, if $d\gg n$. Previous work had shown pairwise approximate orthogonality of these matrices, but here we show a more collective statement, quantified in terms of the operator norm distance of the Gram matrix to the identity matrix. This simple point has several applications in quantum information and random matrix theory: (1) showing that random maximally entangled states resemble fully random states, (2) showing that Boson sampling output probabilities resemble those from Gaussian matrices, (3) improving the Eggeling-Werner scheme for multipartite data hiding, (4) proving that the product test of Harrow-Montanaro cannot be performed using LOCC without a large number of copies of the state to be tested, (5) proving that the purity of a quantum state also cannot be efficiently tested using LOCC, and (6, published separately) hel** prove that poly-size random quantum circuits are poly-designs. △ Less

Submitted 1 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Comments: 23 pages

Report number: MIT-CTP/5603

Journal ref: Letters in Mathematical Physics (2024) 114:1

Quantum entropy thermalization

Authors: Yichen Huang, Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: In an isolated quantum many-body system undergoing unitary evolution, the entropy of a subsystem (smaller than half the system size) thermalizes if at long times, it is to leading order equal to the thermodynamic entropy of the subsystem at the same energy. In this paper, we prove entropy thermalization for a nearly integrable Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model initialized in a pure product state. The model… ▽ More In an isolated quantum many-body system undergoing unitary evolution, the entropy of a subsystem (smaller than half the system size) thermalizes if at long times, it is to leading order equal to the thermodynamic entropy of the subsystem at the same energy. In this paper, we prove entropy thermalization for a nearly integrable Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model initialized in a pure product state. The model is obtained by adding random all-to-all $4$-body interactions as a perturbation to a random free-fermion model. △ Less

Submitted 20 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

Report number: MIT-CTP/5468

Improved concentration of Laguerre and Jacobi ensembles

Authors: Yichen Huang, Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: We consider the asymptotic limits where certain parameters in the definitions of the Laguerre and Jacobi ensembles diverge. In these limits, Dette, Imhof, and Nagel proved that up to a linear transformation, the joint probability distributions of the ensembles become more and more concentrated around the zeros of the Laguerre and Jacobi polynomials, respectively. In this paper, we improve the conc… ▽ More We consider the asymptotic limits where certain parameters in the definitions of the Laguerre and Jacobi ensembles diverge. In these limits, Dette, Imhof, and Nagel proved that up to a linear transformation, the joint probability distributions of the ensembles become more and more concentrated around the zeros of the Laguerre and Jacobi polynomials, respectively. In this paper, we improve the concentration bounds. Our proofs are similar to those in the original references, but the error analysis is improved and arguably simpler. For the first and second moments of the Jacobi ensemble, we further improve the concentration bounds implied by our aforementioned results. △ Less

Submitted 28 November, 2023; v1 submitted 21 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 16 pages. v2: minor changes, close to published version

Report number: MIT-CTP/5469

Journal ref: SIAM Journal on Mathematical Analysis. Vol. 56, Iss. 1, pp. 554-567 (2024)

Thermalization without eigenstate thermalization

Authors: Aram W. Harrow, Yichen Huang

Abstract: In an isolated quantum many-body system undergoing unitary evolution, we study the thermalization of a subsystem, treating the rest of the system as a bath. In this setting, the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) was proposed to explain thermalization. Consider a nearly integrable Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model obtained by adding random all-to-all 4-body interactions as a perturbation to a random… ▽ More In an isolated quantum many-body system undergoing unitary evolution, we study the thermalization of a subsystem, treating the rest of the system as a bath. In this setting, the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) was proposed to explain thermalization. Consider a nearly integrable Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model obtained by adding random all-to-all 4-body interactions as a perturbation to a random free-fermion model. When the subsystem size is larger than the square root of but is still a vanishing fraction of the system size, we prove thermalization if the system is initialized in a random product state, while almost all eigenstates violate the ETH. In this sense, the ETH is not a necessary condition for thermalization. △ Less

Submitted 28 November, 2023; v1 submitted 20 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: 18 pages. v2: minor changes

Report number: MIT-CTP/5467

Maximal entanglement velocity implies dual unitarity

Authors: Tianci Zhou, Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: A global quantum quench can be modeled by a quantum circuit with local unitary gates. In general, entanglement grows linearly at a rate given by entanglement velocity, which is upper bounded by the growth of the light cone. We show that the unitary interactions achieving the maximal rate must remain unitary if we exchange the space and time directions -- a property known as dual unitarity. Our r… ▽ More A global quantum quench can be modeled by a quantum circuit with local unitary gates. In general, entanglement grows linearly at a rate given by entanglement velocity, which is upper bounded by the growth of the light cone. We show that the unitary interactions achieving the maximal rate must remain unitary if we exchange the space and time directions -- a property known as dual unitarity. Our results are robust: approximate maximal entanglement velocity also implies approximate dual unitarity. We further show that maximal entanglement velocity is always accompanied by a specific dynamical pattern of entanglement, which yields simpler analyses of several known exactly solvable models. △ Less

Submitted 21 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Comments: 13 pages, 7 figures

Report number: MIT-CTP/5368

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 106, L201104 (2022)

From communication complexity to an entanglement spread area law in the ground state of gapped local Hamiltonians

Authors: Anurag Anshu, Aram W. Harrow, Mehdi Soleimanifar

Abstract: In this work, we make a connection between two seemingly different problems. The first problem involves characterizing the properties of entanglement in the ground state of gapped local Hamiltonians, which is a central topic in quantum many-body physics. The second problem is on the quantum communication complexity of testing bipartite states with EPR assistance, a well-known question in quantum i… ▽ More In this work, we make a connection between two seemingly different problems. The first problem involves characterizing the properties of entanglement in the ground state of gapped local Hamiltonians, which is a central topic in quantum many-body physics. The second problem is on the quantum communication complexity of testing bipartite states with EPR assistance, a well-known question in quantum information theory. We construct a communication protocol for testing (or measuring) the ground state and use its communication complexity to reveal a new structural property for the ground state entanglement. This property, known as the entanglement spread, roughly measures the ratio between the largest and the smallest Schmidt coefficients across a cut in the ground state. Our main result shows that gapped ground states possess limited entanglement spread across any cut, exhibiting an "area law" behavior. Our result quite generally applies to any interaction graph with an improved bound for the special case of lattices. This entanglement spread area law includes interaction graphs constructed in [Aharonov et al., FOCS'14] that violate a generalized area law for the entanglement entropy. Our construction also provides evidence for a conjecture in physics by Li and Haldane on the entanglement spectrum of lattice Hamiltonians [Li and Haldane, PRL'08]. On the technical side, we use recent advances in Hamiltonian simulation algorithms along with quantum phase estimation to give a new construction for an approximate ground space projector (AGSP) over arbitrary interaction graphs. △ Less

Submitted 30 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Comments: 29 pages, 1 figure

Report number: MIT-CTP/5287

Journal ref: Nature Physics (2022)

Small quantum computers and large classical data sets

Authors: Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: We introduce hybrid classical-quantum algorithms for problems involving a large classical data set X and a space of models Y such that a quantum computer has superposition access to Y but not X. These algorithms use data reduction techniques to construct a weighted subset of X called a coreset that yields approximately the same loss for each model. The coreset can be constructed by the classical c… ▽ More We introduce hybrid classical-quantum algorithms for problems involving a large classical data set X and a space of models Y such that a quantum computer has superposition access to Y but not X. These algorithms use data reduction techniques to construct a weighted subset of X called a coreset that yields approximately the same loss for each model. The coreset can be constructed by the classical computer alone, or via an interactive protocol in which the outputs of the quantum computer are used to help decide which elements of X to use. By using the quantum computer to perform Grover search or rejection sampling, this yields quantum speedups for maximum likelihood estimation, Bayesian inference and saddle-point optimization. Concrete applications include k-means clustering, logistical regression, zero-sum games and boosting. △ Less

Submitted 31 March, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Comments: 25 pages

Report number: MIT-CTP/5189

Efficient classical simulation of random shallow 2D quantum circuits

Authors: John Napp, Rolando L. La Placa, Alexander M. Dalzell, Fernando G. S. L. Brandao, Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: Random quantum circuits are commonly viewed as hard to simulate classically. In some regimes this has been formally conjectured, and there had been no evidence against the more general possibility that for circuits with uniformly random gates, approximate simulation of typical instances is almost as hard as exact simulation. We prove that this is not the case by exhibiting a shallow circuit family… ▽ More Random quantum circuits are commonly viewed as hard to simulate classically. In some regimes this has been formally conjectured, and there had been no evidence against the more general possibility that for circuits with uniformly random gates, approximate simulation of typical instances is almost as hard as exact simulation. We prove that this is not the case by exhibiting a shallow circuit family with uniformly random gates that cannot be efficiently classically simulated near-exactly under standard hardness assumptions, but can be simulated approximately for all but a superpolynomially small fraction of circuit instances in time linear in the number of qubits and gates. We furthermore conjecture that sufficiently shallow random circuits are efficiently simulable more generally. To this end, we propose and analyze two simulation algorithms. Implementing one of our algorithms numerically, we give strong evidence that it is efficient both asymptotically and, in some cases, in practice. To argue analytically for efficiency, we reduce the simulation of 2D shallow random circuits to the simulation of a form of 1D dynamics consisting of alternating rounds of random local unitaries and weak measurements -- a type of process that has generally been observed to undergo a phase transition from an efficient-to-simulate regime to an inefficient-to-simulate regime as measurement strength is varied. Using a map** from quantum circuits to statistical mechanical models, we give evidence that a similar computational phase transition occurs for our algorithms as parameters of the circuit architecture like the local Hilbert space dimension and circuit depth are varied. △ Less

Submitted 9 March, 2020; v1 submitted 31 December, 2019; originally announced January 2020.

Comments: 83 pages, 17 figures. v2: minor fixes and clarifications, added a reference

Report number: MIT-CTP/5148

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. X 12, 021021 (2022)

Quantum Computing at the Frontiers of Biological Sciences

Authors: Prashant S. Emani, Jonathan Warrell, Alan Anticevic, Stefan Bekiranov, Michael Gandal, Michael J. McConnell, Guillermo Sapiro, Alán Aspuru-Guzik, Justin Baker, Matteo Bastiani, Patrick McClure, John Murray, Stamatios N Sotiropoulos, Jacob Taylor, Geetha Senthil, Thomas Lehner, Mark B. Gerstein, Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: The search for meaningful structure in biological data has relied on cutting-edge advances in computational technology and data science methods. However, challenges arise as we push the limits of scale and complexity in biological problems. Innovation in massively parallel, classical computing hardware and algorithms continues to address many of these challenges, but there is a need to simultaneou… ▽ More The search for meaningful structure in biological data has relied on cutting-edge advances in computational technology and data science methods. However, challenges arise as we push the limits of scale and complexity in biological problems. Innovation in massively parallel, classical computing hardware and algorithms continues to address many of these challenges, but there is a need to simultaneously consider new paradigms to circumvent current barriers to processing speed. Accordingly, we articulate a view towards quantum computation and quantum information science, where algorithms have demonstrated potential polynomial and exponential computational speedups in certain applications, such as machine learning. The maturation of the field of quantum computing, in hardware and algorithm development, also coincides with the growth of several collaborative efforts to address questions across length and time scales, and scientific disciplines. We use this coincidence to explore the potential for quantum computing to aid in one such endeavor: the merging of insights from genetics, genomics, neuroimaging and behavioral phenoty**. By examining joint opportunities for computational innovation across fields, we highlight the need for a common language between biological data analysis and quantum computing. Ultimately, we consider current and future prospects for the employment of quantum computing algorithms in the biological sciences. △ Less

Submitted 16 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Comments: 22 pages, 3 figures, Perspective

Journal ref: Nature Methods (2021)

Using Spectral Graph Theory to Map Qubits onto Connectivity-Limited Devices

Authors: Joseph X. Lin, Eric R. Anschuetz, Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: We propose an efficient heuristic for map** the logical qubits of quantum algorithms to the physical qubits of connectivity-limited devices, adding a minimal number of connectivity-compliant SWAP gates. In particular, given a quantum circuit, we construct an undirected graph with edge weights a function of the two-qubit gates of the quantum circuit. Taking inspiration from spectral graph drawing… ▽ More We propose an efficient heuristic for map** the logical qubits of quantum algorithms to the physical qubits of connectivity-limited devices, adding a minimal number of connectivity-compliant SWAP gates. In particular, given a quantum circuit, we construct an undirected graph with edge weights a function of the two-qubit gates of the quantum circuit. Taking inspiration from spectral graph drawing, we use an eigenvector of the graph Laplacian to place logical qubits at coordinate locations. These placements are then mapped to physical qubits for a given connectivity. We primarily focus on one-dimensional connectivities, and sketch how the general principles of our heuristic can be extended for use in more general connectivities. △ Less

Submitted 24 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Comments: 27 pages, 5 figures

Report number: MIT-CTP/5153

Journal ref: ACM Transactions on Quantum Computing 2, 1, Article 3 (February 2021)

Quantum Blackjack or Can MIT Bring Down the House Again?

Authors: Joseph X. Lin, Joseph A. Formaggio, Aram W. Harrow, Anand V. Natarajan

Abstract: We examine the advantages that quantum strategies afford in communication-limited games. Inspired by the card game blackjack, we focus on cooperative, two-party sequential games in which a single classical bit of communication is allowed from the player who moves first to the player who moves second. Within this setting, we explore the usage of quantum entanglement between the players and find ana… ▽ More We examine the advantages that quantum strategies afford in communication-limited games. Inspired by the card game blackjack, we focus on cooperative, two-party sequential games in which a single classical bit of communication is allowed from the player who moves first to the player who moves second. Within this setting, we explore the usage of quantum entanglement between the players and find analytic and numerical conditions for quantum advantage over classical strategies. Using these conditions, we study a family of blackjack-type games with varying numbers of card types, and find a range of parameters where quantum advantage is achieved. Furthermore, we give an explicit quantum circuit for the strategy achieving quantum advantage. △ Less

Submitted 25 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: 15 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 102, 012425 (2020)

Quantum Algorithms for Jet Clustering

Authors: Annie Y. Wei, Preksha Naik, Aram W. Harrow, Jesse Thaler

Abstract: Identifying jets formed in high-energy particle collisions requires solving optimization problems over potentially large numbers of final-state particles. In this work, we consider the possibility of using quantum computers to speed up jet clustering algorithms. Focusing on the case of electron-positron collisions, we consider a well-known event shape called thrust whose optimum corresponds to the… ▽ More Identifying jets formed in high-energy particle collisions requires solving optimization problems over potentially large numbers of final-state particles. In this work, we consider the possibility of using quantum computers to speed up jet clustering algorithms. Focusing on the case of electron-positron collisions, we consider a well-known event shape called thrust whose optimum corresponds to the most jet-like separating plane among a set of particles, thereby defining two hemisphere jets. We show how to formulate thrust both as a quantum annealing problem and as a Grover search problem. A key component of our analysis is the consideration of realistic models for interfacing classical data with a quantum algorithm. With a sequential computing model, we show how to speed up the well-known O(N^3) classical algorithm to an O(N^2) quantum algorithm, including the O(N) overhead of loading classical data from N final-state particles. Along the way, we also identify a way to speed up the classical algorithm to O(N^2 log N) using a sorting strategy inspired by the SISCone jet algorithm, which has no natural quantum counterpart. With a parallel computing model, we achieve O(N log N) scaling in both the classical and quantum cases. Finally, we consider the generalization of these quantum methods to other jet algorithms more closely related to those used for proton-proton collisions at the Large Hadron Collider. △ Less

Submitted 5 May, 2020; v1 submitted 23 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: 21 pages, 1 table, 6 figures. v2: correction to doubling trick and additional discussion of resource requirements; approximate version to appear in PRD

Report number: MIT-CTP 5137

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 101, 094015 (2020)

Instability of localization in translation-invariant systems

Authors: Yichen Huang, Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: The phenomenon of localization is usually accompanied with the presence of quenched disorder. To what extent disorder is necessary for localization is a well-known open problem. In this paper, we prove the instability of localization in translation-invariant systems. For any translation-invariant local Hamiltonian exhibiting either Anderson or many-body localization, an arbitrarily small translati… ▽ More The phenomenon of localization is usually accompanied with the presence of quenched disorder. To what extent disorder is necessary for localization is a well-known open problem. In this paper, we prove the instability of localization in translation-invariant systems. For any translation-invariant local Hamiltonian exhibiting either Anderson or many-body localization, an arbitrarily small translation-invariant random local perturbation almost surely leads to the following manifestations of delocalization: (i) Transport: For any (inhomogeneous) initial state, the spatial distribution of energy or any other local conserved quantity becomes uniform at late times. (ii) Scrambling: The out-of-time-ordered correlator of any traceless local operators decays to zero at late times. (iii) Thermalization: Random product states locally thermalize to the infinite temperature state with overwhelming probability. △ Less

Submitted 31 December, 2019; v1 submitted 31 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: v2 contains new results on the thermalization of random product states and a new author

Adaptive Quantum Simulated Annealing for Bayesian Inference and Estimating Partition Functions

Authors: Aram W. Harrow, Annie Y. Wei

Abstract: Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithms have important applications in counting problems and in machine learning problems, settings that involve estimating quantities that are difficult to compute exactly. How much can quantum computers speed up classical Markov chain algorithms? In this work we consider the problem of speeding up simulated annealing algorithms, where the stationary distributions of t… ▽ More Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithms have important applications in counting problems and in machine learning problems, settings that involve estimating quantities that are difficult to compute exactly. How much can quantum computers speed up classical Markov chain algorithms? In this work we consider the problem of speeding up simulated annealing algorithms, where the stationary distributions of the Markov chains are Gibbs distributions at temperatures specified according to an annealing schedule. We construct a quantum algorithm that both adaptively constructs an annealing schedule and quantum samples at each temperature. Our adaptive annealing schedule roughly matches the length of the best classical adaptive annealing schedules and improves on nonadaptive temperature schedules by roughly a quadratic factor. Our dependence on the Markov chain gap matches other quantum algorithms and is quadratically better than what classical Markov chains achieve. Our algorithm is the first to combine both of these quadratic improvements. Like other quantum walk algorithms, it also improves on classical algorithms by producing "qsamples" instead of classical samples. This means preparing quantum states whose amplitudes are the square roots of the target probability distribution. In constructing the annealing schedule we make use of amplitude estimation, and we introduce a method for making amplitude estimation nondestructive at almost no additional cost, a result that may have independent interest. Finally we demonstrate how this quantum simulated annealing algorithm can be applied to the problems of estimating partition functions and Bayesian inference. △ Less

Submitted 6 February, 2020; v1 submitted 23 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: 24 pages

Report number: MIT-CTP/5134

Journal ref: Proc. of SODA 2020

A Separation of Out-of-time-ordered Correlation and Entanglement

Authors: Aram W. Harrow, Linghang Kong, Zi-Wen Liu, Saeed Mehraban, Peter W. Shor

Abstract: The out-of-time-ordered correlation (OTOC) and entanglement are two physically motivated and widely used probes of the "scrambling" of quantum information, a phenomenon that has drawn great interest recently in quantum gravity and many-body physics. We argue that the corresponding notions of scrambling can be fundamentally different, by proving an asymptotic separation between the time scales of t… ▽ More The out-of-time-ordered correlation (OTOC) and entanglement are two physically motivated and widely used probes of the "scrambling" of quantum information, a phenomenon that has drawn great interest recently in quantum gravity and many-body physics. We argue that the corresponding notions of scrambling can be fundamentally different, by proving an asymptotic separation between the time scales of the saturation of OTOC and that of entanglement entropy in a random quantum circuit model defined on graphs with a tight bottleneck, such as tree graphs. Our result counters the intuition that a random quantum circuit mixes in time proportional to the diameter of the underlying graph of interactions. It also provides a more rigorous justification for an argument in our previous work arXiv:1807.04363, that black holes may be slow information scramblers, which in turn relates to the black hole information problem. The bounds we obtained for OTOC are interesting in their own right in that they generalize previous studies of OTOC on lattices to the geometries on graphs in a rigorous and general fashion. △ Less

Submitted 16 August, 2020; v1 submitted 5 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Comments: 6+8 pages

Journal ref: PRX Quantum 2, 020339 (2021)

Universality of EPR pairs in Entanglement-Assisted Communication Complexity, and the Communication Cost of State Conversion

Authors: Matthew Coudron, Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: Entanglement assistance is known to reduce the quantum communication complexity of evaluating functions with distributed inputs. But does the type of entanglement matter, or are EPR pairs always sufficient? This is a natural question because in several other settings maximally entangled states are known to be less useful as a resource than some partially entangled state. These include non-local ga… ▽ More Entanglement assistance is known to reduce the quantum communication complexity of evaluating functions with distributed inputs. But does the type of entanglement matter, or are EPR pairs always sufficient? This is a natural question because in several other settings maximally entangled states are known to be less useful as a resource than some partially entangled state. These include non-local games, tasks with quantum communication between players and referee, and simulating bipartite unitaries or communication channels. By contrast, we prove that the bounded-error entanglement-assisted quantum communication complexity of a function cannot be improved by more than a constant factor by replacing maximally entangled states with arbitrary entangled states. In particular, we show that every quantum communication protocol using $Q$ qubits of communication and arbitrary shared entanglement can be $ε$-approximated by a protocol using $O(Q/ε+\log(1/ε)/ε)$ qubits of communication and only EPR pairs as shared entanglement. Our second result concerns an old question in quantum information theory: How much quantum communication is required to approximately convert one pure bipartite entangled state into another? We show that the communication cost of converting between two bipartite quantum states is upper bounded, up to a constant multiplicative factor, by a natural and efficiently computable quantity which we call the $\ell_{\infty}$-Earth Mover's Distance (EMD) between those two states. Furthermore, we prove a complementary lower bound on the cost of state conversion by the $ε$-smoothed $\ell_{\infty}$-EMD, which is a natural smoothing of the $\ell_{\infty}$-EMD that we will define via a connection with optimal transport theory. △ Less

Submitted 20 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Journal ref: 34th Computational Complexity Conference (CCC 2019), pp. 20:1--20:25

Rapid mixing of path integral Monte Carlo for 1D stoquastic Hamiltonians

Authors: Elizabeth Crosson, Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: Path integral quantum Monte Carlo (PIMC) is a method for estimating thermal equilibrium properties of stoquastic quantum spin systems by sampling from a classical Gibbs distribution using Markov chain Monte Carlo. The PIMC method has been widely used to study the physics of materials and for simulated quantum annealing, but these successful applications are rarely accompanied by formal proofs that… ▽ More Path integral quantum Monte Carlo (PIMC) is a method for estimating thermal equilibrium properties of stoquastic quantum spin systems by sampling from a classical Gibbs distribution using Markov chain Monte Carlo. The PIMC method has been widely used to study the physics of materials and for simulated quantum annealing, but these successful applications are rarely accompanied by formal proofs that the Markov chains underlying PIMC rapidly converge to the desired equilibrium distribution. In this work we analyze the mixing time of PIMC for 1D stoquastic Hamiltonians, including disordered transverse Ising models (TIM) with long-range algebraically decaying interactions as well as disordered XY spin chains with nearest-neighbor interactions. By bounding the convergence time to the equilibrium distribution we rigorously justify the use of PIMC to approximate partition functions and expectations of observables for these models at inverse temperatures that scale at most logarithmically with the number of qubits. The mixing time analysis is based on the canonical paths method applied to the single-site Metropolis Markov chain for the Gibbs distribution of 2D classical spin models with couplings related to the interactions in the quantum Hamiltonian. Since the system has strongly nonisotropic couplings that grow with system size, it does not fall into the known cases where 2D classical spin models are known to mix rapidly. △ Less

Submitted 5 February, 2021; v1 submitted 5 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Comments: 26 pages, 2 figures, version published in Quantum

Report number: MIT-CTP/5286

Journal ref: Quantum 5, 395 (2021)

Quantum Computational Supremacy

Authors: Aram W Harrow, Ashley Montanaro

Abstract: The field of quantum algorithms aims to find ways to speed up the solution of computational problems by using a quantum computer. A key milestone in this field will be when a universal quantum computer performs a computational task that is beyond the capability of any classical computer, an event known as quantum supremacy. This would be easier to achieve experimentally than full-scale quantum com… ▽ More The field of quantum algorithms aims to find ways to speed up the solution of computational problems by using a quantum computer. A key milestone in this field will be when a universal quantum computer performs a computational task that is beyond the capability of any classical computer, an event known as quantum supremacy. This would be easier to achieve experimentally than full-scale quantum computing, but involves new theoretical challenges. Here we present the leading proposals to achieve quantum supremacy, and discuss how we can reliably compare the power of a classical computer to the power of a quantum computer. △ Less

Submitted 19 September, 2018; originally announced September 2018.

Comments: review article originally appearing in a Nature Insight collection on "Quantum Software". 15 pages

Journal ref: Nature volume 549, pages 203-209 (14 September 2017)

How many qubits are needed for quantum computational supremacy?

Authors: Alexander M. Dalzell, Aram W. Harrow, Dax Enshan Koh, Rolando L. La Placa

Abstract: Quantum computational supremacy arguments, which describe a way for a quantum computer to perform a task that cannot also be done by a classical computer, typically require some sort of computational assumption related to the limitations of classical computation. One common assumption is that the polynomial hierarchy (PH) does not collapse, a stronger version of the statement that P $\neq$ NP, whi… ▽ More Quantum computational supremacy arguments, which describe a way for a quantum computer to perform a task that cannot also be done by a classical computer, typically require some sort of computational assumption related to the limitations of classical computation. One common assumption is that the polynomial hierarchy (PH) does not collapse, a stronger version of the statement that P $\neq$ NP, which leads to the conclusion that any classical simulation of certain families of quantum circuits requires time scaling worse than any polynomial in the size of the circuits. However, the asymptotic nature of this conclusion prevents us from calculating exactly how many qubits these quantum circuits must have for their classical simulation to be intractable on modern classical supercomputers. We refine these quantum computational supremacy arguments and perform such a calculation by imposing fine-grained versions of the non-collapse assumption. Each version is parameterized by a constant $a$ and asserts that certain specific computational problems with input size $n$ require $2^{an}$ time steps to be solved by a non-deterministic algorithm. Then, we choose a specific value of $a$ for each version that we argue makes the assumption plausible, and based on these conjectures we conclude that Instantaneous Quantum Polynomial-Time (IQP) circuits with 208 qubits, Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) circuits with 420 qubits and boson sampling circuits (i.e. linear optical networks) with 98 photons are large enough for the task of producing samples from their output distributions up to constant multiplicative error to be intractable on current technology. In the first two cases, we extend this to constant additive error by introducing an average-case fine-grained conjecture. △ Less

Submitted 30 April, 2020; v1 submitted 14 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.

Comments: 24 pages + 3 appendices, 8 figures. v2: number of qubits calculation updated and conjectures clarified after becoming aware of Ref. [42]. v3: Section IV and Appendix C added to incorporate additive-error simulations

Report number: MIT-CTP/5019

Journal ref: Quantum 4, 264 (2020)

Supervised learning with quantum enhanced feature spaces

Authors: Vojtech Havlicek, Antonio D. Córcoles, Kristan Temme, Aram W. Harrow, Abhinav Kandala, Jerry M. Chow, Jay M. Gambetta

Abstract: Machine learning and quantum computing are two technologies each with the potential for altering how computation is performed to address previously untenable problems. Kernel methods for machine learning are ubiquitous for pattern recognition, with support vector machines (SVMs) being the most well-known method for classification problems. However, there are limitations to the successful solution… ▽ More Machine learning and quantum computing are two technologies each with the potential for altering how computation is performed to address previously untenable problems. Kernel methods for machine learning are ubiquitous for pattern recognition, with support vector machines (SVMs) being the most well-known method for classification problems. However, there are limitations to the successful solution to such problems when the feature space becomes large, and the kernel functions become computationally expensive to estimate. A core element to computational speed-ups afforded by quantum algorithms is the exploitation of an exponentially large quantum state space through controllable entanglement and interference. Here, we propose and experimentally implement two novel methods on a superconducting processor. Both methods represent the feature space of a classification problem by a quantum state, taking advantage of the large dimensionality of quantum Hilbert space to obtain an enhanced solution. One method, the quantum variational classifier builds on [1,2] and operates through using a variational quantum circuit to classify a training set in direct analogy to conventional SVMs. In the second, a quantum kernel estimator, we estimate the kernel function and optimize the classifier directly. The two methods present a new class of tools for exploring the applications of noisy intermediate scale quantum computers [3] to machine learning. △ Less

Submitted 5 June, 2018; v1 submitted 30 April, 2018; originally announced April 2018.

Comments: Fixed typos, added figures and discussion about quantum error mitigation

Journal ref: Nature. vol. 567, pp. 209-212 (2019)

Algorithms, Bounds, and Strategies for Entangled XOR Games

Authors: Adam Bene Watts, Aram W. Harrow, Gurtej Kanwar, Anand Natarajan

Abstract: We study the complexity of computing the commuting-operator value $ω^*$ of entangled XOR games with any number of players. We introduce necessary and sufficient criteria for an XOR game to have $ω^* = 1$, and use these criteria to derive the following results: 1. An algorithm for symmetric games that decides in polynomial time whether $ω^* = 1$ or $ω^* < 1$, a task that was not previously known… ▽ More We study the complexity of computing the commuting-operator value $ω^*$ of entangled XOR games with any number of players. We introduce necessary and sufficient criteria for an XOR game to have $ω^* = 1$, and use these criteria to derive the following results: 1. An algorithm for symmetric games that decides in polynomial time whether $ω^* = 1$ or $ω^* < 1$, a task that was not previously known to be decidable, together with a simple tensor-product strategy that achieves value 1 in the former case. The only previous candidate algorithm for this problem was the Navascués-Pironio-Acín (also known as noncommutative Sum of Squares or ncSoS) hierarchy, but no convergence bounds were known. 2. A family of games with three players and with $ω^* < 1$, where it takes doubly exponential time for the ncSoS algorithm to witness this (in contrast with our algorithm which runs in polynomial time). 3. A family of games achieving a bias difference $2(ω^* - ω)$ arbitrarily close to the maximum possible value of $1$ (and as a consequence, achieving an unbounded bias ratio), answering an open question of Briët and Vidick. 4. Existence of an unsatisfiable phase for random (non-symmetric) XOR games: that is, we show that there exists a constant $C_k^{\text{unsat}}$ depending only on the number $k$ of players, such that a random $k$-XOR game over an alphabet of size $n$ has $ω^* < 1$ with high probability when the number of clauses is above $C_k^{\text{unsat}} n$. 5. A lower bound of $Ω(n \log(n)/\log\log(n))$ on the number of levels in the ncSoS hierarchy required to detect unsatisfiability for most random 3-XOR games. This is in contrast with the classical case where the $n$-th level of the sum-of-squares hierarchy is equivalent to brute-force enumeration of all possible solutions. △ Less

Submitted 2 January, 2018; originally announced January 2018.

Comments: 55 pages

Report number: MIT-CTP/4976

Journal ref: Proc. ITCS 2019, pp 10:1-10:18

Limitations of semidefinite programs for separable states and entangled games

Authors: Aram W. Harrow, Anand Natarajan, Xiaodi Wu

Abstract: Semidefinite programs (SDPs) are a framework for exact or approximate optimization that have widespread application in quantum information theory. We introduce a new method for using reductions to construct integrality gaps for SDPs. These are based on new limitations on the sum-of-squares (SoS) hierarchy in approximating two particularly important sets in quantum information theory, where previou… ▽ More Semidefinite programs (SDPs) are a framework for exact or approximate optimization that have widespread application in quantum information theory. We introduce a new method for using reductions to construct integrality gaps for SDPs. These are based on new limitations on the sum-of-squares (SoS) hierarchy in approximating two particularly important sets in quantum information theory, where previously no $ω(1)$-round integrality gaps were known: the set of separable (i.e. unentangled) states, or equivalently, the $2 \rightarrow 4$ norm of a matrix, and the set of quantum correlations; i.e. conditional probability distributions achievable with local measurements on a shared entangled state. In both cases no-go theorems were previously known based on computational assumptions such as the Exponential Time Hypothesis (ETH) which asserts that 3-SAT requires exponential time to solve. Our unconditional results achieve the same parameters as all of these previous results (for separable states) or as some of the previous results (for quantum correlations). In some cases we can make use of the framework of Lee-Raghavendra-Steurer (LRS) to establish integrality gaps for any SDP, not only the SoS hierarchy. Our hardness result on separable states also yields a dimension lower bound of approximate disentanglers, answering a question of Watrous and Aaronson et al. These results can be viewed as limitations on the monogamy principle, the PPT test, the ability of Tsirelson-type bounds to restrict quantum correlations, as well as the SDP hierarchies of Doherty-Parrilo-Spedalieri, Navascues-Pironio-Acin and Berta-Fawzi-Scholz. △ Less

Submitted 23 October, 2018; v1 submitted 29 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: 47 pages. v2. small changes, fixes and clarifications. published version

Journal ref: Commun. Math. Phys., Vol. 366, No. 2, pp 423-468 (2019)

Sequential measurements, disturbance and property testing

Authors: Aram W. Harrow, Cedric Yen-Yu Lin, Ashley Montanaro

Abstract: We describe two procedures which, given access to one copy of a quantum state and a sequence of two-outcome measurements, can distinguish between the case that at least one of the measurements accepts the state with high probability, and the case that all of the measurements have low probability of acceptance. The measurements cannot simply be tried in sequence, because early measurements may dist… ▽ More We describe two procedures which, given access to one copy of a quantum state and a sequence of two-outcome measurements, can distinguish between the case that at least one of the measurements accepts the state with high probability, and the case that all of the measurements have low probability of acceptance. The measurements cannot simply be tried in sequence, because early measurements may disturb the state being tested. One procedure is based on a variant of Marriott-Watrous amplification. The other procedure is based on the use of a test for this disturbance, which is applied with low probability. We find a number of applications. First, quantum query complexity separations in the property testing model for testing isomorphism of functions under group actions. We give quantum algorithms for testing isomorphism, linear isomorphism and affine isomorphism of boolean functions which use exponentially fewer queries than is possible classically, and a quantum algorithm for testing graph isomorphism which uses polynomially fewer queries than the best algorithm known. Second, testing properties of quantum states and operations. We show that any finite property of quantum states can be tested using a number of copies of the state which is logarithmic in the size of the property, and give a test for genuine multipartite entanglement of states of n qubits that uses O(n) copies of the state. Third, correcting an error in a result of Aaronson on de-Merlinizing quantum protocols. This result claimed that, in any one-way quantum communication protocol where two parties are assisted by an all-powerful but untrusted third party, the third party can be removed with only a modest increase in the communication cost. We give a corrected proof of a key technical lemma required for Aaronson's result. △ Less

Submitted 21 October, 2016; v1 submitted 12 July, 2016; originally announced July 2016.

Comments: 21 pages; v2: new author, alternative algorithm, improved results; v3: minor changes to presentation

Report number: MIT-CTP-4847

Journal ref: Proc. SODA 2017, pp. 1598-1611

Efficient Quantum Pseudorandomness

Authors: Fernando G. S. L. Brandao, Aram W. Harrow, Michal Horodecki

Abstract: Randomness is both a useful way to model natural systems and a useful tool for engineered systems, e.g. in computation, communication and control. Fully random transformations require exponential time for either classical or quantum systems, but in many case pseudorandom operations can emulate certain properties of truly random ones. Indeed in the classical realm there is by now a well-developed t… ▽ More Randomness is both a useful way to model natural systems and a useful tool for engineered systems, e.g. in computation, communication and control. Fully random transformations require exponential time for either classical or quantum systems, but in many case pseudorandom operations can emulate certain properties of truly random ones. Indeed in the classical realm there is by now a well-developed theory of such pseudorandom operations. However the construction of such objects turns out to be much harder in the quantum case. Here we show that random quantum circuits are a powerful source of quantum pseudorandomness. This gives the for the first time a polynomialtime construction of quantum unitary designs, which can replace fully random operations in most applications, and shows that generic quantum dynamics cannot be distinguished from truly random processes. We discuss applications of our result to quantum information science, cryptography and to understanding self-equilibration of closed quantum dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 2 May, 2016; originally announced May 2016.

Comments: 6 pages, 1 figure. Short version of http://arxiv.longhoe.net/abs/1208.0692

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 170502 (2016)

The Mathematics of Entanglement

Authors: Fernando G. S. L. Brandao, Matthias Christandl, Aram W. Harrow, Michael Walter

Abstract: These notes are from a series of lectures given at the Universidad de Los Andes in Bogotá, Colombia on some topics of current interest in quantum information. While they aim to be self-contained, they are necessarily incomplete and idiosyncratic in their coverage. For a more thorough introduction to the subject, we recommend one of the textbooks by Nielsen and Chuang or by Wilde, or the lecture no… ▽ More These notes are from a series of lectures given at the Universidad de Los Andes in Bogotá, Colombia on some topics of current interest in quantum information. While they aim to be self-contained, they are necessarily incomplete and idiosyncratic in their coverage. For a more thorough introduction to the subject, we recommend one of the textbooks by Nielsen and Chuang or by Wilde, or the lecture notes of Mermin, Preskill or Watrous. Our notes by contrast are meant to be a relatively rapid introduction into some more contemporary topics in this fast-moving field. They are meant to be accessible to advanced undergraduates or starting graduate students. △ Less

Submitted 6 April, 2016; originally announced April 2016.

Comments: Lecture notes for the 5th Summer School on Mathematical Physics at the Universidad de Los Andes, Bogotá, Colombia http://matematicas.uniandes.edu.co/~cursillo_gr/escuela2013/index_en.php

Universal Refocusing of Systematic Quantum Noise

Authors: Imdad S. B. Sardharwalla, Toby S. Cubitt, Aram W. Harrow, Noah Linden

Abstract: Refocusing of a quantum system in NMR and quantum information processing can be achieved by application of short pulses according to the methods of spin echo and dynamical decoupling. However, these methods are strongly limited by the requirement that the evolution of the system between pulses be suitably small. Here we show how refocusing may be achieved for arbitrary (but time-independent) evolu… ▽ More Refocusing of a quantum system in NMR and quantum information processing can be achieved by application of short pulses according to the methods of spin echo and dynamical decoupling. However, these methods are strongly limited by the requirement that the evolution of the system between pulses be suitably small. Here we show how refocusing may be achieved for arbitrary (but time-independent) evolution of the system between pulses. We first illustrate the procedure with one-qubit systems, and then generalize to $d$-dimensional quantum systems. We also give an application of this result to quantum computation, proving a new version of the Solovay-Kitaev theorem that does not require inverse gates. △ Less

Submitted 25 February, 2016; originally announced February 2016.

Report number: MIT/CTP-4772

Quantum Supremacy through the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm

Authors: Edward Farhi, Aram W Harrow

Abstract: The Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) is designed to run on a gate model quantum computer and has shallow depth. It takes as input a combinatorial optimization problem and outputs a string that satisfies a high fraction of the maximum number of clauses that can be satisfied. For certain problems the lowest depth version of the QAOA has provable performance guarantees although there… ▽ More The Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) is designed to run on a gate model quantum computer and has shallow depth. It takes as input a combinatorial optimization problem and outputs a string that satisfies a high fraction of the maximum number of clauses that can be satisfied. For certain problems the lowest depth version of the QAOA has provable performance guarantees although there exist classical algorithms that have better guarantees. Here we argue that beyond its possible computational value the QAOA can exhibit a form of Quantum Supremacy in that, based on reasonable complexity theoretic assumptions, the output distribution of even the lowest depth version cannot be efficiently simulated on any classical device. We contrast this with the case of sampling from the output of a quantum computer running the Quantum Adiabatic Algorithm (QADI) with the restriction that the Hamiltonian that governs the evolution is gapped and stoquastic. Here we show that there is an oracle that would allow sampling from the QADI but even with this oracle, if one could efficiently classically sample from the output of the QAOA, the Polynomial Hierarchy would collapse. This suggests that the QAOA is an excellent candidate to run on near term quantum computers not only because it may be of use for optimization but also because of its potential as a route to establishing quantum supremacy. △ Less

Submitted 20 October, 2019; v1 submitted 24 February, 2016; originally announced February 2016.

Comments: 23 pages. v2 fixes bug in section 4. Results unchanged

Report number: MIT/CTP-4771

Simulated Quantum Annealing Can Be Exponentially Faster than Classical Simulated Annealing

Authors: Elizabeth Crosson, Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: Simulated Quantum Annealing (SQA) is a Markov Chain Monte-Carlo algorithm that samples the equilibrium thermal state of a Quantum Annealing (QA) Hamiltonian. In addition to simulating quantum systems, SQA has also been proposed as another physics-inspired classical algorithm for combinatorial optimization, alongside classical simulated annealing. However, in many cases it remains an open challenge… ▽ More Simulated Quantum Annealing (SQA) is a Markov Chain Monte-Carlo algorithm that samples the equilibrium thermal state of a Quantum Annealing (QA) Hamiltonian. In addition to simulating quantum systems, SQA has also been proposed as another physics-inspired classical algorithm for combinatorial optimization, alongside classical simulated annealing. However, in many cases it remains an open challenge to determine the performance of both QA and SQA. One piece of evidence for the strength of QA over classical simulated annealing comes from an example by Farhi, Goldstone and Gutmann . There a bit-symmetric cost function with a thin, high energy barrier was designed to show an exponential seperation between classical simulated annealing, for which thermal fluctuations take exponential time to climb the barrier, and quantum annealing which passes through the barrier and reaches the global minimum in poly time, arguably by taking advantage of quantum tunneling. In this work we apply a comparison method to rigorously show that the Markov chain underlying SQA efficiently samples the target distribution and finds the global minimum of this spike cost function in polynomial time. Our work provides evidence for the growing consensus that SQA inherits at least some of the advantages of tunneling in QA, and so QA is unlikely to achieve exponential speedups over classical computing solely by the use of quantum tunneling. Since we analyze only a particular model this evidence is not decisive. However, techniques applied here---including warm starts from the adiabatic path and the use of the quantum ground state probability distribution to understand the stationary distribution of SQA---may be valuable for future studies of the performance of SQA on cost functions for which QA is efficient. △ Less

Submitted 23 June, 2016; v1 submitted 12 January, 2016; originally announced January 2016.

Comments: 21 pages, revised analysis includes worldline updates and spikes with polynomial width

Report number: MIT-CTP/4760

Journal ref: Proc of FOCS 2016, pp. 714-723

Random and free observables saturate the Tsirelson bound for CHSH inequality

Authors: Z. Yin, A. W. Harrow, M. Horodecki, M. Marciniak, A. Rutkowski

Abstract: Maximal violation of the CHSH-Bell inequality is usually said to be a feature of anticommuting observables. In this work we show that even random observables exhibit near-maximal violations of the CHSH-Bell inequality. To do this, we use the tools of free probability theory to analyze the commutators of large random matrices. Along the way, we introduce the notion of "free observables" which can b… ▽ More Maximal violation of the CHSH-Bell inequality is usually said to be a feature of anticommuting observables. In this work we show that even random observables exhibit near-maximal violations of the CHSH-Bell inequality. To do this, we use the tools of free probability theory to analyze the commutators of large random matrices. Along the way, we introduce the notion of "free observables" which can be thought of as infinite-dimensional operators that reproduce the statistics of random matrices as their dimension tends towards infinity. We also study the fine-grained uncertainty of a sequence of free or random observables, and use this to construct a steering inequality with a large violation. △ Less

Submitted 2 March, 2017; v1 submitted 1 December, 2015; originally announced December 2015.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 95, 032101 (2017)

Local Hamiltonians Whose Ground States are Hard to Approximate

Authors: Lior Eldar, Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: Ground states of local Hamiltonians can be generally highly entangled: any quantum circuit that generates them (even approximately) must be sufficiently deep to allow coupling (entanglement) between any pair of qubits. Until now this property was not known to be "robust" - the marginals of such states to a subset of the qubits containing all but a small constant fraction of them may be only locall… ▽ More Ground states of local Hamiltonians can be generally highly entangled: any quantum circuit that generates them (even approximately) must be sufficiently deep to allow coupling (entanglement) between any pair of qubits. Until now this property was not known to be "robust" - the marginals of such states to a subset of the qubits containing all but a small constant fraction of them may be only locally entangled, and hence approximable by shallow quantum circuits. In this work we construct a family of 16-local Hamiltonians for which any 1-10^{-9} fraction of qubits of any ground state must be highly entangled. This provides evidence that quantum entanglement is not very fragile, and perhaps our intuition about its instability is an artifact of considering local Hamiltonians which are not only local but spatially local. Formally, it provides positive evidence for two wide-open conjectures in condensed-matter physics and quantum complexity theory which are the qLDPC conjecture, positing the existence of "good" quantum LDPC codes, and the NLTS conjecture due to Freedman and Hastings positing the existence of local Hamiltonians in which any low-energy state is highly-entangled. Our Hamiltonian is based on applying the hypergraph product by Tillich and Zemor to a classical locally testable code. A key tool in our proof is a new lower bound on the vertex expansion of the output of low-depth quantum circuits, which may be of independent interest. △ Less

Submitted 21 November, 2016; v1 submitted 7 October, 2015; originally announced October 2015.

Comments: v3: 41 pages. Main result changed from NLTS to a different theorem which we call NLETS, due to a bug in the corresponding theorem of the previous version. The construction and techniques are the same, with some additions

Report number: MIT-CTP/4722

Journal ref: FOCS 2017, pp. 427-438

Estimating operator norms using covering nets

Authors: Fernando G. S. L. Brandao, Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: We present several polynomial- and quasipolynomial-time approximation schemes for a large class of generalized operator norms. Special cases include the $2\rightarrow q$ norm of matrices for $q>2$, the support function of the set of separable quantum states, finding the least noisy output of entanglement-breaking quantum channels, and approximating the injective tensor norm for a map between two B… ▽ More We present several polynomial- and quasipolynomial-time approximation schemes for a large class of generalized operator norms. Special cases include the $2\rightarrow q$ norm of matrices for $q>2$, the support function of the set of separable quantum states, finding the least noisy output of entanglement-breaking quantum channels, and approximating the injective tensor norm for a map between two Banach spaces whose factorization norm through $\ell_1^n$ is bounded. These reproduce and in some cases improve upon the performance of previous algorithms by Brandão-Christandl-Yard and followup work, which were based on the Sum-of-Squares hierarchy and whose analysis used techniques from quantum information such as the monogamy principle of entanglement. Our algorithms, by contrast, are based on brute force enumeration over carefully chosen covering nets. These have the advantage of using less memory, having much simpler proofs and giving new geometric insights into the problem. Net-based algorithms for similar problems were also presented by Shi-Wu and Barak-Kelner-Steurer, but in each case with a run-time that is exponential in the rank of some matrix. We achieve polynomial or quasipolynomial runtimes by using the much smaller nets that exist in $\ell_1$ spaces. This principle has been used in learning theory, where it is known as Maurey's empirical method. △ Less

Submitted 16 September, 2015; originally announced September 2015.

Comments: 24 pages

Sample-optimal tomography of quantum states

Authors: Jeongwan Haah, Aram W. Harrow, Zhengfeng Ji, Xiaodi Wu, Nengkun Yu

Abstract: It is a fundamental problem to decide how many copies of an unknown mixed quantum state are necessary and sufficient to determine the state. Previously, it was known only that estimating states to error $ε$ in trace distance required $O(dr^2/ε^2)$ copies for a $d$-dimensional density matrix of rank $r$. Here, we give a theoretical measurement scheme (POVM) that requires $O (dr/ δ) \ln (d/δ) $ copi… ▽ More It is a fundamental problem to decide how many copies of an unknown mixed quantum state are necessary and sufficient to determine the state. Previously, it was known only that estimating states to error $ε$ in trace distance required $O(dr^2/ε^2)$ copies for a $d$-dimensional density matrix of rank $r$. Here, we give a theoretical measurement scheme (POVM) that requires $O (dr/ δ) \ln (d/δ) $ copies of $ρ$ to error $δ$ in infidelity, and a matching lower bound up to logarithmic factors. This implies $O( (dr / ε^2) \ln (d/ε) )$ copies suffice to achieve error $ε$ in trace distance. We also prove that for independent (product) measurements, $Ω(dr^2/δ^2) / \ln(1/δ)$ copies are necessary in order to achieve error $δ$ in infidelity. For fixed $d$, our measurement can be implemented on a quantum computer in time polynomial in $n$. △ Less

Submitted 24 January, 2017; v1 submitted 7 August, 2015; originally announced August 2015.

Comments: revtex, 16 pages, 3 figures. (v1) in STOC 2016, 913-925. (v2) improved lower bound for independent measurements

Report number: MIT-CTP/4699

Journal ref: IEEE Transactions on Information Theory 63(9), 5628-5641 (2017)

Extremal eigenvalues of local Hamiltonians

Authors: Aram W. Harrow, Ashley Montanaro

Abstract: We apply classical algorithms for approximately solving constraint satisfaction problems to find bounds on extremal eigenvalues of local Hamiltonians. We consider spin Hamiltonians for which we have an upper bound on the number of terms in which each spin participates, and find extensive bounds for the operator norm and ground-state energy of such Hamiltonians under this constraint. In each case t… ▽ More We apply classical algorithms for approximately solving constraint satisfaction problems to find bounds on extremal eigenvalues of local Hamiltonians. We consider spin Hamiltonians for which we have an upper bound on the number of terms in which each spin participates, and find extensive bounds for the operator norm and ground-state energy of such Hamiltonians under this constraint. In each case the bound is achieved by a product state which can be found efficiently using a classical algorithm. △ Less

Submitted 21 April, 2017; v1 submitted 2 July, 2015; originally announced July 2015.

Comments: 5 pages; v4: uses standard journal style

Journal ref: Quantum 1, 6 (2017)

Strengthened Monotonicity of Relative Entropy via Pinched Petz Recovery Map

Authors: David Sutter, Marco Tomamichel, Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: The quantum relative entropy between two states satisfies a monotonicity property meaning that applying the same quantum channel to both states can never increase their relative entropy. It is known that this inequality is only tight when there is a "recovery map" that exactly reverses the effects of the quantum channel on both states. In this paper we strengthen this inequality by showing that th… ▽ More The quantum relative entropy between two states satisfies a monotonicity property meaning that applying the same quantum channel to both states can never increase their relative entropy. It is known that this inequality is only tight when there is a "recovery map" that exactly reverses the effects of the quantum channel on both states. In this paper we strengthen this inequality by showing that the difference of relative entropies is bounded below by the measured relative entropy between the first state and a recovered state from its processed version. The recovery map is a convex combination of rotated Petz recovery maps and perfectly reverses the quantum channel on the second state. As a special case we reproduce recent lower bounds on the conditional mutual information such as the one proved in [Fawzi and Renner, Commun. Math. Phys., 2015]. Our proof only relies on elementary properties of pinching maps and the operator logarithm. △ Less

Submitted 29 March, 2016; v1 submitted 1 July, 2015; originally announced July 2015.

Comments: v3: minor changes, published version. v2: 11 pages, proof of the main result simplified (see Lemma 3.12), setting generalized, new upper bound added (see Proposition 3.8)

Journal ref: IEEE Transactions on Information Theory, vol. 62, no. 5, pages 2907-2913, 2016

An improved semidefinite programming hierarchy for testing entanglement

Authors: Aram W. Harrow, Anand Natarajan, Xiaodi Wu

Abstract: We present a stronger version of the Doherty-Parrilo-Spedalieri (DPS) hierarchy of approximations for the set of separable states. Unlike DPS, our hierarchy converges exactly at a finite number of rounds for any fixed input dimension. This yields an algorithm for separability testing which is singly exponential in dimension and polylogarithmic in accuracy. Our analysis makes use of tools from alge… ▽ More We present a stronger version of the Doherty-Parrilo-Spedalieri (DPS) hierarchy of approximations for the set of separable states. Unlike DPS, our hierarchy converges exactly at a finite number of rounds for any fixed input dimension. This yields an algorithm for separability testing which is singly exponential in dimension and polylogarithmic in accuracy. Our analysis makes use of tools from algebraic geometry, but our algorithm is elementary and differs from DPS only by one simple additional collection of constraints. △ Less

Submitted 15 June, 2017; v1 submitted 29 June, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Comments: 22 pages. v2: published version, adds numerical results. Matlab code available at https://github.com/isobovine/dpsplus/

Report number: MIT-CTP/4587

Journal ref: Commun. Math. Phys. Vol. 352, No. 3, pp 881-904 (2017)

Why now is the right time to study quantum computing

Authors: Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: Quantum computing is a good way to justify difficult physics experiments. But until quantum computers are built, do computer scientists need to know anything about quantum information? In fact, quantum computing is not merely a recipe for new computing devices, but a new way of looking at the world that has been astonishingly intellectually productive. In this article, I'll talk about where quantu… ▽ More Quantum computing is a good way to justify difficult physics experiments. But until quantum computers are built, do computer scientists need to know anything about quantum information? In fact, quantum computing is not merely a recipe for new computing devices, but a new way of looking at the world that has been astonishingly intellectually productive. In this article, I'll talk about where quantum computing came from, what it is, and what we can learn from it. △ Less

Submitted 30 December, 2014; originally announced January 2015.

Comments: 6 pages, written to explain quantum computing to computer science undergrads

Journal ref: ACM XRDS: vol. 18, no. 3, pp. 32-37, Spring 2012

Review of Quantum Algorithms for Systems of Linear Equations

Authors: Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: This article reviews the 2008 quantum algorithm for linear systems of equations due to Harrow, Hassidim and Lloyd, as well as some of the followup and related work. It was submitted to the Springer Encyclopedia of Algorithms. This article reviews the 2008 quantum algorithm for linear systems of equations due to Harrow, Hassidim and Lloyd, as well as some of the followup and related work. It was submitted to the Springer Encyclopedia of Algorithms. △ Less

Submitted 30 December, 2014; originally announced January 2015.

Comments: 3 pages

Journal ref: Encyclopedia of Algorithms, pp. 1680-1683. Springer New York, 2016

Compressibility of positive semidefinite factorizations and quantum models

Authors: Cyril J. Stark, Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: We investigate compressibility of the dimension of positive semidefinite matrices while approximately preserving their pairwise inner products. This can either be regarded as compression of positive semidefinite factorizations of nonnegative matrices or (if the matrices are subject to additional normalization constraints) as compression of quantum models. We derive both lower and upper bounds on c… ▽ More We investigate compressibility of the dimension of positive semidefinite matrices while approximately preserving their pairwise inner products. This can either be regarded as compression of positive semidefinite factorizations of nonnegative matrices or (if the matrices are subject to additional normalization constraints) as compression of quantum models. We derive both lower and upper bounds on compressibility. Applications are broad and range from the statistical analysis of experimental data to bounding the one-way quantum communication complexity of Boolean functions. △ Less

Submitted 23 December, 2014; originally announced December 2014.

Comments: 13 pages

Report number: MIT-CTP 4619

Journal ref: IEEE Trans. Inf. Th., vol 62, no 5, pp 2867 - 2880, May 2016

Quantum Conditional Mutual Information, Reconstructed States, and State Redistribution

Authors: Fernando G. S. L. Brandao, Aram W. Harrow, Jonathan Oppenheim, Sergii Strelchuk

Abstract: We give two strengthenings of an inequality for the quantum conditional mutual information of a tripartite quantum state recently proved by Fawzi and Renner, connecting it with the ability to reconstruct the state from its bipartite reductions. Namely we show that the conditional mutual information is an upper bound on the regularised relative entropy distance between the quantum state and its rec… ▽ More We give two strengthenings of an inequality for the quantum conditional mutual information of a tripartite quantum state recently proved by Fawzi and Renner, connecting it with the ability to reconstruct the state from its bipartite reductions. Namely we show that the conditional mutual information is an upper bound on the regularised relative entropy distance between the quantum state and its reconstructed version. It is also an upper bound for the measured relative entropy distance of the state to its reconstructed version. The main ingredient of the proof is the fact that the conditional mutual information is the optimal quantum communication rate in the task of state redistribution. △ Less

Submitted 2 June, 2016; v1 submitted 18 November, 2014; originally announced November 2014.

Comments: 6 pages, 1 figure. v3 minor fixes and some added explanation. v4. minor fixes. Published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 050501 (2015)

Sparse Quantum Codes from Quantum Circuits

Authors: Dave Bacon, Steven T. Flammia, Aram W. Harrow, Jonathan Shi

Abstract: We describe a general method for turning quantum circuits into sparse quantum subsystem codes. The idea is to turn each circuit element into a set of low-weight gauge generators that enforce the input-output relations of that circuit element. Using this prescription, we can map an arbitrary stabilizer code into a new subsystem code with the same distance and number of encoded qubits but where all… ▽ More We describe a general method for turning quantum circuits into sparse quantum subsystem codes. The idea is to turn each circuit element into a set of low-weight gauge generators that enforce the input-output relations of that circuit element. Using this prescription, we can map an arbitrary stabilizer code into a new subsystem code with the same distance and number of encoded qubits but where all the generators have constant weight, at the cost of adding some ancilla qubits. With an additional overhead of ancilla qubits, the new code can also be made spatially local. Applying our construction to certain concatenated stabilizer codes yields families of subsystem codes with constant-weight generators and with minimum distance $d = n^{1-ε}$, where $ε= O(1/\sqrt{\log n})$. For spatially local codes in $D$ dimensions we nearly saturate a bound due to Bravyi and Terhal and achieve $d = n^{1-ε-1/D}$. Previously the best code distance achievable with constant-weight generators in any dimension, due to Freedman, Meyer and Luo, was $O(\sqrt{n\log n})$ for a stabilizer code. △ Less

Submitted 16 February, 2017; v1 submitted 12 November, 2014; originally announced November 2014.

Comments: 28 pages, 2 figures. v4. Fixed an error regarding our fault-tolerant gadgets; results unchanged. Added discussion of explicit constant factors. v5. Final published version

Journal ref: Proc. of STOC '15, pp. 327-334 (2015); IEEE Transactions on Information Theory, vol 63, no 4, pp 2464-2479, April 2017

Local tests of global entanglement and a counterexample to the generalized area law

Authors: Dorit Aharonov, Aram W. Harrow, Zeph Landau, Daniel Nagaj, Mario Szegedy, Umesh Vazirani

Abstract: We introduce a technique for applying quantum expanders in a distributed fashion, and use it to solve two basic questions: testing whether a bipartite quantum state shared by two parties is the maximally entangled state and disproving a generalized area law. In the process these two questions which appear completely unrelated turn out to be two sides of the same coin. Strikingly in both cases a co… ▽ More We introduce a technique for applying quantum expanders in a distributed fashion, and use it to solve two basic questions: testing whether a bipartite quantum state shared by two parties is the maximally entangled state and disproving a generalized area law. In the process these two questions which appear completely unrelated turn out to be two sides of the same coin. Strikingly in both cases a constant amount of resources are used to verify a global property. △ Less

Submitted 3 October, 2014; originally announced October 2014.

Comments: 21 pages, to appear FOCS 2014

Journal ref: Proc. of FOCS 2014, pp. 246-255

Product-state Approximations to Quantum Ground States

Authors: Fernando G. S. L. Brandão, Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: The local Hamiltonian problem consists of estimating the ground-state energy (given by the minimum eigenvalue) of a local quantum Hamiltonian. First, we show the existence of a good product-state approximation for the ground-state energy of 2-local Hamiltonians with one or more of the following properties: (1) high degree, (2) small expansion, or (3) a ground state with sublinear entanglement wi… ▽ More The local Hamiltonian problem consists of estimating the ground-state energy (given by the minimum eigenvalue) of a local quantum Hamiltonian. First, we show the existence of a good product-state approximation for the ground-state energy of 2-local Hamiltonians with one or more of the following properties: (1) high degree, (2) small expansion, or (3) a ground state with sublinear entanglement with respect to some partition into small pieces. The approximation based on degree is a surprising difference between quantum Hamiltonians and classical CSPs (constraint satisfaction problems), since in the classical setting, higher degree is usually associated with harder CSPs. The approximation based on low entanglement, in turn, was previously known only in the regime where the entanglement was close to zero. Since the existence of a low-energy product state can be checked in NP, the result implies that any Hamiltonian used for a quantum PCP theorem should have: (1) constant degree, (2) constant expansion, (3) a "volume law" for entanglement with respect to any partition into small parts. Second, we show that in several cases, good product-state approximations not only exist, but can be found in polynomial time: (1) 2-local Hamiltonians on any planar graph, solving an open problem of Bansal, Bravyi, and Terhal, (2) dense k-local Hamiltonians for any constant k, solving an open problem of Gharibian and Kempe, and (3) 2-local Hamiltonians on graphs with low threshold rank, via a quantum generalization of a recent result of Barak, Raghavendra and Steurer. Our work introduces two new tools which may be of independent interest. First, we prove a new quantum version of the de Finetti theorem which does not require the usual assumption of symmetry. Second, we describe a way to analyze the application of the Lasserre/Parrilo SDP hierarchy to local quantum Hamiltonians. △ Less

Submitted 15 December, 2014; v1 submitted 30 September, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Comments: 44 pages. v2: proof of thm 6 corrected

Journal ref: Proc. of the 45th ACM Symposium on theory of computing (STOC 2013), pp. 871-880. : Communications in Mathematical Physics, 342(1), 47-80 (2016)

Adversarial hypothesis testing and a quantum Stein's Lemma for restricted measurements

Authors: Fernando G. S. L. Brandao, Aram W. Harrow, James R. Lee, Yuval Peres

Abstract: Recall the classical hypothesis testing setting with two convex sets of probability distributions P and Q. One receives either n i.i.d. samples from a distribution p in P or from a distribution q in Q and wants to decide from which set the points were sampled. It is known that the optimal exponential rate at which errors decrease can be achieved by a simple maximum-likelihood ratio test which does… ▽ More Recall the classical hypothesis testing setting with two convex sets of probability distributions P and Q. One receives either n i.i.d. samples from a distribution p in P or from a distribution q in Q and wants to decide from which set the points were sampled. It is known that the optimal exponential rate at which errors decrease can be achieved by a simple maximum-likelihood ratio test which does not depend on p or q, but only on the sets P and Q. We consider an adaptive generalization of this model where the choice of p in P and q in Q can change in each sample in some way that depends arbitrarily on the previous samples. In other words, in the k'th round, an adversary, having observed all the previous samples in rounds 1,...,k-1, chooses p_k in P and q_k in Q, with the goal of confusing the hypothesis test. We prove that even in this case, the optimal exponential error rate can be achieved by a simple maximum-likelihood test that depends only on P and Q. We then show that the adversarial model has applications in hypothesis testing for quantum states using restricted measurements. For example, it can be used to study the problem of distinguishing entangled states from the set of all separable states using only measurements that can be implemented with local operations and classical communication (LOCC). The basic idea is that in our setup, the deleterious effects of entanglement can be simulated by an adaptive classical adversary. We prove a quantum Stein's Lemma in this setting: In many circumstances, the optimal hypothesis testing rate is equal to an appropriate notion of quantum relative entropy between two states. In particular, our arguments yield an alternate proof of Li and Winter's recent strengthening of strong subadditivity for quantum relative entropy. △ Less

Submitted 9 March, 2020; v1 submitted 30 August, 2013; originally announced August 2013.

Comments: 34 pages. v4. fixes bugs in proofs and adds detail

Journal ref: Proc. of 5th ITCS, pp. 183-194 (2014), IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory, vol 66, no 8, pp. 5037-5054 (2020)

The Church of the Symmetric Subspace

Authors: Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: The symmetric subpace has many applications in quantum information theory. This review article begins by explaining key background facts about the symmetric subspace from a quantum information perspective. Then we review, and in some places extend, work of Werner and Chiribella that connects the symmetric subspace to state estimation, optimal cloning, the de Finetti theorem and other topics. In th… ▽ More The symmetric subpace has many applications in quantum information theory. This review article begins by explaining key background facts about the symmetric subspace from a quantum information perspective. Then we review, and in some places extend, work of Werner and Chiribella that connects the symmetric subspace to state estimation, optimal cloning, the de Finetti theorem and other topics. In the third and final section, we discuss how the symmetric subspace can yield concentration-of-measure results via the calculation of higher moments of random quantum states. There are no new results in this article, but only some new proofs of existing results, such as a variant of the exponential de Finetti theorem. The purpose of the article is (a) pedagogical, and (b) to collect in one place many, if not all, of the quantum information applications of the symmetric subspace. △ Less

Submitted 29 August, 2013; originally announced August 2013.

Comments: 22 pages, review article

Quantum de Finetti Theorems under Local Measurements with Applications

Authors: Fernando G. S. L. Brandao, Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: Quantum de Finetti theorems are a useful tool in the study of correlations in quantum multipartite states. In this paper we prove two new quantum de Finetti theorems, both showing that under tests formed by local measurements one can get a much improved error dependence on the dimension of the subsystems. We also obtain similar results for non-signaling probability distributions. We give the follo… ▽ More Quantum de Finetti theorems are a useful tool in the study of correlations in quantum multipartite states. In this paper we prove two new quantum de Finetti theorems, both showing that under tests formed by local measurements one can get a much improved error dependence on the dimension of the subsystems. We also obtain similar results for non-signaling probability distributions. We give the following applications of the results: We prove the optimality of the Chen-Drucker protocol for 3-SAT, under the exponential time hypothesis. We show that the maximum winning probability of free games can be estimated in polynomial time by linear programming. We also show that 3-SAT with m variables can be reduced to obtaining a constant error approximation of the maximum winning probability under entangled strategies of O(m^{1/2})-player one-round non-local games, in which the players communicate O(m^{1/2}) bits all together. We show that the optimization of certain polynomials over the hypersphere can be performed in quasipolynomial time in the number of variables n by considering O(log(n)) rounds of the Sum-of-Squares (Parrilo/Lasserre) hierarchy of semidefinite programs. As an application to entanglement theory, we find a quasipolynomial-time algorithm for deciding multipartite separability. We consider a result due to Aaronson -- showing that given an unknown n qubit state one can perform tomography that works well for most observables by measuring only O(n) independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) copies of the state -- and relax the assumption of having i.i.d copies of the state to merely the ability to select subsystems at random from a quantum multipartite state. The proofs of the new quantum de Finetti theorems are based on information theory, in particular on the chain rule of mutual information. △ Less

Submitted 23 July, 2014; v1 submitted 23 October, 2012; originally announced October 2012.

Comments: 39 pages, no figure. v2: changes to references and other minor improvements. v3: added some explanations, mostly about Theorem 1 and Conjecture 5. STOC version. v4, v5. small improvements and fixes

Journal ref: Proc. of the 45th ACM Symposium on theory of computing (STOC 2013), pp. 861-870; Communications in Mathematical Physics, 353(2), 469-506

Dimension-free L2 maximal inequality for spherical means in the hypercube

Authors: Aram W. Harrow, Alexandra Kolla, Leonard J. Schulman

Abstract: We establish the result of the title. In combinatorial terms this has the implication that for sufficiently small eps > 0, for all n, any marking of an eps fraction of the vertices of the n-dimensional hypercube necessarily leaves a vertex x such that marked vertices are a minority of every sphere centered at x. We establish the result of the title. In combinatorial terms this has the implication that for sufficiently small eps > 0, for all n, any marking of an eps fraction of the vertices of the n-dimensional hypercube necessarily leaves a vertex x such that marked vertices are a minority of every sphere centered at x. △ Less

Submitted 24 November, 2013; v1 submitted 19 September, 2012; originally announced September 2012.

Comments: 17 pages. v2. This version matches the published version and fixes typos, simplifies some proofs and makes other minor changes. The main results are unchanged from v1

Journal ref: Theory of Computing. vol 10, pp 55-75 (2014)

Local random quantum circuits are approximate polynomial-designs

Authors: Fernando G. S. L. Brandao, Aram W. Harrow, Michal Horodecki

Abstract: We prove that local random quantum circuits acting on n qubits composed of O(t^{10} n^2) many nearest neighbor two-qubit gates form an approximate unitary t-design. Previously it was unknown whether random quantum circuits were a t-design for any t > 3. The proof is based on an interplay of techniques from quantum many-body theory, representation theory, and the theory of Markov chains. In parti… ▽ More We prove that local random quantum circuits acting on n qubits composed of O(t^{10} n^2) many nearest neighbor two-qubit gates form an approximate unitary t-design. Previously it was unknown whether random quantum circuits were a t-design for any t > 3. The proof is based on an interplay of techniques from quantum many-body theory, representation theory, and the theory of Markov chains. In particular we employ a result of Nachtergaele for lower bounding the spectral gap of frustration-free quantum local Hamiltonians; a quasi-orthogonality property of permutation matrices; a result of Oliveira which extends to the unitary group the path-coupling method for bounding the mixing time of random walks; and a result of Bourgain and Gamburd showing that dense subgroups of the special unitary group, composed of elements with algebraic entries, are infty-copy tensor-product expanders. We also consider pseudo-randomness properties of local random quantum circuits of small depth and prove that circuits of depth O(t^{10}n) constitute a quantum t-copy tensor-product expander. The proof also rests on techniques from quantum many-body theory, in particular on the detectability lemma of Aharonov, Arad, Landau, and Vazirani. We give applications of the results to cryptography, equilibration of closed quantum dynamics, and the generation of topological order. In particular we show the following pseudo-randomness property of generic quantum circuits: Almost every circuit U of size O(n^k) on n qubits cannot be distinguished from a Haar uniform unitary by circuits of size O(n^{(k-9)/11}) that are given oracle access to U. △ Less

Submitted 9 July, 2019; v1 submitted 3 August, 2012; originally announced August 2012.

Comments: 39 pages, no figures. v2. exponent of t went up. v3. small changes, almost identical to published version. v4. further fixes to proofs, results mostly unchanged

Journal ref: Commun. Math. Phys. (2016) vol. 346, no. 2, pp. 397-434

Hypercontractivity, Sum-of-Squares Proofs, and their Applications

Authors: Boaz Barak, Fernando G. S. L. Brandão, Aram W. Harrow, Jonathan A. Kelner, David Steurer, Yuan Zhou

Abstract: We study the computational complexity of approximating the 2->q norm of linear operators (defined as ||A||_{2->q} = sup_v ||Av||_q/||v||_2), as well as connections between this question and issues arising in quantum information theory and the study of Khot's Unique Games Conjecture (UGC). We show the following: 1. For any constant even integer q>=4, a graph $G$ is a "small-set expander" if and o… ▽ More We study the computational complexity of approximating the 2->q norm of linear operators (defined as ||A||_{2->q} = sup_v ||Av||_q/||v||_2), as well as connections between this question and issues arising in quantum information theory and the study of Khot's Unique Games Conjecture (UGC). We show the following: 1. For any constant even integer q>=4, a graph $G$ is a "small-set expander" if and only if the projector into the span of the top eigenvectors of G's adjacency matrix has bounded 2->q norm. As a corollary, a good approximation to the 2->q norm will refute the Small-Set Expansion Conjecture--a close variant of the UGC. We also show that such a good approximation can be obtained in exp(n^(2/q)) time, thus obtaining a different proof of the known subexponential algorithm for Small Set Expansion. 2. Constant rounds of the "Sum of Squares" semidefinite programing hierarchy certify an upper bound on the 2->4 norm of the projector to low-degree polynomials over the Boolean cube, as well certify the unsatisfiability of the "noisy cube" and "short code" based instances of Unique Games considered by prior works. This improves on the previous upper bound of exp(poly log n) rounds (for the "short code"), as well as separates the "Sum of Squares"/"Lasserre" hierarchy from weaker hierarchies that were known to require omega(1) rounds. 3. We show reductions between computing the 2->4 norm and computing the injective tensor norm of a tensor, a problem with connections to quantum information theory. Three corollaries are: (i) the 2->4 norm is NP-hard to approximate to precision inverse-polynomial in the dimension, (ii) the 2->4 norm does not have a good approximation (in the sense above) unless 3-SAT can be solved in time exp(sqrt(n) polylog(n)), and (iii) known algorithms for the quantum separability problem imply a non-trivial additive approximation for the 2->4 norm. △ Less

Submitted 16 November, 2014; v1 submitted 21 May, 2012; originally announced May 2012.

Comments: v1: 52 pages. v2: 53 pages, fixed small bugs in proofs of section 6 (on UG integrality gaps) and section 7 (on 2->4 norm of random matrices). Added comments about real-vs-complex random matrices and about the k-extendable vs k-extendable & PPT hierarchies. v3: fixed mistakes in random matrix section. The result now holds only for matrices with random entries instead of random columns

Journal ref: Proc. STOC 2012, pp. 307--326

Counterexamples to Kalai's Conjecture C

Authors: Steven T. Flammia, Aram W. Harrow

Abstract: We provide two simple counterexamples to Kalai's Conjecture C and discuss our perspective on the implications for the prospect of large-scale fault-tolerant quantum computation. We provide two simple counterexamples to Kalai's Conjecture C and discuss our perspective on the implications for the prospect of large-scale fault-tolerant quantum computation. △ Less

Submitted 31 July, 2012; v1 submitted 16 April, 2012; originally announced April 2012.

Comments: 7 pages, 2 figures. v2, minor changes. To appear in QIC

Journal ref: Q. Inf. & Comp. Vol. 13 No.1&2 pp. 1-8 (2013)