-
Quantum Theory of Measurement
Authors:
Alan K. Harrison
Abstract:
We describe a quantum mechanical measurement as a variational principle including interaction between the system under measurement and the measurement apparatus. Augmenting the action with a nonlocal term (a double integration over the duration of the interaction) results in a theory capable of describing both the measurement process (agreement between system state and pointer state) and the colla…
▽ More
We describe a quantum mechanical measurement as a variational principle including interaction between the system under measurement and the measurement apparatus. Augmenting the action with a nonlocal term (a double integration over the duration of the interaction) results in a theory capable of describing both the measurement process (agreement between system state and pointer state) and the collapse of both systems into a single eigenstate (or superposition of degenerate eigenstates) of the relevant operator. In the absence of the interaction, a superposition of states is stable, and the theory agrees with the predictions of standard quantum theory. Because the theory is nonlocal, the resulting wave equation is an integrodifferential equation (IDE). We demonstrate these ideas using a simple Lagrangian for both systems, as proof of principle. The variational principle is time-symmetric and retrocausal, so the solution for the measurement process is determined by boundary conditions at both initial and final times; the initial condition is determined by the experimental preparation and the final condition is the natural boundary condition of variational calculus. We hypothesize that one or more hidden variables (not ruled out by Bell's Theorem, due both to the retrocausality and the nonlocality of the theory) influence the outcome of the measurement, and that distributions of the hidden variables that arise plausibly in a typical ensemble of experimental realizations give rise to outcome frequencies consistent with Born's rule. We outline steps in a theoretical validation of the hypothesis. We discuss the role of both initial and final conditions to determine a solution at intermediate times, the mechanism by which a system responds to measurement, time symmetry of the new theory, causality concerns, and issues surrounding solution of the IDE.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Calculation of the electron two-slit experiment using a quantum mechanical variational principle
Authors:
Alan K. Harrison
Abstract:
A nonlocal relativistic variational principle (VP) has recently been proposed as an alternative to the Dirac wave equation of standard quantum mechanics. We apply that principle to the electron two-slit experiment. The detection system is modelled as a screen made of atoms, any one of which can be excited by the incident electron, but we avoid restricting the detection mechanism further. The VP is…
▽ More
A nonlocal relativistic variational principle (VP) has recently been proposed as an alternative to the Dirac wave equation of standard quantum mechanics. We apply that principle to the electron two-slit experiment. The detection system is modelled as a screen made of atoms, any one of which can be excited by the incident electron, but we avoid restricting the detection mechanism further. The VP is shown to predict that, at the time the electron reaches the screen, its wavefunction will be localized to the neighborhood of a single atom, resulting in a position-type measurement. In an ensemble of such experiments ("identically prepared" except that the initial phase of the wavefunction--the hidden variable in the VP formulation--is sampled over the expected uniform distribution), the distribution of measured positions will reproduce the interference pattern predicted by the Dirac equation. We also demonstrate that with a detection system designed fundamentally to detect the electron's transverse wavelength rather than its position, the VP predicts that one such mode will be detected, that is, a wavelength measurement will result. Finally, it is shown that these results are unchanged in the "delayed choice" variant of the experiment.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
Wavefunction collapse via a nonlocal relativistic variational principle
Authors:
Alan K. Harrison
Abstract:
We propose, as an alternative theory of quantum mechanics, a relativistically covariant variational principle (VP) capable of describing both wavefunction collapse and, as an appropriate limiting case, evolution of the wavefunction according to the standard quantum mechanical (SQM) wave equation. This results in a nonlinear, nonlocal, time-symmetric hidden-variable theory; the hidden variable is t…
▽ More
We propose, as an alternative theory of quantum mechanics, a relativistically covariant variational principle (VP) capable of describing both wavefunction collapse and, as an appropriate limiting case, evolution of the wavefunction according to the standard quantum mechanical (SQM) wave equation. This results in a nonlinear, nonlocal, time-symmetric hidden-variable theory; the hidden variable is the phase of the wavefunction, which affects the dynamics via zitterbewegung.
The VP is δ(A_1 + εA_2) = 0, in which A_1 and A_2 are positive definite integrals (over all spacetime) of functions of the wavefunction ψ. A_1 is quadratic in deviations of the wavefunction from compliance with the SQM wave equation. A_2 is a measure of the uncertainty of the wavefunction, driving collapse by penalizing certain kinds of superpositions. We also show that A_1 limits the rate of collapse, and that it enforces the Born rule, with suitable assumptions and approximations.
Since the VP optimizes a function ψ of both space and time, the theory is not "causal" in the usual sense. Because it is not clear how Nature solves the optimization problem (e.g., whether a global or a local minimum is sought), we cannot yet say whether it is deterministic.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2012;
originally announced April 2012.
