-
Insights From Experiments With Rigor in an EvoBio Design Study
Authors:
Jen Rogers,
Austin H. Patton,
Luke Harmon,
Alexander Lex,
Miriah Meyer
Abstract:
Design study is an established approach of conducting problem-driven visualization research. The academic visualizationcommunity has produced a large body of work for reporting on design studies, informed by a handful of theoretical frameworks, andapplied to a broad range of application areas. The result is an abundance of reported insights into visualization design, with anemphasis on novel visua…
▽ More
Design study is an established approach of conducting problem-driven visualization research. The academic visualizationcommunity has produced a large body of work for reporting on design studies, informed by a handful of theoretical frameworks, andapplied to a broad range of application areas. The result is an abundance of reported insights into visualization design, with anemphasis on novel visualization techniques and systems as the primary contribution of these studies. In recent work we proposeda new, interpretivist perspective on design study and six companion criteria for rigor that highlight the opportunities for researchersto contribute knowledge that extends beyond visualization idioms and software. In this work we conducted a year-long collaborationwith evolutionary biologists to develop an interactive tool for visual exploration of multivariate datasets and phylogenetic trees. Duringthis design study we experimented with methods to support three of the rigor criteria:ABUNDANT,REFLEXIVE, andTRANSPARENT. As aresult we contribute two novel visualization techniques for the analysis of multivariate phylogenetic datasets, three methodologicalrecommendations for conducting design studies drawn from reflections over our process of experimentation, and two writing devices forreporting interpretivist design study. We offer this work as an example for implementing the rigor criteria to produce a diverse range ofknowledge contributions.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Reducing DRIFT Backgrounds with a Submicron Aluminized-Mylar Cathode
Authors:
James B. R. Battat,
Ed Daw,
Alexei Dorofeev,
Anthony C. Ezeribe,
Jennifer R. Fox,
Jean-Luc Gauvreau,
Michael Gold,
Lydia Harmon,
John Harton,
Randy Lafler,
Robert J. Lauer,
Eric R. Lee,
Dinesh Loomba,
Alexander Lumnah,
John Matthews,
Eric H. Miller,
Frederic Mouton,
Alexander St. J. Murphy,
Nguyen Phan,
Stephen W. Sadler,
Andrew Scarff,
Fred Schuckman II,
Daniel Snowden-Ifft,
Neil J. C. Spooner,
Daniel Walker
Abstract:
Background events in the DRIFT-IId dark matter detector, mimicking potential WIMP signals, are predominantly caused by alpha decays on the central cathode in which the alpha particle is completely or partially absorbed by the cathode material. We installed a 0.9 micron thick aluminized-mylar cathode as a way to reduce the probability of producing these backgrounds. We study three generations of ca…
▽ More
Background events in the DRIFT-IId dark matter detector, mimicking potential WIMP signals, are predominantly caused by alpha decays on the central cathode in which the alpha particle is completely or partially absorbed by the cathode material. We installed a 0.9 micron thick aluminized-mylar cathode as a way to reduce the probability of producing these backgrounds. We study three generations of cathode (wire, thin-film, and radiologically clean thin-film) with a focus on the ratio of background events to alpha decays. Two independent methods of measuring the absolute alpha decay rate are used to ensure an accurate result, and agree to within $10\%$. Using alpha range spectroscopy, we measure the radiologically cleanest cathode version to have a contamination of $3.3\pm0.1$ ppt $^{234}$U and $73\pm2$ ppb $^{238}$U. This cathode reduces the probability of producing an RPR from an alpha decay by a factor of $70\pm20$ compared to the original stainless steel wire cathode. First results are presented from a texturized version of the cathode, intended to be even more transparent to alpha particles. These efforts, along with other background reduction measures, have resulted in a drop in the observed background rate from 500/day to 1/day. With the recent implementation of full-volume fiducialization, these remaining background events are identified, allowing for background-free operation.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2015; v1 submitted 11 February, 2015;
originally announced February 2015.
-
Radon in the DRIFT-II directional dark matter TPC: emanation, detection and mitigation
Authors:
J. B. R. Battat,
J. Brack,
E. Daw,
A. Dorofeev,
A. C. Ezeribe,
J. R. Fox,
J. -L. Gauvreau,
M. Gold,
L. J. Harmon,
J. L. Harton,
J. M. Landers,
E. R. Lee,
D. Loomba,
J. A. J. Matthews,
E. H. Miller,
A. Monte,
A. StJ. Murphy,
S. M. Paling,
N. Phan,
M. Pipe,
M. Robinson,
S. W. Sadler,
A. Scarff,
D. P. Snowden-Ifft,
N. J. C. Spooner
, et al. (4 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Radon gas emanating from materials is of interest in environmental science and also a major concern in rare event non-accelerator particle physics experiments such as dark matter and double beta decay searches, where it is a major source of background. Notable for dark matter experiments is the production of radon progeny recoils (RPRs), the low energy (~100 keV) recoils of radon daughter isotopes…
▽ More
Radon gas emanating from materials is of interest in environmental science and also a major concern in rare event non-accelerator particle physics experiments such as dark matter and double beta decay searches, where it is a major source of background. Notable for dark matter experiments is the production of radon progeny recoils (RPRs), the low energy (~100 keV) recoils of radon daughter isotopes, which can mimic the signal expected from WIMP interactions. Presented here are results of measurements of radon emanation from detector materials in the 1 metre cubed DRIFT-II directional dark matter gas time projection chamber experiment. Construction and operation of a radon emanation facility for this work is described, along with an analysis to continuously monitor DRIFT data for the presence of internal 222Rn and 218Po. Applying this analysis to historical DRIFT data, we show how systematic substitution of detector materials for alternatives, selected by this device for low radon emanation, has resulted in a factor of ~10 reduction in internal radon rates. Levels are found to be consistent with the sum from separate radon emanation measurements of the internal materials and also with direct measurement using an attached alpha spectrometer. The current DRIFT detector, DRIFT-IId, is found to have sensitivity to 222Rn of 2.5 μBq/l with current analysis efficiency, potentially opening up DRIFT technology as a new tool for sensitive radon assay of materials.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2014; v1 submitted 15 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Long-term study of backgrounds in the DRIFT-II directional dark matter experiment
Authors:
J. Brack,
E. Daw,
A. Dorofeev,
A. C. Ezeribe,
J. R. Fox,
J. -L. Gauvreau,
M. Gold,
L. J. Harmon,
J. Harton,
R. Lafler,
J. M. Landers,
R. Lauer,
E. R. Lee,
D. Loomba,
J. A. J. Matthews,
E. H. Miller,
A. Monte,
A. StJ. Murphy,
S. M. Paling,
N. Phan,
M. Pipe,
M. Robinson,
S. Sadler,
A. Scarff,
D. P. Snowden-Ifft
, et al. (4 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Low-pressure gas Time Projection Chambers being developed for directional dark matter searches offer a technology with strong particle identification capability combined with the potential to produce a definitive detection of Galactic Weakly Interacting Massive Particle (WIMP) dark matter. A source of events able to mimic genuine WIMP-induced nuclear recoil tracks arises in such experiments from t…
▽ More
Low-pressure gas Time Projection Chambers being developed for directional dark matter searches offer a technology with strong particle identification capability combined with the potential to produce a definitive detection of Galactic Weakly Interacting Massive Particle (WIMP) dark matter. A source of events able to mimic genuine WIMP-induced nuclear recoil tracks arises in such experiments from the decay of radon gas inside the vacuum vessel. The recoils that result from associated daughter nuclei are termed Radon Progeny Recoils (RPRs). We present here experimental data from a long-term study using the DRIFT-II directional dark matter experiment at the Boulby Underground Laboratory of the RPRs, and other backgrounds that are revealed by relaxing the normal cuts that are applied to WIMP search data. By detailed examination of event classes in both spatial and time coordinates using 5.5 years of data, we demonstrate the ability to determine the origin of 4 specific background populations and describe development of new technology and mitigation strategies to suppress them.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2014; v1 submitted 21 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Simpsonian 'Evolution by Jumps' in an Adaptive Radiation of Anolis Lizards
Authors:
Jonathan M. Eastman,
Daniel Wegmann,
Christoph Leuenberger,
Luke J. Harmon
Abstract:
In his highly influential view of evolution, G. G. Simpson hypothesized that clades of species evolve in adaptive zones, defined as collections of niches occupied by species with similar traits and patterns of habitat use. Simpson hypothesized that species enter new adaptive zones in one of three ways: extinction of competitor species, dispersal to a new geographic region, or the evolution of a ke…
▽ More
In his highly influential view of evolution, G. G. Simpson hypothesized that clades of species evolve in adaptive zones, defined as collections of niches occupied by species with similar traits and patterns of habitat use. Simpson hypothesized that species enter new adaptive zones in one of three ways: extinction of competitor species, dispersal to a new geographic region, or the evolution of a key trait that allows species to exploit resources in a new way. However, direct tests of Simpson's hypotheses for the entry into new adaptive zones remain elusive. Here we evaluate the fit of a Simpsonian model of jumps between adaptive zones to phylogenetic comparative data. We use a novel statistical approach to show that anoles, a well-studied adaptive radiation of Caribbean lizards, have evolved by a series of evolutionary jumps in trait evolution. Furthermore, as Simpson predicted, trait axes strongly tied to habitat specialization show jumps that correspond with the evolution of key traits and/or dispersal between islands in the Greater Antilles. We conclude that jumps are commonly associated with major adaptive shifts in the evolutionary radiation of anoles.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Trees of Unusual Size: Biased Inference of Early Bursts from Large Molecular Phylogenies
Authors:
Matthew W. Pennell,
Brice A. J. Sarver,
Luke J. Harmon
Abstract:
An early burst of speciation followed by a subsequent slowdown in the rate of diversification is commonly inferred from molecular phylogenies. This pattern is consistent with some verbal theory of ecological opportunity and adaptive radiations. One often-overlooked source of bias in these studies is that of sampling at the level of whole clades, as researchers tend to choose large, speciose clades…
▽ More
An early burst of speciation followed by a subsequent slowdown in the rate of diversification is commonly inferred from molecular phylogenies. This pattern is consistent with some verbal theory of ecological opportunity and adaptive radiations. One often-overlooked source of bias in these studies is that of sampling at the level of whole clades, as researchers tend to choose large, speciose clades to study. In this paper, we investigate the performance of common methods across the distribution of clade sizes that can be generated by a constant-rate birth-death process. Clades which are larger than expected for a given constant-rate branching process tend to show a pattern of an early burst even when both speciation and extinction rates are constant through time. All methods evaluated were susceptible to detecting this false signature when extinction was low. Under moderate extinction, both the gamma-statistic and diversity-dependent models did not detect such a slowdown but only because the signature of a slowdown was masked by subsequent extinction. Some models which estimate time-varying speciation rates are able to detect early bursts under higher extinction rates, but are extremely prone to sampling bias. We suggest that examining clades in isolation may result in spurious inferences that rates of diversification have changed through time.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
The DRIFT Dark Matter Experiments
Authors:
E. Daw,
A. Dorofeev,
J. R. Fox,
J. -L. Gauvreau,
C. Ghag,
L. J. Harmon,
J. L. Harton,
M. Gold,
E. R. Lee,
D. Loomba,
E. H. Miller,
A. St. J. Murphy,
S. M. Paling,
J. M. Landers,
N. Phan,
M. Pipe,
K. Pushkin,
M. Robinson,
S. W. Sadler,
D. P. Snowden-Ifft,
N. J. C. Spooner,
D. Walker,
D. Warner
Abstract:
The current status of the DRIFT (Directional Recoil Identification From Tracks) experiment at Boulby Mine is presented, including the latest limits on the WIMP spin-dependent cross-section from 1.5 kg days of running with a mixture of CS2 and CF4. Planned upgrades to DRIFT IId are detailed, along with ongoing work towards DRIFT III, which aims to be the world's first 10 m3-scale directional Dark M…
▽ More
The current status of the DRIFT (Directional Recoil Identification From Tracks) experiment at Boulby Mine is presented, including the latest limits on the WIMP spin-dependent cross-section from 1.5 kg days of running with a mixture of CS2 and CF4. Planned upgrades to DRIFT IId are detailed, along with ongoing work towards DRIFT III, which aims to be the world's first 10 m3-scale directional Dark Matter detector.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2011;
originally announced October 2011.
-
Spin-Dependent Limits from the DRIFT-IId Directional Dark Matter Detector
Authors:
E. Daw,
J. R. Fox,
J. -L. Gauvreau,
C. Ghag,
L. J. Harmon,
M. Gold,
E. Lee,
D. Loomba,
E. Miller,
A. StJ. Murphy,
S. M. Paling,
J. M. Landers,
M. Pipe,
K. Pushkin,
M. Robinson,
D. P. Snowden-Ifft,
N. J. C. Spooner,
D. Walker
Abstract:
Data are presented from the DRIFT-IId detector housed in the Boulby mine in northeast England. A 0.8 m^3 fiducial volume, containing partial pressures of 30 Torr CS2 and 10 Torr CF4, was exposed for a duration of 47.4 live-time days with sufficient passive shielding to provide a neutron free environment within the detector. The nuclear recoil events seen are consistent with a remaining low level b…
▽ More
Data are presented from the DRIFT-IId detector housed in the Boulby mine in northeast England. A 0.8 m^3 fiducial volume, containing partial pressures of 30 Torr CS2 and 10 Torr CF4, was exposed for a duration of 47.4 live-time days with sufficient passive shielding to provide a neutron free environment within the detector. The nuclear recoil events seen are consistent with a remaining low level background from the decay of progeny of radon daughters attached to the central cathode of the detector. However, energy depositions from such events must drift across the entire width of the detector, and thus display large diffusion upon reaching the readout planes of the device. Exploiting this feature, it is shown to be possible to reject energy depositions from these radon decay progeny events while still retaining sensitivity to nuclear recoil events. The response of the detector is then interpreted, using the F nuclei content of the gas, in terms of sensitivity to proton spin-dependent WIMP-nucleon interactions, displaying a minimum in sensitivity cross section at 0.5 pb for a WIMP mass of 100 GeV/c^2.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2011; v1 submitted 14 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
