-
Optimality of weighted contracts for multi-agent contract design with a budget
Authors:
Sumit Goel,
Wade Hann-Caruthers
Abstract:
We study a contract design problem between a principal and multiple agents. Each agent participates in an independent task with binary outcomes (success or failure), in which it may exert costly effort towards improving its probability of success, and the principal has a fixed budget which it can use to provide outcome-dependent rewards to the agents. Crucially, we assume the principal cares only…
▽ More
We study a contract design problem between a principal and multiple agents. Each agent participates in an independent task with binary outcomes (success or failure), in which it may exert costly effort towards improving its probability of success, and the principal has a fixed budget which it can use to provide outcome-dependent rewards to the agents. Crucially, we assume the principal cares only about maximizing the agents' probabilities of success, not how much of the budget it expends. We first show that a contract is optimal for some objective if and only if it is a successful-get-everything contract. An immediate consequence of this result is that piece-rate contracts and bonus-pool contracts are never optimal in this setting. We then show that for any objective, there is an optimal priority-based weighted contract, which assigns positive weights and priority levels to the agents, and splits the budget among the highest-priority successful agents, with each such agent receiving a fraction of the budget proportional to her weight. This result provides a significant reduction in the dimensionality of the principal's optimal contract design problem and gives an interpretable and easily implementable optimal contract. Finally, we discuss an application of our results to the design of optimal contracts with two agents and quadratic costs. In this context, we find that the optimal contract assigns a higher weight to the agent whose success it values more, irrespective of the heterogeneity in the agents' cost parameters. This suggests that the structure of the optimal contract depends primarily on the bias in the principal's objective and is, to some extent, robust to the heterogeneity in the agents' cost functions.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Project selection with partially verifiable information
Authors:
Sumit Goel,
Wade Hann-Caruthers
Abstract:
We consider a principal agent project selection problem with asymmetric information. There are $N$ projects and the principal must select exactly one of them. Each project provides some profit to the principal and some payoff to the agent and these profits and payoffs are the agent's private information. We consider the principal's problem of finding an optimal mechanism for two different objectiv…
▽ More
We consider a principal agent project selection problem with asymmetric information. There are $N$ projects and the principal must select exactly one of them. Each project provides some profit to the principal and some payoff to the agent and these profits and payoffs are the agent's private information. We consider the principal's problem of finding an optimal mechanism for two different objectives: maximizing expected profit and maximizing the probability of choosing the most profitable project. Importantly, we assume partial verifiability so that the agent cannot report a project to be more profitable to the principal than it actually is. Under this no-overselling constraint, we characterize the set of implementable mechanisms. Using this characterization, we find that in the case of two projects, the optimal mechanism under both objectives takes the form of a simple cutoff mechanism. The simple structure of the optimal mechanism also allows us to find evidence in support of the well-known ally-principle which says that principal delegates more authority to an agent who shares their preferences.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2022; v1 submitted 2 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Optimality of the coordinate-wise median mechanism for strategyproof facility location in two dimensions
Authors:
Sumit Goel,
Wade Hann-Caruthers
Abstract:
We consider the facility location problem in two dimensions. In particular, we consider a setting where agents have Euclidean preferences, defined by their ideal points, for a facility to be located in $\mathbb{R}^2$. We show that for the $p-norm$ ($p \geq 1$) objective, the coordinate-wise median mechanism (CM) has the lowest worst-case approximation ratio in the class of deterministic, anonymous…
▽ More
We consider the facility location problem in two dimensions. In particular, we consider a setting where agents have Euclidean preferences, defined by their ideal points, for a facility to be located in $\mathbb{R}^2$. We show that for the $p-norm$ ($p \geq 1$) objective, the coordinate-wise median mechanism (CM) has the lowest worst-case approximation ratio in the class of deterministic, anonymous, and strategyproof mechanisms. For the minisum objective and an odd number of agents $n$, we show that CM has a worst-case approximation ratio (AR) of $\sqrt{2}\frac{\sqrt{n^2+1}}{n+1}$. For the $p-norm$ social cost objective ($p\geq 2$), we find that the AR for CM is bounded above by $2^{\frac{3}{2}-\frac{2}{p}}$. We conjecture that the AR of CM actually equals the lower bound $2^{1-\frac{1}{p}}$ (as is the case for $p=2$ and $p=\infty$) for any $p\geq 2$.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2022; v1 submitted 2 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Quasi-Regular Sequences
Authors:
Joshua Frisch,
Wade Hann-Caruthers,
Pooya Vahidi Ferdowsi
Abstract:
Let $Σ$ be a countable alphabet. For $r\geq 1$, an infinite sequence $s$ with characters from $Σ$ is called $r$-quasi-regular, if for each $σ\inΣ$ the ratio of the longest to shortest interval between consecutive occurrences of $σ$ in $s$ is bounded by $r$. In this paper, we answer a question asked by Kempe, Schulman, and Tamuz, and prove that for any probability distribution $\mathbf{p}$ on a fin…
▽ More
Let $Σ$ be a countable alphabet. For $r\geq 1$, an infinite sequence $s$ with characters from $Σ$ is called $r$-quasi-regular, if for each $σ\inΣ$ the ratio of the longest to shortest interval between consecutive occurrences of $σ$ in $s$ is bounded by $r$. In this paper, we answer a question asked by Kempe, Schulman, and Tamuz, and prove that for any probability distribution $\mathbf{p}$ on a finite alphabet $Σ$, there exists a $2$-quasi-regular infinite sequence with characters from $Σ$ and density of characters equal to $\mathbf{p}$. We also prove that as $\left\lVert\mathbf{p}\right\rVert_\infty$ tends to zero, the infimum of $r$ for which $r$-quasi-regular sequences with density $\mathbf{p}$ exist, tends to one. This result has a corollary in the Pinwheel Problem: as the smallest integer in the vector tends to infinity, the density threshold for Pinwheel schedulability tends to one.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Additive Conjugacy and the Bohr Compactification of Orthogonal Representations
Authors:
Zachary Chase,
Wade Hann-Caruthers,
Omer Tamuz
Abstract:
We say that two unitary or orthogonal representations of a finitely generated group $G$ are additive conjugates if they are intertwined by an additive map, which need not be continuous. We associate to each representation of $G$ a topological action that is a complete additive conjugacy invariant: the action of $G$ by group automorphisms on the Bohr compactification of the underlying Hilbert space…
▽ More
We say that two unitary or orthogonal representations of a finitely generated group $G$ are additive conjugates if they are intertwined by an additive map, which need not be continuous. We associate to each representation of $G$ a topological action that is a complete additive conjugacy invariant: the action of $G$ by group automorphisms on the Bohr compactification of the underlying Hilbert space. Using this construction we show that the property of having almost invariant vectors is an additive conjugacy invariant. As an application we show that $G$ is amenable if and only if there is a nonzero homomorphism from $L^2(G)$ into $\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z}$ that is invariant to the $G$-action.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2021; v1 submitted 28 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Equitable voting rules
Authors:
Laurent Bartholdi,
Wade Hann-Caruthers,
Maya Josyula,
Omer Tamuz,
Leeat Yariv
Abstract:
May's Theorem (1952), a celebrated result in social choice, provides the foundation for majority rule. May's crucial assumption of symmetry, often thought of as a procedural equity requirement, is violated by many choice procedures that grant voters identical roles. We show that a weakening of May's symmetry assumption allows for a far richer set of rules that still treat voters equally. We show t…
▽ More
May's Theorem (1952), a celebrated result in social choice, provides the foundation for majority rule. May's crucial assumption of symmetry, often thought of as a procedural equity requirement, is violated by many choice procedures that grant voters identical roles. We show that a weakening of May's symmetry assumption allows for a far richer set of rules that still treat voters equally. We show that such rules can have minimal winning coalitions comprising a vanishing fraction of the population, but not less than the square root of the population size. Methodologically, we introduce techniques from group theory and illustrate their usefulness for the analysis of social choice questions.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2020; v1 submitted 3 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
A Deterministic Protocol for Sequential Asymptotic Learning
Authors:
Yu Cheng,
Wade Hann-Caruthers,
Omer Tamuz
Abstract:
In the classic herding model, agents receive private signals about an underlying binary state of nature, and act sequentially to choose one of two possible actions, after observing the actions of their predecessors.
We investigate what types of behaviors lead to asymptotic learning, where agents will eventually converge to the right action in probability. It is known that for rational agents and…
▽ More
In the classic herding model, agents receive private signals about an underlying binary state of nature, and act sequentially to choose one of two possible actions, after observing the actions of their predecessors.
We investigate what types of behaviors lead to asymptotic learning, where agents will eventually converge to the right action in probability. It is known that for rational agents and bounded signals, there will not be asymptotic learning.
Does it help if the agents can be cooperative rather than act selfishly? This is simple to achieve if the agents are allowed to use randomized protocols. In this paper, we provide the first deterministic protocol under which asymptotic learning occurs. In addition, our protocol has the advantage of being much simpler than previous protocols.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
The speed of sequential asymptotic learning
Authors:
Wade Hann-Caruthers,
Vadim V. Martynov,
Omer Tamuz
Abstract:
In the classical herding literature, agents receive a private signal regarding a binary state of nature, and sequentially choose an action, after observing the actions of their predecessors. When the informativeness of private signals is unbounded, it is known that agents converge to the correct action and correct belief. We study how quickly convergence occurs, and show that it happens more slowl…
▽ More
In the classical herding literature, agents receive a private signal regarding a binary state of nature, and sequentially choose an action, after observing the actions of their predecessors. When the informativeness of private signals is unbounded, it is known that agents converge to the correct action and correct belief. We study how quickly convergence occurs, and show that it happens more slowly than it does when agents observe signals. However, we also show that the speed of learning from actions can be arbitrarily close to the speed of learning from signals. In particular, the expected time until the agents stop taking the wrong action can be either finite or infinite, depending on the private signal distribution. In the canonical case of Gaussian private signals we calculate the speed of convergence precisely, and show explicitly that, in this case, learning from actions is significantly slower than learning from signals.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2017; v1 submitted 9 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
