-
A probabilistic deep learning model of inter-fraction anatomical variations in radiotherapy
Authors:
Oscar Pastor-Serrano,
Steven Habraken,
Mischa Hoogeman,
Danny Lathouwers,
Dennis Schaart,
Yusuke Nomura,
Lei Xing,
Zoltán Perkó
Abstract:
In radiotherapy, the internal movement of organs between treatment sessions causes errors in the final radiation dose delivery. Motion models can be used to simulate motion patterns and assess anatomical robustness before delivery. Traditionally, such models are based on principal component analysis (PCA) and are either patient-specific (requiring several scans per patient) or population-based, ap…
▽ More
In radiotherapy, the internal movement of organs between treatment sessions causes errors in the final radiation dose delivery. Motion models can be used to simulate motion patterns and assess anatomical robustness before delivery. Traditionally, such models are based on principal component analysis (PCA) and are either patient-specific (requiring several scans per patient) or population-based, applying the same deformations to all patients. We present a hybrid approach which, based on population data, allows to predict patient-specific inter-fraction variations for an individual patient. We propose a deep learning probabilistic framework that generates deformation vector fields (DVFs) war** a patient's planning computed tomography (CT) into possible patient-specific anatomies. This daily anatomy model (DAM) uses few random variables capturing groups of correlated movements. Given a new planning CT, DAM estimates the joint distribution over the variables, with each sample from the distribution corresponding to a different deformation. We train our model using dataset of 312 CT pairs from 38 prostate cancer patients. For 2 additional patients (22 CTs), we compute the contour overlap between real and generated images, and compare the sampled and ground truth distributions of volume and center of mass changes. With a DICE score of 0.86 and a distance between prostate contours of 1.09 mm, DAM matches and improves upon PCA-based models. The distribution overlap further indicates that DAM's sampled movements match the range and frequency of clinically observed daily changes on repeat CTs. Conditioned only on a planning CT and contours of a new patient without any pre-processing, DAM can accurately predict CTs seen during following treatment sessions, which can be used for anatomically robust treatment planning and robustness evaluation against inter-fraction anatomical changes.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Discovery of a point-like source and a third spiral arm in the transition disk around the Herbig Ae star MWC 758
Authors:
M. Reggiani,
V. Christiaens,
O. Absil,
D. Mawet,
E. Huby,
E. Choquet,
C. A. Gomez Gonzalez,
G. Ruane,
B. Femenia,
E. Serabyn,
K. Matthews,
M. Barraza,
B. Carlomagno,
D. Defrère,
C. Delacroix,
S. Habraken,
A. Jolivet,
M. Karlsson,
G. Orban de Xivry,
P. Piron,
J. Surdej,
E. Vargas Catalan,
O. Wertz
Abstract:
Transition disks offer the extraordinary opportunity to look for newly born planets and investigate the early stages of planet formation. In this context we observed the Herbig A5 star MWC 758 with the L band vector vortex coronagraph installed in the near-infrared camera and spectrograph NIRC2 at the Keck II telescope, with the aim of unveiling the nature of the spiral structure by constraining t…
▽ More
Transition disks offer the extraordinary opportunity to look for newly born planets and investigate the early stages of planet formation. In this context we observed the Herbig A5 star MWC 758 with the L band vector vortex coronagraph installed in the near-infrared camera and spectrograph NIRC2 at the Keck II telescope, with the aim of unveiling the nature of the spiral structure by constraining the presence of planetary companions in the system. Our high-contrast imaging observations show a bright (delta L=7.0+/-0.3 mag) point-like emission, south of MWC 758 at a deprojected separation of about 20 au (r=0.111+/- 0. 004 arcsec) from the central star. We also recover the two spiral arms (south-east and north-west), already imaged by previous studies in polarized light, and discover a third one to the south-west of the star. No additional companions were detected in the system down to 5 Jupiter masses beyond 0.6 arcsec from the star. We propose that the bright L band emission could be caused by the presence of an embedded and accreting protoplanet, although the possibility of it being an asymmetric disk feature cannot be excluded. The spiral structure is probably not related to the protoplanet candidate, unless on an inclined and eccentric orbit, and it could be due to one (or more) yet undetected planetary companions at the edge of or outside the spiral pattern. Future observations and additional simulations will be needed to shed light on the true nature of the point-like source and its link with the spiral arms.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2017; v1 submitted 31 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
The W. M. Keck Observatory infrared vortex coronagraph and a first image of HIP79124 B
Authors:
Eugene Serabyn,
Elsa Huby,
Keith Matthews,
Dimitri Mawet,
Olivier Absil,
Bruno Femenia,
Peter Wizinowich,
Mikael Karlsson,
Michael Bottom,
Randy Campbell,
Brunella Carlomagno,
Denis Defrère,
Christian Delacroix,
Pontus Forsberg,
Carlos Gomez Gonzalez,
Serge Habraken,
Aissa Jolivet,
Kurt Liewer,
Scott Lilley,
Pierre Piron,
Maddalena Reggiani,
Jean Surdej,
Hien Tran,
Ernesto Vargas Catalan,
Olivier Wertz
Abstract:
An optical vortex coronagraph has been implemented within the NIRC2 camera on the Keck II telescope and used to carry out on-sky tests and observations. The development of this new L'-band observational mode is described, and an initial demonstration of the new capability is presented: a resolved image of the low-mass companion to HIP79124, which had previously been detected by means of interferom…
▽ More
An optical vortex coronagraph has been implemented within the NIRC2 camera on the Keck II telescope and used to carry out on-sky tests and observations. The development of this new L'-band observational mode is described, and an initial demonstration of the new capability is presented: a resolved image of the low-mass companion to HIP79124, which had previously been detected by means of interferometry. With HIP79124 B at a projected separation of 186.5 mas, both the small inner working angle of the vortex coronagraph and the related imaging improvements were crucial in imaging this close companion directly. Due to higher Strehl ratios and more relaxed contrasts in L' band versus H band, this new coronagraphic capability will enable high-contrast small-angle observations of nearby young exoplanets and disks on a par with those of shorter-wavelength extreme adaptive optics coronagraphs.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Characterization of the inner disk around HD 141569 A from Keck/NIRC2 L-band vortex coronagraphy
Authors:
Dimitri Mawet,
Élodie Choquet,
Olivier Absil,
Elsa Huby,
Michael Bottom,
Eugene Serabyn,
Bruno Femenia,
Jérémy Lebreton,
Keith Matthews,
Carlos A. Gomez Gonzalez,
Olivier Wertz,
Brunella Carlomagno,
Valentin Christiaens,
Denis Defrère,
Christian Delacroix,
Pontus Forsberg,
Serge Habraken,
Aissa Jolivet,
Mikael Karlsson,
Julien Milli,
Christophe Pinte,
Pierre Piron,
Maddalena Reggiani,
Jean Surdej,
Ernesto Vargas Catalan
Abstract:
HD 141569 A is a pre-main sequence B9.5 Ve star surrounded by a prominent and complex circumstellar disk, likely still in a transition stage from protoplanetary to debris disk phase. Here, we present a new image of the third inner disk component of HD 141569 A made in the L' band (3.8 micron) during the commissioning of the vector vortex coronagraph recently installed in the near-infrared imager a…
▽ More
HD 141569 A is a pre-main sequence B9.5 Ve star surrounded by a prominent and complex circumstellar disk, likely still in a transition stage from protoplanetary to debris disk phase. Here, we present a new image of the third inner disk component of HD 141569 A made in the L' band (3.8 micron) during the commissioning of the vector vortex coronagraph recently installed in the near-infrared imager and spectrograph NIRC2 behind the W.M. Keck Observatory Keck II adaptive optics system. We used reference point spread function subtraction, which reveals the innermost disk component from the inner working distance of $\simeq 23$ AU and up to $\simeq 70$ AU. The spatial scale of our detection roughly corresponds to the optical and near-infrared scattered light, thermal Q, N and 8.6 micron PAH emission reported earlier. We also see an outward progression in dust location from the L'-band to the H-band (VLT/SPHERE image) to the visible (HST/STIS image), likely indicative of dust blowout. The warm disk component is nested deep inside the two outer belts imaged by HST NICMOS in 1999 (respectively at 406 and 245 AU). We fit our new L'-band image and spectral energy distribution of HD 141569 A with the radiative transfer code MCFOST. Our best-fit models favor pure olivine grains, and are consistent with the composition of the outer belts. While our image shows a putative very-faint point-like clump or source embedded in the inner disk, we did not detect any true companion within the gap between the inner disk and the first outer ring, at a sensitivity of a few Jupiter masses.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Discovery of a low-mass companion inside the debris ring surrounding the F5V star HD206893
Authors:
Julien Milli,
Pascale Hibon,
Valentin Christiaens,
Elodie Choquet,
Mickael Bonnefoy,
Grant M. Kennedy,
Mark C. Wyatt,
Olivier Absil,
Carlos A. Gomez Gonzalez,
Carlos del Burgo,
Luca Matra,
Jean-Charles Augereau,
Anthony Boccaletti,
Christian Delacroix,
Steve Ertel,
William R. F. Dent,
Pontus Forsberg,
Thierry Fusco,
Julien H. Girard,
Serge Habraken,
Elsa Huby,
Mikael Karlsson,
Anne-Marie Lagrange,
Dimitri Mawet,
David Mouillet
, et al. (8 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Uncovering the ingredients and the architecture of planetary systems is a very active field of research that has fuelled many new theories on giant planet formation, migration, composition, and interaction with the circumstellar environment. We aim at discovering and studying new such systems, to further expand our knowledge of how low-mass companions form and evolve. We obtained high-contrast H-b…
▽ More
Uncovering the ingredients and the architecture of planetary systems is a very active field of research that has fuelled many new theories on giant planet formation, migration, composition, and interaction with the circumstellar environment. We aim at discovering and studying new such systems, to further expand our knowledge of how low-mass companions form and evolve. We obtained high-contrast H-band images of the circumstellar environment of the F5V star HD206893, known to host a debris disc never detected in scattered light. These observations are part of the SPHERE High Angular Resolution Debris Disc Survey (SHARDDS) using the InfraRed Dual-band Imager and Spectrograph (IRDIS) installed on VLT/SPHERE. We report the detection of a source with a contrast of 3.6x10^{-5} in the H-band, orbiting at a projected separation of 270 milliarcsecond or 10 au, corresponding to a mass in the range 24 to 73 Mjup for an age of the system in the range 0.2 to 2 Gyr. The detection was confirmed ten months later with VLT/NaCo, ruling out a background object with no proper motion. A faint extended emission compatible with the disc scattered light signal is also observed. The detection of a low-mass companion inside a massive debris disc makes this system an analog of other young planetary systems such as beta Pictoris, HR8799 or HD95086 and requires now further characterisation of both components to understand their interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2016; v1 submitted 1 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Optimizing the subwavelength grating of L-band Annular Groove Phase Masks for high coronagraphic performance
Authors:
Ernesto Vargas Catalan,
Elsa Huby,
Pontus Forsberg,
Aïssa Jolivet,
Pierre Baudoz,
Brunella Carlomagno,
Christian Delacroix,
Serge Habraken,
Dimitri Mawet,
Jean Surdej,
Olivier Absil,
Mikael Karlsson
Abstract:
Context. The Annular Groove Phase Mask (AGPM) is one possible implementation of the vector vortex coronagraph, where the helical phase ramp is produced by a concentric subwavelength grating. For several years, we have been manufacturing AGPMs by etching gratings into synthetic diamond substrates using inductively coupled plasma etching. Aims. We aim to design, fabricate, optimize, and evaluate new…
▽ More
Context. The Annular Groove Phase Mask (AGPM) is one possible implementation of the vector vortex coronagraph, where the helical phase ramp is produced by a concentric subwavelength grating. For several years, we have been manufacturing AGPMs by etching gratings into synthetic diamond substrates using inductively coupled plasma etching. Aims. We aim to design, fabricate, optimize, and evaluate new L-band AGPMs that reach the highest possible coronagraphic performance, for applications in current and forthcoming infrared high-contrast imagers. Methods. Rigorous coupled wave analysis (RCWA) is used for designing the subwavelength grating of the phase mask. Coronagraphic performance evaluation is performed on a dedicated optical test bench. The experimental results of the performance evaluation are then used to accurately determine the actual profile of the fabricated gratings, based on RCWA modeling. Results. The AGPM coronagraphic performance is very sensitive to small errors in etch depth and grating profile. Most of the fabricated components therefore show moderate performance in terms of starlight rejection (a few 100:1 in the best cases). Here we present new processes for re-etching the fabricated components in order to optimize the parameters of the grating and hence significantly increase their coronagraphic performance. Starlight rejection up to 1000:1 is demonstrated in a broadband L filter on the coronagraphic test bench, which corresponds to a raw contrast of about 1e-5 at two resolution elements from the star for a perfect input wave front on a circular, unobstructed aperture. Conclusions. Thanks to their exquisite performance, our latest L-band AGPMs are good candidates for installation in state-of-the-art and future high-contrast thermal infrared imagers, such as METIS for the E-ELT.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Three years of harvest with the vector vortex coronagraph in the thermal infrared
Authors:
Olivier Absil,
Dimitri Mawet,
Mikael Karlsson,
Brunella Carlomagno,
Valentin Christiaens,
Denis Defrère,
Christian Delacroix,
Bruno Femenia Castella,
Pontus Forsberg,
Julien Girard,
Carlos A. Gomez Gonzalez,
Serge Habraken,
Philip M. Hinz,
Elsa Huby,
Aïssa Jolivet,
Keith Matthews,
Julien Milli,
Gilles Orban de Xivry,
Eric Pantin,
Pierre Piron,
Maddalena Reggiani,
Garreth J. Ruane,
Eugene Serabyn,
Jean Surdej,
Konrad R. W. Tristram
, et al. (3 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
For several years, we have been develo** vortex phase masks based on sub-wavelength gratings, known as Annular Groove Phase Masks. Etched onto diamond substrates, these AGPMs are currently designed to be used in the thermal infrared (ranging from 3 to 13 μm). Our AGPMs were first installed on VLT/NACO and VLT/VISIR in 2012, followed by LBT/LMIRCam in 2013 and Keck/NIRC2 in 2015. In this paper, w…
▽ More
For several years, we have been develo** vortex phase masks based on sub-wavelength gratings, known as Annular Groove Phase Masks. Etched onto diamond substrates, these AGPMs are currently designed to be used in the thermal infrared (ranging from 3 to 13 μm). Our AGPMs were first installed on VLT/NACO and VLT/VISIR in 2012, followed by LBT/LMIRCam in 2013 and Keck/NIRC2 in 2015. In this paper, we review the development, commissioning, on-sky performance, and early scientific results of these new coronagraphic modes and report on the lessons learned. We conclude with perspectives for future developments and applications.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
A Mach-Zehnder interferometer based on orbital angular momentum for improved vortex coronagraph efficiency
Authors:
P. Piron,
C. Delacroix,
E. Huby,
D. Mawet,
M. Karlsson ad G. Ruane,
S. Habraken,
O. Absil,
J. Surdej
Abstract:
The Annular Groove Phase Mask (AGPM) is a vectorial vortex phase mask. It acts as a half-wave plate with a radial fast axis orientation operating in the mid infrared domain. When placed at the focus of a telescope element provides a continuous helical phase ramp for an on axis sources, which creates the orbital angular momentum. Thanks to that phase, the intensity of the central source is canceled…
▽ More
The Annular Groove Phase Mask (AGPM) is a vectorial vortex phase mask. It acts as a half-wave plate with a radial fast axis orientation operating in the mid infrared domain. When placed at the focus of a telescope element provides a continuous helical phase ramp for an on axis sources, which creates the orbital angular momentum. Thanks to that phase, the intensity of the central source is canceled by a down-stream pupil stop, while the off axis sources are not affected. However due to experimental conditions the nulling is hardly perfect. To improve the null, a Mach-Zehnder interferometer containing Dove prisms differently oriented can be proposed to sort out light based on its orbital angular momentum (OAM). Thanks to the differential rotation of the beam, a π phase shift is achieved for the on axis light affected by a non zero OAM. Therefore the contrast between the star and its faint companion is enhanced. Nevertheless, due the Dove prisms birefringence, the performance of the interferometer is relatively poor. To solve this problem, we propose to add a birefringent wave-plate in each arm to compensate this birefringence. In this paper, we will develop the mathematical model of the wave front using the Jones formalism. The performance of the interferometer is at first computed for the simple version without the birefringent plate. Then the effect of the birefringent plate is be mathematically described and the performance is re-computed.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Mid-IR AGPMs for ELT applications
Authors:
Brunella Carlomagno,
Christian Delacroix,
Olivier Absil,
Pontus Forsberg,
Serge Habraken,
Aïssa Jolivet,
Mikael Karlsson,
Dimitri Mawet,
Pierre Piron,
Jean Surdej,
Ernesto Vargas Catalan
Abstract:
The mid-infrared region is well suited for exoplanet detection thanks to the reduced contrast between the planet and its host star with respect to the visible and near-infrared wavelength regimes. This contrast may be further improved with Vector Vortex Coronagraphs (VVCs), which allow us to cancel the starlight. One flavour of the VVC is the AGPM (Annular Groove Phase Mask), which adds the intere…
▽ More
The mid-infrared region is well suited for exoplanet detection thanks to the reduced contrast between the planet and its host star with respect to the visible and near-infrared wavelength regimes. This contrast may be further improved with Vector Vortex Coronagraphs (VVCs), which allow us to cancel the starlight. One flavour of the VVC is the AGPM (Annular Groove Phase Mask), which adds the interesting properties of subwavelength gratings (achromaticity, robustness) to the already known properties of the VVC. In this paper, we present the optimized designs, as well as the expected performances of mid-IR AGPMs etched onto synthetic diamond substrates, which are considered for the E-ELT/METIS instrument.
△ Less
Submitted 28 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
The VORTEX coronagraphic test bench
Authors:
Aissa Jolivet,
Pierre Piron,
Elsa Huby,
Olivier Absil,
Christian Delacroix,
Dimitri Mawet,
Jean Surdej,
Serge Habraken
Abstract:
In this paper, we present the infrared coronagraphic test bench of the University of Liège named VODCA (Vortex Optical Demonstrator for Coronagraphic Applications). The goal of the bench is to assess the performances of the Annular Groove Phase Masks (AGPMs) at near- to mid-infrared wavelengths. The AGPM is a subwavelength grating vortex coronagraph of charge two (SGVC2) made out of diamond. The b…
▽ More
In this paper, we present the infrared coronagraphic test bench of the University of Liège named VODCA (Vortex Optical Demonstrator for Coronagraphic Applications). The goal of the bench is to assess the performances of the Annular Groove Phase Masks (AGPMs) at near- to mid-infrared wavelengths. The AGPM is a subwavelength grating vortex coronagraph of charge two (SGVC2) made out of diamond. The bench is designed to be completely achromatic and will be composed of a super continuum laser source emitting in the near to mid-infrared, several parabolas, diaphragms and an infrared camera. This way, we will be able to test the different AGPMs in the M, L, K and H bands. Eventually, the bench will also allow the computation of the incident wavefront aberrations on the coronagraph. A reflective Lyot stop will send most of the stellar light to a second camera to perform low-order wavefront sensing. This second system coupled with a deformable mirror will allow the correction of the wavefront aberrations. We also aim to test other pre- and/or post-coronagraphic concepts such as optimal apodization.
△ Less
Submitted 28 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Pattern phase diagram for 2D arrays of coupled limit-cycle oscillators
Authors:
Roland Lauter,
Christian Brendel,
Steven J. M. Habraken,
Florian Marquardt
Abstract:
Arrays of coupled limit-cycle oscillators represent a paradigmatic example for studying synchronization and pattern formation. They are also of direct relevance in the context of currently emerging experiments on nano- and optomechanical oscillator arrays. We find that the full dynamical equations for the phase dynamics of such an array go beyond previously studied Kuramoto-type equations. We anal…
▽ More
Arrays of coupled limit-cycle oscillators represent a paradigmatic example for studying synchronization and pattern formation. They are also of direct relevance in the context of currently emerging experiments on nano- and optomechanical oscillator arrays. We find that the full dynamical equations for the phase dynamics of such an array go beyond previously studied Kuramoto-type equations. We analyze the evolution of the phase field in a two-dimensional array and obtain a "phase diagram" for the resulting stationary and non-stationary patterns. The possible observation in optomechanical arrays is discussed briefly.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
Annular Groove Phase Mask coronagraph in diamond for mid-IR wavelengths: manufacturing assessment and performance analysis
Authors:
Christian Delacroix,
Pontus Forsberg,
Mikael Karlsson,
Dimitri Mawet,
Cédric Lenaerts,
Serge Habraken,
Charles Hanot,
Jean Surdej,
Anthony Boccaletti,
Jacques Baudrand
Abstract:
Phase-mask coronagraphs are known to provide high contrast imaging capabilities while preserving a small inner working angle, which allows searching for exoplanets or circumstellar disks with smaller telescopes or at longer wavelengths. The AGPM (Annular Groove Phase Mask, Mawet et al. 2005) is an optical vectorial vortex coronagraph (or vector vortex) induced by a rotationally symmetric subwavele…
▽ More
Phase-mask coronagraphs are known to provide high contrast imaging capabilities while preserving a small inner working angle, which allows searching for exoplanets or circumstellar disks with smaller telescopes or at longer wavelengths. The AGPM (Annular Groove Phase Mask, Mawet et al. 2005) is an optical vectorial vortex coronagraph (or vector vortex) induced by a rotationally symmetric subwavelength grating (i.e. with a period smaller than λ/n, λ being the observed wavelength and n the refractive index of the grating substrate). In this paper, we present our first mid- infrared AGPM prototypes imprinted on a diamond substrate. We firstly give an extrapolation of the expected coronagraph performances in the N-band (~10 μm), and prospects for down-scaling the technology to the most wanted L- band (~3.5 μm). We then present the manufacturing and measurement results, using diamond-optimized microfabrication techniques such as nano-imprint lithography (NIL) and reactive ion etching (RIE). Finally, the subwavelength grating profile metrology combines surface metrology (scanning electron microscopy, atomic force microscopy, white light interferometry) with diffractometry on an optical polarimetric bench and cross correlation with theoretical simulations using rigorous coupled wave analysis (RCWA).
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
A diamond AGPM coronagraph for VISIR
Authors:
Christian Delacroix,
Oliver Absil,
Dimitri Mawet,
Charles Hanot,
Mikael Karlsson,
Pontus Forsberg,
Eric Pantin,
Jean Surdej,
Serge Habraken
Abstract:
In recent years, phase mask coronagraphy has become increasingly efficient in imaging the close environment of stars, enabling the search for exoplanets and circumstellar disks. Coronagraphs are ideally suited instruments, characterized by high dynamic range imaging capabilities, while preserving a small inner working angle. The AGPM (Annular Groove Phase Mask, Mawet et al. 2005) consists of a vec…
▽ More
In recent years, phase mask coronagraphy has become increasingly efficient in imaging the close environment of stars, enabling the search for exoplanets and circumstellar disks. Coronagraphs are ideally suited instruments, characterized by high dynamic range imaging capabilities, while preserving a small inner working angle. The AGPM (Annular Groove Phase Mask, Mawet et al. 2005) consists of a vector vortex induced by a rotationally symmetric subwavelength grating. This technique constitutes an almost unique solution to the achromatization at longer wavelengths (mid-infrared). For this reason, we have specially conceived a mid-infrared AGPM coronagraph for the forthcoming upgrade of VISIR, the mid-IR imager and spectrograph on the VLT at ESO (Paranal), in collaboration with members of the VISIR consortium. The implementation phase of the VISIR Upgrade Project is foreseen for May-August 2012, and the AGPM installed will cover the 11-13.2 μm spectral range. In this paper, we present the entire fabrication process of our AGPM imprinted on a diamond substrate. Diamond is an ideal material for mid-infrared wavelengths owing to its high transparency, small dispersion, extremely low thermal expansion and outstanding mechanical and chemical properties. The design process has been performed with an algorithm based on the rigorous coupled wave analysis (RCWA), and the micro-fabrication has been carried out using nano-imprint lithography and reactive ion etching. A precise grating profile metrology has also been conducted using cleaving techniques. Finally, we show the deposit of fiducials (i.e. centering marks) with Aerosol Jet Printing (AJP). We conclude with the ultimate coronagraph expected performances.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Development of a subwavelength grating vortex coronagraph of topological charge 4 (SGVC4)
Authors:
Christian Delacroix,
Olivier Absil,
Brunella Carlomagno,
Pierre Piron,
Pontus Forsberg,
Mikael Karlsson,
Dimitri Mawet,
Serge Habraken,
Jean Surdej
Abstract:
One possible solution to achieve high contrast direct imaging at a small inner working angle (IWA) is to use a vector vortex coronagraph (VVC), which provides a continuous helical phase ramp in the focal plane of the telescope with a phase singularity in its center. Such an optical vortex is characterized by its topological charge, i.e., the number of times the phase accumulates 2π radians along a…
▽ More
One possible solution to achieve high contrast direct imaging at a small inner working angle (IWA) is to use a vector vortex coronagraph (VVC), which provides a continuous helical phase ramp in the focal plane of the telescope with a phase singularity in its center. Such an optical vortex is characterized by its topological charge, i.e., the number of times the phase accumulates 2π radians along a closed path surrounding the singularity. Over the past few years, we have been develo** a charge-2 VVC induced by rotationally symmetric subwavelength gratings (SGVC2), also known as the Annular Groove Phase Mask (AGPM). Since 2013, several SGVC2s (or AGPMs) were manufactured using synthetic diamond substrate, then validated on dedicated optical benches, and installed on 10-m class telescopes. Increasing the topological charge seems however mandatory for cancelling the light of bright stars which will be partially resolved by future Extremely Large Telescopes in the near-infrared. In this paper, we first detail our motivations for develo** an SGVC4 (charge 4) dedicated to the near-infrared domain. The challenge lies in the design of the pattern which is unrealistic in the theoretically perfect case, due to state-of-the-art manufacturing limitations. Hence, we propose a new realistic design of SGVC4 with minimized discontinuities and optimized phase ramp, showing conclusive improvements over previous works in this field. A preliminary validation of our concept is given based on RCWA simulations, while full 3D finite-difference time-domain simulations (and eventually laboratory tests) will be required for a final validation.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
L'-band AGPM vector vortex coronagraph's first light on LBTI/LMIRCam
Authors:
D. Defrère,
O. Absil,
P. Hinz,
J. Kuhn,
D. Mawet,
B. Mennesson,
A. Skemer,
J. Kent Wallace,
V. Bailey,
E. Downey,
C. Delacroix,
O. Durney,
P. Forsberg,
C. Gomez,
S. Habraken,
W. F. Hoffmann,
M. Karlsson,
M. Kenworthy,
J. Leisenring,
M. Montoya,
L. Pueyo,
M. Skrutskie,
J. Surdej
Abstract:
We present the first observations obtained with the L'-band AGPM vortex coronagraph recently installed on LBTI/LMIRCam. The AGPM (Annular Groove Phase Mask) is a vector vortex coronagraph made from diamond subwavelength gratings. It is designed to improve the sensitivity and dynamic range of high-resolution imaging at very small inner working angles, down to 0.09 arcseconds in the case of LBTI/LMI…
▽ More
We present the first observations obtained with the L'-band AGPM vortex coronagraph recently installed on LBTI/LMIRCam. The AGPM (Annular Groove Phase Mask) is a vector vortex coronagraph made from diamond subwavelength gratings. It is designed to improve the sensitivity and dynamic range of high-resolution imaging at very small inner working angles, down to 0.09 arcseconds in the case of LBTI/LMIRCam in the L' band. During the first hours on sky, we observed the young A5V star HR\,8799 with the goal to demonstrate the AGPM performance and assess its relevance for the ongoing LBTI planet survey (LEECH). Preliminary analyses of the data reveal the four known planets clearly at high SNR and provide unprecedented sensitivity limits in the inner planetary system (down to the diffraction limit of 0.09 arcseconds).
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
The VORTEX project: first results and perspectives
Authors:
Olivier Absil,
Dimitri Mawet,
Christian Delacroix,
Pontus Forsberg,
Mikael Karlsson,
Serge Habraken,
Jean Surdej,
Pierre-Antoine Absil,
Brunella Carlomagno,
Valentin Christiaens,
Denis Defrere,
Carlos Gomez Gonzalez,
Elsa Huby,
Aissa Jolivet,
Julien Milli,
Pierre Piron,
Ernesto Vargas Catalan,
Marc Van Droogenbroeck
Abstract:
(abridged) Vortex coronagraphs are among the most promising solutions to perform high contrast imaging at small angular separations. They feature a very small inner working angle, a clear 360 degree discovery space, have demonstrated very high contrast capabilities, are easy to implement on high-contrast imaging instruments, and have already been extensively tested on the sky. Since 2005, we have…
▽ More
(abridged) Vortex coronagraphs are among the most promising solutions to perform high contrast imaging at small angular separations. They feature a very small inner working angle, a clear 360 degree discovery space, have demonstrated very high contrast capabilities, are easy to implement on high-contrast imaging instruments, and have already been extensively tested on the sky. Since 2005, we have been designing, develo** and testing an implementation of the charge-2 vector vortex phase mask based on concentric subwavelength gratings, referred to as the Annular Groove Phase Mask (AGPM). Science-grade mid-infrared AGPMs were produced in 2012 for the first time, using plasma etching on synthetic diamond substrates. They have been validated on a coronagraphic test bench, showing broadband peak rejection up to 500:1 in the L band, which translates into a raw contrast of about $6\times 10^{-5}$ at $2 λ/D$. Three of them have now been installed on world-leading diffraction-limited infrared cameras (VLT/NACO, VLT/VISIR and LBT/LMIRCam). During the science verification observations with our L-band AGPM on NACO, we observed the beta Pictoris system and obtained unprecedented sensitivity limits to planetary companions down to the diffraction limit ($0.1''$). More recently, we obtained new images of the HR 8799 system at L band during the AGPM first light on LMIRCam. After reviewing these first results obtained with mid-infrared AGPMs, we will discuss the short- and mid-term goals of the on-going VORTEX project, which aims to improve the performance of our vortex phase masks for future applications on second-generation high-contrast imagers and on future extremely large telescopes (ELTs).
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Entanglement Rate for Gaussian Continuous Variable Beams
Authors:
Zhi Jiao Deng,
Steven J. M. Habraken,
Florian Marquardt
Abstract:
We derive a general expression that quantifies the total entanglement production rate in continuous variable systems, where a source emits two entangled Gaussian beams with arbitrary correlators.This expression is especially useful for situations where the source emits an arbitrary frequency spectrum,e.g. when cavities are involved. To exemplify its meaning and potential, we apply it to a four-mod…
▽ More
We derive a general expression that quantifies the total entanglement production rate in continuous variable systems, where a source emits two entangled Gaussian beams with arbitrary correlators.This expression is especially useful for situations where the source emits an arbitrary frequency spectrum,e.g. when cavities are involved. To exemplify its meaning and potential, we apply it to a four-mode optomechanical setup that enables the simultaneous up- and down-conversion of photons from a drive laser into entangled photon pairs. This setup is efficient in that both the drive and the optomechanical up- and down-conversion can be fully resonant.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2016; v1 submitted 30 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Laboratory demonstration of a mid-infrared AGPM vector vortex coronagraph
Authors:
Christian Delacroix,
Olivier Absil,
Pontus Forsberg,
Dimitri Mawet,
Valentin Christiaens,
Michael Karlsson,
Anthony Boccaletti,
Pierre Baudoz,
Markku Kuittinen,
Ismo Vartiainen,
Jean Surdej,
Serge Habraken
Abstract:
Coronagraphy is a powerful technique to achieve high contrast imaging and hence to image faint companions around bright targets. Various concepts have been used in the visible and near-infrared regimes, while coronagraphic applications in the mid-infrared remain nowadays largely unexplored. Vector vortex phase masks based on concentric subwavelength gratings show great promise for such application…
▽ More
Coronagraphy is a powerful technique to achieve high contrast imaging and hence to image faint companions around bright targets. Various concepts have been used in the visible and near-infrared regimes, while coronagraphic applications in the mid-infrared remain nowadays largely unexplored. Vector vortex phase masks based on concentric subwavelength gratings show great promise for such applications. We aim at producing and validating the first high-performance broadband focal plane phase mask coronagraphs for applications in the mid-infrared regime, and in particular the L band with a fractional bandwidth of ~16% (3.5-4.1 μm). Based on rigorous coupled wave analysis, we designed an annular groove phase mask (AGPM) producing a vortex effect in the L band, and etched it onto a series of diamond substrates. The grating parameters were measured by means of scanning electron microscopy. The resulting components were then tested on a mid-infrared coronagraphic test bench. A broadband raw null depth of 2 x 10^{-3} was obtained for our best L-band AGPM after only a few iterations between design and manufacturing. This corresponds to a raw contrast of about 6 x 10^{-5} (10.5 mag) at 2λ/D. This result is fully in line with our projections based on rigorous coupled wave analysis modeling, using the measured grating parameters. The sensitivity to tilt and focus has also been evaluated. After years of technological developments, mid-infrared vector vortex coronagraphs finally become a reality and live up to our expectations. Based on their measured performance, our L-band AGPMs are now ready to open a new parameter space in exoplanet imaging at major ground-based observatories.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
L'-band AGPM vector vortex coronagraph's first light on VLT/NACO: Discovery of a late-type companion at two beamwidths from an F0V star
Authors:
D. Mawet,
O. Absil,
C. Delacroix,
J. H. Girard,
J. Milli,
J. O'Neil,
P. Baudoz,
A. Boccaletti,
P. Bourget,
V. Christiaens,
P. Forsberg,
F. Gonte,
S. Habraken,
C. Hanot,
M. Karlsson,
M. Kasper,
J. -L. Lizon,
K. Muzic,
E. Pena,
R. Olivier,
N. Slusarenko,
L. E. Tacconi-Garman,
J. Surdej
Abstract:
Context. High contrast imaging has thoroughly combed through the limited search space accessible with first-generation ground-based adaptive optics instruments and the Hubble Space Telescope. Only a few objects were discovered, and many non-detections reported and statistically interpreted. The field is now in need of a technological breakthrough.
Aim. Our aim is to open a new search space with…
▽ More
Context. High contrast imaging has thoroughly combed through the limited search space accessible with first-generation ground-based adaptive optics instruments and the Hubble Space Telescope. Only a few objects were discovered, and many non-detections reported and statistically interpreted. The field is now in need of a technological breakthrough.
Aim. Our aim is to open a new search space with first-generation systems such as NACO at the Very Large Telescope, by providing ground-breaking inner working angle (IWA) capabilities in the L' band. The L' band is a sweet spot for high contrast coronagraphy since the planet-to-star brightness ratio is favorable, while the Strehl ratio is naturally higher.
Methods. An annular groove phase mask (AGPM) vector vortex coronagraph optimized for the L' band, made from diamond subwavelength gratings was manufactured and qualified in the lab. The AGPM enables high contrast imaging at very small IWA, potentially being the key to unexplored discovery space.
Results. Here we present the installation and successful on-sky tests of an L'-band AGPM coronagraph on NACO. Using angular differential imaging, which is well suited to the rotational symmetry of the AGPM, we demonstrated a ΔL' > 7.5 mag contrast from an IWA ~ 0".09 onwards, during average seeing conditions, and for total integration times of a few hundred seconds.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Resonances in dissipative optomechanics with nanoparticles: Sorting, speed rectification and transverse cooling
Authors:
S. J. M. Habraken,
W. Lechner,
P. Zoller
Abstract:
The interaction between dielectric particles and a laser-driven optical cavity gives rise to both conservative and dissipative dynamics, which can be used to levitate, trap and cool nanoparticles. We analytically and numerically study a two-mode setup in which the optical potentials along the cavity axis cancel, so that the resulting dynamics is almost purely dissipative. For appropriate detunings…
▽ More
The interaction between dielectric particles and a laser-driven optical cavity gives rise to both conservative and dissipative dynamics, which can be used to levitate, trap and cool nanoparticles. We analytically and numerically study a two-mode setup in which the optical potentials along the cavity axis cancel, so that the resulting dynamics is almost purely dissipative. For appropriate detunings of the laser-drives, this dissipative optomechanical dynamics can be used to sort particles according to their size, to rectify their velocities and to enhance transverse cooling.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
-
Cavity Optomechanics of Levitated Nano-Dumbbells: Non-Equilibrium Phases and Self-Assembly
Authors:
W. Lechner,
S. J. M. Habraken,
N. Kiesel,
M. Aspelmeyer,
P. Zoller
Abstract:
Levitated nanospheres in optical cavities open a novel route to study many-body systems out of solution and highly isolated from the environment. We show that properly tuned optical parameters allow for the study of the non-equilibrium dynamics of composite nano-particles with non-isotropic optical friction. We find friction induced ordering and nematic transitions with non-equilibrium analogs to…
▽ More
Levitated nanospheres in optical cavities open a novel route to study many-body systems out of solution and highly isolated from the environment. We show that properly tuned optical parameters allow for the study of the non-equilibrium dynamics of composite nano-particles with non-isotropic optical friction. We find friction induced ordering and nematic transitions with non-equilibrium analogs to liquid crystal phases for ensembles of dimers.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2013; v1 submitted 19 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Single-photon nonlinearities in two-mode optomechanics
Authors:
P. Kómár,
S. D. Bennett,
K. Stannigel,
S. J. M. Habraken,
P. Rabl,
P. Zoller,
M. D. Lukin
Abstract:
We present a detailed theoretical analysis of a weakly driven multimode optomechanical system, in which two optical modes are strongly and near-resonantly coupled to a single mechanical mode via a three-wave mixing interaction. We calculate one- and two-time intensity correlations of the two optical fields and compare them to analogous correlations in atom-cavity systems. Nonclassical photon corre…
▽ More
We present a detailed theoretical analysis of a weakly driven multimode optomechanical system, in which two optical modes are strongly and near-resonantly coupled to a single mechanical mode via a three-wave mixing interaction. We calculate one- and two-time intensity correlations of the two optical fields and compare them to analogous correlations in atom-cavity systems. Nonclassical photon correlations arise when the optomechanical coupling $g$ exceeds the cavity decay rate $κ$, and we discuss signatures of one- and two-photon resonances as well as quantum interference. We also find a long-lived correlation that decays slowly with the mechanical decay rate $γ$, reflecting the heralded preparation of a single phonon state after detection of a photon. Our results provide insight into the quantum regime of multimode optomechanics, with potential applications for quantum information processing with photons and phonons.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Continuous mode cooling and phonon routers for phononic quantum networks
Authors:
S. J. M. Habraken,
K. Stannigel,
M. D. Lukin,
P. Zoller,
P. Rabl
Abstract:
We study the implementation of quantum state transfer protocols in phonon networks, where in analogy to optical networks, quantum information is transmitted through propagating phonons in extended mechanical resonator arrays or phonon waveguides. We describe how the problem of a non-vanishing thermal occupation of the phononic quantum channel can be overcome by implementing optomechanical multi- a…
▽ More
We study the implementation of quantum state transfer protocols in phonon networks, where in analogy to optical networks, quantum information is transmitted through propagating phonons in extended mechanical resonator arrays or phonon waveguides. We describe how the problem of a non-vanishing thermal occupation of the phononic quantum channel can be overcome by implementing optomechanical multi- and continuous mode cooling schemes to create a 'cold' frequency window for transmitting quantum states. In addition, we discuss the implementation of phonon circulators and switchable phonon routers, which rely on strong coherent optomechanical interactions only, and do not require strong magnetic fields or specific materials. Both techniques can be applied and adapted to various physical implementations, where phonons coupled to spin or charge based qubits are used for on-chip networking applications.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2012; v1 submitted 31 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
-
Optomechanical quantum information processing with photons and phonons
Authors:
K. Stannigel,
P. Komar,
S. J. M. Habraken,
S. D. Bennett,
M. D. Lukin,
P. Zoller,
P. Rabl
Abstract:
We describe how strong resonant interactions in multimode optomechanical systems can be used to induce controlled nonlinear couplings between single photons and phonons. Combined with linear map** schemes between photons and phonons, these techniques provide a universal building block for various classical and quantum information processing applications. Our approach is especially suited for nan…
▽ More
We describe how strong resonant interactions in multimode optomechanical systems can be used to induce controlled nonlinear couplings between single photons and phonons. Combined with linear map** schemes between photons and phonons, these techniques provide a universal building block for various classical and quantum information processing applications. Our approach is especially suited for nano-optomechanical devices, where strong optomechanical interactions on a single photon level are within experimental reach.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2012; v1 submitted 15 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
The Optimal Gravitational Lens Telescope
Authors:
J. Surdej,
C. Delacroix,
P. Coleman,
M. Dominik,
S. Habraken,
C. Hanot,
H. Le Coroller,
D. Mawet,
H. Quintana,
T. Sadibekova,
D. Sluse
Abstract:
Given an observed gravitational lens mirage produced by a foreground deflector (cf. galaxy, quasar, cluster,...), it is possible via numerical lens inversion to retrieve the real source image, taking full advantage of the magnifying power of the cosmic lens. This has been achieved in the past for several remarkable gravitational lens systems. Instead, we propose here to invert an observed multiply…
▽ More
Given an observed gravitational lens mirage produced by a foreground deflector (cf. galaxy, quasar, cluster,...), it is possible via numerical lens inversion to retrieve the real source image, taking full advantage of the magnifying power of the cosmic lens. This has been achieved in the past for several remarkable gravitational lens systems. Instead, we propose here to invert an observed multiply imaged source directly at the telescope using an ad-hoc optical instrument which is described in the present paper. Compared to the previous method, this should allow one to detect fainter source features as well as to use such an optimal gravitational lens telescope to explore even fainter objects located behind and near the lens. Laboratory and numerical experiments illustrate this new approach.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2010;
originally announced June 2010.
-
Geometric phases in astigmatic optical modes of arbitrary order
Authors:
Steven J. M. Habraken,
Gerard Nienhuis
Abstract:
The transverse spatial structure of a paraxial beam of light is fully characterized by a set of parameters that vary only slowly under free propagation. They specify bosonic ladder operators that connect modes of different order, in analogy to the ladder operators connecting harmonic-oscillator wave functions. The parameter spaces underlying sets of higher-order modes are isomorphic to the paramet…
▽ More
The transverse spatial structure of a paraxial beam of light is fully characterized by a set of parameters that vary only slowly under free propagation. They specify bosonic ladder operators that connect modes of different order, in analogy to the ladder operators connecting harmonic-oscillator wave functions. The parameter spaces underlying sets of higher-order modes are isomorphic to the parameter space of the ladder operators. We study the geometry of this space and the geometric phase that arises from it. This phase constitutes the ultimate generalization of the Gouy phase in paraxial wave optics. It reduces to the ordinary Gouy phase and the geometric phase of non-astigmatic optical modes with orbital angular momentum states in limiting cases. We briefly discuss the well-known analogy between geometric phases and the Aharonov-Bohm effect, which provides some complementary insights in the geometric nature and origin of the generalized Gouy phase shift. Our method also applies to the quantum-mechanical description of wave packets. It allows for obtaining complete sets of normalized solutions of the Schrödinger equation. Cyclic transformations of such wave packets give rise to a phase shift, which has a geometric interpretation in terms of the other degrees of freedom involved.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2013; v1 submitted 9 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
-
Rotationally induced vortices in optical cavity modes
Authors:
Steven J. M. Habraken,
Gerard Nienhuis
Abstract:
We show that vortices appear in the modes of an astigmatic optical cavity when it is put into rotation about its optical axis. We study the properties of these vortices and discuss numerical results for a specific realization of such a set-up. Our method is exact up to first order in the time-dependent paraxial approximation and involves bosonic ladder operators in the spirit of the quantum-mech…
▽ More
We show that vortices appear in the modes of an astigmatic optical cavity when it is put into rotation about its optical axis. We study the properties of these vortices and discuss numerical results for a specific realization of such a set-up. Our method is exact up to first order in the time-dependent paraxial approximation and involves bosonic ladder operators in the spirit of the quantum-mechanical harmonic oscillator.
△ Less
Submitted 5 January, 2009; v1 submitted 26 November, 2008;
originally announced November 2008.
-
Rotational stabilization and destabilization of an optical cavity
Authors:
Steven J. M. Habraken,
Gerard Nienhuis
Abstract:
We investigate the effects of rotation about the axis of an astigmatic two-mirror cavity on its optical properties. This simple geometry is the first example of an optical system that can be destabilized and, more surprisingly, stabilized by rotation. As such, it has some similarity with both the Paul trap and the gyroscope. We illustrate the effects of rotational (de)stabilization of a cavity i…
▽ More
We investigate the effects of rotation about the axis of an astigmatic two-mirror cavity on its optical properties. This simple geometry is the first example of an optical system that can be destabilized and, more surprisingly, stabilized by rotation. As such, it has some similarity with both the Paul trap and the gyroscope. We illustrate the effects of rotational (de)stabilization of a cavity in terms of the spatial structure and orbital angular momentum of its modes.
△ Less
Submitted 5 January, 2009; v1 submitted 1 September, 2008;
originally announced September 2008.
-
Inverse spin switch effects in Ferromagnet / Superconductor hybrids with strong ferromagnets
Authors:
A. Yu. Rusanov,
S. Habraken,
J. Aarts
Abstract:
In F/S/F trilayers where the magnetization directions of the F layers can be controlled separately, it has theoretically been predicted that the antiparallel (AP) configuration can have a higher superconducting transition temperature T_c than the parallel configuration. This is the so-called spin switch, which also experimentally has been found for the case of weak ferromagnets. Here we show tha…
▽ More
In F/S/F trilayers where the magnetization directions of the F layers can be controlled separately, it has theoretically been predicted that the antiparallel (AP) configuration can have a higher superconducting transition temperature T_c than the parallel configuration. This is the so-called spin switch, which also experimentally has been found for the case of weak ferromagnets. Here we show that strong ferromagnets yield the opposite effect. We study the transport properties of F/S/F trilayers with F = Ni_0.80Fe_0.20 (Permalloy, Py) and S = Nb, structured in strips of different sizes. Using two different thicknesses for the Py layers, we can switch in a well-defined way between the AP- and P-configurations. In the superconducting transition we find a clear increase of the resistance in the AP-state. We ascribe this to enhanced reflection of spin-polarized quasiparticles at the S/F interfaces which leads to a stronger suppression of superconductivity on the S-side.
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2005;
originally announced September 2005.
-
Depairing currents in superconductor / ferromagnet Nb/CuNi trilayers close to T$_c$
Authors:
A. Rusanov,
M. Hesselberth,
S. Habraken,
J. Aarts
Abstract:
In superconductor/ferromagnet (S/F) heterostructures, the exchange field $h_{ex}$ of the F-layer suppresses the superconducting order parameter in the S-layer via the proximity effect. One issue in current research is the effect of a domain state, or, more generally, different directions of $h_{ex}$, on the superconductivity. We used a pulsed-current technique in order to measure the superconduc…
▽ More
In superconductor/ferromagnet (S/F) heterostructures, the exchange field $h_{ex}$ of the F-layer suppresses the superconducting order parameter in the S-layer via the proximity effect. One issue in current research is the effect of a domain state, or, more generally, different directions of $h_{ex}$, on the superconductivity. We used a pulsed-current technique in order to measure the superconducting transport properties of Cu$_{1-x}$Ni$_x$/Nb/Cu$_{1-x}$Ni$_x$ ($x$ = 0.54) F/S/F trilayers structured in strips of about 2 $μ$m wide and 20 $μ$m long as function of a small in-plane magnetic field. We find that the depairing current is tied to the magnetization behavior. In particular, we show that the suppression of superconductivity in the S-layer is smallest when the external magnetic field equals the coercive field H$_{c}$ of the F-layers.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2003;
originally announced October 2003.
