-
Charge Density Wave Order in Superconducting Topological Insulator Nbx-Bi2Se3
Authors:
Yanan Li,
Christian Parsons,
Sanath Ramakrishna,
Anand Dwivedi,
Nelson William,
Ryan Baumbach,
Marvin Schofield1,
Arneil Reyes,
Prasenjit Guptasarma
Abstract:
Spontaneously broken symmetry in the ground state of Bi-based topological materials can lead to promising Topological superconductors, such as Cu-Bi2Se3, Sr-Bi2Se3 and Nb-Bi2Se3. In recent studies, coexistence of multiple Fermi surface features and superconductivity was found in Nb-Bi2Se3. However, the resultant mutliple Fermi surface--charge density wave has not been experimentally reported yet.…
▽ More
Spontaneously broken symmetry in the ground state of Bi-based topological materials can lead to promising Topological superconductors, such as Cu-Bi2Se3, Sr-Bi2Se3 and Nb-Bi2Se3. In recent studies, coexistence of multiple Fermi surface features and superconductivity was found in Nb-Bi2Se3. However, the resultant mutliple Fermi surface--charge density wave has not been experimentally reported yet. In this paper, we report possible evidence of co-occurence of a charge density wave (CDW) ground state and a superconducting (SC) ground state in Nb intercalated Bi2Se3. An intercalation induced Periodic Lattice Distortion appears to help stabilize the CDW state, possibly assisting in the formation of 1D chains and rendering electronic and phonon anisotropy to this intriguing system.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Possible Lattice and Charge Order in CuxBi2Te2Se
Authors:
Yanan Li,
Nathaniel P. Smith,
William Rexhausen,
Marvin A Schofield,
Prasenjit Guptasarma
Abstract:
Metal intercalation into layered topological insulator materials such as the binary chalcogenide Bi2X3 (X=Te or Se) has yielded novel two-dimensional electron-gas physics, phase transitions to superconductivity, as well as interesting magnetic ground states. Of recent interest is the intercalation-driven interplay between lattice distortions, density wave ordering, and the emergence of new phenome…
▽ More
Metal intercalation into layered topological insulator materials such as the binary chalcogenide Bi2X3 (X=Te or Se) has yielded novel two-dimensional electron-gas physics, phase transitions to superconductivity, as well as interesting magnetic ground states. Of recent interest is the intercalation-driven interplay between lattice distortions, density wave ordering, and the emergence of new phenomena in the vicinity of instabilities induced by intercalation. Here, we examine the effects of Cu-intercalation on the ternary chalcogenide Bi2Te2Se. We report the discovery, in Cu0.3Bi2Te2Se, of a periodic lattice distortion at room temperature, together with a charge density wave transition around Td = 220K. We also report, for the first time, a complete study of the CuxBi2Te2Se system, and the effect of Cu-intercalation on crystal structure, phonon structure, and electronic properties for 0.0 $\le$ x $\le$ 0.5. Our electron diffraction studies reveal strong Bragg spots at reciprocal lattice positions forbidden by ABC stacking, possibly resulting from stacking faults, or a superlattice. The c-axis lattice parameter varies monotonically with x for 0 $\lt$ x $\lt$ 0.2, but drops precipitously for higher x. Similarly, Raman phonon modes $A^2_{1g}$ and $E_g$ soften monotonically for 0 $\lt$ x $\lt$ 0.2 but harden sharply for x $\gt$ 0.2. This indicates that Cu likely intercalates up to x $\sim$0.2, followed by partial site-substitutions at higher values. The resulting strain makes the 0.2 $\lt$ x $\lt$ 0.3 region susceptible to instabilities and distortions. Our results point toward the presence of an incommensurate CDW above Td = 220 K. This work strengthens prevalent thought that intercalation contributes significantly to instabilities in the lattice and charge degrees of freedom in layered chalcogenides.
△ Less
Submitted 29 February, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
A Charge Density Wave-like Transition in High Temperature Quenched $Bi_2Se_3$
Authors:
Yanan Li,
Christian Parsons,
Sanath Kumar Ramakrishna,
Anand Prashant Dwivedi,
Marvin A. Schofield,
Arneil P. Reyes,
Prasenjit Guptasarma
Abstract:
Hexagonally deformed Fermi surfaces and strong nesting, found in topological insulators (TIs) such as $Bi_2Se_3$ and $Bi_2Te_3$, have led to several predictions of the existence of Density Wave order in these systems. Recent evidence for strong Fermi surface nesting in superconducting $Cu-Bi_2Se_3$ and $Nb-Bi_2Se_3$ has further led to speculation about the importance of charge order in the context…
▽ More
Hexagonally deformed Fermi surfaces and strong nesting, found in topological insulators (TIs) such as $Bi_2Se_3$ and $Bi_2Te_3$, have led to several predictions of the existence of Density Wave order in these systems. Recent evidence for strong Fermi surface nesting in superconducting $Cu-Bi_2Se_3$ and $Nb-Bi_2Se_3$ has further led to speculation about the importance of charge order in the context of unconventional superconductivity. Here, we report the first observation of a novel anomaly in $Bi_2Se_3$ at 140K, which may be associated with a Charge Density Wave (CDW)-like transition. This transition was identified from both structural and electronic measurements, where: a) a periodic lattice distortion at above room temperature was characterized as a diffuse charge order in $Bi_2Se_3$ between \vec{k} and \vec{k}\pm\mathrmΔ\vec{k} from electron diffraction; and b) an opening of energy gap signatured with metal-to-insulator like transition at 140K was identified from resistivity vs temperature measurement. This is further corroborated by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) studies of the spin-lattice relaxation ( $\frac{1}{T_1}$) rate of the $^{209}Bi$ nucleus, which also displays a transition at 140K associated with an opening of an energy gap of ~8meV. Additionally, we also observe another anomaly in $\frac{1}{T_1}$ near 200K, which appears to display anisotropy with the direction of the applied magnetic field.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2023; v1 submitted 28 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Discovery of highly spin-polarized conducting surface states in the strong spin-orbit coupling semiconductor Sb$_2$Se$_3$
Authors:
Shekhar Das,
Suman Kamboj,
Anshu Sirohi,
Aastha Vasdev,
Sirshendu Gayen,
Prasenjit Guptasarma,
Goutam Sheet
Abstract:
Majority of the A$_2$B$_3$ type chalcogenide systems with strong spin-orbit coupling, like Bi$_2$Se$_3$, Bi$_2$Te$_3$ and Sb$_2$Te$_3$ etc., are topological insulators. One important exception is Sb$_2$Se$_3$, where a topological non-trivial phase was argued to be possible under ambient conditions, but such a phase could be detected to exist only under pressure. In this Letter, we show that like B…
▽ More
Majority of the A$_2$B$_3$ type chalcogenide systems with strong spin-orbit coupling, like Bi$_2$Se$_3$, Bi$_2$Te$_3$ and Sb$_2$Te$_3$ etc., are topological insulators. One important exception is Sb$_2$Se$_3$, where a topological non-trivial phase was argued to be possible under ambient conditions, but such a phase could be detected to exist only under pressure. In this Letter, we show that like Bi$_2$Se$_3$, Sb$_2$Se$_3$, displays generation of highly spin-polarized current under mesoscopic superconducting point contacts as measured by point contact Andreev reflection spectroscopy. In addition, we observe a large negative and anisotropic magnetoresistance in Sb$_2$Se$_3$, when the field is rotated in the basal plane. However, unlike in Bi$_2$Se$_3$, in case of Sb$_2$Se$_3$ a prominent quasiparticle interference (QPI) pattern around the defects could be obtained in STM conductance imaging. Thus, our experiments indicate that Sb$_2$Se$_3$ is a regular band insulator under ambient conditions, but due to it's high spin-orbit coupling, non-trivial spin-texture exists on the surface and the system could be on the verge of a topological insulator phase.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Sharp Raman Anomalies and Broken Adiabaticity at a Pressure Induced Transition from Band to Topological Insulator in Sb2Se3
Authors:
Achintya Bera,
Koushik Pal,
D. V. S. Muthu,
Somaditya Sen,
Prasenjit Guptasarma,
U. V. Waghmare,
A. K. Sood
Abstract:
The nontrivial electronic topology of a topological insulator is thus far known to display signatures in a robust metallic state at the surface. Here, we establish vibrational anomalies in Raman spectra of the bulk that signify changes in electronic topology: an E2 g phonon softens unusually and its linewidth exhibits an asymmetric peak at the pressure induced electronic topological transition (ET…
▽ More
The nontrivial electronic topology of a topological insulator is thus far known to display signatures in a robust metallic state at the surface. Here, we establish vibrational anomalies in Raman spectra of the bulk that signify changes in electronic topology: an E2 g phonon softens unusually and its linewidth exhibits an asymmetric peak at the pressure induced electronic topological transition (ETT) in Sb2Se3 crystal. Our first-principles calculations confirm the electronic transition from band to topological insulating state with reversal of parity of electronic bands passing through a metallic state at the ETT, but do not capture the phonon anomalies which involve breakdown of adiabatic approximation due to strongly coupled dynamics of phonons and electrons. Treating this within a four-band model of topological insulators, we elucidate how nonadiabatic renormalization of phonons constitutes readily measurable bulk signatures of an ETT, which will facilitate efforts to develop topological insulators by modifying a band insulator.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
-
Two component dynamics of the superconducting order parameter revealed by time-resolved Raman scattering
Authors:
R. P. Saichu,
I. Mahns,
A. Goos,
S. Binder,
P. May,
S. G. Singer,
B. Schulz,
A. Rusydi,
J. Unterhinninghofen,
D. Manske,
P. Guptasarma,
M. S. Williamsen,
M. Rübhausen
Abstract:
We study the dynamics of the superconducting order parameter in the high-$T_c$ cuprate Bi$_2$Sr$_2$CaCu$_2$O$_{8-δ}$ by employing a novel time-resolved pump-probe Raman experiment. We find two different coupling mechanisms that contribute equally to the pair breaking peak. One coupling sets in very fast at 2ps and relaxes slow, while the other one is delayed and sets in roughly at 5ps and relaxe…
▽ More
We study the dynamics of the superconducting order parameter in the high-$T_c$ cuprate Bi$_2$Sr$_2$CaCu$_2$O$_{8-δ}$ by employing a novel time-resolved pump-probe Raman experiment. We find two different coupling mechanisms that contribute equally to the pair breaking peak. One coupling sets in very fast at 2ps and relaxes slow, while the other one is delayed and sets in roughly at 5ps and relaxes fast. A model that couples holes through phonons is able to reproduce one part of the condensate dynamics, thus, we argue that hole-spin interactions are of importance as well.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2009; v1 submitted 7 January, 2009;
originally announced January 2009.
-
Intrinsic Impurity in the High Temperature Superconductor Bi_2Sr_2CaCu_2O$_{8+δ}$
Authors:
Bo Chen,
Sutirtha Mukhopadhyay,
W. P. Halperin,
Prasenjit Guptasarma,
D. G. Hinks
Abstract:
The {}^{17}O NMR spectra of Bi_2Sr_2CaCu_2O$_{8+δ}$ (Bi-2212) single crystals were measured in the temperature range from 4 K to 200 K and magnetic fields from 3 to 29 T, reported here principally at 8 T. The NMR linewidth of the oxygen in the CuO_{2} plane was found to be magnetically broadened with the temperature dependence of a Curie law where the Curie coefficient decreases with increased d…
▽ More
The {}^{17}O NMR spectra of Bi_2Sr_2CaCu_2O$_{8+δ}$ (Bi-2212) single crystals were measured in the temperature range from 4 K to 200 K and magnetic fields from 3 to 29 T, reported here principally at 8 T. The NMR linewidth of the oxygen in the CuO_{2} plane was found to be magnetically broadened with the temperature dependence of a Curie law where the Curie coefficient decreases with increased do**. This inhomogeneous magnetism is an impurity effect intrinsic to oxygen do** and persists unmodified into the superconducting state.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2007;
originally announced July 2007.
-
Two-dimensional Vortices in Superconductors
Authors:
Bo Chen,
W. P. Halperin,
Prasenjit Guptasarma,
D. G. Hinks,
V. F. Mitrovic,
A. P. Reyes,
P. L. Kuhns
Abstract:
Superconductors have two key characteristics. They expel magnetic field and they conduct electrical current with zero resistance. However, both properties are compromised in high magnetic fields which can penetrate the material and create a mixed state of quantized vortices. The vortices move in response to an electrical current dissipating energy which destroys the zero resistance state\cite{An…
▽ More
Superconductors have two key characteristics. They expel magnetic field and they conduct electrical current with zero resistance. However, both properties are compromised in high magnetic fields which can penetrate the material and create a mixed state of quantized vortices. The vortices move in response to an electrical current dissipating energy which destroys the zero resistance state\cite{And64}. One of the central problems for applications of high temperature superconductivity is the stabilization of vortices to ensure zero electrical resistance. We find that vortices in the anisotropic superconductor Bi$_{2}$Sr$_{2}$CaCu$_{2}$O$_{8+δ}$ (Bi-2212) have a phase transition from a liquid state, which is inherently unstable, to a two-dimensional vortex solid. We show that at high field the transition temperature is independent of magnetic field, as was predicted theoretically for the melting of an ideal two-dimensional vortex lattice\cite{Fis80,Gla91}. Our results indicate that the stable solid phase can be reached at any field as may be necessary for applications involving superconducting magnets\cite{Has04,Sca04,COHMAG}. The vortex solid is disordered, as suggested by previous studies at lower fields\cite{Lee93,Cub93}. But its evolution with increasing magnetic field displays unexpected threshold behavior that needs further investigation.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2007;
originally announced January 2007.
-
Nonequilibrium Campbell length: probing the vortex pinning potential
Authors:
R. Prozorov,
R. W. Giannetta,
T. Tamegai,
P. Guptasarma,
D. G. Hinks
Abstract:
The $AC$ magnetic penetration depth $λ(T,H,j)$ was measured in presence of a macroscopic $DC$ (Bean) supercurrent, $j$. In single crystal BSCCO below approximately 28 K, $λ(T,H,j)$ exhibits thermal hysteresis. The irreversibility arises from a shift of the vortex position within its pinning well as $j$ changes. It is demonstrated that below a new irreversibility temperature, the nonequilibrium C…
▽ More
The $AC$ magnetic penetration depth $λ(T,H,j)$ was measured in presence of a macroscopic $DC$ (Bean) supercurrent, $j$. In single crystal BSCCO below approximately 28 K, $λ(T,H,j)$ exhibits thermal hysteresis. The irreversibility arises from a shift of the vortex position within its pinning well as $j$ changes. It is demonstrated that below a new irreversibility temperature, the nonequilibrium Campbell length depends upon the ratio $j/j_c$. $λ(T,H,j)$ {\it increases} with $j/j_c$ as expected for a non-parabolic potential well whose curvature {\it decreases} with the displacement. Qualitatively similar results are observed in other high-$T_{c}$ and conventional superconductors.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2000;
originally announced April 2000.
-
Low temperature vortex phase diagram of Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8 : a magnetic penetration depth study
Authors:
R. Prozorov,
R. W. Giannetta,
T. Tamegai,
P. Guptasarma,
D. G. Hinks
Abstract:
We report measurements of the magnetic penetration depth λ_m(T) in the presence of a DC magnetic field in optimally doped BSCCO-2212 single crystals. Warming, after magnetic field is applied to a zero-field cooled sample, results in a non-monotonic λ_m(T), which does not coincide with a curve obtained upon field cooling, thus exhibiting a hysteretic behaviour. We discuss the possible relation of…
▽ More
We report measurements of the magnetic penetration depth λ_m(T) in the presence of a DC magnetic field in optimally doped BSCCO-2212 single crystals. Warming, after magnetic field is applied to a zero-field cooled sample, results in a non-monotonic λ_m(T), which does not coincide with a curve obtained upon field cooling, thus exhibiting a hysteretic behaviour. We discuss the possible relation of our results to the vortex decoupling, unbinding, and dimensional crossover.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2000;
originally announced March 2000.
-
Electronic Spectra and Their Relation to the (pi,pi) Collective Mode in High-Tc Superconductors
Authors:
J. C. Campuzano,
H. Ding,
M. R. Norman,
H. M. Fretwell,
M. Randeria,
A. Kaminski,
J. Mesot,
T. Takeuchi,
T. Sato,
T. Yokoya,
T. Takahashi,
T. Mochiku,
K. Kadowaki,
P. Guptasarma,
D. G. Hinks,
Z. Konstantinovic,
Z. Z. Li,
H. Raffy
Abstract:
Photoemission spectra of Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8 reveal that the high energy feature near (pi,0), the "hump", scales with the superconducting gap and persists above Tc in the pseudogap phase. As the do** decreases, the dispersion of the hump increasingly reflects the wavevector (pi,pi) characteristic of the undoped insulator, despite the presence of a large Fermi surface. This can be understood from the…
▽ More
Photoemission spectra of Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8 reveal that the high energy feature near (pi,0), the "hump", scales with the superconducting gap and persists above Tc in the pseudogap phase. As the do** decreases, the dispersion of the hump increasingly reflects the wavevector (pi,pi) characteristic of the undoped insulator, despite the presence of a large Fermi surface. This can be understood from the interaction of the electrons with a collective mode, supported by our observation that the do** dependence of the resonance observed by neutron scattering is the same as that inferred from our data.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 1999;
originally announced June 1999.
-
Predominantly Superconducting Origin of Large Energy Gaps in Underdoped Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8-d from Tunneling Spectroscopy
Authors:
N. Miyakawa,
J. F. Zasadzinski,
L. Ozyuzer,
P. Guptasarma,
D. G. Hinks,
C. Kendziora,
K. E. Gray
Abstract:
New tunneling data are reported in underdoped Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8-d using superconductor-insulator-superconductor break junctions. Energy gaps, Delta, of 51+2, 54+2 and 57+3 meV are observed for three crystals with Tc=77, 74, and 70 K respectively. These energy gaps are nearly three times larger than for overdoped crystals with similar Tc. Detailed examination of tunneling spectra over a wide do** r…
▽ More
New tunneling data are reported in underdoped Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8-d using superconductor-insulator-superconductor break junctions. Energy gaps, Delta, of 51+2, 54+2 and 57+3 meV are observed for three crystals with Tc=77, 74, and 70 K respectively. These energy gaps are nearly three times larger than for overdoped crystals with similar Tc. Detailed examination of tunneling spectra over a wide do** range from underdoped to overdoped, including the Josephson IcRn product, indicate that these energy gaps are predominantly of superconducting origin.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 1998;
originally announced September 1998.
-
C-axis electronic Raman scattering in Bi_2Sr_2CaCu_2O_{8+δ}
Authors:
H. L. Liu,
G. Blumberg,
M. V. Klein,
P. Guptasarma,
D. G. Hinks
Abstract:
We report a c-axis-polarized electronic Raman scattering study of Bi_2Sr_2CaCu_2O_{8+δ} single crystals. In the normal state, a resonant electronic continuum extends to 1.5 eV and gains significant intensity as the incoming photon energy increases. In the superconducting state, a coherence 2Δpeak appears around 50 meV, with a suppression of the scattering intensity at frequencies below the peak…
▽ More
We report a c-axis-polarized electronic Raman scattering study of Bi_2Sr_2CaCu_2O_{8+δ} single crystals. In the normal state, a resonant electronic continuum extends to 1.5 eV and gains significant intensity as the incoming photon energy increases. In the superconducting state, a coherence 2Δpeak appears around 50 meV, with a suppression of the scattering intensity at frequencies below the peak position. The peak energy, which is higher than that seen with in-plane polarizations, signifies distinctly different dynamics of quasiparticle excitations created with out-of-plane polarization.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 1998;
originally announced August 1998.
-
ARPES study of the superconducting gap and pseudogap in Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8+x
Authors:
H. Ding,
J. C. Campuzano,
M. R. Norman,
M. Randeria,
T. Yokoya,
T. Takahashi,
T. Takeuchi,
T. Mochiku,
K. Kadowaki,
P. Guptasarma,
D. G. Hinks
Abstract:
In this paper, we review some of our ARPES results on the superconducting and pseudo gaps in Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8+x. We find that optimally and overdoped samples exhibit a d-wave gap, which closes at the same temperature, Tc, for all k points. In underdoped samples, a leading edge gap is found up to a temperature T* > Tc. We find that T* scales with the maximum low temperature gap, increasing as the do…
▽ More
In this paper, we review some of our ARPES results on the superconducting and pseudo gaps in Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8+x. We find that optimally and overdoped samples exhibit a d-wave gap, which closes at the same temperature, Tc, for all k points. In underdoped samples, a leading edge gap is found up to a temperature T* > Tc. We find that T* scales with the maximum low temperature gap, increasing as the do** is reduced. The momentum dependence of the pseudogap is similar to that of the superconducting gap; however, the pseudogap closes at different temperatures for different k points.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 1997;
originally announced December 1997.
-
Evolution of Magnetic and Superconducting Fluctuations with Do** of High-Tc Superconductors (An electronic Raman scattering study)
Authors:
G. Blumberg,
M. V. Klein,
K. Kadowaki,
C. Kendziora,
P. Guptasarma,
D. Hinks
Abstract:
For YBa_2Cu_3O_{6+δ} and Bi_2Sr_2CaCu_2O_8 superconductors, electronic Raman scattering from high- and low-energy excitations has been studied in relation to the hole do** level, temperature, and energy of the incident photons. For underdoped superconductors, it is concluded that short range antiferromagnetic (AF) correlations persist with hole do** and doped single holes are incoherent in t…
▽ More
For YBa_2Cu_3O_{6+δ} and Bi_2Sr_2CaCu_2O_8 superconductors, electronic Raman scattering from high- and low-energy excitations has been studied in relation to the hole do** level, temperature, and energy of the incident photons. For underdoped superconductors, it is concluded that short range antiferromagnetic (AF) correlations persist with hole do** and doped single holes are incoherent in the AF environment. Above the superconducting (SC) transition temperature T_c the system exhibits a sharp Raman resonance of B_1g symmetry and about 75 meV energy and a pseudogap for electron-hole excitations below 75 meV, a manifestation of a partially coherent state forming from doped incoherent quasi-particles. The occupancy of the coherent state increases with cooling until phase ordering at T_c produces a global SC state.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 1997;
originally announced November 1997.
-
Destruction of the Fermi Surface in Underdoped High Tc Superconductors
Authors:
M. R. Norman,
H. Ding,
M. Randeria,
J. C. Campuzano,
T. Yokoya,
T. Takeuchi,
T. Takahashi,
T. Mochiku,
K. Kadowaki,
P. Guptasarma,
D. G. Hinks
Abstract:
The Fermi surface is a central concept in the theory of metals. Even though the optimally doped high temperature superconductors exhibit an anomalous normal state, angle resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) has revealed a large Fermi surface despite the absence of well-defined quasiparticles and the necessity of working at finite temperatures. However, the even more unusual behavior in th…
▽ More
The Fermi surface is a central concept in the theory of metals. Even though the optimally doped high temperature superconductors exhibit an anomalous normal state, angle resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) has revealed a large Fermi surface despite the absence of well-defined quasiparticles and the necessity of working at finite temperatures. However, the even more unusual behavior in the underdoped high temperature superconductors, which show a pseudogap above Tc, requires us to carefully re-examine this concept. Here, we present the first results on how the Fermi surface is destroyed as a function of temperature in underdoped Bi2212 using ARPES. We find the remarkable effect that different k points become gapped at different temperatures. This leads to a break up of the Fermi surface at a temperature T* into disconnected Fermi arcs which shrink with decreasing T, eventually collapsing to the point nodes of the dx2-y2 superconducting ground state below Tc. This novel behavior, where the Fermi surface does not form a continuous contour in momentum space, is unprecedented in that it occurs in the absence of long range order. Moreover, although the d-wave superconducting gap below Tc smoothly evolves into the pseudogap above Tc, the gaps at different k points are not related to one another above Tc the same way as they are below, implying an intimate, but non-trivial relation, between the two.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 1997; v1 submitted 15 October, 1997;
originally announced October 1997.
