-
Seasonality Patterns in 311-Reported Foodborne Illness Cases and Machine Learning-Identified Indications of Foodborne Illnesses from Yelp Reviews, New York City, 2022-2023
Authors:
Eden Shaveet,
Crystal Su,
Daniel Hsu,
Luis Gravano
Abstract:
Restaurants are critical venues at which to investigate foodborne illness outbreaks due to shared sourcing, preparation, and distribution of foods. Formal channels to report illness after food consumption, such as 311, New York City's non-emergency municipal service platform, are underutilized. Given this, online social media platforms serve as abundant sources of user-generated content that provi…
▽ More
Restaurants are critical venues at which to investigate foodborne illness outbreaks due to shared sourcing, preparation, and distribution of foods. Formal channels to report illness after food consumption, such as 311, New York City's non-emergency municipal service platform, are underutilized. Given this, online social media platforms serve as abundant sources of user-generated content that provide critical insights into the needs of individuals and populations. We extracted restaurant reviews and metadata from Yelp to identify potential outbreaks of foodborne illness in connection with consuming food from restaurants. Because the prevalence of foodborne illnesses may increase in warmer months as higher temperatures breed more favorable conditions for bacterial growth, we aimed to identify seasonal patterns in foodborne illness reports from 311 and identify seasonal patterns of foodborne illness from Yelp reviews for New York City restaurants using a Hierarchical Sigmoid Attention Network (HSAN). We found no evidence of significant bivariate associations between any variables of interest. Given the inherent limitations of relying solely on user-generated data for public health insights, it is imperative to complement these sources with other data streams and insights from subject matter experts. Future investigations should involve conducting these analyses at more granular spatial and temporal scales to explore the presence of such differences or associations.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Pragmatic Evaluation of Clarifying Questions with Fact-Level Masking
Authors:
Matthew Toles,
Yukun Huang,
Zhou Yu,
Luis Gravano
Abstract:
The ability to derive useful information by asking clarifying questions (ACQ) is an important element of real life collaboration on reasoning tasks, such as question answering (QA). Existing natural language ACQ challenges, however, evaluate generations based on word overlap rather than the value of the information itself. Word overlap is often an inappropriate metric for question generation since…
▽ More
The ability to derive useful information by asking clarifying questions (ACQ) is an important element of real life collaboration on reasoning tasks, such as question answering (QA). Existing natural language ACQ challenges, however, evaluate generations based on word overlap rather than the value of the information itself. Word overlap is often an inappropriate metric for question generation since many different questions could be useful in a given situation, and a single question can be phrased many different ways. Instead, we propose evaluating questions pragmatically based on the value of the information they retrieve. Here we present a definition and framework for natural language pragmatic asking of clarifying questions (PACQ), the problem of generating questions that result in answers useful for a reasoning task. We also present fact-level masking (FLM), a procedure for converting natural language datasets into self-supervised PACQ datasets by omitting particular critical facts. Finally, we generate a PACQ dataset from the HotpotQA dataset using FLM and evaluate several zero-shot language models on it. Our experiments show that current zero-shot models struggle to ask questions that retrieve useful information, as compared to human annotators. These results demonstrate an opportunity to use FLM datasets and the PACQ framework to objectively evaluate and improve question generation and other language models.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2024; v1 submitted 17 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Detecting Foodborne Illness Complaints in Multiple Languages Using English Annotations Only
Authors:
Ziyi Liu,
Giannis Karamanolakis,
Daniel Hsu,
Luis Gravano
Abstract:
Health departments have been deploying text classification systems for the early detection of foodborne illness complaints in social media documents such as Yelp restaurant reviews. Current systems have been successfully applied for documents in English and, as a result, a promising direction is to increase coverage and recall by considering documents in additional languages, such as Spanish or Ch…
▽ More
Health departments have been deploying text classification systems for the early detection of foodborne illness complaints in social media documents such as Yelp restaurant reviews. Current systems have been successfully applied for documents in English and, as a result, a promising direction is to increase coverage and recall by considering documents in additional languages, such as Spanish or Chinese. Training previous systems for more languages, however, would be expensive, as it would require the manual annotation of many documents for each new target language. To address this challenge, we consider cross-lingual learning and train multilingual classifiers using only the annotations for English-language reviews. Recent zero-shot approaches based on pre-trained multi-lingual BERT (mBERT) have been shown to effectively align languages for aspects such as sentiment. Interestingly, we show that those approaches are less effective for capturing the nuances of foodborne illness, our public health application of interest. To improve performance without extra annotations, we create artificial training documents in the target language through machine translation and train mBERT jointly for the source (English) and target language. Furthermore, we show that translating labeled documents to multiple languages leads to additional performance improvements for some target languages. We demonstrate the benefits of our approach through extensive experiments with Yelp restaurant reviews in seven languages. Our classifiers identify foodborne illness complaints in multilingual reviews from the Yelp Challenge dataset, which highlights the potential of our general approach for deployment in health departments.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Cross-Lingual Text Classification with Minimal Resources by Transferring a Sparse Teacher
Authors:
Giannis Karamanolakis,
Daniel Hsu,
Luis Gravano
Abstract:
Cross-lingual text classification alleviates the need for manually labeled documents in a target language by leveraging labeled documents from other languages. Existing approaches for transferring supervision across languages require expensive cross-lingual resources, such as parallel corpora, while less expensive cross-lingual representation learning approaches train classifiers without target la…
▽ More
Cross-lingual text classification alleviates the need for manually labeled documents in a target language by leveraging labeled documents from other languages. Existing approaches for transferring supervision across languages require expensive cross-lingual resources, such as parallel corpora, while less expensive cross-lingual representation learning approaches train classifiers without target labeled documents. In this work, we propose a cross-lingual teacher-student method, CLTS, that generates "weak" supervision in the target language using minimal cross-lingual resources, in the form of a small number of word translations. Given a limited translation budget, CLTS extracts and transfers only the most important task-specific seed words across languages and initializes a teacher classifier based on the translated seed words. Then, CLTS iteratively trains a more powerful student that also exploits the context of the seed words in unlabeled target documents and outperforms the teacher. CLTS is simple and surprisingly effective in 18 diverse languages: by transferring just 20 seed words, even a bag-of-words logistic regression student outperforms state-of-the-art cross-lingual methods (e.g., based on multilingual BERT). Moreover, CLTS can accommodate any type of student classifier: leveraging a monolingual BERT student leads to further improvements and outperforms even more expensive approaches by up to 12% in accuracy. Finally, CLTS addresses emerging tasks in low-resource languages using just a small number of word translations.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Weakly Supervised Attention Networks for Fine-Grained Opinion Mining and Public Health
Authors:
Giannis Karamanolakis,
Daniel Hsu,
Luis Gravano
Abstract:
In many review classification applications, a fine-grained analysis of the reviews is desirable, because different segments (e.g., sentences) of a review may focus on different aspects of the entity in question. However, training supervised models for segment-level classification requires segment labels, which may be more difficult or expensive to obtain than review labels. In this paper, we emplo…
▽ More
In many review classification applications, a fine-grained analysis of the reviews is desirable, because different segments (e.g., sentences) of a review may focus on different aspects of the entity in question. However, training supervised models for segment-level classification requires segment labels, which may be more difficult or expensive to obtain than review labels. In this paper, we employ Multiple Instance Learning (MIL) and use only weak supervision in the form of a single label per review. First, we show that when inappropriate MIL aggregation functions are used, then MIL-based networks are outperformed by simpler baselines. Second, we propose a new aggregation function based on the sigmoid attention mechanism and show that our proposed model outperforms the state-of-the-art models for segment-level sentiment classification (by up to 9.8% in F1). Finally, we highlight the importance of fine-grained predictions in an important public-health application: finding actionable reports of foodborne illness. We show that our model achieves 48.6% higher recall compared to previous models, thus increasing the chance of identifying previously unknown foodborne outbreaks.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Leveraging Just a Few Keywords for Fine-Grained Aspect Detection Through Weakly Supervised Co-Training
Authors:
Giannis Karamanolakis,
Daniel Hsu,
Luis Gravano
Abstract:
User-generated reviews can be decomposed into fine-grained segments (e.g., sentences, clauses), each evaluating a different aspect of the principal entity (e.g., price, quality, appearance). Automatically detecting these aspects can be useful for both users and downstream opinion mining applications. Current supervised approaches for learning aspect classifiers require many fine-grained aspect lab…
▽ More
User-generated reviews can be decomposed into fine-grained segments (e.g., sentences, clauses), each evaluating a different aspect of the principal entity (e.g., price, quality, appearance). Automatically detecting these aspects can be useful for both users and downstream opinion mining applications. Current supervised approaches for learning aspect classifiers require many fine-grained aspect labels, which are labor-intensive to obtain. And, unfortunately, unsupervised topic models often fail to capture the aspects of interest. In this work, we consider weakly supervised approaches for training aspect classifiers that only require the user to provide a small set of seed words (i.e., weakly positive indicators) for the aspects of interest. First, we show that current weakly supervised approaches do not effectively leverage the predictive power of seed words for aspect detection. Next, we propose a student-teacher approach that effectively leverages seed words in a bag-of-words classifier (teacher); in turn, we use the teacher to train a second model (student) that is potentially more powerful (e.g., a neural network that uses pre-trained word embeddings). Finally, we show that iterative co-training can be used to cope with noisy seed words, leading to both improved teacher and student models. Our proposed approach consistently outperforms previous weakly supervised approaches (by 14.1 absolute F1 points on average) in six different domains of product reviews and six multilingual datasets of restaurant reviews.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Automatic Classification of Text Databases through Query Probing
Authors:
Panagiotis Ipeirotis,
Luis Gravano,
Mehran Sahami
Abstract:
Many text databases on the web are "hidden" behind search interfaces, and their documents are only accessible through querying. Search engines typically ignore the contents of such search-only databases. Recently, Yahoo-like directories have started to manually organize these databases into categories that users can browse to find these valuable resources. We propose a novel strategy to automate…
▽ More
Many text databases on the web are "hidden" behind search interfaces, and their documents are only accessible through querying. Search engines typically ignore the contents of such search-only databases. Recently, Yahoo-like directories have started to manually organize these databases into categories that users can browse to find these valuable resources. We propose a novel strategy to automate the classification of search-only text databases. Our technique starts by training a rule-based document classifier, and then uses the classifier's rules to generate probing queries. The queries are sent to the text databases, which are then classified based on the number of matches that they produce for each query. We report some initial exploratory experiments that show that our approach is promising to automatically characterize the contents of text databases accessible on the web.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2000;
originally announced March 2000.
